Results
Study 1: Determine if surgical denervation of IBAT changes the ability of the beta 3-adrenergic receptor (β3-AR) agonist, CL 316243, to increase TIBAT in DIO rats.
The goal of this study was to confirm there was no functional defect in the ability of IBAT to respond to direct β3-AR stimulation as a result of the denervation procedure relative to sham operated animals. As expected, HFD-fed rats were borderline obese as determined by both body weight (336.8±7.8 g) and adiposity (99.0±6.7 g fat mass; 28.9±1.3% adiposity) after maintenance on the HFD for approximately 4 months prior to sham/denervation procedures.
All IBAT tissues from Study 1/Study 2 animals were analyzed for IBAT NE content and only 1 out of 5 animals was removed on account of having a failed IBAT denervation procedure. IBAT NE content was reduced in denervated rats by 76.9±2.7% in denervated rats relative to sham-operated control rats [(F(1,10) = 18.975, P=0.001). In contrast, NE content was unchanged in IWAT, EWAT, liver or pancreas in denervated rats relative to sham rats (P=NS). There was no significant difference in body weight between sham and denervation groups at the end of the study (P=NS; data not shown).
In sham rats, CL 316243 (1 mg/kg) increased T
IBAT at 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1, 1.25, 1.5, 1.75, 2, 3 and 4-h post-injection. The lowest dose (0.1 mg/kg) also stimulated T
IBAT at 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1, 1.25, 1.5, 1.75, 2, 3 and 4-h post-injection (
P<0.05;
Figure 1A).
Similarly, in denervated rats, CL 316243 (1 mg/kg) increased T
IBAT at 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1, 1.25, 1.5, 1.75, 2, 3 and 4-h post-injection. The lowest dose (0.1 mg/kg) also stimulated T
IBAT at 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1, 1.25, 1.5, 1.75, 2, 3 and 4-h post-injection (
P<0.05;
Figure 1B).
Importantly, there was no difference in the TIBAT response to CL 316243 (0.1 or 1 mg/kg) when the data were averaged over the 1-h or 4-h post-injection period between sham and denervated rats (P=NS).
Overall, these findings indicate that IBAT denervation did not result in a change in the ability of CL 316243 to increase BAT thermogenesis (surrogate measure of EE) in DIO mice relative to sham operated rats.
In sham rats, CL 316243 reduced daily energy intake at both 0.1 and 1 mg/kg by 42.3 and 51.4% (
P<0.05). Similarly, in denervated rats, CL 316243 also reduced daily energy intake at both 0.1 and 1 mg/kg (
P<0.05) by 46.2 and 50.4% relative to vehicle (
Figure 1C).
CL 316243 did not significantly impact body weight or body weight in either group (
P=NS;
Figure 1D). There was a tendency for the high dose (1 mg/kg) to reduce body weight gain in the sham-operated group but this was not significant (
P=0.111).
Importantly, there was no difference in the effectiveness of CL 316243 (0.1 or 1 mg/kg) to reduce food intake between sham and denervated rats (P=NS).
Overall, these findings indicate that IBAT denervation did not result in a significant change in the ability of CL 316243 to reduce food intake in DIO rats relative to sham operated rats.
Study 2: Determine the extent to which OT-induced activation of sympathetic outflow to IBAT contributes to its ability to increase TIBAT in female HFD-fed rats.
After having confirmed there was no functional defect in the ability of IBAT to respond to direct β3-AR stimulation (Study 3), the goal of this study was to determine if OT-elicited elevation of TIBAT requires intact SNS outflow to IBAT. Three of the sixteen rats available at study onset were euthanized during the course of the study and were excluded from the data analysis.
In sham rats, OT (5 μg) increased T
IBAT at 0.75, 1, 1.25, 1.5, 1.75, and 2-h post-injection (
P<0.05). A lower dose (1 μg) also stimulated T
IBAT at 0.5, 0.75, 1, 1.25, and 1.5-h post-injection (
P<0.05;
Figure 2A).
In denervated rats, OT (5 μg) increased T
IBAT at 1.25, 1.5, 1.75, and 2-h post-injection (
P<0.05) and tended to stimulate T
IBAT at 0.75, and 1-h post-injection (0.05<
P<0.1). The low dose (1 μg) stimulated T
IBAT at 1.75 and 4-h post-injection (0.05<
P<0.1;
Figure 2B).
