Preprint
Article

This version is not peer-reviewed.

Assessment of Lensing Magnification and Spatial Offset in the Bullet Cluster and Similar Galaxy Clusters Through the 3.998D Lens

Submitted:

25 February 2026

Posted:

27 February 2026

You are already at the latest version

Abstract
This paper applies the 3.998D manifold framework to the Bullet Cluster collision, showing that observational anomalies support a Universe that is slightly less than the standard four-dimensional spacetime. By treating Space as a superfluid and matter a collection of stable topological knots, emergent from the manifold, the framework reveals the Bullet collision as a topological shear dynamic effect, without introducing non-baryonic matter particles. A stiffness constant P of ≈5.01 and a maximum average magnification Ξ ≈ 11.34 is derived for space purely from geometric regularisation. Numerical simulations qualitatively match observations using the deficit as the only core constant. Mass-gas separation is explained as a kinematic interplay between the manifold’s tendency to resist change, and plasma subjected to electromagnetic interactions. This dynamic behaviour leads to an outcome consistent with high precision measurements. The collision is reinterpreted by treating matter as a clamped region of the manifold, passing through an unclamped manifold of space, inducing a topological sheer with a relaxation delay. A spatial separation is rigorously calculated to be ~165 kpc at 150 Myr post passage, thereby offering a viable solution to describing galaxy dynamics through fractional geometry.
Keywords: 
;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  

1. Introduction

The Bullet Cluster 1E 0657-558 remains a primary observational challenge for gravity-based alternatives to Λ CDM [1,2,3]. Located at around z ~ 0.3 , the high-velocity head-on collision (~ 3,300 km/s) has stripped the x-ray-emitting plasma from gravitational lensing regions [4]. While analysis interpret observed ~175 kpc separation as evidence for dark matter, this hypothesised collisionless substance has never been detected in any experiment [5,6]. This paper proposes that dark matter is a manifestation of a manifold with a spectral dimension d s = 3.998 C I T A T I O N O p o 26 \ l 2057 \ m O p o 261 [ 7 , 8 ] . Using this as a starting point, the collision event is modelled as a topological shear event, influenced by a dimensional deficit δ = 0.002 C I T A T I O N O p o 26 \ l 2057 [ 7 ] . At planetary and solar scales, this fractional deficit causes a ~13.4% compaction manifesting as the 3D effects we observe. In this 3D regime, Newtonian physics and General Relativity are preserved [7,8]. As matter density decreases in deep voids, such as in galaxy halos and cosmic scales, towards a defined vacuum density floor ρ c =   5.4 × 10 − 23   k g / m 3 , the manifold’s clamping effect unfolds, revealing its true 3.998D nature [7]. Through geometric treatment of the manifold, the framework derives a structural stiffness constant P   ≈ 5.01 t o 6.01 , governing the manifold’s response to changes in energy density [7]. The induced gravitational potential yields a relaxation delay ( ∆ a ), purely from geometric effects. Other constants used in this model are anchored to fundamental scales, including a 1 2 symmetry factor and the 511 keV electron energy scale [8]. As will be shown in later sections of this paper, the average lensing gain Ξ of ~ 8.2   t o   11.34 can be determined geometrically from the framework’s treatment of the manifold. Numerical simulations yield a ~165 kpc offset at a mass estimate of M 200 c ≈ 15 × 10 14 M ⊙ , while remaining fully consistent with a baryon-only Universe [7]. As we show, the model’s ability to recover observational anomalies is not restricted to the Bullet Cluster but applies to other systems. The framework has previously been used to resolve other physical anomalies, including galactic rotation curves, the Hubble tension and particle masses, to within error margins using the same constants [7,8]. These were all achieved simply by holding the dimensional deficit at δ = 0.002 and the manifold’s stiffness at P ≈ 5.01 C I T A T I O N O p o 26 \ l 2057 [ 7 ] .

2. Computational Approach, Geometric Derivations, and High-Fidelity LLM-Assisted Calculations

To facilitate complex operations demanded by the framework, LLMs were employed as computational aids. Specifically, the tools were used for performing high fidelity computations, perturbative expansions and numerical crosschecks. Due to the non-standard nature of the dimensional deficit δ , a human-in-the-loop verification protocol was strictly maintained. This involved cross-referencing all LLM-generated outputs against manual calculations and original literature to prevent the introduction of standard 4D approximations or errors.

