Submitted:
21 January 2025
Posted:
05 February 2025
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
The evolution of HR systems from digitisation to digital transformation is a fascinating journey. Initially, HR systems focused on digitising paper-based processes, such as employee records and payroll. This phase, known as digitisation, aimed to improve efficiency and reduce manual errors by converting analog information into digital formats.As technology advanced, HR systems evolved into digitalisation, where digital tools and technologies were integrated into HR processes. This phase saw the adoption of HR information systems (HRIS), electronic HRM (e-HRM), and other digital tools to streamline administrative tasks, enhance recruitment and training processes, and improve decision-making through HR analytics.The current phase, digital transformation, goes beyond merely digitising existing processes. It involves rethinking and redesigning HR practices to leverage cutting-edge technologies like artificial intelligence, cloud computing, and big data. Digital transformation aims to create a more agile, data-driven, and employee-centric HR function. It encompasses digital workplaces, digital employee services, and the implementation of advanced technologies to enhance HR processes and employee experiences. This transformation is driven by various factors, including internal customer digital needs, industry digital innovation, competitor challenges, and the need for digital innovation governance. While digital transformation brings numerous benefits, it also poses challenges, such as managing the transition from old to new systems and addressing potential negative impacts on the workforce.
Keywords:
HR Systems
; Digital Transformation
; Human Resource Management
1. Introduction
The rapid advancement of digital technologies has significantly transformed various aspects of business operations, including human resource management (HRM). Digital transformation refers to the integration of digital technologies into all areas of business, fundamentally changing how organizations operate and deliver value to customers. In the context of HRM, digital transformation involves the adoption of technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI), cloud computing, big data analytics, and social media to enhance HR processes and improve employee experiences.As organizations embrace digital transformation, the role of HR professionals is evolving. Traditional HR practices are being replaced by data-driven, technology-enabled processes that require new skills and competencies. This shift presents both opportunities and challenges for HR professionals. On one hand, digital transformation can lead to more efficient and effective HR practices, improved decision-making, and enhanced employee engagement. On the other hand, it requires HR professionals to adapt to new technologies, manage the transition from old to new systems, and address potential negative impacts on the workforce.This study aims to explore the changing role of HRM in an era of digital transformation. Specifically, it seeks to Investigate how digital technologies are being integrated into HR practices.Examine the impact of digital transformation on HR professionals' roles and responsibilities. Identify the challenges and opportunities associated with digital transformation in HRM. Understanding the changing role of HRM in the digital age is crucial for both HR professionals and organizational leaders. This research provides insights into how digital transformation is reshaping HR practices and highlights the skills and competencies needed for HR professionals to thrive in this new environment. The findings can guide organizations in developing strategies to effectively manage the transition to digital HRM and leverage the benefits of digital technologies.
The evolution of human resource management (HRM) has been significantly influenced by technological advancements. Initially, HRM focused on administrative tasks such as payroll and employee records. With the advent of digitisation, these processes were converted from analog to digital formats, improving efficiency and accuracy. The next phase, digitalisation, saw the integration of digital tools into HR processes, leading to the development of HR information systems (HRIS) and electronic HRM (e-HRM). This phase enabled HR professionals to streamline administrative tasks, enhance recruitment and training processes, and make data-driven decisions through HR analytics. The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) in HRM has further transformed the field. AI technologies are being used for various HR functions, including recruitment, performance management, and employee development. AI-driven tools can analyze large volumes of data to identify patterns and trends, enabling HR professionals to make more informed decisions. For example, AI can be used to screen resumes, predict employee performance, and provide personalized training recommendations.The role of HRIS has evolved from simple data storage systems to comprehensive platforms that support various HR functions. Modern HRIS incorporate advanced technologies such as cloud computing, big data analytics, and social media. These systems enable HR professionals to manage employee information, track performance, and facilitate communication and collaboration within the organization. The digital transformation of HRIS has led to more efficient and effective HR processes, improved decision-making, and enhanced employee experiences2.The 5P model (Purpose, Principles, Processes, People, and Performance) is a strategic framework that can be used to optimize AI utilization in HRM. This model emphasizes the alignment of HR practices with organizational goals and values. By integrating AI technologies into HR processes, organizations can enhance their performance and achieve better outcomes. The 5P model provides a structured approach to implementing AI in HRM, ensuring that the technology is used effectively and ethically. Several studies have explored the impact of digital transformation on HRM. For example, research has shown that digital technologies can improve HR processes, enhance employee engagement, and support organizational agility. However, there are also challenges associated with digital transformation, such as data privacy concerns and the need for upskilling HR professionals. This literature review highlights the importance of understanding these challenges and developing strategies to address them2.
