Preprint
Article

This version is not peer-reviewed.

Tax Share Analysis and Prediction of Kernel Extreme Learning Machine Optimized by Vector Weighted Average Algorithm

A peer-reviewed article of this preprint also exists.

Submitted:

06 June 2025

Posted:

06 June 2025

You are already at the latest version

Abstract
In this paper, a kernel Extreme Learning Machine (KELM) model based on vector weighted average algorithm is proposed for the prediction of national tax revenue ratio, which provides a new way of thinking and method for tax revenue prediction. By analyzing the correlation between each index and tax share, it is found that gasoline price and life expectancy are significantly positively correlated with tax share, while fertility rate and birth rate are significantly negatively correlated. The model shows excellent predictive performance on both training set and test set, with an R² of 0.995 in training set and 0.994 in test set, indicating that the model has excellent generalization ability. In addition, the root mean square error (RMSE) of the training set and the test set are 0.185 and 0.177, respectively, and the relative prediction deviation (RPD) is 14.234 and 13.178, respectively, which further verifies the high accuracy and stability of the model. Scatter plots of actual predicted versus actual values show that the model is able to accurately capture trends in tax shares with little prediction error. In summary, the optimized KELM model proposed in this paper not only has excellent performance on known data, but also has good expansion ability, and can be effectively applied to the tax share prediction of unknown data, providing a reliable tool for relevant policy making and economic analysis. The research of this paper provides a new technical path for the field of tax forecasting, which has important theoretical significance and practical value.
Keywords: 
;  ;  

1. Introduction

The ratio of tax revenue to GDP is an important indicator of a country's fiscal health and economic structure. As the main source of government financial revenue, taxation directly affects the provision of public services, the construction of infrastructure and the distribution of social welfare [1]. With the global economic integration and the complexity of national economic structure, the design and optimization of tax policy has become an important issue faced by governments. Studying the tax-to-GDP ratio not only helps to understand the fiscal capacity of different countries, but also provides data support for policymakers to assess the fairness and efficiency of tax policies [2]. In addition, this study can also reveal the relationship between tax revenue and economic growth, income distribution, and social welfare, and provide references for tax reform on a global scale [3].
Machine learning algorithms have played an important role in the study of countries' tax as a percentage of GDP. Recent advances in machine learning have demonstrated strong cross-domain applicability, with successful implementations in areas such as healthcare risk modeling that offer methodological insights for economic and policy-related forecasting [4]. First of all, machine learning can process large-scale and multi-dimensional economic data, and identify key factors affecting the proportion of tax revenue through data mining technology [5], such as economic growth rate, industrial structure, population structure, etc. Second, machine learning models (such as regression analysis, decision trees, neural networks, etc.) can predict the impact of different tax policies on the proportion of GDP, helping policymakers model the effects of policies [6]. For example, through time series analysis and clustering algorithm, researchers can identify the similarities and differences of tax patterns in different countries, thus providing scientific basis for international comparison of tax policies [7]. In addition, machine learning can also analyze policy texts through natural language processing technology, extract key features of tax policies, and provide suggestions for policy optimization [8].
Tax research is of great strategic significance to the country. First of all, a reasonable tax policy can promote sustainable economic development [9]. By adjusting the tax ratio, the government can strike a balance between economic growth and social equity. Secondly, tax research helps to optimize resource allocation, improve the efficiency of financial funds, and thus improve the quality of public services. For example, by analyzing the ratio of tax revenue to GDP, the government can identify areas where the tax burden is too heavy or too light and adjust the structure of the tax system. In addition, tax research can enhance a country's international competitiveness, improve its tax system, attract foreign investment and promote international trade by learning from the successful experience of other countries [10]. In short, tax research is not only an important tool for financial management, but also a key support for achieving the long-term development goals of the country. In this paper, the kernel extreme learning machine algorithm is optimized based on vector weighted average algorithm, which provides a new idea and method for tax share prediction.

2. Data Set Sources and Data Analysis

We chose to experiment with a classic open source data set in the field of taxation, which has been extensively validated to verify the predictive power of machine learning algorithms. This dataset contains a number of annual economic indicators of many countries, such as population, unemployment rate, birth rate, higher education enrollment rate, urban population, latitude and more than a dozen other indicators, which can be used to analyze the correlation between various indicators and the tax proportion, and then use machine learning algorithms to predict the tax proportion [11]. This dataset is collected from 2023 and covers national tax data from all over the world, totaling 187 entries. Due to limited space, we select some indicators for presentation, and some open source data sets are shown in Table 1.
Pearson correlation analysis method is used to explore the indicators that have the greatest correlation with the tax revenue proportion, output the correlation coefficients of each indicator and the tax revenue proportion, and rank them. The ranking of correlation coefficients is shown in Figure 1.
According to the ranking of correlation coefficients, the index most positively correlated with the tax share is gasoline price, followed by life expectancy, and the index negatively correlated with the tax share is fertility rate, followed by birth rate.

