Submitted:
02 March 2025
Posted:
03 March 2025
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
Reservoir sedimentation presents a critical challenge to sustainability, impacting operational capacity and increasing maintenance costs. This study analyzes the impact of sediment accumulation in La Estancilla Reservoir, located in Manabí, Ecuador, and proposes sustainable strategies to mitigate its effects. Simulations using AutoCAD Civil 3D project a 45.06% loss of active capacity by 2024 and sediment accumulation exceeding 103% by 2042. The Carrizal River basin, which feeds the reservoir, exhibits physiographic characteristics that enhance sediment transport, exacerbated by land-use changes and intensive agricultural activities. Proposed solutions include reforestation with native species, sediment traps, and continuous monitoring with drones and LiDAR sensors. These strategies not only improve the operational sustainability of the reservoir but are also replicable in other regions facing similar challenges.
Keywords:
INTRODUCTION
STATE OF THE ART
1. Introduction to the Sedimentation Problem
1.1. The Challenge of Sedimentation
2. Factors Contributing to Sedimentation
2.1. Physiographic Characteristics of Watersheds
2.2. Anthropogenic Activities
2.3. Land-Use Changes
3. Emerging Technologies for Sediment Management
3.1. Monitoring with Sensors and Drones
3.2. Predictive Models with Artificial Intelligence
3.3. Green Infrastructure
4. Nature-Based Strategies
4.1. Adaptation to the Manabí Context
4.2. Applicable International Examples
5. Policies and International Collaboration
5.1. Global Regulations
5.2. International Lessons
- Japan: Utilization of artificial intelligence to predict sedimentation (Fujimoto et al., 2022).
- United States: Predictive models optimizing dredging strategies (Reisenbüchler et al., 2021).
- Spain: Public policies combined with technological infrastructure reducing sedimentation (Cattanéo et al., 2020).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Watershed Characterization
Physiographic and Hydrological Characteristics
| Parameter | Description |
|---|---|
| Area | 2,391 km² - Considered a small watershed. |
| Actual Surface Area | 2,394 km² - Calculated considering slopes and curvature. |
| Average Slope | 4.86% - Contributes to high erosion rates. |
| Average Elevation | 19.82 m - Mean watershed elevation. |
| Compactness Coefficient | 1.13 - Oval-oblong watershed shape. |
| Elongation Ratio | 0.70 - Pronounced relief, favoring good drainage. |
| Circularity Ratio | 0.78 - Efficient runoff evacuation without excessive flooding. |
METHODOLOGY
- Historical land-use analysis within the watershed.
- Vegetation loss assessment and its correlation with erosion rates.
- Identification of sedimentation zones in the reservoir using spectral indices.
- Digital elevation modeling (DEM) of the reservoir and its surroundings.
- Simulation of sediment deposition patterns based on hydrological data.
- Projection of storage capacity loss under different climate scenarios up to 2042.
- The modeling process included:
- Topographic surface generation using LiDAR data and bathymetric surveys.
- Hydrodynamic flow simulation incorporating sediment transport parameters.
- Validation through historical bathymetric data, ensuring model accuracy.
- Topographic surveys: Differential GPS and total stations were used to measure terrain variations within the reservoir.
- Sediment granulometry analysis: Samples were collected from multiple points in the reservoir to classify sediment size distribution and origin.
-
Drone-based monitoring:
- ○
- Drones equipped with LiDAR sensors (DJI Matrice 300 RTK with Zenmuse L1 LiDAR) were deployed to capture high-resolution terrain data.
- ○
- Point cloud data processing enabled precise mapping of sediment accumulation zones.
- ○
- Temporal analysis: Repeated flights were conducted to monitor sedimentation changes over time.
- "Reservoir sedimentation management."
- "Emerging technologies in hydrological monitoring."
- "Nature-based solutions for sediment control."
- Overlaying topographic, climatic, and hydrological data for integrated analysis.
- Identifying priority intervention areas for sediment control measures.
- Generating predictive models to optimize reservoir management under various scenarios.
- Satellite Image Resolution: While ALOS PALSAR data is suitable, its resolution may not capture minor erosion changes.
- Field Measurement Constraints: Adverse weather conditions and logistical challenges limited data collection in some key areas.
- Model Generalization: The unique characteristics of the Carrizal River basin may restrict direct application of these strategies to other watersheds without further adaptation.
Conclusion
RESULTS
- Periodic reservoir dredging: Implementing a sediment removal program to preserve operational capacity.
- Sediment control infrastructure: Enhancing sediment traps and constructing retention structures in key tributaries.
- Continuous monitoring and maintenance: Deploying drones and advanced sensors to identify critical areas and adjust interventions in real time.
DISCUSSION
- Porce II Reservoir (Colombia): Reforestation in upper watershed areas and drone monitoring reduced sedimentation by 30% (Martínez et al., 2020).
- Itaipú Reservoir (Brazil): The use of sediment traps and reforestation significantly extended the reservoir’s lifespan (González & Pérez, 2021).
- Tajo River Basin (Spain): A project integrating public policies with green infrastructure achieved a 25% reduction in sediment accumulation through riverbank restoration and land-use control (Mudaly & Chirikure, 2023).
