3.1. Characterization of materials
In this study, bimetallic MCM-41 ordered mesoporous molecular sieves MCM-41 with Ta/ Nb, Ta/V, Ta/Ti, Ta/Co were successfully prepared. The powder XRD diffractograms of Ta-MCM-41 and Ta/Me-MCM-41 samples obtained at low angle are depicted in
Figure 1. It can be seen a distinct and sharp peak (d100) along with weaker and broadening secondary peaks of the (110) and (200). For the samples with second metal near Ta into the MCM-41 structure, the intensity of the first peak decreases and the secondary peak declines or vanishes, indicating structural distortions caused by metal incorporation [
34].
The decrease more significant of the first peak intensity and its slight shift is observed for the samples with Ti and Co.
Table 1 also show the significant decreasing of the Ta/Me molar ratio for these samples. For the similar synthesis conditions in the case of samples with Nb and V this ratio is closer to 1, the value calculated for these syntheses. Additionally, high angle XRD patterns (
Figure S1) showed no characteristic peak regarding to crystalline metals (Nb, V, Ti, Co) species oxides only a broad peak at around 2θ = 23◦ which proof the presence of well dispersed amorphous species and silica support. TEM images of Ta-MCM-41 (
Figure 2a) and Ta/Me-MCM-41 (
Figure S2) samples indicate the presence of materials with ordered porous structure in a high percent with cylindrical pore channels conformed in a hexagonal array. In
Figure 2b, TEM image shows a spherical morphology for the majority of nanoparticles with dimensions close to 100 nm. Many of these nanoparticles are agglomerated to form spherical packages or of wire-like shapes.
SEM microscopy images for the obtained samples, illustrated in
Figure 3, confirm the spherical morphology of the agglomerated nanoparticles which may be completed for the bimetallic samples by the wire-like shapes.
The textural properties of the catalysts have been determined by the N
2 absorption–desorption isotherms of nitrogen.
Figure 4 show type IV nitrogen physisorption isotherms which general characteristic for mesoporous materials. The H1 hysteresis loop of isotherms is insignificant which indicates a narrow variation in pore size, except for the TaNb sample.
Table 2 presents the variation of the specific surface area, pore volume, and pore sizes of the obtained samples. These samples showed large surface area and pore size diameter similar to those reported for Me-modified MCM-41 mesoporous materials [
8,
9].
The insignificant changes in the pore diameter can be due to a very good dispersion of the metallic species into the silica mesoporous network and on the pore surface.
The Raman spectra of monometallic(Ta, Nb, V, Ti, Co)-MCM-41 samples (
Figure S3 and
Table S1 [
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41,
3542]) are dominated by the spectra features of the n-membered SiO
4 rings (where n is within 3-7) of the MCM-41 [
42,
35]. The 490 and 606 cm
-1 bands belong to the defect bands of the 4- and 3-membered SiO
4 rings. The Raman modes for the 4-membered SiO
4 rings are shifted towards lower wavenumbers at 481 cm
-1 under the vanadium influence [
37]. The distinct band at about 657 cm
-1 in the Ta-MCM-41 (Ta) spectrum belongs (
Figure 5) to the Ta-O-Ta (TaO
6) stretching mode in crystalline Ta
2O
5 [
38] which is the major tantalum phase.The 808 cm
-1 band is due to the symmetric stretching modes of the SiO
4 tetrahedra in the MCM-41 [
34].
The total or partial incorporation of metal oxides into the MCM-41 structure is depicted by the bands within the 900-1200 cm
-1 range in the Si-O stretching domain [
34,
35].Thus, the weak band of the polymerized TaO
x with TaO
4 coordination [
38] on the surface of the MCM-41 was noticeable by fitting the Ta spectrum at about 940 cm
-1 (see
Figure 5).Previous
29Si MAS NMR studies [
29] highlighted the incorporation of tantalum into the sol-gel obtained silica framework by (–O–Si)
3–Ta=O bonds due to modification of the Q
4/Q
3 ratio in comparison with the silica counterpart (Q
4 and Q
3 represent the SiO
4 tetrahedra with 0 and 1 Non-Bridging Oxygen atom, NBO). The V-MCM-41 spectra show a strong band at about 980 cm
-1, possibly due to the stretching of the SiO-H bonds [
42]. Since the SiO-H band within 3740-3750 cm
-1 (isolated hydroxyl groups on the MCM-41 support [
42]) is less intense than those of Me-MCM-41 spectra in
Figure S3b, the assignment of the 980 cm
-1 might consist of stretching vibrations Si-O-Si in SiO
4 tetrahedra [
43] with 2 or 1 NBOs, e.g. Q
2 and/ or Q
3 units [
44].The intense band at about 1100 cm
-1 in the Ti-MCM-41 spectrum indicates that the tetrahedrally coordinated titanium ion is in a flexible environment [
40] hence titanium incorporation into the MCM-41 structure by Si replacement in its sites. The more flexible environments the more shifted to the lower wavenumbers compared to the 1125 cm
-1 band position assignable to Si-O-Ti for the TS-1 [
40]. Raman spectroscopy is a useful technique for hydrogen bonding interactions between catalysts and water [
42]. Also, the presence of the isolated hydroxyl groups on the MCM-41 support is validated by the sharp band at about 3740 cm
-1 [
39]. The hydroxyl groups linked to the metal ions give weaker Raman modes at about 3600 cm
-1, namely the left-tailed shoulders of the SiO-H band [
42]. The small band at about 3610 cm
-1 (
Figure S3b) signals the presence of the Me-OH [
45,
46] and free water [
42].
