Computer Science and Mathematics

Concept Paper
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Debashis Roy

Abstract: Many teams can say how a new feature creates data. Fewer can say how that data will be deleted: where every copy lives, which service removes it, in what order, by when, at what load, and how anyone would check that it is gone. Answering those questions after release is expensive, because copies have already spread into indexes, caches, analytics stores, and backups. This article proposes a 12-item deletion-readiness checklist that a feature team and its platform team complete before release. It draws on a large messaging platform’s deletion system and on published studies of deletion failures. Each item names the failure it addresses and the red flags of a weak answer. A worked example shows good answers, and a release gate makes them a written, owned commitment.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Gábor Pozsgai

,

Zsófia Varga-Szilay

,

Tomaz Ponce Dentinho

Abstract: Q methodology identifies shared patterns in how respondents evaluate sets of statements, but analysis is limited to a few respondents whose number should be lower than that of statements. Moreover, the process can become cumbersome when respondents rank many statements and difficult to reproduce when methodological choices span data preparation, component extraction and interpretation. Generalised Q (GQ) analysis addresses these limitations by constructing synthetic combined statements from smaller sets of constituent statements. Here, we introduce GQR (Generalised Q Analysis in R), an open-source R package implementing the GQ workflow through both a programmatic interface and an interactive Shiny application.GQR supports unrestricted full binary, one-per-group, and random-pattern designs, data transformation and respondent filtering, construction of synthetic evaluation matrices, ordinary and SPSS-compatible principal component analysis (PCA), and regression-based interpretation of both component content and respondent associations. For large ordinary-PCA problems, GQR provides an exact compact method that avoids materialising the synthetic evaluation matrix. The Shiny application uses the same analytical core and can export executable R code recording the current analysis and settings.Computational benchmarks showed that compact PCA reproduced materialised-matrix solutions to numerical precision while reducing runtime and memory requirements by orders of magnitude as the number of synthetic statements and respondents increased. Using the built-in Central and Eastern European gardening dataset, we further demonstrate how GQ analysis can identify multidimensional response patterns and relate them to respondent and garden characteristics. GQR therefore provides an accessible, reproducible and computationally efficient implementation of GQ analysis for multidimensional preference and survey data.

Technical Note
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Edervaldo José de Souza Melo

Abstract: A shared computing quota took two applications offline simultaneously after a code change intended to reduce dashboard polling. The available evidence identifies the scope of the suspension and the routines that changed, but cannot establish CPU savings. This technical note compares four deployment arrangements for enterprise systems serving multiple organizational units: shared commercial cloud hosting, centralized institutional infrastructure, per-unit installation, and local operation with central consolidation. It follows a record update from the initial write to the display, identifying authority over the data, limits on visibility across units, and the components needed during an outage. Two UML diagrams illustrate deployment boundaries and recovery after a lost acknowledgment. A third figure shows how local installations exchange data with a central service. The note proposes criteria for assessing polling costs, release distribution, fault diagnosis, and provider substitutability. The evaluation scenarios are analytical proposals.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Yufeng Li

