Background and Clinical Significance: Plexiform fibromyxoma (PFM) is a rare benign gastric mesenchymal neoplasm characterized by multinodular plexiform growth of bland spindle cells in a myxoid or fibromyxoid stroma. We report a case of the cellular form of PFM with limited myxoid stroma and aberrant KIT expression, resulting in diagnostic difficulty by biopsy. Case presentation: A 59-year-old woman presented with a slowly enlarging 15-mm gastric antral submucosal tumor. A resected specimen by laparoscopic and endoscopic cooperative surgery revealed spindle cell proliferation forming plexiform nodules with a myxoid background in limited areas. Positive immunoreactivity of a subset of spindle cells for KIT suggested a diagnosis of gastrointestinal stromal tumor (GIST), although DOG1 was negative. In addition, diffuse staining for CD10, smooth muscle actin, and D2-40 were confusing. MALAT1::GLI1 fusion was detected by next-generation sequencing analysis. Consequently, a diagnosis of PFM was established. Conclusions: This case expands the morphologic and immunophenotypic spectrum of PFM and indicates the possible diagnostic utility and biological significance of D2-40 expression. Although molecular confirmation of MALAT1::GLI1 fusion is definitive for diagnosis of PFM, the findings of present case may aid diagnosis in challenging cases that mimic GIST.