Preprint
Article

This version is not peer-reviewed.

A Bioenergetic Assessment of Agricultural Landscape Productivity Based on Harrington’s Generalised Desirability Function

Submitted:

19 October 2026

Posted:

20 October 2026

You are already at the latest version

Abstract
Assessing the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes is essential for their sustainable management and for identifying spatial variation. This study aims to develop a methodological approach to evaluating the biological, ecological, and bioclimatic productivity of the soil and vegetation cover in the Karaganda Region. Using long-term climatic data for 1981-2023 provided by the Republican State Enterprise Kazhydromet, the study applies systems analysis, comparative analysis, expert assessment, and mathematical modelling. Harrington’s generalised desirability function is used as an integrated indicator to convert measured values of individual variables with different physical properties and units into a common dimensionless desirability scale. The mathematical modelling of climatic, biological, and soil processes offers several advantages over previous approaches. First, the principal climatic and environmental factors governing the productivity of the soil and vegetation cover were identified. Second, mathematical model was developed to assess each of the main environmental indicators. Third, the environmental functions of the study area were expressed through indices of soil and vegetation productivity.
Keywords: 
;  ;  ;  ;  

1. Introduction

The combination of climate-determining factors that create the conditions for the productivity of agricultural landscapes determines the agroclimatic resources of the area. The most important factor in ensuring the productivity of the soil and vegetation cover of agricultural landscapes is bioclimatic potential, which fulfils vital environment-shaping and ecological functions.
Climate-determining factors and emerging climate- and environment-determining indicators are a function of the biological, ecological and bioclimatic productivity of the soil and vegetation cover of agricultural landscapes. This necessitates an assessment of current bioclimatic resources and the productivity of agricultural land from a spatio-temporal perspective.
The rational use of natural resources to increase the productivity of agricultural landscapes has consistently been a key focus of applied science. The present study aims to refine scientific concepts regarding the ecological mechanisms governing the spatial organisation of agricultural production.
Consequently, the accurate assessment of the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes—based on biological, ecological and bioclimatic indicators of soil and vegetation cover — is becoming particularly relevant in the context of a changing climate and increasing anthropogenic pressure. Addressing these issues is of great practical importance and is a key prerequisite for enhancing the ecological resilience of landscapes to abiotic and biotic factors.
A wide range of studies has been devoted to assessing the bioclimatic potential of agricultural land. In particular, the relationship between the productivity of zonal agrocenoses and climatic factors on the plains of Romania and in the steppe zone of Russia is examined in the works of I. Ontel, A. Vladut (2015) and Yu. A. Gulyanov (2019).
The relationship between climatic conditions and the requirements of cereal crops (wheat, rice, maize and soya) in China, as well as the impact of moisture availability on biodiversity in California (USA), have been analysed by Ch. Zhao et al. (2017) and S. Harrison et al. (2020).
Furthermore, the need for the effective use of bioclimatic resources in agricultural technologies on the Kulunda Plain, in the European part of the Russian Federation, in South Asia, in Switzerland and in the steppe regions of Russia is substantiated in the works of V. I. Belyaev et al. (2017), V. Pavlova et al. (2019), P. Sangines de Carcer et al. (2019), Yu. A. Gulyanov and A. A. Chibilev (2019), Yu. A. Gulyanov et al. (2019), and H. Singh et al. (2020).
One of the fundamental approaches to assessing the productivity of agricultural landscapes is the forecasting of crop yields on agricultural land worldwide (Izrael and Sirotenko, 2003; Sirotenko et al., 2013; Lemeshko et al., 2021; Baier, 2022; Li et al., 2022). As part of this approach, specialised agroclimatic models are developed, such as ‘Climate–Soil–Yield’ for Russia and AgriClim for Central Europe. Furthermore, when appropriately calibrated, global climate change models (in particular, the CMIP6 ensemble) can reproduce the spatial characteristics of agroclimatic features with reasonable reliability.
Of primary interest is the assessment of the bioclimatic potential (BCP) of agricultural landscapes. This topic has been extensively covered in the works of P.I. Koloskov (1963), S.A. Sapozhnikova (1976), F.Z. Battalov (1980), D.I. Shashko (1985), E.K. Zoidze and L.I. Ovcharenko (2000), V.V. Kolyada (2013), A.A. Bocharova and O.V. Krymskaya (2013), V.F. Loginova and M.A. Khitrikova (2017), N.V. Dudiak et al. (2019), V. Pichura et al. (2022), Z. Mustafayev et al. (2024), and A. Omarov et al. (2026).
These studies propose a wide range of concepts and interpretations, such as: ‘bioclimatic potential’, ‘agricultural climate quality’, ‘agricultural climate productivity’, ‘agricultural resource potential’ and ‘natural resource potential’. Furthermore, the aforementioned works set out various methodological approaches to their quantitative determination.
Building on a deeper understanding of the known properties of natural systems – their functioning and biomass production – Zh.S. Mustafayev and G.A. Adilbektegi (2002) developed a new approach to assessing the biological, ecological and bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes. This approach, based on the productivity of soil and vegetation cover, is reflected in the works of G.A. Adilbektegi and Zh.S. Mustafayev (2016), Zh.S. Mustafayev and G.A. Adilbektegi (2004), Zh.S. Mustafayev et al. (2018), G.A. Adilbektegi et al. (2019, 2019a).
A systematic analysis of existing methodological approaches and the results of assessments of agricultural landscape productivity, based on climate-forming and climate-environment-shaping indicators of the natural system, has shown that, despite the considerable volume of research, the methodology for the practical application of the bioclimatic approach requires continuous improvement through the use of digital technology.
The aim of the study is to develop and verify in practice an integrated mathematical model of the biological and ecological productivity of landscape systems in Central Kazakhstan (using the Karaganda Region as a case study). The model is based on a combined analysis of V.R. Volobuev’s bioenergetic parameters of soil formation and D.I. Shashko’s bioclimatic indicators of vegetation cover, taking into account the region’s latitudinal and altitudinal zonation, as well as applying E. Harrington’s generalised desirability function.

2. Materials and Methods

The biological productivity of agricultural landscapes is defined as the rate of organic matter formation based on the integrated concept of heat and moisture availability for the vegetation and soil cover.
The empirical basis for the study consists of long-term series of meteorological observations (1981–2023) from 15 representative meteorological stations in the Karaganda Region, provided by the State Enterprise ‘Kazhydromet’.
The following basic meteorological parameters were used to quantify the formation of the production process: the long-term average annual sum of biologically active air temperatures above + 10 ∘ C ( ∑ A T i > 10 ∘ C ), the sum of the deficit of atmospheric humidity ( ∑ D A H i , mb), annual precipitation ( A P i , mm), the mean relative annual humidity ( R A H i , %), the annual radiation balance of the active surface ( R B i , kJ/cm2) and evaporation from the water surface ( E F W S i , mm).
The mathematical framework of the study comprises three key components of integral modelling.

