Submitted:
14 February 2026
Posted:
27 February 2026
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
Keywords:
1. Introduction
2. Theoretical Foundations
2.1. Precision Agriculture as a Data-Driven Ecosystem
2.2. Nutraceutical Crops and Phytochemical Optimization
2.3. Spatial Variability Management in Nutraceutical Cropping Systems
3. Technologies and Methodologies in Precision Nutraceutical Farming
3.1. Hyperspectral and Multispectral Imaging
3.2. UAV-Based Thermal Imaging
3.3. IoT Soil–Plant–Atmosphere Sensor Networks
3.4. LiDAR-Based Canopy Characterization
3.5. Machine Learning, Artificial Intelligence, and Decision-Support Systems
3.6. Precision Irrigation Technologies
3.7. Precision Nutrient Management Systems
3.8. Low-Cost Precision Tools for Smallholders
4. Impacts on Yield, Quality, and Sustainability
4.1. Yield Improvements
4.2. Enhancement of Nutraceutical Quality
4.3. Environmental Sustainability and Resource Efficiency
4.4. Economic Competitiveness and Market Value
5. Challenges and Barriers to Precision Nutraceutical Farming
5.1. High Initial Costs and Limited Access to Technology
5.2. Technical Complexity and the Need for Digital Skills
5.3. Data Interoperability and Standardization Constraints
5.4. Infrastructure and Connectivity Limitations
5.5. Policy, Incentive, and Institutional Gaps
5.6. Biological Variability and Crop-Specific Calibration Requirements
5.7. Limited Long-Term and Large-Scale Field Validation
5.8. Socioeconomic Factors and Adoption Behavior
6. Future Perspectives
6.1. Advances in Sensor Technologies and High-Resolution Phenotyping
6.2. Artificial Intelligence, Predictive Analytics, and Digital Twins
6.3. Integration of Controlled-Environment Agriculture and Vertical Systems
6.4. Blockchain and Advanced Traceability Systems
6.5. Low-Cost and Open-Source PA Tools for Smallholders
6.6. Climate Resilience and Adaptation Strategies
6.7. Expansion of Genotype-Specific PA Models for Emerging Crops
7. Conclusions and Outlook
Author Contributions
Funding
Data Availability Statement
Conflicts of Interest
References
- Rai, M., & Ingle, A. Role of nanotechnology in agriculture with special reference to management of insect pests. Applied microbiology and biotechnology 2012, 94(2), 287-293. [CrossRef]
- Zude-Sasse, M., Akbari, E., Tsoulias, N., Psiroukis, V., Fountas, S., & Ehsani, R. Sensing in Precision Horticulture. Sensing approaches for precision agriculture 2021, 221-251.
- Bian, X., Wang, L., Ma, Y., Yu, Y., Guo, C., & Gao, W. A flavonoid concentrate from Moringa oleifera Lam. leaves extends exhaustive swimming time by improving energy metabolism and antioxidant capacity in mice. Journal of Medicinal Food 2024, 27(9), 887-894. [CrossRef]
- Moghimi, A., Yang, C., & Anderson, J. A. Aerial hyperspectral imagery and deep neural networks for high-through put yield phenotyping in wheat. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture 2020, 172, 105299. [CrossRef]
- Greco, C.; Agnello, A.; La Placa, G.; Mammano, M.M.; Navickas, K. Biowaste in a circular bioeconomy in Mediterranean area: A case study of compost and vermicompost as growing substrates alternative to peat. Riv. Studi Sulla Sostenibilità 2019, 2, 345–362. [CrossRef]
- Greco, C.; Comparetti, A.; Fascella, G.; Febo, P.; La Placa, G.; Saiano, F.; Mammano, M.M.; Orlando, S.; Laudicina, V.A. Effects of Vermicompost, Compost and Digestate as Commercial Alternative Peat-Based Substrates on Qualitative Parameters of Salvia officinalis. Agronomy 2021, 11, 98. [CrossRef]
- Greco, C., Gaglio, R., Settanni, L., Alfonzo, A., Orlando, S., Ciulla, S., & Mammano, M. M. Monitoring Moringa oleifera Lam. in the Mediterranean Area Using Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) and Leaf Powder Production for Food Fortification. Agriculture 2025a, 15(13), 1359. [CrossRef]
- Comparetti, A.; Greco, C.; Mammano, M.M.; Navickas, K.; Orlando, S.; Venslauskas, K. Valorisation of urban green areas for producing renewable energy and biochar as growing substrate of Sicilian aromatic and nutraceutical species in a circular economy. Riv. Studi Sulla Sostenibilita 2019, 2 (Suppl. S2), 299–314.
- Comparetti, A.; Greco, C.; Orlando, S.; Ciulla, S.; Mammano, M.M. Comparison of mechanical, assisted and manual harvest of Origanum vulgare L. Sustain. For. 2022, 14, 2562. [CrossRef]
- Greco, C., Catania, P., Orlando, S., Vallone, M., & Mammano, M. M. Assessment of Vegetation Indices as Tool to Decision Support System for Aromatic Crops. Lect. Notes Civ. Eng. 2024, 521 LNCE,322–331. [CrossRef]
- Greco, C., Gaglio, R., Settanni, L., Sciurba, L., Ciulla, S., Orlando, S., & Mammano, M. M. Smart farming technologies for sustainable agriculture: A case study of a Mediterranean aromatic farm. Agriculture 2025b, 15(8), 810. [CrossRef]
- Balafoutis, A.T.; Beck, B.; Fountas, S.; Tsiropoulos, Z.; Vangeyte, J.; van der Wal, T.; Soto-Embodas, I.; Gómez-Barbero, M.; Pedersen, S.M. Smart Farming Technologies—Description, Taxonomy and Economic Impact. Springer: Berlin/Heidelberg, Germany 2017; pp. 21–77. ISBN 978-3-319-68713-1. [CrossRef]
- Mesgaran, M.B.; Madani, K.; Hashemi, H.; Azadi, P. Iran’s land suitability for agriculture. Sci. Rep. 2017, 7, 1–12. [CrossRef]
- Virk, A. L., Noor, M. A., Fiaz, S., Hussain, S., Hussain, H. A., Rehman, M., ... & Ma, W. Smart farming: an overview. Smart village technology: concepts and developments 2020, 191-201.
