1. Introduction
Cloud computing has garnered significant interest from researchers and professionals due to its applicability across various industries, including education as a service [
1]. This technology has transformed educational spaces, bringing about a shift in how students learn and how educators teach [
2].
In particular, cloud platforms are of great interest to the educational community for their accessibility features, enabling shared learning anytime, anywhere, across different devices and multiple platforms [
3]. They offer services that enhance the functionality of learning management systems by facilitating the creation, editing, and sharing of educational resources [
4].
Currently, cloud platforms enable collaborative projects and the development of teamwork and communication skills, essential attributes for success in the job market. This is a necessary requirement for the training of highly qualified engineering specialists geared towards the labor market [
5]. Faced with this need, educational systems are confronted with the challenge of implementing new learning environments using technologies. In this regard, cloud platforms can be a valuable tool for promoting practical activities where students acquire the competencies required in their specialization area within a virtual environment [
6].
The ability to access multiple services available on a cloud platform facilitates innovative teaching strategies in the classroom or enhances online education to meet the demands of modern education. Tobarra and colleagues [
7] rely on game-based learning with a cloud platform to enhance the learning process of engineering students in the field of cybersecurity. Another research, also on an online cybersecurity course, employs a cloud platform to develop practical skills in computer engineering students [
8]. Authors Pramod Abichandani and colleagues [
9] utilize a virtual reality system based on a cloud platform for teaching about solar energy, employing team-based and project-based learning to generate motivation in first-year engineering students and develop up-to-date general competencies in solar energy from strategic and business perspectives. In another study, a cloud technology platform is used to adapt the flipped learning model and assess critical thinking skills in mathematics among fourth-year university students [
10]. Another related research utilizes the deployment of resources from a cloud platform to support ubiquitous English language learning [
11].
To achieve these aforementioned teaching strategies, there are various cloud platforms available. Research by Nur Diyana Rossiman and colleagues employs Google Drive due to its popularity among higher education institution students [
12]. Dropbox is also widely accepted and highly useful for collaborative learning and content management [
4,
13,
14]. Glazunova and colleagues evaluate through a set of criteria and indicators how platforms like Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace are the most suitable for providing group work to students in distance learning [
15]. However, other studies propose implementing similar solutions using open-source software like Nextcloud [
16,
17,
18,
19]. The choice between them depends on issues related to software acquisition, having hardware resources for space allocation, and hiring personnel if one wishes to implement with their own infrastructure [
20].
1.1. Usage of Nextcloud in the university context. Nextcloud at “José Antonio Echeverría” Technological University of Havana
In today's education, the learning environment extends beyond the physical classroom space, with cloud platforms like Nextcloud enabling universal access to education. This platform allows for hosting, synchronizing, and sharing files online with other users, accessible through a website or a desktop program for various operating systems (
https://nextcloud.com/education/).
For many universities, Nextcloud proves to be a functional platform as it requires minimal financial investment and offers a solution for deploying storage as a service using free and open-source software [
5,
18].
Vásquez Bermúdez et al. affirm that it can be a valuable tool for collaborative learning, allowing for control over files and applications within the universities where it is implemented [
16,
18]. This is because it boasts a high level of security and privacy, with data stored on the universities' own servers rather than third-party servers, ensuring full control over data and access [
16,
18].
This file management tool offers a wide range of features and functionalities for online learning [
21], a necessity for the current training of professionals.
In Cuba, "José Antonio Echeverría" Technological University of Havana (CUJAE) adopted Nextcloud as the most suitable platform to support the teaching-learning process. By being installed on CUJAE's own servers, this platform offers greater technological independence, storage space at no additional cost, and data security and privacy. The Faculty of Chemical Engineering was the first to implement Nextcloud in 2016 and was named CloudIQ (Chemical Engineering Cloud). The term "cloud" was used for the computer services that would be provided via the Internet [
18].
In its early stages, CloudIQ presented a structure of shared storage folders for users, among which stood out the management of teaching documents and academic theses. These experiences were enhanced with the cessation of face-to-face training, with the arrival of the COVID-19 pandemic; new tools were added to the platform, such as the activity calendar, forms, online office suite, conferences, and the inclusion of email and chat in a virtual collaborative environment.
However, once the various functionalities of the platform were implemented, the authors of this study posed the following questions:
Question 1: How frequently is the platform used by professors and students of the Faculty of Chemical Engineering?
Question 2: Is the platform accepted by professors and students of the Faculty of Chemical Engineering?