3. Method

3.1. Vector Weighted Average Algorithm

Vector weighted average algorithm is a method to calculate the average vector by the weighted sum of multiple vectors [12]. The core idea is to assign a weight to each vector, and the weight reflects the importance or contribution of the vector in the whole. By weighted average, the information of multiple vectors can be synthesized to obtain a more representative result [13].
The advantage of vector-weighted average algorithm lies in its flexibility and interpretability. By adjusting the weights, you can control the contribution of different vectors to the final result, thus adapting to different task requirements. For example, in natural language processing, weighted averages can be used for the representation of sentences or documents to improve the accuracy of semantic representations by assigning higher weights to important words. In the recommendation system, weighted average can be used to integrate the characteristics of multiple users or items to generate more accurate recommendation results [14].

3.2. Nuclear Extreme Learning Machine

Kernel Extreme Learning Machine (KELM) is a machine learning algorithm based on ELM and kernel method. ELM is a single hidden layer feedforward neural network (SLFN), its core idea is to randomly initialize the weight and bias from the input layer to the hidden layer, and directly calculate the weight from the hidden layer to the output layer through the least square method. ELM is extremely fast to train because it avoids the time-consuming backpropagation process in traditionalneural networks. However, when ELM deals with nonlinear problems, the random initialization of hidden layer nodes may lead to unstable performance [15].
Kernel method can deal with nonlinear problems effectively by mapping data to high-dimensional feature space. Common kernel functions include radial basis function (RBF), polynomial kernel, etc [16]. KELM introduced the kernel method into the ELM framework to calculate the inner product in the high-dimensional feature space implicitly through the kernel function, thus avoiding the need for explicitly designing hidden layer nodes [17].

3.3. Vector Weighted Average Algorithm to Optimize the Kernel Extreme Learning Machine

Vector weighted average algorithm (VWA) is an ensemble learning method used to improve the performance of prediction models. When applied to the Kernel Extreme Learning Machine (KELM), the VWA generates the final prediction output by combining the predictions of multiple KELM models using a weighted average. The core idea of this method is to give different weights to different models and make full use of the advantages of each model to improve the accuracy and stability of the overall prediction [18].
In the VWA-KELM framework, you first need to train multiple KELM models. These models can be constructed with different kernel functions, parameter Settings, or subsets of data to increase the diversity of the model. Each KELM model makes an independent prediction of the input data and produces its own output. Next, the VWA algorithm assigns a weight to each model's prediction, which can be assigned based on the model's performance on the validation set, the model's confidence level, or other optimization strategies. Finally, the forecast results of all models are combined by a weighted average to generate the final forecast output [19]. This integrated approach can not only reduce the overfitting risk of a single model, but also effectively improve the generalization ability of the model.
The strength of VWA-KELM is its flexibility and robustness [20]. By introducing a weighted averaging mechanism, VWA-KELM is able to adaptively adjust the contributions of each model, thus showing greater stability in complex data distributions and noisy environments. In addition, VWA-KELM is computationally efficient because KELM itself trains and predicts faster, while the weighted average operation has a relatively small computational overhead [21].

4. Result

In terms of experimental parameter setting, the number of population is 20, the maximum number of iterations is 35, and the dimension of the optimization problem is 2, that is, C and S are optimized simultaneously. The lower and upper boundaries of the parameters are set to [1,1] and [50,50], respectively, and the objective function fobj calculates the fitness value by calling fun on the function handle. The final output of the best fitness value, the best parameter position and the fitness curve in the optimization process.
After the training, the scatterplot of the predicted value and actual value of the model on the training set is output, as shown in Figure 2. The scatterplot of the predicted value and actual value of the test set is output, as shown in Figure 3.
It can be seen from the predicted value and actual value scatter plots of the training set and the test set that the model can accurately predict the tax share, R2 of the training set is 0.995, R2 of the test set is 0.994, there is little difference between the R2 of the training set and the test set, indicating that the model has good generalization ability.
The scatter plot of the actual forecast results of the training concentration tax share is output, as shown in Figure 4. The scatter plot of the actual forecast results of the concentration tax share of the test is output, as shown in Figure 5.
According to the actual forecast results of the training set and the test set, it can be seen that this model can accurately predict the national tax share, and the error between the forecast value and the actual tax share is small. In addition, in terms of specific evaluation indicators, RMSE of training set is 0.185, RMSE of test set is 0.177, RPD of training set is 14.234, and RPD of test set is 13.178. The model shows good effect on test set, has good expansion ability, and can be applied to the prediction of tax share of unknown data.