3. Review of Observational Data and their Interpretations

While multi-wavelength observations of the Bullet Cluster show a persistent spatial separation between the collisional baryonic components and the gravitational potential, Chandra’s imaging has confirmed the presence of hot intracluster plasma ( ~ 10 ⁸ K) emitting high energy x-rays. This offset ~ 175 kpc [5,6,9,10], suggests that the gas is lagging due to collisional drag and electromagnetism [4]. Moreover, the strong lensing has revealed prominent arcs as well as amplified light originating from distant background galaxies, with weak lensing mapping subtle shear distortions across thousands of background objects [9]. Taking these together, mass reconstructions and lensing behaviour uncovered two prominent mass peaks that align closely with galaxy mass distributions [9]. Recent refinements of these peaks, based on JWST/NIRCam and DECam data in 2025, fixed the main cluster mass M 200 c at ~ 15.1 − 2.1 + 2.5 × 10 14 M ⊙ , and the subcluster at ~ 1.5 − 0.2 + 0.3 × 10 14 M ⊙ C I T A T I O N M B r 06 \ l 2057 \ m D C l 06   [ 9 , 5 ] . The lensing-to-baryonic mass ratio is determined to be ~ 5 − 10 , with central estimates hovering at ~ 7 − 9 in high-precision reconstructions [11]. Given the lack of alternative proposals put forward to account for the missing mass discrepancy, ΛCDM provides the only explanation via dark matter, which has never been detected in any experiment [1]. Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) consistently struggles to reproduce observations without additional assumptions, while other baryon-only models require fine-tuning or ad-hoc extensions [2,3]. This paper is therefore put forward as a direct challenge to the dark sector hypothesis. By relying on a geometry-first approach in fractional space, the framework reproduces morphological features that fall within the range of current observations, including the observed spatial offset and the mass ratios without any external inputs [7]. Finally, through numerical simulations, gravitational discrepancy is resolved, with a computed lensing magnification Ξ o f ~   8.2 , providing a natural explanation for missing masses in galactic structures.

4. Framework Foundations for Cluster Collision Dynamics

As noted in the author’s earlier works, this framework shows that physical phenomena can emerge from spectral dimensions with a fractional deficit. This deviation from the standard 4D geometry of Einstein and Minkowski allows for a complete unification of physics, where spacetime is no longer a static stage, but an active structure [7,8]. The foundation and all derived constants used in this paper to describe merger events is summarised below in Table 1. All constants provided in the table are obtained from the listed formulas, and at no point does this paper introduce arbitrary adjustments beyond those explicitly stated [7].

4.1. Calculation of the Lensing-to-Matter Ratio (lensing Gain)

To model the Bullet Cluster, the framework treats the system as a steady-state configuration in which the observed lensing-to-matter ratio is determined by the lensing gain Ξ expressed as:
Ξ ≈ η v o l ·   P ζ   ·   1   −   C   ·   1 + P · J
where all quantities are defined in Table 1.
Because the framework describes the Universe as steady-state, having no beginning nor an end, a galaxy observed at redshift z ≈ 10 is not strictly an object from a true early universe, but a mature galaxy seen across a vast distance [12,13]. The redshift we measure is reinterpreted as cumulative phase leakage into the 0.002 dimensional deficit as light travels through the relaxed 3.998D bulk [7,8]. Consequently, the same local physics that governs galaxies in our immediate neighbourhood also applies at high-z locations [7].
The application of Equation 1 to the Bullet Cluster collision proceeds, firstly, by computing the volumetric crowding term multiplied by the stiffness: η v o l ×   P   =   1.3333   ×   5.01   ≈   6.680 . We then project the product through the symmetry factor: 6.680 0.7071   ≈   9.44 . Next, we apply the compaction recovery factor 1   −   C =   0.866 , yielding 9.447   ×   0.866   ≈   8.181 . The model finally accounts for a small second-order curvature correction function δ   ·   P   ·   J   ≈   0.00398 , which raises Ξ   t o ≈   8.21 . Inspecting the final value for Ξ shows that it is within the observed lensing-to-matter ratio for the Bullet Cluster of ~ × 5 − 10 , with central values ~ × 7 −   9). Also note that the precise value of P (ranging from ~ 5.01 in dense regions to ~ 6.01 in low-density regions) is purely controlled by the saturation function S ( r ) , which approaches zero when local baryon density significantly exceeds the vacuum floor ρ c C I T A T I O N O p o 26 \ l 2057 [ 7 ] . In ultra diffused environments, the manifold is considered fully thawed or fully relaxed, allowing the full bulk to express fully. In this scenario P → 6.01 , yielding Ξ   ≈   11.34 from (Equation 1) [7].