To investigate this, the research was conducted with the aim of evaluating the usage and acceptance of the Nextcloud platform, from the perspective of students and professors of the Faculty of Chemical Engineering at CUJAE.
1.2. Information Technology Acceptance Models in Cloud Computing
Once the platform is selected, there are various user acceptance models in the literature to assess the impact of implemented technology [
22]. In the educational context, these models are useful for academic researchers to study, understand, and improve variables such as usability, attitude, behavior, control, intention, perception, ease of use, among others, and their relationships. Research has been conducted that combines models to study the influence among various acceptance factors during the teaching and learning process using cloud-based platforms [
23]. It has also been used to determine which platforms are most suitable based on their functionalities and what didactic strategies they enable teachers to develop [
16,
17,
19], as well as to enhance understanding of the motivational factors behind student satisfaction or dissatisfaction [
24].
This study will employ the Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) model. According to the literature, despite the existence of various models, UTAUT has been considered one of the most popular in the field of technology acceptance and technological factors for the successful implementation of information systems [
25,
26,
27].
2. Materials and Methods
The research was of an exploratory, non-experimental, and cross-sectional nature [
28]. It was conducted from March to September 2022.
In line with the research objective, the instruments used for data collection were observation and a survey. Both instruments were validated by experts, yielding the following Cronbach's alpha values: α=0.88 and α=0.91, respectively.
A guide for observation was employed, taking into account variables such as the number of visits, web browsers, operating systems, types of devices, and services utilized (
Figure 1). For this purpose, the online, free, and open-source tool Matomo Analytics [
29] was used. This web analytics tool monitored user traffic, access, and interaction with the CloudIQ platform.
The survey was voluntarily administered to a sample of 32 students and 32 randomly selected professors (simple random sampling) of Chemistry Faculty at CUJAE. It was based on a design similar to the research [
17], which used UTAUT as the model [
30]. This instrument consisted of 4 constructs and 12 items (
Figure 2), distributed as follows:
Items 1 to 3 corresponded to Construct 1 (C1): Performance Expectancy, which is the user's perception of the platform's performance in carrying out their work.
Items 4 to 6 corresponded to Construct 2 (C2): Effort Expectancy, which is the user's perception of the ease associated with using the platform.
Item 7 corresponded to Construct 3 (C3): Social Influence, which is the user's perception of the platform's adoption by their reference institution.
Items 8 to 12 corresponded to Construct 4 (C4): Facilitating Conditions, which is the user's perception of the technical and organizational infrastructure of the platform.
All items were assessed on a 4-value Likert scale, where positive responses corresponded to values 1 as "Completely Agree" and 2 as "Agree." Negative responses were values 4 as "Disagree" and 5 as "Completely Disagree."
Figure 3 shows the survey published from the form service of the CloudIQ platform (
https://cloud.quimica.cujae.edu.cu/). This service allowed for the export of results in Microsoft Excel spreadsheet format for data processing.
3. Results
3.1. Results Obtained Through Scientific Observation
During the evaluated period from March to September 2022, user access and usage of the CloudIQ platform experienced several fluctuations. After reaching its highest value in April, there was a prolonged drop to zero due to issues in the data center. From late July and throughout the month of August, very low visit numbers were recorded due to the vacation season.
Figure 4 displays the visit numbers obtained from the records in the Matomo Analytics tool.
Access to the platform was done through various web browsers. The top three were Google Mobile, Firefox, and Chrome. Following them were Mobile Safari, Samsung Browser, Microsoft Edge, MIUI Browser, Chrome Mobile iOS, Firefox Mobile, and Opera to a lesser extent. Similarly, there were various accesses from a diverse range of operating systems, with Android taking the lead, followed by Windows. Subsequently, iOS, GNU/Linux, and Mac were also used. There was a greater tendency to use mobile devices (smartphones, phablets, tablets, and laptops) rather than desktop computers to access the platform.
There was limited use of the services offered by the platform. The most commonly used were email, chat, and files (shared folders) containing bibliographic materials and software programs. Therefore, in the early stages of implementing Nextcloud, a strategy to encourage its use was to unify various tools as services integrated into the platform, including the most commonly used ones like email and chat. This way, users could navigate from one service to another within the platform itself, without the need to access different avenues.
Furthermore, professors used the platform with their students in their final year of study to develop their undergraduate theses. Meanwhile, students shared study materials with each other to avoid overloading their phones with files.
3.2. Results Obtained from the Survey
The survey results provided the percentage of positive and negative responses for the twelve items.