- Papaloapan River Basin (Mexico): Reforestation programs using native species reduced erosion by 35% in five years (Romero et al., 2021).
- Mantaro River Basin (Peru): Drone monitoring optimized interventions, reducing operational costs by 25% (Setiawan et al., 2018).
- Economic limitations: High initial costs for acquiring advanced equipment.
- Lack of trained personnel: Difficulties in operating and analyzing data from these technologies.
- Lack of historical data: The absence of complete flow and sedimentation records limits the accuracy of long-term projections.
- Local specificity: The unique characteristics of the Carrizal River Basin make direct extrapolation of results to other regions challenging without contextual adjustments.
- Resource constraints: Implementation of the proposed strategies will depend heavily on financial resources and political support at the local and national levels.
- Investment in green infrastructure and ecosystem restoration.
- Capacity-building initiatives to implement and maintain emerging technologies.
- Collaboration between academia, governments, and local communities to ensure long-term sustainability.
- Assessing the effectiveness of these strategies in different geographical and socioeconomic contexts across Ibero-America.
- Analyzing the long-term economic impact of these measures, incorporating implementation costs and environmental benefits.
- Developing participatory mechanisms that include local communities in the monitoring and management of water resources.
CONCLUSIONS
- Emerging Technologies: Tools such as drones equipped with LiDAR sensors and AI-based predictive models enable precise monitoring of critical sedimentation areas and the projection of future scenarios. These technologies are key to optimizing decision-making in reservoir management.
- Nature-Based Solutions: Practices such as reforestation with native species and riverbank stabilization are essential for reducing erosion and minimizing sediment transport into the reservoir, complementing technological interventions.
- Implementation of Integrated Strategies: The combination of technological innovation and environmental management not only ensures the long-term operational functionality of La Estancilla Reservoir but also promotes water sustainability and socioeconomic well-being for local communities.
Author Contributions
Acknowledgments
Conflicts of Interest
References
- Álvarez-Álvarez MJ, Regalado-Jalca JJ, Pino Tarragó JC. 2024. Emerging technologies for the management of the azolvamiento at La Estancilla Dam, Manabí, Ecuador. Salud, Ciencia y Tecnología 4:1067. [CrossRef]
- Amadei B. 2018. Engineering for sustainable human development: A guide to successful small-scale community projects. IEEE. [CrossRef]
- Amadei L. 2018. Estrategias de reforestación en cuencas tropicales. Environmental Sustainability Journal 12(3):215–228.
- Cattanéo F, Guillard J, Babut M. 2020. Mitigation of ecological impacts on fish of large reservoir sediment management through controlled flushing. The Science of the Total Environment 712:135569. [CrossRef]
- Davies I, Evans M. 2018. Global collaboration in education: Opportunities and challenges for developing countries. Globalisation, Societies and Education 16(4):393–406. [CrossRef]
- FAO. 2022. Estrategias de infraestructura verde en la gestión de sedimentos. Journal of Environmental Management 14(3):211–225.
- Fujimoto K, Yoshimura S, Takahashi T. 2022. Advanced seismic simulation methods in education: Applications and implications. Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics 51(2):512–529. [CrossRef]
- González A, Pérez R. 2021. Aplicación de tecnologías emergentes en la Represa Porce II. Water Resources Management 35(6):1421–1435. [CrossRef]
- Henseruk P, Junyent M. 2023. Digital equity in rural education: Lessons from global initiatives. Sustainability 13(12):7112. [CrossRef]
- Henseruk P, Junyent M. 2023. Emerging technologies for sustainable water resource management. Sustainability 15(3):321–340. [CrossRef]
- Horton RE. 1945. Erosional development of streams and their drainage basins: Hydrophysical approach to quantitative morphology. Geological Society of America Bulletin 56(3):275–370. [CrossRef]
- Johnson RB, Christensen LB. 2019. Predicting sedimentation trends using machine learning models. Computers and Geosciences 129:1–15. [CrossRef]
- Martínez MA, Rodríguez JL, López PA. 2018. Sedimentation impacts on reservoir capacity in Latin America: A review of management practices. Water Resources Research 54(8):5905–5918. [CrossRef]
- Martínez MA, Rodríguez JL, López PA. 2020. Sedimentation impacts on reservoir capacity in Latin America: A review of management practices. Water Resources Research 54(8):5905–5918. [CrossRef]
- Morris GL. 2020. Reservoir sedimentation: Global impacts and solutions. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms 45(6):789–805.
- Mudaly R, Chirikure S. 2023. Education for sustainable development in the global south. Frontiers in Education 8:1144399. [CrossRef]
- Reisenbüchler M, Bui Q, Roos S. 2021. Reservoir sediment management using artificial neural networks: A case study. Water 13(10):1402. [CrossRef]
- Romero A, Hernández D, Ríos P. 2021. Digital infrastructure gaps in developing countries. Comparative Education 57(1):87–102. [CrossRef]
- Setiawan A, Nugroho A, Wardhana A. 2018. Evaluation of sediment management for two large reservoirs in Lombok island. Journal of Water Resources Management 32(3):789–803. [CrossRef]




Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2025 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).