- Abhinav, S.; Jain, A.; Gupta, P.; Chowdary, V. Machine learning applications for precision agriculture: A comprehensive review. IEEE Access 2021, 9, 4843–4873. [CrossRef]
- Kwaghtyo, D.K.; Eke, C.I. Smart farming prediction models for precision agriculture: A comprehensive survey. Artif. Intell. Rev. 2023, 56, 5729–5772. [CrossRef]
- Petrovìc, B.; Bumbálek, R.; Zoubek, T.; Kuneš, R.; Smutný, L.; Bartoš, P. Application of precision agriculture technologies in Central Europe-review. J. Agric. Food Res. 2024, 15, 101048 . [CrossRef]
- Greco, C.; Campiotti, A.; De Rossi, P.; Febo, P.; Giagnacovo, G. Energy consumption and improvement of energy efficiency for the European agricultural-food system. Riv. Studi Sulla Sostenibilità 2020, 92–103 . [CrossRef]
- Greco, C., Serio, G., Viola, E., Barbera, M., Mammano, M. M., Orlando, S., ... & Gaglio, R. Exploring the Functional Properties of Leaves of Moringa oleifera Lam. Cultivated in Sicily Using Precision Agriculture Technologies for Potential Use as a Food Ingredient. Antioxidants 2025c. [CrossRef]
- Kumar, V., Zadokar, A., Kumar, P., Sharma, R., Sharma, R., Siddiqui, M. W., Irfan, M., & Chandora, R. Advancing medicinal plant agriculture: Integrating technology and precision agriculture for sustainability. 2025, Peer J, 13(4). [CrossRef]
- Aftab, T. A review of medicinal and aromatic plants and their secondary metabolites status under abiotic stress. Journal of Medicinal Plants 2019, 7(3), 99-106.
- Matías, J., Rodríguez, M. J., Carrillo-Vico, A., Casals, J., Fondevilla, S., Haros, C. M., ... & Reguera, M. From ‘farm to fork’: Exploring the potential of nutrient-rich and stress-resilient emergent crops for sustainable and healthy food in the Mediterranean region in the face of climate change challenges. Plants 2024, 13(14), 1914. [CrossRef]
- Vidican, R., Mălinaș, A., Ranta, O., Moldovan, C., Marian, O., Ghețe, A., ... & Cătunescu, G. M. Using remote sensing vegetation indices for the discrimination and monitoring of agricultural crops: A critical review. Agronomy 2023, 13(12), 3040. [CrossRef]
- Sharma, S. Precision agriculture: Reviewing the advancements technologies and applications in precision agriculture for improved crop productivity and resource management. Reviews In Food and Agriculture 2023, 4(2), 45-49. [CrossRef]
- Mahlein, A. K. Plant disease detection by imaging sensors–parallels and specific demands for precision agriculture and plant phenotyping. Plant disease 2016, 100(2), 241-251. [CrossRef]
- Zarco-Tejada, P. J., González-Dugo, V., & Berni, J. A. Fluorescence, temperature and narrow-band indices acquired from a UAV platform for water stress detection using a micro-hyperspectral imager and a thermal camera. Remote sensing of environment 2012, 117, 322-337. [CrossRef]
- Jabed, M. A., & Murad, M. A. A. Crop yield prediction in agriculture: A comprehensive review of machine learning and deep learning approaches, with insights for future research and sustainability. Heliyon 2024, 10(24).
- Greco, C.; Catania, P.; Orlando, S.; Vallone, M.; Mammano, M.M. Assessment of vegetation indices as tool to decision support system for aromatic crops. In International Conference on Safety, Health and Welfare in Agriculture and Agro-food Systems. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland. 2023a, pp. 322-331.
- Pierpaoli, E.; Carli, G.; Pignatti, E.; Canavari, M. Drivers of precision agriculture tech-nologies adoption: a literature review. Procedia Technology 2013, 8(2013) 61-69. [CrossRef]
- Fountas, S.; Malounas, I.; Athanasakos, L.; Avgoustakis, I.; Espejo-Garcia, B. AI-assisted vision for agricultural robots. AgriEngineering 2022, 4(3), 674-694. [CrossRef]
- Louta, M.; Karagiannis, P.; Papanikolopoulou, V.; Vouraki, S.; Tsipis, E.; Priskas, S.; Arsenos, G.F. A Decision Support System for Dairy Sheep and Goat Production. Animals 2023, 13,1495. [CrossRef]
- Akhter, R.; Sofi, S.A. Precision agriculture using IoT data analytics and machine learning. Journal of King Saud University-Computer and Information Sciences 2022, 34(8), 5602-5618. [CrossRef]
- Sharma, S.; Srushtideep, A. Precision agriculture and its future. International Journal of Plant & Soil Science 2022, 34(24), 200-204.
- Mourtzis, D.; Angelopoulos, J.; Panopoulos, N. Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) path planning and control assisted by Augmented Reality (AR): The case of indoor drones. International Journal of Production Research 2024, 62(9), 3361-3382. [CrossRef]
- Colaço, A.F.; Molin, J.P.; Rosell-Polo, J.R.; Escolà, A. Application of light detection and ranging and ultrasonic sensors to high-throughput phenotyping and precision horticulture: current status and challenges. Horticulture research 2018, 5. [CrossRef]
- Sandonís-Pozo, L.; Rufat, J.; Pascual, M.; Villar, J.M.; Arnó, J.; Escolà, A.; Rosell-Polo, J.R.; Martínez-Casasnovas, J.A. LiDAR-derived indices and their relationship with productivi-ty and oil quality attributes in high-density olive orchards. Smart Agricultural Technology 2025, 12(2025) 101213. [CrossRef]
- Ouda, S.; Zohry, A.E.H. Climate-smart agriculture 2022, Springer International Publishing.
- Alexandridis, T.K.; Andrianopoulos, A.; Galanis, G.; Kalopesa, E.; Dimitrakos, A.; Katsogiannos, F.; Zalidis, G. An integrated approach to promote precision farming as a measure toward reduced-input agriculture in Northern Greece using a spatial decision support system. Comprehensive Geographic Information Systems 2017, 1, 315-52.
