Preprint
Article

This version is not peer-reviewed.

Performance of Concrete Containing Water-Hyacinth Ash (WHA) as Cement Replacement: Resistance to Elevated Temperature and Seawater Exposures

Submitted:

10 February 2025

Posted:

10 February 2025

You are already at the latest version

Abstract

The current research aims at determining the resistance of concrete mixtures containing the ashes resulting from the water-hyacinth plants [1] as a cement replacement to elevated temperature and to seawater. Two types of water-hyacinth ashes (WHA); burnt in open air and burnt in a closed oven at 600°C for 30 minutes were used as partial replacement materials of ordinary portland cement in concrete mixtures with percentages of up to 15% (by weight of cement). The concrete mixtures were designed with three coarse aggregates types; gravel, dolomite, and basalt. To study the resistance to high temperatures, the specimens were exposed to different elevated temperatures of 200, 400, and 600°C and compared to 25°C as a reference. To investigate the resistance to seawater, three curing regimes were followed; curing in laboratory atmosphere (25°C and 50% relative humidity), immersing in seawater during the entire curing period of one month, and subjecting to drying-wet cycles composed of one-day at laboratory atmosphere and one-day in seawater for a total period of one month before testing. The concrete mixes containing WHA were compared with plain concretes and others proportioned with 10% silica fume. The results revealed significant effect of WHA percentages, coarse aggregates types, and curing methods on the concrete strength. With up to 10% cement replacement with WHA, there was no reduction in strength relative to the reference. The optimal replacement value was around 5%.

Keywords: 
;  ;  ;  ;  ;  

1. Introduction

Water hyacinth plants are growing extensively in rivers in Latin America, south and central states of USA, and different worm places in the world, including river Nile in Egypt. It curtails river transports, damages canal walls, increases water evaporation losses, decreases amount of oxygen in water, causes organic pollution in slow moving stream and canals. It is mostly fought by collecting it mechanically and burning it in open air. This method participates significantly to air pollution [1] and large quantities of dried materials on rivers’ banks (dry materials constitutes about 28% of the fresh plants). In recent years, many researches were interested in the nutritional values of water hyacinth plants for animal feeds. On the other hand, the nature of water hyacinth plants may predict other applicable uses as reinforcing agents in paper industries [2]. Under controlled burning and sufficiently ground, the water-hyacinth ash (WHA) can be used as cement replacement material in concrete [3,4]. From economic, technological, and ecological points of view, alternative supplementary cementitious materials (ASCM) have an undoubted role in construction industry. These materials can be used in small quantities as inert fillers, or larger quantities if they have pozzolanic properties. Both materials impart technical advantages to the resulting concrete; however, the latter enable reducing the significantly the cement, which is costly, consumes natural resources, and negatively affects environment through CO2 emissions and increasing greenhouse effect [5]. Many of these mineral admixtures are industrial by-products like silica fume and fly ash. Other manufactured pozzolans have a vegetable origin like rice-husk ash, rice-straw ash [6,7,8,9,10].
Concrete durability is closely related, among other factors, to the type of environment in which the concrete has to perform. Fire is one of the natural hazards, which may attack building. The need for heat–resistant building materials is particularly important for structural purposes, especially in the chemical and metallurgical industries and for the thermal shielding of nuclear power plants [11]. On the other hand, the permeability of concrete dictates the rate at which aggressive agents can penetrate and attack the concrete and reinforcing steel bars. The aggressive agents are different and may exist in form of gases (CO2, SO2) or liquids (acid rains, acidic water, sulfate–rich water, extra pure water, seawater, etc.).
The WHA has proven success to improve mortar and concrete strengths; however, there are no available reports about its utilization in cement-based materials subjecting to harsh environment conditions. Therefore, it was decided to discuss the influence of using the new pozzolanic material (WHA) as a partial cement replacement in concrete mixtures to resist the deteriorating effects, including high temperatures and seawater. On one hand, the concrete has been extensively used in structures that may subjected to elevated temperature cause by the fire. In such case, the concrete should be designed to resist the deterioration for few hours before complete collapse. On the other hand, cement concrete is finding extensive application in construction of marine structures (coastal and offshore sea structures) either in precast or cast in situ forms as per requirements. A large number of structures can be exposed to seawater either directly or indirectly (e.g., winds can carry seawater spray up to a few miles inland from the coast). In these structures, the effect of seawater on concrete deserves special attention, as the concrete exposes to simultaneous action of several physical and chemical deterioration processes, which provide an excellent opportunity to understand the complexity of concrete durability problems in practice.
To study the resistance to high temperatures, the specimens were exposed to different elevated temperatures up to 600°C, while three curing regimes were followed before testing to investigate the resistance to seawater; curing in laboratory atmosphere, full-time immersion in seawater for a period of one month, and consecutive cycles of one day at laboratory atmosphere and one-day immersion in seawater for a total period of one month. The concrete mixes containing WHA were compared with plain concretes made with pure cement and others proportioned with 10% silica fume.

