In this section, the results of the SN and CFC fatigue curves are presented for rotating bending (25 kHz), tension/compression (150 Hz), and tension/compression at (20kHz) loads. The results are initially presented separately and then subsequently combined to create a full range model from the HCF to VHCF regime for bending and tension/compression, for both SN and CFC models. The effects of frequency and type of loading on fatigue strength are analysed and discussed. The fatigue fracture surfaces obtained by SEM and EDS analysis are considered to clarify the results obtained.
4.1. Basquin SN Fatigue Model
The rotating bending fatigue tests were carried out from a level stress amplitude,
, close to the yield strength of the material, up to a stress amplitude where run-outs begin appearing, corresponding to a fatigue life around of 10
7 cycles.
Table 6 summarizes the parameters
and
obtained by the linear regression model, for specimens with different surface finishing conditions. According to the results presented in
Table 6 and
Figure 9, a value of
equal -0.1460 and a value of
equal 3715.0 MPa with a coefficient of determination of
were obtained. However, considering only polished specimens, the value of
increases to -0.082, and
decreases to 2005.68 MPa, as expected for specimens tested in the HFC regime with a better surface quality. The change of the exponent
was due to the most extreme point that fractured in the zone close to the occurrence of run-outs, as can be seen in
Figure 10, which hence increases
and decreases
. In addition, from the comparison between the data set corresponding to the turned and polished specimens, one verified that specimens with a surface roughness of 0.5
m had no significant influence on the fatigue strength.
Thus, considering a combination of the obtained results from turned and polished specimens, one verifies that
and
are close to the SN fatigue model considering only turned specimens, such that the combined model results in
= -0.1369 and
= 3433.3 MPa with a coefficient of determination of
of approximately 0.57. Additionally, the fatigue limit,
, does not undergo significant changes, 660.8 MPa for specimens only turned and 667.3 MPa for specimens turned and polished. The fatigue limit is determined by the arithmetic average of the data set below the stress amplitude level in which the first run-out was observed. Notice that this value of fatigue limit is 1.48 of the Vickers hardness value, which corresponds approximately to the relationship of
[
6]. The low calculated values of
are associated with the high scatter obtained in the zone close to the fatigue limit stress. The parameters obtained for the equation model (
1) consider that the distribution of the points around the mean curve is given by a Gaussian distribution, and hence the outliers increase significantly the scatter of the model.
Regarding the failure probability curves (Equation (
3)) in
Figure 10 obtained from
Table 6, it is verified that the median curve contains most of the failure points for stress amplitudes higher than 700 MPa. In the range of 600 and 800 MPa, it is verified that some failures occur for a failure probability inferior to 25 %. Moving on to the analysis in longer lives, the statistical model cannot contemplate the outliers correctly, as is the case of the polished specimen fractured close to 10
7 cycles.
Regarding the tests carried out under fully-reversed stress conditions at subsonic frequency (150 Hz), for a region of interest from
to 1.0
cycles, a reduction in the resistance coefficient value,
, to 2355 MPa is obtained when compared with results obtained for cyclic rotating bending conditions. The value associated with the regression resistance exponent,
, also decreases slightly to values around -0.09. The coefficient of determination of
= 0.4361 indicates a large variance of the results in relation to the linearised regression model. In fact, from
Figure 11 it is clear that for stress amplitudes below 700 MPa, we will be in the fatigue limit zone and the occurrence of outliers is likely increasing. Under these conditions, regressive models considering distributions based on the outer limits are recommended.
Table 7 summarizes the coefficients of Basquin’s model (equation (
1)).
Increasing the testing frequency to 20 kHz, it is possible to test the spring steel up to 1.0
cycles in a suitable testing time. Analysing the region of interest from 1.0
to 1.0
cycles as shown in
Figure 12, it is verified an increase in the fatigue life scatter of the spring steel for the same stress amplitude. From the regression analysis, the resistance coefficient,
, decreases to half of the value for tension/compression conditions at subsonic frequencies, while the resistance exponent,
, is reduced to one-third of the previously obtained value. Following the same trend, the value of the coefficient of determination also decreases by half to
= 0.2377. This analysis sequence indicates that the regression model is practically not adequate in this analysis region due to the high scatter of the data and the increase of run-outs obtained.
