Submitted:
26 August 2024
Posted:
27 August 2024
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
Keywords:
1. Introduction
2. Materials and Methods
1.1. Theoretical Analysis and Research Hypotheses
1.1.1. The Impact of New Digital Infrastructure on Green Agricultural Development
1.1.2. New Digital Infrastructure and Green Agricultural Development: The Mediating Role of Land and Technological Factors
1.1.3. New Digital Infrastructure and Green Agricultural Development: The Regulatory Role of Labor Factors
1.2. Variable Description
1.2.1. Explained variable: Agricultural Green Total Factor Productivity (GTFP)
1.2.2. Core Explanatory Variable: Digital Infrastructure Development Level (DI)
1.2.3. Mediating and Moderating Variables
1.2.4. Control Variables
1.3. Data Sources and Descriptive Statistics
1.4. Model Settings
1.4.1. Benchmark Regression Model
1.4.2. Mediation and Moderation Models
1.4.3. moderated mediation effect model
3. Results
2.1. New Digital Infrastructure and Agricultural Green Total Factor Productivity
2.2. The Mediating Effect of Land Factors and the Moderating Effect of Labor Factors
2.3. Mediating Effect with Regulation - The Mediating Effect of Labor Factors Regulating Technological Factors
2.4. Further Heterogeneity Analysis
2.4.1. Geographical differences
2.4.2. Market Environment Differences
2.4.3. policy Environment Differences
4. Discussion
5. Conclusions
Author Contributions
Funding
Conflicts of Interest
References
- Wei Qi, Zhang Bin, Jin Shuqin. Construction and Regional Comparison of China’s Agricultural Green Development Index [J]. Agricultural Economic Issues, 2018, No. 467 (11): 11-20.
- Gao Ming, Zhang Zhexi. Positioning and Policy Suggestions for Green Agricultural Development in China under the Goals of Carbon Peak and Carbon Neutrality [J]. Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2022(01): 24-31.
- Jin Shuqin, Niu Kunyu, Han Dongmei. The path of green agricultural development and its “14th Five Year Plan” orientation [J]. Reform, 2020, No.312 (02): 30-39.
- Yu Fawen. Research on the Motivation, Core and Countermeasures of Green Agricultural Development in the New Era [J]. China Rural Economy, 2018 (05): 19-34.
- Zhu Zhiyong, Liu Changchang. The impact of new digital infrastructure on urban-rural income gap and its threshold effect [J]. Journal of South China Agricultural University (Social Sciences Edition), 2022, 21 (05): 126-140.
- Qian Xiaojing, Xue Zhixin, Sun Yiming. How New Digital Infrastructure Affects the Upgrading of Foreign Trade: Empirical Evidence from Chinese Cities at or above the Prefectural Level [J]. Economic Science, 2020, No.237 (03): 46-59.
- Yang Qian, Wang Jue, Li Chao, et al. Spatial differentiation and driving factors of green total factor productivity in China’s agriculture [J]. Quantitative Economic and Technological Research, 2019, 36 (10): 21-37.
- Zhao Huijie, Yu Fawen. Evaluation of Agricultural Green Development Level in Main Grain Production Areas Based on Entropy Method [J]. Reform, 2019 (11): 136-146.
- Tang Yifan, Wu Bo. Does Financial Support for Agriculture Promote Green Agricultural Development? — An Empirical Test Based on the PVAR Model [J]. Journal of Hunan Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2022, 23(06): 46-54.
- Li Minjie, Wang Jian The Quality of Foreign Direct Investment and the Growth of Green Total Factor Productivity in Chinese Agriculture [J] Soft Science, 2019, 33 (9): 13-20.
- Liu Yiwen, Ouyang Ying, Cai Hongyu. Measurement and spatiotemporal evolution characteristics of green total factor productivity in Chinese agriculture [J]. Quantitative Economic and Technological Research, 2021,38 (05): 39-56.
- Fan Shengyue, Li Yaolong, Ma Xiaojie, et al. An Empirical Study on the Impact of Digitalization Level on Green Agricultural Development — Based on Panel Data from 30 Provinces in China [J]. World Agriculture, 2021(12): 4-16.