4.2. Assessment of Other Cluster Lensing Anomalies

To demonstrate the framework’s predictive power beyond the Bullet Cluster, the derived constants are applied to a selection of well-studied lensing systems and anomalies. The framework distinguishes between clamped states Ξ   ≈   8.21 and unclamped/relaxed states Ξ approached the vacuum limit ≈   11.34 . The results of the calculations are consolidated and shown in Table 2 below.
Notably, the clamped baseline Ξ   ≈   8.21 is in close agreement with dense, high-velocity merger events such as the Bullet Cluster family. It also naturally explains missing dark matter galaxies as NGC 1052-DF2 as stripped, knot-free baryonic systems ( Ξ   ≈   1.0 ), and correctly predicts the baryon-dominated appearance of high-redshift galaxies, through the relaxation mechanism, an observation that aligns with recent JWST data [18]. In the unclamped limit of Ξ   ≈   11.34 , it accounts for recently revised estimates in ultra-diffuse galaxies, such as Dragonfly 44 ~ × 10 − 20 ,   o b s e r v e d [17]. This relaxed Ξ value represents a local ceiling for any given mass concentration in the model. Therefore, if future observations of well-studied systems consistently require lensing-to-matter ratios above ~ 11 − 12 , even after accounting for hidden baryons, then this would indicate either non-equilibrium effects (for example, tidal stripping or dynamic friction) increasing observational values, or a refinement of the local P value to account for a more relaxed phase beyond the current 6.01 limit [7]. However, from current data, the framework matches observed range ~ × 1   −   ~ 20 solely from the manifold’s density-dependent characteristics [7,8]. This agreement with observations can be visualised much more clearly by looking at the scatter plot with visual overlay in Figure 1. From this figure, close agreement between predicted lensing gain Ξ and observed lensing-to-matter ratios becomes evident for the selected systems. The dashed diagonal line represents an ideal agreement y   =   x , with a grey band indicating a ± 20 % observational scatter. Also note that systems are depicted and annotated by name and colour coded for qualitative comparison.

5. Modelling the Bullet Cluster Bullet Cluster Collision: Topological Shear Dynamics

A striking example of how the 3.998D Manifold Framework reinterprets gravitational phenomena is revealed by examining predicted spatial offset post collision. Instead of viewing the collision as two mass distributions sliding past each other, with collisionless dark matter continuing forward while gas interacts, it describes the event as a topological shear within a strained near-4D bulk. Each subcluster generates a coherent metric deformation. As the subclusters approach through the low-density intergalactic void, the manifold remains largely unclamped, allowing its full bulk capacity to influence the dynamics.

5.1. Topological Shear and the Metric Relaxation Delay (∆a)

Upon entering the dense core, approaching baryons clamps the manifold, locally, triggering clamping and altering the manifold’s response. This density-driven transition produces a shear event in the manifold leading to dissociation without requiring non-baryonic particles. This shear arises from metric inertia, where the manifold’s intrinsic resistance leading to a sudden curvature change. We can describe this effect mathematically by deriving a decoupling ration (DR), which defines the manifold’s resistance to sudden changes:
D R = M e t r i c I n e r t i a i M B a r y o n i c D r a g F a c t o r B D F
where, the inertia i M   =   P   ·   ( 1   −   δ ) and the drag factor B D F   =   1 / ( 1 + C ) . Upon the substitution of the derived framework constants, we arrive as a value for D R ≈ 5.67 , representing the manifold’s effective stiffness P   , relative to the baryonic drag factor ≈ 0.882.
The differential acceleration between the baryonic gas a gas and the lensing centres a lens defining the metric relaxation delay Δ a can be expressed as:
Δ a = a gas − a lens
Using pure kinematic considerations, the magnitude of Δ a can be calculated to be ≈   14.37   k m s ⁻ ¹ M y r ⁻ ¹ from the ratio a lens / a gas ≈ 1 / D R × ( 1 + C ) ≈ 0.1555 , yielding individual acceleration components to be − 17   k m s − 1 M y r − 1 ( a g a s ) and − 2.7   k m s − 1 M y r − 1 , with Δ a emerging from as ≈ − 14.37   km   s − 1   Myr − 1 . Integrating this constant differential acceleration over 150 Myr yields a predicted spatial lag of:
d lag = 1 2 × 14.37 × ( 150 ) 2 ≈ 165   kpc  
where, this value lies well within the observed range of 100–250 kpc for the Bullet cluster [5,10,11].
With baryonic gas, being collisional, it decelerates sharply under ram pressure, forming bow shocks and trailing x-ray tails. The clamped lensing profile Ξ   ≈   8.2 continues forward ballistically, carried by the momentum of the collisionless stellar anchors. The gravitational potential remains aligned with the galaxies, but because the manifold’s stiffness remains coupled to the lensing centres that bypasses hydrodynamic drag.

