1. Introduction
Gibberellins (GAs) are a large group of plant hormones, encompassing 136 chemically similar compounds found in plants, fungi, and bacteria [
1,
2]. They belong to diterpene carboxylic acids with a tetracyclic
ent-gibberellane skeleton, composed of 19–20 carbon atoms [
3]. Biologically active GAs act as endogenous plant growth and development regulators, transmitting internal and environmental signals within the organism [
1]. They stimulate cell elongation, cell division, regulate seed germination, control the transition between juvenile and generative plant phases, induce flowering, influence sex determination, and play a role in fruit setting and growth processes [
4,
5]. However, only a small group are biologically active: gibberellin A
1 (GA
1), gibberellin A
3 (GA
3), gibberellin A
4 (GA
4), and gibberellin A
7 (GA
7) [
1]. Interestingly, GA
1 and GA
4 are the dominant forms in plant tissues [
6,
7,
8]. GA
3 and GA
7 metabolism in plants is not a common process, and these GA species are present in trace amounts, however, microorganisms can metabolize GA
20 to GA
3, or GA
7 directly from GA
4, involving GA desaturases [
9,
10]. For plants, it is crucial to regulate GA levels precisely; however, the chemical structure specificity of 1,2-unsaturated GAs (GA
3 and GA
7) obstructs their inactivation in plants by 2β-hydroxylation, which results in their prolonged activity and may explain their low amounts in plants [
2,
10].
GA biosynthesis has been studied in many plant species, and it occurs in three stages according to subcellular localization, where involved enzymes act [
4,
11]. The first stage of GA biosynthesis takes place in plastids, where geranylgeranyl diphosphate is converted to
ent-kaurene through an intermediate, catalysed by terpene synthases:
ent-copalyl diphosphate synthase (CPS) and
ent-kaurene synthase (KS) [
12,
13]. Subsequently, in the outer plastid membrane and endoplasmic reticulum, cytochrome P450 monooxygenases catalyse oxidation reactions, during which
ent-kaurene is converted through four intermediates to GA
12 [
14,
15]. The third stage of synthesis occurs in the cell cytoplasm, where the common precursor GA
12 is oxidised by two distinct soluble 2-oxoglutarate-dependent dioxygenases (2-ODDs) – GA 20-oxidase (GA20ox) and GA 3-oxidase (GA3ox) – leading to the biologically active GA
1 or GA
4 [
11,
16,
17]. To keep optimal levels of active GAs species within tissues, the inactivation process is essential for plant growth and development. The main mechanism involves two groups of 2-ODDs enzymes, differentiated by their substrate specificity: C
19-GA 2-oxidase and C
20-GA 2-oxidase, both of which utilise 2β-hydroxylation to catabolize precursors and biologically active GAs into inactive products [
2,
18,
19,
20].
The 2-ODD superfamily contains four enzyme subfamilies (GA20ox, GA3ox, C
19-GA2ox and C
20-GA2ox), involved in GA biosynthesis and catabolism, which are encoded by small multigene families and are conserved between multiple species [
19,
21,
22,
23]. Genes of GAoxs subfamilies were first isolated in model plant species:
GA20ox in pumpkin [
24],
GA3ox in
Arabidopsis thaliana [25],
GA2ox in runner bean (
Phaseolus coccineus) and in
A. thaliana [
26]. To date, GAoxs genes have been identified in many commercially important plants such as: cucumber [
18], watermelon [
27], tomato [
28,
29,
30], maize [
31], rice [
32,
33], peach [
34], grapevine [
35], wild cherry, wild strawberry [
36], breadfruit [
37] and others. With the identification of GAoxs enzymes and their genes, the mechanism of fruit-set became better understood, which opened opportunities to manipulate fruit-set and induce parthenocarpy [
28,
29,
38,
39].
H. sosnowskyi is a noxious invasive weed species enlisted into Invasive Alien Species of Union concern and national lists of invasive species in many EU countries [
40,
41].
H. sosnowskyi propagates only by seeds and after bearing them, eventually dies [
42,
43]. Interestingly,
Pastinaca sativa (Apiaceae) is adapted to cope with some pests by producing seedless fruits. This strategy enables it to regulate outbreaks of herbivores [
44]. Previous studies have indicated an exogenous GA
3 effect in inducing seedlessness in
H. sosnowskyi [
45,
46]. However, to date, analysis of endogenous GAs and related genes has not been available. With the recent article on the
H. sosnowskyi genome, GAoxs and gene analysis have become accessible in this invasive species [
47].