Table 7 summarizes the quantities of Basquin’s model (Equation (
1)) and the respective statistical parameters of the regression.
Since the frequency effect affects the fatigue strength, the frequency sensitivity of spring steel is analysed using the data set presented in
Figure 11 and
Figure 12, 150 Hz and 20 kHz, respectively. Since both data are overlapped, one concludes that the spring steel 51CrV4 has a low sensitivity up to 20 kHz, for the fatigue life region between 1.
to 1
cycles. Quantitatively, the frequency effect can be evaluated by determining the nominal stress,
which does not take into account the frequency effect, and it is given as
where the effective stress,
, is the stress that takes into account the frequency effect, and the correction factor
, that is the ratio,
with
and
denoting respectively the Young’s modulus evaluated for quasi-static conditions and the Young’s modulus evaluated with the existence of frequency effect. For spring steel 51CrV4, the factor
is approximately 0.98, which indicates that there is only a 2 % variation of Young’s modulus when we excite the material at a frequency of 20 kHz. Thus, converting the effective stresses,
, presented in the data of
Figure 12 by the Equation (
6) the stresses are slightly reduced as presented in
Figure 14. From the analysis performed to identify the fatigue limit of 51CrV4 steel under tension/compression conditions, results in
MPa. In similarity to the bending conditions, the fatigue limit is very close to the relationship of
[
6], such that the ratio between
and HV is 1.45.
In is important to note that by applying this correction to the data tested at 20 kHz, the coefficient of determination increased from 0.1202 to 0.1738, also verifying a greater overlapping of the fatigue failure data for stresses between 650 and 700 MPa. Furthermore, for a stress of 650 MPa, one verifies that the first run-out obtained for tests at 150 Hz is almost coincident with the run-out at the lowest stress obtained for 20 kHz. Regarding the resistance parameters, the coefficient
decreased from 1888 to 1572 MPa while the exponent,
, underwent a slight change, changing from -0.0664 to -0.0551.
Table 8 presents the summary of the statistical parameters obtained for each of the regressions.
4.2. CFC Fatigue Model
Although the Basquin SN linear regression model has shown to predict material failure for higher stress amplitudes, that model does not allow a good fitting of the failure probability to low-stress levels. Additionally, the SN model does not take into account the outliers and run-outs in its predictions. To overcome these constraints, the CFC fatigue model using a 3-parameter Weibull distribution is considered.
Figure 15 presents the failure data of smooth fatigue specimens under rotating bending loading conditions in a stress field given by the CFC fatigue model. The estimators determined for the construction of the SN-field presented in
Figure 15 are presented in
Table 9 column 1. According to the results obtained by the estimation methods, a fatigue limit value of 261.0 MPa is estimated for a scale parameter,
, shape parameter,
, and the location parameter
.
Figure 15 shows that the mean curve of the Weibull distribution and the corresponding median curve are very close to the values for the normalized random variable,
v of 12.32 and 12.07, respectively. This proximity indicates that the determined distribution is almost symmetrical with the largest amount of data occurring between the 25th and 75th percentiles % for loads greater than 700 MPa. Concerning stresses lower than or equal to 700 MPa, it appears that the model allows including run-outs up to a failure probability of 99 %. Note that only one of the data points occurs for a failure probability of less than 1 %.
For subsonic and ultrasonic tension/compression fatigue tests, percentile curves illustrated in
Figure 16 were constructed considering the parameters presented in
Table 9 column 2 (considering both failures and run-outs). Notice that the estimate for the 450 MPa run-out that was tested to a life of 10
7 cycles is nearly 10
10 cycles.