- Behmann, J.; Mahlein, A.K.; Rumpf, T.; Römer, C.; Plümer, L. A review of advanced machine learning methods for the detection of biotic stress in precision crop protection. Precision agriculture 2015, 16(3), 239-260 . [CrossRef]
- Peña, J.M.; Torres-Sánchez, J.; de Castro, A.I.; Kelly, M.; López-Granados, F. Weed mapping in early-season maize fields using object-based analysis of unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) images. PloS one 2013, 8(10) e77151. [CrossRef]
- Bendig, J.; Bolten, A.; Bennertz, S.; Broscheit, J.; Eichfuss, S.; Bareth, G. Estimating biomass of barley using crop surface models (CSMs) derived from UAV-based RGB imaging. Remote sensing 2014, 6(11), 10395-10412. [CrossRef]
- Pádua, L.; Marques, P.; Hruška, J.; Adão, T.; Peres, E.; Morais, R.; Sousa, J.J. Multi-temporal vineyard monitoring through UAV-based RGB imagery. Remote Sensing 2018, 10(12), 1907. [CrossRef]
- Adão, T.; Hruška, J.; Pádua, L.; Bessa, J.; Peres, E.; Morais, R.; Sousa, J.J. Hyperspectral imaging: A review on UAV-based sensors, data processing and applications for agriculture and forestry. Remote sensing 2017, 9(11), 1110. [CrossRef]
- Hosoi, F.; Omasa, K. Estimating vertical plant area density profile and growth parameters of a wheat canopy at different growth stages using three-dimensional portable lidar imaging. ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 2009, 64(2), 151-158. [CrossRef]
- Torres-Sánchez, J.; López-Granados, F.; Borra-Serrano, I.; Peña, J.M. Assessing UAV-collected image overlap influence on computation time and digital surface model accuracy in olive orchards. Precision Agriculture 2018, 19(1), 115-133. [CrossRef]
- Rosell, J.; Sanz, R. A review of methods and applications of the geometric character-ization of tree crops in agricultural activities. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture 2012, 81,124–141. [CrossRef]
- Moorthy, I.; Miller, J.R.; Berni, J.A.J.; Zarco-Tejada, P.; Hu, B.; Chen, J. (2011) Field characterization of olive (Olea europaea L.) tree crown architecture using terrestrial laser scanning data. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 2011, 151, 204–214. [CrossRef]
- Karim, M.R.; Reza, M.N.; Jin, H.; Haque, M.A.; Lee, K.H.; Sung, J.; Chung, S.O. Application of LiDAR sensors for crop and working environment recognition in agriculture: a review. Remote Sensing 2024, 16, 4623.
- Béland, M.; Widlowski, J.L.; Fournier, R.A. A model for deriving voxel-level tree leaf area density estimates from ground-based LiDAR. Environmental Modelling & Software 2014, 51, 184–189. [CrossRef]
- Hatfield, J.L.; Prueger, J.H. Variable atmospheric, canopy, and soil effects on energy and carbon fluxes over crops. Improving Modeling Tools to Assess Climate Change Effects on Crop Response 2016, 7, 195-216.
- Haboudane, D.; Miller, J.R.; Tremblay, N.; Zarco-Tejada, P.J.; Dextraze, L. Integrated Narrow-Band Vegetation Indices for Prediction of Crop Chlorophyll Content for Application to Precision Agriculture. Remote Sensing of Environment 2002, 81, 416-426. [CrossRef]
- Popescu, S.C.; Zhao, K.; Neuenschwander, A.; Lin, C. Satellite lidar vs. small footprint airborne lidar: Comparing the accuracy of aboveground biomass estimates and forest structure metrics at footprint level. Remote Sensing of Environment 2011, 115(11), 2786-2797. [CrossRef]
- PEñA, A. L. F. R. E. D. O.; Gryning, S. E.; Floors, R. R. Lidar observations of marine boundary-layer winds and heights: a preliminary study. Meteorologische Zeitschrift 2015, 24(6), 581-589. [CrossRef]
- Garofalo, G.; Buzzanca, C.; Ponte, M.; Barbera, M.; D’Amico, A.; Greco, C.; ... & Gaglio, R. Comprehensive analysis of Moringa oleifera leaves’ antioxidant properties in ovine cheese. Food Bioscience 2024, 61, 104974. [CrossRef]
- Greco, C.; Catania, P.; Orlando, S.; Vallone, M.; Mammano, M.M. An Innovative Indoor and Controlled Sustainable Snail Breeding System. In International Conference on Safety, Health and Welfare in Agriculture and Agro-food Systems (pp. 243-253). Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland. 2023b.
- Greco, C.; Gaglio, R.; Settanni, L.; Alfonzo, A.; Orlando, S.; Ciulla, S.; Mammano; M.M. Monitoring Moringa oleifera Lam. in the Mediterranean Area Using Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) and Leaf Powder Production for Food Fortification. Agriculture 2025d, 15(13), 1359. [CrossRef]
- Leone, A.; Spada, A.; Battezzati, A.; Schiraldi, A.; Aristil, J.; Bertoli, S. Cultivation, genetic, ethnopharmacology, phytochemistry and pharmacology of Moringa oleifera leaves: An overview. International journal of molecular sciences 2015, 16(6), 12791-12835. [CrossRef]
- Rockwood, J.L.; Anderson, B.G.; Casamatta, D.A. Potential uses of Moringa oleifera and an examination of antibiotic efficacy conferred by M. oleifera seed and leaf extracts using crude extraction techniques available to underserved indigenous populations. International Journal of Phytotherapy Research 2013, 3(2), 61-71.
- Gupta, R., Mathur, M., Bajaj, V. K., Katariya, P., Yadav, S., Kamal, R., & Gupta, R. S. Evaluation of antidiabetic and antioxidant activity of Moringa oleifera in experimental diabetes. Journal of diabetes 2012, 4(2), 164-171. [CrossRef]
- Gupta, S., Kumar, D., Aziz, A., AbdelRahman, M. A., Fiorentino, C., D’Antonio, P., & Moursy, A. R. Modern optical sensing technologies and their applications in agriculture. African Journal of Agricultural Research 2024, 20(10), 896-909.