2. Experimental Program

2.1. Testing Program

A total of 24 concrete mixtures were prepared and tested. The main investigated parameters and their ranges are given in Table 1 of the mix design. Type GU cement, WHA burnt in open air (WHA(0)), WHA burnt in closed oven at 600˚C for 30 minutes (WHA(600)), and silica fume (SF) were considered as binder materials. Three replacement ratios of cement by each the two WHA types (5%, 10%, 15%) and one replacement ratio by SF (10%) were considered in the investigation. Three coarse aggregate (CA) types (gravel, dolomite, and basalt) were also incorporated in the concrete mixtures.
The 24 concrete mixtures were tested at the fresh state (slump and unit weight) and at the hardened state (28-day cubic compressive strength (Fcu) and 28-day indirect-tensile-splitting strength (Fsp)).
The durability aspects of WHA concretes were evaluated through the determination of the losses in compressive strength due to the exposure to different elevated temperatures and to dry-wetting cycles of seawater. This was realized on cubic specimens.
Resistance of concrete to high temperatures – After 28 days of moisture curing (lime-water path at 23°C), the concrete specimens were kept at laboratory atmosphere (23oC and 50% relative humidity (RH)) until the age of 91 days. The specimens were then dried at a 105±5ºC for 24 hours in electric furnace. To evaluate the resistance of concrete to high temperatures, the concrete specimens were exposed to the target high temperatures of 200ºC, 400ºC, and 600ºC for a duration of three hours. The heat-treated samples were cooled slowly to room temperature before testing. The results were compared with concrete mixtures remained at the laboratory atmosphere (23oC and 50% RH).
Resistance of concrete to dry-wet cycles of seawater – Concrete exposed to sea water is wetted by a solution of salts – principally sodium, chloride, and magnesium sulfate. In such case, damage to concrete usually results from failure to use good practices in concreteconstruction. Magnesium sulfate may attack most, if not all, of the constituents of hardened portland cement paste, especially the aluminate constituent; chlorides may promote corrosion of steel; and alkalis may participate in alkali-aggregate reaction.
After the 28-day moisture curing (lime-water path at 23°C), the concrete specimens were kept at laboratory atmosphere (23oC and 50% RH) until the age of 58 days. To investigate the resistance to seawater, three curing regimes were evaluated. In first case, the specimens were kept at laboratory atmosphere for another 32 days (from the age of 58 to 90 days), and was considered as control. In second case, the specimens were stored in seawater for a period of 32 days. In third case, the specimens were subjected to drying-wet composed of one-day at laboratory atmosphere and one-day in seawater for same period of 32 days. The concentration of the major ions in the seawater used in this investigation are listed in Table 2. The chemical composition of the seawater is characterized by the presence of about 3.5% soluble salts by wt. The ionic concentrations of Na+ and Cl- are the highest, typically 12,000 and 21,000 mg/liter, respectively. However, from the standpoint of aggressive action to cement hydration products, sufficient amounts of Mg++ and SO4-- are present, 1500 and 2600 mg/liter, respectively. The average value of the pH of the seawater is around 8.2.

2.2. Materials

Type GU cement was used in all mixtures. The SF obtained from a silicon company in Cairo Egypt was used in certain mixtures at a replacement level of 10%. Chemical and physical properties of cement and SF (provided by manufacturer) are given in Table 3.
Gravel, dolomite, and basalt as coarse aggregates (CA) with maximum-nominal size of 25 mm, as well as natural siliceous sand as fine aggregate (FA), with the physical and mechanical properties shown in Table 4, were incorporated in the mixtures. The grading curves of the combined aggregates were in good compliance with the limits of the British Standard code requirements.
The water hyacinth plants collected from the river Nile at Delta Barrages area in Egypt were used to obtain the investigated WHA. Two burning methods for producing the WHA were followed; burning in open air for 60 min (WHA(0)) and in a closed oven at 600˚C for 30 min (WHA(600)). The complete preparation processes are summarized in [3]. The two WHA types are presented in Figure 1.
The physical and chemical characterization of the two WHA types are described in Table 3. The elements expressing the potential of pozzolanic activity (SiO2, Al2O3, and Fe2O3) represent approximately 50% of the ash. This value corresponds to that found in some of fly ash types [12]. The large loss on ignition (LOI) values indicate existing of high quantity of organic materials in the resultant WHA. The percentages of WHA mass to the original dry plants that can be obtained from the open-air burning was found slightly greater (27.65%) than that obtained from the oven burning condition (25.85%).
After grinding process, laser-diffraction analysis was carried out on the WHA to determine the particle-size distribution (PSD), and the resultant PSDs are presented in Figure 2. The results indicate that the WHA(0) is coarser than the WHA(600). The respective particle size ranges from 1 to 125 μm for the WHA(0) with mean-particle diameters (d50) of 23 µm, and ranges from 1 to 62 μm for the WHA(600) with a d50 of 12 µm.
The scanning-electron microscope (SEM) photography using SEM model Philips XL30 attached with EDX unit carried out on the WHA revealed that the WHA is porous and mainly contained angular particles of irregular shape and rough textures, with few spherical particles of smooth surfaces similar to the OPC particles [3,13].