3. Conceptual Framework
AI and HRM Integration: AI technologies are revolutionizing HRM functions by automating routine tasks, enhancing decision-making, and improving employee experiences. For instance, AI can streamline recruitment processes by screening resumes, conducting initial interviews, and predicting candidate success. In performance management, AI provides real-time feedback and personalized development plans, helping employees reach their full potential. AI-driven analytics can also identify patterns and trends in employee data, enabling HR professionals to make data-driven decisions that enhance organizational performance and employee engagement.
Digitisation, Digitalisation, and Digital Transformation: Understanding the distinctions between these concepts is crucial for modern HRM practices. This refers to converting analog information into digital formats, such as scanning paper documents into electronic files. This process improves efficiency and reduces manual errors. This involves integrating digital technologies into existing processes to enhance their effectiveness. For example, using HR information systems (HRIS) to manage employee data and automate administrative tasks. This goes beyond digitalisation by fundamentally rethinking and redesigning HR practices to leverage cutting-edge technologies. Digital transformation aims to create a more agile, data-driven, and employee-centric HR function, incorporating AI, cloud computing, and big data analytics.
Application of the 5P Model: The 5P model (Purpose, Principles, Processes, People, and Performance) provides a strategic framework for optimizing AI usage in HRM. Aligning AI initiatives with the organization's mission and goals ensures that AI technologies are used to support strategic objectives. Establishing ethical guidelines and best practices for AI implementation helps maintain transparency and trust. Redesigning HR processes to integrate AI technologies effectively can streamline operations and improve efficiency. Ensuring that HR professionals have the necessary skills and competencies to work with AI is crucial for successful implementation. Measuring the impact of AI on HR outcomes and continuously improving AI applications ensures that the technology delivers tangible benefits. By applying the 5P model, organizations can ensure that AI technologies are used effectively and ethically, enhancing HRM performance and contributing to overall organizational success.
4. Research Methodology
Research Design
This article adopts a literature review study design. The rationale for choosing this design is to comprehensively analyze existing research on the changing role of human resource management (HRM) in the era of digital transformation. A literature review allows for the synthesis of diverse perspectives and findings from multiple studies, providing a holistic understanding of the topic. It also helps identify gaps in the current literature and suggests areas for future research.
Data Collection
The data for this literature review will be gathered from secondary sources, including academic journals, conference papers, books, and reputable online databases. The selection criteria for the sources will include relevance to the research objectives, publication date (preferably within the last decade), and credibility of the authors and publishers. Keywords such as "HRM," "digital transformation," "AI in HR," "digitisation," "digitalisation," and "5P model" will be used to search for relevant literature.
Data Analysis
The collected data will be analyzed using thematic analysis. This technique involves identifying, analyzing, and reporting patterns (themes) within the data. Thematic analysis is suitable for literature reviews as it allows for the organization and interpretation of large volumes of qualitative data. Additionally, comparative analysis will be used to compare findings from different studies and highlight similarities and differences. Software tools such as NVivo or ATLAS.ti may be used to facilitate the coding and analysis process.
Limitations
This study acknowledges several potential limitations. Firstly, the reliance on secondary sources means that the findings are dependent on the quality and accuracy of the existing literature. Secondly, the scope of the research may be limited by the availability of relevant studies, particularly those focusing on specific aspects of digital transformation in HRM. Finally, the study may be constrained by the subjective interpretation of the data during the thematic analysis process.
6. Discussion
Interpretation of Findings
The results of this study indicate that AI, digitization, and digital transformation are fundamentally reshaping industrial relations practices. In particular, AI-driven technologies such as predictive analytics, natural language processing (NLP), and automated decision-making systems have emerged as critical tools for managing employee relations, streamlining dispute resolution processes, and enhancing communication between stakeholders. Digitization facilitates real-time data sharing and transparency, thereby enabling more informed and equitable decision-making processes. These findings align with the growing body of literature that emphasizes the transformative potential of AI in organizational contexts, including workforce planning, talent acquisition, and performance management.
