Introduction
Natural radioactivity is an intrinsic and unavoidable component of the Earth's environment, resulting from the spontaneous decay of unstable atomic nuclei found in naturally occurring elements [
1]. This fundamental physical process involves the emission of ionizing radiation in the form of particles and electromagnetic waves. Consequently, low levels of natural radioactivity are constantly present in the Earth's crust, the atmosphere, and within all living organisms, contributing to the continuous background radiation exposure experienced by human populations [
1].
The sources of this natural background radiation are diverse and include terrestrial radiation, cosmic radiation, and radon gas. Terrestrial radiation originates from primordial radionuclides such as isotopes of uranium, thorium, and potassium, and their decay series, which are naturally distributed in rocks and soil [
2]. The geological composition of a region significantly influences the levels of terrestrial radiation. Cosmic radiation, consisting of high-energy particles from outer space, interacts with the atmosphere to produce secondary radiation that reaches the surface; its intensity varies with altitude and latitude [
2]. Radon, a radioactive gas produced by the decay of uranium and radium in the ground, can accumulate indoors and is a major contributor to inhaled radiation dose [3, 4].
Considering the specific context of Arizona, the state's geological makeup includes naturally occurring deposits of radioactive elements like uranium and thorium, which contribute to the regional terrestrial background radiation [
5]. While elevated levels have been noted in localized areas, particularly associated with historical mining activities, the presence of these elements means that trace amounts are naturally present throughout the state's geology, contributing to the basal background radiation in areas like Mesa [5, 6]. Cosmic radiation also contributes to the background levels in Arizona, with the intensity being lower in areas of lower elevation like Mesa compared to higher regions such as Flagstaff, due to greater atmospheric shielding [2, 7].
Radon gas is a recognized natural radiation source in Arizona [
8]. The Arizona Geological Survey has identified areas with higher potential for elevated indoor radon, although Mesa is not specifically highlighted as a high-radon "hot spot" [
8]. Maricopa County, where Mesa is located, is designated by the EPA as Zone 2, indicating a moderate potential for indoor radon levels [9, 10]. Furthermore, analyses of Mesa's drinking water have detected the presence of naturally occurring radioactive elements, including uranium and radon, although these typically represent a minor contribution to overall exposure compared to radon from soil gas [11, 12].
To quantify and assess these levels of natural radioactivity, various measurement units are employed. While units like Becquerel and Curie describe the rate of radioactive decay, and Sievert and Roentgen relate to dose and exposure, practical monitoring often uses Counts Per Minute (CPM) and Counts Per Second (CPS) [13, 14]. These units indicate the number of radiation detection events registered by an instrument per unit of time and are dependent on the instrument's characteristics and efficiency [13, 15]. For the purpose of this study, which involves monitoring potential subtle variations in detected radiation events, reporting measurements in Counts Per Second (CPS) is a relevant and practical approach.
Understanding the typical baseline levels and inherent variability of natural radioactivity in Mesa, Arizona, is essential for investigating whether external factors, such as focused human activity, might have a measurable influence on these natural processes. Based on analysis of EPA's RadNet data from a nearby Phoenix monitoring station, the Gamma Gross Count Rate ranged from approximately 1500 to 1700 CPM on December 2, 2024, converting to an estimated range of 25 to 28.3 CPS for the gamma radiation component of natural background radiation in the air for the broader metropolitan area, likely representative of Mesa as well
The notion that human consciousness might subtly influence physical systems, often termed mind-matter interaction or psychokinesis, has been a subject of scientific investigation for many decades. Early explorations, though limited by methodology, hinted at potential biases in the outcomes of macroscopic random events like dice throws [
16]. The development of electronic random number generators (RNGs) provided a more controlled and precise tool to study subtle potential influences of consciousness on inherently random physical processes [
16].
Research in this area, including prominent efforts like the Princeton Engineering Anomalies Research (PEAR) project and the Global Consciousness Project (GCP), has explored whether individual or collective intention correlates with deviations from randomness in RNG output [
16]. While much of this research has focused on shifts in the mean output of RNGs, some findings suggest that consciousness might also influence the statistical variance or variability of random processes. This implies that focused mental states could potentially lead to a wider spread of outcomes in a random system, rather than just a shift towards a higher or lower average.
