1. Introduction and Theoretical Context
1.1. Notation and Assumptions
| Symbol |
Description |
Unit (in CSIF) |
|
Informational Conductivity |
|
|
Informational Equilibrium State |
Dimensionless Density Operator |
|
Local Quantum State |
Dimensionless Density Operator |
|
Relative Entropy,
|
Dimensionless (Nats) |
|
Informational Energy Density |
|
|
Informational Stress-Energy Tensor |
|
|
Conversion Factor () |
|
|
Informational Order Parameter Fields (Minimal Model: )1
|
Dimensionless (Topological Indices) |
|
Informational Sector Lagrangian Density |
|
1.2. Assumptions and Validity Scope
Effective Field Theory (EFT): The CSIF is treated as an effective theory below a near-Planck UV cutoff scale. The physical UV cutoff defines the coherent informational cell.
Local Boundary Conditions (Z): The equilibrium state is the maximum entropy state, constrained by locally conserved quantities Z.
WEC Conformance of the Matter Sector: satisfies the Weak Energy Condition (WEC). WEC violation occurs exclusively through the sector.
1.3. Novelty and Relation to Existing FTL Literature
Previous FTL solutions (Alcubierre [1], Krasnikov [2], Natário, Lentz) suffer from two major challenges: the requirement of exotic matter and the violation of causality (Closed Timelike Curves, CTCs).
Conceptually, the present work combines three ingredients developed in previous CSIF papers: (i) gravity as an informational equation of state [4,10], (ii) the causal-symmetric dynamics of spacetime and informational conductivity [5–7], and (iii) the reinterpretation of non-equilibrium information as an effective energy source [10,14]. Here, these elements are brought together to specify an Alcubierre-type metric whose source is entirely informational.
The key distinction of the CSIF approach is twofold:
Source Replacement: Instead of relying on ad-hoc or quantum field theory (QFT) derived negative energy densities (e.g., Casimir effect in curved spacetime), the source is fundamentally derived from an Informational Equation of State ([4, 10]), sourced by non-equilibrium quantum information (). This reinterprets `exotic matter’ as controllable, emergent negentropy.
Causality Control: The CSIF framework inherently links the local light speed to the informational conductivity ([7]). The -gradient profile is explicitly designed to satisfy the Chronology Protection Conjecture (Sect. 3.3), providing a robust mechanism absent in most classical FTL solutions.
Comparison to Recent Literature
Recent work has explored FTL solutions that minimize the need for exotic matter (Bobrick & Martire [24]) or even postulate positive-energy warp drive solutions (Lentz [25]). While these approaches are highly valuable, they typically achieve reduced exotic matter requirements at the cost of complex shell geometries or remain subluminal. Our approach deliberately embraces the necessity of controlled NEC violation for true FTL and instead focuses on providing a physically realized, non-QFT source ( from negentropy) and a built-in mechanism for Chronology Protection (the -gradient). Our solution thus falls into the class of Alcubierre-like metrics but replaces the unknown exotic matter with a quantifiable informational source derived from first principles within the CSIF.
Relative to previous FTL proposals, the present work adds two structural elements: (i) an explicit informational equation-of-state replacing ad-hoc exotic matter, and (ii) a -controlled chronology protection mechanism that yields a sufficient condition for global hyperbolicity of the warp metric.
2. Theoretical Foundations and Consistency Check
2.1. Gravity as an Informational Equation of State
The underlying field equation is a
modified Einstein equation, where the source term is partitioned into the standard matter sector
and the informational contribution
:
The
Informational Energy Density (), derived from the CSIF (cf. [4]), serves as the primary source:
The relation
is taken as a summary expression of the informational equation-of-state derived in [4,10], where the relative entropy density is shown to play the role of a local free energy (negentropy) source. We loosely refer to
as “negentropy”, i.e. an informational energy density that becomes available when the local state
deviates from the equilibrium state
.
Exact Normalization of
The conversion factor
has the dimension
. In the Planck limit, the product
(with
) is normalized to the Planck energy density
:
Here,
and
denote the Planck time and Planck volume, respectively. The
physical UV cutoff defines the size of the entropy cell
, which corresponds to
in the Planck limit.
