3.1. EDS analysis and morphology TiO2/ITO/glass photoelectrodes
Figure 2a shows EDS spectra TiO
2/ITO/glass photoelectrodes with a TiO
2 layer thickness of 15 nm. In the EDS spectrum, one can clearly distinguish lines belonging to the elements of each photoelectrode layer, so the
Kα1 line of silicon with an energy of 1.740 keV, the
Kα1 line of sodium with an energy of 1.040 keV, the
Kα1 line of magnesium with an energy of 1.254 keV and the
Kα1 line of aluminum with an energy of 1.486 keV belong to the glass substrate. The ITO transparent conductor layer contains lines with energies of 3.286 keV, 3.487 keV, 3.712 keV and 3.920 keV, which correspond to the
Lα1,
Lβ1,
Lβ2 and
Lγ1 series of indium, respectively. The tin lines doped with ITO at a level of ~10% have energies of 3.444 keV, 3.663 keV, 3.904 keV, which can be attributed to
Lα1,
Lβ1,
Lβ, however, as can be seen from the spectrum, the tin lines partially overlap with the indium lines, resulting in they cannot be separated on a spectrum.
The titanium oxide layer corresponds to lines with energies of 4.512 keV and 4.933 keV, which correspond to the
Kα1 and
Lβ1 series of titanium (
Figure 2a). An increase in the number of ALD cycles of TiO
2 deposition from 150 to 450 cycles is accompanied by an increase in the intensity of the peaks. This fact is clear evidence of an increase in the thickness of the TiO
2 film. The line with an energy of 0.525 keV corresponds to the
Kα1 series of oxygen, which is present in all three layers of the photoelectrodes under consideration.
Figure 3 shows SEM images of TiO
2 layers, 5, 10 and 15 nm thick, on ITO/glass substrate. All films are characterized by TiO
2 and have a polycrystalline structure; crystallites are characterized by spherical and needle-shaped morphology. Spherical crystallites have sizes in the range of 20-60 nm, while needle-shaped ones have a size of 40-60 nm and a length of 50-150 nm.
TiO
2 films have a domain structure, which is probably caused by the polycrystallinity of the ITO film on which the TiO
2 layer is deposited. This morphology is typical for the ALD method [
39].
3.3. EDS analysis and morphology TiO2/Au/ITO/glass photoelectrodes
Figure 5 shows the EDS spectra of TiO
2/Au/ITO/glass photoelectrodes with a TiO
2 layer thickness of 15 nm and different thicknesses of the dispersed gold layer of 5 nm (
Figure 5a) and 10 nm (
Figure 5b).
The general pattern of spectral lines looks similar to TiO2/ITO/glass photoelectrodes, with the exception that peaks with energies of 2.193 keV and 2.203 keV are observed, which correspond to the Mα1 and Mβ series of gold.
Figure 6 shows SEM images of TiO
2/Au (5 nm)/ITO/glass and TiO
2/Au (10 nm)/ITO/glass nanocomposite photoelectrodes, with different thicknesses of Au films and a TiO
2 layer at different magnifications.
Based on the SEM data, the following conclusions can be drawn: firstly, gold films with a thickness of 5 and 10 nm are dispersed during the annealing process at 450 °C due to the effect of dimensional melting. Poor wetting of the ITO substrate by molten gold leads to the fact that it is energetically favorable for gold to coalesce into droplets. Moreover, the thickness of the initial gold film determines the particle size after annealing. According to the SEM of a 5 nm thick Au film, after annealing the particles have high polydispersity, this is typical for this process. The particles have sizes from 10 to 60 nm. For an Au film with a thickness of 10 nm, the particles have a significantly larger size from 20 to 200 nm, therefore the scatter in particle sizes is even greater than for a Au film with a thickness of 5 nm.
The second important aspect of SEM studies is understanding how the TiO2 film covers gold nanoparticles and what morphology it has in the case of nanocomposite photoelectrodes. A detailed study of the surface of Au nanoparticles shows that in the case of a TiO2 film 5 nm thick, there is no continuous coating of the surface of both particles based on 5 nm and 10 nm Au films. Only decoration of Au particles and TiO2 particles is observed. An increase in the thickness of the TiO2 film leads to a greater degree of coverage of the surface of Au nanoparticles with TiO2 nanoparticles. One can even assume a transition from an island coating to a continuous one. Moreover, the morphologies of TiO2/Au (5 nm)/ITO and TiO2/Au (10 nm)/ITO are similar for TiO2 thicknesses of 10 and 15 nm, respectively.
The morphology of the TiO2 layer in the spaces between Au nanoparticles is also different from continuous TiO2 films. For TiO2/Au (5 nm)/ITO the crystallites have only a spherical shape; the needle-shaped morphology of the crystallites is not observed for all TiO2 thicknesses. For TiO2/Au (10 nm)/ITO, crystallites of both spherical and needle-shaped morphology are visible in the spaces between Au particles, thus the average distance between Au particles has a strong influence on the morphology of TiO2 films.