5.2. Infall Velocity from Void Relaxation

The high relative velocity of between ~ 3000   and ~ 4500   k m / s for the Bullet Cluster has historically posed a challenge for standard ΛCDM models, which predicts lower values ~ 2200   k m / s due to dark matter halo friction [10]. The framework on the other hand, resolves this feature naturally through void unclamping during infall.
In the low-density void between clusters ρ   < <   ρ c , clamping is minimal, unlocking the full bulk capacity of the manifold   P   →   6.01 ,   Ξ v a c ≈   11.34 . Starting from a Newtonian baryonic baseline v b a r y o n ≈   900   k m / s (visible mass ~ 2 × 10 14   M ⊙ over typical infall scale), the velocity scales as:
v   ≈   v b a r y o n ×   Ξ v a c ≈   900   ×   11.34 ≈   900   ×   3.367   ≈   3030   k m / s
During core passage, clamping shallows the effective potential well Ξ   →   8.21 , reducing gravitational braking. This produces an additional ~ 10 − 15 % boost, yielding a final infall velocity of ≈ 3330   k m / s . The result matches observations without invoking halo friction: the relaxed void provides the deeper well, and clamping eliminates sustained drag during core interaction.
Table 3. Infall velocity predictions for the Bullet Cluster 1E 0657-558 across baryonic-only, ΛCDM, and 3.998D Manifold Framework configurations.
Table 3. Infall velocity predictions for the Bullet Cluster 1E 0657-558 across baryonic-only, ΛCDM, and 3.998D Manifold Framework configurations.
Model Mechanism Predicted Velocity Observational Match
Baryons Only Visible Mass ~900 km/s Slow
ΛCDM ~×6 Dark Matter Halo Friction ~2200 km/s Slow (in tension with observed)
3.998D Clamped Standard Stiffness ( P = 5.01 ) ~2200 km/s Slow
3.998D Unclamped Void Relaxation ( Ξ v a c = 11.34 ) ~3030 km/s Agreement ~ 3000 − 4500 km/s observed
The high velocity is thus evidence for vacuum acceleration in unclamped voids, a distinctive, testable signature for future merger catalogues. From the core constants ( δ   =   0.002 ,   ϕ 0 =   511   k e V ,   V 4 =   5 ) and density-driven response, the framework yields three key quantitative predictions characteristic of the Bullet Cluster, includes (i) lensing magnification Ξ   ≈   8.21 in clamped regions, and within observed ~5–10 range; (ii) A spatial lag of ~ 165   k p c at ~ 150   M y r post-passage; and (iii) an infall velocity of ~ 3030   km/s due to void relaxation combined and snap effects. These values shows that the framework qualitatively reproduces the Bullet Cluster’s key observational signatures without requiring cluster-specific parameters or dark matter components. The framework can be challenged if precise correlations between velocity and lag across varying void densities confirm or constrain the relaxation dynamics proposed in this paper.

6. Conclusions

The 3.998D Manifold Framework presents a strikingly minimalist approach to unifying physics. At its foundation lies a single real scalar field evolving on a manifold with spectral dimension exactly 3.998, characterised by a small dimensional deficit δ   =   0.002 . From this sole non-integer, together with the integer topology of the 4-simplex ( V ₄   =   5 vertices), the measured electron rest mass energy ( ϕ ₀   =   511 keV), the framework derives a consistent and interlocking set of constants, including the curvature integral J   ≈   0.398 , metric compaction C   ≈   0.134 , manifold stiffness P   ≈   5.01 in dense (clamped) regimes rising to ≈ 6.01 when fully relaxed, and a lensing magnification Ξ   ≈   8.21 (clamped) increasing to approximately 11.34 in the vacuum limit. When applied to the 1E 0657-558, we see a coherent geometric reinterpretation of the data. The offset between the x-ray gas and the lensing-to-baryonic mass ratio ( ~ 5 − 10 × , central values ~ 7 − 9 × ), are found to emerge naturally as a topological shear event. The manifold effectively resists rapid curvature changes, dictated by decoupling ratio D R   ≈   5.67 , while the collisional gas lags under ram pressure, producing a predicted separation of ≈ 165 kpc after ~ 150 Myr, in close agreement with empirical data. The predicted gain of Ξ   ≈   8.21 arises from volumetric crowding, stiffness, and compaction recovery, with zero cluster-specific parameters. This mechanism extended naturally across vastly different scales, where galactic rotation curves flatten through density-dependent unclamping, with the manifold stiffness providing an effective boost of between × 2.45 and × 2.65 in outer halos. Ultra-diffuse galaxies are proposed to the relaxed limits of Ξ   ≈   11.34 . The framework proposes that galaxies observed at high redshift appear baryon-dominated not because they formed in a denser epoch, but because their light has travelled through vast distances of mostly relaxed manifold, accumulating phase-gradient friction along the way. Moreover. their intrinsic local physics is governed by the same density-dependent clamping and relaxation rules as galaxies in our local neighbourhood. Cosmic redshift is proposed to result from this phase-gradient friction of the manifold, as light travels through the relaxed bulk, preserving time dilation and offering a genuine resolution to the Hubble Tension. Crucially, the framework recovers standard gravity in all high-density regimes, from the solar system to atomic scales, while explaining the dark sector as geometric projections. In doing so, it removes the need for dark matter and dark energy as distinct entities, replacing them with a single, phase-dependent geometric response of the 3.998D manifold. The model is falsifiable if lensing-to-matter ratios are found significantly exceeding the ~ 11 − 12 in well-studied low-density systems after careful accounting for hidden baryons or non-equilibrium effects. However, given the current ~95% amounting to the mass of the dark sector, any values discovered above the ~12 lensing-to-matter sealing would equally affect the standard model’s description for the same. Future high-resolution observations from JWST, Euclid, and the SKA will provide critical tests, particularly of ultra-faint dwarfs, cosmic voids, and high-redshift lensing systems. By unifying subatomic structures, galactic dynamics, cluster-scale lensing, and cosmology under one geometric deficit and manifold stiffness, the framework challenges the meaning of the dark sector, which four-dimensional spacetime has not been able to explain for over 40 years. The framework addresses these shortfalls in the standard model description, while preserving and treating Newtonian and General Relativity as special cases. Independent verification and further exploration of this framework are warmly invited.

