Submitted:
14 September 2024
Posted:
20 September 2024
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
Keywords:
Preface
Callinectes sapidus
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Examine the overall body form:
- If the specimen has a crab-like form with the fifth pair of thoracic legs not markedly reduced, a reduced abdomen folded under the body lacking uropods, and short antennae set medial to the eyes, proceed to step 2. (Figure 1A,B)
- If not, the specimen is not a “true crab.”
- 2.
-
Assess the carapace shape:
- If the carapace is broader than long with a small or absent rostrum, proceed to step 3. (Figure 1C)
- If not, the specimen is not Callinectes sapidus.
- 3.
-
Evaluate the crab’s habitat and pigmentation:
- If the specimen is free-living, well-pigmented, and has non-reduced eyes, proceed to step 4. (Figure 1D)
- If not, the specimen is not Callinectes sapidus.
- 4.
-
Observe the carapace outline and size:
- If the front margin is curved and bears a series of teeth between the eye and the anterolateral corner on each side, and the carapace is over 5 cm across, proceed to step 5. (Figure 1E)
- If not, the specimen is not Callinectes sapidus.
- 5.
-
Check the orientation of the first antennae:
- If the first antennae are folded transversely or obliquely, proceed to step 6. (Figure 1D)
- If not, the specimen is not Callinectes sapidus.
- 6.
-
Examine the last pair of legs:
- If the last pair of legs are flattened, paddle-like with rounded tips for swimming, proceed to step 7. (Figure 1F)
- If not, the specimen is no Callinectes sapidus.
- 7.
-
Count the anterolateral teeth and assess carapace characteristics:
- If the specimen has nine anterolateral teeth, and extremely broad carapace, and the outermost lateral tooth is especially long and sharp, proceed to step 8. (Figure 1C)
- If not, the specimen is not Callinectes sapidus.
- 8.
-
Look for distinctive coloration:
- If the specimen shows blue coloration, particularly on the chelipeds, it is likely Callinectes sapidus (Atlantic Blue Crab). (Figure 1G)

Carcinus maenas
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Examine the overall body form:
- If the specimen has a crab-like form with the fifth pair of thoracic legs not markedly reduced, a reduced abdomen folded under the body lacking uropods, and short antennae set medial to the eyes, proceed to step 2. (Figure 2A,B)
- If not, the specimen is not a “true crab.”
- 2.
-
Assess the carapace shape:
- If the carapace is broader than long with a small or absent rostrum, proceed to step 3. (Figure 2A)
- If not, the specimen is not Carcinus maenas.
- 3.
-
Evaluate the crab’s habitat and pigmentation:
- If the specimen is free-living, well-pigmented, and has non-reduced eyes, proceed to step 4. (Figure 2C)
- If not, the specimen is not Carcinus maenas.
- 4.
-
Observe the carapace outline and size:
- If the front margin is curved and bears a series of teeth between the eye and the anterolateral corner on each side, and the carapace is over 5 cm across, proceed to step 5. (Figure 2C,D)
- If not, the specimen is not Carcinus maenas.
- 5.
-
Check the orientation of the first antennae:
- If the first antennae are folded transversely or obliquely, proceed to step 6. (Figure 2C)
- If not, the specimen is not Carcinus maenas.
- 6.
-
Examine the last pair of walking legs:
- If the last pair of walking legs are not markedly adapted for swimming, have sharp tips for walking, and are slightly flattened, proceed to step 7. (Figure 2E)
- If not, the specimen is not Carcinus maenas.
- 7.
-
Assess specific carapace features:
- If the front region between the eyes is produced into three low teeth, and there are five very prominent sharp anterolateral teeth, proceed to step 8. (Figure 2C)
- If not, the specimen is not Carcinus maenas.
- 8.
-
Consider overall appearance and size:
- If the specimen is an active, long-legged crab commonly 5 - 7.5 cm across the carapace, with color varying from greenish-black to orange, it is likely Carcinus maenas (European green crab).