Evidence suggesting this influence on variance comes from several studies. The Global Consciousness Project, for instance, observed notable patterns in the variance of its global network of RNGs during significant global events, such as the September 11
th terrorist attacks. Analysis of the data around this period indicated a deviation in the variance of the RNG output, with a period of increased variability followed by a decrease, suggesting that moments of intense, widespread human emotion might correlate with fluctuations in the randomness of these physical systems [
17].
Further supporting this idea, research by Nelson
et al. indicated that group meditations might be associated with changes not only in the mean but also in the variance of true RNG outputs [
18]. This work suggests that coherent collective mental states cultivated during meditation could potentially lead to a wider range of random outcomes generated by these devices. A study specifically predicting the effects of a global meditation hypothesized that the output variance of various random event generators would increase during the meditation period, and the results were reported to support this hypothesis, indicating a correlation between the meditation and a change in RNG performance potentially related to increased variability [
19].
While these examples often involve group settings or reactions to major global events, the underlying principle that focused or coherent consciousness can affect the statistical properties of random systems, including their variability, could potentially be relevant to the study of highly experienced individuals engaged in specific mental disciplines. The ability of a skilled meditator or practitioner of focused intention to achieve deep and sustained states of mental focus might, hypothetically, lead to observable increases in the range of outcomes generated by an RNG. This potential influence on the variance of random processes, in addition to any potential effect on the mean, adds another dimension to the investigation of consciousness-matter interactions.
Building upon the background of natural radioactivity and the intriguing, albeit debated, research into the potential influence of consciousness on random physical systems, this paper presents an observational study conducted in Mesa, Arizona. This study investigates whether the practice of chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo by a single, long-time practitioner of Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism correlates with variations in detected natural radioactivity levels.
This research diverges from the previously discussed studies in several key aspects. Unlike large-scale collaborations such as the Global Consciousness Project or extensive laboratory programs like PEAR, this study focuses on a single subject, allowing for an in-depth examination of potential effects associated with an individual's specific spiritual practice. Furthermore, the subject is a practitioner of Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism, and the study examines the effects related to chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo, a practice distinct from the meditation techniques or purported psychic abilities explored in much of the existing literature on consciousness and randomness. To our knowledge, this is the first study to investigate potential correlations between the practice of Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism and variations in natural radioactivity, representing a novel area of inquiry within this broader field. The study is observational in nature, collecting data on natural radioactivity levels during the course of the practitioner's regular chanting activities in their environment in Mesa, Arizona.
To provide context for the specific practice examined in this study, it is necessary to introduce Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism. This school of Buddhism was established in Japan over 750 years ago by Nichiren Daishonin, and its teachings and practices are centered on the Lotus Sutra, considered the ultimate teaching of Shakyamuni Buddha [
20]. A core belief is the inherent potential for all individuals to attain enlightenment, or Buddhahood, in their present lifetime through the practice revealed by Nichiren Daishonin [
20]. This potential is fundamentally linked to Myoho-Renge-Kyo, understood as the ultimate Law and essence of all life [
20]. Nichiren Daishonin is revered as the True Buddha who appeared in the Latter Day of the Law to illuminate this universal path to enlightenment, which is accessible regardless of age, background, or social standing [
20]. The overarching goals are individual enlightenment and the realization of a peaceful world [
20].
The central object of worship in Nichiren Shoshu is the Gohonzon, regarded as the embodiment of Nichiren Daishonin's enlightened life [
20]. The daily practice, known as Gongyo, involves reciting portions of the Lotus Sutra and chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo while directing one's focus towards the Gohonzon [
20]. This chanting of Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo is considered the fundamental practice that enables individuals to connect with their inherent Buddhahood and transform their lives [
21].