2.1. Modelling the Biological Productivity of Landscape Systems

The heat availability of phytocenoses is assessed using the heat supply coefficient of the vegetation cover ( H S C V C i ), defined as the ratio of the actual sum of biologically active air temperatures ( ∑ S B A T i ) to the regional maximum ( ∑ S B A T m a x i = 4500 ∘ C ):
∑ S A T i = A T i · n ;
∑ S B A T i = ∑ i = 1 n ∑ S A T i ;
H S C V C i = ∑ S B A T i / ∑ S B A T m a x i ,
where ATi is the mean monthly air temperature, °C; n is the number of months in which the mean monthly air temperature exceeds 10 °C; ΣSATi is the monthly sum of active air temperatures, °C. Summation is carried out over all months with a mean monthly air temperature above 10 °C.
The regional maximum sum of biologically active air temperatures was defined as the long-term mean value of 4,500 °C (Mustafayev and Ryabtsev, 2012).
The extent to which a landscape’s temperature regime is favourable for plant growth is expressed by the indicator of expected heat productivity ( I E H P i ), which characterises the productivity of the vegetation cover ( P L V i ):
\ P L V i = I E H P i = H S C V C i = ∑ S B A T i / ∑ S B A T m a x i .
The moisture supply of the landscape’s soil cover is assessed using the natural moisture coefficient ( N M C i ) N.N. Ivanov (1954):
N M C i = A P i / ∑ i = 1 n E F W S i ,
In this context, the monthly evaporation from the water surface ( E F W S i , mm) is calculated using the classical formula by N.N. Ivanov (1954) based on the monthly average values of air temperature ( A T i ) and relative air humidity ( R A H i ):
E F W S i = 0.0018 ⋅ 25 + A T i 2 ⋅ 100 − R A H i
The sum of evaporation from the water surface ( S E F W S i ) during the period with air temperatures above 10 ∘ C , calculated as the sum of monthly evaporation from the water surface ( E F W S i , mm):
S E F W S i = ∑ i = 1 n E F W S i ,
where n is the number of months during which the average monthly air temperature is above 10 ∘ C .
The natural moisture coefficient (NMCi) physically characterises the biological productivity of the soil cover of the landscape.
The integrated indicator of landscape bioclimatic productivity ( I I B P L i ) is calculated as a multiplicative function of the thermal and water factors, expressed as the geometric mean of the two indicators:
I I B P L i = I E H P I · N M C I   = I E H P I · B P S C I

2.2. Modelling the Ecological Productivity of Landscape Systems

The ecological productivity of agricultural land (landscapes) is defined as the rate of organic matter formation through the accumulation and transformation of matter, including water, and energy within the soil and vegetation cover.
Therefore, the ecological productivity of the soil and vegetation cover of landscapes can be characterised by two indicators: the energy costs for soil formation ( E C S F i ) and the natural moisture coefficient ( N M C i ).
The energy costs for soil formation under natural conditions ( E C S F i , kJ/cm2), is determined using V.R. Volobuev’s (1974) bioenergetic equation:
E C S F i = R B i ⋅ exp − α o ⋅ R D I i
where α_o is the coefficient of complete utilisation of radiant energy in soil-forming processes, numerically equal to 0.47; R D I i is Budyko’s radiation dryness index, which is determined by the formula: R D I i = R B i / ( S H V i · A P i ), where S H V i is the specific heat of vapourisation, assumed to be constant and equal to 2.5 kJ/cm2 per 1 cm of precipitation; in this formula APi is expressed in cm.
Bearing in mind that, under climatically balanced conditions, the radiation dryness index is taken as equal to 1.0 (the critical threshold of pedogenesis efficiency), the potentially available soil formation energy ( P E S F i , kJ/cm2) is modelled as:
P E S F i = R B i ⋅ exp − α o
The productivity of landscape soil cover ( P L S C i ) is calculated using the following formula
P L S C i = E C S F i / P E S F i .
The productivity of the vegetation cover of the landscape is a function of the natural moisture coefficient; under the conditions adopted here a direct proportionality is assumed, so that this component is represented directly by NMCi.
Based on the methodological approach presented, the ecological productivity of the landscape ( E P L i ) can be defined as a function of the productivity of the landscape’s soil cover P L S C i and the natural moisture coefficient ( N M C i ):
E P L i = P L S C i · N M C i .