The bimetallic Ta(V,Co,Nb,Ti) samples show spectral features within the 640-745 cm
-1 range in
Figure 6a unlike their (V,Nb,Ti)-MCM41 counterparts (
Figure S4,
Table 3 and
Table S1). Fitting of thepeak within 554-758 cm
-1 for the bimetallic TaTi spectrum revealed three components, namely 607, 616, and 685 cm
-1. The 616 cm
-1 band might be attributable to the A
1g modes of the extra-framework TiO
2 as rutile [
35]. The most intense band of the Ta-O stretching modes [
38] is noticeable at ~ 660 cm
-1 for the monometallic Ta-MCM-41 spectrum (
Table S1).
Very intense Raman bands of the bimetallic TaV spectrum in
Figure 6a are due to anearly resonant effect (UV-VIS absorptions at about 262 and 380 nm of MCM-41 framework and supported vanadium, respectively are presented further in UV-Vis spectra). Atrueresonant effect is expected for the TaCo sample due to its UV absorption at about 320 nm which is very close to the Raman excitation line of 325 nm. The most intense bands of the TaVsample are located at 488 cm
-1 and 1031 cm
-1. At higher vanadium content up to 2wt. %, the tetrahedral vanadate (SiO)
3V=O is responsible for the strong band at ~1031 cm
-1 [
36] while the spectral features of the V
2O
5 (530, 703, and 995 cm
-1) are missing from the spectrum. The very weak 920 cm
-1 of the V-O-V stretching modes indicates that the VO
x clusters are scarce [
36,
37]. Vibration modes of the tantalum speciation are diminished when compared with 1031 cm
-1 and 488 cm
-1bands (4-membered TO
4 units, where T stands for the tetrahedral coordinated Si or V). The shoulder at about 1060 cm
-1 might originate from the shorter V=O bonds [
47].The tinnySi-OH band at 3738 (
Table 3) for the TaVspectrum pointed out that the TaV sample is almost desiccated analogous to the V-MCM-41 sample. This is also supported by the lack of the ~970 cm
-1 band for Si-OH stretching vibrations in the TaVspectrum. The bimetallicTaNb spectrum has a wide band peaking-up at about 945 cm
-1 originating from the (Ta,Nb)-O-Si stretching [
38]. A less hygroscopic TaNb sample than its Nb-MCM-41 sample is observed in
Figure S4.
Table 3.
Peak position and assignments for the Ta and bimetallic Ta(Nb, T, Co, V) catalysts within 260-1200 cm-1 and 2600-4000 cm-1 ranges.
Table 3.
Peak position and assignments for the Ta and bimetallic Ta(Nb, T, Co, V) catalysts within 260-1200 cm-1 and 2600-4000 cm-1 ranges.