In this study, we identified 27 putative GAoxs enzymes in the H. sosnowskyi genome. Phylogenetic analysis clustered these proteins into three subgroups: GA20ox, GA3ox and C19-GA2ox. We identified the effects of exogenous GA3 on the expression of HsGA20ox1, HsGA3ox1 and HsGA2ox1, as well as on the endogenous GA profiles in gradually opening H. sosnowskyi flowers. These results open opportunities to further analyse the role of GAs in H. sosnowskyi fruit-set mechanism and develop invasion control strategies.
3. Discussion
Gibberellins play an important role in the processes of fruit set, development, and ripening [
48,
49]. In horticulture, plants are often sprayed with bioactive GAs to obtain high-quality seedless fruits, but this can have a negative impact on the histological and morphological structure of the fruit [
50,
51,
52,
53]. The 2-ODD protein superfamily is the second-largest enzyme family in plants. Moreover, 2-ODDs have a crucial role in leading oxygenation or hydroxylation in various plant metabolic events [
19]. Members of 2-ODDs have been identified in many model plant species:
Arabidopsis thaliana, rice, cucumber, tomato and others [
18,
26,
54,
55,
56,
57,
58,
59]. However, information about 2-ODDs in invasive
Heracleum sosnowskyi is very limited. A recent study by [
47] made the genome of
H. sosnowskyi available for genome-wide analysis. According to GAoxs protein sequences from
A. thaliana and
Oryza sativa [
60], we identified and named 9
HsGA20ox1-9, 13
HsGA2ox1-13 and 5
HsGA3ox1-5 protein homologues from
H. sosnowskyi (
Table 1). All putative GAoxs contained 2OG-Fe(II) oxygenase (PF03171) and non-haem dioxygenase N-terminal (PF14226) domains, which are known to be specific for 2-ODDs [
61,
62]. In our study, we predicted the 3D protein structures of several HsGAoxs and identified that both previously named domains are located in the reaction crevice of the proteins (
Figure 3A). This aligns with the previous models of suggested GAoxs in rice [
63]. Interestingly, HsGA20ox1 and HsGA20ox2, seem to be duplicates, which have one amino acid substitution caused by single nucleotide polymorphism (
Figure 3A). Gene duplication is generally seen as a major driver of genes developing different functions, a process steered by natural selection, which is important to consider in further HsGAox analysis [
64,
65]. Phylogenetic analysis suggested that HsGA20oxs belong to three distinct clades, similarly, HsGA3oxs seem to belong to two different paraphyletic groups. Interestingly, we have not found any members of C
20-GA2oxs (
Figure 2). However, the functional characterization using C
20- and C
19-GA substrates of HsGA2oxs might improve our classification. Previous studies indicate that GA2oxs are composed of three groups: C
19-GA2ox-I, C
19-GA2ox-II, and C
20-GA2ox-I [
11,
58,
66,
67]. In our study, we observed that
H. sosnowskyi C
19-2ox members cluster together with
O. sativa and
A. thaliana members into two monophyletic groups: C
19-GA2ox-I and C
19-GA2ox-II (
Figure 2). These findings suggest that C
19-HsGA2oxs might have functional differences among the groups. Furthermore, it is known that different
GAox genes display significant variations in their expression across different tissues [
39,
68,
69,
70,
71]. Comparison of the phylogenetic tree with the gene structure and motif analysis, it is apparent that the most closely related members within subfamilies share similar gene structure and motif composition (
Figure 2;
Figure 3). Interestingly, HsGA20ox and HsGA2ox are found in greater numbers than HsGA3oxs, similarly to
A. thaliana,
O. sativa,
Cucumis sativus,
Salix matsudana [
18,
63,
72,
73]. To delve into the evolutionary relationships of GAox genes, we analysed motif composition and gene structure (Fig. 3). However, GA20ox and GA3ox subfamilies were distinct from GA2ox by the LPWKET motif, which is characteristic of GA20oxs and for some GA3oxs [
39,
63,
72]. Whereas motif 9 was observed in all C
19-HsGA2oxs, it is distinct from the rest of the 2-ODD subfamilies [
63]. Gene structure revealed that all
HsGA20oxs contain three exons and two introns except for
HsGA20ox4 and
-7, which are similar to the structure of the GA20ox subfamily in
A. thaliana [
58].