,

Zhengyuan Wang

Abstract: The large number of various requests for fleet management systems needs to be handled promptly, such as right-of-way grant applications, collision avoidance rerouting and task assignments. Among them, right-of-way grants and collision-avoidance requests will cause a protective stop of the robot if they exceed the deadline; task assignment requests can be delayed. The current system handles all requests through a first-come, first-served thread pool and fails to control tail latency for high-priority requests during peak load. We model the fleet management system as a mixed-criticality real-time system and propose a two-level scheduling framework (MC-TLS). The first level applies earliest-deadline-first scheduling and admission control using empirical upper-tail execution-time quantiles, while the second level employs a constant-bandwidth server to allocate processing budgets to soft-real-time requests and reduces their available bandwidth under overload. An end-to-end response-time assessment incorporates queuing, execution, communication, and scheduling overhead under the evaluated workload. MC-TLS was evaluated in an operational fleet management system serving 800 mobile robots. This 800-robot deployment constitutes the production baseline, whereas the larger fleet configurations were examined separately in the scalability evaluation.The production workload comprises right-of-way granting, collision-avoidance replanning, and task assignment requests, with deadlines of 50 ms, 200 ms, and 2 s, respectively. The reported peak arrival rate in the 800-robot production environment is 4,200 requests/s.The evaluation reported a maximum observed response time of 41 ms in the analyzed latency series and a model-derived reference of 47 ms, compared with a 99.9th-percentile latency of 312 ms for FCFS. The reported deadline-miss rate decreased to 0.003%, while task-assignment starvation was 14% under fixed-priority scheduling and 0% under MC-TLS. These results demonstrate improved deadline compliance under the evaluated workload. However, because admission control relies on an upper-tail quantile of historical execution-time distributions rather than a certified worst-case execution-time (WCET) bound, the findings do not establish deterministic schedulability guarantees.Protective stops due to request timeouts were reduced by 63%, fleet throughput increased by 7.8%, and processor utilisation remained at 78%. During the reported 30-day production observation, the 800-robot system processed 2.6×10⁹ requests, corresponding to an average processing rate of approximately 1,003 requests/s. These production observations are distinguished from the separate scalability evaluation.A separate scalability stress test examined fleet sizes from 800 to 1,400 robots under unchanged server hardware and scheduling parameters, corresponding to a 75% increase in the evaluated fleet size. The 1,400-robot configuration is not included in the reported 30-day, 800-robot production observation.This study integrates mixed-criticality scheduling into fleet management software and provides a workload-conditioned approach to deadline assurance and end-to-end latency assessment.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

P. Alexander Burnham

,

Matthew P. Dube

,

Quinlan Dubois

,

Matthew M. Kling

,

Bailey P. McLaughlin

,

Stephanie N. Miller

,

Nicholas J. Gotelli

,

Brian J. McGill

Abstract: As climate change accelerates, spatiotemporal climate and weather data rasters are increasingly used in academic research, agriculture, infrastructure, and other disci-plines across public and private domains. Unfortunately, these raster data are often stored under numerous file types with different spatial and temporal boundaries, spa-tial reference systems, and spatial and temporal resolutions. The tools and workflows that we have are often hindered by coordinate reference system mismatches, data type mismatches, data aggregation mismatches, and other fundamental challenges. To fully harness the impacts of these data, software tools are needed that can be leveraged effi-ciently and intuitively and without a steep learning curve for the new user. In this pa-per, we introduce Spacetime, a novel programming library in Python that enables effi-cient spatiotemporal data processing, management, alignment, and analysis. Spacetime is an open-source project written in Python that provides a set of powerful functions to manipulate spatiotemporal data in a single, unified library. Spacetime’s overarching themes are simplicity and usability. However, the library does not com-promise processing speed. In our comparison, it was as fast or faster than other popu-lar Python libraries, while requiring many fewer lines of code and no external loops or control functions. We hope this library will lower the barrier of entry to scientists in fields that have not traditionally used spatiotemporal raster data but are doing so in-creasingly frequently in the current climate.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Junqiang Wu

,

Feipeng Li

,

Wenfeng He

,

Xibo Wu

Abstract: Ratio-type measures of structural association compare observed co-occurrence with what the marginal distribution would produce, and they return a number whether or not that number can be read. EduCEQ-Toolkit is a Python framework that declines to do so: on a public panel of 4,785 U.S. higher-education institutions, its runtime contract reports that no bandwidth between 50 and 500 km is decidable, and the call returns a structured non-decidability object instead of a coefficient. The framework generalizes the co-location quotient to an arbitrary non-negative pairwise weight, so distance, attribute similarity and network proximity are handled by one estimator. It implements three composable kernel families, an exact first- and second-order decomposition, conditional permutation inference with false discovery rate control, and a three-step contract binding the population count, the neighbourhood count and the coverage proportion. We present the contract as a reusable design pattern for research software: where a condition on a method's validity can be computed, it belongs in the execution path rather than in the manual. Evaluation covers threshold calibration, a decidable case, a refusal case on public data, and computational cost.