Nichiren Daishonin's advent is viewed as pivotal, as he revealed Myoho-Renge-Kyo as the fundamental Law of life and established a practice universally effective for actualizing the potential for enlightenment [
21]. The foundation of Nichiren Shoshu is traced to his declaration of Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo on April 28, 1253, and the inscription of the Dai-Gohonzon on October 12, 1279, which serves as the fundamental object of worship [
21]. Before his passing, Nichiren Daishonin designated Nikko Shonin as his successor, ensuring the transmission of the Law [
21]. This emphasis on Nichiren Daishonin as the "True Buddha" and the specific lineage distinguishes Nichiren Shoshu within the broader Buddhist landscape, positioning it as the orthodox tradition for the current age [
21].
The daily liturgical practice, Gongyo, is highly structured, involving specific excerpts from the Lotus Sutra (chapters 2 and 16) and the chanting of Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo [
22]. Practitioners typically perform Gongyo twice daily, in the morning and evening, with prescribed procedures and a focus on the Gohonzon [
22]. This practice is understood as a means of fusing one's life with the enlightened life of the Buddha and transforming one's karma [22, 23]. The Silent Prayers offered during Gongyo reflect a hierarchy of reverence and aspiration, directed towards protective functions, the Dai-Gohonzon, the lineage of teachers, and ultimately encompassing the broader community and the deceased [
22].
In the context of the present study, the focus is specifically on the potential influence of the focused mental and vocal activity involved in chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo as practiced within Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism. This practice, deeply rooted in the belief of activating inherent life potential and connecting with a universal law, provides a unique subject for exploring potential correlations with subtle variations in natural radioactivity, distinct from the meditation or general intention practices examined in previous research on consciousness and randomness.
Building upon the established understanding of natural radioactivity in the study location and the findings from research exploring potential correlations between consciousness and random physical systems, this observational study investigates a specific question: Does the practice of chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo by a long-time practitioner in Mesa, Arizona, correlate with measurable variations in local natural radioactivity levels?
Specifically, drawing from the concept that focused consciousness might influence the statistical properties of random systems, including their variance [17, 18, 19], this study explores whether the intense and focused mental and vocal activity involved in this unique spiritual practice is associated with deviations from the expected random fluctuations in detected radiation events.
A finding of such a correlation, if observed and rigorously analyzed, could have significant implications. It would not only contribute to the limited body of research exploring potential interactions between specific spiritual practices and physical phenomena but could also provide a novel perspective on the subtle ways in which focused human consciousness might interact with the fundamental randomness inherent in natural processes like radioactive decay. While acknowledging the extraordinary nature of such a claim, this study seeks to provide empirical data to explore this frontier question.
Results and Discussion
Figure 1 shows a representative energy spectrum of the natural radioactivity detected by the RadiaCode 10X series instrument in the study location in Mesa, Arizona. This spectrum represents the cumulative data collected across all measurement periods, encompassing both chanting practice sessions and control periods. The spectrum is presented with energy on a logarithmic scale on the X-axis and the detected count rate (in Counts Per Second, CPS) on a linear scale on the Y-axis.
The most prominent feature of the spectrum is a single, sharp peak observed at a low energy level, located between 2 keV and 617 keV, with the peak positioned closer to the 2 keV end of this range. The height of this peak is slightly above 0.132 CPS. This low-energy peak is not characteristic of the primary gamma-ray emissions from the major naturally occurring radioactive isotopes commonly found in the environment, such as isotopes from the uranium and thorium decay series or Potassium-40, which typically produce distinct peaks at significantly higher energies. The presence of this relatively narrow and distinct peak within the broader natural background radiation provides a more defined spectral feature that may be particularly useful for investigating subtle variations or influences compared to analyzing the total, more broadly distributed count rate alone.
The presence of a sharp peak at such a low energy strongly suggests the detection of X-rays rather than typical natural background gamma radiation. While low-energy photons are part of the natural radiation environment, a defined peak at this specific low energy indicates a concentrated detection of photons within a narrow energy band. This peak represents a small fraction of the total detected radiation events, which, based on broader area monitoring, is estimated to be in the range of 25 to 28.3 CPS, encompassing contributions from all detected energies including terrestrial gamma radiation, cosmic rays, and other potential sources. The analysis of this spectrum provides insight into the specific energy distribution of the radiation being measured in the study environment.