- Greco, C., Catania, P., Orlando, S., Calderone, G., & Mammano, M. M. Rosemary Biomass Estimation from UAV Multispectral Camera. Lect. Notes Civ. Eng., 2025e, 586 LNCE, 615–623. [CrossRef]
- Salsi, G., Greco, C., Laudicina, V. A., Lucia, C., Muscarella, S. M., Greco, G., ... & Mammano, M. M. Preliminary results of Moringa oleifera Lam. grown in a semi-arid Mediterranean environment in a climate change scenario. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 2025, 9, 1576147. [CrossRef]
- Gadhwal, M. Precision irrigation management through thermal and multispectral remote sensing: An integration of sensing systems and analytical techniques. Kansas State University, 2023.
- Cánovas-García, F.; Alonso-Sarría, F.; Gomariz-Castillo, F.; Oñate-Valdivieso, F. Modification of the random forest algorithm to avoid statistical dependence problems when classifying remote sensing imagery. Computers & Geosciences 2017, 103, 1-11. [CrossRef]
- Wu, D.; Johansen, K.; Phinn, S.; Robson, A. Suitability of airborne and terrestrial laser scanning for mapping tree crop structural metrics for improved orchard management. Remote Sensing 2020, 12, 1647. [CrossRef]
- Perna, C.; Pagliai, A.; Sarri, D.; Lisci, R.; Vieri, M. Can a Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR) and Multispectral Sensor Discriminate Canopy Structure Changes Due to Prun-ing in Olive Growing? A Field Experimentation. Sensors 2024, 24, 7894. [CrossRef]
- Madec, S.; Baret, F.; De Solan, B.; Thomas, S.; Dutartre, D.; Jezequel, S.; Comar, A. High-throughput phenotyping of plant height: comparing unmanned aerial vehicles and ground LiDAR estimates. Frontiers in plant science 2017, 8, 2002. [CrossRef]
- Tsoulias, N.; Fountas, S.; Zude-Sasse, M. Estimating the canopy volume using a 2D LiDAR in apple trees. In IV International Symposium on Horticulture in Europe-SHE 2021. 2021. 1327, pp. 437-444 . [CrossRef]
- Vigani, M.; Rodríguez-Cerezo, E.; Gómez-Barbero, M. The determinants of wheat yields: The role of sustainable innovation, policies and risks in France and Hungary. JRC Science and Policy Reports 2015, EUR, 27246.
- Zarco-Tejada, P.J.; Diaz-Varela, R.; Angileri, V.; Loudjani, P. Tree height quantification using very high resolution imagery acquired from an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) and automatic 3D photo-reconstruction methods. European journal of agronomy 2014, 55, 89-99. [CrossRef]
- Getahun, S., Kefale, H., & Gelaye, Y. Application of precision agriculture technologies for sustainable crop production and environmental sustainability: A systematic review. The Scientific World Journal 2024(1), 2126734. [CrossRef]
- Tsouros, D. C., Bibi, S., & Sarigiannidis, P. G. A review on UAV-based applications for precision agriculture. Information 2019, 10(11), 349. [CrossRef]
- Adamchuk, V. I., Hummel, J. W., Morgan, M. T., & Upadhyaya, S. K. On-the-go soil sensors for precision agriculture. Computers and electronics in agriculture 2004, 44(1), 71-91. [CrossRef]
- Tabussam, N., Rana, R. M., Shah, M. K. N., Ahmad, M. S., Sajjad, M., & Lu, Y. Nutraceutical profiling of elite onion germplasm and breeding hybrids with improved nutraceutical quality. Plos one 2022, 17(1), e0262705. [CrossRef]
- Isah, T. Stress and defense responses in plant secondary metabolites production. Biological research 2019, 52. [CrossRef]
- Al Murad, M., Razi, K., Jeong, B. R., Samy, P. M. A., & Muneer, S. Light emitting diodes (LEDs) as agricultural lighting: Impact and its potential on improving physiology, flowering, and secondary metabolites of crops. Sustainability 2021, 13(4), 1985. [CrossRef]
- Franco-Navarro, J. D., Padilla, Y. G., Álvarez, S., Calatayud, Á., Colmenero-Flores, J. M., Gómez-Bellot, M. J., ... & Acosta-Motos, J. R.. Advancements in Water-Saving Strategies and Crop Adaptation to Drought: A Comprehensive Review. Physiologia Plantarum 2025, 177(4), e70332. [CrossRef]
- Sharma, P., Jha, A. B., & Dubey, R. S.. Oxidative stress and antioxidative defense system in plants growing under abiotic stresses. In Handbook of Plant and Crop Stress, Fourth Edition 2019, (pp. 93-136). CRC press.
- Garza-Alonso, C. A., González-García, Y., Pérez-Labrada, F., & Juárez-Maldonado, A. Nanotechnology to Improve Plant Secondary Metabolite Production. In Agricultural Sustainability through Nanotechnology (pp. 129-146). CRC Press 2025.
- Wu, W., Wu, H., Liang, R., Huang, S., Meng, L., Zhang, M., ... & Zhu, H. Light regulates the synthesis and accumulation of plant secondary metabolites. Frontiers in Plant Science 2025, 16, 1644472. [CrossRef]
- Tosin, R. Advanced Methodologies for the Diagnosis of Agronomic Processes Based on Systems Biology for Precision Agriculture (Doctoral dissertation, Universidade do Porto (Portugal)), 2024.
- Avola, G., Matese, A., & Riggi, E. An overview of the special issue on “precision agriculture using hyperspectral images”. Remote Sensing 2023, 15(7), 1917. [CrossRef]
- Sarić, R., Nguyen, V. D., Burge, T., Berkowitz, O., Trtílek, M., Whelan, J., ... & Čustović, E. Applications of hyperspectral imaging in plant phenotyping. Trends in plant science 2022, 27(3), 301-315. [CrossRef]
- Xu, R., Li, C., & Bernardes, S. Development and testing of a UAV-based multi-sensor system for plant phenotyping and precision agriculture. Remote Sensing 2021, 13(17), 3517. [CrossRef]
- Kuo, C. G., Schafleitner, R., Schreinemachers, P., & Wopereis, M. Vegetables and climate change: pathways to resilience. 2020 (No. WorldVeg Publication 20-843).