Table 1 displays the results based on the students' perceptions, while
Table 2 presents the results from the perspective of the professors.
When comparing
Table 1 and
Table 2, it is observed that for students, the majority of responses were in the categories "Agree" and "Disagree." As for the professors, the majority of responses fell into the categories "Completely Agree" and "Completely Disagree."
In
Figure 5, the percentage of the four constructs in positive and negative acceptances is shown, except for the third construct which maintains the same data as it corresponds to only one item (item 7). It is evident that the highest results were in positive acceptances of "Completely Agree" and "Agree," both for students and professors, when compared to negative acceptances of "Disagree" and "Completely Disagree."
4. Discussion and Interpretation
The objective of this research aligns with what authors Garzón and colleagues have analyzed. They argue that positive acceptance by users is a key factor for the success of any technology implemented in an organization, and it is more likely that they will actively engage in its use. [
31].
4.1. Question 1: How often is the platform used by the users?
To address question 1, the evaluation method employed was observation. This method utilized a guide based on the reports obtained through the Matomo Analytics tool. The results revealed that while users frequently utilize the CloudIQ platform, the registered visit count was relatively low in comparison to the number of students and professors in the faculty.
Although Nextcloud proves very useful in supporting the teaching-learning process due to the tools it provides, it's important to note that the platform alone is not sufficient to guide learning. In the Faculty of Chemical Engineering, an underutilization issue has been identified in terms of the advantages offered by the platform regarding the implementation of didactic and methodological strategies that promote its use and acceptance by students.
It's worth noting that cloud platforms, including Nextcloud, ensure an enriching educational experience that fosters the development of strategies such as project-based learning [
9], game-based learning [
7], and flipped learning [
10,
32], among others.
The above requires motivating teachers to acquire digital competencies through training provided by the platform administrator or administrators [
33,
34], in order to achieve a greater integration of technology in the teaching-learning process. In this regard, they should explore the various available tools, learn to use them, and apply them effectively to make the most of classes and connect with students through technology [
24]. It would be valuable for the platform administrator to have pedagogical training that allows them to understand the needs of the teacher and support them in their educational work.
Nextcloud offered teachers' Faculty of Chemical Engineering to develop of undergraduate theses in chemistry students during their final year of the program. It allowed them to share documentation with their mentors and synchronize it from various devices with different operating systems.
4.2. Question 2. Is the platform accepted by users?
On the other hand, to answer question 2, a survey was administered to a sample of students and teachers who commonly used the CloudIQ platform. This survey was based on the UTAUT model. In the results obtained from this instrument, higher levels of positive acceptance were observed in the categories "Completely Agree" and "Agree," both in the overall analysis of the constructs and in the different items that compose them.
Regarding negative acceptances, it was observed that the category "Disagree" had higher results among students compared to teachers. Conversely, a greater number of negative acceptances were observed among teachers in the category "Completely Disagree." These general results demonstrate the interest of the teaching staff in exploring new teaching methodologies that incorporate technologies; however, there still exists a predominant use of traditional teaching strategies in face-to-face education and a resistance to change. Consequently, low levels of interaction in the use of the platform's services by students are generated in relation to the exploitation of the services it offers. These results are reaffirmed in the research by Robles-Gómez and collaborators [
23], who combined the UTAUT and TAM (Technology Acceptance Model) models.
To expand the response to the second question, an analysis was carried out on the relationship between the constructs that make up the survey. In our case, the results of the construct "Better Expectations" were related to the constructs "Performance Expectancy" and "Social Influence," while the construct "Ease of Use Conditions" only influenced "Performance Expectancy." However, this did not occur in another similar study where the results were different, and new evaluation variables were added [
2].
Firstly, the results of the construct "Better Expectations" were related to the construct "Performance Expectancy," where acceptable values were obtained with better results in teachers than in students, which coincides with the findings of other research [
35,
36]. In the context of the Faculty of Chemical Engineering, students consider Nextcloud as complementary, as there are other platforms that meet their needs, such as Moodle. In a related study, both platforms were integrated to provide users with greater technological possibilities in an e-learning environment [
21]. The authors believe that this synergy between both platforms enhances the quality of virtual teaching and enriches the learning experience of students by allowing teachers to use innovative and personalized pedagogical tools for each student.