3.4. Optical properties TiO2/Au/ITO/glass photoelectrodes
Figure 7 shows the spectral transmittance of TiO
2/Au (5 nm)/ITO/glass и TiO
2/Au (10 nm)/ITO/glass photoelectrodes with different TiO
2 layer thicknesses
The transmission spectra for two types of photoelectrodes show resonant absorption associated with the excitation of plasmons in spherical gold nanoparticles. Moreover, the position of the absorption peak is related both to the average size of nanoparticles and to the dielectric constant of their environment.
For TiO2/Au (5 nm)/ITO/glass with a TiO2 thickness of 5 nm, the resonant wavelength is 640 nm. An increase in the thickness of the TiO2 layer leads to a shift of the absorption peak to the red region; the resonance wavelengths are 665 nm and 677 nm, respectively. For TiO2/Au (10 nm)/ITO/with a TiO2 thickness of 5 nm, the resonance wavelength is 706 nm. An increase in the thickness of TiO2 leads to a shift of the absorption peak to the red region; the resonance wavelengths are 750 nm and 775 nm, respectively.
The shift in the plasmon resonance frequency to a longer wavelength region in gold nanoparticles for each line of photoelectrodes is due to the gradual coating of Au nanoparticles with a TiO2 layer, which leads to a change in the local dielectric constant near the particle. Thus, we can conclude that increasing the thickness of TiO2 from 10 nm to 15 nm leads to an increase in the continuity of the coating of Au nanoparticles. This result is in good agreement with the theoretical dependence of the plasmon resonance frequency on the dielectric constant of the medium in which the particle under study is located.
The width of the absorption line is related to the polydispersity of Au nanoparticles; the higher it is, the wider the absorption line. Thus, for TiO2/Au (5 nm)/ITO/glass, the absorption peak width is significantly narrower than for TiO2/Au (10 nm)/ITO/glass, which confirms our conclusions drawn from the analysis of the SEM image.
3.5. Photoelectrochemical properties of TiO2/ITO/glass photoelectrodes
Figure 8 shows voltammograms of the TiO
2/ITO/glass photoelectrodes under study. We classify photoelectrodes as the first series of samples depending on the thickness of the TiO
2 layer; they have the nomenclature: 1-1 (5 nm TiO
2), 1-2 (10 nm TiO
2) and 1-3 (15 nm TiO
2). The voltammogram contains peaks around -0.6 V for all samples and a lower intensity peak around -0.4 V.
From the voltammetry data, the photovoltaic characteristics of the samples were calculated; they are presented in
Table 2. It should be noted that the short-circuit current densities for all samples without gold particles are low and decrease with increasing thickness of the titanium dioxide layer. The open circuit potential varies with different samples, but the nature of these changes is difficult to determine. Most often, this is due to a change in the position of the level of the conduction band of the samples and the peculiarities of the formation of a double electrical layer at the electrode/electrolyte interface. The filling factor value gradually increases with increasing TiO
2 thickness. The efficiency values for converting light energy into electrical energy are quite low and do not exceed 0.004% for a TiO
2 film 5 nm thick.
Samples in this series are comparison samples. The short circuit current density and efficiency for all samples in the series are low. Sample 1-1 (TiO2 (5 nm)/ITO/glass) has the best results-light energy conversion is carried out with an efficiency of ~0.004%, while the photocurrent density is 0.005 mA/cm2. The worst sample of series 1-3 (TiO2 (15 nm)/ITO/glass) has an efficiency of 0.002% at a photocurrent density of 0.002 mA/cm2.
To obtain more detailed information about the system, the photoelectrodes were examined using impedance spectroscopy. Nyquist curves are shown in Fig 9a. Dots indicate experimental data, lines indicate data approximation. The data obtained by the impedance spectroscopy method are consistent with the data of the cyclic voltammetry method: a decrease in the short-circuit current density is accompanied by an increase in the resistance in the system.
The resulting hodographs can be approximated by an equivalent electrical circuit [
36,
37], shown in
Figure 9a. The approximation parameters are given in
Table 3.
The circuit consists of a series resistance RD, which includes the resistance of the conductive glass and electrolyte, Rw, associated with the transfer of charge carriers from the surface of the photoelectrode to the electrolyte solution, and RK, which is responsible for the processes that occur at the counter electrode and at the counter electrode/electrolyte interface. Capacitors C1 and C2 in the diagram indicate double electrical layers that appear at the working electrode/electrolyte and counter electrode/electrolyte interfaces, respectively. The RD parameter shows the resistance in the electrochemical circuit, associated with the resistance of the solution itself, the connection of the electrodes to the external circuit, etc. As a rule, this value is no more than ten ohms and weakly depends on the nature of the photoelectrode. The RW parameter, reflecting the processes occurring on the working electrode, increases by an order of magnitude as the thickness of the titanium dioxide layer increases from 5 to 10 nm; further growth of the layer thickness does not change this parameter. In the case of the RK parameter, which reflects the processes occurring at the counter electrode, opposite patterns are observed.