Technical Note
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Ang Li

,

Fanxi Liu

,

Xinhao Zhang

,

Xiurui Zhao

,

Yuxin Zheng

,

Xinyu Li

,

Tianxiao Zhang

Abstract: Objective: To develop a natural-language statistical-analysis agent that integrates a local large language model, specialized medical statistical tools, and output-checking stages, and to illustrate its functionality through representative software-interface displays.Materials and Methods: MedAnalysis Studio version 1.0.1 integrates a locally quantized Qwen2-family model, named EpiMind within the application, with structured tool calls, numerical traceability checks, and methodological auditing. The system provides Chinese and English interaction. Representative single-goal operations are illustrated by preserved screenshots of missingness reporting, correlation visualization, and event categorization.Results: The system comprises 93 configured tools in 12 modules. Illustrative software screenshots show a missingness-report panel, a correlation heatmap, and an event-status display within the natural-language workflow. These examples are presented as interface demonstrations rather than quantitative validation.Conclusions: The integrated workflow connects natural-language requests with explicit statistical operations, checking stages, and structured research outputs. Representative interface displays illustrate the organization of data-quality reporting, visualization, and outcome-category handling. Broader accuracy and clinical performance require separate evaluation.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

ZeFan Xu

,

Yi Wu

,

Wei Long

Abstract: Validating a concrete Android bug requires more than choosing a tool category: the rule, inputs, and oracle must decide whether the target mechanism is present on the buggy version and absent on the fixed one. We present ABAF-VP, a validation-planning approach that profiles the target mechanism, filters and ranks candidate plans using mechanism, capability, oracle, and evidence predicates drawn from a 191-record knowledge base, aligns the selected rule to the concrete target, and verifies both artifact versions against an independent two-sided reference. On 100 formal tasks with independent human reference labels, ABAF-VP ranks a valid plan first for 10 of 13 jointly solvable tasks (P@1 = 76.9%), ahead of category, retrieval, and capability baselines; ablation attributes the gain mainly to mechanism matching (−69.2 pp when removed). Target-rule alignment raises paired verification on 60 bug/fix pairs from 5 to 47 (78.3%) and end-to-end task success from 5/100 to 47/100, adding 30.274 s of known machine time (5.5%). Results are bounded by a small solvable subset, manual alignment bindings, and documented capability limits. Within these bounds, validation planning offers an executable, evidence-aware path from Android bug-mechanism knowledge to concrete verification.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Debashis Roy

,

Sankalp Mulye

,

Narasimhan Govindarajan

,

Jay Rajeevalochanam

Abstract: Cross-region migration is difficult when one logical resource spans independently owned services and heterogeneous storage backends. Concurrent mutations and stale routing state complicate complete-ness and write authority at cutover. We present a four-phase protocol combining selective operation fencing, content-stripped deletion tombstones, routing-embedded locks, and atomic cutover. His-torical copy permits mutations; final synchronization temporarily fences them. Service-confirmed enforcement closes the mutation boundary, primary-write-replica routing reads expose current lock state, and token- and version-checked cutover transfers authority. We give correctness arguments under explicit service contracts. Production summaries from a messaging platform report 6–10 million conversation migrations per day over 30 days and 99.9% first-attempt success. Successful attempts had write-lock intervals of 13 s at the median and 19 s at the 99th percentile, measured from request issuance through cutover. Approximately 1000 lock-rejected message sends subsequently succeeded according to service-side telemetry; this does not establish absence of user-visible errors or delay. Count and sampled-content validation detected some schema-related contract drift before cutover. An analytical comparison illustrates fencing-window costs under fixed observed durations, without benchmarking alternative implementations. The contribution integrates established mechanisms with production observations and explicit consistency and availability boundaries.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Isah Mohammed

,

Qingzhong Liu

,

Narasimha Shashidhar

Abstract: Short-lived Kubernetes workloads can terminate before investigators acquire evidence, leaving reconstruction dependent on telemetry retained by other components. How consistently that telemetry is retained as workloads scale, and whether count-based retention measurements can be trusted, remain poorly characterized. We analyzed 180 scripted trial attempts on a single-node kind cluster that collected Kubernetes Event objects, Istio control-plane logs, node packet captures, and eBPF/Tetragon process events. At 100 replicas, the volume of orchestration-event records and control-plane log lines fell to about two-thirds and three-quarters of matched no-attack baselines, with lower run-to-run stability than at 4 or 50 replicas. All ten four-collector trials at 100 replicas failed under host memory pressure. A trial-level audit of the released raw data showed that the credential-access and stress actions were not recorded in any run, that the in-pod deletion action was recorded only at the smallest scale, and that most orchestration-event records in some conditions were carry-over from earlier trials. We report those scenarios as inconclusive and quantify how these measurement-pipeline effects change retention estimates. The findings apply to the evaluated single-node configuration.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Debashis Roy

