Submitted:
25 August 2024
Posted:
26 August 2024
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
Keywords:
1. Introduction
2. Architectural Description of the Great Throne Hall


3. The Geological Nature of the Area
4. Factors Affecting the Deterioration of the Great Throne Hall
4.1. Natural Factors

4.2. Human Factors
- the fire in 1972 that destroyed the truss and the false ceiling figure. 4.
- deterioration of the means of drainage and nutrition, which leads to water leakage.
- pollution from workshops, factories, car exhaust, and encroachment of buildings near the castle.
- inconsistency between the agencies supervising the historical buildings.

5. Structural Study for Restoration and Consolidation
5.1. Building Pattern and Configureuration Elements
5.2. Structure of the Great Throne Hall
5.3. Previous Stages of the Restoration of Al-Jawhara Palace
6. A Study of the Most Important Manifestations of Damage in the Great throne Hall and the Reasons that Led to Its Emergence and Its Current and Future Impact
6.1. The Cracks in the Structure of the Great throne Hall Figure 5

6.2. Analysis of the Causes of Cracking of the Structure
- on the other hand, the earthquake in 1992 helped to cause cracks and the inclination of some marble columns in the facade of the palace. it also led to the separation of large parts of the walls and the creation of deep cracks in them. the earthquake helped move the soil between the eastern and western parts of the building, in addition to the different conditions of foundation over old foundations or over heterogeneous stone layers between the two parts (eastern and western) [3].
- it also helped to descend the foundation layers, a defect in the sewage lines adjacent to the palace and the leakage of sewage water and the harmful salt it carries to the ground and to the foundation layers of buildings, which include a percentage of water-vulnerable clay soil [49].
- the presence of the foundations on shallow depths and their reliance on old buildings that were built and presented in earlier stages also on deep layers of backfill that include the clay child, which is known to be susceptible to water, and has helped to be severely affected by the water leaking from rain and garden irrigation, as well as the water leaking from the sewage network dilapidated health .
- there is a difference in the nature of the soil bearing the foundations of the palace units; as the nature of the soil for the western part of the palace is coherent soil because it is located on the slope of the mountain. it differs from the nature of the soil in the eastern part, which is located on weak backfill layers that were affected by the leaking ground water. in addition, the foundations of the units were built in the depth of the units on the remains of old buildings that had previously been demolished [3].
- there is a difference in the levels of the floors of the buildings that descend from west to east, and therefore the different levels of foundation for the palace buildings between the eastern and western parts have doubled the impact of the earthquakes with successive earthquakes and the horizontal forces they caused in the ground, which helped the foundation layers to crawl under the building units [49].
- on the other hand, the western part of the palace is surrounded by the old walls of the citadel, which extends to the depth, and led to the escaping of the soil in this part, while the eastern part is surrounded by empty spaces used in planting green areas and thus saturation of the soil with water, which helped to find loose soil in this parts, thus led to the movement of the layers of the earth from the solid part ruled by the old walls extending to the depth to the soft part at the east, especially after the occurrence of ground movements in the 1992 ad earthquake [3].
- a gap of about 5.00 m in diameter and 4.00 m in depth was detected in the space area of the northeastern corner outside the palace area, which confirms our analysis of the high items of the movement of the earth and the difference in the nature of the soil between the eastern and western parts of the area under study [3,49].
- it is not possible to detect the foundations at their full length below the walls, so when starting the repair, exploratory excavations must be made at different distances along the walls in areas where there are cracks in the walls above [25].
6.3. Renovation Steps for Walls and Their Foundations
6.4. Restoration Works of Walls and Their Associated Foundations
6.4.1. Repair Work for Cracks in the Walls [30]
- simple lattice cracks that appeared with layers of whiteness, and these cracks must be detected to determine the extent of their continuity in the buildings themselves. its components are with the original stones and mortar, and the necessary tests must be done on the components and on the mortar mixture [35].
- small-thickness window cracks in the walls (less than 50 cm) and are repaired by stitching on one side using wooden segments and fillers from the same mortar referred to. installing the stone itself or, if necessary, an alternative stone, according to the details shown on the plates, or with alternative details. it also includes the injection between the sectors at the full depth of the wall [5,37].
- large thick window cracks in the walls are buttoned from both sides [39].
- if the wooden beam is cracked inside the walls, especially in the places of the threshold, in this case it is replaced with a similar beam [40].
6.4.2. Treatment of Cracks on the Corners
6.4.3. Wall Strengthening Works by Replacing or Removing Stones or Bricks
- the dilapidated walls shall be dismantled while preserving the sound stones and storing them in a safe place in accordance with the principles of stowing until re-installation. the item includes steel and reinforcement works approved by the consultant and the transfer of waste to public landfills [9,50].
- use suitable mortar based on test results and material specification recommendations [11].
- the stones are reconstructed in their original places according to the principles of industry by maintaining the original dimensions and levels [40].
- cracked or damaged stones shall be replaced with new stones according to specifications [13].
6.5. Foundation restoration
6.5.1. Examination of a Sample of the Foundations
6.5.2. Corrosion and Damage to Some Components
6.5.3. Case of Subsidence and Disintegration of the Foundation Layer below the Foundations
6.5.4. Preventing Soil Movement by Implementing Curtain Piling
6.6. Restoration of the Truss of the Great Throne Hall