Interpreting the source of this low-energy peak requires consideration of potential origins of low-energy photons in an indoor residential setting. While natural processes like the decay of certain isotopes can produce low-energy X-rays, a sharp, prominent peak at a very low energy could potentially be associated with characteristic X-rays emitted by elements present in building materials, household items, or even the detector itself interacting with other radiation. For instance, fluorescence X-rays can be produced when higher-energy photons interact with materials, causing the emission of lower-energy X-rays characteristic of the elements in that material. Without further analysis or calibration specific to identifying low-energy X-ray emitters, definitively identifying the precise source based solely on this spectrum is challenging. However, its distinct nature suggests a specific component of the radiation environment that is separate from the broader, higher-energy gamma background. Further investigation, potentially involving spectral analysis calibration and consideration of materials in the immediate vicinity of the detector, would be necessary to precisely identify the origin of this low-energy radiation.
It is important to distinguish the detected radiation from other forms of energy emission from living organisms, such as biophotons [
25]. Biophotons are weak light emissions typically in the visible and near-ultraviolet range of the electromagnetic spectrum, with photon energies in the range of a few electronvolts (eV). The RadiaCode 10X series instrument, utilizing a CsI(Tl) scintillation crystal, is designed to detect gamma and X-ray photons, which have energies in the kiloelectronvolt (keV) to megaelectronvolt (MeV) range. Given that 1 keV is equal to 1000 eV, the energy levels of biophotons are orders of magnitude lower than the detection threshold of the RadiaCode 10X. Therefore, biophotons emitted by the body of the practitioner would not be detected by this instrument and are not contributing to the observed spectrum, including the low-energy peak. Nevertheless, one could speculate, as a frontier hypothesis, whether subtle quantum interference or effects related to biological energy fields might, in principle, influence the observed spectrum, even if the direct energy emissions are below the detection threshold.
Exploring such possibilities moves into highly speculative domains at the intersection of consciousness, biology, and physics. While current mainstream scientific paradigms do not offer a clear mechanism for biological energy fields or conscious intention to directly influence radioactive decay or the detection of high-energy photons, some theoretical frameworks in frontier science consider the potential for subtle interactions between consciousness, biological systems, and the quantum vacuum or other fundamental fields. These hypotheses often involve concepts like entangled states, resonant interactions, or the influence of organized biological energy fields on physical processes. However, it is crucial to emphasize that these remain theoretical and are not supported by the established and experimentally verified principles of physics governing radioactive decay and energy detection. The observed spectrum is most likely a result of conventional environmental radiation sources and detector response characteristics.
Any potential influence of consciousness or biological fields on such a spectrum would represent a phenomenon far beyond our current understanding. This discussion is presented solely for the sake of exploring theoretical possibilities at the furthest edges of current scientific thought.
Figure 2 presents a spectrogram illustrating the temporal distribution of detected radiation events across different energy levels during a single representative chanting session. Unlike
Figure 1, which shows the cumulative energy spectrum across all measurement periods,
Figure 2 provides a dynamic view of how the radiation profile changes over the course of a specific session.
In
Figure 2, the X-axis represents the energy of the detected photons, similar to the energy spectrum in
Figure 1. The Y-axis represents time, with the start of the recording session located at the bottom of the axis and time progressing upwards. The spectrogram is segmented into two distinct periods: the initial portion represents the control period during which no chanting occurred, and the subsequent portion, indicated by an arrow in the figure, corresponds to the period of chanting practice. The intensity or color at any given point on the spectrogram indicates the rate of detected counts (CPS) at a specific energy and time. This visualization allows for the identification of temporal variations in the count rate at different energy bands throughout the session.
Upon visual inspection of
Figure 2, there is no immediately apparent or striking difference in the pattern or intensity distribution of detected radiation events across the energy spectrum when comparing the control period to the chanting period. The overall spectral profile and the rate of counts at various energy levels appear qualitatively similar throughout the duration of this representative session.