Next was the construct "Social Influence," which was also related to the construct "Better Expectations," as affirmed by the authors [
37]. However, in this research, these results were only present in the "Completely Agree" ratings among teachers, without a significant impact among students. In a similar study where only students participated, no significant effects of Social Influence were observed in the evaluation of an electronic learning system [
38]. It is undeniable that students today have a wide mastery of electronic and technological devices, allowing them to navigate digital environments with ease [
39]. In this sense, it is evident that they do not need an external entity to develop their learning in a technological environment, as their familiarity with these tools enables them to access a large amount of educational resources autonomously. However, it is important to highlight that the presence of teachers is essential to provide appropriate pedagogical guidance and personalized support to students, contributing to maximizing their learning potential.
Finally, the constructs "Ease of Use Conditions" and "Performance Expectancy" were related, as users increased their confidence in the platform when technical support was provided to remove barriers that hindered its effective use. Similar results coincide with other research studies where it is affirmed that when infrastructure conditions are facilitated and technological and organizational support is provided, users' perception is very positive in the acceptance of a technological system [
35,
40]. Therefore, the Faculty of Chemical Engineering must consider these factors in order to improve the acceptance of the platform for those students and teachers who find it difficult to understand.
4.3. Limitation
This research is fundamentally limited by the chosen sample for the survey, which hinders a deeper analysis of the results. Therefore, as part of the current doctoral research project, it is intended to conduct an analysis with a larger number of participants, which would allow for the verification and enrichment of these findings. It is important to note that the obtained results confirm that the use of Nextcloud enables better collaboration between students and teachers and more efficient management of educational resources, reaffirming findings presented in similar studies [
16,
17,
19].
In the educational context, this research is important for improving the educational experience with Nextcloud, adapting to the needs and requirements of students and teachers, as they are the ones using it. This helps identify possible difficulties that may be affecting the platform's usage and take measures to address them. The authors believe that the results serve as a reference for the continuous improvement of other Nextcloud platforms implemented in the remaining faculties of CUJAE.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, M.A.F.A. and A.D.C.O.; methodology, M.A.F.A.; software, A.D.C.O.; validation, M.A.F.A; A.D.C.O; O.E.M and J.M.Z.A.; formal analysis, M.A.F.A; O.E.M; investigation, M.A.F.A.; resources, M.A.F.A and A.D.C.O.; data curation, M.A.F.A; J.M.Z.A; and L.F.C.C; writing—original draft preparation, M.A.F.A; A.D.C.O.; O.E.M; writing—review and editing, M.A.F.A, O.E.M.; visualization, O.E.M; J.M.Z.A; M.A.F.A.; supervision, O.E.M.; project administration, M.A.F.A. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank the professors and students who participated in the survey. Theirs contributions were very useful for the development of research.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
- Hung, Y. H. Investigating How the Cloud Computing Transforms the Development of Industries. IEEE Access 2019, 7, 181505–181517. [CrossRef]
- Alhamazani, F. H. Exploratory Factor Analysis Toward Adoption Of Cloud Computing By Faculty Members In Saudi Arabian Universities For Teaching And Learning. Int. J. Comput. Sci. Netw. Secur. 2020, 20 (2), 8–15. [CrossRef]
- Gutiérrez González, Á.; García Muñoz Aparicio, C. La Nube, Una Plataforma Alternativa En Una Organización Educativa. Etic@net. Rev. científica electrónica Educ. y Comun. en la Soc. del Conoc. 2019, 19 (2), 26–47. [CrossRef]
- Tuesta Durango, N.; Villanueva Valentín-Gamazo, D.; Alvarado Lorenzo, M. A. El Uso de Flip Teaching y Dropbox Como Medios Para Generar Nuevos Entornos Que Potencien El Proceso de Enseñanza-Aprendizaje. In V Congreso Internacional sobre Aprendizaje, Innovación y Competitividad (CINAIC 2019); Servicio de Publicaciones Universidad: Zaragoza, 2019; pp 273–278. [CrossRef]
- Asenov, S.; Raydovska, V.; Lyubomirov, S.; Shehova, D. USING OF THE NEXTCLOUD TECHNOLOGY IN THE ENGINEER EDUCATION. In ICERI2019 Proceedings; 2019; Vol. 1, pp 7087–7095. [CrossRef]
- Scalera, M.; Gentile, E.; Plantamura, P.; Dimauro, G. A Systematic Mapping Study in Cloud for Educational Innovation. Appl. Sci. 2020, 10 (13), 4531. [CrossRef]
- Tobarra, L.; Utrilla, A.; Robles-Gómez, A.; Pastor-Vargas, R.; Hernández, R. A. Cloud Game-Based Educative Platform Architecture: The CyberScratch Project. Appl. Sci. 2021, 11 (2), 807. [CrossRef]
- Robles-Gomez, A.; Tobarra, L.; Pastor-Vargas, R.; Hernandez, R.; Haut, J. M. Analyzing the Users’ Acceptance of an IoT Cloud Platform Using the UTAUT/TAM Model. IEEE Access 2021, 9, 150004–150020. [CrossRef]
- Abichandani, P.; Mcintyre, W.; Fligor, W.; Lobo, D. Solar Energy Education Through a Cloud-Based Desktop Virtual Reality System. IEEE Access 2019, 7, 147081–147093. [CrossRef]
- Chimmalee, B.; Anupan, A. The effects of using flipped cloud learning with advancing mathematical thinking approaches on undergraduate students’ mathematical critical thinking. Turkish Online J. Distance Educ. 2023, 24 (3), 240–260.
