Chlorography as a Natural Alternative for Photographic Development in Leaves and Flowers from the Decomposition of Chlorophyll and Natural Pigments

1. Introduction

Chlorography, also known as chlorotyping or phytography, represents a completely natural photographic development process that is carried out directly on the leaves and flowers of various plants. This technique is distinguished by its sustainable and ecological nature, as it exclusively utilizes the internal compounds present in the plant material, without requiring the addition of external chemicals beyond the leaves' own composition [1]. This approach aligns with a growing global awareness and an increased priority placed on sustainability across multiple sectors, including the field of photography. Indeed, there is a growing interest in environmentally friendly practices within art, science, and education. This interest ranges from individual artists and educational programs to community-level initiatives focused on ecological balance.

Photography, in its essence, is both an art and a science, founded upon the ability to capture images through the action of light on sensitive materials. Throughout its history, this discipline has evolved from complex chemical processes that required darkrooms and often toxic substances, to the contemporary digital era. However, in parallel with the main avenues of development, there has always been an interest in exploring alternative and unconventional methods for creating photographic images. These alternative processes encompass a wide range of rediscovered historical techniques and novel approaches that deviate from standard gelatin silver photography or digital printing.

Within alternative processes, a particularly intriguing category is that of natural photography, which employs organic materials, specifically of plant origin, as the photosensitive medium. These methods leverage the inherent properties of plant pigments, which are the natural compounds responsible for color in plants and perform vital functions in light absorption for photosynthesis and photoprotection. The fascination lies in the fact that these same pigments can undergo light-induced chemical changes, thereby laying the foundation for natural photographic image formation.

Two prominent examples of natural photography that utilize the principle of photobleaching of plant pigments are chlorophyll printing (also known as chlorotyping) and anthotypes. Chlorophyll printing is a process in which images are formed directly on live or freshly picked plant leaves, using sunlight to bleach the chlorophyll in the exposed areas [1]. On the other hand, anthotypes employ photosensitive emulsions extracted from various plants, which are applied to paper and exposed to sunlight.

The present report aims to analyze these natural photographic processes in depth, exploring their historical origins, the underlying photochemical mechanisms, the methodologies employed, the specific properties of the pigments utilized, the challenges related to the permanence and conservation of the images, and their relevance in contemporary artistic and scientific practice. By examining these aspects, this study seeks to contribute to a deeper understanding of the scientific principles that govern these ecological artistic methods.

To contextualize chlorography, it is useful to recall the history of photography, which in its early stages explored various non-traditional methods [2]. In the 19th century, several alternative processes emerged, such as anthotypes, cyanotypes, and other techniques that were not silver-based [3] [4]. Chlorography can be situated within this historical context as a continuation of the exploration of natural photosensitive materials for image creation. Specifically, chlorography is a technique within alternative photography that utilizes the photosensitivity of plant pigments directly within the vegetal material itself. Early explorations and the contemporary resurgence of this technique by artists like Binh Danh [5] and others demonstrate its continued relevance and artistic potential in the modern era.

The fundamental scientific principle behind chlorography is the decomposition or photobleaching of chlorophyll [6] and other natural pigments present in leaves and flowers when exposed to light [7] [8]. Light energy induces chemical changes in the pigment molecules, which leads to a discoloration or alteration of color in the exposed areas. This process is based on the inherent light sensitivity of plant pigments, a natural phenomenon related to photosynthesis and photoprotection [9]. Chlorophyll, the predominant green pigment in plants, primarily absorbs light in the red and blue regions of the visible spectrum. When exposed to intense light, particularly ultraviolet (UV) light, the chlorophyll molecule can decompose, losing its green color [10]. Other pigments present in plants, such as carotenoids (yellows and oranges) and anthocyanins (reds, purples, and blues), can also be sensitive to light and undergo alterations in their chemical structure and color.

