1. Introduction: Fluorescent Nucleoside Analogs – An Outlook
Fluorescence spectroscopy is one of the most sensitive methods of bio-molecules detection and measurements of their interactions and activities, at both the ensemble and single-molecule levels [
1,
2,
3]. For this reason, various fluorescence techniques are frequently used in biological, biochemical and biophysical research. Unfortunately, some of the most important biomolecules (nucleic acids, membranes, some proteins) are not fluorescent under natural conditions (neutral aqueous medium, moderated temperatures). Therefore, direct application of fluorescence methods to biological research
in vivo or
in vitro requires finding appropriate fluorescent markers, which can provide structural and dymamic information about molecules as well as their activities.
Among these, fluorescent nucleoside and nucleotide analalogs play key role [
4]. They are applied,
inter alia, to structural and dynamic research of nucleic acids, including ribozymes [
5,
6,
7,
8], their interaction with proteins [
9], and detection of enzymatic activities of enzymes related to nucleic acid metabolism both
in vitro and
in vivo with aid of the fluorescence microscopy [
10,
11,
12].
Natural nucleosides and nucleotides are virtually nonfluorescent in neutral aqueous media [
13] with exception of some weakly fluorescent minor RNA subunits [
14]. First fluorescent nucleoside analogs, among them the intensely fluorescent 2-aminopurine riboside, were described five decades ago [
15], and some of them still are employed in biophysical research [
16,
17]. Since that, hundreds of fluorescent nucleobase and nucleoside analogs were developed for various applications, most of them by multi-step chemical procedures [
4,
6,
10,
18,
19,
20,
21].
There are two broad classses of nucleoside analogs [
5]: (i) nucleosides linked to strong aromatic or heteroaromatic fluorophores, like coumarin, pyrene or fluorene, typically via the C-8, N7, or ribose moiety, and (ii) nucleosides with the heteroaromatic ring (purine or pyrimidine) replaced by a fluorescent analog of nucleobase [
5,
21]. The most useful analogs are those which combine good spectral parameters with substrate or inhibitory activities towards the selected enzymatic or other biological systems, and this condition is usually fulfilled by isosteric or isomorphic (that is, mimicking the natural nucleosides in size, shape, and hydrogen bonding abilities) analogs. In this brief review we concentrate mainly on this kind of nucleoside analogs.
There is a growing number of such analogs known, and recent finding of Tor’s group enlarged the available “libraries” by the substituted thieno- and thiazolo-pyrimidine compounds, isosteric and, to the large extent, isofunctional with natural purine nucleosides [
22]. All the thieno- and thiazolo-purine nucleoside analogs are strongly fluorescent in the visible region [
22,
23]. These are all C-nucleosides, what makes them resistant to some nucleolytic enzymes, what is important for biological applications.
Many nucleoside analogs, including elements of “RNA emissive alphabet” can be selectively incorporated into polynucleotides and ribozymes, either chemically, or using enzymes like T7 RNA polymerase and other polymerases [
5,
22].
Most of the fluorescent analogs are generated chemically, using sometimes quite complex multi-step procedures, but some can be obtained in much simpler, enzymatic way [
24,
25]. Purine-nucleoside phosphorylase (see below) offer possibilty of nucleoside (but not of the C-nucleoside) analogs synthesis from nucleobase and pentose analogs.
There are also examples of fluorescent pyrimidine nucleoside analogs [
5,
6,
21,
26,
27], but nearly all of them belong to the first (“noncanonical”) group, with pyrimidine moiety liked to organic fluorophore, or significantly modified. They are nevertheless utilized in polynucleotide and nucleic acid reserch, e.g. to detection of apurinic sites in double-stranded polynucleotides or DNA fragments [
28].
2. Purine Nucleoside Phosphorylase as a Synthetic Tool
Purine-nucleoside phosphorylase (PNP, E.C. 2.4.2.1) catalyzes a reversible phosphorolysis of natural purine nucleosides (or deoxynucleosides) to the respective nucleobases and α-(deoxy)ribose-1-phosphate (r1P, [
29]). It is a key enzyme of the so-called purine-salvage pathway [
30], and its physiological role is regulation of nucleoside concentration within the cells.