- Martínez-Peña, R., Vélez, S., Vacas, R., Martín, H., & Álvarez, S. Remote sensing for sustainable pistachio cultivation and improved quality traits evaluation through thermal and non-thermal UAV vegetation indices. Applied Sciences 2023, 13(13), 7716. [CrossRef]
- Panwar, E., Singh, D., Sharma, A. K., & Kumar, H. Monitoring wheat crop biochemical responses to random rainfall stress using remote sensing: a multi-data approach. IEEE Access, 2024. [CrossRef]
- Witkowicz, R., Skrzypek, E., Gleń-Karolczyk, K., Krupa, M., Biel, W., Chłopicka, J., & Galanty, A.Effects of application of plant growth promoters, biological control agents and microbial soil additives on photosynthetic efficiency, canopy vegetation indices and yield of common buckwheat (Fagopyrum esculentum Moench). Biological Agriculture & Horticulture 2021, 37(4), 234-251. [CrossRef]
- Žalohar, J. Remote Sensing in Conservation and Farming. 2025.
- Psiroukis, V., Papadopoulos, G., Darra, N., Koutsiaras, M. G., Lomis, A., Kasimati, A., & Fountas, S. Unmanned aerial vehicles applications in vegetables and arable crops. In Unmanned Aerial Systems in Agriculture. 2023. Academic Press. (pp. 71-91).
- Dlamini, C. M., Odindi, J. O., Mutanga, O., & Matongera, T. N. The Use of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV) Remotely Sensed Data and Machine Learning Techniques to Predict Maize Yield. 2024.
- Gerhards, M., Schlerf, M., Rascher, U., Udelhoven, T., Juszczak, R., Alberti, G., ... & Inoue, Y. Analysis of airborne optical and thermal imagery for detection of water stress symptoms. Remote Sensing 2018, 10(7), 1139. [CrossRef]
- Gerhards, M., Schlerf, M., Mallick, K., & Udelhoven, T. Challenges and future perspectives of multi-/Hyperspectral thermal infrared remote sensing for crop water-stress detection: A review. Remote Sensing 2019, 11(10), 1240. [CrossRef]
- Aslan, M. F., Durdu, A., Sabanci, K., Ropelewska, E., & Gültekin, S. S. A Comprehensive Survey of the Recent Studies with UAV for Precision Agriculture in Open Fields and Greenhouses. Applied Sciences (Switzerland) 2022, 12(3). [CrossRef]
- Postolache, S., Sebastião, P., Viegas, V., Postolache, O., & Cercas, F. IoT-based systems for soil nutrients assessment in horticulture. Sensors 2022, 23(1), 403. [CrossRef]
- Alhasnawi, B. N., Jasim, B. H., & Issa, B. A. Internet of things (IoT) for smart precision agriculture. Iraqi Journal for Electrical and Electronic Engineering 2020, 16(1), 28-38. [CrossRef]
- García, L., Parra, L., Jimenez, J. M., Lloret, J., & Lorenz, P. IoT-based smart irrigation systems: An overview on the recent trends on sensors and IoT systems for irrigation in precision agriculture. Sensors 2020, 20(4), 1042. [CrossRef]
- Abuzanouneh, K. I. M., Al-Wesabi, F. N., Albraikan, A. A., Al Duhayyim, M., Al-Shabi, M., Hilal, A. M., ... & Muthulakshmi, K. Design of machine learning based smart irrigation system for precision agriculture. Computers, Materials & Continua 2022, 72(1). [CrossRef]
- Yu, S., Fan, J., Lu, X., Wen, W., Shao, S., Liang, D., ... & Zhao, C. Deep learning models based on hyperspectral data and time-series phenotypes for predicting quality attributes in lettuces under water stress. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture 2023, 211, 108034. [CrossRef]
- Farmonov, N., Amankulova, K., Szatmári, J., Sharifi, A., Abbasi-Moghadam, D., Nejad, S. M. M., & Mucsi, L. Crop type classification by DESIS hyperspectral imagery and machine learning algorithms. IEEE Journal of selected topics in applied earth observations and remote sensing 2023, 16, 1576-1588. [CrossRef]
- Wang, C., Liu, B., Liu, L., Zhu, Y., Hou, J., Liu, P., & Li, X. A review of deep learning used in the hyperspectral image analysis for agriculture. Artificial Intelligence Review 2021, 54(7), 5205-5253. [CrossRef]
- Tayade, R., Yoon, J., Lay, L., Khan, A. L., Yoon, Y., & Kim, Y. Utilization of spectral indices for high-throughput phenotyping. Plants 2022, 11(13), 1712. [CrossRef]
- Bhargava, A., Sachdeva, A., Sharma, K., Alsharif, M. H., Uthansakul, P., & Uthansakul, M. Hyperspectral imaging and its applications: A review. Heliyon 2024, 10(12).
- Raghav, M., Dubey, A., & Singh, J. Hyperspectral Imaging for Detection and Classification of Plant Primary and Secondary Metabolites: A Review. Phytochemical Analysis 2025. [CrossRef]
- Mahajan, G. R., Das, B., Murgaokar, D., Herrmann, I., Berger, K., Sahoo, R. N., ... & Kulkarni, R. M. Monitoring the foliar nutrients status of mango using spectroscopy-based spectral indices and PLSR-combined machine learning models. Remote Sensing 2021, 13(4), 641. [CrossRef]
- Hafsah, S., Ahmad, F., Arianti, N. D., Saputra, E., & Hartuti, S. Rapid and non-destructive determination of vitamin C and antioxidant activity of intact red chilies using visible near-infrared spectroscopy and machine learning tools. Case Studies in Chemical and Environmental Engineering 2023, 8, 100435. [CrossRef]
- Eshkabilov, S., & Simko, I. Assessing Contents of Sugars, Vitamins, and Nutrients in Baby Leaf Lettuce from Hyperspectral Data with Machine Learning Models. Agriculture 2024, 14(6), 834. [CrossRef]
- Wang, Y., An, J., Shao, M., Wu, J., Zhou, D., Yao, X., ... & Zhu, Y. A comprehensive review of proximal spectral sensing devices and diagnostic equipment for field crop growth monitoring. Precision Agriculture 2025, 26(3), 54. [CrossRef]
- Surendran, U., Nagakumar, K. C. V., & Samuel, M. P. Remote sensing in precision agriculture. In Digital agriculture: A solution for sustainable food and nutritional security. Cham: Springer International Publishing 2025, (pp. 201-223).