A significant advantage of chlorography is its avoidance of the harsh and potentially toxic chemicals employed in traditional photographic development [9]. This stands in contrast to the environmental concerns associated with chemical photography. This aspect aligns with the broader movement toward sustainable, non-toxic artistic practices and a heightened environmental consciousness across various fields.

Due to its interdisciplinary nature, chlorography holds potential for diverse applications in the fields of art and education, fostering creativity, learning, and scientific inquiry. In art, it enables the creation of unique, ephemeral photographic works that are integrated with nature. In education, it can serve as an engaging and practical method for teaching photography, botany, and environmental sciences. In scientific research, it offers an avenue for exploring plant physiology, pigment properties, and the interactions of light with biological materials.

Therefore, the primary objective of this article is to delve into the scientific principles, historical context, and methodological considerations of chlorography as a promising natural alternative for photographic development using leaves and flowers.

2. Materials and Methods

The creation of this series on chlorotypes and anthotypes resulted from the link between an ethnographic study focused on understanding the visual changes that occurred in the graphic art of the Salasaka people from 1960 to 2018, and the exploration of alternative photographic development practices during the isolation period of the COVID-19 pandemic.

In the exploratory research on the iconography of the Salasaka indigenous people, processes of aesthetic transculturation that occurred during the specified period in this indigenous community of the Ecuadorian Andes—renowned for its textile craftsmanship—were identified. As part of this previous investigation, a large number of images associated with the community's production of tapestries, sashes, and drums were collected and cataloged.

Towards the end of 2020, these two moments converged to give rise to a new artistic research experience, born from the visual interest in utilizing the images collected in the ethnographic study on the Salasaka and using the nearby natural resources that were available during the period of isolation.

Thus, the idea arose to revive several alternative photographic development techniques with natural products that could be sourced without violating the health protocols established at that time. This marked the beginning of the exploration into creating chlorotypes and anthotypes with plants found in the province of Tungurahua (a region located in the central highlands of Ecuador).

Initially, the collection of this material was limited to the leaves from the potted plants and gardens of this study's initial author. The collection range for the plant substrate was subsequently expanded to other locations within the province of Tungurahua.

Between 2021 and 2024, approximately 1000 trials were conducted on various types of leaves and, subsequently, on flower petals to identify the most suitable species for this natural development process (Figure 1). In 2023, a series of tests on the encapsulation of leaves also commenced, aimed at prolonging their preservation.

This process led to the conception of an exhibition proposal, which came to fruition as the exhibition “Origen vivo” (Living Origin). This exhibition opened in April 2024 in Quito and included an installation of chlorotypes.

2.1. Chlorophyll Development Process

Chlorophyll printing is a natural photographic technique that enables the transfer of images directly onto the surface of plant leaves. Its origins can be traced back to early observations of how light affected plant coloration, a phenomenon known long before the formal development of photography. While Sir John Herschel conducted early research into the photographic properties of chlorophyll in the 19th century, the modern application of this technique to create recognizable photographic images is largely attributed to contemporary artists.

Heather Ackroyd and Dan Harvey pioneered the technique of projecting images onto growing grass, using light to influence chlorophyll synthesis and thereby create ephemeral "photographs" in art installations [26]. Subsequently, the Vietnamese artist Binh Danh [5] significantly refined the concept by applying it to individual leaves, often from his own garden. He is recognized for developing methods to preserve these delicate organic images, typically by encapsulating them in resin [1].

The process of chlorotyping or chlorography is based on exploring the artistic potential generated by using diverse species of vascular and non-vascular plants, flowers, and other natural species such as fungi. These serve as a substrate in place of paper to generate images, which are often linked to themes of memory, nature, and sustainability.

The process for creating a chlorophyll print involves several key steps, which can be summarized as follows:

2.1.1. Leaf Selection:

Suitable leaves are chosen, which ideally should be large, flat, and healthy, although successful results have been achieved with leaves smaller than 4 cm. The choice of plant species is crucial, as different types of leaves—such as those from pumpkin, oak, fig, ivy, and granadilla (passion fruit)—yield varying results in terms of color, texture, and light sensitivity. For fibrous leaves, it is recommended that the stem be cut at an angle to ensure the pressing process is uniform across the entire leaf structure.