- b.
- reconstruction of the wall shows layers. the app as an example of the throne room.
- c.
- sectional perspectives showing the reconstruction of the ceiling of the throne hall and the baghdadli ceiling below.
- d.
- longitudinal sectional perspective showing the reconstruction of the throne room.
- e.
- reconstructioning sketch of the windows facing the throne room.
- f.
- reconstructioning a drawing of the great throne hall truss.
- g.
- reconstructioning sketch of the throne room for the entrance wall.
- h.
- reconstructioning sketch of the throne room facing the entrance.

7. Tests and Results
7.1. Field, Laboratory, and Electrical Tests of Soil
7.1.1. Laboratory Test Results
7.1.1.1. Fracture Stress Determination Experiments
7.1.1.2. Extraction Ratio Determination (rec) and Stone Continuity (Rod) Experiments
7.1.1.3. Free swell test results
7.1.1.4. Chemical analysis
7.1.1.5. Underground Geoelectrical Testing
7.1.2. Curves and Spheres Monitoring Results [3,49]
- no caves or voids appeared in the ground up to a depth of 10.00 m in the measurement areas, and they appeared in other places with open digging.
- heterogeneity of soil layers at the horizontal level.
- soil layers were monitored to a depth of 10.00 m. they consist in some areas of calcareous clay components, which are areas that gave values of resistance to current ranging between (30-60) ohms.
- these superficial clay deposits cover the basic bottom of the foundation of the soil layers, which is limestone, and it is the basic soil on which castle was built.
7.1.3. Results of Probes and Nature of Soil Formations
7.1.4. Study and Testing of Building Materials Used in the Great Throne Hall
7.1.5. Red Bricks Are Used in Building Walls
- A.
- tensile test
- B.
- 2. shear test

- C.
- pressure test

- D.
- xrd polarized microscopy

7.1.6. Stone is Used in Building Walls






7.1.7. Double-Sided Grouting Mortar for the Construction of Walls


7.1.8. Mortar for Piling Walls

7.1.9. Wall Mortar




8. Suggested Solutions for Restoration
8.1. Foundations
- you notice a subsidence in the foundations of the al-jawhara palace buildings.
- subsidence in some layers bearing the foundations. the results of electrical detection tests under the palace confirmed the reasons for the decline in the foundations and the causes of cracking due to the different type of soil of the foundation layers and the effect of the movement of water leaking into the ground from rain, agriculture, and sewage.
- decomposition of the bonding mortar, weakness and fracture of the stone courses bearing the foundations under the walls.
- decomposition of the soil itself at the foundation level, especially for the backfill layers or the old foundations.
8.2. Walls
8.3. Evaluation of the Walls of the Great Throne Hall
8.3.1. Cracks in the Walls of the Great throne Hall
8.3.2. Walls below Ground Level [42]
8.3.3. Walls above Ground Level
- 2.
- 3.
- maintenance and conservation of the burrow.
- 4.
- cleaning.
- 5.
- maintenance.
- 6.
- reinforcement and consolidation.
- A.
- intels.
- a.
- outer and inner grout.
- B.
- flooring.
- C.
- roof and truss.
- D.
- interior and exterior paints.