Covariant Definition and QFT Regularization
The finiteness of is ensured by the EFT with the physical UV cutoff . This coarse-graining causes the local observable algebra to effectively become a Type-I algebra with a finite number of degrees of freedom per cell ([18, 15]), thereby making the relative entropy well-defined. Physically, acts as the measure of "free energy" (negentropy) available from a local state relative to its maximal entropy equilibrium . Crucially, the local definition of relates to the generalized second law and the holographic entanglement entropy principle (cf. [21, 23]), supporting its interpretation as a localized energy density source that effectively couples information to curvature.
2.2. Causal-Symmetric Field Equations and
The informational sector Lagrangian density is defined as a k-essence model (cf. [19]):
with the kinetic term
Note on Full Consistency
The requirement that the resultant Einstein tensor
, derived from the postulated metric (
8), exactly matches the generated source
constitutes a set of coupled non-linear differential equations for
and
I. Finding the complete, self-consistent numerical solution for this coupling is reserved for subsequent work. In the high-energy warp drive region, where the ordinary matter contribution
is negligible compared to
, the field equations effectively reduce to
. However, the fundamental consistency constraints (NEC violation,
) are established here.
General Relativity (GR) Limit
In the limit of constant conductivity
and constant order parameter
, one has
, meaning
. Consequently, the informational contribution
vanishes (
), and the field equation (
1) reduces exactly to the standard Einstein field equations.
Minimal Model for NEC Violation and Stability
The FTL warp drive requires a controlled violation of the Null Energy Condition (NEC), meaning for a null vector . This sector formally constitutes exotic matter in the GR sense, but it is physically sourced by informational negentropy ().
An explicit minimal model chooses and . For a timelike I-gradient (), this is a ghost-free k-essence model (cf. [16, 17]).
- (i)
Ghost-Free Condition: Ghost-freedom requires .
- (ii)
-
Speed of Sound: For a general k-essence Lagrangian
, the squared speed of sound is given by
where
and
. For the minimal choice
, one has
and
, hence
This confirms dynamical stability in the sense of the absence of gradient instabilities.
In this minimal choice, the NEC violation arises not from superluminal sound speed or ghost-like degrees of freedom, but from the effective pressure profile generated by the controlled gradients of in the wall region.
Quantum Energy Inequalities (QEI)
Standard QFT-derived negative energy densities are severely constrained by Quantum Energy Inequalities (QEI), such as those established by Ford and Roman [26]. These QEI place sharp lower bounds on the possible time-averaged or spatially integrated negative energy density, effectively limiting the scope of FTL metrics derived from standard QFT. However, the source in the CSIF is not a vacuum expectation value derived from a standard QFT stress-energy tensor. Instead, it is an emergent, effective energy density arising from the coarse-graining of quantum information () at the UV cutoff . Since is defined via coarse-grained relative entropy at the UV cutoff rather than as the expectation value of a local QFT stress–energy operator, the standard QEI theorems, which assume local operator-valued distributions and Hadamard states, do not directly constrain .
3. The Warp Mechanism: Metric and Causality
3.1. Specification of the Warp Metric and -Profile
The metric family is described by the shift vector
:
The form function
, which determines the shape of the warp drive bubble, is controlled by the strongly damped
-profile. An idealized
-profile along the direction of travel (
x) can be specified as:
where
is the constant conductivity inside the bubble,
is the background value,
R is the bubble radius, and
is the wall thickness. The rapid gradient of
in the wall (
) is key to generating the necessary
.
3.2. Effective Invariant Speed
The CSIF posits that the local invariant speed
is dynamically coupled to the informational conductivity
and the curvature scalar
(cf. [7]). The coupling is generally expressed as a running speed:
where
is a
schematic curvature invariant (e.g.,
). The essential result relevant for causality is that
is a monotonic function of
. For the FTL solution, the profile is tailored such that
is minimized in the interior, allowing
locally, while the background
dictates the maximum speed. The
strict monotonicity of this function is guaranteed by the physical requirement that the informational renormalization procedure damps the effective speed only as a function of the local background conductivity
and not of the gradient of
. This running form is directly taken from the result of the
c-renormalization procedure derived in [7].
