3. Discussion
Drought stress is one of the premier limitations to global agricultural production due to the complexity of the water-limiting environment and changing climate [
26]. Drought can affect wheat plants at any point in their life cycle, but the seedling stage appears to be highly vulnerable to water deficit.
Drought stress causes significant impacts on the morphology, biochemistry, and physiology of wheat. Drought also causes to a loss of turgor pressure and a reduction in plant height [
27]. On the other hand, when wheat height decreases under drought stress conditions, it leads to reduced spike length [
28]. Lack of water triggers serious disruptions in metabolic activity in wheat [
29]. Low water potential reduces stomatal conductance, resulting in diminished CO
2 uptake and lowered photosynthetic rate [
30]. These conditions increase the demand in ATP and might favor the alternative electron pathways. Moreover, the decline in photosynthetic activity restricts carbon assimilation and reduces sugar accumulation [
31]. Identifying physiological and biophysical markers associated with drought tolerance at the seedling stage is crucial for developing drought-resistant varieties with high yield.
In this study, we investigated two Bulgarian wheat varieties, Katya and Zora, which were exposed to drought, and after seven days of dehydration, they were rehydrated. Previous studies have found that Katya is drought-tolerant, while Zora is a sensitive variety [
32,
33].
Our results showed that Zora loses approximately 40% of its fresh weight and 30% of its dry weight during the drought period, while Katya loses only 20%. These differences in dry and fresh weight loss between the two varieties suggest that Katya can retain more water than Zora, which is probably due to better stomatal control leading to an increase in water use efficiency and proline synthesis [
34]. Both varieties fully recovered their fresh weight after rehydration, and the dry weight of the rehydrated plants was greater than that of the controls, which means the plants restored their growth rate after resumption of watering. The fresh weight of the rehydrated plants was 10% higher than that of the controls for the Katya and 7% higher for Zora. The dry weight of the rehidrated plants from Katya variety was 75% higher than the dry weight of the controls, while that of Zora increased only 32% after restoring the water supply. These results show that Katya is much more drought-resistant than Zora, as it has much better rehydration compensatory mechanisms which can be associated with the synthesis of phytohormones such as indoleacetic acid (IAA), abscisic acid (ABA), jasmonic acid (JA), gibberellins (GA), and silicic acid (SA) during the stage of drought [
35].
These results are consistent with the water content measurements obtained in both varieties across control, dehydrated, and rehydrated plants. Both wheat varieties had approximately the same water content, losing about 45% of it during the drought. However, Katya was able to recover up to 60% of its water content during the rehydration period, while Zora was not able to.
The specific leaf area decreased slowly only in Katya variety. Still, the differences in this indicator are not significant between the control and dried plants. Statistical differences were observed only between rehydrated plants on the one hand and controls and dehydrated plants on the other. This means that the dry matter in the leaves of the rehydrated plants is more than that in the leaves of the controls and the dried ones, which corresponds to previous results. In Zora varietie, no significant changes between control, dehydrated and rehydrated plants in the SLA were observed. Conversely, Katya reduced SLA during dehydration as a strategy of investment in structural support.
In Zora wheat, chlorophyll content decreases during drought and continues to decline even during the rehydration period. During the drought period, the chlorophyll content decreases by 10% compared to plants not subjected to this stress, which aligns with results from previous studies [
36,
37]. During rehydration, Zora did not restore its chlorophyll content, but, on the contrary, lost another 10% compared to control plants. This ongoing degradation of chlorophyll in Zora variety may be due to oxidative damage or upregulation of the enzyme chlorophyllase during drought [
38,
39].
On the other hand, Katya showed an 18% increase in chlorophyll content during drought compared to control plants. This level also maintained during the rehydration period. That kind of behavior is typicall for drought-tolerant species, which use light very efficiently during drought [
40].
The decrease in SLA and the increase in chlorophyll indicate that wheat of the Katya variety retains its chlorophyll content during the drought, which allows for faster recovery upon rehydration [
41].
In dark adapted leaves, TL bands in result of flash excitation are associated with the recombination of charge pairs within the photosynthetic apparatus, particularly in PSII, which is the B band (S
2/3Q
B-), but also afterglow (AG) band (S
2/3Q
B +e) may appear, which is connected to electron transfer capacity and activation of cyclic electron flow around PSI, or a strong NADPH + ATP assimilatory potential [
42].
In the Katya variety, a decrease in the B and AG bands intensities, without a downshift in Tmax were observed during drought. That means there is a decline in the number of recombining pairs, but there are no disturbances in the functionality of photosynthetic reactions. During rehydration, they both bands recovered and assumed values close to those of the control plants.
Unlike in Katya, dehydration produced significant downshifts in TmaxB and TmaxAG in Zora variety of wheat and the intensity of AG increased. The downshift of the B band is due to a decrease in lumen pH and leads to disturbances in the charge recombination, which is not restored in the rehydrated plants [
43,
44]. AG increased and represents the more intensive band in the curve of rehydrated leaves, simultaneously TmaxAG remains downshifted, indicating that cyclic pathways are stimulated after rehydration.