2.3. Mixture Proportions, Mixing Sequence, Samples Preparation, and Curing Conditions

All concrete ingredients were kept at 23°C for 24 hours prior mixing. The cementitious materials content were; 300 kg/m3 of OPC, OPC blended with 5%, 10%, 15% WHA(0) (by weight), OPC blended with 5%, 10%, 15% WHA(600) (by weight), and OPC blended with 10% SF (by weight). The w/cm was set at 0.50, without any superplasticizer addition. The ratio between the CA and FA was 2.0. The detailed concrete mix designs are given in Table 1.
Mixing was performed using an open-pan mixer of 50-L capacity at 20-rpm speed. The CA and FA were first charged in a mixer and homogenized for 1.0 minute, then cement (mixed with replacement materials; WHA or SF) was added and mixed for another 1.0 minute. The mixing water was finally added followed by a final mixing period of 3.0 minutes. At the end of mixing, the slump and unit weight for each concrete were measured.
Cubes specimens measuring 100 x 100 x 100 mm were prepared for measuring the Fcu (ASTM C39). Cylindrical specimens measuring 100 x 200 mm were prepared for measuring the Fsp (ASTM C496).
The concrete was placed in molds in layers of 50 mm in thickness and subjected to 30 blows using a standard compacting rod. The cast moulds were then placed on a vibrating table for 30 seconds before surface finishing. The specimens were kept in the moulds at a temperature of about 23°C and a RH of 50% for 24 hours before demolding and storing in lime-water path at 23°C until the age of 28 days. After 28 days, the specimens were removed from the water and kept in the laboratory atmosphere (a temperature of about 23°C and a RH of 50%). The results are the average of three samples.

3. Results and Discussions

3.1. Fresh Concrete Properties

3.1.1. Workability

The workability of the concrete mixtures was measured using slump cone, and the results are shown in Table 5. When WHA or SF was introduced into the concrete, the workability decreased. The results showed also more slump loss with increasing the WHA replacement ratio. The WHA of the porous, angular, irregular shape, and rough textures particles required higher water content compared to the cement particles. The higher percentage of the Al2O3 in the WHA compared to cement can also interpret the slump loss for the mixtures containing WHA. However, introducing the SF with large specific surface area compared to cement particles required also higher water content to lubricate the surface area of the particle. While maintaining the same water contents for all concrete mixtures, this affected the final workability. There was a probability of workability increase with increasing WHA content due to the cement dilution, which tends to reduce the formation of cement hydration products in the first few minutes of mixing. Therefore, there were insufficient products to bridge various particles together. It is worth noting that the WHA replacement of cement was by weight. As the specific gravity of WHA was lower than that of cement, the solid particles-to-water ratio, by volume, was higher than in case of cement and WHA blends compared to only cement. This increased the friction between the solids in the paste in the case of the WHA/cement blend, thereby resulting in a slight improvement in workability. This positive effect of cement dilution on workability was less effective compared to the rough and porous WHA particles. The higher WHA content ended up with workability loss.
Relative to the control mixture, the slump losses for the concretes containing WHA(600) were slightly higher than those of the concretes containing WHA(0), due to the finer particles of the former compared to the latter ashes (d50 = 12 vs. 23 μm, respectively). In addition, the slump of gravel concretes was higher than that of basalt concretes, then the dolomite concretes, which ranked the third. This was related to the surface texture and shape of the aggregates. The natural gravel was rounded and solid surface texture, crushed dolomite had with irregular and angular shapes with more porosity, and the basalt was crushed with non-porous particles.

3.1.2. Unit Weight

The unit weight results of the evaluated concrete mixtures are given in Table 5. The control concrete mixtures gave the largest values: the gravel, dolomite, and basalt concretes resulted in 2364 2493, and 2527 kg/m3 unit weight values, respectively, while the WHA concretes showed lower values than the control. The unit weight of concrete changes normally due to the change in the mix proportions or the properties of the ingredients used. In current results, the partial replacement of cement by WHA of lower density of the WHA yielded lower unit weight values. In fact, the density values of the WHA(600) concretes were lower than the control but higher than those containing the WHA(0) or SF, because the densities of the cement, WHA(600), WHA(0), and SF were 3.13, 2.65, 2.52, and 2.2, respectively.

3.2. Hardened Concrete Results

3.2.1. Cubes Compressive Strength (Fcu)

The results of the 28-day Fcu are shown in Figure 3 for three types of coarse aggregates; gravel, dolomite, and basalt.
The Fcu for the concrete containing 5% and 10% WHA was higher than that of the reference. The pozzolanic reactivity and the filling effect of the WHA can explain this increase. On the other hand, the strength of the concrete containing 15% WHA was lower than that of the reference. This might be due to the fact that the quantity of WHA in the mix may be higher than the required to react with the liberated calcium hydroxide resulted from cement hydration, thus leading to excess silica leached out and causing a deficiency in strength as it replaces part of the cementitious material but does not contribute to strength. This was the case for both burning conditions; WHA(0) and WHA(600). The concrete made with 5% WHA in some cases were found similar or greater than the concrete containing 10% SF. These findings are similar to the results obtained in [4,14].
The controlled burning process of the WHA in an oven at 600oC showed to be slightly more effective than the open-air burning on the Fcu. The Fcu of the WHA(600) concretes were slightly higher than those made with WHA(0) with little variations. This can be due to the small variations in the fineness between the two ashes.
It can also be observed that the Fcu results for the basalt concretes were greater than dolomite concretes, which in their turn were greater than the gravel concretes. This is referred to the relative crushing strengths and the surface texture of different aggregates.
Through visual inspection, the failure pattern of cubes after compressive test for the different mixes containing WHA are classified as non-explosive failure. However, the pattern of failure for the control mix and the mix containing SF showed explosive failure modes. It can also be seen that most of the cube specimens incorporating WHA showed the cracking to be at approximately 45°to the axis near the ends.