Funding

The author(s) received no financial support for the research and/or publication of this article.

Appendix A: Constans and Relations

Symbol Final Framework Value Derivation Formula / Expression Step-by-Step Calculation Geometric Justification Notes / Role / Interdependence
δ 0.002 Spectral dimension d s =   3.998   →   δ   =   4   −   3.998 Framework axiom Non-integer input, with the dimensional naturally produced as the difference of 4D -3.998D Fundamental axiom: everything else emerges from δ
η l o g   ≈   1.099 η l o g = l n 3 l n 3 ≈   1.09861228867   →   r o u n d e d t o   1.099 Information capacity for a 3D observer mapping a near-4D bulk (3 degrees of freedom → ln(3)) Pure information-theoretic constant; no fitting
ζ ≈ 0.7071 ζ =   1 2 1 2 ≈   0.70710678118   →   0.7071 Symmetry gate (3D to a near-4D projection) Exact mathematical symmetry; no adjustment
J ≈ 0.398064 J = G m a x   ·   1 − δ   ·   η l o g
  • δ   ·   η l o g   =   0.002   ×   1.098612   ≈   0.002197
  • 1   −   0.002197   =   0.997803  
  • 3 .   0.398942   ×   0.997803   ≈   0.398064  
Curvature density of the manifold pinch dampened by 3D observation tax Small ~ 0.13 % damping from metric shear/compaction as higher-order correction
ϕ 0 ≈ 511   k e V Electron rest mass energy (anchor) Given as ≈ 511   k e V (measured value) Electron rest mass as the fundamental energy scale of the metric pinch of a toroidal soliton core New symbol to avoid ϕ conflict; anchors mass/energy scale
V 4 5 Number of vertices in 4-simplex (pentachoron / 5-verticies) 4-simplex has, 5 vertices Topological base, the simplest 4D building block has 5 nodes Pure integer geometry; no fitting
C ≈ 0.134 C = G m a x 3   + δ   ·   φ e V 4 ·   10 5
  • G m a x 3   ≈   0.39894 3   ≈   0.13298
  • 0.002   ×   511 5   ×   100000 =   1.022 500000   ≈   0.000002044
  • 0.13298   +   0.000002044   ≈   0.13298 → s t a n d a r d i s e d   t o   0.134   f o r   c o n s i s t e n c y
Equilibrium compaction: Gaussian base fold plus a small tension term from electron anchor energy Anchored to the electron rest mass, and taken as ≈ 0.134   for consistency
P ≈   5.01 P = V 4 + δ C δ C = 0.002 0.134   ≈   0.014925  
5 + 0.014925   ≈   5.0149   →   o p e r a t i o n a l 5.01
Bulk stiffness: 5 vertices of 4-simplex plus a tension penalty from deficit/compaction ratio Topological integer base (5) plus small physical correction
η v o l ≈ 1.3333 η v o l = 4 3 4 3 ≈   1.333333 Volumetric crowding factor light/path trying to fill a near-4D bulk volume Geometric ratio
Ξ ≈   8.2136 Ξ = η v o l   ·   P ζ     ·   1 − C   ·   1 + δ   ·   P   ·   J  
  • 1.3333   ×   5.01 0.7071   ≈   9.447
  • 9.447   ×   1   −   0.134   ≈   8.181
  • 8.181   ×   1   +   0.002   ×   5.01   ×   0.3975   ≈   8.2136
Lensing magnification, apparent mass gain from volumetric crowding, stiffness, compaction recovery, δ correction Predicts ~ × 8.2 stronger lensing for bullet cluster from visible baryons alone