- ARAYA, N., GOKOOL, S., AMOO, S., SITHOLE, N., MULOVHEDZI, N., & NDAYAKUNZE, A. DETERMINING THE WATER USE, WATER AND NUTRITIONAL WATER PRODUCTIVITY OF MORINGA UNDER VARYING CROP MANAGEMENT PRACTICES. 2024.
- Santesteban, L. G., Di Gennaro, S. F., Herrero-Langreo, A., Miranda, C., Royo, J. B., & Matese, A. High-resolution UAV-based thermal imaging to estimate the instantaneous and seasonal variability of plant water status within a vineyard. Agricultural Water Management 2017, 183, 49-59. [CrossRef]
- Pineda, M., Barón, M., & Pérez-Bueno, M. L. Thermal imaging for plant stress detection and phenotyping. Remote Sensing 2020, 13(1), 68. [CrossRef]
- Gerhards, R., Kollenda, B., Machleb, J. et al. Camera-guided Weed Hoeing in Winter Cereals with Narrow Row Distance. Gesunde Pflanzen 2020, 72, 403–411. [CrossRef]
- Wen, T., Li, J. H., Wang, Q., Gao, Y. Y., Hao, G. F., & Song, B. A. Thermal imaging: The digital eye facilitates high-throughput phenotyping traits of plant growth and stress responses. Science of The Total Environment 2023, 899, 165626. [CrossRef]
- Messina, G., & Modica, G. Applications of UAV thermal imagery in precision agriculture: State of the art and future research outlook. Remote Sensing 2020, 12(9), 1491. [CrossRef]
- Ullah, U., Usama, M., Muhammad, Z., & Akbar, A. AI-enabled low-powered wireless area networks for quality air. In Low-Power Wide Area Network for Large Scale Internet of Things. CRC Press, 2024. (pp. 100-141).
- Bhargava, K., Ivanov, S., McSweeney, D., & Donnelly, W. Leveraging fog analytics for context-aware sensing in cooperative wireless sensor networks. ACM Transactions on Sensor Networks 2019, (TOSN), 15(2), 1-35. [CrossRef]
- Kannan, J., Palani, T., Selvakumar, D., Dhashnamurthi, V., Shanmugam, V., Duraisamy, K., & Mannu, J.. Computational Approaches in Multi-Omics for Crop Improvement. Current Bioinformatics, 2025. [CrossRef]
- Liang, L., Shi, H., Wang, Z., Wang, S., Li, C., & Diao, M. Research on time series prediction model for multi-factor environmental parameters in facilities based on LSTM-AT-DP model. Frontiers in Plant Science, 2025, 16, 1652478. [CrossRef]
- Gómez-García, R., Campos, D. A., Aguilar, C. N., Madureira, A. R., & Pintado, M. Valorisation of food agro-industrial by-products: From the past to the present and perspectives. Journal of Environmental Management 2021, 299, 113571. [CrossRef]
- Ahmad, Q. U. A., Biemans, H., Moors, E., Shaheen, N., & Masih, I. The impacts of climate variability on crop yields and irrigation water demand in South Asia. Water 2021, 13(1), 50. [CrossRef]
- Cotera, R. V., Guillaumot, L., Sahu, R. K., Nam, C., Lierhammer, L., & Costa, M. M. An assessment of water management measures for climate change adaptation of agriculture in Seewinkel. Science of the Total Environment 2023, 885, 163906. [CrossRef]
- Gago, J., Douthe, C., Coopman, R. E., Gallego, P. P., Ribas-Carbo, M., Flexas, J., ... & Medrano, H. UAVs challenge to assess water stress for sustainable agriculture. Agricultural water management 2015, 153, 9-19. [CrossRef]
- Gitelson, A. A., & Merzlyak, M. N. Non-destructive assessment of chlorophyll carotenoid and anthocyanin content in higher plant leaves: principles and algorithms. 2004.
- Saranwong, S., Sornsrivichai, J., & Kawano, S. Prediction of ripe-stage eating quality of mango fruit from its harvest quality measured nondestructively by near infrared spectroscopy. Postharvest biology and technology 2004, 31(2), 137-145. [CrossRef]
- Zhang, C., & Kovacs, J. M. The application of small unmanned aerial systems for precision agriculture: a review. Precision agriculture 2012, 13(6), 693-712. [CrossRef]
- Bousquet, E., Mialon, A., Rodriguez-Fernandez, N., Prigent, C., Wagner, F. H., & Kerr, Y. H. Influence of surface water variations on VOD and biomass estimates from passive microwave sensors. Remote Sensing of Environment 2021, 257, 112345. [CrossRef]
- Mansoor, S., Iqbal, S., Popescu, S. M., Kim, S. L., Chung, Y. S., & Baek, J. H. Integration of smart sensors and IOT in precision agriculture: trends, challenges and future prospectives. Frontiers in Plant Science 2025, 16, 1587869. [CrossRef]
- Aman, M., Khan, Z. U., Khan, J., Mashori, A. S., Ali, A., Jabeen, N., ... & Li, F.. A Comprehensive Review on Crop Stress Detection: Destructive, Non-Destructive, and ML-Based Approaches. Frontiers in Plant Science 2025, 16, 1638675. [CrossRef]
- Sharma, H., Sidhu, H., & Bhowmik, A. Remote Sensing Using Unmanned Aerial Vehicles for Water Stress Detection: A Review Focusing on Specialty Crops. Drones 2025, 9(4), 241. [CrossRef]
- Vera-Esmeraldas, A., Pizarro-Oteíza, S., Labbé, M., Rojo, F., & Salazar, F. UAV-Based Spectral and Thermal Indices in Precision Viticulture: A Review of NDVI, NDRE, SAVI, GNDVI, and CWSI. Agronomy 2025, 15(11), 2569. [CrossRef]
- Han, S., Liu, J., Zhou, G., Jin, Y., Zhang, M., & Xu, S. InceptionV3-LSTM: A deep learning net for the intelligent prediction of rapeseed harvest time. Agronomy 2022, 12(12), 3046. [CrossRef]
- Peng, W., & Karimi Sadaghiani, O. A review on the application of machine learning in production of woody biomass from natural and planted forests. Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy 2023, 15(3). [CrossRef]
- [134] Hernández Hernández, G. C., Gómez Gómez, J., & Jiménez-Cabas, J. Predictive Models Based on Artificial Intelligence to Estimate Crop Yield: A Literature Review. Agriculture 2025, 15(23), 2438. [CrossRef]
- Bounoua, I., Saidi, Y., Yaagoubi, R., & Bouziani, M. (2024). Deep learning approaches for water stress forecasting in arboriculture using time series of remote sensing images: Comparative study between convlstm and cnn-lstm models. Technologies 2024, 12(6), 77. [CrossRef]
- Marques, P., Pádua, L., Sousa, J. J., & Fernandes-Silva, A. Advancements in remote sensing imagery applications for precision management in olive growing: A systematic review. Remote Sensing 2024, 16(8), 1324. [CrossRef]
- Joana Gil-Chávez, G., Villa, J. A., Fernando Ayala-Zavala, J., Basilio Heredia, J., Sepulveda, D., Yahia, E. M., & González-Aguilar, G. A. Technologies for extraction and production of bioactive compounds to be used as nutraceuticals and food ingredients: An overview. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety 2013, 12(1), 5-23. [CrossRef]
- Mishra, H. Nanobiostimulants and Precision Agriculture: A Data-Driven Approach to Farming and Market Dynamics. In Nanobiostimulants: Emerging Strategies for Agricultural Sustainability. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland 2024. (pp. 365-398).