According to these obtained results obtained, a fatigue limit value,
C, for the axial tension/compression loading of 319.1 MPa is estimated, which is a higher value, around 22.60 % when compared to the value of
C = 261 MPa for the rotating bending model (see
Figure 15). With respect to the distribution parameters, this model obtained a shape parameter,
of 2.89, a scale parameter,
of 7.21, and a location parameter
of 5.70. Since the
parameter shapes the probability density function, it is expected that for more dispersed data along the SN field, the value of
will be higher. However, these parameters refer to the random variable
V and therefore only the combination of the applied stress, number of cycles and parameters
B and
C can explain this change in values in greater detail. Analysing the failure occurrence zone in more detail, one can observe from
Figure 15 that the mean curve of the distribution and the percentile corresponding to the median are even closer with the greater amount of data occurring between the 5-95 % percentiles.
4.3. Combined Fatigue Model
The combined fatigue model requires that the data sets considered are provided for the same test frequency and type of loading. Regarding the frequency effect, this has already been analysed previously, and no significant influence on fatigue resistance was observed for 20 kHz. With respect to the effect of the type of loading, it is seen in
Table 8 that a higher fatigue strength in the finite life zone when subjected to bending loads. This conclusion is consistent with some previously conducted studies [
50,
51] and engineering design literature [
52] that compare this detrimental effect of axial stress versus bending. In addition, it is also verified that this harmful effect will tend to be greater for lower life regimes.
Despite the differences in fatigue strength for the two types of loads, it is verified that for lower stress amplitudes, there is an overlap of strength data under rotating bending and axial tension/compression stresses. Assuming that in the zone close to the fatigue limit, the loading effect for 51CrV4 steel can be neglected since the fatigue limit for both loading conditions is very close with an average value of 655.16 MPa, and an SN curve is determined containing these data sets.
Figure 17 presents the SN curve and the curves corresponding to the percentiles of the Gaussian function obtained from the experimental data.
Comparing
Figure 17 with
Figure 10 and
Figure 14, it can be observed that there is a certain deviation in the gradient of the SN curve compared to resistance data between the range of 600 and 900 MPa. The obtained SN curve regression parameters were
= 1904 MPa and
= -0.0703 with a
of 0.43. These values are close to those obtained for the SN curves in tension/compression uniform stress, showing the large weight that failure data in the fatigue limit region have on the parameters of the average SN curve.
Table 8- column 3, presents the data used to create the percentile curves of
Figure 17. According to the results obtained, the SN curve with stress amplitude, will not be the most suitable for representing the combined fatigue prediction model of 51CrV4 steel.
Considering the advantages of fitting the CFC model (already shown) on the test data set, the CFC model is now analyzed. For the CFC model with the normalized random variable
V, the joint data of rotating bending and compressive stress/strain alternation were used. The parameters calculated and used to build the CFC model in
Figure 18 are presented in
Table 9-column 3. It should be noted that the introduction of information regarding higher stress amplitudes, in this case, due to fatigue data from rotating bending, allowed the estimated fatigue limit to be changed to 338.4 MPa. However, this increase was only 6.05 %, which indicates that the information obtained by the axial alternating tensile tests has a great impact on the estimation of the fatigue limit of the model. Furthermore, this impact is verified in the scale parameter
which remained at 2.89. Regarding the rest of the parameters, a shape parameter
of 6.35, and a location parameter
= 4.62 were computed. Concerning the percentile curves, again values are very close to the mean curve and median curve, (
v = 10.28 and
v = 10.21, respectively). Furthermore, it is also shown in
Figure 18 that the data set under analysis is all contained in the probabilistic band corresponding to the failure probability of 1 and 99 %.
Thus, from the comparison between the SN and CFC fatigue prediction models, some comparative points can be mentioned. According to
Figure 19, in addition to the fact that the SN model is monotonically decreasing until it vanishes, while the CFC model tends to its limited value
. The percentage curves appear that the median curves and the 25th and 75th percentage curves tend to coincide in the intermediate zone of the analysed data, approximately around 800 MPa, becoming divergent for higher and lower stresses. Another big difference is that the percentile curves obtained by the SN model tend to be conservative for higher stress amplitudes. Furthermore, for long lifetimes, the SN law tends to be non-conservative since it does not consider the effect of run-outs on the SN field estimate. In summary, the CFC model produces a better fatigue strength prediction for both high-cycle and giga-cycle fatigue regimes, and this model is recommended for future predictions.