- Shi Zhou, Liang Zongzheng, Yang Yuanyuan, et al. Current Status and Prospects of Agricultural Remote Sensing Research [J]. Journal of Agricultural Machinery, 2015,46 (02): 247-260.
- Xu Guangyue. Research on the Development of Low Carbon Agriculture in China [J]. Economist, 2010 (10): 72-78.
- Zhao Chunjiang, Li Jin, Feng Xian, etc Application Status and Development Trend of “Internet plus” Modern Agriculture at Home and Abroad [J]. China Engineering Science, 2018,20 (02):50-56.
- Tan Qiucheng. Green Agriculture as a Production Method [J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2015,25 (09): 44-51.
- Yang Jianli, Zheng Wenling, Xing Jiaoyang, Jin Wenwen. Empowering high-quality agricultural development with digital technology [J]. Shanghai Economic Research, 2021 (07): 81-90+104.
- Zhang Junling, Zhang Jiangzhou, Shen Jianbo, et al. Soil Health and Green Agricultural Development: Opportunities and Strategies [J]. Acta Pedologica Sinica, 2020, 57(04): 783-796.
- Zhao Xing. Research on the Technological Innovation Effect of New Digital Infrastructure [J]. Statistical Research, 2022, 39 (4): 13.
- Lv Na, Zhu Lizhi. Research on China’s Agricultural Environmental Technology Efficiency and Green Total Factor Productivity Growth [J]. Agricultural Technology and Economics, 2019 (04): 95-103.
- Li Zhou. Green Development of Agriculture in China: Innovation and Evolution [J]. Chinese Rural Economy, 2023(02): 2-16.
- Zhu Qingying, Chen Yinrong, Hu Weiyan, et al. Social capital, farmland value cognition, and farmers’ willingness to pay for farmland protection: an empirical study based on a moderated mediation effect model [J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2019,29 (11): 120-131.
- Wu Jing, Wang Tianyu, Wang Zhengbing. The Impact of Social Networks and Perceived Value on Farmers’ Choice of Farmland Quality Protection Behavior [J]. Journal of Northwest A&F University (Social Science Edition), 2021,21 (06): 138-147.
- Guo Junhua, Ni Ming, Li Bangyi. Research on Agricultural Production Efficiency Based on a Three Stage DEA Model [J]. Quantitative Economic and Technological Research, 2010,27 (12):27-38.
- Ma Guoqun, Tan Yanwen. Research on the Impact of Environmental Regulations on Agricultural Green Total Factor Productivity: Analysis Based on Panel Threshold Model [J]. Agricultural Technology and Economics, 2021 (05): 77-92.
- Li Zhaoliang, Luo Xiaofeng, Xue Longfei, Zhang Junbiao. Analysis of regional differences and influencing factors of green agricultural production efficiency in China [J]. Journal of China Agricultural University, 2017, 22 (10): 203-212.
- Zhou Li, Feng Jianming, Cao Guangqiao. Research on the adoption behavior of green agricultural technology by farmers: A case study of farmer surveys in Hunan, Jiangxi, and Jiangsu [J]. Rural Economy, 2020 (03): 93-101.
- Yang Lijun. Inspiration of Israel’s Modern Agricultural Development Experience on China’s Agricultural Supply Side Reform [J]. Economic Review, 2016 (06): 111-114.
- Wu Xuelian, Zhang Junbiao, Feng Junhui. Factors influencing farmers’ perception of green agricultural technology and their hierarchical structure decomposition: based on the Probit ISM model [J]. Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2017 (05): 36-45+145.
- Li Houjian. Empirical analysis of the influencing factors of farmers’ willingness to adopt circular agriculture technology [J]. China Rural Observation, 2012 (02): 28-36+66.
- Liu Hongmei, Wang Keqiang, Huang Zhijun. Analysis of factors influencing the adoption of water-saving irrigation technology by Chinese farmers [J]. China Rural Economy, 2008 (04):44-54.