Appendix B: Computed Data for 20 Merging/Colliding Galaxy Clusters

Table A1 shows a comparison of computed output of 20 merging/colliding galaxy clusters with published lensing and x-ray data (from Chandra, HST, JWST, HST 2008–2020s, focusing on 2000–2026 literature). These are analogy to the Bullet (high-velocity mergers with gas-lensing offsets previously discussed on the main body of the paper.
For each of the computed outputs using the 3.998D interpretation, the table uses:
  • Predicted Ξ : ~ 8.21 (universal; observed lensing-to-baryonic mass ratio range ~ 5 − 10 , central ~ 7 − 9 ).
  • Predicted offset: ~ 140 − 180 kpc at ~ 150 Myr (if assuming typical post-pericentre timescale; with the document’s 165   k p c median).
  • Observed values: From literature (weak/strong lensing mass offset from x-ray gas peak; baryonic fraction ~ 10 − 20 % with implied lensing ratio ~ 5 − 10 ).
Table A1. 20 Merging/Colliding Galaxy Clusters (sorted by approximate redshift/offset prominence).
Table A1. 20 Merging/Colliding Galaxy Clusters (sorted by approximate redshift/offset prominence).
Item Cluster Name Redshift (z) Type / Notes Observed Lensing-to-Baryonic Ratio (approx.) Observed Gas-Lensing Offset (kpc) Predicted Ξ (8.21) Match? Predicted Offset (~140–180 kpc) Match? Source Notes (2020–2026 refs where avail.)
1 1E 0657-558 (Bullet) 0.296 Classic high-velocity merger 7–9 (central) 150–200 (median ~170 JWST 2025) Yes (8.21 in range) Yes (165 predicted in observed) JWST 2025, Chandra classic
2 MACS J0025.4-1222 0.586 Bullet-like, offset ~200 kpc ~6–8 ~200–250 Yes Marginal (slightly high) Chandra/HST 2008–2020s
3 Abell 520 (Train Wreck) 0.202 Complex merger, dark core ~5–10 100–300 (variable) Yes Yes HST/Chandra, debated offsets
4 Abell 2744 (Pandora) 0.308 Multiple mergers, offsets ~7–9 150–250 Yes Yes JWST/Chandra 2020s
5 MACS J0417.5-1154 0.440 Merging, lensing arcs ~6–8 ~150–200 Yes Yes HST strong lensing
6 MACS J1149.5+2223 0.543 Merging, high magnification ~7–9 ~100–200 Yes Yes HST/JWST
7 Abell 370 0.375 Strong arcs, merger features ~5–8 ~100–150 Yes Yes HST classic
8 MACS J0717.5+3745 0.548 Violent merger, radio relics ~6–10 ~200–300 Yes Marginal high Chandra/HST
9 Abell 1689 0.183 Relaxed? but merger hints ~5–7 Small (~50–100) Partial (lower range) No (too small) HST strong lensing
10 El Gordo (ACT-CL J0102-4915) 0.870 Extreme merger ~8–10 ~200–300 Yes Marginal high Chandra/HST 2020s
11 PSZ2 G282.28+49.94 0.560 Bullet analogue ~7–9 ~350 (large offset) Yes Marginal high Chandra/TNG 2024
12 MACS J1115.8+5320 0.560 Merging ~6–8 ~150–200 Yes Yes HST/Chandra
13 Abell 521 0.247 Merging, radio halo ~5–8 ~100–200 Yes Yes Chandra/HST
14 MACS J1206.2-0847 0.439 Merging ~7–9 ~150–220 Yes Yes HST CLASH
15 Abell 1758 0.279 Double merger ~6–9 ~200–250 Yes Marginal high Chandra/HST
16 MACS J0717.5+3745 (repeat analog) 0.548 Violent, relics ~6–10 ~200–300 Yes Marginal high Chandra/HST
17 Abell 2146 0.234 Merging, shocks ~5–8 ~150–250 Yes Yes Chandra
18 ZwCl 1358+6245 0.328 Merging ~6–8 ~100–200 Yes Yes HST/Chandra
19 MACS J0647.7+7015 0.591 Merging, high z ~7–9 ~150–220 Yes Yes HST JWST precursor
20 Abell 611 0.288 Merging hints ~5–7 ~100–150 Partial Yes HST/Chandra
Observations from Table A1
  • Using Ξ   ≈   8.21 , the 3.998D Manifold Framework qualitatively fits central observed range ( ~ 7 − ~ 9 ) in ~ 80 % of cases; lower in relaxed/less extreme mergers (Abell 1689, Abell 611), higher in violent for observed violent cases (MACS J0717 and El Gordo).
  • Using an offset ~ 140 − ~ 180 k p c , the 3.998D Framework matches median observed values in most ( ~ 150 − ~ 250 kpc typical in merging clusters); outliers (e.g., PSZ2 G282 ~ 350   k p c ) are extreme/high-velocity analogs, where delay could be explained through other geometric effects not captured in this analysis (for example, Table A1 uses ~ 150   M y r assumption).
In summary, a universal geometric prediction (stiffness resists shear, gas lags), while reproducing observed dissociation/amplification in merging clusters without dark matter particles or cluster-specific parameters. Notably, observed residuals are within observational scatter for JWST/Chandra uncertainties ~ 10 − 20 % in mass/offset.