,

Sankalp Mulye

,

Narasimhan Govindarajan

,

Jay Rajeevalochanam

Abstract: Live cross-region data migration in Internet-scale cloud services needs distributed locking, but a dedicated lock service adds infrastructure, a lookup on the request path, and an atomicity gap between lock release and location cutover. We instead embed lock metadata in the routing records that services already read on every request. The primitives—fencing tokens, leases, and conditional writes—are standard; what changes is where lock state lives. In a messaging platform performing 6–10 million migrations per day, lock checks ride the existing routing lookup, adding a point read only for resources holding an active lock; location swap and lock release become one atomic write; and locks propagate by passive cache expiry. Write-lock duration, the only user-impacting phase, stays under 20 seconds at p99. We compare the design with established lock services and separate measured from inferred benefits.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Marcela Mosquera

,

Rodolfo Bojorque

Abstract: Machine learning-based code smell detection relies on structural metrics, but predictive performance alone does not establish whether the information used by classifiers corresponds to the characteristics reported in the literature. This study examines the explanatory behavior of Support Vector Machine (SVM) models by integrating SHAP-based feature importance, point-biserial associations, and literature-based code smell indicators. The analysis reconstructs 120 SVM models across three open-source Java systems and four code smells, using ten folds per system–smell combination. Feature importance, persistence across folds, and consistency across software systems are examined alongside SHAP–correlation concordance, indicator coverage, and directional compatibility. The results show that influential metrics vary across code smells and software systems, while high average importance does not necessarily imply persistence across folds. Agreement between SHAP-based rankings and statistical associations is partial. Indicator coverage and directional compatibility provide distinct forms of evidence, and some literature-based operationalizations cannot be evaluated using the available metrics. A complementary sensitivity analysis shows high agreement among repeated SHAP realizations under the tested conditions. These findings indicate that explanatory relevance depends on the experimental context and that model contributions, statistical associations, and literature-based indicators provide complementary evidence for interpreting code smell predictions.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Bintang Ekananda

Abstract: Context. Vibe coding, building software by describing it to AI systems and accepting the code they write, now produces products that people pay for. Evidence comes mostly from interviews and online posts, rarely from the records of a live system built by a non-programmer. Objective. To describe how one such product was built and kept under control over its first 104 days, starting the day before public launch. Method. A single-case study of Curie, a research platform built by an environmental engineer who does not write code, using a commercial AI app builder and external AI agents. I analysed all 2,334 commits, 1,940 instructions to the builder, 2,457 checkpoints and weekly code snapshots. Results. AI tools generated every code change: the builder made 972 commits (41.6%) and external agents 1,296 (55.5%). Agent commits were smaller (median 21 against 87 lines; rank-biserial r = 0.40, p < 0.001); durability did not differ consistently once timing was controlled. Half of all file edits revisited a file changed within 24 hours. The codebase grew 6.2-fold while decision points per thousand lines rose 94%. Tests first appeared on day 88, and a rollback on day 102 discarded 302 commits, including half the tests. The product reached about 500 paying users. Conclusions. Ten guardrails, four prompted directly by platform behaviour, form a ladder from prototype to team: three observed levels and a proposed fourth. With AI writing all the code, the founder's work was directing the AI and checking its output.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Yufeng Lin