- Zhai Jinliang. Characteristics, problems and development strategies of transformation of agricultural scientific and technological achievements in China [J]. Journal of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2015,30 (03): 378-385.
- Ke Bingsheng, Chen Huaning. Reflections on Cultivating New Farmers [J]. China Party and Government Cadre Forum, 2006 (04): 36-38.
- Chen Chao, Zhou Ning. The impact of cultural differences among farmers on agricultural production and technology selection channels: an analysis based on a survey questionnaire of farmers in ten provinces across the country [J]. China Rural Economy, 2007 (09): 33-38.
- Yang Wenzhi. The Quality of Agricultural Workers in China Faces Challenges from Joining the WTO [J]. Agricultural Economic Issues, 2002 (01): 28-33.
- Ge Pengfei, Wang Songji, Huang Xiulu. Measurement of Green Total Factor Productivity in Chinese Agriculture [J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2018,28 (05): 66-74.
- Fan Hejun, Wu Ting. New Digital Infrastructure, Digital Capability, and Total Factor Productivity [J]. Economic and Management Research, 2022 (1): 3-22.
- Wen Zhonglin, Zhang Lei, Hou Jietai. Mediated moderating variables and moderated mediating variables [J]. Journal of Psychology, 2006 (03): 448-452.
- Liang Jun, Long Shaobo. Growth of Agricultural Green Total Factor Productivity and Its Influencing Factors [J]. Journal of South China Agricultural University (Social Sciences Edition), 2015,14 (03): 1-12.
- Lin Li, Li Jing, Xiao Bo. Will the willingness of farmers to adopt green production technologies be market driven or government driven? [J] Economic issues, 2021 (12): 67-74.
- Chen Zhuanqing. The Impact of Policy and Market Orientation on Farmers’ Green Production: An Empirical Analysis Based on 865 Farmers in Henan [J]. Journal of Management Sciences, 2021, 34(05): 109-125.
- Du Wencui, Zhang Pingdan, Zhu Song. Agricultural marketization, agricultural modernization, and environmental pollution [J]. Journal of Beijing Institute of Technology (Social Sciences Edition), 2016,18 (01): 1-9.
- Jie Xuemei, Zhu Qiwei. How can green innovation practices in enterprises solve the problem of “harmonious coexistence”? [J] Managing the World, 2021, 37 (1): 23.
- Yu Honghai, Xu Longbing, Chen Baizhu. Ultimate controlling shareholder control and excessive investment in free cash flow [J]. Economic Research, 2010 (8): 12.
- Guo Haihong, Li Shuchao. Environmental Regulation, Spatial Effects, and Green Agricultural Development [J]. Journal of Research and Development Management, 2022, 34(02): 54-67.
- Gao Fan. The Evolution Trends and Influencing Factors of Regional Agricultural Total Factor Productivity in China: An Empirical Analysis Based on Inter provincial Panel Data [J]. Quantitative Economic and Technological Research, 2015,32 (05): 3-19+53.

