2.1. Overview
The reviewed literature provides a comprehensive exploration of how social media, particularly visual-centric platforms, influences body image, self-perception, and eating behaviors in young women. Social comparison theory plays a central role across many of these studies, suggesting that individuals, especially young women, tend to compare their own lives and appearances to the idealized portrayals they see on social media. This comparison often leads to negative outcomes, such as body dissatisfaction, self-objectification, and disordered eating behaviors.
Key studies, such as those by Tiggemann and Slater (2014) and Perloff (2014), emphasize the negative impact of social media on body image, with platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Snapchat providing constant exposure to idealized images. These images, often curated by influencers or peers, fuel the social comparison process, amplifying body dissatisfaction. Chae (2017) extends this idea by focusing on envy toward social media influencers, demonstrating how their highly curated content contributes to unrealistic beauty standards that negatively affect followers’ self-esteem. In this context, Veldhuis, Konijn, and Seidell (2014) add an important perspective by emphasizing the role of peer norms and media exposure in shaping adolescent girls’ perceptions of weight and body image on social network sites.
Other studies, such as Cohen, Newton-John, and Slater (2017), investigate specific behaviors related to social media use, such as the act of posting selfies, which can reinforce self-objectification and lead to disordered eating patterns. Vartanian and Dey (2013) also highlight the impact of appearance-related commentary, demonstrating how both positive and negative feedback on one’s appearance can significantly influence body dissatisfaction and behaviors related to eating and dieting.
Collectively, these studies underscore the power of social media in shaping body image and self-perception among young women. They point to the need for media literacy programs to mitigate the harmful effects of social comparison and encourage more authentic representations on social media platforms.
2.2. Empirical Review
In Chae’s (2017) study, ‘Explaining Females’ Envy Toward Social Media Influencers’. The author investigates the psychological reasons behind why young women often feel envy toward influencers on social media. The research highlights how influencers present curated, idealized versions of their lives, focusing on beauty, wealth, and success, which prompts followers to compare themselves unfavorably. The theory of social comparison plays a central role in explaining these feelings of envy, as young women are particularly susceptible to comparing their own appearance and lifestyles to the seemingly flawless images portrayed online. This often leads to dissatisfaction with one’s own body, material possessions, and life circumstances.The study further suggests that social media influencers, by presenting only positive and curated content, contribute to unrealistic beauty and lifestyle standards that negatively affect the self-esteem of their followers. Chae also points out that while envy can have detrimental emotional consequences, it can sometimes motivate individuals to improve themselves or mimic aspects of influencers’ lives. The findings underline the importance of media literacy programs to help women critically analyze social media content and reduce negative comparisons. Additionally, the research calls for more authenticity from influencers to mitigate the harmful effects of unrealistic portrayals on young women’s self-perception and emotional well-being.
A study, published in the International Journal of Eating Disorders, examined how different online activities, especially those involving social media, contribute to body dissatisfaction. Tiggemann, M., & Slater, A. (2014). NetGirls: The Internet, Facebook, and body image concern in adolescent girls. Tiggemann and Slate investigated the relationship between internet use, particularly Facebook, and body image concerns in adolescent girls. They found that greater exposure to social media, particularly through Facebook, was associated with heightened body image concerns. The study highlighted how social comparisons and the emphasis on appearance in online environments can negatively impact self-perception in adolescent girls.Their findings underscore the potential role of social media in fostering body dissatisfaction and its relevance for eating disorder risks.
A Research paper highlighted how social media platforms amplify body image issues through constant exposure to idealized body types, social comparisons, and feedback on appearance. Perloff, R. M. (2014). Social Media Effects on Young Women’s Body Image Concerns: Theoretical Perspectives and an Agenda for Research. It explores the impact of social media on young women’s body image concerns, offering theoretical perspectives and setting a research agenda on this topic. Published in Sex Roles, Perloff integrates theories such as objectification, social comparison, and cultivation theory to explain these effects, emphasizing that young women are particularly vulnerable due to the visual and interactive nature of social media. The article calls for further research to understand the long-term consequences and to develop interventions that mitigate these negative impacts on body image.
Self-presentation and gender on MySpace examined self-presentation and gender differences , focusing on how adolescents and young adults navigate identity construction in online spaces. Manago, A. M., Graham, M. B., Greenfield, P. M., & Salimkhan, G. (2008). Published in the Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, the study found that users, particularly females, tended to present themselves in ways that conformed to traditional gender norms, with an emphasis on physical attractiveness and appearance. The study highlighted how social networking sites like MySpace provide a platform for self-expression, yet also reinforce societal expectations around gender. Their findings suggest that online platforms can influence users’ self-concept by encouraging them to align with culturally constructed gender roles.