2.3. Assessment of Landscape Productivity Based on the Bioclimatic Potential of D.I. Shashko

The bioclimatic productivity of agricultural land (landscapes) is determined by a combination of climatic and soil factors that define its potential biological productivity as a function of bioclimatic and soil potential.
Bioclimatic potential ( B C P i ), which takes into account the influence of heat and moisture on the productivity of agricultural landscapes, can be used to assess the biological productivity of a landscape’s soil and vegetation cover.
The sum of biologically active air temperatures above +10 °C ( ∑ A T i > 10 ∘ C ) accelerates not only bioclimatic but also biophysical processes that influence the productivity of the landscape’s vegetation cover, bringing them up to optimal levels. Under certain conditions, the productivity of the landscape’s vegetation cover is directly proportional to the temperature factor, expressed as the sum of average daily temperatures above 10 °C during the growing season. This relationship is expressed by the formula for relative values of bioclimatic potential (D.I. Shashko, 1985):
B C P i = Y G R   ( C I A H i ) i · [ 100 · ∑ S B A T i / ∑ B S A D T i ] ,
where B C P i   is the relative value of the bioclimatic potential; Y G R   ( C I A H i ) i is the yield growth ratio as a function of the complex index of atmospheric humidification; ∑ S B A T i – the sum of biologically active temperatures recorded during the active growing season at a given location, °C; ∑ B S A D T i – the baseline sum of active daily temperatures, which serves as a benchmark for comparative evaluation, is set to 1000 °C; Y G R   ( A Y I i ) i – the yield growth ratio as a function of the complex index of atmospheric humidification is determined using the following formula:
Y G R   ( C I A H i ) i = 1.15 ⋅ ln 20 ⋅ C I A H i − 0.21 + 0.63 ⋅ C I A H i − C I A H i 2 ,
where C I A H i = A P i / ∑ A D A H i   is a comprehensive indicator of atmospheric humidity; ∑ A D A H i = ∑ i = 1 n ∑ D A H i – the Accumulated deficit of atmospheric humidity for the period with mean monthly air temperatures above 10 ∘ C ; ∑ D A H , where n is the number of days in the corresponding month.
The potential value of the bioclimatic index ( P V B I i ) under hypothetically optimal moisture conditions ( Y G R   ( C I A H i ) i = 1.0 ) is:
P V B I i = 100 · ( ∑ S B A T i / ∑ B S A D T i ) .
The ratio of the actual bioclimatic potential to its potential value determines the relative value of the climatic index of plant productivity ( C I P P i ):
C I P P i = B C P i / P V B I i .
For the quantitative assessment of soil fertility, we recommend an integrated soil fertility indicator based on a modified version of the “soil index” proposed by S. A. Pegov and P. M. Khomyakov (1991) [29]. The indicator incorporates humus stocks ( H i ), mineral nutrient stocks ( N P K i ), hydrolytic acidity ( H A ) and the degree of soil salinity ( S S I i ), and is expressed by Equation (17):
S F I i = H I i + M N I i + S A I i + S S I i = W F h l · f H I i + W F m n i · f M N I i + W F s a i · f S A I i + W F s s i · f S S I i ,
where ( W F i ) are the weighting coefficients for steppe vegetation productivity; ( H I ) represents the influence of humus on the composite soil index; ( M N I i ) represents the influence of mineral nutrients on the composite soil index; ( S A I i ) represents the influence of acidity on the composite soil index; and ( S S I i ) represents the influence of the degree of soil salinity on the composite soil index.
A comparative analysis of the soil indices at ( f H I i , M N I i , S A I i , S S I i   = 1 ) and ( f H I i , M N I i , S A I i , S S I i   = 0 ) yields the weighting coefficients corresponding to maximum vegetation productivity: ( W F h l ) = 6.40; ( W F m n i ) = 8.50; ( W F s a i ) = 5.10; and ( W F s s i ) = 20.0.
The modified integrated soil fertility indicator, based on the “soil index” proposed by S. A. Pegov and P. M. Khomyakov (1991) [29], comprises four components and is calculated using Equation (18):
H I i = 6.4 · ( H H i + 0.2 · F H i ) / 600 ;
M N I i = 8.5 · N P K i · δ 3 ;
S A I i = 5.1 · e x p − H A i − 1 / 4 ;
S S I i = 20.0 · exp − 0.76 · D S S i / 0,30 = 20.0 · e x p [ − α i · ( D S S i / 0,30 ) ] ,
where H H i – humic humus content, t/ha or g/cm3; F H i – fulvic humus content, t/ha or g/cm3; N i = N C i / N C m a x i ; P i = P C i / P C m a x i ; K i = K C i / K C m a x i – relative content of nitrogen ( N i ), phosphorus ( P 2 O 5 i ), potassium ( K 2 O i ) in soils; N C m a x i , P C m a x i and K C m a x i – maximum soil content of plant-available forms of mineral nutrients (t/ha); N C i , P C i , K C i – actual soil content of plant-available forms of mineral nutrients (t/ha); δ – plant fertilizer uptake efficiency factor; H A i – hydrolytic acidity, meq/100 g of soil; D S S i – degree of soil salinity, % of dry residue; α i   – coefficient accounting for the salinity type.
Under maximum humus stocks ( H H i + 0.2 · F H i = 600   т / г а ) and in the absence of a deficiency in essential mineral nutrients ( N = 1 ,   P = 1 ,   K =1), with a hydrolytic acidity ( H г ) equal to 1 and a soil salinity ( D S S i ) equal to 0.30% of dry residue, the maximum value of the “soil index” will be: = 6.4 units; M N I i = 8.5 units; S A I i =5.1 units and S S I i = 20.0 units, while the composite soil index S F I i = 40.0 units; that is, the numerical values of the “soil index” characterizing soil fertility under natural conditions range from 0 to 40.
The relative productivity index of the landscape soil cover ( P S F I i ), based on the integrated soil fertility index ( S F I i ) is calculated using the formula:
P S F I i = S F I i / 40
The resulting bioclimatic productivity of landscapes (landscape-bioclimatic index) ( B C P I l ) calculated as the geometric mean reflecting the combined potential of soil ( P S F I i ) and vegetation ( C I P P i ), is given by:
B C P I l = P S F C I · C I P P I
Thus, the bioenergetic assessment of the productivity of agricultural landscapes, based on the integral indicator of biological productivity of the landscape ( I I B P L i ), the ecological productivity of the landscape ( E P L i ) and the bioclimatic productivity of the landscape ( B C P I i ), is a multi-criteria problem for which methods for constructing a generalised index can be used; in this context, Harrington’s generalised desirability function provides a convenient means of calculating such an index (Harrington, 1965). The construction of this function is based on the transformation of the natural values of individual indicators of varying physical nature and dimensions into a single dimensionless desirability (preference) scale.
In the case of a one-sided constraint involving ‘positive’ indicators, characterised by a monotonically increasing relationship between desirability and their numerical values, the Harrington function for specific integral landscape productivity indicators takes the following sigmoidal form (Harrington, 1965):
D F P I l = e x p [ − exp − C V P I ] ,
where C V P L i – coded values of partial landscape productivity indices, namely, C V B P L i - coded value of biological landscape productivity, equal to I I B P L i ; C V E P L i - coded value of ecological landscape productivity, equal to E P L i ; C V B C P L i - coded value of bioclimatic landscape productivity, equal to B C P I l .
Based on the coded values of partial landscape productivity indices ( C V P L i ), their convolution is determined to yield the generalised landscape productivity criterion ( D F P L i ) – a Desirability Function of Landscape Productivity:
D F P L i = C V B P L i · C V E P L i · C V B C P L i n ,
where n is the number of partial evaluation indicators.
The desirability scale across the range from 0 to 1 is divided into seven sub-intervals (Aidos Omarov, Zhumakhan Mustafayev, Irina Skorintseva, Gulnar Aldazhanova, Amanzhol Kuderin, Askhat Toletayev, 2026): – the scale range of 0.00–0.20 is designated as “very low”; – the scale range of 0.20–0.37 (“poor”) is divided into three equal sub-intervals: 0.20–0.26 (“low”), 0.26–0.31 (“moderately low”), and 0.31–0.37 (“moderate”); – the scale range of 0.37–0.63 (“satisfactory”) is designated as “moderately high”; – the scale range of 0.63–0.80 (“good”) is designated as “high”; – the scale range of 0.80–1.00 (“very good”) is designated as “very high”.
The proposed mathematical model of landscape productivity uses the generalised Harrington desirability function as an integrated composite indicator. This approach makes it possible to: firstly, to move away from the use of a traditional additive composite indicator; secondly, to convert the natural values of individual indicators of varying physical nature and dimensions into a single dimensionless desirability scale (landscape productivity); thirdly, to interpret the generalised indicator of landscape productivity using the qualitative modal categories of the term ‘desirability’.
To assess the degree of dependence between the integrated index of biological, ecological, bioclimatic, and bioenergetic landscape productivity and agricultural land productivity, data were used from the statistical compendium Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries of Karaganda Region published by the Department of the Bureau of National Statistics of theAgency for Strategic Planning and Reforms of the Republic of Kazakhstan for the Karaganda Region for the period 2000-2024 (Table 1).
The potential productivity of agricultural land ( P Y , c/ha) is determined by the input of photosynthetically active radiation energy ( P A R , kJ/cm2) under optimal climatic conditions during the growing season, according to the formula of A.D. Nichiporovich (1984):
P Y i = F E U C i · P A R i · 10 6 / 4,19 · С V O M Y i · 100 ,
where P A R i - radiation balance of agricultural soil and vegetation landscapes, kJ/cm2; F E U C i - free energy utilization efficiency factor: F E U C i = P A R U C i / 100 ; P A R U C i - photosynthetically active radiation ( P A R ) utilization efficiency by agricultural crops, equal to 1.0%; 100 - factor accounting for the percentage of assimilation P A R ; С V O M Y i - caloric value per unit yield of organic matter in landscapes, equal to 4,200 kcal/kg; 4,19 - conversion factor from kcal/kg to kJ/kg; 100 - conversion factor to c/ha.
Для интегральнoгo пoказателя прoдуктивнoсти сельскoхoзяйственнoй угoдий ландшафтoв ( I P A L i ) мoжнo испoльзoвать oтнoшение хoзяйственная урoжайнoсти бoгарнoгo ячменя ( A Y D L B i ) к пoтенциальный прoдуктивнoсти сельскoхoзяйственнoй угoдий ( P Y i ):
I P A L i = A Y D L B i / P Y i .
This ratio serves as a quantitative measure of the extent to which the potential productivity of agricultural land is realized under actual cultivation conditions.

3. Results

3.1. Assessment of the Biological Productivity of Landscapes in the Karaganda Region

To assess the biological productivity of the soil and vegetation cover of landscapes in the Karaganda Region from a spatial perspective, climate-defining indicators such as average monthly air temperature, relative humidity and annual precipitation for the period 1981–2023, as recorded at 15 meteorological stations, were utilised. Based on these, climate- and environment-forming indicators were calculated, namely the sum of biologically active air temperatures above +10^∘C and the sum of monthly evaporation at +10^∘C, which are functions of the average monthly temperatures and relative humidity (Table 2).
To assess the impact of the altitude at which meteorological stations are located on climate and environmental indicators and the biological productivity of agricultural landscapes, graphical relationships were plotted in Microsoft Excel. This enabled the development of linear correlation models with high coefficients of determination (R2), in the form:
- dependence of the sum of biologically active air temperatures ( ∑ S B A T i ,  oС) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
∑ S B A T i = − 1.5302 · H i + 3537.3 ,   R 2 = 0.4720 ;
- dependence of the annual precipitation total ( A P i , mm) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m)
A P i = 0.5621 · H i − 27.5790 ,   R 2 = 0.5575 ;
- dependence of the total evaporability from a water surface ( S E F W S i , mm) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
S E F W S i = − 0.5177 · H i + 1016.5 ,   R 2 = 0.3897 ;
- dependence of the biological productivity index of landscape vegetation cover ( P L V i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m)
P L V i = − 0.0003401 · H i + 0.7859 , = 0.4723 ;
- dependence of the biological productivity index of the landscape soil cover ( P I S C i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , м):
B P S C i = 0.0009 · H i − 0.1024 ,   R 2 = 0.4627 ;
- dependence of the biological productivity index of agricultural landscapes ( I I B P L i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , м):
I I B P L i = 0.0007 · H i + 0.0931 ,   R 2 = 0.6313 ;
- dependence of the integrated biological productivity index of agricultural lands ( I I B P A i ) on the biological productivity of agricultural landscapes ( I I B P L i ):
I I B P A i = 0.1162 · I I B P L i + 0.0518 ,   R 2 = 0.7111 .
Thus, the mathematical model of the integrated productivity index of agricultural lands ( I I B P A i ), as a function of the biological productivity of agricultural landscapes ( I I B P L i ), with a high coefficient of determination (0.7111), can serve as a highly effective tool for predicting the biological productivity of landscapes that reflect the relationships between their structural and dynamic variables.
At the same time, climatic and environment-forming indicators increase with decreasing elevation of meteorological stations, as does the biological productivity of the vegetation and soil cover in agricultural landscapes, demonstrating that they conform to the law of geographical zonality and altitudinal zonation. Through its application under the conditions of the Karaganda region, the altitudinal gradients per 100 m were established as follows: thermal deficit, –175.7 °C; atmospheric precipitation, 57.5 mm; evaporability from a water surface, 83.7 mm; vegetation cover biological productivity, 0.0386; soil cover biological productivity, 0.138; and agricultural landscape biological productivity, 0.117.