,

Sio Fong Cheong

,

Seong Lai Chan

,

Xiulan Lin

,

Jie Tan

,

Jialu Zhang

Abstract: Most of the 135 million users registered with Scratch by July 2024 were children, and the tools that grade, test and rank their games replay them in a browser, assuming that a program under the same inputs ends the same way in every browser. For one popular game in fourteen it does not: a game that works at home can end differently when the teacher grades it on another computer. The main cause is how Scratch tests touching: it compares collision outlines that the browser rasterizes and that Scratch keeps at the largest scale drawn so far, so the browser, the screen and the computer are hidden inputs of every game that tests touching with a vector costume. Our replay, built on Scratch's own virtual machine and renderer, fixes the keys, the random numbers and the clock, can pin the browsers' arithmetic, and names the first pixel test whose answer differs. We prove that browsers that draw every edge within a pixel can disagree about touching only near contact, and we give a fix: one outline per costume, drawn at a fixed scale by one portable rasterizer. We replayed 500 popular Scratch games, chosen before any evaluation run, for ten seconds of scripted play. Of the 473 that use no camera or web service and finish in all three browsers, 33 (7.0%) end differently across Chrome, Safari and Firefox, and the Scratch editor itself, in release Chrome and Firefox, splits 22 of the 33. Within one browser, a sharper screen or a larger stage changes 7.0% of the games, and moving release Chrome from a Mac to Windows changes 2.5%. With the arithmetic pinned, 24 of the 28 browser splits start at a pixel test, and feeding one browser the other's renderer answers reproduces the other's ending in all 24 games tested. The fix cuts browser splits to 1.3%, and those of every other setting on one computer to at most one game.

Technical Note
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Yipeng Sun

,

Linda-Sophie Schneider

,

Chengze Ye

,

Andreas Maier

Abstract: diffct implements computed-tomography projection and reconstruction in PyTorch using Numba CUDA kernels. Its native forward model integrates a cell-constant attenuation field along rays defined by per-view acquisition geometry; the backprojector is the matched discrete adjoint. The same model supports parallel, fan and cone beams, non-circular trajectories, and parameterized detector surfaces. This report describes the implementation through release 2.2.1: the geometry and sampling conventions, Siddon traversal, data and first-order geometry derivatives, differentiable analytical FBP/FDK, and execution on one or several GPUs. We derive the ownership and reduction rules for distributed view and spatial partitions and explain how spatial, view and detector blocks extend native operations to CPU-backed and disk-backed data. Experiments include measured walnut cone-beam data, synthetic reconstruction and calibration, and a recorded 512³ scaling benchmark. On A100-SXM-64GB GPUs, eight GPUs on two nodes reduce forward projection from 493.05 to 73.18 ms and the amortized cost of a ten-step CGLS solve from 2054.36 to 373.38 ms per iteration. Analytical gathers have their own discrete transposes; differentiability does not make FDK an exact inverse. We distinguish numerical correctness, reconstruction quality and execution cost, and state the limits of each experiment.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Fan Shen

Abstract: Composing mechanism models published separately across disciplines into one executable, optimizable simulation remains an open modeling and simulation problem. Existing model-exchange standards describe mechanisms within a single domain, and simulation-based optimization is usually attached afterward through bespoke scripts. Individual health decisions make the problem acute, since physiological, behavioral, psychological, social, and economic constraints, each supplied by a different discipline, have to be satisfied at once. This paper introduces LM format 1.0, an open YAML specification built around four structural blocks, variables, equations, simulation, and optimization, collectively VESO, which organize cross-disciplinary effect sizes, equations, thresholds, and constraints into an executable, optimizable system-science object. The specification ships with an open-source reference implementation, the LM Reference Engine. Two joint-simulation case studies demonstrate feasibility. A chronic kidney disease (CKD) protein-muscle tradeoff model connects nephrology and geriatric medicine, reproducing a classic cross-specialty guideline conflict. An aircrew cross-timezone scheduling model connects aviation medicine, chronobiology, and operations scheduling, jointly optimizing a decision frontier between operating cost and on-duty fatigue safety. Neither case constitutes a clinical or operational validation of the CKD treatment plan or the aircrew schedule itself.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Nata Sulakvelidze

,

Anzori Kuparadze

Abstract: Digital-twin research on additive-manufacturing (AM) fleets needs experi-ments in which the physical process, the communication channel and thetwin’s synchronisation state can be manipulated and measured indepen-dently; existing tools cover only fragments. SimTwin is an open-sourcePython simulator that couples a lumped-parameter thermal plant withproportional–integral heater control, a per-device job and health state ma-chine, an explicit message-level transport with latency, jitter, loss, dupli-cation, outage and staleness-based discarding, and a twin registry writtenonly by delivered messages. Faults are injected as mechanisms acting onthe plant, not as scripted telemetry labels, so fault signatures emerge fromthe dynamics, and seeding gives byte-identical telemetry. Seven experimentsreport scalability to 1 000 printers, throughput to 70 363 msg s−1, twin stale-ness rising from 0.99 s to 6.99 s with loss, 10 of 11 fault families separable atCohen’s |d| ≥ 1.45, and QoS 1 holding 95th-percentile staleness at 1.2 s on areal broker where QoS 0 lets it grow 12.6-fold.