Although freshly cut leaves are preferred, access to collection sites has sometimes required preserving leaves for up to a maximum of three weeks before their use in the chlorotype process. For preservation, leaves were kept dry inside a plastic bag under refrigeration. For best results, the stored leaves were wrapped in absorbent paper towels to prevent moisture accumulation. The process cannot be performed once the leaf is dry.

Figure 2. Process of selecting and cleaning leaves for use in development.

Figure 2. Process of selecting and cleaning leaves for use in development.

2.1.2. Image Preparation:

For the development process, a positive transparency of the desired image is required. This can be a laser print on acetate or an illustration on plastic film created with permanent markers that block sunlight. A high-contrast black and white digital image is often used for optimal results, as this helps to clearly delineate the areas that will be bleached from those that will remain dark. In this case, the print is made from a photographic positive, in contrast to the cyanotype process, which utilizes a negative.

2.1.3. Setup for Development:

The leaf and the positive transparency are placed together in a contact frame. A rigid surface (such as a board or a sheet of pressboard) and a sheet of glass are recommended to ensure firm and uniform contact between the transparency and the leaf, which is crucial for image sharpness. Materials that could prematurely dry the leaf should be avoided. For prolonged exposures, the leaf can be kept hydrated by allowing its stem to protrude from the frame into a water source.

2.1.4. Exposure:

The assembly is placed under direct sunlight. Exposure time varies considerably, ranging from a few hours for young, freshly cut leaves to longer periods. For example, an image can be developed on a granadilla leaf under such conditions in three to four hours of direct exposure. Most of the leaves tested have required between one day and up to three weeks to generate an image, depending on the leaf type, solar intensity, season, and meteorological conditions. It is necessary to monitor the progress periodically, taking care not to displace the transparency. An abrupt change in weather can cause the internal chemical reaction to cease, a phenomenon analogous to the fogging of a photograph in traditional development.

2.1.5. Drying and preservation:

Once the image has formed satisfactorily, the leaf is removed from the setup and dried between sheets of absorbent paper. Given that chlorophyll prints are inherently ephemeral, preservation is a critical step. Methods such as resin encapsulation, chemical baths (e.g., alcohol, copper sulfate), or the application of sealants (e.g., wax, varnish) are used to arrest degradation and protect the image from light and physical deterioration.

Figure 3. Solar exposure process for chlorotypy generation.

Figure 3. Solar exposure process for chlorotypy generation.

Nevertheless, exposure to light remains a key factor for the developed leaf. Even when attempts are made to halt the chemical process of photodecomposition, ambient light continues to deteriorate the image. Under direct light exposure, the developed images have lasted for approximately one year before beginning to degrade. Climatic conditions are also influential; in the dry climate of the Ecuadorian highlands, chlorotypes are more durable and the leaves do not warp. In contrast, leaves exposed in the humid climate of the coastal regions have warped, developed fungus, and unencapsulated images have deteriorated within a period of approximately three months.

The detailed mechanism behind chlorophyll printing centers on the photobleaching of chlorophyll. The image is formed as sunlight, particularly UV radiation, degrades the chlorophyll molecules in the exposed areas of the leaf. The areas of the leaf shielded from light by the transparency or object retain their chlorophyll, maintaining their original green color and thereby creating the necessary contrast for the image. As chlorophyll degrades in the exposed areas, the underlying yellow and orange carotenoids may become visible, contributing to the tones in these parts of the image.

Figure 4. Differences between negative development of a bogonia leaf and positive development of a malanga leaf.

Figure 4. Differences between negative development of a bogonia leaf and positive development of a malanga leaf.