5. Conclusions

In this paper, a new method of kernel extreme Learning machine (KELM) optimization based on vector weighted average algorithm is proposed and applied to tax revenue share prediction. By optimizing the regularization coefficient and kernel function parameters of KELM, the model can more accurately capture the complex relationship between the tax share and related indicators. The results show that the gasoline price is the most positively correlated index with the tax share, followed by the life expectancy; The fertility rate and birth rate showed a significant negative correlation with the tax share. These findings provide an important reference for understanding the factors affecting the tax share.
From the perspective of model performance, the scatterplot of the predicted and actual values of the training and test sets shows that the model can predict the tax share very accurately. The R² of the training set is 0.995, and the R² of the test set is 0.994. The difference between the two is very small, indicating that the model has excellent generalization ability and can adapt to unknown data well. In addition, the RMSE of the training set and the test set are 0.185 and 0.177, and the RPD of the test set are 14.234 and 13.178, respectively, which further verifies the high accuracy and stability of the model. These evaluation indicators show that the model not only performs well on the training data, but also shows strong predictive ability on the test data.
The method proposed in this paper not only performs well in tax share forecasting, but also provides a new way to solve similar economic index forecasting problems. By combining vector weighted average algorithm and kernel extreme learning machine, the model can deal with nonlinear relationship and high dimensional data effectively, and avoid overfitting problem. In the future, this method can be further extended to other economic and social fields to provide scientific support for policy making and decision analysis.
In short, the research in this paper not only provides an efficient and accurate model for the tax share forecast, but also provides an important methodological reference for the research in related fields, which has high theoretical value and practical application significance.
DiscussThe kernel extreme learning machine algorithm based on vector weighted average algorithm proposed in this paper performs well in tax revenue share prediction, with high prediction accuracy and good generalization ability. Through correlation coefficient analysis, we find that gasoline prices and life expectancy are significantly positively correlated with the tax share, while fertility and birth rates are negatively correlated. These findings provide a new perspective for understanding the factors affecting the tax share. The R2 values of the training set and the test set of the model are close to 1, and the RMSE and RPD indicators also show that the model has high accuracy and stability in predicting the tax share. This shows that the application of vector weighted average algorithm in the optimized kernel extreme learning machine algorithm is effective, and can better capture the complex relationship in the data, so as to achieve the accurate prediction of tax share.
In future studies, we will further explore and verify the applicability and robustness of this model in different economic environments and policy contexts. For example, consider introducing more macroeconomic indicators and socioeconomic variables to enhance the explanatory and predictive power of the model. In addition, the real-time updating and dynamic adjustment mechanism of the model is also an important direction of future research to adapt to the rapidly changing economic environment. At the same time, consider applying this model to the prediction of other economic indicators, such as GDP growth rate, unemployment rate, etc., to verify its wide applicability. Building upon methodological insights from prior work on machine learning bias and robustness in deception detection [22], this study demonstrates the potential for cross-domain adaptation of bias-aware model design in economic forecasting. Finally, the explainability and transparency of the model are also the focus of future research. By improving the explainability of the model, the policy making and decision-making process can be better supported.