Genetic deficiency of PNP activity leads to severe impairment of immune system in man [
29,
31], and is a subject of experimental gene therapy [
31]. Inhibitors of PNP reveal potent pharmacological activities towards bacterial, viral, and parasitic infections (including malaria), and also can be applied as antineoplastic and immunosuoppresive agents [
29,
32]. One of them, the transition-state inhibitor forodesine (known as immucilin H, [
33]), with inhibition constant ~60 pM, has been recently approved in Japan for the treatment of relapsed/refractory peripheral T-cell lymphoma [
34]. Even more potent is ulodesine [
35], with K
i ~9 pM, actually under examination.
Various forms of PNP are employed as catalysts in enzymatic syntheses of nucleosides and their analogs (for reviews, see refs. [
24,
25,
36,
37,
38,
39]). For canonical purines and many analogs, the reaction equillibrium is shifted towards nucleoside synthesis [
29], but there are also ribosides for which phosphorolysis is virtually irreversible, and these are ideal to serve as ribose-donors in the synthetic “one pot” reactions, while the purified r1P is rarely used because of its high price and relative instability [
36]. The commonly known example is a commercially available 7-methylguanosine [
40], and another good ribose donors involve 7-methyl-thioguanosine, 7-methyl-inosine and nicotinamide riboside [
29]. Another way of the “one-pot” purine (deoxy)nucleoside syntheses is that proposed long ago by Krenitsky [
41], with uridine or thymidide phosphorylase, acting on uridine or thymidine, serving as a source of r1P or its deoxy analog.
More than 100 natural forms of PNP are known [
38]. Various forms of PNP, both natural and modified via the site-directed mutagenesis [
39] differ quantitatively or qualitatively in substrate specificities, and may be used for synthetic purposes. There are two broad classes of PNP (i) mammalian (trimeric) forms which are specific towards 6-oxopurine nucleosides [
29], but single genetic mutation in the active site, N243D, can alter this specificity [
42], and (ii) bacterial forms, which are mostly hexameric and reveal broader substrate specificity, particularly in respect to heteroaromatic moieties of the substrates. Thermophilic PNP variants [
43] offer opportunities for large-scale applications. Whole-cell catalysis is also recognized for its relative simplicity and enzyme stabilty [
36,
39]. Various advanced techniques, including those utilizing enzyme immobilisation on magnetic expoxide microspheres, led to effective syntheses on a gram or even kilogram scale [
44]. Analysis of the indutrial potential of such techniques has been recenty presented [
39].
PNP, particularly its bacterial forms, is characterized by broad substrate specificity, and this refers both to the heteroaromatic and sugar moieties, as well to various non-typical arrangements of these [
38]. Early works pointed unexpected activities of mammalian PNP against N3- and N7- ribosides of canonical purines [
45], as well as effective modifications of enzyme specificities via the site-directed mutagenesis of the active-site amino acids [
42]. These observations lead to many applications in syntheses of chemically, biochemically, and pharmacologically important nucleoside analogs, like arabinosyl-purines, cordycepin (3-deoxyribosyl-adenine) and analogs, halogenated purine and benzimidazole ribosides and deoxyribosides, including cladribine (2-Chlorodeoxyadenosine), fludarabine (2-fluoro-arabinyl-adenine) arabino- and other nucleosides modified on sugar and/or heteroarometic moieties, reviewed recently [
37]. All known PNP forms maintain strict regioselectivity in the ribosylation site (purine N9) and pentose configuration (β), rare exceptions to the former rule are discussed below. Attemtpts to further modify enzyme specificity in a controlled manner are under way [
39,
43,
46].
Another enzymatic systems effecting in deoxynucleoside production are deoxyribosyl transferases (DNT’s) of bacterial origin [
36,
47]. Analogous synteses of nucleotides from nucleobases are possible using phosphoribosyl tranferases [
48].
In the present paper, we summarize recent progress in obtaining new highly fluorescent nucleoside analogs and point their potential for analytical applications. This paper is an update of our previous, more extended review [
49].
3. Chemo-Enzymatic Synthesis of Fluorescent Ribosides of Purines and 8-Azapurines
The only strongly fluorescent purine riboside is 2-aminopurine riboside, but this compound is apparently not ribosylated by PNP. Its deoxy analog can be synthesized using DNT as a catalyst [
36]. Weak fluorescence is exhibited by 2,6-diaminopurine riboside and N
6,N
6-dimethyladenosine [
49], and these analogs, and the corresponding (deoxy)ribosides, can be synthesized chemo-enzymatically using either PNP from
E. coli or bacterial DNT’s as catalysts [
36]. Moderately fluorescent 7-methylguanosine and 7-methylinosine undergo almost irreversible phosphorpolysis by both trimeric and hexameric PNP’s [
29], so they cannot be synthesized this way. In contrast, the 8-azapurines show much better spectral properties and are substrates for many forms of PNP in the synthetic pathway [
49,
50].