A fundamental characteristic of chlorophyll printing or development is that the substrate (the leaf or flower petal) is itself the photosensitive material, in contrast to techniques that involve coating an inert material like paper. This means that the biological state of the leaf—its freshness, type, thickness, and pigment concentration—directly impacts the photographic outcome. The image forms as the leaf withers and its chlorophyll and other natural pigments degrade, a process intimately linked to the life and death of the leaf. This deep connection with the specific plant used, including its natural structures such as veins and textures, renders each print unique and unpredictable, a true collaboration with nature.

The inherent impermanence of chlorotypes is another defining aspect. Although preservation methods exist, the fleeting nature of the image, which continues to fade over time if not adequately protected, is not merely a technical limitation but a characteristic that is often exploited artistically. The tension between the fragility of the organic support and the attempt to render it permanent through fixation adds layers of meaning to the work. The following table details several preservation methods:

Table 2. Preservation methods for chlorographs.

Preservation Method	Process Description	Primary Purpose
Resin Encapsulation (Epoxy)	The dry, imaged leaf is completely submerged in liquid epoxy resin, which then cures to form a solid, transparent block.	Physical protection and arresting degradation from light/oxygen.
Chemical Baths (Copper Sulfate)	The leaf is submerged in a dilute solution of copper sulfate or other chemical fixatives in an attempt to stabilize the chlorophyll and other pigments.	To deactivate chlorophyll, halt enzymatic reactions, or replace ions (e.g., Mg with Cu).
Application of Sealants (Wax, Varnish)	A thin layer of beeswax, microcrystalline wax, or a UV-filtering spray varnish is applied to the surface of the dry leaf.	To physically protect the surface and block UV light.
Pressing and Storage in Darkness	The leaf is carefully pressed between blotting paper to remove all moisture and is then stored in an acid-free environment in complete darkness.	To stabilize the image in a more environmentally friendly manner.

Table 2. Preservation methods for chlorographs.

Preservation Method	Process Description	Primary Purpose
Resin Encapsulation (Epoxy)	The dry, imaged leaf is completely submerged in liquid epoxy resin, which then cures to form a solid, transparent block.	Physical protection and arresting degradation from light/oxygen.
Chemical Baths (Copper Sulfate)	The leaf is submerged in a dilute solution of copper sulfate or other chemical fixatives in an attempt to stabilize the chlorophyll and other pigments.	To deactivate chlorophyll, halt enzymatic reactions, or replace ions (e.g., Mg with Cu).
Application of Sealants (Wax, Varnish)	A thin layer of beeswax, microcrystalline wax, or a UV-filtering spray varnish is applied to the surface of the dry leaf.	To physically protect the surface and block UV light.
Pressing and Storage in Darkness	The leaf is carefully pressed between blotting paper to remove all moisture and is then stored in an acid-free environment in complete darkness.	To stabilize the image in a more environmentally friendly manner.

3. Results

Chlorotyping, also known as chlorography or phytotyping, is an alternative photographic process that utilizes plant leaves as a substrate for image generation, leveraging the photosensitivity of the chlorophyll they contain. This process is conducted via exposure to sunlight, which induces a chemical reaction resulting in the degradation of the leaf's own chemical compounds. These compounds oxidize in the areas exposed to light, while the areas shielded from light retain their original hue, thus creating the image (Figure 5).

As described in the methodology section, climatic variables such as solar intensity and humidity play a decisive role in the development process. The required exposure time varies depending on the type of leaf.

From the experiments conducted, it can be inferred that granadilla leaves are the most versatile. An image can be developed on very young leaves in approximately two to three hours of solar exposure. In contrast, more fibrous leaves, such as those from fig, monstera, or certain types of orchids, have required up to three weeks of daily exposures lasting 10 to 12 hours.

Continuous monitoring is necessary during the development process, as in some cases, the liquid content of the leaves evaporates very rapidly. This disintegrates the leaf pulp, causing the leaf to become skeletonized. The following table presents a graphical sample of the results obtained during this experimental process.