Impedance data were also plotted in Bode coordinates (
Figure 9b-9c). The resulting peaks were decomposed into components using the Fityk 1.3.1 program. Each peak in the Bode diagrams corresponds to a charge carrier involved in various charge transfer processes. For sample 1-1 there are two such carriers, and for samples 1-2 and 1-3 – three. From these Bode plots, the lifetimes of each type of charge carrier were calculated and shown in
Table 4.
From the data presented in
Table 4, it is clear that the concentrations of charge carriers are close, and the number of electrons involved in electrochemical processes exceeds the number of holes. Most likely, holes in this case should be understood as trivalent titanium (Ti
3+), the proportion of which, apparently, increases for samples with layer thicknesses of 10 nm and 15 nm.
3.6. Photoelectrochemical properties of a series of TiO2/Au (5 nm)/ITO/glass and TiO2/Au (10 nm)/ITO/glass photoelectrodes
Figure 10 shows the voltammograms of the TiO
2/Au (5 nm)/ITO/glass and TiO
2/Au (10 nm)/ITO/glass photoelectrodes under study. For convenience, the samples are labeled as follows: photoelectrodes with Au, 5 nm thick, belong to the second series of samples and, accordingly, depending on the thickness of the TiO
2 layer, have the nomenclature 2-1 (5 nm TiO
2); 2-2 (10 nm TiO
2) and 2-3 (15 nm TiO
2); photoelectrodes with Au, 10 nm thick, belong to the third series of samples and, accordingly, depending on the thickness of the TiO
2 layer, have the nomenclature 3-1 (5 nm TiO
2); 3-2 (10 nm TiO
2) and 3-3 (15 nm TiO
2)
It should be noted that for samples 2-1, 2-2 and 2-3, the voltammogram shows peaks at -0.3-0.4 V and at -0.6 V, which was typical for the reference samples. For sample 7-6, an additional peak is observed in the positive region with a maximum in the region of +0.4 V. This is probably due to the transformation of gold in an alkaline medium [
29].
From the CV data, the photovoltaic characteristics were calculated and summarized in
Table 5. All samples containing gold demonstrate higher current densities compared to samples without gold (1-1, 1-2, 1-3). However, in the case of samples 2-1 and 3-1 this increase is most significant. It is likely that in a titanium dioxide layer 5 nm thick, charge separation and transfer are more active than in a layer of greater thickness. Applying gold reduces the open circuit potential. The filling factor for all samples is 23-34%. The efficiency of electrochemical cells is largely related to the short-circuit current densities and duplicates the patterns of their changes. The most active sample of the series with gold, 5 nm thick (sample 2-1), allows you to convert light energy with an efficiency of 0.025%. The most active sample of the series with gold, 10 nm thick (sample 3-1), allows you to convert light energy with an efficiency of 0.135%.
Nyquist plot for TiO
2/Au (5 nm)/ITO/glass and TiO
2/Au (10 nm)/ITO/glass photoelectrodes are shown in
Figure 11a,b.
The resulting hodographs can be approximated by an equivalent electrical circuit shown in
Figure 8a; the approximation parameters are given in
Table 6. The R
D parameter shows the resistance in the electrochemical circuit associated with the resistance of the solution itself, the connection of the electrodes to an external circuit, etc. As a rule, this value is no more than ten ohms and weakly depends on the nature of the photoelectrode. The R
W parameter, which reflects the processes occurring on the working electrode, increases with increasing thickness of the titanium dioxide layer on the substrate. In the case of the R
K parameter, which reflects the processes occurring on the counter electrode, the same patterns are observed.
Impedance data were also plotted in Bode coordinates (
Figure 11c and 11d). It should be noted that for all samples except 2-1 and 3-1, two peaks are observed in the Bode curves, indicating the presence of two types of charge carriers with different electrochemical activities. The application of gold nanoparticles has a significant effect on the electrochemical characteristics of the system. From these Bode plots, the lifetimes of each type of charge carrier were calculated and shown in
Table 7.
From the approximation of the linear portion of the obtained dependences, the concentrations of charge carriers multiplied by the dielectric constant of the semiconductor were calculated (see
Table 7). From the data presented in
Table 7, it is clear that in the case of the presence of both electrons and holes in the samples, the electron concentration is higher, and higher values of electron concentration correspond to samples with higher short-circuit densities. For samples with hole conductivity, no clearly formulated patterns are observed.