An Integrated Structural–Typological–Value Sensitivity Model (STVSM) for Vulnerability Assessment and Conservation Prioritization of Historic Buildings

This study presents the Structural–Typological–Value Sensitivity Model (STVSM), a multidimensional framework for evaluating vulnerability in historic buildings where physical fragility cannot be adequately captured through structural indicators alone. While existing approaches primarily prioritize load-bearing behaviour, they often overlook typological discontinuity, spatial fragmentation, and the erosion of architectural and cultural value. STVSM addresses this limitation through three weighted sub-indices: structural vulnerability (SV), typological degradation (TV), and heritage value (HV), each calibrated using expert-derived micro- and macro-level weighting coefficients. Field-based deterioration scores (0–1) are combined with these weights to generate SV, TV, and HV values, which are then integrated into a Conservation Priority Index (CPI). Although conceptually informed by building-scale seismic vulnerability literature, the model does not aim to simulate earthquake performance or replace numerical structural analysis. Instead, it operates as a comparative decision-support framework that incorporates seismic-informed deterioration patterns within a broader, conservation-oriented logic. The model is applied to twenty-five historic buildings across three heritage contexts: traditional houses in Cumalikizik, vernacular dwellings in Balıkesir–Karesi, and nineteenth-century Greek Orthodox churches in Bursa. The results demonstrate that integrating structural condition, typological integrity, and heritage value provides a transparent, repeatable, and scalable basis for conservation prioritization across diverse historic building stocks.