4. Discussion
Cataract surgery performed using the Eight-chop technique demonstrated a characteristic postoperative inflammatory profile and exceptionally small corneal endothelial cell loss in this prospective observational study. The present findings provide comprehensive insight into the intraocular response after Eight-chop phacoemulsification and clarify the relationships among postoperative aqueous flare, intraoperative surgical parameters, and corneal endothelial preservation. To our knowledge, this is the first study to evaluate early flare, CECD, morphological corneal endothelial parameters, and IOP changes simultaneously using a unified surgical technique, with all operations performed by a single surgeon experienced in the Eight-chop method. This study provides important evidence regarding the low-invasive nature of this technique and its potential to minimize intraoperative and postoperative ocular tissue stress.
Early postoperative flare is widely recognized as an indicator of acute inflammatory response following phacoemulsification [
27,
28]. Previous studies consistently reported Day 1 flare values between approximately 27 and 31 photon counts/ms, including classical parameters such as 30.6 ± 15.7 and 27.8 ± 4.4 photon counts/ms, depending on surgical technique and patient-specific variables [
27,
28]. These values have been regarded as the typical magnitude of postoperative breakdown of the blood–aqueous barrier in conventional ultrasound-dependent phacoemulsification. In contrast, the present study observed a substantially lower Day 1 flare level of 15.1 photon counts/ms, far below the previously established ranges. This clearly indicates that the Eight-chop technique attenuates the inflammatory response in the immediate postoperative period. Although flare increased on postoperative Day 1 and Day 7 as expected after cataract extraction, the magnitude of elevation was modest and diminished rapidly by Week 7, with continued improvement through Week 19. This clinical pattern suggests that the Eight-chop technique minimizes mechanical contact, fluid turbulence, and ultrasound exposure within the anterior chamber.
In evaluating the mechanistic foundation of this minimal flare response, the principled characteristics of the Eight-chop technique must be considered. In conventional phaco-chop or divide-and-conquer techniques, ultrasound energy is applied from the very beginning of nuclear division. In contrast, the Eight-chop technique performs complete mechanical fragmentation of the nucleus before phacoemulsification, dividing it into eight small and uniformly shaped segments. This mechanical disassembly markedly reduces the amount of ultrasound energy required during emulsification and greatly improves aspiration efficiency, thereby shortening operative time, aspiration duration, and irrigation fluid usage. Reductions in aspiration time and irrigation volume are particularly important, as fluctuations in inflow and outflow are known to increase shear stress on the corneal endothelium and iris, which can elevate early postoperative flare [
29]. By suppressing these fluidic disturbances, the Eight-chop technique establishes a less invasive intraocular environment and minimizes both mechanical and thermal trauma to uveal tissues [
30].
A central finding of this study was the complete lack of association between Day 1 flare and any intraoperative parameter, including CDE, irrigation fluid volume, operative time, phaco time, aspiration time, or lens hardness. Linear mixed-effects modeling revealed that none of these conventional surgical markers significantly predicted postoperative flare intensity. The regression coefficients were small and nonsignificant across all variables, indicating that postoperative inflammation remained uniformly low regardless of nuclear hardness or intraoperative energy delivery. Moreover, the residual variance in the model was approximately 26.75, substantially exceeding the random-effect variance attributed to patient-specific factors (15.72), suggesting that most of the variation in flare was not explained by intraoperative differences. This pattern strongly supports the conclusion that the Eight-chop technique standardizes the surgical stress applied to intraocular tissues, resulting in consistently low inflammatory responses across cases.
This homogeneity in postoperative flare is highly unusual in phacoemulsification literature. Numerous studies have reported that higher ultrasound energy, longer operative time, or larger fluid volumes are associated with elevated postoperative flare [
31,
32,
33]. For example, prior analyses demonstrated that cataracts requiring prolonged ultrasound exposure generated higher levels of early flare due to increased blood–aqueous barrier breakdown [
34]. However, the present findings suggest that the Eight-chop technique suppresses the pathway through which ultrasonic and fluidic stress translates into inflammatory response. These results align with the mechanistic advantages previously proposed in earlier Eight-chop research, including reduced fragmentation time, minimized turbulence, and rapid aspiration of pre-segmented nuclear fragments. The lack of correlation between Day 1 flare and surgical parameters underscores the consistent, low-trauma performance of the technique, providing important evidence that Eight-chop may represent a less invasive alternative to standard phaco-chop or divide-and-conquer.
The extremely small corneal endothelial cell loss observed in this study further supports the minimally invasive nature of the Eight-chop technique. Mean CECD loss was only 1.38% at Week 7 and 1.46% at Week 19, far lower than previously reported values of 4.4–18.8% following standard phacoemulsification techniques [
35,
36]. These values remained stable over time, indicating that early corneal endothelial cell loss was minimal and did not progress. The magnitude of corneal endothelial preservation observed herein is clinically meaningful, especially in elderly patients or those with borderline corneal endothelial reserves. The linear mixed-effects model identified lens hardness (Emery–Little grade) as the only consistent predictor of corneal endothelial cell loss, in agreement with existing literature that associates nuclear density with greater intraoperative trauma. CDE and fluid volume showed borderline associations with cell loss, reflecting the influence of energy delivery but also the limited magnitude of that effect within the Eight-chop framework.