An Article investigated the relationship between media exposure, sexual objectification, and the internalization of beauty ideals among girls in their article published in the Journal of Communication. Vandenbosch, L., & Eggermont, S. (2012). Understanding sexual objectification: A comprehensive approach toward media exposure and girls’ internalization of beauty ideals, self-objectification, and body surveillance. The study employs a comprehensive approach to understand how media portrayals contribute to self-objectification and body surveillance in young women. They found that consistent exposure to sexualized media content correlates with girls internalizing narrow beauty standards, leading to increased self-objectification and heightened body surveillance behaviors. The authors argue that this cycle perpetuates negative body image and emphasizes the need for critical media literacy to help mitigate these harmful effects on young women’s self-perception and identity.
Hogue, explored how active engagement with peers on social media influences body image in young women in their study published in Body Image. Hogue, J. V., & Mills, J. S. (2019). The effects of active social media engagement with peers on body image in young women. It explored how active engagement with peers on social media influences body image in young women in their study published in Body Image. They found that interactions such as liking, commenting, and sharing content significantly affect body image perceptions, suggesting that positive engagement can lead to improved body satisfaction while negative interactions may exacerbate body dissatisfaction. The study highlights the importance of the nature of social media interactions, indicating that supportive and positive peer feedback can mitigate the detrimental effects often associated with social media use, while critical or negative comments can have the opposite effect. Their findings underscore the nuanced role of social media in shaping body image among young women.
This study identifies individual susceptibility factors, such as low self-esteem and high social comparison tendencies, that make users more vulnerable to negative comparisons on the platform. De Vries, D. A., & Kühne, R. (2015). Facebook and self-perception: Individual susceptibility to negative social comparison on Facebook. It investigates how Facebook use influences self-perception through negative social comparison in their article published in personality and individual Differences. They found that these factors can lead to decreased self-esteem and increased body dissatisfaction, illustrating how social media environments may exacerbate feelings of inadequacy. The authors emphasize the importance of understanding individual differences in susceptibility to social comparison in order to address the psychological impacts of social media use.
A study investigates how exposure to thin-ideal media, such as television and magazines, affects body image and self-esteem. Bell, B. T., & Dittmar, H. (2011). Does Media Type Matter? The Role of Identification in Adolescent Girls’ Media Consumption and the Impact of Different Thin-Ideal Media on Body Image. It explored the impact of different types of media on body image among adolescent girls, focusing on the role of identification with media characters in their article published in Sex Roles. They found that girls who strongly identified with thin-ideal characters experienced greater body dissatisfaction and were more likely to internalize beauty ideals. The research highlights the importance of media type and the mechanisms of identification, suggesting that the nature of media consumption significantly influences adolescents’ body image perceptions and reinforces societal standards of attractiveness.
Henderson examines the influence of social media influencers on fashion trends in her article published in the Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management. Henderson, K. (2015). The Role of Social Media Influencers in Shaping Fashion Trends. The study highlights how these influencers shape consumer perceptions and behaviors through their curated content and personal branding, effectively acting as key opinion leaders in the fashion industry. Henderson identifies the mechanisms through which influencers impact followers’ fashion choices, including authenticity, relatability, and engagement. The research underscores the power of social media in driving trends, suggesting that influencers not only reflect current styles but also actively contribute to the creation and dissemination of new fashion norms, thereby transforming traditional marketing dynamics in the fashion world. w
The paper by Veldhuis, Konijn, and Seidell (2014) explores how weight-related information on social network sites (SNS) affects adolescent girls’ weight perceptions, with a particular focus on the roles of media exposure and peer norms. Veldhuis, J., Konijn, E. A., & Seidell, J. C. (2014). Weight information on social network sites: The role of media exposure and peer norms in adolescent girls’ weight perceptions. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking. The paper by Veldhuis, Konijn, and Seidell (2014) explores how weight-related information on social network sites (SNS) affects adolescent girls’ weight perceptions, with a particular focus on the roles of media exposure and peer norms. This study sheds light on a significant aspect of modern adolescent behavior and self-image, particularly in the context of social media.
Media exposure has long been recognized as a powerful influencer of adolescent body image, especially through the portrayal of idealized body types. Research by Levine and Murnen (2009) and Grabe et al. (2008) has highlighted that media, including television, magazines, and increasingly social media platforms, often present unrealistic beauty ideals that adolescents internalize. The authors of the study, Veldhuis et al. (2014), build upon this body of work, suggesting that social media amplifies these effects, as it allows adolescents to continuously view and compare themselves to both celebrities and peers who may present an unrealistic standard of beauty.