However, further analysis of the spectrogram image using a dedicated software, ImageJ, allows for a more quantitative assessment thus establishing that subtle changes exist that are not visible upon visual inspection. Quantitative analysis of the spectrogram segments using ImageJ yielded the histograms presented in
Figure 3. The histogram on the left summarizes the pixel intensity distribution for the control period, and the histogram on the right shows the distribution for the chanting period. Comparing the total integrated pixel counts (representing accumulated detection events) from these analyses, a significant difference was observed: the control period registered 471,680 counts, whereas the chanting period recorded 498,432 counts, demonstrating a higher total count during the chanting session. This finding is representative of at least five other sessions that yielded qualitatively superimposable results, and the session presented here is shown as a notable example.
Figure 4 illustrates the temporal fluctuations in the detected natural radioactivity count rate (CPS) during representative control and chanting periods. Visual inspection reveals that the amplitude of these fluctuations, representing the variability in the count rate, appears notably higher during the chanting period compared to the control period, with more pronounced deviations from the mean in both positive and negative directions.
Figure 5 presents the same CPS data as shown in
Figure 4, but with a magnified Y-axis to highlight the details of the fluctuations. This enlarged view makes the differences in the amplitude of the peaks more evident. Of particular interest is the observation of instances during the chanting period where the count rate appears to approach or reach zero for brief intervals, an occurrence not readily apparent or consistently observed in the control period. This suggests that during these specific time intervals within the chanting period, the instrument did not register any radioactive decay events.
To explore potential correlates for these observed subtle changes in detected radiation, it is relevant to consider the physiological and neurological processes occurring in the practitioner during the chanting practice, as described in previous work [
24]. Chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo generates specific sound frequencies, notably a reproducible peak around 8 Hz, which aligns with the first Schumann resonance (approximately 7.83 Hz). This resonance is hypothesized to influence human biology through resonant coupling with physiological rhythms, and studies suggest synchronization between autonomic nervous system activity and Schumann resonances. Another prominent frequency generated is 116 Hz, previously termed the fundamental sound of life, which has been shown to reduce chloride ion concentration in seawater. Given the crucial role of chloride ions in maintaining electrical potential, regulating cell volume, and influencing cell function, particularly within the central nervous system, modulation of chloride ion concentration could hypothetically influence brain function and other systemic processes. Furthermore, the chanting generates specific frequencies known as solfeggio frequencies. Research on frequencies like 528 Hz suggests potential stress-reducing effects, positive impacts on brain cell viability, modulation of hormone production, and reduction of reactive oxygen species in both human and animal models. These findings suggest that the specific sound frequencies generated during chanting may induce measurable physiological and cellular changes [
24].
Simultaneously, studies of brain activity during chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo indicate significant changes in the prefrontal cortex, with a modest increase during chanting compared to a larger increase before and a very large increase immediately after. This pattern, including a relative decrease during chanting, is hypothesized to relate to a state of focused attention and a potential shift towards slower brainwaves like theta waves. These changes in brain activity are integrated with physiological changes in brain water content and blood flow. Chanting, characterized by rapid inspiration and prolonged exhalation, is associated with increased combined thickness of the meninges and cerebral cortex and greater water content in the cortex during exhalation. Increased blood flow during brain activity further augments brain water content. Consequently, during chanting, sound waves are hypothesized to travel through the brain with greater speed and energy due to the increased water content and the properties of myelin. These enhanced sound waves within the brain are speculated to modulate gene expression and contribute to beneficial effects on brain health, independent of auditory perception, via bone conduction through the skull bones [
24].
