1. Introduction
Brazil is in a prominent position in global agribusiness, mainly in meat production, and has one of the largest cattle herds, with 224,602,112 heads. The country has stood out as a major global meat exporter, with a total of 1,867,574 tons exported in 2021 [
1]. According to McManus et al. [
2], Brazilian livestock farming showed rapid growth and modernization, mainly in the north (Amazon Biome) and Midwest regions. Freitas Junior and Barros [
3] studied the spatial distribution of cattle herds in Brazilian microregions between 1995–2016, reporting that herd and cattle densities grew more quickly and significantly in the Amazon regions and that this production growth was particularly due to increased pasture sizes, mainly resulting from deforestation for cattle production. Additionally, animal production intensified, changing production systems due to greater animal density per hectare and consequently changing nutritional, health, reproductive, and facility management [
4,
5]. An increased number of bovines associated with production intensification directly increases foot diseases that cause considerable economic losses in the beef cattle production chain, such as septic digital dermatitis, laminitis, heel and sole erosion and ulcers, white line disease, and dewclaw lesions. Foot diseases are estimated to reduce weight gain by up to 25% in sick beef cattle consequently reducing meat production, productivity, and profit for producers and the agricultural sector [
6].
Bovine dewclaw dermatitis (BDCD) is characterized by inflammation of the second and fifth accessory digits and the skin in this region. Inflammation is usually associated with necrosis and loss of corneal substance. BDCD onset is associated with a wide variety of epidemiological factors, mainly due to differences between production systems, geographic location, climate factors, and pastures in different regions and farms, in addition to the physical structures of the pens [
5,
6,
7]. BDCD is not a frequently described lesion in the world literature; however, in the Brazilian Amazon Biome region, it has been constantly observed in dairy and beef cattle raised in extensive production systems [
10,
12]. Even though BDCD is not a frequently reported and studied foot injury, it can be considered aggressive and has a negative impact on the cattle production system. BDCD’s epidemiology has not yet been elucidated, being generally associated with traumatic dewclaw injuries in bovine raised in recently deforested or cleared pastures with the presence of tree stumps [
7].
Almost all studies on hoof injuries are related to dairy herds raised in an intensive production system [
3,
6,
9]. There is a lack of studies on the reality of extensive production systems and beef herds and a lack of data on the incidence and epidemiology of hoof diseases in these animals and production systems, especially regarding dewclaw injuries [
10,
11,
12]. Therefore, the objective of this study was to be a pioneer in describing the epidemiological factors involved in BDCD onset in beef cattle raised in an extensive production system in the Brazilian Amazon Biome.
3. Results
Distal extremities of 706 bovines of both sexes were evaluated, with males aged between 2–4 years and females aged between 2–11 years, with a mean weight of 550 kg. Of these, 506 bovines were of the Nellore breed, and 200 were crossbred (Nellore X taurine breeds), as shown in
Table 1. Of the total number of bovines inspected and clinically examined, 49 (6.9%) presented with BDCD (
Figure 1) and (Graph 1), of which 19 (38.8%) were Nellore, and 30 (61.2%) were crossbred, with 30 (61 %) females and 19 (39%) males (
Table 2). Also, 15 bovines (30.6%) presented with lesions in more than one dewclaw on different limbs. Pelvic limb dewclaw was affected in 45 bovines (91.8%), with only four bovines (8,2%) affected in the thoracic limbs.
Of the epidemiological factors identified, five (62.5%) farms (A, E, F, G, and H) had recently cleared or deforested pastures with trunks and stumps, in addition to stones and gravel on the roads used to transport cattle (
Figure 2).
A large number of stones was observed in the pastures of six (75%) farms (
Table 3), mainly near water troughs and cattle management areas (
Figure 3). There was also mud accumulation in the pens, and organic matter adhered to the hooves, especially in the rainy season (
Figure 4).
The physical facilities used for the bovines were not in adequate maintenance conditions on the farms analyzed, with the presence of broken boards (
Figure 5) and exposed nails and screws. There was a high density of bovines in the pens during management, which exceeded the maximum facility capacity, in addition to stressful animal management with the use of sticks and shocks, making the animals visibly agitated.
Farm A had the largest territorial extension, with cattle being transported in vehicles from one area to another due to the long distances between pastures. Trucks with cages were used to transport the bovines. On the floor of these vehicles, we noticed the presence of non-slip iron railings that were not in good condition, not maintained, misaligned, and with loose iron spikes facing upwards (
Figure 6).