9. Modern Techniques in Restoration
10. Conclusion and Recommendations
References
- Alaa Jamal Mahmoud, Rehabilitation of Archaeological Buildings, Deposit No. 11726/2021, Dar Al-Mashreq Al-Arabi, 2021 AD.
- Al-Sayyid Mahmoud Al-Banna, Fatima Muhammad Helmy, Hossam Al-Din Al-Barambali, Alia Abdel Aziz Mahmoud Abdel Dayem Abdel Dayem, Reuse of Archaeological Buildings “A Study of Data and Evaluation of Alternatives” Application to the Saray Al-Musafer Khana in Cairo, Journal of the Faculty of Arts in Qena, Faculty of Arts in Qena, University of South Al-Wadi, Issue Ten, 2022 AD.
- Atalaa, Hemeda, Intervention Retrofitting and Rehabilitation of Al-Gawhara Palace At the Saladin Citadel, Cairo, Egypt, Open Journal of Geology, January 2019.
- Ayman Hassan Ahmed Hijab, Study of the Destructive Human Effects on Some Islamic Monuments and Methods of Preserving Them in the Old City of Cairo as An Application to One of the Selected Islamic Archaeological Buildings, Master’s Thesis, Cairo University, Faculty of Archeology, Department of Restoration, 2020 AD.
- Bahía, P. A Recepc.o do Team 10 em Portugal; Circo de Ideias: Porto, Portugal, 2020.
- Bosone, M.; De Toro, P.; Fusco Girard, L.; Gravagnuolo, A.; Iodice, S. Indicators for Ex-Post Evaluation of Cultural Heritage Adaptive Reuse Impacts in the Perspective of the Circular Economy. Sustainability 2021, 13, 4759. [CrossRef]
- Buser, B. Reuse! In Reuse in Construction: A compendium of Circular Architecture; Stricker, E., Brandi, G., Sonderegger, A., Angst, M., Buser, B., Massmunster, M., Eds.; Park Books: Zurich, Switzerland, 2022; pp. 11–16.
- Coscia, C.; Lazzari, G.; Rubino, I. Industrial heritage, adaptive reuse, and sustainable redevelopment scenarios: Including local communities’ multiple values in the decision-making process. In Science of Valuations: Natural Structures, Technological Infrastructures, Cultural Superstructures; Giuffrida, S., Trovato, M.R., Rosato, P., Fattinnanzi, E., Oppio, A., Chiodo, S., Eds.; Springer: Cham, Switzerland, 2023; pp. 1–15; ISBN 978-3-031-53708-0.
- Coscia, C.; Pasquino, F. Demand Analysis Models to Support Cultural Tourism Strategy: Application of Conjoint Analysis in North Sardinia (Italy). Land 2023, 12, 2150. [CrossRef]
- Coscieme, L.; Mortensen, L.F.; Anderson, S.; Ward, J.; Donohue, I.; Sutton, P.C. Going beyond Gross Domestic Product as an indicator to bring coherence to the Sustainable Development Goals. J. Clean. Prod. 2020, 248, 119232. [CrossRef]
- Council of Europe (CoE). Council of Europe Framework Convention on the Value of Cultural Heritage for Society. 2005. Available .online: https://rm.coe.int/1680083746 (accessed on 13 March 2023).
- Coutinho, J.M.A.F. Construir a Transformac.o. Entre quatro paredes, quatro casas com Álvaro Siza. Master’s Thesis, Faculty of Architecture of the University of Porto, Porto, Portugal, 2023.
- Cucco, P.; Maselli, G.; Nestic., A.; Ribera, F. An evaluation model for adaptive reuse of cultural heritage in accordance with 2030 SDGs and European Quality Principles. J. Cult. Herit. 2023, 59, 202–216. [CrossRef]