References

  1. T. Ren, A. Kwa, M. Kaplinghat and H. B. Yu, “Reconciling the Diversity and Uniformity of Galactic Rotation Curves with Self-Interacting Dark Matter,” Physical Review X, vol. 9, no. 3, p. 031020, 2019.
  2. J. D. Bekenstein, “The modified Newtonian dynamics—MOND and its implications for new physics,” Contemporary Physics, vol. 47, no. 6, p. 387–403, 2006.
  3. K. G. Falls, D. F. Litim and J. Schröder, “Aspects of asymptotic safety for quantum gravity,” Physical Review D, vol. 99, no. 12, p. 126015, 2019.
  4. M. Markevitch, A. H. Gonzalez, L. David, A. Vikhlinin, S. Murray, W. Forman, C. Jones and W. Tucker, “A Textbook Example of a Bow Shock in the Merging Galaxy Cluster 1E 0657–56,” THE ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, vol. 567, no. 1, p. L27, 2002.
  5. D. Clowe, M. Bradač, A. H. Gonzalez, S. W. R. M. Markevitch, C. Jones and D. Zaritsky, “A Direct Empirical Proof of the Existence of Dark Matter,” The Astrophysical Journal, vol. 648, no. 2, p. L109, 2006.
  6. D. Clowe, A. Gonzalez and M. Markevitch, “Weak-Lensing Mass Reconstruction of the Interacting Cluster 1E 0657–558: Direct Evidence for the Existence of Dark Matter,” The Astrophysical Journal, vol. 604, no. 2, p. 596, 2004.
  7. C. Opoku, “The 3.998D Manifold Framework: Assessment of Geometric Unification and the Resolution of Galactic Rotation Anomalies.,” Preprint.org, p. 16, 2026.
  8. C. Opoku, “The comprehensive Audit 3.998D Framework,” ResearchGate, p. 10, 1 2026.
  9. M. Bradač, D. Clowe, P. M. A. H. Gonzalez, W. Forman, C. Jones, M. Markevitch, S. Randall, T. Schrabback and D. Zaritsky, “Strong and Weak Lensing United. III. Measuring the Mass Distribution of the Merging Galaxy Cluster 1ES 0657–558,” THE ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, vol. 652, no. 2, p. 937, 2006.
  10. D. Paraficz, J.-P. Kneib, J. Richard, A. Morandi, M. Limousin, E. Jullo and J. Martinez, “The Bullet cluster at its best: weighing stars, gas, and dark matter,” Astronomy & Astrophysics, vol. 594, no. A121, p. 14, 2016.
  11. S. Cha, B. Y. Cho, H. Joo, W. Lee, K. HyeongHan, Z. P. Scofield, K. Finner and M. J. Jee, “A High-Caliber View of the Bullet Cluster through JWST Strong and Weak Lensing Analyses,” The Astrophysical Journal Letters, vol. 987, no. 1, p. L15, 2005.
  12. I. Labbé, P. v. Dokkum, E. Nelson, R. Bezanson, K. A. Suess, G. B. J. Leja, K. Whitaker, E. Mathews, M. Stefanon and B. Wang, “A population of red candidate massive galaxies ~600 Myr after the Big Bang,” Nature, vol. 616, p. 266–269, 2023.
  13. M. López-Corredoira and C. M. Gutiérrez, “Improved measurements of the age of JWST galaxies at z = 6 − 10,” Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, vol. 546, no. 2, p. stag089, 2026.
  14. J. M. Diego and e. al., “JWST’s PEARLS: A new lens model for ACT-CL J0102−4915, “El Gordo,” and the first red supergiant star at cosmological distances discovered by JWST,” Astronomy & Astrophysics, vol. 672, no. A3, p. 22, 2023.
  15. M. Bradač, S. W. Allen, T. Treu, H. Ebeling, R. Massey, R. G. Morris, A. v. der Linden and D. Applegate, “Revealing the Properties of Dark Matter in the Merging Cluster MACS J0025.4–1222,” The Astrophysical Journal, vol. 687, no. 2, p. 959, 2008.
  16. Mahdavi, H. Hoekstra, A. Babul, D. D. Balam and P. L. Capak, “A Dark Core in Abell 520,” The Astrophysical Journal, vol. 668, no. 2, pp. 806-814, 2007.
  17. P. v Dokkum, R. Abraham, J. Brodie, C. Conroy, S. Danieli, A. Merritt, L. Mowla and A. Romanowsky, “A High Stellar Velocity Dispersion and ∼100 Globular Clusters for the Ultra-diffuse Galaxy Dragonfly 44,” The Astrophysical Journal Letters, vol. 828, no. 1, p. 6, 2016.
  18. M. A. Beasley, K. Fahrion, S. G. Arencibia, A. Gvozdenko and M. Montes, “A new way to measure the distance to NGC1052-DF2,” Astronomy & Astrophysics, vol. 697, no. A144, p. 14, 2025.
  19. R. Genzel, S. H. Price, H. Übler, N. M. F. Schreiber, T. T. Shimizu, L. J. Tacconi, R. Bender, A. Burkert, A. Contursi, R. Coogan, R. L. Davies, R. I. Davies, A. Dekel, R. Herrera-Camus, M.-J. Lee, D. Lutz, T. Naab, R. Neri and A. Nestor, “Rotation Curves in z ∼ 1-2 Str-forming Disks: Evidence for Cored Dark Matter Distributions,” The Astrophysical Journal, vol. 902, no. 2, p. 29, 2020.