HsGA3oxs have a simple gene structure of one intron and two exons, consistent with those in
A. thaliana,
C. sativus and
O. sativa [
58,
60]. Our findings reveal that closely related members within GAox subfamilies possess similar structures and motifs, implying shared functions.
A more detailed analysis of terminal umbel ovaries in the early stages of fruit development revealed a differential distribution of GA and metabolites between the central and lateral regions. This was particularly reflected in a significant increase in the levels of metabolites GA
44 and GA
20 in the control samples of the central umbel region at 0 and 3 days after application (DAA) (
Figure 4D). This inter-regional distribution may be due to the complex umbel architecture, as the flowers in the lateral part of the umbel open first [
74]. In addition, the literature indicates that GA is involved in the sex determination of male flowers [
75,
76,
77], with high levels of GA precursors and the hormone GA
4 accumulating in the floral parts of stamens [
78]. As is known, male flowers in the umbels of some Apiaceae family representatives, such as
Zizia aurea and
Thaspium barbinode, are distributed centripetally [
79]. However, the terminal umbel of
Heracleum mantegazzianum is usually composed only of hermaphrodite flowers [
74]. There is no literature data on the distribution of hermaphrodite and male flowers in the terminal umbel of
H. sosnowskyi but based on our endogenous GA profiles (
Figure 4D), it can be assumed that there should be more of them in the centre of the
H. sosnowskyi umbel. Three days after exogenous GA
3 treatment, the accumulation of the metabolite GA
20 was significantly reduced in the ovaries of both parts of the umbel, but the level of the hormone GA
1 in the ovary tissues increased (
Figure 4D). Ten days after application, the synthesis of the hormone GA
1 in the ovary tissues of the central part of the umbel was completely suppressed, but only partially in the lateral part of the umbel. The inhibitory effect of exogenous GA
3 on GA biosynthesis can be identified by a significant decrease in the precursor GA
20 and a marked increase in the amount of the catabolite GA
29 in the ovaries of both parts of the umbel. However, it remains unclear why exogenous GA
3 forms a GA
1 gradient in different parts of the umbel (
Figure 4D). It is known that an increase in the level of biologically active GA forms in the early stages of fruit development leads to the development of parthenocarpic fruit set [
38,
49,
51,
80,
81]. It should be noted that in this experiment, flower pollination was not controlled, so the GA
1 content at 10 DAA could have increased due to natural fertilization (
Figure 4D).
Before analysing the abundance of GA biosynthesis gene (
HsGA20ox1,
HsGA3ox1, and
HsGA2ox1) transcripts, these genes were cloned from
H. sosnowskyi umbel tissues collected 10 days after application (DAA) and specific primers were designed for them. It was observed that in the early stage of fruit development (3 DAA),
HsGA20ox1 was more highly expressed, but its expression decreased in later stages (10 DAA). On the other hand, the expression of the metabolic
HsGA3ox1 gene was much more intense, with no differences detected between umbel regions. Other studies have indicated that the increase in
GA20ox gene expression and the decrease in
GA2ox are essential factors in regulating GA biosynthesis during fruit set [
48,
51,
82,
83]. It should also be noted that in other plant species (e.g., white clover, tomato, cultivated rice), more than one GA oxidase gene is involved in fruit set control [
28,
49,
78,
80,
84]. However, our results suggest that intense fruit development is dependent on endogenous GA, which is supported by the obtained levels of endogenous GA (
Figure 4E). Additionally, the results of phenotypic analysis of ovaries (
Figure 4B) correspond to the peak of gibberellin during the cell expansion phase observed in the model plant tomato [
85,
86]. However, the effect of exogenous GA
3 stimulated
HsGA3ox1 expression in the central and lateral parts of the umbel ovaries, while the inhibition of
HsGA2ox1 gene expression, as speculated, was not detected (
Figure 4E). Furthermore, the obtained expression profile of the
HsGA20ox1 gene at 10 DAA, both in the control and after GA
3 treatment, suggests that fruit set had already occurred, as seen in some species such as pear, where after a similar treatment with exogenous biologically active GA, the expression of genes
PbGA20ox1,
PbGA20ox2, and
PbGA20ox3 is suppressed [
39]. Our results align with the suppressed expression of paralogous genes of the PbGA20ox (
PbGA20ox1,
PbGA20ox3) in pollinated pear ovaries [
39].