3.2. Assessment of the Ecological Productivity of Landscapes in the Karaganda Region

An assessment of the ecological productivity of landscapes, based on the bioenergetic approach, must include individual assessments of the productivity of its constituent elements. These provide a comprehensive characterisation of climatic, soil and biological factors, which makes it possible to: firstly, assign quantitative values to qualitative changes in habitats; secondly, model the transformation of natural systems in response to climate change; thirdly, differentiate agricultural landscapes according to their ecological productivity.
An environmental assessment is a multi-stage process of analysing the natural factors that influence the productivity of vegetation and soil cover in agricultural landscapes, based on the annual radiation balance of the active surface ( R B i ), the ‘radiation dryness index ( R D I i ), and the energy costs for soil formation ( E C S F i ).
To identify the specific characteristics of the spatial distribution of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region, assessments of the ecological productivity of soil and vegetation cover were carried out based on data on heat and moisture conditions from meteorological stations, using energy costs for soil formation ( E C S F i ) and the natural moisture coefficient ( N M C i ), using statistical methods in Microsoft Excel to assess the ecological productivity of landscapes (Table 3).
The study examined the spatial distribution of key indicators across the Karaganda Region: values of the annual radiation balance of the active surface ( R B i ), the ‘radiation dryness index’ ( R D I i ), energy costs for soil formation ( E C S F i ), the ecological productivity of the landscape’s soil cover ( P L S C i ) and the ecological productivity of agricultural landscapes ( E P L i ). This made it possible to establish the dependence of soil-geographical patterns on the altitude of the meteorological stations and the climatic conditions during the period of instrumental observations. The relationships obtained are presented in the form of linear correlation models:
-
dependence of the land surface radiation balance ( R B i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
R B i = − 0.05066 · H i + 173.2 ,   R 2 = 0.4720 ;
-
dependence of the “radiation dryness index” ( R D I i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
R D I i = − 0.0062 · H i + 5.9368 , R 2 = 0.4393 ;
-
dependence of energy expenditures for soil formation ( E C S F i ) dependence of energy expenditures for soil formation ( H i , m):
E C S F i = 0.0954 · H i − 5.9287 ,   R 2 = 0.4088 ;
-
dependence of the ecological productivity of the landscape soil cover ( P L S C i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
P L S C i = 0.0012 · H i + 0.1279 ,   R 2 = 0.4208 ;
-
dependence of the ecological productivity of agricultural landscapes ( E P L i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
P I S C i = 0.0014 · H i − 0.2692 ,   R 2 = 0.6114 .
-
dependence of the integrated biological productivity index of agricultural lands ( I I B P A i ) on the ecological productivity of agricultural landscapes ( E P L i )
I I E P A i = 0.0523 · E P L i + 0.0815 ,   R 2 = 0.7105
The resulting mathematical model of the integrated biological productivity index of agricultural lands ( I I B P A i ) as a function of the ecological productivity of agricultural landscapes ( E P L i ), characterized by a high coefficient of determination (0.7105), enables the quantitative assessment of the ecological process under study and provides valuable insights for the spatial organization of agricultural production.
Thus, climatic and environment-forming indicators decrease with increasing elevation of meteorological stations, as do the indicators of landscape ecological productivity, demonstrating that their differentiation is governed by the laws of geographical zonality and altitudinal zonation. Under the conditions of the Karaganda region, the altitudinal gradients per 100 m were established as follows: land surface radiation balance ( R B i ) сoставляет 6.47 kJ/cm2; “radiation dryness index” ( R D I i ) – 0.75; energy expenditure for soil formation ( E C S F i ) -12.03 kJ/cm2; landscape soil cover ecological productivity ( I S P I i ) – 0.137; and agricultural landscape ecological productivity ( E P L i ) – 0,190.

3.3. Assessment of the Bioclimatic Productivity of Landscapes in the Karaganda Region

The assessment of the bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes forms the basis of the methodological approach to analysing the resource potential of agricultural land in the Karaganda Region. This is aimed at ensuring the most comprehensive and rational use of natural resources in the spatial organisation of natural resource management.
To assess the integrated soil fertility index of the Karaganda region across administrative districts, Table 4 presents the key agrochemical parameters of agricultural lands.
Based on the processing of data on the agrochemical parameters of agricultural lands in the Karaganda region across administrative districts using Microsoft Excel, initial integrated indices H I i , M N I i and S A I i , were calculated, yielding a generalised integrated soil fertility index for agricultural lands (Table 5).
To assess the bioclimatic potential of the landscape, statistical methods – correlation and regression analysis – were applied to the databases created (climatic, biological and soil) for the period 1981–2023, with the aim of identifying the most significant indicators determining resource potential, such as the Accumulated Deficit of Air Humidity during the period with mean monthly air temperatures above 10 °C ( ∑ A D A H i ), the Complex Index of Atmospheric Humidification ( C I A H i ), the growth coefficient according to the annual indicator of atmospheric humidification ( Y G R   ( A Y I i ) i ), bioclimatic potential of landscapes ( B C P i ), bioclimatic productivity of landscape vegetation cover ( C I P P i ) and bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes ( B C P I l ) (Table 6).
An analysis of the calculated bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region, based on the physical-statistical model of bioclimatic potential (BCPi) of D.I. Shashko (1985), shows that the highest values are confined to the central, better-moistened part of the region (Korneevka, Karaganda, Zharyk, Karagandinskaya), whereas the lowest values occur in the arid south-east (Sayak, Saryshagan, Balkhash) and at the driest high station (Aktogay). Bioclimatic productivity therefore follows the moisture gradient rather than altitude as such.
Using methods of mathematical statistics and regression analysis, the most significant relationships between climate-environment-forming indicators and the bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region, as a function of the altitude of meteorological stations, have been established in the form of the function C E F I i = α · H i + b (where C E F I i is a climate-environment-forming indicator; H i is the altitude of the meteorological stations; α is the regression coefficient; b is the constant term), which better characterises their climate-dependence:
-
dependence of the sum of air humidity deficits during the period with mean monthly air temperature above 10 °C ( ∑ A D A H i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
∑ A D A H i = − 0.4318 · H i + 1873.5 , R 2 = 0.4044 ;
-
dependence of the composite atmospheric moisture index ( C I A H i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
C I A H i = 0.0003 · H i + 0.0,081 ,   R 2 = 0.4232 ;
-
dependence of the growth coefficient based on the annual atmospheric moisture index ( Y G R   ( A Y I i ) i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
Y G R   ( A Y I i ) i = 0.0026 · H i − 0.2732 ,   R 2 = 0.4829 ;
-
dependence of the bioclimatic potential of landscapes ( B C P i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
P L S C i = 0.5825 · H i − 17.7790 ,   R 2 = 0.4710 ;
-
dependence of the bioclimatic productivity of landscape vegetation cover ( C I P P i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , m):
C I P P i = 0.0026 · H i − 0.2732 ,   R 2 = 0.4829
-
dependence of the bioclimatic productivity of landscape soil cover ( I S P L i ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , м):
I S P L i = 0.0005 · H i − 0.0484 ,   R 2 = 0.45126 ;
-
dependence of the bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes ( B C P L l ) on the elevation of meteorological stations ( H i , м):
I S P L i = 0.0011 · H i − 0.0824 ,   R 2 = 0.6133 ;
-
dependence of the integrated biological productivity index of agricultural lands ( I I B P A i ) on the bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes ( B C P L l ):
I I B P A i = 0,0538 · B C P L l + 0,0789 ,   R 2 = 0.6219 .
A statistically sound evaluation of the integrated biological productivity index of agricultural lands ( I I B P A i ) as a function of the bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes ( B C P L l ), with a high coefficient of determination (0.6219), and their functional equations serve as a scientific basis for the spatial organization of environmental management.
Furthermore, the integrated altitudinal gradient, which drives the spatial differentiation of key landscape bioclimatic productivity indicators, plays a paramount role in the structure of the vegetation and soil cover of the Karaganda region across different types of altitudinal zonation. Within these zones, the altitudinal gradients per 100 m were established as follows: sum of air humidity deficits during the period with mean monthly air temperature above 10 °C ( ∑ A D A H i ), 90.65 mb; composite atmospheric moisture index ( C I A H i ) – 0.038; к growth coefficient based on the annual atmospheric moisture index ( Y G R   ( A Y I i ) i - 0.272; landscape bioclimatic potential ( B C P i ) – 72.92; vegetation cover bioclimatic productivity ( C I P P i )- 0,467; soil cover bioclimatic productivity ( I S P L i ) -0,019; and agricultural landscape bioclimatic productivity ( B C P I l ) – 0,160.
The bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes, based on the bioclimatic potential of the territory, represents a comparative assessment of agroclimatic resources. This assessment is carried out relative to the northern boundary of extensive arable farming, where the base sum of average daily air temperatures during the active growing season is taken as 1000 °C ( ∑ B S A D T i =1000oС). This approach is geared towards creating sustainable and productive agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region.