The lack of association between postoperative flare and corneal endothelial cell loss is notable. In more invasive phacoemulsification approaches, postoperative inflammation has been implicated in corneal endothelial damage through cytokine-mediated mechanisms, including oxidative stress and nitric oxide–related injury [
37]. However, in the present cohort, flare levels were so low and uniform that they failed to predict corneal endothelial decline. This dissociation suggests that corneal endothelial injury during Eight-chop is determined more by direct surgical factors—such as lens hardness and intraoperative ultrasound energy—than by postoperative inflammatory activity. The Eight-chop technique’s minimal ultrasound usage and stable fluidics likely reduce direct shear and mechanical insult, thereby preventing incremental corneal endothelial damage independent of flare activity. This finding has important clinical implications: flare measurement may have limited value in predicting corneal endothelial outcomes when the surgical technique is inherently less invasive.
Corneal morphological indices, including CCT, CV, and PHC, provided further quantitative evidence of corneal endothelial preservation. CCT showed only a small transient increase at Week 7, returning toward baseline at Week 19. Moreover, significant improvements in CV and PHC at Week 19 reflected stabilization and recovery of corneal endothelial cell morphology. These morphological improvements contrast with the patterns seen after more invasive phacoemulsification techniques, where sustained increases in CV and decreases in PHC often reflect ongoing corneal endothelial stress or delayed healing [
38,
39]. The normalization of corneal endothelial morphology in this study reinforces the concept that the Eight-chop technique imposes minimal long-term biomechanical stress.
Visual acuity recovery was rapid, with dramatic improvements in BCVA by Week 7 and further gains at Week 19. This early recovery is consistent with minimal corneal edema, limited tissue trauma, and efficient removal of nuclear fragments without excessive manipulation. Intraocular pressure (IOP) exhibited a significant and sustained postoperative reduction, averaging 12–13% at Week 7 and Week 19. Although cataract surgery is known to lower IOP through enhanced aqueous outflow [
40,
41], the Eight-chop technique may provide an additional advantage by minimizing fluidic stress on the trabecular meshwork and Schlemm’s canal. Linear mixed-effects modeling showed no association between IOP reduction and postoperative flare, confirming that early inflammation does not compromise the outflow pathway in the context of Eight-chop’s low-invasive approach.
The clinical implications of these findings are substantial. Eight-chop appears to offer a highly reproducible surgical method that standardizes intraocular stress, minimizes reliance on ultrasound energy, and reduces postoperative inflammation across a wide range of cataract densities. Surgeons managing patients with fragile corneal endothelium—such as elderly individuals, patients with Fuchs endothelial dystrophy, shallow anterior chambers, or pre-existing borderline cell counts—may benefit from adopting this technique. Given its low fluid requirements and gentle manipulation of nuclear fragments, the Eight-chop technique could serve as a viable alternative to femtosecond laser-assisted cataract surgery [
42,
43], particularly when cost or accessibility is limiting. Furthermore, the minimal corneal endothelial damage associated with Eight-chop may lower the risk of long-term complications such as persistent corneal edema, bullous keratopathy, or delayed corneal endothelial decompensation.
Recent independent literature has also acknowledged the potential advantages of the Eight-chop technique. A 2025 international review on cataract surgery in diabetic eyes cited preliminary clinical studies of the Eight-chop method and described it as a low-invasiveness technique that reduces ultrasound dependence, minimizes fluidic stress, and may help preserve corneal endothelial function in metabolically vulnerable eyes [
44]. These external evaluations are consistent with the mechanistic and clinical findings of the present study and further support the position of Eight-chop as a promising refinement of modern phacoemulsification.
Findings from diabetic microangiopathy research provide a biologically grounded context for interpreting the present results. Our previous work demonstrated that prolonged high-glucose exposure (30 mmol/L) markedly disrupts endothelial homeostasis by downregulating connexin 43, the principal gap-junction protein responsible for intercellular communication in microvascular endothelial cells [
45]. Specifically, high glucose reduced connexin 43 mRNA expression to 68% of control levels and protein expression to 55.6%, accompanied by decreased phosphorylation of all isoforms. Gap-junction intercellular communication was similarly impaired, with scrape-load dye transfer activity falling to approximately 60% of control, and Cx43 plaque formation along cell–cell borders reduced to 63%. These alterations indicate a substantial loss of coordinated endothelial signaling under metabolic stress. Comparable vulnerability has been observed in trabecular meshwork cells, in which high-glucose conditions induce excessive extracellular matrix deposition and significantly increase fibronectin expression, while simultaneously suppressing cell proliferation, thereby weakening aqueous outflow regulation [
46]. Together, these findings illustrate a shared fragility across ocular endothelial and endothelial-like tissues, each exhibiting reduced stress tolerance, impaired cell–cell communication, and susceptibility to extracellular matrix dysregulation under hyperglycemic or inflammatory conditions. In this context, the exceptionally low flare response and minimal corneal endothelial cell loss observed after Eight-chop phacoemulsification suggest that the technique imposes substantially less mechanical, inflammatory, and fluidic stress on ocular tissues. Although our study excluded patients with diabetes, the biological parallels imply that Eight-chop’s efficient nuclear segmentation, reduced ultrasound dependence, and inherent fluidic stability may be especially advantageous for diabetic eyes, where Cx43 downregulation, impaired gap-junction signaling, and extracellular matrix accumulation may otherwise magnify postoperative tissue injury. Future studies including diabetic populations are warranted to determine whether these mechanistic advantages extend to metabolically compromised ocular environments.
This study does have limitations, including the absence of a direct comparison group using phaco-chop, divide-and-conquer, or Phaco Pre-chop techniques. However, extensive prior literature describing typical flare patterns and corneal endothelial outcomes allows the present results to be contextualized appropriately. The observation period was limited to 19 weeks, and longer follow-up would be required to determine whether subtle corneal endothelial changes emerge beyond this timeframe. Additionally, although the linear mixed-effects model accounted for inter-eye correlation, potential confounding factors not captured in the dataset may influence inflammatory or corneal endothelial responses.