| Indicator category | Factor | meaning | unit |
| Input metrics | Labor input | Number of people employed in agriculture | Ten thousand person |
| Land resource input | Crop sown area | Thousand hectares | |
| Agricultural machinery inputs | Total power of agricultural machinery | Ten thousand kW | |
| Fertilizer inputs | The amount of chemical fertilizer applied (converted to pure). | Ten thousand tons | |
| Agricultural film inputs | The amount of agricultural film used | Ten thousand tons | |
| Pesticide inputs | Pesticide application rate | Ten thousand tons | |
| Irrigation inputs | Agricultural water use | Billion cubic meters | |
| Output indicators | Expected output | Gross agricultural output | Billion yuan |
| Undesired outputs | Agricultural carbon emissions | Ten thousand tons |
| Primary index | Secondary index | Unit of measurement | Index type |
| Capital | Length of long distance optical cable line | Ten thousand kilometers | Positive |
| Mobile phone exchange capacity | Ten thousand households | Positive | |
| Number of broadband Internet access ports | Ten thousand | Positive | |
| Data | Number of Domains | Ten thousand | Positive |
| Number of pages | Ten thousand | Positive | |
| Internet penetration | % | Positive | |
| Mobile phone penetration | Per hundred people | Positive |
| Variable | Observed value | Mean value | Standard deviation | Minimum value | Maximum value |
| GTFP | 510 | 2.248 | 1.488 | 0.488 | 1.807 |
| GEC | 510 | 0.948 | 0.300 | 0.241 | 0.974 |
| GTC | 510 | 2.566 | 1.714 | 0.757 | 1.975 |
| LQ | 510 | 0.365 | 0.234 | 0.070 | 1.800 |
| TL | 510 | 9.779 | 1.660 | 4.575 | 13.679 |
| WQ | 510 | 2.191 | 0.111 | 1.886 | 2.548 |
| DI | 510 | -0.000 | 0.578 | -0.902 | -0.101 |
| DR | 510 | 0.182 | 0.145 | 0.000 | 0.147 |
| MD | 510 | 0.623 | 0.251 | 0.220 | 0.563 |
| FS | 510 | 0.659 | 0.141 | 0.355 | 0.667 |
| ED | 510 | 5.796 | 0.898 | 2.472 | 5.994 |
| AS | 510 | 0.747 | 2.261 | 0.008 | 0.083 |
| Variable | (1) | (2) | (3) | (4) | (5) | (6) |
| GTFP | GEC | GTC | GTFP | GEC | GTC | |
| DI | 2.4076*** | -0.0624*** | 2.8491*** | 2.9916*** | 0.0300 | 3.0464*** |
| (26.7768) | (-3.0966) | (27.2769) | (16.4030) | (0.7678) | (14.5148) | |
| DR | -0.7825** | 0.0417 | -1.2665*** | |||
| (-2.0499) | (0.5092) | (-2.8831) | ||||
| MD | -0.6546 | 0.1179 | -1.0191** | |||
| (-1.5483) | (1.2994) | (-2.0947) | ||||
| FS | -2.6961** | -0.9048*** | -0.2458 | |||
| (-2.1164) | (-3.3109) | (-0.1677) | ||||
| ED | -0.3958*** | -0.0943*** | -0.1013 | |||
| (-3.5328) | (-3.9222) | (-0.7855) | ||||
| AS | -0.1326*** | 0.0418*** | -0.2095*** | |||
| (-3.6575) | (5.3820) | (-5.0236) | ||||
| Constant term | 2.2485*** | 0.9478*** | 2.5655*** | 6.9704*** | 1.9786*** | 4.3375*** |
| (57.4113) | (108.0649) | (56.3907) | (6.5402) | (8.6536) | (3.5365) | |