3.2.2. Splitting-Tensile Strength (Fsp)

Normally, plain concrete is not strong enough to resist tension loads, leading to cracking when subjected to shrinkage or any tensile stresses. So, improving the tensile strength of concrete by using alternative supplementary cementitious materials such as WHA is of importance for increasing the potential to crack resistance. The 28-day Fsp results for the investigated 24 concrete mixtures are illustrated in Figure 4.
The Fsp for the concrete mixtures made with WHA at all replacement ratios were greater than the control concrete. The maximum increase in the Fsp relative to the control were reported at 5% WHA and reached about 50%, such as in the case of gravel concrete with WHA(0)5% and basalt concrete with WHA(600)5%. These values were higher than the concrete mixtures containing 10% SF (the increase ranged between 39% and 44%). These findings are similar to the results obtained by other researchers [14]. However, incorporating higher percentage of WHA than 5% resulted in reduction in the Fsp, but in all cases, it was greater than the reference. Even at 15% WHA replacement, the increase in the Fsp was about 6% compared to the reference. As explained earlier in the compressive strength, this tensile strength gain can be due to the pozzolanic reactivity and the filling effect when incorporating WHA.
The cylinder specimens after cylindrical splitting tensile strength test exhibited fracture surfaces.

3.3. Resistance to High Temperatures

The effect of elevated temperature on mechanical performance of concrete depends on all concrete ingredients, including type and content of cement, cement replacement materials, admixtures, and aggregates. Figure 5 shows the effect of different treatment temperatures on compressive strength of the investigated concrete mixtures containing different cementitious materials (cement, WHA, and SF) and different types of coarse aggregates (gravel, dolomite, and basalt).
In general, the WHA concretes showed the highest resistance to elevated temperatures. This may be due to the higher thermal stability of concrete containing WHA than that of the reference concrete. At 200˚C, the compressive strength has been increased and reached about, for gravel concrete, 5%, 14%, and 10%, for dolomite concrete, 3%, 8%, and 4%, and for basalt concrete, 5%, 10%, and 6%, for reference, 5%WHA(0, 600), and 10% SF, respectively. These results are associated with the formation of more C-S-H hydrates with stronger binding forces and sufficient thermal stability during the heat treatment. As temperature increased to 400ºC, the compressive strength decreased for all concrete mixtures. The 600˚C temperature caused a major decrease in compressive strength, due to the disruption of the structure of the cementitious components under the effect of high temperature. The WHA concretes remained again the best in resisting this high temperature. The drops in the compressive strength recorded for the gravel concretes were 70%, 61%, and 65%, for the dolomite concrete were 62%, 57%, and 61%, and for the basalt concrete were about 65%, 60%, and 64% for the reference, 5%WHA(0, 600), and 10% SF, respectively. In this study, we can assume that the aggregate is thermally stable within the temperature range of exposures. The unstable component of the concrete under investigation is the portland cement paste. Heterogeneity of concrete due to its components, both in micro and macroscale, causes a large number of phenomena and physico-chemical processes during heat treatment. Therefore, the moisture is removed at a faster rate which affects the surrounding phase of cement paste when exposed to high temperatures. Mainly due to flow resistance and high temperature, steam creates a high pressure in the paste. In consequence, the so-called conditions for internal autoclaving are formed in cement paste. The temperature range between l00-300°C is the most favourable for the formation of such conditions because in this temperature range steam is liberated most intensively [15]. Additional hydration of unhydrated cement grains is the results of steam effect under the condition of internal autoclaving. This is indicated by a decrease in phases (C3S + β-C2S) and an increase in the Ca(OH) phase due to recrystallization of the amorphous Ca(OH) into more C-S-H.
Obviously, the concrete specimens made with 5% WHA, as cement replacement, possessed the highest strength at all temperatures during heat treatment relative to the reference. The addition of 10% WHA has proved also efficiency relative to the reference, but less than the 5% WHA. However, the situation was reversed when the replacement was more than 10% WHA. These results agree with those reported in the review [15,16]. These results can be related to the relative porosity of concrete at the various treatment temperatures. Generally, the porosity increases with increasing the temperature during the thermal treatment. So, the higher resistance to fire is mainly associated with the formation of a denser internal concrete structure when incorporating 5-10% WHA, resulting higher thermal stability. With increasing the WHA content in concrete, higher porosity values were obtained. This result is related to the formation and enlargement of microcracks and/or the increased degree of crystallinity of the formed hydrates leading to a sort of opening of the pore system of concrete specimens. As the WHA increases from 0 to 10%, larger amounts of C-S-H can be formed due to the decomposition of the cement hydrates. However, the concrete made with 15% WHA, there is no more C-S-H can be formed and the excess WHA remains free in the concrete medium.
The reduction in compressive strength due to the exposure to high temperatures for the dolomite concretes was higher than that for the basalt concretes and gravel concretes. This may be associated to the differences in the thermally stability values of the various coarse aggregates types used in this study at the various exposure temperature.

