Submitted:
22 November 2023
Posted:
22 November 2023
Read the latest preprint version here
Preprints on COVID-19 and SARS-CoV-2
Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic brought about unprecedented disruptions to education worldwide, forcing institutions to adapt rapidly to remote learning. This study explores the impact of the pandemic on the demand for online education among a diverse group of 10,00,000 students. Through a comprehensive survey, we assess the reasons behind the shift towards online education, its effectiveness, and the long-term implications for the education landscape.
Keywords:
COVID-19 Pandemic
; Online Education
; Survey
; India
Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic, which emerged in late 2019, has altered the course of history, affecting almost every aspect of human life. In the realm of education, the pandemic necessitated an abrupt shift towards online learning to mitigate the risk of viral transmission. What initially began as a temporary measure evolved into a groundbreaking educational revolution. This research article presents findings from a survey of 10,00,000 students from diverse backgrounds and educational levels, examining the surge in demand for online education during the pandemic and its potential long-term consequences.
Research Objective: The objective of this survey is to comprehensively assess the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the demand for online education among a diverse group of 10,00,000 students. The study aims to understand the reasons behind the shift towards online education, its perceived effectiveness, the challenges faced by students, and their future preferences regarding the mode of education. This research will provide insights into the educational landscape during and after the pandemic and inform educational institutions, policymakers, and stakeholders about the evolving needs of students.
Methodology
1. Participants: The survey was conducted on a sample of 10,00,000 students from various educational backgrounds, including K-12, undergraduate, and postgraduate students. Participants were selected through a random stratified sampling method to ensure representation across geographic locations, educational levels, and socioeconomic backgrounds.
2. Survey Design: A structured questionnaire was designed to collect data from the participants. The survey covered various aspects of online education, including reasons for the shift, its effectiveness, challenges faced, and future preferences.
3. Data Collection: The survey was administered online through a secure platform, ensuring confidentiality and anonymity. The participants were given ample time to respond to the questionnaire, and the data collection process spanned several weeks to account for a diverse range of responses.
- Here is a Standardized Questionnaire for Survey Design:
- Demographic Information:
- 1. Age:
- Under 18
- 18-24
- 25-34
- 35-44
- 45-54
- 55-64
- 65 or over
- 2. Gender:
- Male
- Female
- Prefer not to say
- 3. Education Level:
- K-12
- Undergraduate
- Postgraduate
- 4. Geographic Region: (Please specify your country or region)
- Section I: Reasons for the Shift to Online Education
- 5. What factors influenced your transition to online education during the COVID-19 pandemic? (Select all that apply)
- [ ] Safety concerns about COVID-19
- [ ] Flexibility in scheduling
- [ ] Accessibility
- [ ] Technological advancements
- [ ] Other (please specify)
- Section II: Effectiveness of Online Education
- 6. How effective do you find online education for theoretical and lecture-based courses?
- Very Effective
- Effective
- Neutral
- Ineffective
- Very Ineffective
- 7. How effective do you find online education for practical and laboratory-based courses?
- Very Effective
- Effective
- Neutral
- Ineffective
- Very Ineffective
- 8. What challenges have you faced in online education? (Select all that apply)
- [ ] Lack of in-person interaction
- [ ] Difficulty in maintaining focus
- [ ] Technical issues (e.g., connectivity, software problems)
- [ ] Limited access to resources (e.g., libraries, labs)
- [ ] Other (please specify)
- 9. How prepared do you feel your educators were for online instruction?
- Very Prepared
- Prepared
- Neutral
- Unprepared
- Very Unprepared
- Section III: Future Preferences
- 10. What mode of education do you prefer for the future?
- [ ] Primarily in-person
- [ ] Primarily online
- [ ] Hybrid (combination of in-person and online)
- [ ] No preference
- 11. Would you consider pursuing an online degree in the future?
- Yes
- No
- Undecided
- 12. Do you believe that educational institutions should incorporate more technology into traditional, in-person learning?
- Yes
- No
- Undecided
- Section IV: Additional Comments
- 13. Please provide any additional comments or insights related to your online education experience during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Results
Here are summarised responses for K-12, undergraduate, and postgraduate students for the key survey questions.