With respect to specimens tested under fatigue tension/compression loadings, in this region of interest, most fractures occurred due to the initiation of cracks on the surface, except in one case. In this single case, the crack started through a non-metallic inclusion in the interior zone of the specimen. Concerning the tests carried out at a stress of 600 and 700 MPa, the specimens that obtained a life of 5
and 8
cycles, respectively, failed from a "macro" surface scratch contrary to the rest of the specimens. Under these conditions, the probabilistic model given by the normal distribution considering the parameters presented in the
Table 7 subsonic tensile column, encompassed all the test specimens that failed in a failure probability between 5 and 95 %.
4.4. Fracture Surfaces Analysis
Fracture surfaces analysed via SEM for rotating bending specimens (for three distinct applied stress amplitude levels) are illustrated in
Figure 20.
Figure 20A,B are associated with the highest stress amplitude region. It is clear that there is an initiation of multiple cracks around the specimen circumference with crack propagation areas of 6.20 and 7.33 mm
2 and a critical crack length of 0.84 and 0.95 mm, respectively. Some of these cracks along their propagation process merge with other cracks in their vicinity. Additionally, it is visible that some of these cracks produced larger cracks than others. Reducing the load to 816.56 MPa, the occurrence of multiple initiation cracks with different crack lengths is still verified. In this condition, a total crack area of 12.99 mm
2 and a critical crack length of 1.671 mm are measured. In the lowest loaded region (595.67 MPa), the failure mode predominantly occurs by single crack initiation, which propagates to an extent of almost half the specimen diameter as shown in
Figure 20D with 5.07 mm
2 and a length of 1.847 mm.
With respect to specimens tested under fatigue tension/compression loading,
Figure 21 presents the comparison of fracture surfaces for different stress amplitudes of specimens tested at 150 Hz and 20 kHz. One verifies that for higher stresses between 770 and 705 MPa (
Figure 21A and B, respectively), the failure mode occurs mainly by crack initiation on the surface. However, for stress amplitudes below 680 and 670 MPa, a mixed failure mode occurs. Therefore, under these load conditions, crack initiation can occur either on the surface or from in the interior or sub-regions of the specimen from non-metallic inclusions. The occurrence of both situations will depend on several factors such as surface roughness, and inclusion size, among others. In
Figure 21D,E the occurrence of failure with crack initiation in the core of the specimen is verified. While the fracture surface of
Figure 21D exhibits an inclusion with a shallow and elongated shape, the inclusion in the fracture surface of
Figure 21E, has a circular shape.
A more detailed analysis of the fracture surface of
Figure 21D is performed in terms of surface morphology around the non-metallic inclusion.
Figure 22 shows the fracture surface of the fish-eye with details on the morphology in the zones close to the inclusion. Comparing zones A and B (immediately after the inclusion) with zone C (away from the inclusion), the surface roughness is very different. Zone C shows higher roughness than zones A and B. From this verification, it is possible to conclude that the initiation occurs without the formation of a fine-granual-area zone (FGA) [
6]. From the analysis of zone C, fracture micro-mechanisms predominantly by cleavage are visible.
In this region, surface defects become very important for the occurrence of failures or run-outs. As observed for specimens tested under subsonic fatigue conditions (150 Hz) in tension/compression, some failures occurred on the free surface of the specimen or from non-metallic inclusions in the interior of the specimens.
Figure 23 succinctly illustrates the fatigue fracture surfaces observed for different stress amplitude levels from high-cycle to giga-cycle fatigue regime considering the loading type, rotating bending (SRB) and uniaxial tensile/compressive (SAT).