8-azapurines are isosteric and isomorphic analogs of natural purine bases, substituting the latters in a variety of biochemical transformations [
49,
50,
51,
52,
53]. Some of them are quite toxic, and to date no direct medical application of these compounds is repoted, but are widely employed in laboratories for various purposes, including mutagenicity tests [
51,
52]. Their chemical and physicochemical properties differ somewhat from those of the analogous purines, particularly in the acido-basic equillibria and prototropic tautomerism [
52]. Nevertheless, they can be classified as probably the most isomorphic purine analogs, although their emissive properties are inferior to those of the “RNA alphabet”.
In contrast to the canonical nucleobases, some of 8-azapurines, as well as the corresponding nucleosides and nucleotides, reveal marked fluorescence in neutral aqueous medium (see refs [
49,
54], and
Table 1). Their nucleotides can be selectively incorporated to mRNA molecules, including ribosymes, and have been applied to mechanistic research of ribozyme action [
55,
56].
Figure 1.
Purines and 8-azapurines.
Figure 1.
Purines and 8-azapurines.
3.1. 8-Azaadenosine, 8-Azainosine, 8-Azaxanthosine and Derivatives
Although 8-azaadenine is very weakly fluorescent, and only as a neutral species (pH<6.1), 8-azaadenosine exhibits moderate fluorescence in a broad pH range [
50]. Incorporated into ribozyme molecules, it served as a reporter of acid-base equillibria important for the reaction mechanism [
55]. As expected, wild-type PNP from
E.coli accepts 8-azaadenine as a substrate, but the ribosylation goes about 50-fold slower than that for adenine [
50]. Mutations of bacterial PNP sofar were not effective in improving the rate of ribosylation.
8-azainosine (synthesized chemically) was investigated by Seela and co-workers [
53], who reported moderate fluorescence of the anionic form of the nucleoside (pK
a ~8). 8-Azahypoxanthine reveals poor substrate properties towards PNP in the synthetic pathway, since in the neutral aqueous medium it exists as an anion [
53].
8-azaxanthine (8-azaXan) and particularly its methyl derivatives are known to be strongly fluorescent in aqueous medium [
57], but the chemo-enzymatic synthesis of 8-azaxanthosine from 8-azaxanthine is difficult, probably because this compound is even more acidic than 8-azaisoguanine (pK
a ~4.8, [
51]). It has been however reported that the inducible xanthosine phosphorylase from
E. Coli, known as PNP-II [
58], accepts 8-azaxanthine as a substrate in the ribosylation pathway, although the ribosylation site is cetrainly not N9, but either N7 or N8, as inferred from the spectral properties of the products, strongly fluorescent at 440 nm in the neutral aqueous medium, similarly to those of N7- or N8-methyl, but not to N9-methyl derivatives of 8-azaXan [
57].
3.2. 8-Azaguanosine and Analogs
8-Azaguanine is known as a very toxic analog of guanine, which is applied in the mutagenicity tests [
59]. It reveals quite intense fluorescence as a neutral species (<pH 7), ascribed to its minor N(8)H tautomer [
50]. By contrast, 8-azaguanosine is very weakly fluorescent below pH 6, where it exists in the neutral form, but strongly as a monoanion (pK
a~8). This compound is readily, and almost irreversibly, synthesized enzymatically from 8-azaguanine, using calf spleen PNP as a catalyst, and r1P as a ribose donor [
50]. It has been applied to mechanistic research of ribozyme action, primarily as a probe of micro-acididity of the active guanine residue of
glms ribozyme [
56].
The mutated form of calf PNP, N243D, in analogous (slower) reaction gave a mixture of N9- and moderately fluorescent N-7 riboside [
60]. By contrast, the bacterial (
E.coli) enzyme lead (rather slowly) maily to N9- riboside, with some minor contribution of another strongly fluorescent product, tentatively identified as N8-riboside [
60,
61].
