1. Introduction
We consider the div-curl problem in 2D exterior domain
:
Here , - 2D vector field, is the vorticity, - the divergence, - is the given fixed velocity of the flow at infinity, is the exterior to bounded simply connected domain G with a piecewise smooth boundary.
Quartapelle and Valz-Gris in paper [
1] derived the
projection conditions on the vorticity for solenoidal flows defined in bounded domains. In bounded domains for flows with finite energy this problem also was studied in [
2,
3,
4]. In [
5] author solved exterior div-curl problem in case of solenoidal flows and in [
6] there was studied div-curl problem in exterior of the disk.
We will find a new
orthogonality conditions for solvability of the above div-curl problem in case of non-solenoidal exterior flows. For example, for the horizontal flow
in exterior of the disk with radius
these conditions will have the form:
From Stokes’ and Green’s formulas follows that in the case of the non-zero circulation or in the case of the non-zero flux at infinity we will have
Non-zero circulation and flux at infinity generate harmonic fields with infinite kinetic energy(see [
5]). In order to obtain finite
-norm
one should additionally impose restrictions on circulation and flux:
or
For -estimates of with the above condition is not necessary.
In the paper we will use weighted space
Our aim is to find restrictions on
w,
for solvability of the div-curl problem (
1)–(4) and to estimate its solution in
-norm as
2. Div-Cirl Problem in Exterior of the Disk
First, we study (
1)–(4) in
. We construct the solution of (
1)–(
5) in
as Fourier series in polar coordinates
r,
:
Here - vector filed in polar coordinates, , , , - are the Fourier coefficients.
The Fourier coefficients for exterior flow
are given by the formulas:
and so we have the relation between
and
:
Here
All the Fourier coefficients of the external flow are zero (except
). For horizontal flow
Equations (
1) and (2) in polar coordinates are written as:
For non-zero
k the solution of this system with condition at infinity (4) is given by the following formula:
where
,
- Kronecker delta.
For
using no-slip condition (3) we have:
Since the conditions of zero-circulation (
5) and zero-flux (6) are satisfied, then from Stokes’ and Green’s formulas
and
will belong to
. And Formulas (
8) and (9) will be valid and for
.
These formulas have an integral representation with singular kernels:
where
.
The kernels in the formula above are the gradient
and the skew gradient
of the Green function
Formulas (
8) and (9) with no-slip condition (3) lead to relations for
:
These relations are the orthogonality conditions
where
.
The singular integrals involved in Formula (
10) are the operators of Calderón-Zygmund type[
7] and for
From the Hardy-Littlewood-Sobolev inequality for
, satisfying
, the following estimate holds with some
:
Theorem 1.
Suppose that the orthogonality conditions (12) are satisfied and with . Then there exists the unique solution of the div-curl problem (1)–(4) in the exterior of the disk and with some the following estimate holds:
Note, that from (
12) with
follows that the conditions (
5) and (6) are satisfied. Existence and uniqueness follows from the explicit formulas (
8) and (9).
Now we prove (
14). We estimate the first term in (
8) and (9) involving
w for
,
:
Here
is the weighted space of functions (with the weight
) which is related to the space
:
Also we will use space
related to
:
Then we have
-estimate:
A similar estimate is valid for
. And so, the first term in (
8) and (9) for
belongs to
.
Second term in (
8) and (9) we estimate in a similar way:
So, for
it also belongs to
. Lets study the case
. We have
and
So,
,
will belong to
. Then, summing by
k, and using Parseval’s equality for Fourier series, we obtain the inequality with some
:
Finally, in virtue of the inequality (
13) we obtain the required estimate (
14).
3. Div-cirl Problem in Exterior Domain
For further consideration we need some additional requirements on
. Suppose the there exists a Riemann mapping
from
into
such that
where
.
And also suppose that for
there exists the inverse transform
, which satisfies
and
We change the variables
onto
in the system (
1) and (2). Vector field
in
with
defines the vector field
in
:
where
is the transpose matrix to Jacobian matrix
Then
is the vector field in
. And
,
are the divergence and vorticity functions in
correspondingly.
From the Cauchy-Riemann relations
we will have
and
Finally, the system (
1) and (2) goes to
Using the representation of the complex derivative
:
we will have
Now we calculate the divergence of the field
. Using Jacobian matrix
and its transpose
we will have
and
Then the system (
1)–(4) transfers to new one, defined in
:
Denote
where
means the
k-th Fourier coefficient and
.
Rewrite (
18) and (19) in polar coordinates using Fourier coefficients
,
:
From (
5) and (6), Stokes and divergence formulas we have:
The solution of the system (
18)–(21) is given by
Formulas (
22) and (23) with no-slip condition (20) lead to relations (
):
or
for
.
Finally, these moment relations in
will take the form
For horizontal flow
it will be the relations
Formulas (
22) and (23) have an integral representation
In
this formula takes the form
The kernels of integrals involved in above formula are the gradient and the skew gradient of the Green’s function:
4. Uniqueness Solvability of the div-curl Problem
Theorem 2. Let Ω be the exterior domain with a piecewise smooth boundary such that there exists a Riemann mapping from Ω into satisfying (15) and (16), with , and the moment relations (24) are satisfied. Then there exists the unique solution of the problem (1)–(4), and the estimate (7) holds.