4. Discussion
In 1990, the cattle herd in the states that make up the Brazilian Legal Amazon included 26.2 million heads. In 2013, this number increased to 80.7 million heads, an increase of 207.38%. The states of Pará and Mato Grosso contributed with an increase of 32.3 million heads, being responsible for almost 60% of the total increase [
15]. This increased agricultural production, especially in cattle farming, is the main cause of deforestation due to the opening of new cattle farming areas, causing serious environmental, social, and cultural damage to the Amazon Biome [
16]. Increased cattle farming in recently deforested pastures has also been associated with an increased incidence of hoof injuries in these bovines [
7]. The study by Silveira et al. [
12] reported epidemiological characteristics of foot lesions, such as the fact that 91.7% (11/12) of the farms had tree-trunk paddocks, 66.7% (8/12) had sloping terrains and stones, and 16.7% (2/12) had flooded areas. Those data corroborate the epidemiological factors reported in this study, which include the presence of stones in pastures and roads, mud in management pens, and frequent grazing in recently cleared areas with stumps, stones, and branches. Dirty recently cleared areas are a practice adopted by most rural farmers in the Amazon Biome, who do not clean deforested areas before introducing bovines due to cleaning and tree stump removal costs, keeping stumps, branches, and roots in the pastures [
17]. Therefore, pastures in newly cleared areas increase the onset of traumatic dewclaw lesions caused mostly by stumps, justifying the presence of BDCD in 6.9% of the bovines analyzed in this study.
The Bovines were evaluated in 2022, a year with increased rainfall (September, 57.8 mm; October, 98.6 mm; November, 132.6 mm; and December, 180.79 mm) [
18], much higher than the expected for 2023, justifying the accumulation of mud and organic matter in animal management areas on the studied properties, with rainfall and humidity being important epidemiological factors in the Amazon Biome. However, Rodrigues et al. [
19] and Klitgaard et al. [
20] studied foot disorders in dairy cows, determining spirochetes the possible agent involved in hoof injury cases, including BDCD, and suggesting that humidity is a relevant factor in BDCD pathogenesis, was observed in the present study, especially during the rainy season in which it was conducted.
Another factor evaluated in the present study was the physical structure of bovine management facilities. Costa et al. [
21] stated that zootechnical facilities should not cause physical harm to the animals, ensuring the welfare and safety of animals and rural workers. All farms analyzed in the present study managed animals in pens and containment pens not adapted to best practices aimed at animal welfare, with stressful procedures leading to fear and aggressive behaviors such as restlessness, kicking, agitation, and escape attempts, considerably increasing the risk of digits and dewclaw lesions in the cattle [
22,
23]. The pens also had containment trunks with broken boards and access ramps with holes and stones, favoring traumatic foot injuries and the consequent onset of BDCD.
Crossbred bovines were more affected by BDCD (61.2%) than zebu bovines (38.7%). Burrow et al. [
24] reported a predominance of zebu breeds and crossings in beef farming, which are considered more agitated, aggressive, and temperamental than European breeds. Furthermore, human-animal interaction in the extensive farming system is minimal, and with less frequent contact between bovines and rural workers, animals with more agitated temperaments demonstrate more intense and traumatic behavioral responses when exposed to stress situations or human presence [
25,
26]. Breed, temperament, and extensive breeding systems with reduced management and animal-human contact may have contributed to the agitated behavior of the bovines in this study, which possibly increased BDCD onset.
The physical conditions of the trucks and cages used to transport bovines on farm A may be a predisposing factor associated with dewclaw injuries because the floors of these vehicles had misaligned non-slip iron railings, with loose iron spikes facing upwards, which may increase the risk of injuries during transportation, aspects corroborated by Nielsen et al. [
27], who reported that transport-related factors play a major role in the incidence foot injuries in cattle. The poor maintenance of transport vehicles and the lack of road paving and maintenance cause animal stress during transportation, with less balance in the trucks, which consequently increases the risk of slips and falls, resulting in injuries such as dewclaw lesions.
Rueda et al. [
28] also report that frequent and recurrent management in pens can affect regulatory and behavioral responses typical of animals with poor welfare, increasing cattle reactivity and predisposing them to injuries. This factor was observed in the present study, with most animals with BDCD being females (61%) subjected to reproductive management, which requires at least three transportations to the management pen in a short period of time. This greater animal management frequency increases stress levels, making beef cattle used for reproduction more prone and exposed to the risk of accessory digit injuries for being transported more often to management areas, for being subjected to higher stress levels, and for walking greater distances on soils with stones.