8-Azaguanine forms weak, but fluorescent complex with calf spleen PNP, which was a subject of spectroscopic investigations [
62,
63]. Fluorescence excitation spectrum of the complex is markedly shifted to the long wavelength relative to free 8-azaGua. Interestingly, the weakly fluorescent N9-phosphonomethoxy analog of 8-azaguanine binds to this enzyme quite tightely as a bi-substrate analog, also showing marked increase in fluorescence [
62]. Somewhat surprisingly, these two complexes are spectrally quite different [
63], the fact interpreted in terms of prototropic tautomerism of the bound 8-azaguanine, possibly involving the enol tautomer.
8-Aza-deoxyguanosine has been also synthesized, on a larger scale, using PNP as a catalyst [
64], and its fluorescence is reported to be very similar to that of the riboside.
3.3. Other 8-Azapurine Analogs and Their Enzymatic Ribosylation
Although 2,6-diaminopurine is only moderately fluorescent, and its riboside even less [
65], their 8-aza analog, 2,6-diamino-8-azapurine (DaaPu) reveals high fluorescence yield in neutral aqueous media [
53]. Even stronger emission is observed in some ribosides of DaaPu (
Table 1), which could be generated enzymatically using mammalian (calf) or bacterial (
E. coli) forms of PNP [
61]. The ribosylation site depends in this case qualitatively on catalyst used. Wild-type calf PNP ribosylates DaaPu at N7 and N8, its mutated form (D243N) at N7 and N9, and bacterial (
E.coli) enzyme at N9 and N8 [
61]. All three ribosides differ markedly by their spectroscopic parameters, particularly fluorescence maxima (spectral data summarized in
Table 1). The N9-riboside of DaaPu is probably the most intensely fluorescent nucleoside analog known todate, with yield reaching 90% (
Table 1).
The non-typical ribosides of DaaPu, after purification, revealed good and selective substrate properties towards human erythrocytic and bacterial (
E.coli) forms of PNP, allowing quantitation of PNP activity in whole human blood, diluted 1000-fold, without necessity of removal of hemoglobin [
66]. Mammalian and bacterial forms of PNP can be detected selectively, since N7-riboside of DaaPu is resistant to the
E. coli PNP, and N8-riboside is apparently not phosphorolysed by human erythrocytic enzyme [
66]. This assay is possible because of marked spectral differences between the above-mentioned ribosides and the nucleobase analog (DaaPu). This selectivity in PNP ribosylation is a subject of molecular modeling investigations [
67], which can lead to further broadening of their synthetic possibilities.
The effect of non-typical ribosylation of DaaPu may be kinetic in nature, at least in the case of E.coli PNP, as evidenced by the bi-phasic nature of the reaction progress (unpublished data). Initially, probably kinetically produced N8-riboside is eventually converted to the final thermodynamic product, which is the “canonical” N9-riboside. This reaction progress is easily observed using UV or fluorescence spectroscopy (unpublished data).
It may be also interesting that the phosphonomethoxy analog of DaaPu, PME-DaaPu, prepared by Holy et al. [
68], is also intensely fluorescent in near UV and as a bi-substrate analog strongly binds to the mammalian PNP in the absence of phoshate ions [
69].
8-Aza-deoxy-isoguanosine has been obtained chemically by Seela and Jiang [
70] and polymerized to study oligonucleoside associations. This deoxyriboside is strongly fluorescent, particularly in the anionic form [
70]. Unlike many other nucleosides, 8-aza-isoguanosine ribosides are fluorescent also in polymers [
70,
71], and may serve as reporters of their structure and interactions. Chemo-enzymatic synthesis of 8-aza-isoguanosine is possible, but difficult because of marked acidity of the corresponding purine analog (pK ~5.5, [
53]), so at pH>6 only small fraction of molecules is in neutral form. Preliminary experiments (unpublished) conducted in acetate buffer at pH 5.5, at 30℃, showed slow reaction to occur, leading to moderately fluorescent product, but the ribosylation site remains problematic.
3.4. 8-Aza-7-Deazapurine and 8-aza-9-Deazapurine Ribosides
The title compounds (known also as pyrazolo[3,4-d]pyrimidine and pyrazolo[4,3-d]pyrimidine ribosides, respectively) are isomorphic purine analogs, revealig strong biological and pharmaceutical activities, exemplified by allopurinol (4-oxo-pyrazolo[3,4-d]pyrimidine), an ihibitor of xanthine oxidase, widely applied in anti-gout therapy [
72]. The corresponding ribosides and deoxyribosides can be synthesized enzymatically using bacterial (
E. coli) PNP [
64]. This reaction is much slower than that for natural purines, apparently because protonation of purine N7 is essential for the substrate activation by D204 residue [
53]. According to Mikhailopulo, this role is in this case taken by Ser90 residue of the
E. coli PNP, interacting with puirine N8 [
73].