Table No. 3 presents a sample of 30 species, including fruit-bearing and flowering plants, shrubs, and flowers. All are vascular plants that grow in the central region of Ecuador and were tested for the production of chlorotypes.

Table 3. Sample of chlorotypes in various types of leaves.

No.	Plant Description	Scientific and Common Name (Spanish)	Developed Image	Approximate Exposure Time
1	Passiflora ligularis, or sweet granadilla, is part of the Passifloraceae family. The plant is a vine and is native to the Andes of northwestern South America.	Passiflora ligularis / Granadilla		Depending on the age of the leaf, between 3 and 12 hours.
2	Curuba or Taxo are species of the Passifloraceae family. They are climbing plants or vines, native to the Andean regions of South America.	Curuba / Taxo		8 hours
3	It is a shrub-like plant belonging to the Solanaceae family and is native to the Andes.	Solanum quitoense / Naranjilla		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
4	Known as squash or pumpkin, it is an annual herbaceous plant of the Cucurbitaceae family. It is a creeping or climbing plant with long stems.	Cucurbita maxima / Zapallo		4 hours
5	Vasconcellea pubescens, also known as mountain papaya, papayuela, or chamburo, is an evergreen shrub or small tree belonging to the Caricaceae family.	Vasconcellea pubescens / Jigacho		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
6	An annual herbaceous plant belonging to the legume family (Fabaceae).	Phaseolus vulgaris / Fréjol		Between 6 and 8 hours
7	Ficus carica, commonly called the fig tree, is a tree or shrub of the Moraceae family, which produces the fruit known as the fig.	Ficus carica / Higo		24 hours (three days of sun exposure)
8	Eucalyptus camaldulensis is a tree of the genus Eucalyptus. It is a species planted in many parts of the world.	Eucalyptus / Eucalipto rojo		Between 8 and 10 hours
9	The parrot's beak heliconia is a genus that includes more than 100 species of tropical plants, native to South America, Central America, and Indonesia.	Heliconia rostrata / Platanillo		Between 8 and 10 hours
10	Also known as "Elephant Ear," it is a perennial herbaceous plant of the Araceae family. Its leaves are large and heart-shaped, and its stems are blackish-purple.	Colocasia fontanesii Schott / Araceae – oreja de elefante		6 hours
11	Calla lilies are perennial rhizomatous herbaceous plants of the Araceae family. Known as arum lily, water lily, or calla lily.	Zantedeschia aethiopica / Cala		8 hours
12	An ornamental perennial plant belonging to the genus Pelargonium and the Geraniaceae family. It is a perennial, shrubby, or succulent plant with showy flowers.	Geranium / Geranio		4 hours
13	A perennial and woody climbing plant belonging to the Araliaceae family. It is known for its ability to climb using adventitious roots that allow it to adhere to various supports.	Hedera helix / Hiedra		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
14	A shrub of the mallow family (Malvaceae). It is an evergreen plant that can reach up to 5 meters in height.	Hibiscus / Cucarda		8 hours
15	A tree species belonging to the Euphorbiaceae family, famous for its latex known as dragon's blood, which has extraordinary healing properties.	Croton urucurana Baillon / Sangre de dragón		Between 4 and 6 hours
16	A climbing plant of the Solanaceae family, characterized by its large, yellow, trumpet-shaped flowers.	Solandra grandiflora / Copa de oro		8 hours
17	A tropical, climbing plant of the Araceae family, belonging to the species Monstera deliciosa.	Monstera / Costilla de Adán		Between 40 and 80 hours (five to ten days of sun exposure)
18	Commonly known as achocha or caigua, it is an annual herbaceous climbing plant of the Cucurbitaceae family.	Cyclanthera pedata / Achocha		Between 4 and 6 hours
19	A perennial climbing plant belonging to the Asteraceae family.	Delairea odorata / Hiedra amarilla		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
20	A tree belonging to the genus Micropholis and the Sapotaceae family. It is a plant endemic to Brazil.	Micropholis crotonoides / Pierre		Between 40 and 80 hours (five to ten days of sun exposure)
21	A shrub-like plant of the Melastomataceae family, also called the glory bush.	Pleroma urvilleanum / Sietecueros Nazareno Brasileño		Between 24 and 40 hours (three to five days of sun exposure)
22	A plant of the Polypodiaceae family. It is an epiphytic fern.	Phlebodium decumanum / Helecho		Between 6 and 10 hours
23	A shrub of the genus Nicotiana, the same genus as tobacco, from the Solanaceae family.	Nicotiana glauca / Palán palán		Between 6 and 10 hours
24	A plant species belonging to the Acanthaceae family.	Acanthus mollis / Acanto		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
25	A slow-growing perennial palm belonging to the Arecaceae family.	Licuala grandis / Palma de abanico		Between 24 and 40 hours (three to five days of sun exposure)
26	A perennial herbaceous plant of the genus Begonia.	Begonia sericoneura /Begonia		Between 8 and 10 hours
27	An epiphytic herbaceous plant of the Gesneriaceae family. It belongs to the genus Columnea.	Columnea medicinalis / Punta de flecha		Between 8 and 10 hours
28	A deciduous tree of the genus Tilia, belonging to the mallow family (Malvaceae).	Tilia europaea / Tilo		Between 6 and 8 hours
29	A perennial herbaceous plant with wide, lobed leaves.	Malva sylvestris / Malva		Between 12 and 16 hours (one to two days of sun exposure)
30	Flower petal. The genus Rosa is composed of a well-known group of generally thorny and flowering shrubs, primary representatives of the rose family (Rosaceae).	Rosa grandiflora / Rosa		8 hours