- Dabbene, D. Patrimonio architettonico e benessere. In Nuovi Scenari Per Il Restauro Nel XXI Secolo;WriteUp: Rome, Italy, 2023; ISBN 979-12-5544-032-1. Heritage 2024, 7 2864.
- Dabbene, D.; Bartolozzi, C.; Coscia, C. How to Monitor and Evaluate Quality in Adaptive Heritage Reuse Projects from aWell-Being Perspective: A Proposal for a Dashboard Model of Indicators to Support Promoters. Sustainability 2022, 14, 7099.
- Dalia Ali Abdel-Al El-Sayed, Restoration and Rehabilitation of The Ancient Buildings of Muhammad Ali Pasha’s Sabil as A Model of an Architectural Masterpiece That Houses the Egyptian Textile Museum, Journal of Architecture, Arts and Humanities, Special Issue 2, April 2021, Pp. 2161: 2172.
- Della Torre, S. A coevolutionary approach to reusing built cultural heritage. In The Changing Cultural Heritage. The Challenges of Use; Biscontin, G., Driussi, G., Eds.; Arcadia Ricerche: Venice, Italy, 2019; pp. 25–34.
- Dimitrova, E.; Lavenir, M.L.; McMahon, P.; M ̄ urniece, B.; Musso, S.F.; Nagy, G.; Selfslagh, B. European Quality Principles for EU-funded Interventions with Potential Impact upon Cultural Heritage; ICOMOS: Charenton-le-Pont, France, 2020.
- endlebury, J.; Brown, J. Conserving the Historic Environment. In Concise Guides to Planning; Lund Humphries: London, UK, 2021.
- ESPON. HERIWELL—Cultural Heritage as a Source of SocietalWell-Being in European Regions: Final Report; Espon EGTC: Luxembourg,2022. Available online: https://archive.espon.eu/sites/default/files/attachments/HERIWELL_Final%20Report.pdf (accessed on 13 March 2023).
- European Commission. European Framework for Action on Cultural Heritage. 2019. Available online: https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/5a9c3144-80f1-11e9-9f05-01aa75ed71a1 (accessed on 13 March 2023).
- Fantini, E. Patrimonio storico e progetto nell’architettura portoghese. Riflessi della cultura italiana nell’opera di Távora, Soutinhoe Siza. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy, 2021.
- Fernandes, E. From CIAM to Team Ten, between theory and practice: Fernando Távora and the international debate of modern architects. In Team Ten Farwest; Circo de Ideias: Porto, Portugal, 2019.
- Ferreira, T.C. Altas of Architectural design in Built heritage: Pedagogies of the School of Porto. In CA2RE+ Delft Recommendation: Conference for Artistic and Architectural Research & Collective Evaluation of Design-Driven Doctoral Training Programme; Carvallo, R., Alkan, A., Kuijper, J., Eds.; TU Delft OPEN Publishing: Delft, The Netherlands, 2023; pp. 186–192.
- Ferreira, T.C. Editorial Project New/Old: A method for analysis of the intervention in the built. In Novo/antigo. Fernando Távora: Obras = New/Old. Fernando Távora: Works; Ferreira, T.C., Ordónez-Castanón, D., Fantini, E., Eds.; FAUP/FIMS/Afrontamento: Porto, Portugal, 2023; pp. 11–20.
- Ferreira, T.C.; Ordónez-Castanón, D.; Fantini, E.; Coutinho, M.F.; Cruz, T.T. Adaptive reuse of vernacular built heritage: Learnings from Alcino Cardoso House (1971–1991) by Álvaro Siza. J. Build. Rehabil. 2023, 8, 73. [CrossRef]
- Ferreira, T.C.; Ordónez-Castanón, D.; Póvoas, R.F. Methodological approach for an Atlas of architectural design in built heritage: Contributions of the School of Porto. J. Cult. Herit. Manag. Sustain. Dev. 2023. [CrossRef]