A paper investigated the relationship between appearance-related commentary, body dissatisfaction, and dietary restraint among college women, with a particular focus on how appearance semanticity moderates these relationships. Vartanian, L. R., & Dey, S. (2013). Appearance-related commentary, body dissatisfaction, and dietary restraint in college women: The moderating role of appearance semanticity. Body Image, 10(4), 451-456. This study is a contribution to the growing body of literature examining the role of external factors, such as peer commentary, in shaping body image and health-related behaviors. The impact of appearance-related commentary on body dissatisfaction has been well-documented in the literature. Appearance-related comments, whether positive or negative, can significantly influence individuals’ body image, particularly among those who are highly invested in their physical appearance.
According to Levine and Murnen (2009), receiving feedback on one’s appearance can lead to heightened body dissatisfaction, especially when the feedback is negative or when individuals internalize societal beauty standards. Vartanian and Dey (2013) extend this idea by focusing on how commentary impacts body dissatisfaction among college women, a demographic particularly vulnerable to body image concerns. Their study provides additional evidence that appearance-related comments, particularly negative ones, contribute to the development of body dissatisfaction, aligning with previous findings by Tiggemann and Slater (2014), which emphasized the significant influence of external judgments on self-perception.
A paper explored the relationship between selfies, self-objectification, and disordered eating in young women. Cohen, R., Newton-John, T., & Slater, A. (2017). “Selfie”-objectification: The role of selfies in self-objectification and disordered eating in young women. Computers in Human Behavior, 79, 68-74. DOI: 10.1016/j.chb.2017.10.027. The study aims to understand how the act of taking and sharing selfies can contribute to self-objectification, which, in turn, influences body image concerns and eating behaviors. This research adds to the growing body of literature that links social media behavior to psychological outcomes, particularly regarding body image and eating disorders. Cohen et al. (2017) build on this theory by linking self-objectification to selfie culture. They argue that selfies, which often highlight physical appearance and are shared for social validation, reinforce objectification by prompting individuals to focus on their looks, potentially exacerbating body dissatisfaction. This is consistent with previous research by Tiggemann and Slater (2013), who found that self-objectification, induced by social media exposure, is linked to body dissatisfaction and harmful weight control behaviors. The work of Cohen et al. (2017) provides further evidence that selfies contribute to the cycle of self-objectification, as the act of taking and sharing selfies often involves the scrutiny of one’s physical appearance, potentially leading to increased dissatisfaction with one’s body image.
2.4. Research Gap
While the reviewed literature offers valuable insights into the relationship between social media use and body image concerns, there are several key areas where further research is needed:
Longitudinal Studies on Social Media Impact: Much of the existing research focuses on short-term effects or correlational data. Longitudinal studies could provide deeper insights into the long-term consequences of social media use on body image and eating behaviors over time. This could help to identify whether the effects are persistent or if they change as individuals age or reduce their social media usage.
Role of Different Social Media Platforms: The studies reviewed primarily focus on Facebook, Instagram, and general social media engagement. However, newer platforms like TikTok and Snapchat, which are particularly popular among younger audiences, have different engagement dynamics. Research exploring how these platforms influence body image, self-objectification, and eating behaviors is needed to understand platform-specific effects.
Intersectionality in Body Image Concerns: The majority of the studies reviewed focus on young women from Western contexts. Research examining the intersectionality of race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and other identity factors in relation to social media’s impact on body image is needed. Understanding how these factors might influence the way different groups experience body dissatisfaction and self-objectification in the context of social media can help create more inclusive interventions.
Authenticity and the Role of Influencers: Although studies like Chae (2017) and Henderson (2015) touch on the role of influencers, more research is needed on how influencers’ authenticity—or lack thereof—shapes followers’ self-perception. While influencers are often seen as role models, the impact of “real” vs. curated content on body image remains underexplored. Understanding how influencers can mitigate negative effects by promoting authenticity or engaging in body-positive messaging is a promising area for future research.
Psychological Mechanisms Beyond Social Comparison: While social comparison is a key mechanism in many of these studies, other psychological mechanisms, such as self-esteem, identity development, and emotional regulation, could also play a significant role in how social media affects body image. Research that looks at these broader psychological factors could provide a more nuanced understanding of how social media influences young women’s body image and eating behaviors.
Impact of Peer vs. Influencer Comparison: While studies such as Veldhuis et al. (2014) examine the role of peer norms in shaping body image, more research is needed to understand the differential impact of comparing oneself to peers versus influencers. Influencers often have a larger following and may present more polished, aspirational content, whereas peer comparisons might involve more relatable, albeit still idealized, representations. Examining these dynamics in greater detail could offer insights into how different types of comparison affect body image.