| Sample size | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 |
| R2 | 0.574 | -0.042 | 0.584 | 0.600 | 0.101 | 0.616 |
| Variable | (1) | (2) | (3) | (4) | (5) | (6) | (7) | (8) | (9) |
| GTFP | GEC | GTC | GTFP | GEC | GTC | GTFP | GEC | GTC | |
| DI | 3.4947*** | 0.0452 | 3.5633*** | 4.0780*** | 0.0298 | 4.2610*** | 3.7044*** | 0.0391 | 3.7477*** |
| (16.2837) | (1.0123) | (14.5043) | (15.7596) | (0.5868) | (14.3951) | (15.3970) | (0.8177) | (13.6591) | |
| DR | -0.8804** | -0.0500 | -1.1168** | -0.9583** | -0.0607 | -0.9670* | -0.9828** | -0.0601 | -1.0007** |
| (-2.1659) | (-0.5920) | (-2.4004) | (-2.1905) | (-0.7069) | (-1.9324) | (-2.2717) | (-0.6999) | (-2.0283) | |
| MD | -0.5853 | 0.1187 | -0.9662* | -0.4909 | 0.1105 | -0.8371 | -0.5345 | 0.1115 | -0.8970* |
| (-1.3388) | (1.3059) | (-1.9306) | (-1.0635) | (1.2185) | (-1.5855) | (-1.1713) | (1.2307) | (-1.7237) | |
| FS | -2.9524** | -1.0286*** | -0.2950 | -2.8480* | -1.1227*** | 0.0894 | -3.0034* | -1.1188*** | -0.1241 |
| (-2.0831) | (-3.4900) | (-0.1818) | (-1.8156) | (-3.6438) | (0.0498) | (-1.9366) | (-3.6321) | (-0.0702) | |
| ED | -0.6493*** | -0.1354*** | -0.2609 | -0.9765*** | -0.1414*** | -0.5515** | -0.7461*** | -0.1471*** | -0.2350 |
| (-4.4401) | (-4.4512) | (-1.5585) | (-5.1555) | (-3.8019) | (-2.5454) | (-4.1582) | (-4.1287) | (-1.1484) | |
| AS | -0.1444*** | 0.0420*** | -0.2232*** | -0.1570*** | 0.0413*** | -0.2401*** | -0.1475*** | 0.0410*** | -0.2271*** |
| (-3.7982) | (5.3136) | (-5.1289) | (-3.8890) | (5.2030) | (-5.2005) | (-3.7002) | (5.1810) | (-4.9958) | |
| Constant term | 8.5844*** | 2.3216*** | 5.2147*** | 10.3781*** | 2.4316*** | 6.5244*** | 9.1556*** | 2.4619*** | 4.8449*** |
| (6.7472) | (8.7757) | (3.5805) | (6.6860) | (7.9757) | (3.6745) | (6.0701) | (8.2177) | (2.8166) | |
| Sample size | 480 | 480 | 480 | 450 | 450 | 450 | 450 | 450 | 450 |
| R2 | 0.6232 | 0.1821 | 0.6405 | 0.6076 | 0.1812 | 0.6227 | 0.6163 | 0.1811 | 0.6333 |
| Variable | (1) | (2) | (3) | (4) | (5) | (6) | (7) | (8) | (9) |
| GTFP | GEC | GTC | GTFP | GEC | GTC | GTFP | GEC | GTC | |
| DI | 3.0832*** | 0.0275 | 3.0915*** | 2.7377*** | 0.0402 | 3.5585*** | 16.1740*** | -0.0864 | 17.5805*** |
| (16.7699) | (0.7220) | (14.5350) | (19.7133) | (0.9045) | (15.3674) | (19.3708) | (-0.4510) | (18.8248) | |
| DR | -0.7942** | 0.0555 | -1.2677*** | -1.0138*** | 0.0571 | -1.6307*** | -0.4854 | 0.0310 | -0.9031** |
| (-2.1048) | (0.7105) | (-2.9042) | (-3.5442) | (0.6249) | (-3.4190) | (-1.3543) | (0.3774) | (-2.2528) | |
| MD | -0.7285* | 0.0338 | -1.1055** | -0.7907** | 0.1168 | -1.1496** | -0.6057 | 0.1130 | -0.9456** |
| (-1.7432) | (0.3907) | (-2.2866) | (-2.4410) | (1.1283) | (-2.1283) | (-1.5315) | (1.2456) | (-2.1376) | |
| FS | -3.0363** | -0.7701*** | -0.6408 | -3.5076*** | -1.6720*** | 0.3190 | -2.7790** | -0.9242*** | -0.2475 |