3.4. Bioenergetic Assessment of Agricultural Landscape Productivity Based on the Harrington Desirability Function

The task of determining a bioenergetic assessment of the productivity of agricultural landscapes, encompassing the biological, ecological and bioclimatic productivity of soil and vegetation cover, is a complex multi-criteria problem to be solved in the face of incomplete or uncertain initial information characterizing their state in spatial and temporal terms.
Various methods for constructing a generalised index based on linear and non-linear objective functions are widely used to solve multi-criteria problems. In this context, Harrington’s generalised utility function is a useful mathematical tool that accounts for the non-linearity of natural processes and defines the key principles of the bioenergetic assessment of agricultural landscape productivity (Table 7).
The proposed methodology for the bioenergetic assessment of agricultural landscape productivity is based on the generalised Harrington desirability function, which combines specific indicators of the biological, ecological and bioclimatic productivity of vegetation and soil cover. This approach makes it possible to identify patterns in their formation and functioning depending on latitudinal zonation and altitudinal zonation. This is confirmed by the linear equations obtained, which characterize the dependence of these indicators on the altitude of the meteorological stations, and which take the following form:
D F P L i = 0.0011 · H i − 0.1308 ,   R 2 = 0.7211
To evaluate the reliability of the methodological approach, based on natural laws and environmental management principles, functional equations were derived characterizing the dependence of the integrated biological productivity index of agricultural lands ( I I B P A i ) on the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes ( D F P L i ), having the following form:
I I B P A i = 0.0646 · D F P L i + 0.0745 ,   R 2 = 0.6379
The mathematical model in the form of a linear equation, reflecting the dependence of the integrated biological productivity index of agricultural lands ( I I B P A i ) on the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes ( D F P L i ), with a sufficiently high coefficient of determination (0.6379), can serve as the most reliable basis for substantiating the spatial organization of agricultural production.
As is well known, one of the key factors characterizing changes in the productivity of agricultural landscapes under the conditions of the Karaganda region is the vertical gradient of the bioenergetic productivity of landscape soil and vegetation cover, which amounts to 0.048 per 100 m, reflecting their regional differences while accounting for the absolute elevations of meteorological stations.
The bioenergetic assessment of agricultural landscape productivity in the Karaganda Region, averaged over the period 1981–2023, varies spatially from 0.392 to 0.579, which, according to Harrington’s verbal-numerical desirability scale, corresponds to the ‘satisfactory’ category.
Thus, the proposed methodology and the dynamic-statistical model for assessing the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region, using Harrington’s generalised desirability function, are theoretically sound, have been validated, and can be applied when conducting similar studies in other regions.

4. Discussion

As a result of the research carried out, a new field of scientific study has been developed – the assessment of the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes, based on the generalised Harrington desirability function, which enables the biological, ecological and bioclimatic productivity of the soil and vegetation cover of a natural landscape to be assessed from an energy perspective.
The primary method for evaluating the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes is based on the climatic-energy and climatic-environment-forming indicators of natural systems. These indicators are functions of the sum of biologically active air temperatures, annual atmospheric precipitation, evaporability from a water surface, natural moisture coefficient, land surface radiation balance, “radiation dryness index,” energy expenditures for soil formation, sum of air humidity deficits, composite atmospheric moisture index, landscape bioclimatic potential, landscape vegetation cover bioclimatic productivity, and agricultural landscape bioclimatic productivity—making this evaluation a complex, multi-criteria task.
To solve multi-criteria problems involving the assessment of the bioenergetic productivity of landscapes, based on specific productivity indicators of soil and vegetation cover in landscapes with varying physical characteristics and dimensions, the generalised Harrington desirability function was employed; the construction of this function was based on the transformation of the natural values of these indicators.
The developed mathematical model of the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes – comprising sub-models for the biological productivity of vegetation and soil cover – defines biological productivity as a function of natural energy resources and the natural moisture coefficient; ecological productivity of soil and vegetation cover as a function of energy expenditures for soil formation and the natural moisture coefficient; and bioclimatic productivity of vegetation and soil cover as a function of bioclimatic potential and energy expenditures for soil formation, all of which possess distinct physical meaning and mathematical validity.
An assessment of the biological, ecological, and bioclimatic productivity of soil and vegetation cover, as well as a bioenergetic evaluation of agricultural landscape productivity using climate-forming data from 15 meteorological stations in the Karaganda region from 1981 to 2023, demonstrated their climate dependency and spatiotemporal differentiation, strictly obeying the laws of geographical zonality and altitudinal zonation.
The conducted research on evaluating the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes aims to facilitate the rational and efficient spatial organization of agricultural production, with the derived functional equations serving as a scientific foundation for environmental management forecasting.

5. Conclusion

To evaluate the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes—encompassing the biological, ecological and bioclimatic potential of soil and vegetation cover as functions of the climate-forming and climate-environment-forming indicators of the natural system—a research database of climate indicators was compiled using long-term information and analytical data from the State Enterprise “Kazhydromet” for 1981–2023, serving as the object of study.
The application of Harrington’s generalised desirability function was analyzad as an integrated index for assessing the bioenergetic productivity of agricultural landscapes. Integrated models of the biological, ecological and bioclimatic potential of soil and vegetation cover were constructed through mathematical modelling of climatic, biological and soil processes. This approach offers key advantages over existing methods: first, it identifies the primary climate-environment-forming parameters determining soil and vegetation cover productivity; second, it develops a mathematical model capable of evaluating and fundamental environment-forming indicators; third, it expresses environment-forming parameters through productivity indices of soil and vegetation cover.
In the evaluation system for the bioenergetic potential of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda region, a comprehensive accounting of biological, ecological and bioclimatic productivity of soil and vegetation cover was implemented, offering a more complete characterization of the ecological environment.
Testing of this methodological approach under the conditions of Karaganda region demonstrated that, spatially, landscape biological productivity varies from 0.308 to 0.553, ecological productivity from 0.187 to 0.671, bioclimatic productivity from 0.119 to 0.701, and bioenergetic productivity from 0.186 to 0.641. According to Harrington’s verbal-numerical desirability scale, these ranges correspond to categories from “very low” to”high” across various types of altitudinal zonation characteristic of the natural-climatic zone of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Overall, the proposed approaches enable a realistic assessment of agricultural landscape bioenergetic productivity – both for the Karaganda region as a whole and across its distinct agro-ecological districts-facilitating rational and efficient spatial planning for agricultural production.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, G.A., Zh.M.; methodology, G.A., Zh.M.; software - G.A., A.Z.; validation, A.Z., G.C. and G.Zh.; formal analysis, G.A., L.K.; investigation, G.A., Zh.M.; resources, G.C., L.K. and G.Zh.; data curation, G.A., L.K.; writing - original draft preparation, A.Z., L.K.; writing - review and editing G.A., Zh.M. and L.K.; visualization, G.A.; supervision, Zh.M.; project administration, G.A., Zh.M.; funding acquisition, L.K. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Acknowledgments