3.4. Resistance to Seawater

The factors inherent in seawater exposure that influence concrete are wetting and drying, chemical reaction of chlorides, sulfates, and alkalis (sodium and potassium), and in some instances, dissolved carbon dioxide. The SO4-- and Mg++ are also harmful constituents in seawater; sulfate attack is classified as severe when the SO4-- ion concentration is higher than 1500 mg/l; similarly, Portland cement paste can deteriorate by cat–ion-exchange reactions when Mg++ ion concentration exceeds, for instance, 500 mg/l. The seawater used in the current study had SO4-- and Mg++ concentrations of around 2600 and 1500 mg/l, respectively, as indicated in Table 2).
The percentage of decrease (relative to the dry curing at the laboratory atmosphere) in Fcu due to the exposure to wet-dry cycles of seawater (1 day in seawater and 1 day at laboratory atmosphere for a total period of 32 days – intermittent immersion) and to the full exposure to seawater for a total period of 32 days (continuous immersion) are shown in Figure 6 and Figure 7, respectively. The concrete mixtures containing different percentages of WHA(0) and WHA (600) were compared to a reference concrete mixture made only with cement and with 10%SF. The choice of these two exposure conditions were selected for various technical reasons which can detailed, as follows.

3.4.1. Effect of Continuous Immersion of Concrete in Seawater

Concrete that is totally and continuously immersed in water, even if the water contains dissolved salts such as are found in seawater, generally may be regarded as being in a protected exposure. Continuous immersion usually provides a uniformity of environment with respect to temperature and moisture content that prevents the immersed concrete from being subjected to such deteriorating influences as frost action, volume change due to wetting and drying, and differential volume change due to moisture content differences between the surface and the interior. Continuous immersion also tends to reduce the potential for chemical reaction by removing changes in degree of saturation as a mechanism for the flow in and out of the concrete of solutions containing ions that can attack concrete constituents, and leaving only concentration gradients as the means of ingress of such ions. Locher and Pisters [18] noted that under equal conditions of exposure, the aggressiveness of water increases with increasing concentration of the relevant substances, but that aggressiveness is also increased by higher temperatures, higher pressures, wetting and drying, or mechanical abrasion by fast-flowing or turbulent waters.

3.4.2. Effects of Intermittent Immersion of Concrete in Seawater

Most concrete structures exposed to seawater are partially or wholly situated so that they are sometimes immersed in seawater and sometimes exposed to air. If the structure is located where the temperatures fall below freezing, then the concrete that is exposed to the air with falling tide is probably subjected to as severe frost action as is any concrete in natural exposure. The second important effect on concrete related to wetting and drying is the volume change relations due to changes in, or changes in uniformity of, moisture content. These phenomena, often referred to as "drying shrinkage" effects.
The obtained results confirmed these observations. It can also be seen from the results in Figs. 6 and 7 that the decrease in the Fcu of the concrete mixtures with the intermittent immersion in seawater was greater than the decrease in the Fcu of the concrete mixtures with the continuous immersion in seawater. This can be illustrated in in the relationship in Figure 8.
The results revealed also that the WHA concretes presented higher resistance to seawater compared to reference with 100% cement. For example in the case of intermittent immersion and for reference, 5%WHA(0), 5%WHA(600), and 10% SF concretes, respectively, these reductions were about 7%, 4%, 3%, and 6% for the gravel concretes, 10%, 8%, 5%, and 7% for the dolomite concretes, 9%, 5%, 5%s and 5% for the basalt concretes. The respective values in the case of continuous immersion and for the reference, 5%WHA(0), 5%WHA(600), and 10% SF concretes, respectively, these reductions were about 5%, 2%, 2%, and 4.2% for the gravel concretes, 8%, 6%, 4%, and 5% for the dolomite concretes, 7%, 4%, 3%, and 5% for the basalt concretes. Other general observations are; (1) the decrease in Fcu of WHA and SF concretes was inferior than the decrease in Fcu of reference concrete, (2) the decrease in the Fcu of the concrete mixtures containing 5%WHA(600) or 5%WHA(0) were lower than the decrease in the Fcu of the reference concrete and in most cases than SF 10% concrete. The 5%WHA replacement ratio could be considered the best ratio resulting in the best resistance to seawater exposure, and (3) the decrease in the Fcu of the concrete mixtures contained 10% and 15% WHA(600) and 10% and 15% WHA(0) were higher than the decrease in the Fcu of the reference and the 10%SF concrete mixtures.
The use of proper dosage of WHA in concrete mixture can densify the concrete microstructure, leading to a reduction in the porosity and an improvement in permeability and strength. This can be related to the role of the WHA in filling the voids between concrete particles. By doing so, the concrete structure can better prevent the seawater from penetrating inside the concrete. The use of pozzolans in concrete to be exposed to seawater has been recommended because of the observations stating that their use increases the resistance of the concrete to chemical attack to the seawater. Lea [19] reviewed the various explanations that have been offered for this effect. The explanations include: (1) reduction in amount of free calcium hydroxide, by reaction with pozzolan, thus reducing the degree to which the reaction of sulfates and calcium hydroxide can occur; (2) increased solubility of hydrated calcium aluminates with decreased concentration of calcium hydroxide, and hence greater likelihood that the sulfate-aluminate reaction will take place through solution rather than in the solid state and thus produce less expansion; (3) decreased tendency of the low-sulfate calcium-aluminum sulfate to convert to the high-sulfate form (ettringite) as the concentration of calcium hydroxide in solution decreases, due to the higher sulfate concentration required to effect the conversion as such decrease occurs; (4) decreased permeability of the concrete with reduced rate of entry of sulfate solution; (5) formation of lime-pozzolan reaction product films that protect the hydrated calcium aluminate; and (6) decomposition of lime-pozzolan reaction products by seawater to leave silica and alumina gel which are more stable products.
The expansive hydraulic cement (ASTM C845) [20] has received attention for concrete construction in marine exposures. Concretes made with expansive cement may be controlled to achieve shrinkage compensation, resistance to cracking, reduced permeability, and wear resistance. Such properties may help to render wharf decks crackproof, waterproof, and hence more wear-resistant. Expansive-cement concrete should further enhance the resistance to seawater of both reinforced and prestressed concrete piles for waterfront applications. The WHA could give a tendency like the expansive cement, because the WHA can increase the percentage of the Al2O3 of the WHA/cement blend as it possesses higher percentage of Al2O3 than cement.
The decrease in the Fcu for the concretes containing WHA(600) was slightly lower than the decrease in the Fcu of the concretes containing WHA(0). This can be due to the small variations in the fineness between the two ashes.
It can also be seen from the results that, the reduction in the Fcu due to immersed in seawater for the gravel concrete was less than the reduction reported in Fcu for the basalt concretes, while the dolomite concretes placed the third. This is referred to the relative crushing strengths and the surface texture of different aggregates.