Table 3. Sample of chlorotypes in various types of leaves.

No.	Plant Description	Scientific and Common Name (Spanish)	Developed Image	Approximate Exposure Time
1	Passiflora ligularis, or sweet granadilla, is part of the Passifloraceae family. The plant is a vine and is native to the Andes of northwestern South America.	Passiflora ligularis / Granadilla		Depending on the age of the leaf, between 3 and 12 hours.
2	Curuba or Taxo are species of the Passifloraceae family. They are climbing plants or vines, native to the Andean regions of South America.	Curuba / Taxo		8 hours
3	It is a shrub-like plant belonging to the Solanaceae family and is native to the Andes.	Solanum quitoense / Naranjilla		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
4	Known as squash or pumpkin, it is an annual herbaceous plant of the Cucurbitaceae family. It is a creeping or climbing plant with long stems.	Cucurbita maxima / Zapallo		4 hours
5	Vasconcellea pubescens, also known as mountain papaya, papayuela, or chamburo, is an evergreen shrub or small tree belonging to the Caricaceae family.	Vasconcellea pubescens / Jigacho		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
6	An annual herbaceous plant belonging to the legume family (Fabaceae).	Phaseolus vulgaris / Fréjol		Between 6 and 8 hours
7	Ficus carica, commonly called the fig tree, is a tree or shrub of the Moraceae family, which produces the fruit known as the fig.	Ficus carica / Higo		24 hours (three days of sun exposure)
8	Eucalyptus camaldulensis is a tree of the genus Eucalyptus. It is a species planted in many parts of the world.	Eucalyptus / Eucalipto rojo		Between 8 and 10 hours
9	The parrot's beak heliconia is a genus that includes more than 100 species of tropical plants, native to South America, Central America, and Indonesia.	Heliconia rostrata / Platanillo		Between 8 and 10 hours
10	Also known as "Elephant Ear," it is a perennial herbaceous plant of the Araceae family. Its leaves are large and heart-shaped, and its stems are blackish-purple.	Colocasia fontanesii Schott / Araceae – oreja de elefante		6 hours
11	Calla lilies are perennial rhizomatous herbaceous plants of the Araceae family. Known as arum lily, water lily, or calla lily.	Zantedeschia aethiopica / Cala		8 hours
12	An ornamental perennial plant belonging to the genus Pelargonium and the Geraniaceae family. It is a perennial, shrubby, or succulent plant with showy flowers.	Geranium / Geranio		4 hours
13	A perennial and woody climbing plant belonging to the Araliaceae family. It is known for its ability to climb using adventitious roots that allow it to adhere to various supports.	Hedera helix / Hiedra		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
14	A shrub of the mallow family (Malvaceae). It is an evergreen plant that can reach up to 5 meters in height.	Hibiscus / Cucarda		8 hours
15	A tree species belonging to the Euphorbiaceae family, famous for its latex known as dragon's blood, which has extraordinary healing properties.	Croton urucurana Baillon / Sangre de dragón		Between 4 and 6 hours