Hemigrapsus sanguineus
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Examine the overall body form:
- If the specimen has a crab-like form with the fifth pair of thoracic legs not markedly reduced, a reduced abdomen folded under the body lacking uropods, and short antennae set medial to the eyes, proceed to step 2. (Figure 3A,B)
- If not, the specimen is not a “true crab.”
- 2.
-
Assess the carapace shape:
- If the carapace is broader than long with a small or absent rostrum, proceed to step 3. (Figure 3C)
- If not, the specimen is not Hemigrapsus sanguineus.
- 3.
-
Evaluate the crab’s habitat and pigmentation:
- If the specimen is free-living, well-pigmented, and has non-reduced eyes, proceed to step 4. (Figure 3D)
- If not, the specimen is not Hemigrapsus sanguineus.
- 4.
-
Observe the last pair of walking legs:
- If the last pair of walking legs are not markedly adapted for swimming and have sharp tips for walking, proceed to step 5. (Figure 3E)
- If not, the specimen is not Hemigrapsus sanguineus.
- 5.
-
Count the sharp edges along the carapace:
- If there are three sharp edges along the carapace, proceed to step 6. (Figure 3A)
- If not, the specimen is not Hemigrapsus sanguineus.
- 6.
-
Examine the anterior carapace and antennae:
- If the anterior carapace between the eyes is relatively flat (rather than curved), and the first antennae are obtuse and located between the eyes, proceed to step 7. (Figure 3D)
- If not, the specimen is not Hemigrapsus sanguineus.
- 7.
-
Check for distinctive features:
- If the specimen has three individual sets of teeth on the anterolateral margins, and its overall appearance matches the description (square-shaped carapace, typically not exceeding 4 cm in width, variable coloration often mottled with shades of green, purple, and brown, with distinctive light and dark bands on its legs), it is likely Hemigrapsus sanguineus (Asian Shore Crab).

Libinia dubia
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Observe the overall body structure:
- If the specimen has a typically crablike form with all five pairs of thoracic legs well-developed, a reduced abdomen folded under the body, and short antennae set medial to the eyes, proceed to step 2. (Figure 8A,C)
- If not, the specimen is not Libinia dubia.
- 2.
-
Examine the carapace shape:
- If the carapace is triangular or globose, with the apex projecting forward to form a rostrum, proceed to step 3. (Figure 8D)
- If not, the specimen is not Libinia dubia.
- 3.
-
Check the walking legs:
- If the walking legs are long and conspicuous, proceed to step 4. (Figure 8A,B)
- If not, the specimen is not Libinia dubia.
- 4.
-
Observe the dorsal spines:
- If the carapace has medial dorsal spines, proceed to step 5. (Figure 8D)
- If not, the specimen is not Libinia dubia.
- 5.
-
Count the medial dorsal spines:
- If there are six spines in the median dorsal row with few dorsal tubercles, it is likely Libinia dubia (Longnose Spider Crab). (Figure 8D)

Limulus polyphemus
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Observe the overall body structure:
- If the specimen has a large horseshoe-shaped carapace with bilateral symmetry, proceed to step 2. (Figure 5A,B)
- If not, the specimen is not Limulus polyphemus.
- 2.
-
Examine the ventral side:
- If the specimen shows a bilateral plane of symmetry on the ventral side, proceed to step 3. (Figure 5B)
- If not, the specimen is not Limulus polyphemus.
- 3.
-
Check for moveable spines:
- If the specimen has moveable spines on its abdomen, proceed to step 4. (Figure 5C)
- If not, the specimen is not Limulus polyphemus.
- 4.
-
Identify key features on the dorsal side:
- If the specimen has compound eyes and simple eyes visible on the dorsal side, proceed to step 5. (Figure 5D)
- If not, the specimen is not Limulus polyphemus.
- 5.
-
Examine the legs:
- If the specimen has five pairs of walking legs with sharp tips (not adapted for swimming), proceed to step 6. (Figure 5E)
- If not, the specimen is not Limulus polyphemus.
- 6.
-
Check for chelicerae:
- If chelicerae are present and folded between the walking legs, proceed to step 7. (Figure 5E)
- If not, the specimen is not Limulus polyphemus.
- 7.
-
Assess taxonomic grouping:
- If the specimen belongs to the order Xiphosurida (“horseshoe crabs”), which are ancient (450 mya) chelicerates, it is likely Limulus polyphemus (Atlantic Horseshoe Crab). (Figure 5B)