Another factor related to the greater incidence of BDCD in females is age. Molina et al. [
29] reported a higher frequency of hoof problems in older bovines which are exposed several times to predisposing factors, reinforcing the results of this present study, in which most bovines with BDCD were older females that stayed for long periods on breeding farms, being more exposed to conditions predisposing traumatic dewclaw lesions.
Inappropriate mounting is a behavioral disorder that predisposes digit and accessory digit lesions [
30]. Silveira et al. [
12] reported corneal tissue erosions in the heels, at the base of the accessory digit, in the pasterns, and in the crown of the pelvic limbs as a result of mounting. In this study, inappropriate mounting was a common practice between females on properties 5 and 8 (62.5%), which were intended for breeding and used the fixed-time artificial insemination technique. Therefore, on the insemination day, cows in heat constantly mounted on the others, predisposing foot injuries. In males, mounting was observed during the period they were trapped in the pen before immunization.
Another important factor in digit and dewclaw lesions is parasitism by the fly
Cochliomyia hominivorax, considered the main species associated with primary myiasis in Brazil [
31]. Fly parasitism is facilitated in environments with excess humidity and organic matter, associated with infrastructure problems and management difficulties, consequently increasing the incidence of primary traumatic injuries with hemorrhage, which end up attracting flies to deposit eggs in the region [
32]. This is a significant factor that cannot be discarded in the epidemiology of accessory digit injuries. Myiasis can be a gateway for foot injury agents, hindering the visualization and diagnosis of primary foot diseases [
33].
Escaping and kicking reactions were observed in the study bovines, which caused dewclaw injuries, mainly in the pelvic limbs. This kicking behavior was repeatedly observed during management in the pens, resulting in 91.8% BDCD injuries in the pelvic limbs, being, therefore, another important epidemiological factor in beef cattle in the Amazon Biome. The lateral dewclaw (60.60%) was more affected than the medial dewclaw (39.40%), which may be justified by the fact that this structure is more exposed to mechanical trauma [
34]. There was greater occurrence of injuries in the right limbs (60.60%). Gargano et al. [
35] reported that the right limb is more affected in cattle, possibly due to decreased blood circulation in this limb, since sternal rest commonly exerts greater pressure on this limb.
More studies are needed on this subject to evaluate the real losses and impacts of BDCD on Brazilian and global agribusiness, as well as studies on the etiology of BCDC in beef cattle farming.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, J.B.d.S., J.D.B., C.M.C.O. and F.M.S.; methodology, J.B.d.S., J.D.B., H.G.d.S.O., C.C.B., T.T.A.F., J.A.S.d.S., N.d.S.e.S.d.S., M.F.B, C.M.C.O., H.d.A.B. and F.M.S.; formal analysis, J.B.d.S., J.D.B., C.M.C.O., H.d.A.B. and F.M.S.; investigation, J.B.d.S., J.D.B., H.G.d.S.O., C.C.B., T.T.A.F., J.A.S.d.S., N.d.S.e.S.d.S, M.F.B, C.M.C.O., H.d.A.B. and F.M.S.; data curation, J.B.d.S., J.D.B., H.G.d.S.O., C.C.B., T.T.A.F., J.A.S.d.S., N.d.S.e.S.d.S, M.F.B, C.M.C.O., H.d.A.B. and F.M.S.; writing—original draft preparation J.B.d.S., J.D.B. and F.M.S; writing—review and editing, J.B.d.S., J.D.B., N.d.S.e.S.d.S, M.F.B, T.T.A.F., H.d.A.B. and F.M.S..; supervision, F.M.S., H.d.A.B. and J.D.B.; project administration, F.M.S., H.d.A.B. and J.D.B.. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Figure 1.
BDCD lesions in beef cattle from farms south and southeast region of Pará, Amazon Biome. a) BDCD on the left pelvic limb in a pen with stones. b) Chronic BDCD, with corneal tissue loss and increase in volume with proliferation of granulation tissue. Convex surface with filamentous projections interspersed with ulcerated areas and blood clots, on the lateral dewclaw of the right pelvic limb.
Figure 1.
BDCD lesions in beef cattle from farms south and southeast region of Pará, Amazon Biome. a) BDCD on the left pelvic limb in a pen with stones. b) Chronic BDCD, with corneal tissue loss and increase in volume with proliferation of granulation tissue. Convex surface with filamentous projections interspersed with ulcerated areas and blood clots, on the lateral dewclaw of the right pelvic limb.
Graph 1.
Distribution of BDCD lesions by properties studied.
Graph 1.
Distribution of BDCD lesions by properties studied.
Figure 2.