| (-2.4393) | (-2.9900) | (-0.4450) | (-4.1450) | (-6.1810) | (0.2261) | (-2.3334) | (-3.3822) | (-0.1858) | |
| ED | -0.4357*** | -0.0871*** | -0.1108 | -0.4000*** | -0.0992*** | -0.3732*** | -0.9348*** | -0.0692** | -0.7863*** |
| (-3.8144) | (-3.6858) | (-0.8386) | (-4.7879) | (-3.7147) | (-2.6793) | (-7.7138) | (-2.4875) | (-5.8013) | |
| AS | -0.1520*** | 0.0286*** | -0.2373*** | 0.4806** | 0.1665*** | -0.1705 | -0.1040*** | 0.0434*** | -0.1860*** |
| (-3.8519) | (3.5059) | (-5.1968) | (2.5801) | (2.7972) | (-0.5489) | (-3.0977) | (5.6276) | (-4.9511) | |
| Constant term | 7.4910*** | 1.9046*** | 4.7261*** | 7.2713*** | 2.4588*** | 5.6667*** | 5.7050*** | 1.8727*** | 3.4644*** |
| (7.1401) | (8.7737) | (3.8939) | (9.7118) | (10.2735) | (4.5391) | (5.9564) | (8.5221) | (3.2339) | |
| Sample size | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 |
| R2 | 0.613 | 0.065 | 0.625 | 0.720 | 0.073 | 0.625 | 0.650 | 0.100 | 0.683 |
| Variable | (1) | (2) | (3) | (4) |
| LQ | GTFP | GTC | LQ | |
| DI | 0.2083*** | 2.2817*** | 3.0464*** | 0.1685*** |
| (11.3422) | (11.8002) | (14.5148) | (8.3373) | |
| DR | -0.0708* | -0.5412 | -1.2665*** | -0.0659* |
| (-1.8421) | (-1.5024) | (-2.8831) | (-1.7305) | |
| MD | 0.1479*** | -1.1589*** | -1.0191** | 0.1565*** |
| (3.4757) | (-2.8788) | (-2.0947) | (3.7434) | |
| FS | -1.0569*** | 0.9065 | -0.2458 | -0.9919*** |
| (-8.2407) | (0.7078) | (-0.1677) | (-7.7730) | |
| ED | 0.0291** | -0.4950*** | -0.1013 | 0.0360*** |
| (2.5777) | (-4.6654) | (-0.7855) | (2.6114) | |
| AS | -0.0016 | -0.1270*** | -0.2095*** | -0.0080* |
| (-0.4468) | (-3.7260) | (-5.0236) | (-1.7404) | |
| LQ | 3.4086*** | |||
| (7.9461) | ||||
| Inter1 | 0.2675** | |||
| (2.0451) | ||||
| WQ | 0.3593** | |||
| (2.5443) | ||||
| Constant term | 0.8151*** | 4.1919*** | 4.3375*** | 0.7246*** |
| (7.5968) | (3.9495) | (3.5365) | (5.9726) | |
| Sample size | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 |
| R2 | 0.701 | 0.646 | 0.616 | 0.712 |
| Variable | (1) | (2) | (3) | (4) | (5) | (6) | (7) | (8) |
| GTFP | GEC | GTC | TL | GTFP | GTC | GTFP | GTC | |
| CDI | 2.8571*** | 0.0402 | 2.8448*** | 0.6877*** | 2.2389*** | 1.8591*** | 2.0213*** | 1.7317*** |
| (15.5140) | (1.0071) | (13.5487) | (9.2853) | (11.9793) | (9.4283) | (9.2696) | (7.5071) | |
| WQ | 3.2199*** | -0.2443 | 4.8268*** | 2.0727*** | 1.3567 | 1.8559** | 0.9969 | 1.6453* |
| (3.5405) | (-1.2380) | (4.6550) | (5.6671) | (1.5467) | (2.0054) | (1.1144) | (1.7387) | |
| DR | -0.6977* | 0.0353 | -1.1394*** | -0.7425*** | -0.0303 | -0.0752 | -0.0564 | -0.0905 |
| (-1.8462) | (0.4300) | (-2.6445) | (-4.8854) | (-0.0837) | (-0.1971) | (-0.1564) | (-0.2371) | |
| MD | -0.7774* | 0.1272 | -1.2032** | -0.6830*** | -0.1635 | -0.2243 | -0.1022 | -0.1884 |
| (-1.8547) | (1.3982) | (-2.5177) | (-4.0517) | (-0.4108) | (-0.5342) | (-0.2566) | (-0.4474) | |