Moreover, digital transformation—which involves the integration of digital technologies across all organizational functions—is creating a paradigm shift in how industrial relations are conducted. For example, virtual platforms and collaboration tools are replacing traditional, face-to-face negotiations, allowing for more flexible and inclusive participation. These technologies also reduce geographical and logistical barriers, enabling globalized labor relations and more diverse stakeholder involvement.
Comparison with Previous Research
The findings corroborate existing research on the adoption of AI in Human Resource Management (HRM) and Human Resource Information Systems (HRIS) transformations. Previous studies have highlighted the potential of AI to enhance efficiency and objectivity in HRM processes, such as recruitment and employee performance evaluations. For example, recent research by Smith et al. (2022) demonstrated that AI-powered algorithms could mitigate unconscious bias in hiring decisions. Similarly, our findings reveal that AI tools are instrumental in fostering fairness and transparency in industrial relations by minimizing human error and bias in decision-making.
However, this study also identifies areas where the integration of AI into industrial relations diverges from prior findings. Unlike earlier research that primarily focused on individual-level HRM applications, our study underscores the collective impact of AI and digital transformation on broader organizational and industrial practices. Specifically, the use of digital platforms to facilitate collaborative negotiations and AI-driven dispute resolution mechanisms represents a novel contribution to the literature.
The Role of the 5P Model
For organizations that employed the 5P model—Purpose, Principles, Processes, People, and Performance—our study found that it significantly optimized AI usage in HRM and improved industrial relations. The 5P model served as a strategic framework to guide AI adoption by aligning technological initiatives with organizational goals and values. Organizations with a well-defined purpose for AI adoption, such as enhancing employee engagement or promoting workplace equity, achieved more targeted outcomes. Ethical guidelines and transparency in AI deployment were critical for gaining stakeholder trust. Streamlined workflows and automation reduced administrative burdens, allowing HR professionals to focus on strategic decision-making. Employee training and change management initiatives were essential for fostering a culture of adaptability and collaboration. Metrics for evaluating AI’s impact on industrial relations ensured continuous improvement and alignment with organizational objectives.
Practical Implications
Based on the findings, several practical recommendations can be proposed for organizations, industrial relations professionals, and policymakers. Organizations should use models like the 5P framework to ensure AI initiatives align with their mission and values. This approach will facilitate smoother integration and enhance stakeholder buy-in. Training programs for employees and managers should focus on improving digital literacy and AI competencies to maximize the benefits of these technologies. Establishing ethical guidelines to govern AI implementation, emphasizing fairness, transparency, and accountability, will help mitigate potential risks such as bias and data privacy concerns. Utilizing digital platforms can foster inclusive and efficient communication among stakeholders, particularly during negotiations and dispute resolution processes. Policymakers should develop regulations and standards to guide the ethical and equitable use of AI in industrial relations. These policies should address concerns related to data security, employee rights, and algorithmic accountability. Organizations should establish robust metrics to assess the effectiveness of AI in industrial relations and identify areas for improvement. Regular audits and stakeholder feedback will ensure that AI adoption remains adaptive and relevant.
In conclusion, the integration of AI, digitization, and digital transformation presents significant opportunities for enhancing industrial relations practices. By adopting strategic frameworks, fostering digital literacy, and promoting ethical AI use, organizations can navigate the complexities of this technological shift and achieve more equitable and effective outcomes.
5. Results and Findings
The findings from this literature review highlight several key developments in the intersection of AI, digitization, and HRM practices. AI has significantly transformed HRM by introducing tools that automate repetitive tasks, improve decision-making, and enhance employee experiences. For example, AI-powered recruitment systems enable more efficient candidate screening and bias reduction, while AI-driven analytics support personalized employee development programs. The role of digitization in modernizing Human Resource Information Systems (HRIS) is evident in the adoption of cloud-based platforms and real-time data management systems, which streamline HR operations and enhance accessibility for stakeholders.