- Riar, C. S., & Panesar, P. S. (Eds.). Bioactive Compounds and Nutraceuticals from Plant Sources: Extraction Technology, Analytical Techniques, and Potential Health Prospects. CRC Press, 2024.
- Pant, P., Pandey, S., & Dall’Acqua, S. The influence of environmental conditions on secondary metabolites in medicinal plants: A literature review. Chemistry & Biodiversity 2021, 18(11), e2100345. [CrossRef]
- Prinsloo, G., & Nogemane, N. The effects of season and water availability on chemical composition, secondary metabolites and biological activity in plants. Phytochemistry Reviews 2018, 17(4), 889-902 . [CrossRef]
- Qaderi, M. M., Martel, A. B., & Strugnell, C. A. Environmental factors regulate plant secondary metabolites. Plants 2023, 12(3), 447. [CrossRef]
- Chai, Q., Gan, Y., Zhao, C., Xu, H. L., Waskom, R. M., Niu, Y., & Siddique, K. H. Regulated deficit irrigation for crop production under drought stress. A review. Agronomy for sustainable development 2016, 36(1), 3. [CrossRef]
- Yang, B., Fu, P., Lu, J., Ma, F., Sun, X., & Fang, Y. Regulated deficit irrigation: an effective way to solve the shortage of agricultural water for horticulture. Stress Biology 2022, 2(1), 28. [CrossRef]
- Chen, Y., Leng, Y. N., Zhu, F. Y., Li, S. E., Song, T., & Zhang, J. Water-saving techniques: physiological responses and regulatory mechanisms of crops. Advanced Biotechnology 2023, 1(4), 3. [CrossRef]
- Zude, M. PRODUCT MONITORING AND PROCESS CONTROL IN THE HORTICULTURAL SUPPLY CHAIN. Progress in Food Engineering Research and Development 2008, 1.
- Zhang, Q., Liu, M., & Ruan, J. Metabolomics analysis reveals the metabolic and functional roles of flavonoids in light-sensitive tea leaves. BMC plant biology 2017, 17(1), 64. [CrossRef]
- Gorai, T., Yadav, P. K., Choudhary, G. L., & Kumar, A. Site-specific crop nutrient management for precision agriculture—A review. Curr. J. Appl. Sci. Technol 2021, 40, 37-52. [CrossRef]
- Velusamy, P., Rajendran, S., Mahendran, R. K., Naseer, S., Shafiq, M., & Choi, J. G. Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV) in precision agriculture: Applications and challenges. Energies 2021, 15(1), 217. [CrossRef]
- Mostafa, H., Saha, K. K., Tsoulias, N., & Zude-Sasse, M. Using LiDAR technique and modified community land model for calculating water interception of cherry tree canopy. Agricultural Water Management 2022, 272, 107816. [CrossRef]
- Dabek, A., Mantovani, L., Mirabella, S., Vignati, M., & Cinquemani, S. Advancements in Non-Destructive Detection of Biochemical Traits in Plants Through Spectral Imaging-Based Algorithms: A Systematic Review. Algorithms 2025, 18(5), 255. [CrossRef]
- Szechyńska-Hebda, M., Hołownicki, R., Doruchowski, G., Sas, K., Puławska, J., Jarecka-Boncela, A., ... & Włodarek, A. Application of Hyperspectral Imaging for Early Detection of Pathogen-Induced Stress in Cabbage as Case Study. Agronomy 2025, 15(7), 1516. [CrossRef]
- Smith, R. J., Baillie, J. N., McCarthy, A. C., Raine, S. R., & Baillie, C. P. Review of precision irrigation technologies and their application. National Centre for Engineering in Agriculture Publication 2010, 1003017(1).
- Bwambale, E., Abagale, F. K., & Anornu, G. K. Smart irrigation monitoring and control strategies for improving water use efficiency in precision agriculture: A review. Agricultural Water Management 2022, 260, 107324. [CrossRef]
- Lakhiar, I. A., Yan, H., Zhang, C., Wang, G., He, B., Hao, B., ... & Rakibuzzaman, M. A review of precision irrigation water-saving technology under changing climate for enhancing water use efficiency, crop yield, and environmental footprints. Agriculture 2024, 14(7), 1141. [CrossRef]
- Xing, Y., & Wang, X. Precision agriculture and water conservation strategies for sustainable crop production in arid regions. Plants 2024, 13(22), 3184. [CrossRef]
- Ali, A., Hussain, T., & Zahid, A. Smart irrigation technologies and prospects for enhancing water use efficiency for sustainable agriculture. AgriEngineering 2025, 7(4), 106. [CrossRef]
- Betteridge, K., Schnug, E., & Haneklaus, S. Will site specific nutrient management live up to expectation. Agriculture and Forestry Research 2008, 4(58), 283-294.