Pasture conditions and roads used for the cattle on farms south and southeast region of Pará, Amazon Biome. a) Farm G with cattle in recently cleared pastures with branches and stumps. b) Road with stones and gravel on farm E.
Figure 2.
Pasture conditions and roads used for the cattle on farms south and southeast region of Pará, Amazon Biome. a) Farm G with cattle in recently cleared pastures with branches and stumps. b) Road with stones and gravel on farm E.
Figure 3.
Places where the cattle stayed: a) Farm F with stones around the cattle drinking trough. b) Farm B with stones used on the pen and containment pen floor as non-slip objects.
Figure 3.
Places where the cattle stayed: a) Farm F with stones around the cattle drinking trough. b) Farm B with stones used on the pen and containment pen floor as non-slip objects.
Figure 4.
Cattle management pens on the properties studied in the Amazon Biome. a) Management pen with a large amount of stones on farm D. b) Mud accumulation in a pen during the rainy season on farm C.
Figure 4.
Cattle management pens on the properties studied in the Amazon Biome. a) Management pen with a large amount of stones on farm D. b) Mud accumulation in a pen during the rainy season on farm C.
Figure 5.
Physical conditions of bovine management facilities on the properties studied in south and southeast region of Pará, Amazon Biome. a) Individual containment pen on farm B with broken boards. b) Blood on the pen floor, indicating distal extremity injuries in the cattle after management on farm A.
Figure 5.
Physical conditions of bovine management facilities on the properties studied in south and southeast region of Pará, Amazon Biome. a) Individual containment pen on farm B with broken boards. b) Blood on the pen floor, indicating distal extremity injuries in the cattle after management on farm A.
Figure 6.
Vehicles used to transport cattle on farm A. a) and b) Loose transport truck grilles, with misaligned and prominent metal parts with exposed ends.
Figure 6.
Vehicles used to transport cattle on farm A. a) and b) Loose transport truck grilles, with misaligned and prominent metal parts with exposed ends.
Table 1.
BDCD lesions in beef cattle raised in extensive systems in the south and southeast region of Pará, Brazilian Amazon Biome.
Table 1.
BDCD lesions in beef cattle raised in extensive systems in the south and southeast region of Pará, Brazilian Amazon Biome.
Farms |
Inspected Bovines |
Bovines with BDCD |
Limbs |
Bovines with BDCD in more than one limb |
TL* |
PL** |
A |
90 |
8 |
1 |
7 |
2 |
B |
75 |
5 |
1 |
4 |
1 |
C |
30 |
2 |
0 |
2 |
0 |
D |
80 |
5 |
1 |
4 |
1 |
E |
120 |
10 |
1 |
9 |
6 |
F |
115 |
11 |
0 |
11 |
4 |
G |
120 |
6 |
0 |
6 |
1 |
H |
76 |
2 |
0 |
2 |
0 |
Absolute value |
706 |
49 |
4 |
45 |
15 |
Relative value |
100% |
6,9% |
8,2% |
91,8% |
30,6% |
Minimum |
30 |
2 |
0 |
2 |
0 |
Maximum |
120 |
11 |
1 |
11 |
6 |
Average |
88,25 |
6,13 |
0,50 |
5,63 |
1,88 |
Standard deviation |
30,523 |
3,357 |
0,535 |
3,249 |
2,100 |
Table 2.
Absolute and relative values of the distribution of dewclaw dermatitis in beef cattle, raised extensively in south and southeast region of Pará, according to sex, breed and affected limbs.
Table 2.
Absolute and relative values of the distribution of dewclaw dermatitis in beef cattle, raised extensively in south and southeast region of Pará, according to sex, breed and affected limbs.
|
Sex |
Cattle breed |
Limbs |
F |
M |
Mest* |
Nel** |
TL* |
PL** |
Absolute value |
30 61,2% |
19 38,8% |
30 61,2% |
19 38,8% |
4 |
45 |
Relative value |
8,2% |
91,8 |
Table 3.
Absolute and relative frequency analysis of the presence of dirty, recently mowed pastures and the presence of stones on the studied properties.
Table 3.
Absolute and relative frequency analysis of the presence of dirty, recently mowed pastures and the presence of stones on the studied properties.
Freshly mown pastures |
Pastures with stones |
Test Mann-whitney in between pastures with stones and freshly mown pastures |
|
Frequency |
Percentage |
Frequency |
Percentage |
|
Valid |
No |
3 |
37,5 |
2 |
25,0 |
0,237 |
|
Yes |
5 |
62,5 |
6 |
75,0 |
|