Some of the pyrazolo[3,4-d]pyrimidine ribosides are fluorescent, as indiciated by fluorescence of the commercial nucleobase analog 8-aza-7-deaza-isoguanine (4-amino-6-hydroxyprazolo[3,4-d]pyrimidine), which is a slow substrate of PNP from E.coli (unpublished). Fluorescence changes, observed during the reaction (unpublished) show that at least one of the products must be fluorescent.
The ribosides of 2-aminopurine analog, 8-aza-7-deaza-2-aminopurine, and its 2,6-diaminopurine analog (IUPAC name 4,6-diaminopyrazolo[3,4-d]pyrimidine) were prepared and modified chemically by Seela et al. [
74] and enzymatically by Mikhailopulo’s group [
64]. Both compounds exhibit measurable fluorescence, which was applied in the polynucleotide studies [
74].
8-Aza-9-deazapurine ribosides, known as formycins [
75], are C-nucleosides and as such are not phosphorolysed by PNP, but reveal good substrate properties towards other enzymes of purine metabolism and some of them are fluorescent in neutral aqueous media [
76,
77]. These compounds strongly inhibit hexameric PNP’s [
29,
78] and their fluorescence was utilized in investigations of enzyme-inhibitor complexes, especially to identify tautomeric forms of the bound ligand(s) [
79].
3.5. Other Bicyclic Heteroaromatics
Benzimidazole fluorescence is known from many years, and this compound, and many derivatives, are readily (deoxy)ribosylated by PNP from
E. coli [
24]. Also halogenated derivatives of benzimidazole were reported to be substrates of PNP [
24,
80,
81]. Another fluorescent isomer, indazole (benzopyrazole), is probably poor or not a substrate. Benzoxazole is apparently not a substrate for the PNP from
E. coli [
24], but enzymatic ribosylation of 2-aminobenzoxazole is possible, and apparently takes place on the amine group [
73]. N1-deaza and N3-deaza purines can be ribosylated by bacterial forms of PNP, but their fluorescence is not known [
73].
5. Conclusion and Perspectives
This brief review illustrates possibility of rapid and effective syntheses of many strongly fluorescent ribosides, which can be used in future biophysical and analytical research. The presented examples involve various forms of PNP used as catalysis, and illustrate possibilities of modifying enzyme specificity via site-directed mutagenesis not only in quantitative, but sometimes in qualitative sense. Variability in the ribosylation sites, exhibited by PNP in some analogs, is helpful for preparation of ribosides with better spectral characteristics, suitable, e. g., for fluorescence microscopy. This variabilty was not observed for canonical purines, with the only exception of recently reported synthyesis of xanthine-N7-β-D-riboside [
97].
Efforts to modify specificity of PNP using various genetic modifications are published [
98]. In the future, specific enzymes may be designed for specific substrates to be ribosylated at specific sites, and theoretical methods potentially leading to this goal are being developed [
99]. Sensitive and specific fluorimetric assays for PNP, briefly presented above, can be regarded as “bonuses” of this kind of research.
It would be interesting to examine analogous possibilities of other enzymatic systems, for example phosphoribolsyl transferases, catalysing formation of nucleotides from nucleobases and 5-phosphoribose-1-pyrophosphate (PrPP), and extensively investigated because of their medical significance [
100,
101]. Various bacterial ezymatic systems, like deoxy-riboside transferases, phosphoribosyl transferases and/or nucleoside hydrolases (acting in non-aqueous media) may be also useful but their specificities towards fluorescent or fluorogenic analogs are mostly unknown.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, J.W. and A.S.-W..; methodology, J.W. and A.S.-W.; software, A.S.-W.; validation, J.W., A.S.-W.; formal analysis, J.W.; investigation, J.W. and A.S.-W.; resources, J.W.; data curation, J.W.; writing—original draft preparation, J.W.; writing—review and editing, J.W. and A.S.-W.; visualization, J.W. and A.S.-W.; supervision, J.W.; project administration, J.W.; funding acquisition, A.S.-W. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.