16	A climbing plant of the Solanaceae family, characterized by its large, yellow, trumpet-shaped flowers.	Solandra grandiflora / Copa de oro		8 hours
17	A tropical, climbing plant of the Araceae family, belonging to the species Monstera deliciosa.	Monstera / Costilla de Adán		Between 40 and 80 hours (five to ten days of sun exposure)
18	Commonly known as achocha or caigua, it is an annual herbaceous climbing plant of the Cucurbitaceae family.	Cyclanthera pedata / Achocha		Between 4 and 6 hours
19	A perennial climbing plant belonging to the Asteraceae family.	Delairea odorata / Hiedra amarilla		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
20	A tree belonging to the genus Micropholis and the Sapotaceae family. It is a plant endemic to Brazil.	Micropholis crotonoides / Pierre		Between 40 and 80 hours (five to ten days of sun exposure)
21	A shrub-like plant of the Melastomataceae family, also called the glory bush.	Pleroma urvilleanum / Sietecueros Nazareno Brasileño		Between 24 and 40 hours (three to five days of sun exposure)
22	A plant of the Polypodiaceae family. It is an epiphytic fern.	Phlebodium decumanum / Helecho		Between 6 and 10 hours
23	A shrub of the genus Nicotiana, the same genus as tobacco, from the Solanaceae family.	Nicotiana glauca / Palán palán		Between 6 and 10 hours
24	A plant species belonging to the Acanthaceae family.	Acanthus mollis / Acanto		16 hours (two days of sun exposure)
25	A slow-growing perennial palm belonging to the Arecaceae family.	Licuala grandis / Palma de abanico		Between 24 and 40 hours (three to five days of sun exposure)
26	A perennial herbaceous plant of the genus Begonia.	Begonia sericoneura /Begonia		Between 8 and 10 hours
27	An epiphytic herbaceous plant of the Gesneriaceae family. It belongs to the genus Columnea.	Columnea medicinalis / Punta de flecha		Between 8 and 10 hours
28	A deciduous tree of the genus Tilia, belonging to the mallow family (Malvaceae).	Tilia europaea / Tilo		Between 6 and 8 hours
29	A perennial herbaceous plant with wide, lobed leaves.	Malva sylvestris / Malva		Between 12 and 16 hours (one to two days of sun exposure)
30	Flower petal. The genus Rosa is composed of a well-known group of generally thorny and flowering shrubs, primary representatives of the rose family (Rosaceae).	Rosa grandiflora / Rosa		8 hours

For each selected species, the approximate direct solar exposure time under natural conditions throughout the year has been documented. The development process was conducted in the city of Ambato, located in the province of Tungurahua, at an altitude of 2580 meters above sea level.

Additional tests have also been conducted in coastal cities, which have higher solar incidence and elevated temperatures, a condition that shortens the exposure times required to develop the image.

The average solar exposure for thin, non-fibrous leaves is typically between 6 and 10 hours, whereas for thick leaves, the exposure can require several days. Trials have been conducted to generate prints using UV lamps, but the exposure time triples compared to that required when using sunlight.