Peak position (cm-1) |
Assignments |
Ref. |
Ta |
TaNb |
TaTi |
TaCo |
TaV |
<650 cm-1 n-SiO4 rings |
34, 35 |
|
|
|
|
355 |
δ (O-V-O) |
36,37 |
360 |
348 |
375 |
362 |
|
5,6,7-SiO4 rings |
34 |
441 |
447 |
|
435 |
|
5,6,7-SiO4 rings and Eg modes of the extra-framework rutile (445 cm-1) |
34, 35 |
497 |
496 |
497 |
495 |
488 |
D1 modes (4- SiO4 rings), bending modes of the framework Ti-O-Si speciation |
34, 35 |
608 |
608 |
607 |
612 |
609 |
D2 modes (3- SiO4 rings) |
34 |
|
615 |
616 |
|
|
υ(Nb-O-Nb) polymerized Nb species (607-650 cm-1) and A1g modes in extra-framework rutile (612 cm-1) |
[48] and 35 |
660 |
|
685 |
670 |
|
υ(Ta-O) in TaO6 and Co3O4 (690 cm-1) |
38, 39 |
|
689 |
|
|
|
Nb2O5
|
48 |
|
|
|
707 |
|
|
|
|
801 |
798 |
796 |
|
υs modes of the siloxane bridges Si-O-Si |
34 |
828 |
|
|
830 |
|
νs modes of the siloxane bridges Si-O-Si |
34 |
958 |
|
945 |
|
|
υs (Si-O-Ti/Nb) |
41 |
980 |
978 |
985 |
973 |
|
υ (Si-OH), ν(Si-NBO) in Q2 units, υ(Nb=O) of isolated NbO4 and TaOx species (965-980 cm-1) |
34,44,48 and 18 |
|
|
|
|
1031 |
(SiO)3V=O stretching modes |
26 |
|
|
|
|
1060 |
Shorter V=O bonds |
47 |
1050 |
1056 |
|
1065 |
|
Q4 units in silica framework |
34,44 |
|
|
1097 |
|
|
υas (Si-O-Ti) with Ti4+
|
35 |
1185 |
|
1164 |
1187 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
>3500 cm-1 (hydroxyl stretching modes) |
|
3617 |
|
3602 |
3623 |
3547 |
Me-OH and free H2O |
41 |
3746 |
3744 |
3744 |
3744 |
3738 |
Isolated Si-OH in MCM-41 |
42 |
The pentavalent elements (Ta, Nb and V) were reported to form (O=Me
5+ OSi)
3OH)Si(OH)
2 and (O=Me
5+ (OSi)
3)Si(OH) [
49] in hydrated samples. However almost desicated TaV sample were obtained.
XPS was further utilized to analyze the chemical states of elements from the bimetallic materials (TaCo-MCM-41, TaV-MCM-41, TaTi-MCM-41, TaNb-MCM-41) surface. The wide survey spectra Ta/Me-MCM-41 samples showed that all the essential (O 1s, Si 2p, Co 2p, V 2p, Ti 2p, Nb 3d, Ta4f) could be detected (
Figure S5). Unfortunately, the intensity of the peak for Nb and Ta are very low. In addition, the peak of Ta4f is masked by that of O2p (
Figure 7) in condition of high content of oxygen and lower Ta very dispersed into silica support. The previous studies evidenced changes in coordination for the supported metal oxides of the Group V metals. Thus, the surface tantalum species possess TaO
4 coordination at low surface coverage and highly distorted TaO
5/TaO
6 coordination at intermediate and high surface coverage [
50].
The isolated surface TaO
4 species are present at low surface coverage and especially on the SiO
2 support. Also, on silica surface the maximum achievable density of Ta is much lower than on other oxide supports (~1 toward 5–6 Ta atom/nm
2). Thus, the molecular structures and densities of tantalum and niobium species on surface are very similar. For niobia supported on silica the density is less than 2 Nb atoms/nm
2 [
50]. These results can explain the very low intensity of XPS spectra for Ta and Nb.
Figure 7,
Figure S6 and
Figure 8 show significant differences between peaks intensity of the metals immobilized on silica under the conditions of similar Ta/Me molar ratio. These indicated the presence of isolated TaO
4 and NbO
4 species and Ta=O, Nb=O bonds in strong interaction with silica (
Table 3,
Figure 6). The spectra of metals associated with Ta are illustrated in
Figure 8, except Nb whose XPS spectrum (
Figure S6).
The use of Density Functional Theory (DFT) to investigate Ta oxides in various oxidation states was evidenced that stoichiometry and amorphous state change the Coulomb repulsion and hence the binding energies [
51]. The results showed a significant fraction of Ta atoms in all samples are under-coordinated state and the longer Ta–O distances in amorphous TaO
x leads to lower Coulomb repulsion and hence higher binding energies. These results can explain difficulty in analysis of XPS spectra both for Ta and the other oxide species incorporated into MCM-41 mesoporous silica by direct synthesis in lower quantity [
52,
53].
The analyzed spectra of Co 2p, V2p and Ti2p revealed the coexistence of different chemical states of each metal. Co 2p spectrum presents two main components and their satellites, at binding energies (BE) of 782.9 eV and 781.2 eV, attributed to 2+ and 3+ chemical states of cobalt from Co
3O
4. The spectrum of V 2p shows a main peak at around 516 eV and the presence of the satellite at ~523 eV attributed to V
2O
5. These results agree with others published results [
54] that evidenced two main different coordinated forms for the isolated vanadium species on support: tetrahedral V
5+ of type (VO
43-) and tetrahedrally coordinated vanadium sites ((SiO)
3V=O). XPS narrow scan of Ti 2p indicate that the valence state of Ti from TaTi-MCM-41 sample is Ti
4+ and Ta
0+ [
55,
56,
57]. Spectra of Nb3d from TaNb-MCM-41 sample (
Figure S6) can be attributed to Nb
2O
5 high dispersed into MCM-41 network. These results confirm the interaction of metals and their specific distribution on mesoporous silica support. The high-resolution spectra of O1s evidence (
Figure S7) the presence of main two kinds of chemical environments: lattice oxygen from silica with shifted binding energy at around 532 eV and oxygen vacancies or oxygen deficient regions from surface (~ 533 eV). XPS spectra of O1s show, for TaTi-MCM-41 sample, a peak at around 524 eV which indicates the presence on the surface of Me-O bonds that the more ionic than the Si-O bond [
58].