3.3. Chronology Protection
We formulate the following sufficient condition and provide a heuristic proof sketch based on the metric control:
Conjecture.
Chronology Protection Conjecture (Sufficient Condition). If the informationally renormalized speed of light scales monotonically with (as established by the field-theoretic running of the invariant speed in [7]) and the -profile satisfies the critical condition and is smooth and strictly monotonic along the bubble normal, then the metric is globally hyperbolic.
The condition stated in the conjecture is meant as a sufficient, not a necessary, criterion for global hyperbolicity.
Proof Sketch
Global hyperbolicity requires the existence of a global time function
with an everywhere timelike gradient, thus ensuring the absence of closed timelike curves (CTCs). The
strict monotonicity of the -gradient in the transition region controls the effective light cones via
and guarantees that the coefficient of
in (
8) remains negative:
The condition ensures the local time coordinate t defines a good global time function and that a global Cauchy surface exists (cf. [13, 20]). The argument follows the standard requirement that an everywhere timelike gradient defines a global time function and hence a Cauchy surface, as in the usual treatments of globally hyperbolic spacetimes.
4. Quantitative Analysis and Technical Specification
4.1. Energy Requirements and Scaling
The total required negative energy
must match the requirement derived from the classical
Alcubierre/Visser metric analysis (cf. [1, 20]), where the necessary energy is concentrated in a spherical shell (wall) of thickness
and radius
R. This leads to the requirement:
Since
holds (see Appendix A), the required informational energy density
scales quadratically with the bubble radius:
The main technological difficulty lies in the local generation and stabilization of this negentropy () in a magnitude comparable to the Planck energy density.
Concrete Estimate for
To quantify the difficulty, we consider a large yet technologically motivated example: a bubble radius , wall thickness , and speed . The volume of the wall is .
Assuming a reference value for the required negative energy density
of
(equivalent mass density, a conservative estimate compared to the original Alcubierre value of order
before Visser’s thin-wall reduction), the required total negentropy is:
This total energy (stored as informational negentropy) is still astronomical (of order times the world’s annual energy consumption). The minimum relative entropy density required is Nats per Planck volume. This confirms that the problem is not merely about finding `exotic matter’, but about achieving quantum control at the Planck-scale energy density. This estimate makes explicit that the present proposal is not a near-future engineering scheme but a consistency analysis of whether, in principle, a CSIF-sourced FTL metric can be made compatible with GR, energy conditions, and causality.
4.2. Operationalization of the QRNG Falsification Experiment
The protocol tests the correlation function in the Delayed-Choice QRNG. The expected deviation is . The observed quantity in the experiment is the shift in the probability distribution (), which depends on the informational conductivity and the delay time .
Any experimental constraint on directly bounds the accessible informational energy density and thus the practical feasibility of the proposed warp drive. This makes the QRNG experiment a critical test, as bounds on directly translate into bounds on the accessible .
For a effect, detecting a 5-sigma result requires of order measurements, far beyond any current experimental capability, but conceptually ties the warp drive feasibility directly to an experimentally falsifiable parameter . Even though the required statistics are far beyond current experimental reach, any upper bound inferred from such protocols would immediately translate into a lower bound on and hence on the minimal wall energy density required for the informational warp drive.
5. Discussion and Outlook
The CSIF provides a consistent theoretical pathway to FTL, shifting the central challenge from unknown exotic matter to controlled quantum information. We categorize the ongoing research tasks into three areas:
Mathematical Consistency: Further work is needed to find complete, self-consistent numerical solutions for the coupled field equations
where the
-profile and the
I-field profile are dynamically generated (not just postulated), ensuring
exactly yields the required metric
.
Physical Plausibility: Phenomenological constraints on the coupling constant must be tightened through terrestrial experiments, such as the proposed QRNG falsification experiment. Experimental limits on directly bound the minimum required relative entropy and thus the plausibility of the informational source.
Technological Realizability: The fundamental hurdle remains the generation and stabilization of immense negentropy at Planck-scale energy densities. This identifies the problem as a grand challenge in quantum engineering (Planck-scale informational control).
