Methodology
A survey was conducted with 30 students from various universities in the state of Queretaro, including a range of questions targeting previously mentioned design areas. The first question asked students how they believed interior design impacts their productivity and well-being in an academic setting.
Figure 1.
Influence of Interior Design on Productivity and Well-being. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Figure 1.
Influence of Interior Design on Productivity and Well-being. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Of the five possible responses, only three were selected, and over 63% of the students affirmed that interior design significantly enhances productivity by creating a comfortable and stimulating environment. This suggests from the outset that most university students recognize the importance of their work setting and the ambiance in which they carry out academic tasks.
The questions that follow were divided by category and compared with existing studies and literature. This comparison enabled the extraction of results used to formulate interior design recommendations for academic and work environments, tailored to university students.
Figure 2.
Colors or Textures in the Space that Induce Comfort. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Figure 2.
Colors or Textures in the Space that Induce Comfort. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
In the survey's only open-ended question, students were asked if any color or texture in their workspace helped them work better or feel more comfortable. Most leaned toward the color white, which they claimed "brightens the space better." Several also indicated that green, especially when associated with natural elements like plants, was highly important, and light blue tones made them feel more relaxed while working.
However, in the article "Cognitive Performance and Emotion Are Indifferent to Ambient Color" by Christoph von Castell from the Psychology Department at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, the cognitive and emotional impacts of color were evaluated. Participants completed reasoning, mental rotation, and memory tasks in cabins painted red, pink, or blue, compared to a white control. Results showed no consistent effect of color on cognitive performance, though a small significant improvement in mental rotation occurred with red and pink backgrounds. There were no observed effects on numerical reasoning, visual/verbal memory, or object recognition. Emotional responses also did not vary significantly by color, despite expectations that blue would induce calmness and red excitement (von Castell et al., 2018).
Considering students' comments about green being beneficial only in the context of natural elements like plants, further exploration of biophilic design was warranted. "Biophilic design is the intentional incorporation of natural elements into architectural space due to the benefits they offer to humans" (Rosales & Garcia, 2019).
The study "Are Biophilic-Designed Site Office Buildings Linked to Health Benefits and High Performing Occupants?" by Tonia Gray and Carol Birrell (Australia, 2014) tracked employees for two years following modifications to an office space to include natural elements. Within just three months, workers reported increased collaboration, stress reduction, and greater job satisfaction (Gray & Birrell, 2014).
The impact of color alone on cognitive performance is not consistent, whereas the presence of biophilic design, such as vegetation, does demonstrate positive changes in well-being and productivity. This emphasizes the importance of nature in work environments beyond the effects of color.
Figure 3.
Importance of Light Intensity Control. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Figure 3.
Importance of Light Intensity Control. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
More than 73% of students considered light intensity control a very important factor in their study and work hours. However, the question did not differentiate between natural and artificial light. A follow-up question was posed to gain more clarity.
Figure 4.
Influence of Natural Light on Mood and Productivity. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Figure 4.
Influence of Natural Light on Mood and Productivity. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
When specifying the influence of natural versus artificial light on mood and productivity, students clearly preferred natural light. Despite natural light involving gradual changes in intensity (unlike artificial light), its benefits appear more appreciated.
In the study "La luz en el espacio docente. Diferencias de percepción entre la luz natural y artificial" by Carmen Jovacho, the affective responses of 521 students to lighting in 17 classrooms were analyzed. Five classrooms had natural lighting, six had artificial, and six combined both. Students associated natural light with feelings of surprise, clarity, tranquility, and liveliness, while artificial lighting induced feelings of uniformity and glare (Jovacho & Castilla, 2018).
Although artificial lighting offers stable illumination, students prefer natural light due to its positive effect on mood and productivity. Natural light fosters a more pleasant environment and better academic performance. Combined with findings on color and biophilic design, this underscores the importance of nature in study environments.
Figure 5.
Influence of Posture and Comfort on Concentration and Efficiency. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Figure 5.
Influence of Posture and Comfort on Concentration and Efficiency. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Over 76% of students stated that furniture comfort is crucial for maintaining concentration and being effective in their tasks. The next question: what features make furniture comfortable? This is where ergonomics becomes key. Ergonomics is defined as "The study of the adaptation of machines, furniture, and tools to the person who habitually uses them to achieve greater comfort and efficiency" (Real Academia Española, 2024).
Students were asked to select from a list of eight items (with no selection limit) those they considered essential for a healthy workspace. A healthy workspace is defined as one that provides accessibility based on individuals' abilities, minimizes barriers, and promotes health and disease prevention (Government of Mexico, 2022).
Figure 6.
Essential Elements for a Healthy Workspace. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Figure 6.
Essential Elements for a Healthy Workspace. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
The ergonomic chair was most selected (86.7%), followed by the desk (70%). These are logical given the time students spend sitting and working. What elements of a chair make it comfortable?
According to Rosario Párraga's research in "Diseño ergonómico de aulas universitarias," the key discomfort factors were seat material, backrest shape, and material. Párraga concluded: "University classroom furniture must be adjustable to suit different user measurements and avoid forced postures" (Párraga & García, 2014).
This aligns with the concept of flexible furniture, which can easily change configuration to prevent prolonged forced postures. Students were asked whether they supported or opposed the use of flexible furniture.
Figure 7.
Opinion on Flexible Furniture. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Figure 7.
Opinion on Flexible Furniture. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
All students (100%) supported trying flexible furniture, confirming their aversion to static, rigid positions during study/work. Flexible furniture enhances spatial organization and allows movement. Audrey Migliani states: "Furniture should be flexible to allow different spatial arrangements, adapting quickly and quietly to curriculum activities" (Migliani, 2020).
Lastly, students were asked which furniture layout best fostered both concentration and interaction during collaborative tasks.
Figure 8.
Influence of Furniture Layout on Concentration and Interaction. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Figure 8.
Influence of Furniture Layout on Concentration and Interaction. Source: Author’s compilation from Google Forms summary, 2024.
Again, students favored flexible layouts (over 70%) that enabled individual focus or group collaboration over more rigid or isolated configurations.
Furniture comfort is fundamental for university students. Ergonomics is essential, adapting to their physical needs for comfort and efficiency. Desks and chairs, especially those that consider material and support, are vital in preventing fatigue. Flexible furniture allows students to shift postures and layouts, improving spatial organization and enabling teamwork. Lightweight, movable furniture and adjustable height/rotation features outperform fixed, rigid options, supporting academic success.
Incorporate Biophilic Design: Integrate natural elements like plants to enhance emotional well-being, reduce stress, and boost productivity.
Prioritize Natural Light: Maximize access to natural light to improve mood and study performance.
Use Suitable Artificial Lighting: When natural light is insufficient, use artificial systems that mimic daylight.
Design Ergonomic Furniture: Focus on adaptable chairs and desks with quality materials and proper support.
Implement Flexible and Adjustable Furniture: Choose chairs with adjustable height and rotation to accommodate various activities.
Use Lightweight and Mobile Furniture: Allow furniture to be easily moved to support collaboration and flexible organization.
Create Healthy, Accessible Environments: Design inclusive spaces that eliminate physical barriers and promote wellness.
Design Areas for Both Interaction and Focus: Offer students options for individual concentration and teamwork.