Ovalipes ocellatus
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Observe the overall body structure:
- If the specimen has a typically crablike form with a carapace broader than long, proceed to step 2. (Figure 6A,C)
- If not, the specimen is not Ovalipes ocellatus.
- 2.
-
Examine the abdomen:
- If the abdomen is reduced and folded under the body, proceed to step 3. (Figure 6B)
- If not, the specimen is not Ovalipes ocellatus.
- 3.
-
Check the eyes and pigmentation:
- If the specimen is well-pigmented with fully developed eyes, proceed to step 4. (Figure 6D)
- If not, the specimen is not Ovalipes ocellatus.
- 4.
-
Examine the carapace margin:
- If the front margin of the carapace is curved and bears a series of teeth between the eye and the anterolateral corner, proceed to step 5. (Figure 6D,E)
- If not, the specimen is not Ovalipes ocellatus.
- 5.
-
Check the antennae:
- If the first antennae are folded transversely or obliquely, proceed to step 6. (Figure 6E)
- If not, the specimen is not Ovalipes ocellatus.
- 6.
-
Examine the last pair of legs:
- If the last pair of legs are flattened and paddle-like with rounded tips, adapted for swimming, proceed to step 7. (Figure 6F)
- If not, the specimen is not Ovalipes ocellatus.
- 7.
-
Assess taxonomic grouping:
-
Count the antero-lateral teeth and observe coloration:If the carapace has five antero-lateral teeth and the crab has a cream to tan coloration with distinctive purple spots on the claws, it is likely Ovalipes ocellatus (Lady Crab). (Figure 6A)
-

Celuca pugilator
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Observe the overall body structure:
- If the specimen has a typically crablike form with reduced abdomen folded under the body, short antennae set medial to the eyes, and the fifth pair of thoracic legs not markedly reduced, proceed to step 2. (Figure 7A)
- If not, the specimen is not Celuca pugilator.
- 2.
-
Examine the carapace:
- If the carapace is squarish with a more or less straight front margin, proceed to step 3. (Figure 7A,B)
- If not, the specimen is not Celuca pugilator.
- 3.
-
Check the eyes and pigmentation:
- If the specimen is well-pigmented with fully developed eyes on long eyestalks, proceed to step 4. (Figure 7C)
- If not, the specimen is not Celuca pugilator.
- 4.
-
Examine the third maxillipeds:
- If the third maxilliped is almost or quite close over the mouth region when held at rest, proceed to step 5. (Figure 7B)
- If not, the specimen is not Celuca pugilator.
- 5.
-
Check for cheliped dimorphism in males:
- If one cheliped of the male is very large (in females, both chelipeds are small), proceed to step 6. (Figure 7B)
- If not, the specimen is not Celuca pugilator.
- 6.
-
Observe the carapace coloration:
- If the carapace is mottled in grays and purple, it is likely Celuca pugilator (Atlantic Sand Fiddler Crab). (Figure 7A,B)

Pagurus longicarpus
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Observe the habitat and body structure:
- If the animal inhabits a gastropod shell and has a soft, twisted abdomen, proceed to step 2. (Figure 7A,B2)
- If not, the specimen is not a hermit crab.
- 2.
-
Examine the thoracic legs:
- If the fifth pair of thoracic legs is very reduced and folded up above the bases of the fourth pair, proceed to step 3. (Figure 7B1,B2)
- If not, the specimen is not Pagurus longicarpus.
- 3.
-
Assess the body form and abdomen:
- If the body form varies from quite crab-like to not very crab-like, and the abdomen is asymmetrical, twisted, or reduced but with uropods, proceed to step 4. (Figure 7B1,B2)
- If not, the specimen is not Pagurus longicarpus.
- 4.
-
Examine the chelipeds:
- If the chelipeds are slender with sub-cylindrical hands, proceed to step 5. (Figure 7C)
- If not, the specimen is not Pagurus longicarpus.
- 5.
-
Check for cheliped banding:
- If the chelae do not have distinct banding, it is likely Pagurus longicarpus (Long-clawed Hermit Crab). (Figure 7C)
- If distinct banding is present, the specimen is not Pagurus longicarpus.