Technical Note
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Alexander I. Erzin

Abstract: Formalizing the transition from qualitative, phenomenological neuropsychological observations to quantitative clinical data structures remains a critical bottleneck in computational neuroscience. Existing methods either rely on scalar psychometric screening tools (e.g., MoCA, MMSE) that obscure the modular and network-level topography of cognitive deficits, or utilize stochastic large language models (LLMs) prone to diagnostic hallucination and predicate drift. This paper presents a deterministic expert core architecture that bridges network neuroscience and clinical practice by formalizing A.R. Luria’s theory of systemic-dynamic localization of higher mental functions into a production-rule predicate processor. The system converts an input 10-dimensional integer vector of multi-domain cognitive error scores [0-5] into standardized syndromic profiles using multi-level nested dictionary traversals and automated mapping onto the WHO International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) taxonomy (b, d, and e codes). To ensure morphosyntactic invariance across language localizations, an isolated regular expression inflection module handles gender agreement tags post-traversal. The computational runtime maintains strict algorithmic transparency, enforces cross-domain data integrity filters, and implements a deterministic interrupt for vector singularities, eliminating probabilistic inference and ensuring auditable, reproducible clinical decision-support reporting.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Daniel França

,

Tiago França

,

Danniel Maced

,

Richelieu Costa

,

Leandro Souza

,

Guido Souza Filho

,

Tiago Araújo

Abstract: This paper introduces highFIS, an open-source Python package for training and evaluating high-dimensional Takagi-Sugeno-Kang (TSK) neuro-fuzzy inference systems. TSK systems are widely appreciated for their local linear approximation capabilities and structural transparency, yet the classical product T-norm formulation suffers from exponential rule activation collapse and softmax saturation in high-dimensional spaces. The highFIS library addresses this limitation by unifying thirteen high-dimensional TSK estimator families and a baseline model under a single declarative, scikit-learn-compatible application programming interface (API). These estimators leverage modern mathematical strategies to mitigate the curse of dimensionality, including antecedent exponent re-formulation, differentiable softmin approximations, adaptive parametric T-norms, double groups of gates for sparse feature and rule selection, and head-based subspace decomposition. Every family is implemented with both a Classifier and a Regressor variant that integrate naturally with the meta-estimators and model evaluation frameworks of scikit-learn. Built on PyTorch, the package en-ables efficient gradient-based optimization with hardware acceleration, offers extensive introspection utilities to extract interpretable rule bases, and supports versioned checkpoints for model persistence. Usage is illustrated on a low-dimensional interpretability example and on real high-dimensional classification and regression datasets.

Article
Computer Science and Mathematics
Software

Anton N. Smolin

Abstract: Generative development is an open loop: a language model produces the code, and readiness is judged by an opinion. This work studies whether a transactional state machine external to the agent — owning the requirements canon, an executable checks table, a double run of every check, and a signed verdict — turns readiness into a reproducible fact. Field experiments ran on a battery of console-utility tasks spanning five task senses and five technology stacks: a three-hand experiment — top and budget models in the system, solo without it — with independent judges, and a September replication on the evolved machine. The system hands delivered verified-twice verdicts on every task, quality invariant to the model class; solo, cheaper on its own tokens, matched the byte-exact reference in a fifth of the judges’ rows — the divergence is freedom of interpreting the brief, not functional defects. Systemic fixes nearly halved the battery’s token cost, the methodology unchanged. On the full path, with the verifying operator priced in, the machine route is also the cheaper one, and the human leaves the loop on most tasks. The closed loop’s benefit is reconcilability, not token economy; an anti-entropy frame is proposed to interpret it.

of 16