Uniqueness follows from the Hodge theory, since the no-slip condition fixes circulation and flux around a solid and in that case there is no one nontrivial harmonic form. Existence follows from the explicit formula for the solution (
22) and (23), or its integral representation (
25).
Then from Theorem 1 using (
16) with some
,
holds:
Finally, using the inequality with some
we obtain the estimate (
7). The Theorem is proved.
5. Numerical Results
Here we will present the method for solving the exterior div-curl problem
which can be realized numerically for solenoidal flows with no-slip condition on the solid and horizontal flow at infinity
. For these flows since the no-slip condition (28) is fullfiled, then there exists a stream function
, such that
where
.
The condition (28) is a particular case of slip interaction between solid and fluid, which is expressed by the formula:
In terms of stream function it can be rewritten as
Also no-slip condition leads to Neumann boundary ones:
At infinity horizontal flow
transfers to boundary constraint on
:
The Equation (27) goes to Poisson equation under curl operator:
But the exterior Poisson problem with boundary condition (
31)–(
33) is overdetermined and incorrect. From (28) follows zero-circulation condition around boundary
This condition combined with slip constraint (
30) guarantees the correctness of the exterior div-curl problem (
26), (27) and (29). And so (
31), (
33) and (
35) guarantee the correctness of the exterior Poisson problem (
34) which can be solved numerically by means of finite elements method (FEM). Conditions (
31) and (
35) generate
N boundary relations, where
N is the amount of boundary nodes in a triangulated domain. Unbounded domain is restricted by rectangular domain where we set the condition on infinity (
33). This condition also generates relations by the number of nodes in rectangular domain. So, FEM becomes a closed numerical method for the system (
31), (
33), (
34) and (
35).
In numerical experiment Poisson equation was solved by FEM with continuous piecewise linear basis functions on triangles in a triangulated plane region with about 3600 nodes. Data for vorticity function
w in right-hand side of (27) which satisfies integral restrictions (
24) with
was generated in AGVortex program from vorticity flow with no-slip condition. In
Figure 1 there are presented vorticity and velocity of flows around rectangle and a line segment.
6. Discussion
Regarding the geometry of the exterior domain
in the current research its boundary consists of two connected components (including point at infinity). But presented approach can be extended to the case of more than two connected components, when the fluid flows through several solids. The relation on moments (
24) will include superposition of several Riemann mappings which are taken by the number of solids. If these solids are far apart from each other, then (
24) becomes an approximation of the no-slip condition for each object.
In exterior of the line segment the statement of the div-curl problem requires some explanation. In that case the line segment has "two sides" in some sense and no-slip condition must be imposed on both sides of it. It can be considered as a limiting case of ellipses which are divided into two parts and when its thickness goes to zero. The definition of the solution can be obtained via Riemann mapping of the div-curl problem into exterior of the disk, where we can correctly define the solution of the equation. Vorticity flow in In
Figure 1 (
c) breaks down into two parts with clock-wise rotation (red color) and counter clock-wise (blue color). These regions are separated by zero-vorticity line (
) which crosses through a line segment for reasons of symmetry.
Orthogonality relations can be extended to 3D domains. For example in case of the spherical solid they can be written using vector spherical harmonics. No-slip condition implies zero value of the curl’s normal component on the boundary when the rest tangent components of w must satisfy integral relations over exterior of the sphere.
7. Conclusions
Integral constraints (
24) imposed on vorticity function
w and divergence
give unique solvability of the exterior div-curl problem with no-slip boundary condition around solid. It can be solved numerically by reducing to Poisson problem. This approach can be extended to flows around several streamlined solids.
For solenoidal flows no-slip condition generates a series of integral constraints on vorticity (orthogonality relations). Under these restrictions the div-curl problem can be solved in correct formulation with more typical boundary conditions - slip condition combined with zero circulation. The source of vorticity data, which satisfies such integral constraints can be derived by solving any equations of motion written in vorticity form which describe fluid dynamics - Stokes, Navier-Stokes, Boussinesq equations. And the div-curl problem becomes one of the steps of the numerical procedure in the planar computational fluid dynamics.
References
- L. Quartapelle and F. Valz-Gris, Projection conditions on the vorticity in viscous incompressible flows. Internat. J. Numer. Methods Fluids, 1(2), 129–144, (1981).
- G. Auchmuty and J. C. Alexander, L2 well-posedness of planar div-curl systems. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal., 160, 91–134, (2001).
- M. Neudert and W. von Wahl, Asymptotic behaviour of the div-curl problem in exterior domains. Adv. Differ. Equ., 6(11), 1347–1376, (2001).
- B. B. Delgado and J. E. Macías-Díaz, An exterior Neumann boundary-value problem for the div-curl system and applications. Mathematics, 9, (2023).
- A. V. Gorshkov, On the unique solvability of the div-curl problem in unbounded domains and energy estimates of solutions. Theor. Math. Phys., 221, 1799–1812, (2024).
- A. V. Gorshkov, Associated Weber-Orr transform, Biot-Savart law and explicit form of the solution of 2D Stokes system in exterior of the disc. J. Math. Fluid Mech., 21(41), (2019).
- A. P. Calderón and A. Zygmund, On singular integrals. Amer. J. Math., 78(2), 289–309, (1956).
|
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2025 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).