4. Discussion
The main objective of this study was to examine substance use and its health-related risks in connection with self-esteem, body image concern, body satisfaction, and beliefs about the effects of substances on body image within a Spanish sample.
The observed consumption patterns align with typical national trends, where alcohol, tobacco, and cannabis remain the most prevalent substances [
2,
3]. Furthermore, according to the ASSIST criteria [
39], the health-related risks associated with substance use were predominantly low for the majority of the sample. This suggests that, while consumption is widespread, the current usage patterns for most participants do not immediately lead to severe clinical complications and indicate a low probability of developing future health issues.
Moderate risk levels were identified primarily for tobacco, alcohol, and cannabis, which aligns with the findings of Rocha et al. [
13]. These three substances, along with sedatives, were also the only ones to reach high-risk scores in this sample.
These results are further supported by López-Rodríguez et al. [
45], who reported that tobacco (41.7%), alcohol (15.4%), sedatives (13.7%), and cannabis (5.7%) are the substances with the highest prevalence and risk screening in Spanish primary care populations.
Notably, the identification of high risk for sedatives in this study, despite a lower overall prevalence compared to alcohol or tobacco, reflects a significant public health concern. This observation is consistent with recent data from Mouriño et al. [
46] and the OEDA [
3], which warn of a substantial increase in both the prevalence and health risks associated with sedative and hypnosedative use in Spain.
The sample in this study displayed medium-high levels of self-esteem alongside moderate scores for body image concern and body satisfaction. The absence of extreme values across these psychological variables suggests that, overall, the participants did not hold significantly negative perceptions toward their own bodies.
Regarding the relationship between these psychological dimensions and substance use, the findings highlight self-esteem as a key factor. Specifically, the prevalence of cocaine use over the last three months was negatively correlated with self-esteem, indicating that lower self-esteem is associated with higher rates of cocaine consumption. This is congruent with research by Jain et al. [
47], which observed that higher self-esteem levels correspond to reduced cocaine use. Furthermore, the health risks associated with alcohol and sedative use were also negatively associated with self-esteem. These findings, supported by previous studies [
48,
49] suggest that high self-esteem acts as a protective factor against problematic alcohol consumption and other substance-related behaviors.
In contrast, body image concern and body satisfaction did not show significant relationships with the prevalence or health risk levels of most evaluated substances. These results align with prior research that failed to observe significant associations between these specific body image variables and substance use patterns [
13,
32,
33,
34]. Consequently, the data from this study suggest that while general self-esteem significantly influences the risk associated with certain substances (such as cocaine, alcohol, and sedatives), specific body image variables do not appear to have a direct impact on the risk levels measured in this sample.
Regarding demographic factors, gender was significantly associated with the health risks of several substances. Male participants exhibited significantly higher risk levels for cannabis, amphetamine-type stimulants, and inhalants. Additionally, a statistical trend was observed for cocaine risk, with males showing higher scores than females. These findings are consistent with previous studies indicating that substance use, particularly cannabis, is a greater concern among the male population [
13,
45].
Notably, although no significant overall differences were found in sedative use risk, high-risk consumption was exclusively identified among female participants, while no such cases were recorded for males. According to Mouriño et al. [
46], the higher prevalence of hypnosedative use in women may be linked to a greater incidence of disorders such as anxiety, depression, or somatization. It might also reflect women's higher awareness of mental health and their greater tendency to seek professional assistance. Furthermore, certain healthcare biases—where clinicians may adopt a more psychological focus when treating women—could also contribute to this disparity.
Psychological variables were also significantly influenced by gender. Male participants reported higher body satisfaction, whereas female participants reported greater body image concern. A statistical trend was also noted for self-esteem, with males scoring higher than females, these results mirror prior research suggesting that gender significantly impacts body image perception, often leading to higher satisfaction and self-esteem in men and greater concern in women [
38].
Age also emerged as a variable with numerous significant associations, indicating that increased age is linked to higher health risks across nearly all evaluated substances, with the exception of opioids and steroids, which showed no significant results. This finding is consistent with consumption prevalence reports from other studies regarding age; specifically, the population with the highest consumption rates is generally found within the 35–64 age group, whereas cannabis remains more prevalent among those under 35 [
3].
The analysis of Substance Use for Body Image Improvement revealed that approximately one-quarter of the sample (25.3%) reported using at least one substance to alter their physical appearance. To a lesser extent, some participants employed between two and eight different substances for this purpose. The most frequently used substances included dietary supplements, alcohol, tobacco, and fat burners (thermogenics). Notably, none of the participants reported using steroids specifically to improve their body image.
Despite the absence of steroid use, the employment of fat burners and dietary supplements for aesthetic goals is consistent with literature reporting the reality of ergogenic substance use to enhance physical appearance [
50]. These results are particularly interesting when compared to findings that link steroid consumption to body dissatisfaction and the pursuit of a hyper-muscular ideal [
20,
23]. In this sample, low levels of body satisfaction were scarce, which aligns with the observed lack of steroid use for body image improvement.
Regarding gender differences, male participants reported significantly higher usage of dietary supplements compared to females. These substances, often categorized in the literature as “Appearance and Performance Enhancing Drugs” (APED), have shown strong associations with the male gender. Their consumption is predominantly linked to men, which is coherent with prevailing male aesthetic ideals centered on increasing muscle mass [
4,
19,
20,
50].
Regarding beliefs about the effects of substances on body image, the majority of the sample considered that substance use worsens physical appearance and perceived attractiveness, while failing to contribute positively to body satisfaction. These beliefs were particularly consistent across most evaluated substances, reflecting a notably negative view regarding muscle mass and physical attractiveness.
However, relevant nuances were observed: in the case of steroids, the sample perceived that they do not affect weight but do contribute to increased muscle mass, which aligns with their use as substances oriented toward appearance and performance enhancement [
4,
19,
50]. Additionally, a degree of ambivalence was noted regarding tobacco; while one part of the sample perceived it as a weight-loss aid, another saw no influence on weight control.
Although the majority expressed negative beliefs, a minority proportion considered that certain substances, such as steroids, alcohol, and tobacco, could have positive effects on physical appearance. Specifically, tobacco was the substance most frequently associated with the belief that it contributes to enhancing physical attractiveness. When considering gender, a significant association was identified regarding the belief that tobacco controls weight, with female participants scoring significantly higher. These data mirror findings from other studies where women utilize tobacco for weight management due to aesthetic standards centered on the thinness ideal [
24,
25,
27].
Notwithstanding the insights provided, the findings of this research should be interpreted with caution due to several methodological limitations. First, while the sample size was sufficient for the conducted analyses, it was not large enough to ensure full representativeness or to generalize the results to the entire Spanish population. Additionally, the underrepresentation of individuals identifying outside the gender binary prevented their inclusion in the comparative statistical analyses, limiting the scope of the gender-based findings
The data collection method also presents certain constraints; although the online format (Google Forms) facilitated anonymity and provided access to a diverse sample, it may have restricted the participation of certain profiles and reduced control over the participants' response environment.
Finally, the lack of standardized instruments specifically designed to evaluate beliefs regarding substance use for aesthetic purposes necessitated the use of ad hoc items, which could potentially impact the validity and reliability of this particular dimension