In the initial drought period, only six JIP parameters changed statistically in Katya compared to control plants. Chlorophyll fluorescence reached its maximum Fm upon complete reduction of Q
A molecules. In dehydrated plants, Fm decreased by approximately 10% compared to non-stressed plants, due to disruption of the ETC, leading to fewer reduced Q
A molecules, and an increase in non-photochemical quenching. The parameter Fv/F0 decreased by 3% compared to non-dehydrated plants. This parameter provides information about the maximum efficiency of the water diffusion reaction on the donor side of PS II, and its slight decrease in the initial stage of drought indicates that minor disturbances occur in the electron transport chain of the photosynthetic apparatus. The parameter Vi reflects the ability of PS I acceptors to oxidize the plastoquinone pool. Its value increased by 3% under drought conditions. Although the lower Vi could in principle reflect accelerated oxidation of the PQ pool by PSI, the simultaneous increase in Vi with unchanged F0 and reduced Fm - together with the weakened AG-band - indicated disturbances in PS II operation and enhanced non-photochemical quenching. The parameter ABS/RC gives information about absorbed light energy per active PSII reaction center, TR0/RC refers to energy trapped at t₀ per RC, and ET0/RC shows the level of electron transport beyond Qᴀ⁻ per RC. In the initial stage of drought, the parameters ABS/RC, TR0/RC, and ET0/RC decreased slightly compared to that calculated for the control plants, with ABS/RC and ET0/RC decreasing by 5% and TR0/RC by 10%. These results align with those of Ghaffar [
45], who compared drought-tolerant and drought-intolerant wheat varieties. The decline in these parameters is considered to be a mechanism by which drought-tolerant plants adapt to drought conditions by limiting electron transport and reducing the photochemical activity of photosystem II [
46].
After seven days of dehydration, the parameters F0, Fm, Vj, Vi, ψ0, ET0/RC, ϕE0, and PI(abs) in Katya statistically change their values compared to the same parameters measured in plants not subjected to drought. F0 and Vj, decrease by 10% and 11% respectively, while the parameters ψ0, ϕE0 and PI(abs) increased by 14%, 11% and 20% respectively. The JIP parameters Fm, Vi and ET0/RC did not change from the values in the initial stage of the drought. F0 is the fluorescence intensity when all reaction centers are “open” and provides information about the emission from excited chlorophyll a molecules on the antenna before the excitation reaches the reaction centers [
47]. Low F0 values under stress are associated with reduced chlorophyll content, which is not the case according to our results, or with low light absorption capacity due to disorders in the light-harvesting complexes [
48]. In the Katya variety, these lower values of the minimal fluorescence of dried plants are due to the high adaptability of photosystem II to the applied stress. Reducing the value of the parameter Vj leads to an increase in the probability that an exciton moves an electron beyond Qᴀ⁻. Also, the parameter φE0, which indicates the quantum efficiency of electron transfer in the ETC after Q
A, increased in dried plants compared to controls. The parameter that increased its value the most under drought is PI(abs), which is an indication of high efficiency of photosystem II during dehydration.
In the initial period of rehydration, the parameters that restored the values are Fm and Vi, which means that the Katya variety very quickly begins to regain its photosynthetic activity. After 7 days of rehydration, the JIP parameters assumed values that were statistically indistinguishable from those measured in the control plants, indicating that after one week of rehydration, the Katya variety fully restored its photosynthetic activity.
Unlike Katya, Zora showed poor adaptability to drought. On the fourth day under stress, only one JIP parameter, Vi, had changed its value, with an increase by 1%. On the 7th day of drought, 14 parameters had statistically changed their values compared to the values of the same parameters calculated in the control plants. The parameters that change the most are ABS/RC, TR0/RC, ET0/RC and DI0/RC, which increased their values by 21%, 20%, 27%, and 29%, respectively. The change in these parameters indicates disturbances in the entire electron transport chain.
Although PI(abs) decreased by 5% on the seventh day of dehydration, its values were 25% lower than that of unstressed plants. This drop in the values of the index indicates that, as a result of dehydration, the photosynthetic apparatus of Zora has suffered irreversible damage. A similar trend is observed for some of the other studied JIP parameters, which confirms this assumption. Only Vi and φ(p0) did not undergo profound changes during the drought and subsequent rehydration of the plants. TR0/RC and ET0/RC are the parameters that during the rehydration process, take on values close to those of the control plants.
A comparison of the JIP parameters and the induction curves of chlorophyll a fluorescence between the two wheat varieties clearly demonstrates the high drought adaptability of the Katya variety. Under drought stress, Zora had higher ABS/RC, TR0/RC, ET0/RC and DI0/RC values, but significantly lower PI(abs) values, indicating less active PSII centers and reduced photochemical efficiency. In contrast, Katya maintained higher RC/ABS and a more balanced energy distribution, consistent with better drought tolerance.
To obtain more detailed information about the differences in the photosynthetic apparatus of the two wheat varieties during drought, methods for analyzing the induction curves were employed. The induction curves between control, dried, and rehydrated plants of the two varieties were compared. The comparison of the induction curves of the control plants between Katya and Zora showed statistical differences in all phases. This means that they react differently to light when optimally watered.
Under drought conditions, the two varieties showed statistical differences only in the OJ phase. This phase is mainly associated with the accumulation of reduced Q
A. Additionally, during the OJ phase, primary photochemistry takes place [
49]. According to the JIP test, F0 decreases in Katya. It increases in Zora, with the increase in F0 likely due to difficulties in electron transfer from Q
A to Q
B, disconnection of LHCII from the PSII RC, and loss of both functional and structural integrity of PSI II [
50].
Rehydrated plants of both genotypes showed significant differences across all phases of the OJIP induction curves, indicating distinct responses of the two wheat varieties to drought and the high adaptability of Katya to this type of stress. The most significant differences again appear in the OJ phase, indicating that in Zora, severe structural and functional disorders occur in photosystem II. In contrast, in Katya, photosynthetic activity is fully restored.