- Fusco Girard, L.; Vecco, M. The “Intrinsic Value” of Cultural Heritage as Driver for Circular Human-Centered Adaptive Reuse. Sustainability 2021, 13, 3231. [CrossRef]
- García Hermida, A. The role of the vernacular in modern architecture: Questions of form, identity and adaptation to context. Cuad. Notas 2019, 20, 29–42.
- Giannattasio, C. The false antagonism between matter and memory. In Conservation/Demolition; Fiorani, D., Franco, G., Kealy, L.,Musso, S.F., Vorlík, P., Eds.; EAAE: Prague, Czech Republic, 2020; pp. 258–269. Heritage 2024, 7 2865.
- Guo, H.; Chen, F.; Tang, Y.; Ding, Y.; Chen, M.; Zhou, W.; Zhu, M.; Gao, G.; Yang, R.; Zheng, W.; et al. Progress toward the sustainable development of world cultural heritage sites facing land-cover changes. Innovation 2023, 4, 100496. [PubMed]. [CrossRef]
- Hani Muhammad Reda, Mamluk Soils in Cairo, PHD Thesis, Cairo University, Faculty of Archeology, Department of Islamic Antiquities, 2020 AD.
- ISTAT. Rapporto BES 2022. Il Benessere Equo e Sostenibile in Italia; ISTAT: Rome, Italy, 2023. Available online: https://www.istat.it/it/archivio/282920 (accessed on 13 March 2023).
- Lanz, F.; Pendlebury, J. Adaptive Reuse: A Critical Review. J. Archit. 2022, 27, 441–462. [CrossRef]
- Mohaddes Khorassani, S.; Ferrari, A.M.; Pini, M.; Settembre Blundo, D.; García Muina, F.E.; García, J.F. Environmental and social impact assessment of cultural heritage restoration and its application to the Uncastillo Fortress. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2019, 24,1297–1318. [CrossRef]
- Muhammad Jamal Hammad, Al-Dahisha Hall and the Events of the Era of the Mamluk Sultans (923-730 AH / 1330-1517 AD), A Historical Study, Journal of the College of Tourism and Hotels, No. 12, December 2022 AD.
- Napoleone, L. Come conosciamo l’oggetto del nostro conservare. Spazio geometrico e spazio vissuto. In Restauro: Conoscenza, Progetto, Cantiere, Gestione; Musso, S.F., Pretelli, M., Scient, C., Eds.; Sezione 1.1 Conoscenza Previa (Preventiva) e Puntuale (Mirata). Metodologie; Boato, A., Caccia Gherardini, S., Eds.; Quasar: Rome, Italy, 2020; pp. 110–117.
- Ordónez-Castanón, D. Fernando Távora. La modernidad enraizada: Continuidad e innovación como principios de inter-vención en la arquitectura tradicional. Ph.D. Thesis, University of the Basque Country UPV/EHU, San Sebastián, Spain, 2022.
- Ordónez-Castanón, D.; Ferreira, T.C.; Sánchez-Beitia, S. Adaptive reuse of manor houses: Modernism and tradition in Fernando Távora’s approach for heritage renovation. Int. J. Sust. Dev. Plan 2021, 16, 569–578. [CrossRef]
- Ordónez-Castanón, D.; Ferreira, T.C.; Sánchez-Beitia, S. Intervention in vernacular architecture: The lesson of Fernando Távora. Int. Arch. Photogramm. Remote Sens. Spat. Inf. Sci. 2020, XLIV-M-1-2020, 123–130. [CrossRef]
- Plevoets, B.; Van Cleempoel, K. Adaptive Reuse of the Built Heritage; Routledge: Oxfordshire, UK, 2019.
- Ramez Jeremiah Gendy, an Archaeological Artistic Study of Wooden Ceilings in the Mamluk Era in the City of Cairo Through Existing Documents and Facilities, Master’s Thesis, Cairo University, Faculty of Archaeology, Department of Islamic Antiquities, 2021 AD.