4. Conclusions

The main conclusions derived from this study can be summarized as follows:
  • During the manufacture of water-hyacinth ash (WHA), burning the dried water-hyacinth plants in closed ovens produces ash with no effect on environment and with high silica content than burning in open air.
  • The use of WHA as a cement replacement material can provide distinguished increase to concrete strength, and the resistance of elevated temperatures and seawater.
  • The addition of WHA to ordinary concrete leads to the consumption of Ca(OH) obtained during cement hydration and forming more C-S-H of stronger binding forces and a sufficient thermal stability, resulting in a concrete with densified microstructure and of lower porosity and permeability. Concrete made with 5% to 10% WHA possess the higher compressive strength compared to reference, with more particular attention when exposed to thermal treatment at elevated temperatures.
  • Deterioration of concrete exposed to seawater is mainly due to chemical action (change in composition of cement by chlorides and sulfates present in seawater). Selecting suitable cementitious materials with pozzolanic-based effects such as WHA can ensure densified and impermeable concrete product with higher resistance to seawater attack.
  • WHA at a 5% replacement ratio to cement is the optimum, leading to a distinguished increase in concrete strength compared to the control due to the pozzolanic activity, filling capacity, and enhancing the transition zones between cement paste and aggregate. The 10% WHA replacement ratio can also result in concrete with performance better than the reference. However, the 15% cannot contribute to strength improvement compared to the control.
  • Using water hyacinth as cement replacement material in concrete participates in keeping the environment clean, while reducing natural resources of cement manufacture.