Pagurus pollicaris
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Observe the overall body structure:
- If the specimen has four visible pairs of legs (the fifth pair is reduced and not visible in this specimen), proceed to step 2. (Figure 8A)
- If not, the specimen is not Pagurus pollicaris.
- 2.
-
Examine the claws:
- If one claw (typically the right) is noticeably larger, broad, flat, and tuberculate, proceed to step 3. (Figure 8B)
- If not, the specimen is not Pagurus pollicaris.
- 3.
-
Check for gastropod shell habitation:
- If the animal is inhabiting a gastropod shell, it is likely Pagurus pollicaris (Flat-Clawed Hermit Crab). (Figure 8C)

Munica Pugnax
Identification Key
- 1.
-
Examine the overall body form:
- If the animal has a typically crablike form, with the fifth (last) pair of thoracic legs not markedly reduced, abdomen reduced and folded under body, lacking uropods, and antennae short and set medial to the eyes, proceed to step 2. (Figure 9A)
- If not, the specimen is not a “true crab.”
- 2.
-
Observe the mouth region and front of the carapace:
- If the third maxillipeds almost or quite close over the mouth region when held at rest, the front is moderately or very narrow, eyestalks are long, and one cheliped of male is very large (typical of “fiddler crabs”), proceed to step 3. (Figure 9B)
- If not, the specimen is not Minuca pugnax.
- 3.
-
Check the habitat and pigmentation:
- If the crab is free-living and well pigmented, with eyes not reduced, proceed to step 4. (Figure 9D,E)
- If not, the specimen is not Minuca pugnax.
- 4.
-
Examine the carapace outline:
- If the carapace outline is squarish with a more or less straight front margin, and the crab is active, semi-terrestrial, rarely over 4 cm across carapace, proceed to step 5. (Figure 9D)
- If not, the specimen is not Minuca pugnax.
- 5.
-
Examine the large claw:
- If the inner surface of the large claw has an oblique ridge and all previous features, the species is most likely Minuca pugnax.