| FS | -2.0016 | -0.9575*** | 0.7953 | -1.1666** | -0.9529 | 2.4674* | -1.6065 | 2.0849 |
| (-1.5712) | (-3.4639) | (0.5476) | (-2.2772) | (-0.7971) | (1.9563) | (-1.2960) | (1.5898) | |
| ED | -0.5431*** | -0.0831*** | -0.3220** | 0.7059*** | -1.1777*** | -1.3339*** | -1.0606*** | -1.2654*** |
| (-4.5922) | (-3.2383) | (-2.3883) | (14.8432) | (-8.8123) | (-9.4605) | (-7.2397) | (-8.1645) | |
| AS | -0.1052*** | 0.0398*** | -0.1686*** | -0.0130 | -0.0935*** | -0.1499*** | -0.1216*** | -0.1663*** |
| (-2.8730) | (5.0035) | (-4.0365) | (-0.8843) | (-2.7334) | (-4.1524) | (-3.2763) | (-4.2368) | |
| TL | 0.8989*** | 1.4333*** | 0.9423*** | 1.4587*** | ||||
| (8.4235) | (12.7308) | (8.6626) | (12.6760) | |||||
| Inter2 | 0.5927* | 0.3469 | ||||||
| (1.9226) | (1.0637) | |||||||
| Constant term | 7.4067*** | 1.9455*** | 4.9915*** | -2.7516*** | 9.8801*** | 8.9355*** | 9.5616*** | 8.7491*** |
| (6.9859) | (8.4559) | (4.1293) | (-6.4535) | (9.5717) | (8.2050) | (9.1714) | (7.9328) | |
| Sample size | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 | 510 |
| R2 | 0.609 | 0.102 | 0.632 | 0.884 | 0.660 | 0.726 | 0.662 | 0.726 |
| Grouping variable | Dependent variable | Coefficient | Standard error | Control variable | Sample size | R2 | |
| Agricultural environment | north | GTFP | 3.5579*** | 11.5781 | Controlled | 204 | 0.635 |
| GEC | -0.0834 | -1.1833 | Controlled | 0.273 | |||
| GTC | 4.2025*** | 11.6154 | Controlled | 0.663 | |||
| south | GTFP | 2.3047*** | 8.9874 | Controlled | 255 | 0.66 | |
| GEC | -0.1184*** | -2.7029 | Controlled | 0.066 | |||
| GTC | 2.4099*** | 10.1046 | Controlled | 0.686 | |||
| northwest | GTFP | 5.8726*** | 7.1469 | Controlled | 255 | 0.581 | |
| GEC | -0.184 | -1.0645 | Controlled | 0.624 | |||
| GTC | 12.0077*** | 11.6154 | Controlled | 0.8 | |||
| Market environment | Developed | GTFP | 2.7588*** | 12.1526 | Controlled | 255 | 0.644 |
| GEC | -0.0158 | -0.3635 | Controlled | 0.176 | |||
| GTC | 2.9363*** | 10.7359 | Controlled | 0.59 | |||
| underdeveloped | GTFP | 5.1217*** | 13.7492 | Controlled | 255 | 0.642 | |
| GEC | -0.0396 | -0.4316 | Controlled | 0.163 | |||
| GTC | 5.7180*** | 14.4343 | Controlled | 0.734 | |||
| Policy environment | Developed | GTFP | 4.2320*** | 11.0244 | Controlled | 255 | 0.641 |
| GEC | -0.2524** | -2.0953 | Controlled | 0.162 | |||
| GTC | 6.3850*** | 11.9027 | Controlled | 0.708 | |||
| comparatively developed | GTFP | 3.0323*** | 8.2303 | Controlled | 255 | 0.626 | |
| GEC | 0.1318** | 2.0521 | Controlled | 0.358 | |||
| GTC | 2.7077*** | 6.9636 | Controlled | 0.56 | |||
| Underdeveloped | GTFP | 2.6195*** | 9.6881 | Controlled | 255 | 0.62 | |
| GEC | 0.0451 | 1.0867 | Controlled | 0.235 | |||
| GTC | 2.6181*** | 8.9141 | Controlled | 0.667 | |||
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).