- Rossitti, M.; Oteri, A.M.; Sarnataro, M.; Torrieri, F. The social dimension of the reuse of architectural heritage: Theoretical reflections starting from a case study in Campania. ArcHistoR 2022, 17, 178–211.
- Samar Saeed Abadi Muhammad, the Role of Reusing Heritage Buildings in Local Community Development, Journal of the Higher Institute for Specific Studies, Issue 2, July 2022.
- Sofaer, J.; Davenport, B.; Sorensen, M.L.S.; Gallou, E.; Uzzell, D. Heritage sites, value and wellbeing: Learning from the COVID-19 pandemic in England. Int. J. Herit. Stud. 2021, 27, 1117–1132. [CrossRef]
- Stone, S. Notes towards a Definition of Adaptive Reuse. Architecture 2023, 3, 477–489. [CrossRef]
- Stone, S. UnDoing Buildings: Adaptive Reuse and Cultural Memory; Routledge: Oxfordshire, UK, 2020.
- Tacon, P.S.C.; Baker, S. New and Emerging Challenges to Heritage and Well-Being: A Critical Review. Heritage 2019, 2, 1300–1315. [CrossRef]
- Taha Abdel Moaty, Study of the Restoration, Rehabilitation and Reuse of Al-Gawhara Palace in Salah Al-Din Al-Ayyubi Citadel in Cairo, Master’s in Architectural Restoration and Conservation of Antiquities, Master’s Thesis, Cairo University, Faculty of Archeology, Department of Restoration, 2019 AD.
- The Fourteenth International Conference, Cultural Heritage Between Theory and Practice, Journal of Architecture, Arts and Humanities, Volume Nine, Special Issue (11), April 2024 AD.
- United Nations. Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. 2015. Available online: https://sdgs.un.org/goals (accessed on 13 March 2023).
- Vaz, P. Edificar no Património. Pessoas e Paradigmas na Conservac.o e Restauro; Edic.es 70: Lisboa, Portugal, 2019.
| underground layers | ves | | ves 2 | ves 3 | ||||
| piece | h | p | h | p | h | ||
| 1 | 14 | 0.93 | 32 | 0.45 | 42 | 0.65 | |
| 2 | 60 | 116 | 125 | 2.7 | 300 | 1.3 | |
| 3 | 160 | ---- | 52 | ---- | 30 | ---- | |
| sp. no | weight (g) | average measured dimensions d*h (mm) | ultimate load (n) | splitting tensile strength (n/mm2) | remarks | |
| 1 | 46.2 | 30.2*54.6 | 1035 | 0.40 | bricks | |
| sp. no | weight (g) | average measured dimensions d*h (mm) | ultimate load (n) | splitting tensile strength (n/mm2) | remarks |
| 1 | 40.1 | 29.2*56.9 | 3110 | 4.6 | bricks |
| sp. no | weight (g) | average measured dimensions d*h (mm) | ultimate load (n) | splitting tensile strength (n/mm2) | remarks |
| 1 | 45.7 | 30.5*57.0 | 5335 | 7.3 | bricks |
| sp. no | weight (g) | average measured dimensions d*h (mm) | ultimate load (n) | splitting tensile strength (n/mm2) | remarks |
| 2 | 164.7 | 40.2*61.4 | 3790 | 0.98 | stone |
| sp. no | weight (g) | average measured dimensions d*h (mm) | ultimate load (n) | splitting tensile strength (n/mm2) | remarks |
| 2 | 76.8 | 27.3*62.3 | 3020 | 5.2 | stone |
| sp. no | weight (g) | average measured dimensions d*h (mm) | ultimate load (n) | splitting tensile strength (n/mm2) | remarks |
| 2 | 167.6 | 40.9*59.4 | 16300 | 12.4 | stone |
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).