6. Conclusions
The derivation of the source from a covariant action, the quantified -scaling, and the formally motivated Chronology Protection Conjecture establish this concept as a valid and rigorous research approach. We provide a formal consistency argument and a sufficient condition for global hyperbolicity.
Appendix A. Brief Derivation of D(ρ∥σ Z ) min Scaling
The total required negative energy
scales with the volume of the bubble wall
and the necessary negative energy density
:
Since
holds, solving for
yields:
References
- lcubierre, M. The warp drive: hyper-fast travel within general relativity. Classical and Quantum Gravity 1994, 11(5), L73–L77. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- rasnikov, S. Hyperfast travel problem. Physical Review D 1998, 57(4), 4760–4766. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- acobson, T. Thermodynamics of spacetime: the Einstein equation of state. Physical Review Letters 1995, 75(7), 1260–1263. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- ubenstein, E. Gravity from Information: An Equation of State for Spacetime Curvature. 2025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- ubenstein, E. Causal-Symmetric Quantum Dynamics of Spacetime. 2025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- ubenstein, E. A Causal Symmetry Approach to Quantum Nonlocality and Information. 2025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- ubenstein, E. Informational Renormalization of the Invariant Speed: A Causal–Symmetric Framework for Dynamical Light Propagation. 2025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- ubenstein, E. The Topological Origin of Space. 2025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- aynes, E. T. Information Theory and Statistical Mechanics. Physical Review 1957, 106(4), 620–630. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- ubenstein, E. Informational Energy in a Causal–Symmetric Framework for Spacetime. 2025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- andauer, R. Irreversibility and heat generation in the computing process. IBM Journal of Research and Development 1961, 5(3), 183–191. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- effner, S.; Jarzynski, C. Information processing and the second law of thermodynamics: An inclusive, Hamiltonian approach. Reports on Progress in Physics 2013, 76(7), 076201. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- horne, K. S. Black Holes and Time Warps: Einstein’s Outrageous Legacy; W. W. Norton & Company: New York, 1994; ISBN 978-0393035850. [Google Scholar]
- ubenstein, E. Magic as Signature Practice: An Informational Engineering Model in a Causal-Symmetric Framework. 2025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- hya, M.; Petz, D. Quantum Entropy and Its Use; Springer Science & Business Media, 1993; ISBN 978-3-642-86088-3. [Google Scholar]
- rkani-Hamed, N.; Creminelli, P.; Mukohyama, S.; Zaldarriaga, M. Ghost condensation and a consistent infrared modification of gravity. Journal of High Energy Physics 2004, 2004(05), 074. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- icolis, A.; Rattazzi, R.; Trincherini, E. The Galileon as a local modification of gravity. Physical Review D 2009, 79(6), 064036. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- raki, H. Relative entropy for states of von Neumann algebras. Publications of the Research Institute for Mathematical Sciences 1976, 11(3), 809–833. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- rmendariz-Picon, C.; Mukhanov, V.; Steinhardt, P. J. Essentials of k-essence. Physical Review D 2001, 63(10), 103510. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- isser, M. Warp drive basics. Classical and Quantum Gravity 1998, 15(6), 1767–1791. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- an Raamsdonk, M. Building up spacetime with quantum entanglement. General Relativity and Gravitation 2010, 42(2), 2323–2329. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- erlinde, E. On the origin of gravity and the laws of Newton. Journal of High Energy Physics 2011, 2011(4), 029. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- all, A. C. The generalized second law as a quantum singularity theorem. International Journal of Modern Physics D 2018, 24(12), 1544014. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- obrick, A.; Martire, G. Introducing physical warp drives. Classical and Quantum Gravity 2021, 38(10), 105009. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- entz, E. W. Breaking the warp barrier: hyper-fast solitons in Einstein–Maxwell–plasma theory. Classical and Quantum Gravity 2021, 38(7), 075015. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- ord, L. H.; Roman, T. A. Quantum field theory constraints on the energy density of a warp drive. Physical Review D 1996, 54(6), 4996–5000. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
| 1 |
The field acts as the non-equilibrium scalar potential, driving the informational flow and coupling to . It serves as a topological index within the CSIF. |
|
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2025 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).