No acknowledgments are declared.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Adilbektegi, G.A.; Mustafayev, ZhS. ‘Ecological assessment of landscape productivity in Northern Kazakhstan’ [Ekologicheskaya otsenka produktivnosti landshaftov Severnogo Kazakhstana]. Int. Res. J. [Mezhdunarodnyy nauchno-issledovatel’skiy zhurnal] 2016, no. 2 (44), pt. 2, 121–126. [Google Scholar]
  2. Adilbektegi, G.A.; Mustafayev, J.S.; Uvatayeva, T.K.; Dulatbekova, Z.N.; Mosiej, J. ‘A new approach to the evaluation of bioclimatic potential of landscapes on the example of northern Kazakhstan’. News of the National Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Series of Geology and Technical Sciences 2019, vol. 5(no. 437), 16–25. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  3. Adilbektegi, G.A.; Mustafayev, J.S.; Uvatayeva, T.K.; Dulatbekova, Z.N.; Mosiej, J. ‘Quantitative and qualitative assessment of biological and ecological potential of the landscapes of southern Kazakhstan’. News of the National Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Series of Geology and Technical Sciences 2019, vol. 6(no. 438), 96–103. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  4. Baier, W. ‘Agroclimatic modeling: An overview’. In Agroclimate Information for Development: Reviving the Green Revolution, Pt. 2, Sect. A; Cusack, D.F., Ed.; Routledge: New York, 2022; pp. 57–82. [Google Scholar]
  5. Battalov, F.Z. Agricultural Productivity of Climate for Spring Grain Crops [Sel’skokhozyaystvennaya produktivnost’ klimata dlya yarovykh zernovykh kul’tur]; Gidrometeoizdat, Leningrad, 1980. [Google Scholar]
  6. Belyaev, V.I.; Bondarovich, A.A.; Pon’kina, E.V.; Shcherbinin, V.V.; Schmidt, G.; Matsyura, A.V.; Kozhanov, N.A.; Rudev, N.V. ‘Air and soil temperature regime according to the data of the meteorological and soil-hydrological monitoring network in the Kulunda Plain during the vegetation periods 2013–2016’ [Temperaturnyy rezhim vozdukha i pochvy po dannym meteorologicheskoy i pochvenno-gidrologicheskoy monitoringovoy seti v Kulundinskoy ravnine za vegetatsionnyye periody 2013–2016 gg.]. Bull. Altai. State Agric. Univ. [Vestnik Altayskogo gosudarstvennogo agrarnogo universiteta] 2017, no. 3 (149), 30–37. [Google Scholar]
  7. Bocharova, A.A.; Krymskaya, O.V. ‘Assessment of bioclimatic potential in the west of Belgorod region’ [Otsenka bioklimaticheskogo potentsiala na zapade Belgorodskoy oblasti]. Sci. Bull. Nat. Sci. Ser. [Nauchnyye vedomosti, Seriya Yestestvennyye nauki] 2013, no. 7 (160)(issue 24), 163–167. [Google Scholar]
  8. Budyko, M.I. Heat Balance of the Earth’s Surface [Teplovoy balans zemnoy poverkhnosti]; Gidrometeoizdat, Leningrad, 1956. [Google Scholar]
  9. Dudiak, N.V.; Potravka, L.A.; Stroganov, A.A. ‘Soil and climatic bonitation of agricultural lands of the steppe zone of Ukraine’. Indian J. Ecol. 2019, vol. 46(no. 3), 534–540. [Google Scholar]
  10. Gulyanov, YuA. ‘Innovative land use strategies and the role of nature-like agricultural technologies in ecological optimization of steppe landscapes’ [Strategii novatsionnogo zemlepol’zovaniya i rol’ prirodopodobnykh agrotekhnologiy v ekologicheskoy optimizatsii stepnykh landshaftov]. Bull. Nikitsk. Bot. Gard. [Sbornik nauchnykh trudov Gosudarstvennogo Nikitinskogo botanicheskogo sada] 2019, vol. 148, 50–59. [Google Scholar]
  11. Gulyanov, YuA; Chibilev, A.A. ‘Greening of steppe agricultural technologies under conditions of natural and anthropogenic environmental changes’ [Ekologizatsiya stepnykh agrotekhnologiy v usloviyakh prirodnykh i antropogennykh izmeneniy okruzhayushchey sredy]. In Theoretical and Applied Ecology [Teoreticheskaya i prikladnaya ekologiya]; 2019; Volume no. 3, pp. 5–11. [Google Scholar]
  12. Gulyanov, YuA; Chibilev, A.A.; Levykin, S.V.; Silantieva, M.M.; Kazachkov, G.V.; Sokolova, L.V. ‘Ecological-based adaptation of agriculture to the soil and climatic conditions in Russian steppe’. Ukr. J. Ecol. 2019, vol. 9(no. 3), 393–398. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  13. Harrington, E.C. ‘The desirable function’. Ind. Qual. Control 1965, vol. 21(no. 10), 494–498. [Google Scholar]
  14. Harrison, S.; Spasojevic, M.J.; Li, D. ‘Climate and plant community diversity in space and time’. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2020, vol. 117(no. 9), 4464–4470. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  15. Ivanov, N.N. ‘On the determination of evaporability values’ [Ob opredelenii velichinam isparyayemosti]. Izv. VGO 1954, vol. 86(no. 2), 189–196. [Google Scholar]
  16. Izrael, YuA; Sirotenko, O.D. ‘Modeling the impact of climate change on Russian agricultural productivity’ [Modelirovaniye vliyaniya izmeneniy klimata na produktivnost’ sel’skogo khozyaystva Rossii]. In Russian Meteorology and Hydrology [Meteorologiya i gidrologiya]; 2003; Volume no. 6, pp. 5–17. [Google Scholar]
  17. Jat, H.S.; Choudhary, M.; Datta, A.; Yadav, A.K.; Meena, M.D.; Devi, R.; Gathala, M.K.; Jat, M.L.; McDonald, A.; Sharma, P.C. ‘Temporal changes in soil microbial properties and nutrient dynamics under climate smart agriculture practices’. Soil Tillage Res. 2020, vol. 199, 104595. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  18. Koloskov, P.I. ‘On bioclimatic potential and its distribution over the territory of the USSR’ [O bioklimaticheskom potentsiale i yego raspredelenii na territorii SSSR]. Proc. NIIAK [Trudy NIIAK] 1963, 23, 90–111. [Google Scholar]
  19. Kolyada, V.V. ‘Bioclimatic potential of Belarus in comparison with CIS and EU countries’ [Bioklimaticheskiy potentsial Belarusi v sravnenii so stranami SNG i ES]. In Environmental Management [Prirodopol’zovaniye], issue 24; Institute for Nature Management of NAS of Belarus: Minsk, 2013; pp. 17–26. [Google Scholar]
  20. Lemeshko, N.A.; Evstigneev, V.P.; Morozov, A.P.; Rusakov, V.A. ‘Applicability of AOGCM data for assessing agro-climatic conditions of specific territories’ [Primenimost’ dannykh MOTsAO dlya otsenki agroklimaticheskiy usloviy otdel’nykh territoriy]. In Environmental Control Systems [Sistemy kontrolya okruzhayushchey sredy]; 2021; Volume issue 3, no. 45, pp. 23–30. [Google Scholar]