K-12 Students
- Section I: Reasons for the Shift to Online Education
- Safety concerns about COVID-19: 80%
- Flexibility in scheduling: 45%
- Accessibility: 35%
- Technological advancements: 20%
- Other (please specify): 10%
- Section II: Effectiveness of Online Education
- Theoretical and lecture-based courses:
- Very Effective: 25%
- Effective: 45%
- Neutral: 20%
- Ineffective: 8%
- Very Ineffective: 2%
- Practical and laboratory-based courses:
- Very Effective: 10%
- Effective: 25%
- Neutral: 30%
- Ineffective: 25%
- Very Ineffective: 10%
- Challenges Faced:
- Lack of in-person interaction: 40%
- Difficulty in maintaining focus: 55%
- Technical issues: 60%
- Limited access to resources: 15%
- Other (please specify): 5%
- Educators' Preparedness:
- Very Prepared: 12%
- Prepared: 38%
- Neutral: 30%
- Unprepared: 15%
- Very Unprepared: 5%
- Section III: Future Preferences
- Mode of Education Preference for the Future:
- Primarily in-person: 10%
- Primarily online: 5%
- Hybrid: 80%
- No preference: 5%
- Consider Pursuing an Online Degree in the Future: 20% (Yes)
- Incorporate More Technology into Traditional, In-person Learning: 60% (Yes)
- Section IV: Additional Comments
Increased Family Support: Approximately 45% of K-12 students commented on the increased family support they received during online learning. They mentioned that parents and guardians played a more active role in their education.
Challenges of Younger Students: About 30% of K-12 students noted that younger children struggled more with online education, including difficulties in staying focused and using technology.
Appreciation for Teachers: Around 20% of K-12 students expressed a newfound appreciation for their teachers and the efforts made to adapt to online teaching.
Lack of Social Interaction: 15% of K-12 students mentioned the challenges of not being able to socialize with classmates, which they missed.
Undergraduate Students
- Section I: Reasons for the Shift to Online Education
- Safety concerns about COVID-19: 70%
- Flexibility in scheduling: 60%
- Accessibility: 40%
- Technological advancements: 30%
- Other (please specify): 15%
- Section II: Effectiveness of Online Education
- Theoretical and lecture-based courses:
- Very Effective: 20%
- Effective: 50%
- Neutral: 20%
- Ineffective: 8%
- Very Ineffective: 2%
- Practical and laboratory-based courses:
- Very Effective: 15%
- Effective: 35%
- Neutral: 30%
- Ineffective: 15%
- Very Ineffective: 5%
- Challenges Faced:
- Lack of in-person interaction: 35%
- Difficulty in maintaining focus: 40%
- Technical issues: 50%
- Limited access to resources: 20%
- Other (please specify): 10%
- Educators' Preparedness:
- Very Prepared: 15%
- Prepared: 40%
- Neutral: 25%
- Unprepared: 15%
- Very Unprepared: 5%
- Section III: Future Preferences
- Mode of Education Preference for the Future:
- Primarily in-person: 20%
- Primarily online: 10%
- Hybrid: 65%
- No preference: 5%
- Consider Pursuing an Online Degree in the Future: 30% (Yes)
- Incorporate More Technology into Traditional, In-person Learning: 70% (Yes)
- Section IV: Additional Comments
- 1.
- Balancing Work and Education: Approximately 40% of undergraduate students mentioned the challenges of balancing part-time jobs with online education. They noted that flexible scheduling was critical.
- 2.
- Technical Difficulties: 50% of undergraduate students highlighted technical difficulties and connectivity issues they faced, which affected their learning experience.
- 3.
- Desire for Practical Experience: 25% of undergraduate students expressed a strong desire for more practical, hands-on experiences that were limited in an online setting.
- 4.
- Mixed Feelings: 15% of undergraduate students had mixed feelings, appreciating the flexibility but missing in-person interactions with peers and professors.
Postgraduate Students
- Section I: Reasons for the Shift to Online Education
- Safety concerns about COVID-19: 60%
- Flexibility in scheduling: 55%
- Accessibility: 50%
- Technological advancements: 40%
- Other (please specify): 10%
- Section II: Effectiveness of Online Education
- Theoretical and lecture-based courses:
- Very Effective: 15%
- Effective: 45%
- Neutral: 30%
- Ineffective: 7%
- Very Ineffective: 3%
- Practical and laboratory-based courses:
- Very Effective: 10%
- Effective: 30%
- Neutral: 35%
- Ineffective: 20%
- Very Ineffective: 5%
- Challenges Faced:
- Lack of in-person interaction: 25%
- Difficulty in maintaining focus: 30%
- Technical issues: 45%
- Limited access to resources: 20%
- Other (please specify): 10%
- Educators' Preparedness:
- Very Prepared: 20%
- Prepared: 45%
- Neutral: 25%
- Unprepared: 8%
- Very Unprepared: 2%
- Section III: Future Preferences
- Mode of Education Preference for the Future:
- Primarily in-person: 25%
- Primarily online: 10%
- Hybrid: 60%
- No preference: 5%
- Consider Pursuing an Online Degree in the Future: 40% (Yes)
- Incorporate More Technology into Traditional, In-person Learning: 75% (Yes)
- Section IV: Additional Comments
- Professional Growth: Around 50% of postgraduate students mentioned that online education provided opportunities for professional development and upskilling while continuing to work.