References

  1. Water Canal Maintenance Research Institute “A guide to water weeds and ways to limit their spread”, December 1999.
  2. El-Enany AE, Mazen AMA “Isolation of Cd-binding protein of water hyacinth (E. Crassipes) grown in Nile river water”, Water, Air, and Soil pollution, 1996; 87(1-4):357-362. [CrossRef]
  3. Omran AF, Soliman NA, Kamal MM, Shaheen YB, Osman MAE “Feasibility of using water-hyacinth ash (WHA) as an alternative supplementary cementitious material” Magazine of concrete research, submitted and pending decision; 44 p.
  4. Krishnan S, MurugeshV “Experimental study on strength of water hyacinth ash as partial replacement of cement in concrete”, International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, March-2018;9(3):93-96. [CrossRef]
  5. Matte V, Moranville M, Adenot F, Riche C, Torrenti JM “Simulated microstructure and transport properties of ultra-high-performance cement-based materials” Journal of Cement and Concrete Research, 2000;30(12):1947-1954. [CrossRef]
  6. Malhotra VM “Fly ash, slag, silica fume, and rice husk ash in concrete a review”, Magazine of Concrete International, April 1993;23-28.
  7. Bouzoubaa N, Min-Hong Zhang VM, Malhotra VM, Golden DM “Blended fly ash cement – a review” ACI Materials Journal, 1999;641-650.
  8. Mehta PK, “Pozzolanic and cementitious by–products in concrete: another look”, ACI SP-114, 1989;1-43.
  9. Mehta PK “Pozzolanic and cementitious by-products as mineral admixtures for concrete – a critical review”, ACI SP-79, 1983;1-46.
  10. Cook DJ, Suwanvitaya P “Rice husk ash based cements - a state-of-the-art review”, Proceedings of the ESCAP/RCTT, 3rd Workshop on Rice – Husk Ash Cement, New Delhi, India, 1981.
  11. Saad M, Abo-El-Enein SA, Hanna GB, Kotkata MF “Effect of temperature on physical and mechanical properties of concrete containing silica fume,” Cement and Concrete Research, 1996; 26(5); 669-675. [CrossRef]
  12. Ramachandran V “Concrete science”, Heyden & Sons Ltd., London, 1981.
  13. Makhlouf AAAH, “Application of water hyacinth ash as a partial replacement for cement”, PhD thesis, Cairo University, Egypt, 2002.
  14. Abdel Hay AS, Fawzy YA“Impact of water hyacinth on properties of concrete made with various gravel to dolomite ratios,” Proc. of the 3rd Intl. Conf. Advances in Civil, Structural and Mechanical Engineering-CSM 2015, Institute of Research Engineers and Doctors, USA, ISBN: 978-1 -63248-062-0. 2015;76-80. [CrossRef]
  15. Piasta J, Sawicz Z, Rudzinski L “Changes in the structure of hardened cement paste due to high temperature,” Journal of Materials and Structure, 1984;100; 291. [CrossRef]
  16. Detwiler RJ., Mehta PK “Chemical and physical effect of silica fume on the mechanical behavior of concrete,” ACI Materials Journal, 86(6);609-614. [CrossRef]
  17. Mather B “Effects of sea water on concrete”, Miscellaneous paper, 1964; (No. 6-690).
  18. Locher FW, Pisters H "Beurteilung betonangreifender Wasser" Zement-Kalk-Gips, April 1964;(No. 4);129-136.
  19. Lea FM “The Chemistry of Cement and Concrete”, St. Martin's Press,New York, N.Y. 1956.
  20. ASTM C845 “Standard Specification for Expansive Hydraulic Cement”, Annual book of ASTM standards, West Conshohocken, PA: American Society for Testing Materials, 2012. 3 pp.
Figure 1. Fresh and dried water hyacinth plants, and water-hyacinth ashes (WHA).
Figure 1. Fresh and dried water hyacinth plants, and water-hyacinth ashes (WHA).
Preprints 148855 g001
Figure 2. Particle-size distribution of water-hyacinth ash (WHA) burnt in open air and closed oven at 600 oC.
Figure 2. Particle-size distribution of water-hyacinth ash (WHA) burnt in open air and closed oven at 600 oC.
Preprints 148855 g002
Figure 3. Cube compressive strength (Fcu) for investigated concrete mixtures at 28 days.
Figure 3. Cube compressive strength (Fcu) for investigated concrete mixtures at 28 days.
Preprints 148855 g003
Figure 4. Splitting-tensile strength (Fsp) (after 28 days of curing) for investigated concrete mixtures.
Figure 4. Splitting-tensile strength (Fsp) (after 28 days of curing) for investigated concrete mixtures.
Preprints 148855 g004
Figure 5. Effect of high temperatures on cube compressive strength (Fcu) for investigated concrete mixtures.
Figure 5. Effect of high temperatures on cube compressive strength (Fcu) for investigated concrete mixtures.
Preprints 148855 g005
Figure 6. Percentage of decrease (relative to the dry curing at the laboratory atmosphere) in cube compressive strength (Fcu) due to the intermittent immersion in seawater for a total period of 32 days.
Figure 6. Percentage of decrease (relative to the dry curing at the laboratory atmosphere) in cube compressive strength (Fcu) due to the intermittent immersion in seawater for a total period of 32 days.