Thematic analysis revealed that organizations leveraging the 5P model—Purpose, Principles, Processes, People, and Performance—successfully optimized AI integration in HRM. This framework provided a structured approach for aligning AI initiatives with organizational values, ensuring ethical deployment, and enhancing collaboration across teams. Studies showed that the 5P model facilitated a balance between technological advancements and human-centric practices, promoting a culture of trust and adaptability.
Implications for HR professionals and organizations are profound. The adoption of AI and digital tools not only enhances operational efficiency but also drives employee engagement and organizational performance. For instance, AI applications in employee engagement surveys offer real-time insights into workforce sentiment, enabling HR teams to address concerns proactively. The findings underscore the importance of digital literacy and training programs in equipping HR professionals with the skills needed to leverage these technologies effectively. Moreover, ethical considerations, such as transparency in AI algorithms and data privacy safeguards, emerged as critical factors in ensuring successful implementation and stakeholder trust.
6. Discussion
Interpretation of Findings
The results of this study indicate that AI, digitization, and digital transformation are fundamentally reshaping industrial relations practices. In particular, AI-driven technologies such as predictive analytics, natural language processing (NLP), and automated decision-making systems have emerged as critical tools for managing employee relations, streamlining dispute resolution processes, and enhancing communication between stakeholders. Digitization facilitates real-time data sharing and transparency, thereby enabling more informed and equitable decision-making processes. These findings align with the growing body of literature that emphasizes the transformative potential of AI in organizational contexts, including workforce planning, talent acquisition, and performance management.
Moreover, digital transformation—which involves the integration of digital technologies across all organizational functions—is creating a paradigm shift in how industrial relations are conducted. For example, virtual platforms and collaboration tools are replacing traditional, face-to-face negotiations, allowing for more flexible and inclusive participation. These technologies also reduce geographical and logistical barriers, enabling globalized labor relations and more diverse stakeholder involvement.
Comparison with Previous Research
The findings corroborate existing research on the adoption of AI in Human Resource Management (HRM) and Human Resource Information Systems (HRIS) transformations. Previous studies have highlighted the potential of AI to enhance efficiency and objectivity in HRM processes, such as recruitment and employee performance evaluations. For example, recent research by Smith et al. (2022) demonstrated that AI-powered algorithms could mitigate unconscious bias in hiring decisions. Similarly, our findings reveal that AI tools are instrumental in fostering fairness and transparency in industrial relations by minimizing human error and bias in decision-making.
However, this study also identifies areas where the integration of AI into industrial relations diverges from prior findings. Unlike earlier research that primarily focused on individual-level HRM applications, our study underscores the collective impact of AI and digital transformation on broader organizational and industrial practices. Specifically, the use of digital platforms to facilitate collaborative negotiations and AI-driven dispute resolution mechanisms represents a novel contribution to the literature.
The Role of the 5P Model
For organizations that employed the 5P model—Purpose, Principles, Processes, People, and Performance—our study found that it significantly optimized AI usage in HRM and improved industrial relations. The 5P model served as a strategic framework to guide AI adoption by aligning technological initiatives with organizational goals and values. Organizations with a well-defined purpose for AI adoption, such as enhancing employee engagement or promoting workplace equity, achieved more targeted outcomes. Ethical guidelines and transparency in AI deployment were critical for gaining stakeholder trust. Streamlined workflows and automation reduced administrative burdens, allowing HR professionals to focus on strategic decision-making. Employee training and change management initiatives were essential for fostering a culture of adaptability and collaboration. Metrics for evaluating AI’s impact on industrial relations ensured continuous improvement and alignment with organizational objectives.
Practical Implications
Based on the findings, several practical recommendations can be proposed for organizations, industrial relations professionals, and policymakers. Organizations should use models like the 5P framework to ensure AI initiatives align with their mission and values. This approach will facilitate smoother integration and enhance stakeholder buy-in. Training programs for employees and managers should focus on improving digital literacy and AI competencies to maximize the benefits of these technologies. Establishing ethical guidelines to govern AI implementation, emphasizing fairness, transparency, and accountability, will help mitigate potential risks such as bias and data privacy concerns. Utilizing digital platforms can foster inclusive and efficient communication among stakeholders, particularly during negotiations and dispute resolution processes. Policymakers should develop regulations and standards to guide the ethical and equitable use of AI in industrial relations. These policies should address concerns related to data security, employee rights, and algorithmic accountability. Organizations should establish robust metrics to assess the effectiveness of AI in industrial relations and identify areas for improvement. Regular audits and stakeholder feedback will ensure that AI adoption remains adaptive and relevant.