- Singh, A. K. Precision agriculture in india–opportunities and challenges. Indian Journal of Fertilisers 2022, 18(4), 308-331.
- Meena, D. K., Brahma, D., Dawar, R., Patidarand, A., & Singh, T. Site-specific nutrient management for enhancing nutrient use efficiency. Site-specific nutrient management for enhancing nutrient use efficiency, 2023. 1-4.
- Nakachew, K., Yigermal, H., Assefa, F., Gelaye, Y., & Ali, S. Review on enhancing the efficiency of fertilizer utilization: Strategies for optimal nutrient management. Open Agriculture 2024, 9(1), 20220356. [CrossRef]
- Ferguson, R. B., Gebbers, R., Yang, C., Zhang, C., Kovacs, J. M., Walters, D., ... & Chen, G. Precision agriculture for sustainability 2018, (Vol. 52). Burleigh Dodds Science Publishing.
- Ferguson, R. B., Pane, C., Sudduth, K. A., Franzen, D. W., & Denton, A. M. Instant Insights: Proximal sensors in agriculture. Burleigh Dodds Science 2023, Publishing. (Vol. 63).
- Taylor, B., Casey, J., Luke, B., Beale, T., Beeken, J., Edgington, S., ... & Godwin, J. EO4AgroClimate: improving modelling of pests and biological control agents to adapt to changing climates. agriRxiv 2023, 20230121664.
- Ayerdi Gotor, A., Marraccini, E., Leclercq, C., & Scheurer, O. Precision farming uses typology in arable crop-oriented farms in northern France. Precision Agriculture 2020, 21(1), 131-146. [CrossRef]
- Chen, X. The role of modern agricultural technologies in improving agricultural productivity and land use efficiency. Frontiers in Plant Science 2025, 16, 1675657. [CrossRef]
- Khaspuria, G., Khandelwal, A., Agarwal, M., Bafna, M., Yadav, R., & Yadav, A. Adoption of precision agriculture technologies among farmers: A comprehensive review. Journal of Scientific Research and Reports 2024, 30(7), 671-686 . [CrossRef]





| Technology | Main measured variables | Key agronomic information | Strengths | Limitations | Main applications in Moringa oleifera |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Multispectral imaging (UAV) | Spectral reflectance (VIS–NIR), vegetation indices (NDVI, NDRE, GNDVI, VARI) | Canopy vigor, chlorophyll content, photosynthetic activity, spatial variability | High spatial coverage; operational scalability; cost-effective; strong link with physiological status | Indirect estimation of biomass; limited sensitivity to canopy internal structure | Monitoring canopy vigor and uniformity; detection of nutrient and water stress; harvest timing optimization; mapping phytochemical maturity |
| Thermal imaging (UAV) | Canopy temperature, thermal indices (e.g., CWSI) | Plant water status, transpiration efficiency, heat stress | Early detection of water stress; strong support for irrigation scheduling; rapid response to stress | Sensitive to atmospheric conditions; lower structural detail; requires calibration | Precision irrigation management; water-use efficiency improvement; stress prevention under semi-arid Mediterranean conditions |
| LiDAR (UAV / terrestrial) | 3D point clouds, canopy height, volume, density, porosity, vertical foliage distribution | Structural architecture, biomass estimation, pruning response, spatial heterogeneity | Direct measurement of canopy structure; high accuracy; non-destructive; robust biomass estimation | Higher costs; data processing complexity; limited spectral information | Canopy architecture analysis; biomass and volume estimation; assessment of pruning strategies; integration with multispectral/thermal data for DSS |
| PA Technology | Key Variables Monitored | Yield-Related Outcomes | Nutraceutical Quality Outcomes | Environmental & Sustainability Impacts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| UAV Multispectral Imaging (NDVI, NDRE, GNDVI, VARI) | Canopy vigor, chlorophyll content, nutrient status, spatial heterogeneity | +12–18% leaf biomass increase; improved canopy uniformity; optimized harvest timing | Stabilization and enhancement of vitamin C, carotenoids, chlorophyll density, antioxidant capacity | Reduced fertilizer overuse; site-specific interventions; lower input waste |
| UAV Thermal Imaging (CWSI) | Canopy temperature, plant water stress | Yield stabilization under water-limited conditions; reduced stress-induced biomass losses | Increased phenolic content and antioxidant activity via controlled water stress | 25–40% water savings; improved irrigation efficiency; climate adaptation |
| LiDAR-Based 3D Canopy Characterization (UAV & Terrestrial) | Canopy height, volume, density, porosity, structural heterogeneity | Improved biomass estimation accuracy; optimized pruning and canopy management | Indirect enhancement of phytochemical uniformity through optimized light interception and microclimate | Reduced unnecessary pruning; improved resource-use efficiency; structural resilience |
| IoT Soil–Plant–Atmosphere Sensor Networks | Soil moisture, NPK, EC, pH, microclimate, plant physiological signals | Stable growth trajectories; reduced yield variability across management zones | Enhanced vitamin C, carotenoids, antioxidant capacity via continuous physiological regulation | Water and nutrient savings; reduced leaching; lower environmental footprint |
| Machine Learning & AI-Based DSS (CNN, RF, LSTM) | Multisource data integration; growth and stress prediction | Accurate biomass forecasting; optimized harvest timing | Prediction of phytochemical accumulation peaks; quality standardization | Reduced trial-and-error inputs; data-driven efficiency gains |
| Precision Irrigation (RDI + Smart Drip Systems) | Soil moisture thresholds; plant water demand | Yield maintenance under deficit irrigation; improved water productivity | Increased phenolics, flavonoids, antioxidant compounds | Water conservation; improved drought resilience |
| Precision Nutrient Management (VRA, Spectral Diagnostics) | Nitrogen, potassium, micronutrient status | Improved leaf biomass production; nutrient-use efficiency | Enhanced carotenoid synthesis, vitamin C stability, antioxidant capacity | Reduced fertilizer losses; lower GHG emissions |
| Low-Cost PA Tools (Smartphone imaging, Open-source IoT) | Visual stress indicators; basic spectral/physiological signals | Yield protection in smallholder systems | Acceptable nutraceutical quality consistency at low cost | Democratization of PA; economic and environmental sustainability |
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).