- Jin, N. Students’ Ubiquitous Learning Model and Resource Sharing of English Education Based on Cloud Computing. Wirel. Commun. Mob. Comput. 2022, 2022, 1–7. [CrossRef]
- Rossiman, N. D.; Rashid, N. H.; Ramzuna, W. A. A.; Almunawar, M. N. The Perception and Usage of Google Drive Among Higher Education Institution Students in Brunei Darussalam. Int. J. Asian Bus. Inf. Manag. 2021, 12 (3), 222–241. [CrossRef]
- Mat Yamin, F.; Wan Ishak, W. H. Continuous Use of Online Storage System for Document Sharing. J. Teknol. 2015, 77 (5), 23–27. [CrossRef]
- Abascal Gaytan, L.; Abascal Gaytan, R. P. La Efectividad de La Aplicación de La Nube, Dropbox y Google Drive Como Apoyo Didáctico a Los Procesos de Enseñanza y Aprendizaje. In Journal of Chemical Information and Modeling; 2017; Vol. 53, pp 1142–1162.
- Glazunova, O. G.; Hurzhii, A. M.; Korolchuk, V. I.; Voloshyna, T. V. SELECTION OF DIGITAL TOOLS FOR ORGANIZING STUDENTS’ GROUP WORK IN DISTANCE EDUCATION. Inf. Technol. Learn. Tools 2023, 94 (2), 87–101. [CrossRef]
- Vásquez Bermúdez, M.; Hidalgo Larrea, J.; Avilés Vera, M. del P. Evaluación Del Uso Efectivo de Nextcloud Como Una Herramienta Colaborativa Para La Gestión Del Aprendizaje. Rev. Científica Cienc. y Tecnol. 2019, 19 (21). [CrossRef]
- Vásquez Bermúdez, M.; Hidalgo Larrea, J.; Avilés Vera, M. del P.; Salavarría Melo, J. Evaluación Difusa de La Calidad de Uso Del Cloud Computing Con NextCloud. Rev. Espac. 2019, 40 (35), 24.
- García Díaz, D.; Díaz Crespo, A.; García Perellada, L. R.; Garófalo Hernández, A. A. Characterization of Open Source and Free Code Type Leading Solutions to Deploy Data Storage as a Service. Rev. Telemática 2020, 19 (2), 1–10.
- Hidalgo, J.; Vásquez, M.; Bravo, L.; Burgos, F.; Vargas, Y. Modelo de Aceptación de Tecnología TAM En NextCloud. Caso de Estudio Escuela Computación e Informática. Rev. Espac. 2019, 40 (21), 4.
- Wu, W.; Plakhtii, A. E-Learning Based on Cloud Computing. Int. J. Emerg. Technol. Learn. 2021, 16 (10), 4. [CrossRef]
- Moses Toto, I.; Hadi Rantelinggi, P.; Sanglise, M. Nextcloud Storage Design as E-Learning Data Storage Media in SMA Negeri 2 Manokwari. JISTECH J. Inf. Sci. Technol. 2023, 12 (1), 52–58.