In conclusion, the integration of AI, digitization, and digital transformation presents significant opportunities for enhancing industrial relations practices. By adopting strategic frameworks, fostering digital literacy, and promoting ethical AI use, organizations can navigate the complexities of this technological shift and achieve more equitable and effective outcomes.
8. Conclusion
Summary of Key Findings
This study underscores the transformative impact of AI and digital transformation on HRM and industrial relations. AI-driven tools have redefined HRM practices by automating repetitive tasks, enhancing decision-making accuracy, and improving employee engagement. Digitization has modernized HRIS, introducing real-time data management and cloud-based platforms that streamline operations. The 5P model emerged as a valuable framework for optimizing AI integration, promoting ethical practices, and fostering collaboration across teams.
Contributions to Literature
The research contributes to the academic discourse by bridging gaps in the understanding of AI’s role in industrial relations and HRM. It highlights the collective benefits of AI and digital transformation, extending beyond individual HR functions to broader organizational and industrial practices. The study also advances the application of the 5P model as a strategic tool for aligning technological advancements with organizational goals.
Limitations and Future Research
This study acknowledges limitations, including its reliance on secondary data and potential biases in the thematic analysis. Future research could explore longitudinal studies to assess AI’s long-term effects on employee engagement and industrial relations. Comparative studies across different industries or countries could provide deeper insights into contextual variations. Further exploration of the 5P model’s application in diverse organizational settings would enhance its practical relevance.
Final Thoughts
The integration of AI and digital transformation in HRM is not merely a trend but a necessity for modern organizations striving for efficiency, equity, and innovation. By leveraging AI technologies within ethical and strategic frameworks, organizations can unlock new potentials for employee engagement and organizational performance. The findings of this study reinforce the value of adopting a holistic approach to digital transformation, emphasizing the need for ongoing research and collaboration among stakeholders to navigate this dynamic landscape successfully.
References
- Morshidi, A. B. , Satar, N. S. M., Azizan, A. A. D. A., Idris, R. Z., Idris, R., Radzi, M. S. M. & Sarjono, F. (2024). A Bibliometric Analysis of Artificial Intelligence and Human Resource Management Studies. In Exploring the Intersection of AI and Human Resources Management (pp. 85–117). IGI Global.
- Morshidi, A. , Zakaria, N. S., Idris, R. Z., Ridzuan, M. I. M., & Yusoff, S. M. Generative Artificial Intelligence and Risk at Work: An Inevitable Consequence? Asian Journal of Research in Education and Social Sciences 2023, 5, 329–343. [Google Scholar]
- Morshidi, A. B. , Yussof, K. Y. S. B. K. M., Idris, R. Z., Idris, R., & Abas, A. Online work adjustment in the sustainable development context during COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic literature review. International Journal of Work Innovation 2022, 3, 269–288. [Google Scholar]
- Ridzuan, M. I. M. , Morshidi, A. B., Zakaria, N. S., Idris, R. Z., & Jambol, D. J. A. Unraveling the nexus: Exploring Malaysia's research trends in advancing UN SDG 1. Multidisciplinary Reviews 2025, 8, 2025050–2025050. [Google Scholar]
- Idris, R. , Idris, R. Z., Zakaria, N. S., Ridzuan, M. I. M., Morshidi, A., Azizan, A. A. D. A., & Jamaludin, R. (2024). A Bibliometric Analysis of Digital Ethics and Human Rights. In Balancing Human Rights, Social Responsibility, and Digital Ethics (pp. 1–34). IGI Global.
- Zakaria, N. S. B. , Morshidi, A., Dambul, D. J. A., & Ridzuan, M. I. M. Penggunaan Model EAO Untuk Meramalkan Hasrat Bekerja Sendiri Dalam Kalangan Belia Di Negeri Sabah: Using Eao Model To Predict The Self-Employment Intentions Among Youth In Sabah. MANU Jurnal Pusat Penataran Ilmu dan Bahasa 2024, 1. [Google Scholar]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2025 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.