Importantly, there was no difference in the TIBAT response to 4V OT (5 μg) when the when the data were averaged over the 4-h post-injection period between sham and denervated rats (P=NS).
There were, however, seizures, barrel-rolling and unexpected deaths that occurred in three out of the sixteen rats (1 sham, 2 denervated) shortly after 4V administration of OT at the high dose (5 μg). Rinaman also reported that acute ICV administration of a higher dose (10 μg) also resulted in seizure-like activity and barrel-rolling in a subset of adult male Sprague-Dawley rats [
66]. These findings raise the possibility that females may be more sensitive to the effects of acute injections of 4V OT compared to what we have observed previously at similar doses in males in the absence of such effects [
31,
63]. Thus, following the completion of these studies, we also examined the effectiveness of a lower dose of 4V OT (0.5 μg/μL) on T
IBAT in an identical manner.
In sham rats, 4V OT (0.5 μg/μL) stimulated T
IBAT 1.25-h post-injection (
P<0.05;
Figure 3A) and tended to stimulate T
IBAT at 0.5, 0.75, and 1-h post-injection (0.05<
P<0.1;
Figure 3A). It also tended to reduce T
IBAT at 2-h post-injection (0.05<
P<0.1;
Figure 3A).
In denervated rats, 4V OT (0.5 μg/μL) stimulated T
IBAT 1.25, 1.5 and 4-h post-injection (
P<0.05;
Figure 3B) and tended to stimulate T
IBAT at 0.75 (
P=0.050) and 1.75-h (
P=0.053) post-injection (
Figure 3B). It also increased T
IBAT at 24-h post-injection (
P<0.05; data not shown).
Importantly, there was no difference in the TIBAT response to 4V OT (0.5 μg) at either 1.25-h post-injection or when the data were averaged over the 1-h post-injection between sham and denervated rats (P=NS).
Overall, these findings indicate that IBAT denervation did not result in a significant change in the ability of 4V OT to increase BAT thermogenesis in denervated rats relative to sham operated rats.
Study 3A: Determine the extent to which OT-induced activation of sympathetic outflow to IBAT contributes to its ability to impact body weight in HFD-fed rats.
The goal of this study was to determine if OT-elicited weight loss requires intact SNS outflow to IBAT. Initially, female rats were lean as defined by body weight (230±2.1 g). Similar to Study 1, HFD-fed rats were borderline obese as determined by both body weight (380±8.3 g) and adiposity (126.4±6.4 g fat mass; 32.8±1.0% adiposity) after maintenance on the HFD for at least 4.5 months prior to sham/denervation procedures.
Note that a subset of rats from Study 3 have been analyzed (9 out of 15) for IBAT NE content and all had successful IBAT denervation procedures. All 15 animals were included in the subsequent analyses. IBAT NE content was reduced in a subset of denervated (9 out of 15) rats by 83.1±3.0% relative to a subset of sham-operated control rats (11 out of 15) [(F(1,18) = 64.663, P=0.000)]. In contrast, NE content was unchanged in IWAT, EWAT, liver or pancreas in denervated rats relative to sham rats (P=NS). There was no significant difference in body weight between sham and denervation groups at the beginning of the study prior to minipump implantation (P=NS; data not shown).
As expected, in sham rats, 4V vehicle resulted in 4.5±1.2% weight gain relative to vehicle pre-treatment [(F(1,6) = 14.125,
P=0.009)]. In addition, 4V OT reduced body weight by 5.5±1.3% relative to 4V OT pre-treatment [(F(1,7) = 8.169,
P=0.024)] (
Figure 4A). In addition, 4V OT treatment reduced weight gain throughout the 29-day infusion period over days 9-29 (
P<0.05;
Figure 4B). By the end of the infusion period (infusion day 29), OT had reduced body weight by -18±5.0 g relative to vehicle treated animals (15.0±3.8 g;
P<0.05). OT reduced relative fat mass (pre- vs post-intervention) (
Figure 4C;
P<0.05), fat mass and relative lean mass (pre- vs post-intervention) but had no effect on total lean body mass (
P=NS). These effects that were mediated, at least in part, by a modest reduction of energy intake that was evident during weeks 2 and 3 of the treatment period (
Figure 4D;
P<0.05).