- Palos-Sanchez, P.; Reyes-Menendez, A.; Saura, J. R. Modelos de Adopción de Tecnologías de La Información y Cloud Computing En Las Organizaciones. Inf. tecnológica 2019, 30 (3), 3–12. [CrossRef]
- Robles-Gomez, A.; Tobarra, L.; Pastor-Vargas, R.; Hernandez, R.; Haut, J. M. Analyzing the Users’ Acceptance of an IoT Cloud Platform Using the UTAUT/TAM Model. IEEE Access 2021, 9, 150004–150020. [CrossRef]
- Sánchez, R. A.; Hueros, A. D. Motivational Factors That Influence the Acceptance of Moodle Using TAM. Comput. Human Behav. 2010, 26 (6), 1632–1640. [CrossRef]
- Almaiah, M. A.; Alamri, M. M.; Al-Rahmi, W. Applying the UTAUT Model to Explain the Students’ Acceptance of Mobile Learning System in Higher Education. IEEE Access 2019, 7, 174673–174686. [CrossRef]
- Al-Mamary, Y. H.; Al-nashmi, M.; Hassan, Y. A. G.; Shamsuddin, A. A Critical Review of Models and Theories in Field of Individual Acceptance of Technology. Int. J. Hybrid Inf. Technol. 2016, 9 (6), 143–158. [CrossRef]
- Walldén, S.; Mäkinen, E.; Raisamo, R. A Review on Objective Measurement of Usage in Technology Acceptance Studies. Univers. Access Inf. Soc. 2016, 15 (4), 713–726. [CrossRef]
- Santiesteban Naranjo, E. Metodología de La Investigación Para Las Ciencias Contables; 2018.
- Maricruz Lazarte, I.; Doria, M. V.; Flores, C. V.; Haustein, M. C.; Córdoba, E. Matomo Como Herramienta Para La Obtención de Estadísticas de Uso de Los Documentos Dispuestos En El Repositorio Institucional de Acceso Abierto de La Facultad de Tecnología y Ciencias Aplicadas, UNCA. In VII Simposio Argentino sobre Tecnología y Sociedad (STS 2020)-JAIIO 49 (Modalidad virtual); 2020; pp 10–23.
- Viswanath Venkatesh, R. H.; Morris, M. G.; Davis, G. B.; Davis, F. D. User Acceptance of Information Technology: Toward a Unified View. MIS Q. 2003, 27 (3), 425. [CrossRef]
- Garzón Goya, M.; Salavarria Melo, J.; Avilés Vera, M. P.; Choez Burgos, J. Evaluacion de Un Sistema de Almaceamiento En La Nube Utilizando El Modelo TAM En La UAE. RITI J. 2018, 6 (12), 2–7.
- Jing, L.; Bo, Z.; Tian, Q.; Xu, W.; Shi, J. Network Education Platform in Flipped Classroom Based on Improved Cloud Computing and Support Vector Machine. J. Intell. Fuzzy Syst. 2020, 39 (2), 1793–1803. [CrossRef]
- Manuel Gallego Pérez, Ó. M.; Cabero Almenara, J.; Sampedro Sampedro, B. Valoraciones de La “Aceptación de La Tecnología de Formación Virtual” Por Profesores Universitarios Asistentes a Un Curso de Formación Virtual. Edutec. Rev. Electrónica Tecnol. Educ. 2016, No. 56, a335. [CrossRef]
- Abarca Amador, Y. El Uso de Las TIC En La Educación Universitaria: Motivación Que Incide En Su Uso y Frecuencia. Rev. Lenguas Mod. 2015, No. 22. [CrossRef]
- Kim, J.; Lee, K. S.-S. Conceptual Model to Predict Filipino Teachers’ Adoption of ICT-Based Instruction in Class: Using the UTAUT Model. Asia Pacific J. Educ. 2020, 42 (4), 699–713. [CrossRef]
- Kim, B.; Park, M. J. Effect of Personal Factors to Use ICTs on E-Learning Adoption: Comparison between Learner and Instructor in Developing Countries. Inf. Technol. Dev. 2018, 24 (4), 706–732. [CrossRef]
- Chandra, Y. U.; Hartono, S. Analysis Factors of Technology Acceptance of Cloud Storage: A Case of Higher Education Students Use Google Drive. In 2018 International Conference on Information Technology Systems and Innovation (ICITSI); IEEE, 2018; pp 188–192. [CrossRef]
- Al-Shehri, M. The Effectiveness of D2L System: An Evaluation of Teaching-Learning Process in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Int. J. Adv. Comput. Sci. Appl. 2017, 8 (1). [CrossRef]
- Amador Ortiz, C. M.; Velarde Peña, L. Competencias Para El Uso de Las TIC En Estudiantes de Educación Superior: Un Estudio de Caso. RIDE Rev. Iberoam. para la Investig. y el Desarro. Educ. 2019, 10 (19), 14. [CrossRef]
- Jaradat, M.-I. R.; Banikhaled, M. Undergraduate Students’ Adoption of Website-Service Quality by Applying the Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) in Jordan. Int. J. Interact. Mob. Technol. 2013, 7 (3), 22–29. [CrossRef]
|
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2023 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).