Appendix A

Appendix B
| Scientific Name | Common Name | Taxonomy | Collection Date | Location |
| Callinectes sapidus | Blue Crab | Kingdom Animalia, Phylum Arthropoda, Subphylum Crustacea, Class Malacostraca, Order Decapoda, Infraorder Brachyura, Family Portunidae, Genus, Callinectes, Species Sapidus | 08/28/24 | Submerged in the mouth |
| Carcinus maenas | Green Crab | Kingdom Animalia, Phylum Arthropoda, Subphylum Crustacea, Class Malacostraca, Order Decapoda, Infraorder Brachyura, Family Portunidae, Genus Carcinus, and Species Maenas | 08/28/24 | Submerged in the mouth |
| Hemigrapsus sanguineus | Asian Shore Crab | Kingdom Animalia, Phylum Arthropoda, Subphylum Crustacea, Class Malacostraca, Order Decapoda, Infraorder Brachyura, Family Varunidae, Genus Hemigrapsus, and Species Sanguineus | 08/28/24 | Under rocks in the beachline |
| Libinia dubia | Spider Crab | Kingdom Animalia, Phylum Arthropoda, Subphylum Crustacea, Class Malacostraca, Order Decapoda, Infraorder Brachyura, Family Epialtidae, Genus Libinia, And Species Dubia | 08/30/24 | Submerged in the shallow end of the beachline |
| Ovalipes ocellatus | Lady Crab | Kingdom Animalia, Phylum Arthropoda, Subphylum Crustacea, Class Malacostraca, Order Decapoda, Infraorder Brachyura, Family Portunidae, Genus Ovalipes, and Species Ocellatus | 08/30/24 | Shallow of the brackish coastline |
| Celuca pugilator | Sand Fiddler Crab | Kingdom Animalia, Phylum Arthropoda, Subphylum Crustacea, Class Malacostraca, Order Decapoda, Infraorder Brachyura, Family Ocypodidae, Genus Celuca, and Species Pugilator | 08/30/24 | Dune |
| Pagurus longicarpus | Long Claw Hermit Crab | Kingdom Animalia, Phylum Arthropoda, Subphylum Crustacea, Class Malacostraca, Order Decapoda, Infraorder Anomura, Family Paguridae, Genus Pagurus, and Species Longicarpus | 09/03/24 | Submerged in shoreline |
| Pagurus pollicaris | Flat Claw Hermit Crab | Kingdom Animalia, Phylum Arthropoda, Subphylum Crustacea, Class Malacostraca, Order Decapoda, Superfamily Paguroidea, Family Paguridae, Genus Pagurus, and Species Pollicaris | 08/30/24 | Submerged in the beachline |
| Minuca pugnax | Mud Fiddler | Kingdom Animalia, Phylum Arthropoda, Subphylum Crustacea, Class Malacostraca, Order Decapoda, Infraorder Brachyura, Family Ocypodidae, Genus Minuca, and Species Pugnax | 09/03/24 | Wet mud in marsh |
References
- DecaNet eds. 2024. DecaNet. Callinectes sapidus Rathbun, 1896. Last modified January 12, 2024: https://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=107379.
- DecaNet eds. 2024. DecaNet. Carcinus maenas Linnaeus, 1758. Last modified January 11, 2024: https://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=107381.
- “REVISED KEYS TO MARINE INVERTEBRATES of the WOODS HOLE REGION”, 1964.
- “Atlantic Horseshoe Crab (Limulus Polyphemus): U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service.” FWS.gov. Accessed September 10, 2024. https://www.fws.gov/species/atlantic-horseshoe-crab-limulus-polyphemus.
- Giribet, Gonzalo, and Gregory D. Edgecombe. The Invertebrate Tree of Life. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2020.
- “Libinia Dubia.” World Register of Marine Species - Libinia Dubia H. Milne Edwards, 1834. Accessed September 10, 2024. https://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=107335.
- “Long-Clawed Hermit Crab.” Barnegat Bay Partnership, August 30, 2023. https://barnegatbaypartnership.org/species/long-clawed-hermit-crab/.
- Walters, Erin A, Jamie Bojko, Claire E Crowley, Ryan L Gandy, Charles W Martin, e, f, g, Highlights•Twelve symbiont groups identified in Florida C. sapidus include Ciliophorans, and AbstractSubtropical Florida blue crabs.
- “Salinity and Temperature Affect the Symbiont Profile and Host Condition of Florida USA Blue Crabs Callinectes Sapidus.” Journal of Invertebrate Pathology, May 4, 2023. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022201123000472.
- Blue Crab Life Cycle. Accessed September 10, 2024. https://www.bluecrab.info/lifecycle.html.
- Rjiba-Bahri, Wafa, Faten Khamassi, Emna Soufi Kechaou, Amani Chaffai, and Jamila Ben Souissi. “Morphological and Biological Traits, Exoskeleton Biochemistry and Socio-Economic Impacts of the Alien Invasive Crab Libinia Dubia H. Milne Edwards, 1834 from the Tunisian Coast (Central Mediterranean) - Thalassas: An International Journal of Marine Sciences.” SpringerLink, January 30, 2019. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s41208-019-0122-5.
- Lillie, Frank R. “The Woods Hole Marine Biological Laboratory.” The University of Chicago, February 1998.
- Smith, Ralph I. “Keys to Marine Invertebrates of the Woods Hole Region”. Woods Hole, Mass: Systematics-Ecology Program, Marine Biological Laboratory, 1964.
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).