Preprints 148855 g006
Figure 7. Percentage of decrease (relative to the dry curing at the laboratory atmosphere) in cube compressive strength (Fcu) due to the continuous immersion in seawater for a total period of 32 days.
Figure 7. Percentage of decrease (relative to the dry curing at the laboratory atmosphere) in cube compressive strength (Fcu) due to the continuous immersion in seawater for a total period of 32 days.
Preprints 148855 g007
Figure 8. Correlation between the reduction in cubic-compressive strength (Fcu) of the intermittent versus the continuous immersions in seawater.
Figure 8. Correlation between the reduction in cubic-compressive strength (Fcu) of the intermittent versus the continuous immersions in seawater.
Preprints 148855 g008
Table 1. Concrete mix design.
Table 1. Concrete mix design.
Group Mix no. Mix proportions (kg/m³) w/cm CA/FA Rep/C
C W FA CA Replacement (Rep)
WHA(0) WHA(600) SF
Gravel concrete OPC 300 150 638 1276 0.5 2
WHA(0)5% 285 150 637 1274 15 0.5 2 0.05
WHA(0)10% 270 150 636 1272 30 0.5 2 0.10
WHA(0)15% 255 150 635 1270 45 0.5 2 0.15
WHA(600)5% 285 150 637 1274 15 0.5 2 0.05
WHA(600)10% 270 150 637 1273 30 0.5 2 0.10
WHA(600)15% 255 150 635 1271 45 0.5 2 0.15
SF 10% 270 150 635 1269 30 0.5 2 0.10
Dolomite concrete OPC 300 150 681 1362 0.5 2
WHA(0)5% 285 150 680 1360 15 0.5 2 0.05
WHA(0)10% 270 150 679 1358 30 0.5 2 0.10
WHA(0)15% 255 150 678 1356 45 0.5 2 0.15
WHA(600)5% 285 150 680 1360 15 0.5 2 0.05
WHA(600)10% 270 150 679 1359 30 0.5 2 0.10
WHA(600)15% 255 150 679 1357 45 0.5 2 0.15
SF 10% 270 150 677 1355 30 0.5 2 0.10
Basalt concrete OPC 300 150 692 1385 0.5 2
WHA(0)5% 285 150 691 1382 15 0.5 2 0.05
WHA(0)10% 270 150 690 1380 30 0.5 2 0.10
WHA(0)15% 255 150 689 1378 45 0.5 2 0.15
WHA(600)5% 285 150 692 1383 15 0.5 2 0.05
WHA(600)10% 270 150 691 1381 30 0.5 2 0.10
WHA(600)15% 255 150 690 1380 45 0.5 2 0.15
SF 10% 270 150 689 1377 30 0.5 2 0.10
Table 2. Major constituents of seawater (% wt. of dissolved materials).
Table 2. Major constituents of seawater (% wt. of dissolved materials).
CONSTITUENT SYMBOL PERCENTAGE % CONCENTRATION (MG/L)
Sodium Na++ 30.61 124000
Magnesium Mg++ 3.69 1500
Calcium Ca++ 1.16 470
Potassium K+ 1.10 445
Strontium Si ++ 0.03 12
Chloride Cl - 55.04 21270
Sulphate SO4 - - 7.68 2596
Bicarbonate HCO3 - 0.41 165
Bromine Br - 0.19 77
These results were experimentally determined at the Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Minoufia University.
Table 3. Chemical composition and physical properties of cement, silica fume, and water-hyacinth ash (WHA).
Table 3. Chemical composition and physical properties of cement, silica fume, and water-hyacinth ash (WHA).
Constituent Cement Silica fume Water-hyacinth ash (WHA)
Burnt in air Burnt in 600°C
Chemical composition SiO2 19.49 93.00 33.9 34.5
Ti2O3 0.75 0.78
Al2O3 4.70 0.5 6.77 6.95
Fe2O3 3.28 1.5 5.77 6.02
SO3 3.4 0.2
MgO 2.40 0.5 5.40 5.93
CaO 62.8 0.2 10.08 11.46
Na2O 0.38 0.5 1.26 1.41
K2O 0.95 0.5 9.83 10.98
H2O 0.6
MnO 0.66 0.73
P2O5 1.04 1.13
Cl‾ 3.82 4.02
SO4‾ ‾ 2.37 3.74
Loss On Ignition (LOI) 2.4 1.5 17.93 11.91
total 99.8 99.60 99.54
Physical properties Blaine surface area (m2/kg) 300 17000
Bulk density (kg/m3) 280
Specific gravity 3.13 2.20 2.52 2.65
Color Light gray Dark gray Light brown
Table 4. Physical and mechanical properties of fine and coarse aggregates.
Table 4. Physical and mechanical properties of fine and coarse aggregates.
Property Fine aggregate (sand) (FA) Coarse aggregates (CA)
Gravel Dolomite Basalt
Specific gravity (SSD) 2.58 2.52 2.78 2.85
Volume weight (t/m³) 1.710 1.630 1.615 1.682
Void ratio (%) 33.72 35.2 41.9 41.0
Aggregate crushing value (%) 15 19 12
Fineness modulus 2.71 7.55 7.45 7.60
Clay, silt, and fine dust (% by weight) 2.13
Chloride (% by weight) 0.031 0.027 0.032 0.023
Sulfate (% by weight) 0.130 0.190 0.160
Table 5. Fresh concrete properties.
Table 5. Fresh concrete properties.
Materials Slump (mm) Unit weight (kg/m³)
Gravel Dolomite Basalt Gravel Dolomite Basalt
OPC 105 100 135 2364 2493 2527
WHA(0)5% 95 92 123 2361 2490 2524
WHA(0)10% 87 77 110 2358 2487 2521
WHA(0)15% 80 67 97 2355 2483 2517
WHA(600)5% 92 85 120 2362 2490 2525
WHA(600)10% 85 70 105 2359 2488 2522
WHA(600)15% 75 60 90 2357 2486 2520
SF 10% 55 40 60 2354 2482 2516
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.
Prerpints.org logo

Preprints.org is a free preprint server supported by MDPI in Basel, Switzerland.

Subscribe

Disclaimer

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy

Privacy Settings

© 2025 MDPI (Basel, Switzerland) unless otherwise stated