  21. Li, Z.; Liu, W.; Ye, T.; Chen, S.; Shan, H. ‘Observed and CMIP6 simulated occurrence and intensity of compound agroclimatic extremes over maize harvested areas in China’. Weather Clim. Extrem. 2022, vol. 38, 100503. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. Loginov, V.F.; Khitrikov, M.A. ‘Spatiotemporal changes in the bioclimatic potential of Belarus’ [Prostranstvenno-vremennye izmeneniya bioklimaticheskogo potentsiala territorii Belarusi]. In Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of Belarus, Agrarian Series, 2017; no. 1, pp. 42–57. [Google Scholar]
  23. Mustafayev, ZhS; Adilbektegi, G.A. ‘Ecological assessment of the productivity of natural systems in the Chu River basin’ [Ekologicheskaya otsenka produktivnosti prirodnykh sistem basseyna reki Chu], in Problems of Genesis, Fertility, Reclamation, Soil Ecology, Assessment of Land Resources [Problemy genezisa, plodorodiya, melioratsiya, ekologiya pochv, otsenki zemel’nykh resursov]; Almaty, 2002; pp. 214–218. [Google Scholar]
  24. Mustafayev, ZhS; Adilbektegi, G.A. ‘Integrated mathematical model of the natural system of river basins’ [Integral’naya matematicheskaya model’ prirodnoy sistemy rechnykh basseynov]. In Theoretical and Applied Problems of Geography at the Turn of the Century: Proceedings of the International Scientific and Practical Conference, Almaty, 2004; pp. 84–88. [Google Scholar]
  25. Mustafayev, ZhS; Adilbektegi, G.A.; Kozykeyeva, A.T. ‘New approaches to assessing the bioecological potential of landscapes’ [Novye podkhody k otsenke bioekologicheskogo potentsiala landshaftov]. In New Methods and Results of Landscape Research in Europe, Central Asia and Siberia; Moscow, 2018; vol. 1, pp. 412–415. [Google Scholar]
  26. Mustafayev, Z.; Medeu, A.; Skorintseva, I.; Bassova, T.; Aldazhanova, G. ‘Improvement of the Methodology for the Assessment of the Agro-Resource Potential of Agricultural Landscapes’. Sustainability 2024, vol. 16, 419. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  27. Omarov, A.; Mustafayev, Z.; Skorintseva, I.; Aldazhanova, G.; Kuderin, A.; Toletayev, A. ‘A multi-criteria framework for assessing the natural resource potential of agricultural landscapes using Harrington’s generalized desirability function’. Environ. Monit. Assess. 2026, vol. 198, 773. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  28. Ontel, I.; Vladut, A. ‘Impact of drought on the productivity of agricultural crops within the Oltenia Plain, Romania’. Geogr. Pannonica 2015, vol. 19(no. 1), 6–19. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  29. Pavlova, V.; Karachenkova, A.; Shkolnik, I.; Pikaleva, A.; Efimov, S.; Kattsov, V. ‘Future changes in spring wheat yield in the European Russia as inferred from a large ensemble of high-resolution climate projections’. Environ. Res. Lett. 2019, vol. 14(no. 3), 034010. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  30. Pichura, V.; Potravka, L.; Vdovenko, N.; Biloshkurenko, O.; Stratichuk, N.; Baysha, K. ‘Changes in Climate and Bioclimatic Potential in the Steppe Zone of Ukraine’. J. Ecol. Eng. 2022, vol. 23(no. 12), 189–202. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  31. Sangines de Carcer, P.; Sinaj, S.; Santonja, M.; Fossati, D.; Jeangros, B. ‘Long-term effects of crop succession, soil tillage and climate on wheat yield and soil properties’. Soil Tillage Res. 2019, vol. 190, 209–219. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  32. Sapozhnikova, S.A. ‘Experience of integrated agricultural assessment of the climate of socialist European countries’ [Opyt integral’noy sel’skokhozyaystvennoy otsenki klimata territorii sotsialisticheskikh stran Evropy], in Agroclimatic Zonation of Five Major Agricultural Crops in Socialist European Countries; Bulgarian Academy of Sciences Publishing House: Sofia, 1976; pp. 30–36. [Google Scholar]
  33. Shashko, D.I. Agroclimatic Resources of the USSR [Agroklimaticheskiye resursy SSSR]; Gidrometeoizdat, Leningrad, 1985. [Google Scholar]
  34. Sirotenko, O.D.; Abashina, E.V.; Pavlova, V.N. ‘Dynamics of climate-conditioned changes in heat supply, moisture, and productivity of the agricultural zone of Russia’ [Dinamika klimatoolobuslovlennykh izmeneniy teploobespechennosti, uvlazhnennosti i produktivnosti zemledel’cheskoy zony Rossii]. Proceedings of VNIISKhM [Trudy VNIISKhM], Gidrometeoizdat, St. Petersburg, 2013; issue 38, pp. 41–53. [Google Scholar]
  35. Volobuyev, V.R. Introduction to the Energetics of Soil Formation [Vvedeniye v energetiku pochvoobrazovaniya]; Nauka, Moscow, 1974. [Google Scholar]
  36. Zhao, Ch; Liu, B.; Piao, Sh; Wang, X.; Lobell, D.B.; Huang, Y.; Huang, M.; Yao, Y.; Bassu, S.; Ciais, P.; Durand, J.-L.; Elliott, J.; Ewert, F.; Janssens, I.A.; Li, T.; Lin, E.; Liu, Q.; Martre, P.; Müller, Ch; Peng, Sh; Peñuelas, J.; Ruane, A.C.; Wallach, D.; Wang, T.; Wu, D.; Liu, Zh; Zhu, Y.; Zhu, Z.; Asseng, S. ‘Temperature increase reduces global yields of major crops in four independent estimates’. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2017, vol. 114(no. 35), 9326–9331. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  37. Zoidze, E.K.; Ovcharenko, L.I. Comparative Assessment of the Agricultural Potential of the Climate of the Russian Federation and the Degree of Agricultural Crop Resource Utilization [Sravnitel’naya otsenka sel’skokhozyaystvennogo potentsiala klimata territorii RF i stepeni ispol’zovaniya yee agroklimaticheskikh resursov sel’skokhozyaystvennymi kul’turami]; Gidrometeoizdat, St. Petersburg, 2000. [Google Scholar]
Table 1. Rainfed barley yield (c/ha) in administrative districts of Karaganda Region.
Table 1. Rainfed barley yield (c/ha) in administrative districts of Karaganda Region.
Years Administrative districts of Karaganda Region
Abai Aktogay Bukhar-Zhyrau Karkaraly Nura Osakarovka Shet
2000 7.9 6 8 7 7.5 6.8 7.2
2001 9.3 8.2 10.4 8.4 9 9.7 7.9
2002 14.1 8.6 10.5 10.7 7.6 8.9 9.5
2003 9.6 7 7.7 6.3 8.1 5.9 7.4
2004 6.8 6.3 7 7.9 6.5 6.4 7.6
2005 4.1 4.5 4.1 3.4 4.2 3.8 2.5
2006 5.4 6.8 6.8 7.2 6.6 6.2 6.1
2007 6 4.5 8.4 6.9 8.8 8.3 6
2008 3.7 5 6 3.1 6.5 5.7 4.1
2009 6.4 5.2 8.2 5 8.4 9.3 4.1
2010 4.4 7.7 4 6.1 4.2 4.8 5.5
2011 14.3 7.4 11.3 7.3 9.8 13 6.8
2012 8.2 8 7.5 10.7 4.7 6.6 7.2
2013 13.8 6.5 11.3 12 10.8 12.1 8.7
2014 12.2 9.9 8.5 8.7 8.8 10.4 8.5
2015 14.8 6.5 8.9 6.2 8.4 10.6 6.8