Connecting these diverse physiological and neurological observations to the subtle increase in detected radiation counts during chanting requires a highly speculative leap beyond established scientific principles. However, within the framework of frontier hypotheses exploring consciousness-matter interactions, one could theoretically propose that the coherent and focused psycho-physiological state achieved during intense chanting, potentially amplified by the specific resonant frequencies generated and the altered brain state, might create a subtle, detectable perturbation in the local environment. This perturbation, perhaps in the form of a subtle electromagnetic field generated by the synchronized brain activity or altered ion dynamics, or even a more direct, but currently unknown, interaction with the quantum vacuum or fundamental fields, could hypothetically influence the probability of interaction between ambient radiation and the detector's scintillation crystal, or, in a far more speculative vein, subtly influence the quantum processes governing nuclear decay rates themselves. The observed increase in detected counts could, within this highly speculative context, be interpreted as a manifestation of this subtle influence. This remains a highly speculative idea, far outside the realm of established physics and biology, but is presented here as a possible, albeit unproven, framework for considering such unexpected observations in the context of consciousness-related research at the furthest edges of current scientific thought.
Conclusions
This observational study investigated the potential correlation between the practice of chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo by a long-time practitioner in Mesa, Arizona, and variations in local natural radioactivity levels, specifically focusing on fluctuations in the detected count rate (CPS) and analyzing the energy spectrum. The findings from this preliminary observational study, particularly the quantitative analysis of the spectrograms indicating a higher total count during chanting periods and the visual observation of increased variability in CPS fluctuations (as shown in
Figure 3,
Figure 4, and
Figure 5), warrant consideration in the context of existing research into consciousness-matter interactions.
Efforts by projects such as the Princeton Engineering Anomalies Research (PEAR) laboratory explored the potential for focused human intention to influence the output of random number generators (RNGs), with some findings suggesting effects on both the mean and variance of random processes. Similarly, the Global Consciousness Project (GCP) has reported correlations between periods of heightened collective consciousness during significant global events and deviations in the variance of a network of RNGs. While the present study examines natural radioactivity rather than engineered random systems, and involves a specific spiritual practice rather than general intention or reaction to global events, the observed pattern of potentially increased activity (higher counts) and notably increased variability/fluctuations during the chanting period aligns conceptually with the type of subtle influences on random systems that have been hypothesized and explored in this frontier research area. These results, therefore, tentatively suggest a possible correlation between the focused psycho-physiological state achieved during chanting and subtle alterations in the pattern of detected natural radiation events, echoing, in principle, the findings related to consciousness influencing the statistical properties of random physical processes observed in the PEAR and GCP studies.
Furthermore, within highly speculative frontier frameworks such as the Orchestrated Objective Reduction (Orch-OR) theory, which postulates that consciousness is deeply embedded in the fundamental structure of the universe, one might theoretically consider how a profoundly focused state of consciousness achieved during chanting could, at a foundational level, interact with or influence physical processes like radioactive decay or the detection of radiation, although this remains far beyond established scientific understanding.
The cumulative energy spectrum analysis revealed a prominent low-energy peak, likely attributable to X-rays from environmental sources, which constitutes a small fraction of the total detected natural background radiation. While the instrument is not designed to detect biophotons, and direct influence of biological energy fields on the detected spectrum is not supported by conventional physics, the study acknowledges the speculative frontier hypothesis regarding potential subtle interactions.
It is important to consider the limitations of this study, including the single-subject design, the observational nature of the data collection, and the inherent variability of natural background radiation. While the study explored a novel area concerning a specific spiritual practice, the results should be interpreted with caution.
Future research could build upon this preliminary investigation by employing a larger sample size of practitioners, utilizing controlled experimental designs, incorporating simultaneous monitoring of a wider range of environmental variables, and potentially employing more sensitive or specialized detection equipment. Further analysis of the energy spectra during chanting versus control periods could also provide additional insights.
As a final remark, it is crucial to recognize that this study, while exploring potential physical correlates, only touches upon one facet of the profound spiritual practice of Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism - the power of practice. The full religious and spiritual experience of chanting Nam-Myoho-Renge-Kyo transcends purely neurophysiological or biophysical mechanisms, encompassing a mystic dimension that, while not necessarily in contradiction with scientific principles, cannot be fully explained by science alone. Nevertheless, in the spirit of Nichiren Daishonin's emphasis on reason and "actual proof," this study, despite its inherent limitations, is offered as a contribution to the empirical exploration of potential phenomena associated with this practice.