4. Discussion
Understanding the variables influencing farmers' intentions to adopt Teak (Tectona grandis) as a source of carbon credits in landscape restoration initiatives is crucial for advancing sustainable forestry practices. The Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) framework provides a valuable lens for analysing these motivations, where the constructs of Attitude, Subjective Norms, and Perceived Behavioural Control collectively reveal the factors that shape adoption intentions. After a factor analysis, specific variables emerged as fitting each construct, offering insights into the motivational structure guiding farmers' decisions.
For Attitude, the analysis identified two variables that best aligned with this construct: (1) the belief that Teak plantations generate more stable income from carbon credits compared to other agricultural activities, and (2) the perception that Teak plantations are economically advantageous for generating income through carbon credits. These findings indicate that farmers in Techiman Municipality of Ghana perceive clear financial benefits in adopting Teak plantations. This is particularly important in Ghana, where many rural communities depend on agriculture for their livelihood. This aligns with previous studies, such as [
30] and [
31], which demonstrate that economic stability provided by carbon credits can significantly enhance farmers’ income, supporting Ghana’s economic development goals. And therefore, the findings suggest that, positive attitudes toward Teak's economic potential could be reinforced through policies that emphasize its profitability in carbon markets, potentially motivating wider adoption.
Regarding Subjective Norms, three variables were found to represent this construct best: (1) government incentives that make Teak plantations a more attractive option, (2) pressure from community leaders to establish Teak plantations, and (3) pressure from family members to adopt Teak plantations. These findings indicate that social influences, including institutional incentives and community expectations, play a substantial role in shaping farmers' intentions. In Ghana, where social structures and community dynamics are critical in decision-making, government incentives can provide formal encouragement, while community and family pressures can amplify adoption tendencies. This highlights the importance of engaging local leaders and communities in promoting Teak plantations. Recognizing these dynamics, effective interventions can benefit from community-based support, making Teak adoption a socially endorsed practice. This reflects insights from [
32], who observed that social pressures and community norms are vital determinants in the uptake of sustainable agricultural practices.
For Perceived Behavioural Control, four variables were identified as central to this construct: (1) the accessibility of support systems to help establish and manage Teak plantations, (2) the readiness of local authorities to support plantation efforts, (3) farmers' perceived control over the factors influencing plantation success, and (4) the belief that high control over resources and support would facilitate establishing a Teak plantation. The availability of resources and support systems is crucial for farmers in Ghana, where infrastructure can be a limiting factor. Enhancing these support structures can boost farmers' confidence and willingness to engage in Teak-based carbon credit initiatives. This aligns with Ghana's need to build robust agricultural support systems for the success of sustainable practices. These results suggest that farmers' perceptions of available support and their sense of control over resources significantly impact their decision to pursue Teak plantations. This is consistent with [
33], who found that supportive infrastructure and resource availability are critical for successful agricultural adoption. Ensuring active involvement from local authorities and increasing support structures could empower farmers, boosting their confidence and willingness to engage in Teak-based carbon credit initiatives.
Therefore, the constructs of Attitude, Subjective Norms, and Perceived Behavioural Control each reveal different but interrelated motivations for Teak adoption. The findings highlight the critical role of financial incentives, social influence, and accessible support systems in shaping farmers' intentions to adopt Teak as a sustainable and profitable carbon credit source in landscape restoration. Emphasising these factors in policy interventions can create an environment conducive to broader adoption, advancing economic and ecological sustainability.
The study examined various latent variables' direct and indirect effects on farmers' intentions to accept Teak (
Tectona grandis) as a carbon credit source in landscape restoration initiatives. These findings are instrumental in understanding the dynamics of farmers' decision-making processes and aligning them with the study's hypotheses. The direct effect of Attitude on farmers' intentions was significantly positive (0.6780346), supporting hypothesis 1. This finding aligns with the Theory of Planned Behaviour [
34], which posits that a favourable attitude toward a behaviour enhances the intention to engage. Farmers who perceive Teak plantations as economically beneficial and a source of stable income are more inclined to adopt this practice. The positive relationship reinforces the hypothesis that attitudes towards Teak plantations directly influence the intention to integrate them on farms. However, the negative indirect effect (-0.14795690) suggests that while the overall perception is favourable, underlying challenges might hinder the full realization of this intention. These could include practical difficulties or unanticipated barriers that must be addressed to maximize the positive impact of favourable attitudes.
The direct positive effect of Subjective Norms (0.3261947) on farmers' intentions substantiates hypothesis 2. This indicates that social pressures and community expectations significantly impact farmers' decisions. Farmers who face pressure from community leaders' family members and benefit from government incentives are likelier to consider teak plantations. This is consistent with findings from [
35], which emphasise the role of social norms in agricultural decision-making.
Interestingly, the negative indirect effect of Subjective Norms (-0.16904337) indicates potential social or cultural barriers that may impede the adoption of Teak despite positive social influences. These barriers might include scepticism or resistance to change within the community, suggesting that simply having positive social pressure is not enough; addressing underlying cultural perceptions is also crucial. In Ghana, traditional practices and community norms play a significant role in decision-making. Overcoming these cultural barriers requires targeted interventions that consider the local context and actively engage community leaders to shift perceptions.
Perceived Behavioural Control showed a negative direct effect (-0.3963715) on farmers' intentions, contradicting hypothesis 3. This suggests that farmers perceive significant constraints in successfully establishing and managing Teak plantations, such as limited access to resources, support systems, or regulatory hurdles. This finding is crucial for Ghana, as it highlights that, despite recognizing the benefits, farmers cannot execute these practices effectively due to infrastructural and regulatory challenges. Enhancing perceived behavioural control by providing better support and resources, such as access to financing, technical assistance, and streamlined regulatory processes, is essential to mitigate these constraints and facilitate adoption.
The positive indirect effect of Attitude on Perceived Behavioural Control (0.08084755) implies that while farmers realize the potential benefits of Teak plantations, their perceived lack of control over necessary resources and support hinders their intention. This further emphasizes the need for robust support systems in Ghana to empower farmers. Ensuring that farmers have access to the necessary resources will not only improve their perceptions of control but also increase their likelihood of adopting Teak plantations.
The analysis also revealed that Attitude directly influences both Subjective Norms (0.1895707) and Perceived Behavioural Control (0.4484383), indicating that favourable attitudes can enhance social approval and increase perceived control over adoption. Furthermore, Subjective Norms demonstrated a positive direct effect (0.4264771) on Perceived Behavioural Control, highlighting the interconnectedness of these variables. These findings suggest that interventions should focus on improving attitudes, leveraging social dynamics, and enhancing perceived control to foster broader adoption of Teak plantations. In Ghana, this means developing policies that reinforce the economic advantages of Teak plantations, engaging community leaders to support adoption, and enhancing infrastructure and resources to support farmers. These findings suggest that interventions should focus on improving attitudes, leveraging social dynamics, and enhancing perceived control to foster broader adoption of Teak plantations.
The findings validate the first two hypotheses, showing that positive attitudes and social norms significantly influence farmers' intentions to adopt Teak as a carbon credit source. However, the third hypothesis is not supported, as perceived behavioural control negatively impacts intentions. This highlights the complexity of adoption behaviours and the need for a multifaceted approach that includes improving attitudes, leveraging social influences, and addressing perceived control barriers. Policymakers and stakeholders should design comprehensive strategies that address these variables holistically to promote sustainable forestry practices and enhance economic and environmental resilience.