Similar to what was observed in sham animals, 4V vehicle resulted in 8.9±1.2% weight gain relative to vehicle pre-treatment in denervated rats [(F(1,6) = 65.633,
P=0.000)]. In addition, 4V OT also reduced body weight by 4.1±1.0% relative to 4V OT pre-treatment [(F(1,7) = 13.723,
P=0.008)]. (
Figure 4A). In addition, 4V OT reduced weight gain throughout the 29-day infusion period over days 3-29 (
P<0.05;
Figure 4B). By the end of the infusion period (infusion day 29), OT had reduced body weight by -15.9±3.7 g relative to vehicle treated animals (30±2.9 g;
P<0.05). OT reduced relative fat mass (pre- vs post-intervention) (
Figure 4C;
P<0.05) and fat mass (
P<0.05) but had no effect on total lean body mass (
P=NS). These effects that were mediated, at least in part, by a modest reduction of energy intake that persisted during weeks 2 and 3 of the treatment period (
Figure 4D;
P<0.05). OT also tended to reduce energy intake during week 1 (
P=0.052) and 4 (
P=0.075) of the treatment period. There was also no effect of chronic 4V OT to significant increase kaolin consumption during the treatment period (
P=NS; data not shown).
Importantly, there was no difference in the effectiveness of 4V OT to reduce body weight, energy intake, and relative fat mass or fat mass between sham and denervated rats (P=NS).
Similar to what we previously observed following chronic 3V [
31] and 4V [
50] administration in male rats, chronic 4V administration of OT appeared to stimulate T
IBAT (at onset of light cycle) relative to vehicle in sham operated rats when the data were averaged over week 2 of the infusion period (
Table 1A;
P=0.081) and throughout the infusion period in ad libitum fed rats on days 6 (
P=0.068), 12 (
P<0.05) and 21 (
P<0.05).
In order to minimize the potential confounding effects of diet-induced thermogenesis,
T
IBAT was also collected 4 hours later from the same sham operated rats following a 4-h fast. Chronic 4V OT elevated T
IBAT when the data were averaged over week 1 of the infusion period (
Table 1A;
P=0.066) and on infusion days 3 (
P<0.05), 5 (
P<0.05), and 7 (
P<0.05).
In addition, chronic 4V administration of OT also appeared to stimulate T
IBAT in denervated rats when the data were averaged over weeks 3 (
Table 1B;
P=0.054) and 4 (
Table 1B;
P<0.05) and throughout the infusion period on days 15 (
P<0.05), 18 (
P=0.063), 20 (
P=0.057), 21 (
P=0.050), 23 (
P<0.05), 24 (
P<0.05) and 26 (
P<0.05.
Based on these collective findings, we conclude that SNS innervation of IBAT does not appear to be a predominant contributor of OT-elicited reduction of weight gain and adiposity.
We characterized the endocrine and metabolic effects of acute 4V OT (5 μg/μL) in sham HFD-fed rats (
Table 2). Samples from the denervated HFD-fed rats were excluded due to the lack of samples/group for valid comparisons (N=1-2/group). There were no significant differences in any of the plasma measurements between vehicle and 4V OT-treated rats in the sham-operated groups.
Study 3B: Determine the extent to which 4V OT impacts thermogenic gene expression in IBAT and IWAT in female HFD-fed rats.
The goal of this study was to determine if 4V OT elicits changes in thermogenic gene expression in IBAT and EWAT in sham operated rats.
We found that chronic 4V OT treatment elicited a near significant increase in β3-AR mRNA expression (
Adrb3;
P=0.063) and a near significant reduction of Dio2 (
P=0.077;
Table 3A).
4V OT treatment elicited a significant increase of the thermogenic markers, beta 1 adrenergic receptor (β1-AR) (
Adrb1;
P<0.05;
Table 3B) and Cidea (
P<0.05) mRNA expression. 4V OT treatment also elicited a near significant increase in Gpr120 mRNA expression (
P=0.060) as well as a near significant reduction of Dio2 mRNA expression (
P=0.097) in IWAT from sham-operated rats.
Collectively, these findings raise the possibility that different thermogenic markers in IBAT and IWAT may contribute, in part, to the metabolic effects of 4V OT in sham-operated rats.
Study 4A: Determine the effects of chronic 4V OT treatment (16 nmol/day) on body weight, adiposity and energy intake in female DIO C57BL/6J mice.