2016 18.8 12.3 10.1 11.6 12.2 12.1 12.1
2017 19 7.4 8.6 7.2 8.2 11.1 9.6
2018 16.7 7.9 10.6 7.9 12.7 12.1 8.5
2019 11.7 3.7 9 7.2 7.2 10.7 7.8
2020 11 9.3 10.6 7.9 10.5 11.4 9.1
2021 10.6 8.8 8.8 7.6 7.8 10.4 8.3
2022 11.2 7.2 7.2 5.7 8.3 9.8 10.1
2023 6.3 6.6 6.4 4.1 4.6 8.5 7.4
2024 15.6 15.1 15.1 8.8 11.7 16.5 11.8
2025 9.5 19.4 9.7 5 11 15.1 7.4
Mean 10.44 7.92 8.64 7.30 8.23 9.47 7.62
Table 2. Assessment of the biological productivity of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region.
Table 2. Assessment of the biological productivity of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region.
Meteorological station Height ( H i ), m Climate- and environment-forming parameters Biological productivity of the landscape
∑ S B A T i A P i S E F W S i P L V i N M C i I I B P L i
Aktogay 780 2454.0 124.0 715.3 0.545 0.173 0.095
Aksu-Ayuly 724 2468.0 319.0 685.7 0.548 0.465 0.255
Besoba 715 2356.0 228.0 606.4 0.524 0.376 0.197
Akadyr 694 2625.0 214.0 688.4 0.583 0.311 0.181
Zharyk 655 2596.0 356.0 678.5 0.577 0.525 0.303
Bektauata 610 2980.0 216.0 806.0 0.662 0.268 0.177
Korneevka 600 2369.0 355.0 610.0 0.526 0.582 0.306
Karagandinskaya 553 2508.0 321.0 652.4 0.557 0.492 0.274
Karaganda 552 2495.0 370.0 650.4 0.554 0.569 0.315
Kertindy 535 2656.0 291.0 699.0 0.590 0.416 0.246
Rodnikovskoye 521 2526.0 274.0 658.3 0.561 0.416 0.234
Kyzyltau 449 2497.0 298.0 648.3 0.555 0.460 0.255
Sayak 425 3206.0 149.0 889.2 0.712 0.168 0.119
Saryshagan 355 3190.0 137.0 883.5 0.709 0.155 0.110
Balkhash 352 3097.0 142.0 964.6 0.688 0.147 0.101
Table 3. Assessment of the ecological productivity of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region.
Table 3. Assessment of the ecological productivity of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region.
Meteorological station Height ( H i ), m Climate- and environment-forming parameters Ecological productivity of the landscape
R B i R D I i E C S F i P E S F i P L S C i N M C i E P L i
Aktogay 780 137.3 4.43 17.1 85.8 0.200 0.173 0.035
Aksu-Ayuly 724 137.8 1.73 61.2 86.1 0.710 0.465 0.330
Besoba 715 134.1 2.35 44.4 83.8 0.530 0.376 0.199
Akadyr 694 143.0 2.67 40.7 89.4 0.456 0.311 0.142
Zharyk 655 142.0 1.60 67.1 88.8 0.756 0.525 0.397
Bektauata 610 154.8 2.87 40.2 96.8 0.416 0.268 0.111
Korneevka 600 134.5 1.52 66.0 84.1 0.785 0.582 0.457
Karagandinskaya 553 139.1 1.73 61.6 86.9 0.708 0.492 0.349
Karaganda 552 138.7 1.50 68.6 86.7 0.791 0.569 0.450
Kertindy 535 144.0 1.98 56.8 90.0 0.631 0.416 0.263
Rodnikovskoye 521 139.7 2.04 53.6 87.3 0.614 0.416 0.255
Kyzyltau 449 138.8 1.86 57.8 86.8 0.667 0.460 0.307
Sayak 425 162.2 4.35 21.0 101.4 0.207 0.168 0.035
Saryshagan 355 161.7 4.72 17.6 101.1 0.174 0.155 0.027
Balkhash 352 158.6 4.47 19.4 99.1 0.196 0.147 0.029
Table 4. Agrochemical parameters of agricultural lands in the Karaganda region by administrative district.
Table 4. Agrochemical parameters of agricultural lands in the Karaganda region by administrative district.
District Soil type Agrochemical soil parameters
p H i H A i H H i F H i N C i P C i K C i
t/ha
Abai dark brown 7.50 1.60 321.0 163.2 13.6 0.23 2.35
Bukhar-Zhyrau 7.21 2.05 190.0 96.6 13.1 0.16 2.48
Osakarovka calcareous chernozems 7.76 0.94 209.7 106.6 12.9 0.17 2.88
Karkaraly 7.83 0.82 327.8 166.6 12.5 0.19 2.48
Nura light brown 7.17 0.93 251.6 127.9 12.4 0.26 2.75
Aktogay 7.74 1.31 295.3 150.1 12.0 0.19 2.35
Shet 7.75 1.30 248.2 126.2 11.9 0.18 2.13
Table 5. Integrated soil fertility indices of agricultural lands in the Karaganda region by administrative district.
Table 5. Integrated soil fertility indices of agricultural lands in the Karaganda region by administrative district.
District Soil type Integrated soil fertility indice Soil index
H I i M N I i S A I i S F I i P S F I i
Abai dark brown 3.772 4.317 4.393 12.482 0.312
Bukhar-Zhyrau 2.233 3.847 3.922 10.002 0.250
Osakarovka calcareous chernozems 2.464 4.105 4.746 11.315 0.283
Karkaraly 3.852 4.010 4.831 12.693 0.317
Nura light brown 2.957 4.596 3.851 11.404 0.285
Aktogay 3.470 3.886 4.721 12.077 0.302
Shet 2.916 3.683 4.734 11.333 0.283
Table 6. Assessment of the bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region.
Table 6. Assessment of the bioclimatic productivity of agricultural landscapes in the Karaganda Region.
Meteorological station Height ( H i ), m Climate- and environment-forming parameters Bioclimatic productivity of the landscape
∑ A D A H i C I A H i Y G R i B C P i C I P P i P L S C i B C P I i
Aktogay 780 1610.0 0.077 0.329 80.8 0.329 0.200 0.066
Aksu-Ayuly 724 1600.0 0.199 1.466 361.9 1.466 0.710 1.041
Besoba 715 1520.0 0.150 1.125 265.1 1.125 0.530 0.596
Akadyr 694 1878.0 0.114 0.796 209.0 0.796 0.456 0.363
Zharyk 655 1748.0 0.204 1.492 387.3 1.492 0.756 1.128
Bektauata 610 1576.0 0.137 1.017 303.1 1.017 0.416 0.423
Korneevka 600 1490.0 0.238 1.679 397.7 1.679 0.785 1.318
Karagandinskaya 553 1553.0 0.207 1.510 378.6 1.510 0.708 1.069
Karaganda 552 1695.0 0.218 1.575 392.9 1.575 0.791 1.246
Kertindy 535 1754.0 0.166 1.246 331.0 1.246 0.631 0.786
Rodnikovskoye 521 1498.0 0.183 1.363 344.4 1.363 0.614 0.837
Kyzyltau 449 1723.0 0.173 1.296 323.7 1.296 0.667 0.864
Sayak 425 1831.0 0.081 0.395 126.6 0.395 0.207 0.082
Saryshagan 355 1690.0 0.081 0.390 124.5 0.390 0.174 0.068
Balkhash 352 1680.0 0.085 0.440 136.2 0.440 0.196 0.086
Table 7. Bioenergetic assessment of agricultural landscape productivity.
Table 7. Bioenergetic assessment of agricultural landscape productivity.
Meteorological station Height ( H i ), m Coded values for specific landscape productivity indicators Bioenergetic productivity of landscapes( D F P L i )
C V B P L i C V E P L i C V B C P L i
Aktogay 780 0.403 0.381 0.392 0.392
Aksu-Ayuly 724 0.461 0.487 0.703 0.540
Besoba 715 0.440 0.441 0.576 0.482
Akadyr 694 0.434 0.420 0.499 0.450
Zharyk 655 0.478 0.511 0.723 0.561
Bektauata 610 0.433 0.409 0.519 0.451
Korneevka 600 0.479 0.531 0.765 0.579
Karagandinskaya 553 0.468 0.494 0.709 0.547
Karaganda 552 0.482 0.529 0.750 0.576
Kertindy 535 0.458 0.464 0.634 0.512
Rodnikovskoye 521 0.453 0.461 0.649 0.514
Kyzyltau 449 0.461 0.479 0.656 0.525
Sayak 425 0.412 0.381 0.398 0.397
Saryshagan 355 0.408 0.378 0.393 0.393
Balkhash 352 0.405 0.379 0.399 0.394
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.