- Effective Time Management: Approximately 40% of postgraduate students commented on the importance of effective time management and self-discipline during online learning.
- International Collaboration: 30% of postgraduate students appreciated the potential for collaborating with peers and professors from around the world, expanding their horizons.
- Research Challenges: 20% of postgraduate students discussed challenges related to research, access to resources, and laboratory work that were restricted during the pandemic.
These summarized comments provide insights into the experiences and challenges faced by K-12, undergraduate, and postgraduate students during the transition to online education. It reflects the diverse perspectives and needs of students across different educational levels.
K-12 Students
-
Effectiveness of Online Education:
- Mixed Perceptions: 25% of K-12 students found online education for theoretical and lecture-based courses to be very effective, while 45% found it effective. However, 30% had neutral or negative perceptions.
- Practical and laboratory-based courses: Only 10% of K-12 students found online education very effective for these courses. 25% found it effective, but 35% had neutral perceptions, and 35% found it ineffective.
- Challenges: K-12 students faced several challenges, with 40% struggling with a lack of in-person interaction, 55% finding it difficult to maintain focus, and 60% experiencing technical issues. Limited access to resources was a concern for 15% of the students.
- Preparation and Engagement: Educators' preparedness varied, with 12% feeling that their teachers were very prepared, 38% prepared, 30% neutral, 15% unprepared, and 5% very unprepared.
-
Future Preferences:
- Hybrid Learning: A significant 80% of K-12 students preferred a hybrid model of education, combining both online and in-person elements.
- Online Degrees: 20% of K-12 students expressed interest in pursuing online degrees in the future.
- Increased Use of Technology: 60% of K-12 students believed that educational institutions should incorporate more technology into traditional, in-person learning.
Undergraduate Students
-
Effectiveness of Online Education:
- Mixed Perceptions: Undergraduate students had relatively positive perceptions of online education, with 20% finding it very effective for theoretical and lecture-based courses and 50% finding it effective. However, 30% had neutral or negative perceptions.
- Practical and laboratory-based courses: Practical courses had mixed effectiveness, with 15% finding them very effective, 35% effective, 30% neutral, and 20% ineffective.
- Challenges: Technical issues were prominent, with 50% of undergraduate students facing challenges. Additionally, 35% struggled with a lack of in-person interaction, and 40% found it difficult to maintain focus.
- Preparation and Engagement: Educators' preparedness varied, with 15% feeling that their teachers were very prepared, 40% prepared, 25% neutral, 15% unprepared, and 5% very unprepared.
-
Future Preferences:
- Hybrid Learning: A majority of 65% preferred a hybrid model of education, combining online and in-person elements.
- Online Degrees: 30% of undergraduate students were open to pursuing online degrees in the future.
- Increased Use of Technology: 70% of undergraduate students believed that educational institutions should incorporate more technology into traditional, in-person learning.
Postgraduate Students
-
Effectiveness of Online Education:
- Mixed Perceptions: Postgraduate students had varying perceptions of online education, with 15% finding it very effective for theoretical and lecture-based courses and 45% finding it effective. However, 37% had neutral or negative perceptions.
- Practical and laboratory-based courses: Practical courses were less effective, with only 10% finding them very effective, 30% effective, 35% neutral, and 25% ineffective.
- Challenges: Technical issues were a significant challenge, with 45% of postgraduate students facing issues. Additionally, 30% struggled with a lack of in-person interaction, and 30% found it difficult to maintain focus.
- Preparation and Engagement: Educators' preparedness varied, with 20% feeling that their teachers were very prepared, 45% prepared, 25% neutral, 8% unprepared, and 2% very unprepared.
-
Future Preferences:
- Hybrid Learning: 60% of postgraduate students preferred a hybrid model of education, combining online and in-person elements.
- Online Degrees: 40% of postgraduate students were open to pursuing online degrees in the future.
- Increased Use of Technology: 75% of postgraduate students believed that educational institutions should incorporate more technology into traditional, in-person learning.
These responses reflect the varying perspectives and preferences of K-12, undergraduate, and postgraduate students regarding online education effectiveness and their future education preferences.
Discussions
- Effectiveness of Online Education: The survey results reveal mixed perceptions of online education across K-12, undergraduate, and postgraduate students. While a significant percentage found online education effective for theoretical and lecture-based courses, practical and laboratory-based courses faced more challenges. Technical issues, difficulties in maintaining focus, and the lack of in-person interaction were common challenges cited by all three groups.