The goal of this study was to determine the susceptibility of female C57BL/6J to DIO and whether the effects of chronic hindbrain (4V) administration to reduce body weight and adiposity could translate to another female rodent model (female C57BL/6J mice). Initially, mice were lean as defined by both body weight (17.4±0.3 g) and adiposity (2.2±0.2 g fat mass; 12.7±0.8% adiposity). HFD-fed C57BL/6J mice became borderline DIO as determined by both body weight (31.2±1.4 g) and adiposity (11.7±1.2 g fat mass; 36±2.2% adiposity) after maintenance on the HFD for at least 4.5 months prior to being implanted with temperature transponders and minipumps as described earlier. There was no significant difference in body weight or adiposity between vehicle and oxytocin treatment groups at the beginning of the study prior to minipump implantation (P=NS; data not shown). Three of the twenty mice available at study onset were euthanized during the course of the study and were excluded from the data analysis (including one whose head cap had become detached).
The mice that received 4V vehicle tended to gain a modest amount of weight relative to vehicle pre-treatment (
P=0.114). While 4V OT treatment failed to result in weight loss (
P=NS;
Figure 5A), it reduced weight gain on treatment day 8 (
P<0.05) and tended to reduce weight gain on treatment days 5, 7, 9-12, and 23 (0.05<
P<0.1;
Figure 5B). OT reduced relative fat mass (pre- vs post-intervention) (
Figure 5C;
P<0.05) and tended to reduce total lean mass (
P=0.131) but had no effect on relative lean mass (pre- vs post-intervention) or total lean mass (
P=NS). These effects were not associated with significant reductions in energy intake (
Figure 5D;
P=NS) or kaolin intake (
P=NS; data not shown) throughout the treatment period.
In contrast to the effects of observed following chronic 4V infusions of OT (16 nmol/day) in male [
64] and female DIO rats, we found that chronic 4V infusions of OT at the same dose (16 nmol/day) in female C57BL/6J mice largely had no effect significant effects on T
IBAT in ad libitum fed mice when the data were averaged over weeks 1, 2, 3 and 4 of the infusion period (data not shown;
P=NS).
While largely similar results were obtained following a 4-h fast over weeks 1-3 (data not shown; P=NS), there was a tendency for chronic 4V OT to reduce TIBAT over week 4 (P=0.076) in 4-h fasted mice. Specifically, chronic 4V OT reduced TIBAT on infusion days 17, 20, and 25 (P<0.05) and tended to reduce TIBAT on infusion days 13, 23, and 24 (0.05<P<0.1).
We characterized the endocrine and metabolic effects of chronic 4V OT (16 nmol/day) in female C57BL/6J mice (
Table 4). There were no significant differences in any of the plasma measurements between vehicle and 4V OT in female C57BL/6J mice.
Study 4B: Determine the effects of chronic 4V OT treatment (16 nmol/day) on body weight, adiposity and energy intake in female DIO DBA/2J mice.
The goal of this study was to determine the susceptibility of female DBA/2J to DIO and whether the effects of chronic hindbrain (4V) administration to reduce body weight and adiposity could translate to another rodent model (female DBA/2J mice) that is susceptible to becoming DIO [
67,
68]. Initially, mice were lean as defined by both body weight (20.3±0.3 g) and adiposity (3.4±0.3 g fat mass; 16.8±1.1% adiposity). DBA/2J mice became DIO as determined by both body weight (35.8±0.9 g) and adiposity (15.1±0.8 g fat mass; 41.9±1.2% adiposity) after maintenance on the HFD for at least 4.5 months prior to being implanted with temperature transponders and minipumps as described earlier. There was no significant difference in body weight or adiposity between vehicle and oxytocin treatment groups at the beginning of the study prior to minipump implantation (
P=NS; data not shown). Four of the twenty mice available at study onset were euthanized during the course of the study and were excluded from the data analysis (including two whose head caps had become detached).
Unexpectedly, 4V vehicle resulted in 6.4±2.0% weight loss relative to vehicle pre-treatment [(F(1,7) = 12.781,
P=0.009)] whereas 4V OT reduced body weight by 11.9±2.1% relative to 4V OT pre-treatment [(F(1,6) = 24.802,
P=0.003)] (
Figure 6A). In addition, 4V OT treatment reduced weight gain on treatment days 8-10, 12-13, and 15 (
P<0.05) and tended to reduce weight gain on treatment days 4, 5 (P=0.050), 6-7, 11, 14, 19-21, and 23-25 (0.05<
P<0.1;
Figure 6B). OT tended to reduce relative fat mass (pre- vs post-intervention) (
Figure 6C; 0.05<
P<0.1) and total fat mass (P<0.05) but had no effect on adipocyte size (data not shown) or relative lean mass (pre- vs post-intervention) or total lean mass (
P=NS). These effects that were mediated, at least in part, by a modest reduction of energy intake that was evident during weeks 1 and 2 of the treatment period (
Figure 6D;
P<0.05). There was no effect of chronic 4V OT to significant increase kaolin consumption during the treatment period (
P=NS; data not shown).