References

  1. Köppl, Angela, and Margit Schratzenstaller. "Carbon taxation: A review of the empirical literature." Journal of Economic Surveys 37.4 (2023): 1353-1388.
  2. Piketty, Thomas, Emmanuel Saez, and Gabriel Zucman. "Rethinking capital and wealth taxation." Oxford Review of Economic Policy 39.3 (2023): 575-591.
  3. Jacob, Martin. "Real effects of corporate taxation: A review." European Accounting Review 31.1 (2022): 269-296.
  4. Yixin Zhang and Yisong Chen. "The Role of Machine Learning in Reducing Healthcare Costs: The Impact of Medication Adherence and Preventive Care on Hospitalization Expenses." arXiv preprint arXiv:2504.07422 [cs.LG], 2025.
  5. Guvenen, Fatih, et al. "Use it or lose it: Efficiency and redistributional effects of wealth taxation." The Quarterly Journal of Economics 138.2 (2023): 835-894.
  6. Delgado, Francisco J., Jaume Freire-González, and Maria J. Presno. "Environmental taxation in the European Union: Are there common trends?." Economic Analysis and Policy 73 (2022): 670-682.
  7. Avi-Yonah, Reuven, Young Ran Kim, and Karen Sam. "A new framework for digital taxation." Harv. Int'l LJ 63 (2022): 279.
  8. World Health Organization. WHO manual on sugar-sweetened beverage taxation policies to promote healthy diets. World Health Organization, 2022..
  9. Bachas, Pierre, et al. Globalization and factor income taxation. No. w29819. National Bureau of Economic Research, 2022.
  10. Abigail, Ekezie Chineze. "Unlocking Economic Growth Through Taxation in the case Nigeria." Journal of Business and Economic Options 6.4 (2023): 21-27.
  11. Andreyeva, Tatiana, et al. "Outcomes following taxation of sugar-sweetened beverages: a systematic review and meta-analysis." JAMA Network Open 5.6 (2022): e2215276-e2215276.
  12. Ahmad, Munir, and Elma Satrovic. "How do transportation-based environmental taxation and globalization contribute to ecological sustainability?." Ecological Informatics 74 (2023): 102009.
  13. Nchofoung, Tii N., Hervé Kaffo Fotio, and Clovis Wendji Miamo. "Green taxation and renewable energy technologies adoption: A global evidence." Renewable Energy Focus 44 (2023): 334-343.
  14. Dray, Sacha, Camille Landais, and Stefanie Stantcheva. Wealth and property taxation in the United States. No. w31080. National Bureau of Economic Research, 2023.Saez, Emmanuel, and Gabriel Zucman. "Wealth taxation: lessons from history and recent developments." AEA Papers and Proceedings. Vol. 112. 2014 Broadway, Suite 305, Nashville, TN 37203: American Economic Association, 2022.
  15. Ganghof, Steffen. The politics of income taxation: A comparative analysis. ecpr Press, 2024.
  16. Hebous, Shafik, and Michael Keen. "Pareto-improving minimum corporate taxation." Journal of Public Economics 225 (2023): 104952.
  17. Paul, Asim, et al. "A green inventory model with the effect of carbon taxation." Annals of Operations Research 309.1 (2022): 233-248.
  18. Paraje, Guillermo R., et al. "Taxation of tobacco, alcohol, and sugar-sweetened beverages: reviewing the evidence and dispelling the myths." BMJ Global Health 8.Suppl 8 (2023): e011866.
  19. Vishnevsky, V. P., et al. "The principles of taxation for digital economy." Terra Economicus 20.2 (2022): 59-71.
  20. Máté, Domicián, László Török, and Judit T. Kiss. "The impacts of energy supply and environmental taxation on carbon intensity." Technological and Economic Development of Economy 29.4 (2023): 1195-1215.
  21. Yunchong Liu , Xiaorui Shen, Yeyubei Zhang, Zhongyan Wang, Yexin Tian, Jianglai Dai, and Yuchen Cao. "A Systematic Review of Machine Learning Approaches for Detecting Deceptive Activities on Social Media: Methods, Challenges, and Biases." arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.20293 [cs.LG], 2025.
Figure 1. The ranking of correlation coefficients.
Figure 1. The ranking of correlation coefficients.
Preprints 162595 g001
Figure 2. The scatterplot of the predicted value and actual value of the model on the training set.
Figure 2. The scatterplot of the predicted value and actual value of the model on the training set.
Preprints 162595 g002
Figure 3. The scatterplot of the predicted value and actual value of the test set.
Figure 3. The scatterplot of the predicted value and actual value of the test set.
Preprints 162595 g003
Figure 4. The scatter plot of the actual forecast results of the training concentration tax share.
Figure 4. The scatter plot of the actual forecast results of the training concentration tax share.
Preprints 162595 g004
Figure 5. The scatter plot of the actual forecast results of the concentration tax share.
Figure 5. The scatter plot of the actual forecast results of the concentration tax share.
Preprints 162595 g005
Table 1. Partial data.
Table 1. Partial data.
Density (P/Km2) Agricultural Land( %) Birth Rate Calling Code Co2-Emissions CPI
60.00 0.58 32.49 93.00 8672.00 149.90
105.00 0.43 11.78 355.00 4536.00 119.05
18.00 0.17 24.28 213.00 150006.00 151.36
26.00 0.48 40.73 244.00 34693.00 261.73
17.00 0.54 17.02 54.00 201348.00 232.75
104.00 0.59 13.99 374.00 5156.00 129.18
3.00 0.48 12.60 61.00 375908.00 119.80
123.00 0.58 14.00 994.00 37620.00 156.32
39.00 0.01 13.97 1.00 1786.00 116.22
1265.00 0.71 18.18 880.00 84246.00 179.68
668.00 0.23 10.65 1.00 1276.00 134.09
383.00 0.45 10.30 32.00 96889.00 117.11
17.00 0.07 20.79 501.00 568.00 105.68
108.00 0.33 36.22 229.00 6476.00 110.71
20.00 0.14 17.26 975.00 1261.00 167.18
4.00 0.46 24.82 267.00 6340.00 149.75
25.00 0.34 13.92 55.00 462299.00 167.40
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.
Prerpints.org logo

Preprints.org is a free preprint server supported by MDPI in Basel, Switzerland.

Subscribe

Disclaimer

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy

Privacy Settings

© 2025 MDPI (Basel, Switzerland) unless otherwise stated