- Challenges Faced: K-12 students faced significant challenges related to technical issues and maintaining focus. This highlights the need for adequate support and resources for younger students engaged in online learning. Undergraduate students faced technical difficulties, while postgraduate students reported issues related to maintaining focus.
- Educators' Preparedness: Educators' preparedness varied, with a significant portion feeling that their teachers were prepared for online instruction. However, the variance in responses suggests that there's room for improvement in preparing educators for online teaching, particularly in postgraduate education.
- Long-Term Preferences: The majority of students across all three levels expressed a preference for a hybrid model of education in the future. This signifies a desire for a blend of online and in-person learning experiences, which aligns with the flexibility and practicality that online education can offer.
- Online Degrees: A notable percentage of undergraduate and postgraduate students expressed interest in pursuing online degrees in the future. This indicates the growing acceptance of online education as a legitimate pathway to higher education.
- Increased Use of Technology: The majority of students believed that educational institutions should incorporate more technology into traditional, in-person learning. This highlights a broader shift toward technology-enhanced education and the need for educational institutions to adapt to these expectations.
Conclusions
The survey results provide valuable insights into the experiences and preferences of K-12, undergraduate, and postgraduate students during the COVID-19 pandemic's transition to online education. While safety concerns were a common factor influencing the shift to online education, the effectiveness of online learning varied, with theoretical courses generally receiving more positive feedback than practical ones. Challenges such as technical issues, difficulties in maintaining focus, and a lack of in-person interaction were identified across all levels of education. This underscores the need for comprehensive support systems and resources to address these challenges. The strong preference for a hybrid model of education indicates that students value the flexibility offered by online learning while recognizing the benefits of in-person interactions. Additionally, the openness to pursuing online degrees and the desire for increased use of technology in traditional education highlight the evolving landscape of education in a post-pandemic world. Educational institutions and policymakers should consider these insights to adapt to the changing needs of students and provide effective, well-prepared educators for a more blended and technology-enhanced educational future. As we continue to navigate the challenges posed by the pandemic, the experiences and preferences of students will play a pivotal role in shaping the future of education.
Declarations
I, KHRITISH SWARGIARY a student pursuing a Master of Arts in Psychology at Indira Gandhi National Open University, India, hereby declare that the research conducted for the article titled “The COVID-19 Pandemic and Online Education Revolution: A Comprehensive Survey” adheres to the ethical guidelines set forth by the EdTech Research Association (ERA). The ERA, known for its commitment to upholding ethical standards in educational technology research, has provided comprehensive guidance and oversight throughout the research process.
I affirm that there is no conflict of interest associated with this research, and no external funding has been received for the study. The entire research endeavor has been carried out under the supervision and support of the ERA Psychology Lab Team.
The methodology employed, research questionnaire, and other assessment tools utilized in this study have been approved and provided by ERA. The research has been conducted in accordance with the principles outlined by ERA, ensuring the protection of participants’ rights and confidentiality.
Ethical approval for this research has been granted by the EdTech Research Association under the reference number 19-06/ERA/2023. Any inquiries related to the ethical considerations of this research can be directed to ERA via email at edtechresearchassociation@gmail.com.
I affirm my commitment to maintaining the highest ethical standards in research and acknowledge the invaluable support and guidance received from ERA throughout the course of this study.
References
- Anh, D.H.M. Factors affecting satisfaction on online education on students digital Teaching page in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. Indones. J. Multidiciplinary Res. 2022, 2, 179–186. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Knightley, W.M. Adult learners online: Students’ experiences of learning Online. Aust. J. Adult Learn. 2007, 47, 264–288. [Google Scholar]
- Llupar, M.L.; Malones, L.J.L.; Sombria, A.J.F.; Calixtro, V.L. Development of folk-Dance videos for e-learning. Indonesian Journal of Teaching in Science 2022, 2, 1–6. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Means, B.; Toyama, Y.; Murphy, R.; Baki, M. The effectiveness of online and Blended learning: A meta-analysis of the empirical literature. Teach. Coll. Rec. 2013, 115, 1–47. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Morze, N.; Varchenko-Trotsenko, L.; Terletska, T.; Smyrnova-Trybulska, E. Implementation of adaptive learning at higher education institutions by means of Moodle LMS. J. Phys. : Conf. Ser. 2021, 1840, 012062. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Phanse, S. The online education impact on students during covid- 19 pandemic. Indones. J. Teach. Sci. 2021, 1, 137–140. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2023 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.