We characterized the endocrine and metabolic effects of chronic systemic OT (16 and 50 nmol/day) in female DBA/2J mice (
Table 5). There were no significant differences in any of the plasma measurements between vehicle and 4V OT in female DBA/2J mice.
Study 5: Determine the effects of chronic systemic OT treatment (16 and 50 nmol/day) on body weight, adiposity and energy intake in female DIO DBA/2J mice
The goal of this study was to extend the findings from Study 4B and determine the extent to which systemic (subcutaneous) infusion of a centrally effective dose of OT (16 nmol/day) can reduce body weight and adiposity in female DBA/2J mice (same strain used in Study 4B). DBA/2J mice became DIO as determined by both body weight (32.2±0.9 g) and adiposity (12.7±0.7 g fat mass; 38.7±1.2% adiposity) after maintenance on the HFD for at least 4.5 months prior to being implanted with temperature transponders. There was no significant difference in body weight or adiposity between vehicle and oxytocin treatment groups at the beginning of the study prior to minipump implantation (P=NS; data not shown).
In contrast to chronic 4V OT treatment in female DBA/2J mice (
Study 4B), chronic SC OT treatment did not result in a significant reduction of body weight (
Figure 7A). SC OT treatment (16 nmol/day) reduced weight gain on treatment days 2-3 (
P<0.05) and tended to reduce weight gain on treatment day 1 (P=0.138;
Figure 7B). The higher dose (50 nmol/day) also reduced weight gain on treatment days 1-3 and tended to increase body weight gain on treatment days 4 (
P=0.055), 5 (
P=0.106), 7 (
P=0.077), 8 (
P=0.051) and 9 (
P=0.092) (
Figure 7B). There was no effect of SC OT at either dose on relative fat mass or lean mass (pre- vs post-intervention) (
Figure 7C). OT (50 nmol/day) produced a transient reduction of energy intake during week 2 (
Figure7D;
P<0.05) but OT failed to impact energy intake at any other time. There was also no effect of chronic SC OT to significant increase kaolin consumption during weeks 2-4 of the treatment period (
P=NS; data not shown) but a slight reduction of kaolin intake during week 1 in response to the higher dose 50 nmol/day (
P=0.016; data not shown).
In contrast to chronic 4V administration, chronic systemic administration of OT (16 and 50 nmol/day) reduced T
IBAT relative to vehicle in ad libitum fed mice when the data were averaged over weeks 3 and 4 (
Table 6A;
P<0.05) of the infusion period. Similar results were obtained from the same mice following a 4-h fast over the same period (
Table 6B;
P<0.05).
In addition to the findings in DIO female DBA/2J mice, we found that there appeared to be a very modest effect of chronic systemic OT (16 nmol/day) to reduce TIBAT in 4-h fasted male DIO (C57Bl/6J) mice on infusion day 9 (P<0.05) and tended to reduce TIBAT on days 10 (0.05<P<0.1), 14 (0.05<P<0.1), and 21 (P=0.05) (data not shown; unpublished findings). Likewise, OT (50 nmol/day) tended to reduce TIBAT in 4-h fasted C57Bl/6J mice on infusion day 4 (P<0.05) and tended to reduce TIBAT on infusion day 21 (0.05<P<0.1). In contrast, we found that OT (100 nmol/day) tended to increase TIBAT on infusion day 13 (0.05<P<0.1), but this was only evident in ad libitum fed C57Bl/6J mice but not in 4-h fasted mice.
We characterized the endocrine and metabolic effects of chronic systemic OT (16 and 50 nmol/day) in female DBA/2J mice (
Table 7). There was a significant increase in plasma glucagon in response to SC OT (16 nmol/day) in female DBA/2J mice. There tended to be a non-significant increase in total cholesterol in response to systemic infusion of OT at both 16 (
P=0.057) and 50 nmol/day (
P=0.062). In addition, OT (50 nmol/day) also tended to produce a non-significant increase in plasma leptin (
P=0.092). and FGF-21 (P=0.051).