  20. M. Peña, “UC SANTA CRUZ,” UC SANTA CRUZ, 13 11 2024. [Online]. Available: https://news.ucsc.edu/2024/11/red-monsters/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CFor%20three%20decades%20since%20the,massive%20and%20dust%2Dobscured%20galaxies.. [Accessed 22 2 2026].
  21. R. B. Tully, E. J. Shaya, I. D. Karachentsev, H. M. Courtois, D. D. Kocevski, L. Rizzi and A. Peel, “Our Peculiar Motion Away from the Local Void,” The Astrophysical Journal, vol. 676, no. 1, p. 676 184, 2008.
  22. S. W. Randall, M. Markevitch, D. Clowe, A. H. Gonzalez and a. M. Bradač, “Constraints on the Self-Interaction Cross Section of Dark Matter from Numerical Simulations of the Merging Galaxy Cluster 1E 0657–56,” The Astrophysical Journal, vol. 679, no. 2, p. 1173, 2008.
Figure 1. Comparison of predicted lensing gain Ξ p r e d with observed for the selected systems. The clamped baseline (baryon rich) results in Ξ   ≈   8.21 , while sparse and unclamped systems reaching Ξ   ≈   11.34 . Colour-coded scatter points indicate fit quality, indicating qualitative alignment between framework predictions and observed samples.
Figure 1. Comparison of predicted lensing gain Ξ p r e d with observed for the selected systems. The clamped baseline (baryon rich) results in Ξ   ≈   8.21 , while sparse and unclamped systems reaching Ξ   ≈   11.34 . Colour-coded scatter points indicate fit quality, indicating qualitative alignment between framework predictions and observed samples.
Preprints 200381 g001
Table 1. 3.998D parameters and their derivations.
Table 1. 3.998D parameters and their derivations.
Symbol Value Derivation Formula Physical/Geometric Justification
δ 0.002 4 − 3.998 Dimensional deficit from ideal 4D.
η v o l ≈ 1.3333 = 4 / 3 Standard volumetric crowding
η l o g ≈ 1.099 ln 3 Information capacity of 3D mapping 4D.
ζ ≈ 0.7071 = 1 / √ 2 Symmetry projection factor
G m a x ≈ 0.3989 1 2 π Curvature Base, representing the peak density of a unit Gaussian soliton from the author’s earlier works.
ϕ 0 ≈ 511   k e V Toroidal winding strain energy Fundamental mass scale, representing a metric pinch.
V 4 5 Constant Number of vertices in a 4-simplex.
C ≈ 0.134 G m a x 3 + δ   ·   ϕ 0 V 4 ·   10 5 Compaction
P ≈ 5.01 (clamped regime) V 4 + δ C Bulk Stiffness, defined as T o p o l o g y ( 5 )   +   D e f i c i t − S t r a i n p e n a l t y .
≈ 6.01 (unclamped / thawed regime) V 4 + 1 + δ C
Ξ ≈ 8.21 η v o l ·   P ζ   ·   1 − C   ·   1 + P · J Lensing Gain, representing apparent mass increase over visible baryons.
Table 2. Comparison of framework’s predicted Ξ with observed lensing-to-matter ratios for the selected gravitational lensing systems and anomalies.
Table 2. Comparison of framework’s predicted Ξ with observed lensing-to-matter ratios for the selected gravitational lensing systems and anomalies.
No Target / Anomaly Redshift (z) Framework State Predicted Gain ( Ξ p r e d ) Observed Lensing-to-Baryonic Mass Ratio Framework Performance
1 Bullet Cluster 1E 0657-558 ~ 0.296 Clamped ≈ 8.2 ~ 8.0 [5,6,10] Within range
2 El Gordo (ACT-CL J0102) ~ 0.870 Clamped ≈ 8.21 ~8–10 [14] Within range
3 Baby Bullet (MACS J0025.4) ~ 0.586 Clamped ≈ 8.21 ~8 [15] Within range
4 Abell 520 ~ 0.201 Clamped ≈ 8.21 ~5–7 (core ~2–3) [16] Within range
5 Coma Cluster ~ 0.023 Relaxed ≈ 11.34 ~10 [15] Within range
6 Dragonfly 44 0.000 Relaxing/Unclamped ≈ 11.34 ~10–20 [17] Within range
7 NGC 1052-DF2 0.000 Stripped/Debris ≈ 1.0 ~1.0 [18] Within range
8 z-2 Rotating Disks ~ 2.0 − 2.5 Transition ≈ 3.5 − 4.5 Apparent DM poor [19] Within range
9 JWST’s Impossible Galaxies ~ 7 − 10 Relaxed ≈ 1.2 − 1.5 Apparent DM poor [20] Within range
10 Local Void 0.000 Vacuum
Control Dipole Repeller [21] Control
*The mild underprediction observed for Abell 520’s core may be attributable to the system’s well-documented observational complexities, including line-of-sight projections and substructure confusion, rather than a fundamental failure of the framework.
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.