Furthermore, trials have been conducted on living leaves while still attached to the plant, specifically with granadilla and sunflower. However, although an image can be obtained, the exposure time is extremely long—around one month—and the resulting image lacks complete sharpness. This is because the leaf continues to grow, while the transparency used for the transfer maintains a constant size.

Each print is a reflection of the specific characteristics of the vegetal material utilized, meaning no two images are identical. This uniqueness becomes an asset for artists, who can explore the diversity of local flora and create works representative of their environment. This experimental approach not only highlights the technique's versatility but also opens new possibilities for contemporary artistic creation by integrating natural elements into the creative process.

When comparing chlorotyping and anthotyping, although both are based on the photobleaching of plant pigments, they differ in fundamental aspects regarding their process, the pigments utilized, and the characteristics of the resulting image.

With respect to the primary photosensitive pigments, chlorotyping focuses almost exclusively on chlorophyll, the predominant green pigment in leaves. The yellow and orange carotenoids present in the leaf may become visible as the chlorophyll degrades, contributing to the tones in the exposed areas. In contrast, anthotypes employ a much broader range of pigments extracted from various plant parts. The most common are anthocyanins (red, purple, blue) and carotenoids (yellow, orange), but they can also include betalains, flavonoids, and tannins, which allows for a greater diversity of initial colors in the emulsion.

In both cases the fundamental mechanism of light-induced photobleaching. Light, particularly UV radiation, excites the pigment molecules, provoking chemical reactions that result in a loss of color in the exposed areas. Areas shielded by a transparency or an object retain their original color, creating the image's contrast. Both are positive-working processes, wherein light bleaches the pigment.

The methodologies differ significantly. Chlorotyping utilizes the plant leaf as a direct photosensitive substrate, a process that involves steps such as selecting suitable leaves and considering their biological state and physical structure. Anthotypes, on the other hand, require the preparation of an emulsion from plant extracts, which is then applied to an inert substrate like paper. This introduces steps such as grinding, diluting, and straining the plant matter, as well as coating and drying the paper.

Permanence is a key challenge for both processes, as the images are inherently ephemeral and will continue to fade with light exposure if not preserved. Various preservation methods have been developed for both, such as resin encapsulation or the use of sealants for chlorotypes, and storage in darkness for anthotypes. Exposure duration is also significantly different; while chlorotypes, depending on the leaf type, can yield results in a few hours or may sometimes require days or weeks, anthotypes often need several weeks of exposure.

Aesthetically, chlorotypes often exhibit a delicate, sometimes ghostly appearance, with the texture and structure of the leaf integrated into the image. Anthotypes can vary widely in color and tone depending on the pigment source, often possessing a watercolor-like quality.

The two processes have contemporary relevance in art, where they are often used to explore themes related to nature, the environment, and memory. Their non-toxic nature and use of renewable materials align them with a growing interest in sustainability within artistic practices.

4. Conclusions

Currently, chlorography has re-emerged as an art form that challenges the conventions of modern photography. This technique has been adopted to explore themes of ecology, identity, and memory.

By utilizing plant materials specific to a particular environment, artists not only create visual works but also establish a dialogue with the local landscape and culture. This approach facilitates a reflection on the relationship between humanity and nature, as well as on the importance of preserving ecosystems in an increasingly urbanized and technologized world.

The perception that photography must rely on conventional techniques and advanced technology, coupled with the increasing use of Artificial Intelligence in design proposals, may limit the acceptance of alternative practices such as chlorotyping. Conversely, its value as an artisanal and sustainable craft can serve as an incentive for engaging in such practices.

Although the design process described in this text originated as an artistic proposal, given the scarce existing literature and documentation on alternative photographic development processes, this preliminary work has laid the foundation for a future research project. This project will be linked to the analysis of plant species from the Tungurahua region and their applications in graphic, textile, and industrial design, based on the biological and chemical analysis of the tinctorial compounds of each species utilized.