UV–Vis diffuse reflectance spectra of the synthesized samples are shown in
Figure 9. For all the samples it was noticed an absorption band at around 263 nm, associated with the charge transfer from oxygen ions of MCM-41 framework to the metal in tetrahedral coordination [
13].
Two other intense absorption bands were observed for TaNbMCM-41 and TaVMCM-41, located at around 318 nm and 380 nm, respectively. Their presence indicates the formation of crystalline Nb
2O
5 [
19], and V
2O
5 [
59] in the modified materials. TaVMCM-41 sample exhibited a very broad band between 250 and 550 nm, due to the charge transfer associated with V-O electron transfer for tetrahedrally coordinated V
5+ species. In the case of Ti modification, an intense band at 220 nm appears (TaTiMCM-41 sample). It corresponds to ligand-to-metal charge transfer (LMCT) from oxygen to tetracoordinated titanium in isolated tetrapodal (Ti(OSi)
4) or tripodal (such as, Ti(OH)(OSi)
3) units. The presence of this absorption band suggests the successful incorporation of Ti as isolated species into the silica structure. Furthermore, the shoulder located at higher wavelength (~270 nm) indicates the presence of higher coordinated Ti species (penta- or hexacoordinated) which could occur through hydration by binding water molecules as extra ligands [
60].
Modification of Ta-MCM-41 with the transition metals Co, Nb, V, and Ti by direct synthesis led to a redshift of absorption spectra in all cases. Thus, the synthesized materials became active under visible light irradiation by lowering the energy of the band gap considerably compared to the sample Ta-MCM-41, as shown in
Table 2.
The photoluminescence (PL) spectra (
Figure 10) were determined to evaluate the separation and recombination of the photogenerated charges in Ta-MCM-41 and Ta/Me-MCM-41 samples. The PL intensity is influenced by both surface defects and internal defects. All the spectra exhibit two emission peaks at around 425 nm and 490 nm. The highest intensity of both peaks was obtained for TaTi-MCM-41 spectra. The PL spectrum of this sample indicates a stronger activation but also a lower stability. The first peak was attributed to the band-to-band direct transitions. The intensity of this peak decreases in the following order Ta>TaNb>TaV>TaCo due to the higher electron-hole separation that gives long-lived photogenerated charge carriers [
61,
62].
At the same time, a shift to 400 nm can be observed and for the bimetallic samples. The second excitonic PL peak (490 nm) suggests that the samples contain high defects generated by metals incorporation. Surface defects refer primarily to the presence of metal ions dispersed on the silica surface and the incomplete coordination of surface species that induce oxygen vacancies. Thus, recombination centers for charge carriers are created. Also, the high dispersion of metal ions and the possibility of incorporating them into the silica network generate defects that act as donors or acceptors [
23,
63].
3.3. Photocatalytic Properties
Ta-based photocatalysts has also garnered considerable attention in photocatalytic applications due to their electronic structure and high chemical stability [
13,
16,
23,
65,
66]. Thus, the photocatalytic properties of tantalum-based mesoporous materials were tested in the oxidative degradation reaction of phenol (Ph) and methyl orange (MO). These organic compounds are the main representative for the common pollutant from waste water, as phenol and dyes, for which it is of particular interest [
67,
68,
69]. For a better understanding of the effect of Ta-MCM-41 modification with different 3d metals (Co, Nb, V) on photocatalytic properties, the valence band (VB) energy of each sample was estimated from the valence band (VB) XPS measurements (
Figure S8). The results revealed the VB maxima of 4.5 eV for the TaNbMCM-41 sample, very close to the VB potential of TaVMCM-41 (4.3 eV), 3.6 eV for TaCoMCM-41, and 2.8 for TaTiMCM-41. The conduction band (CB) potential of the synthesized materials was obtained using the following Equation (1):
where E
CB is CB potential, E
VB is VB potential, and E
g is band gap energy [
70,
71].
Based on the obtained values of the valence, conduction bands, band gape energy and redox potentials for generation of ∙O
2- and ∙OH oxidative radicals are presented in
Figure 13. It can observe that the CB energy level is higher than the normal redox potentials of O
2/∙O
2- for all the bimetallic samples except TaTi.
At the same time, VB energy level is more positive for all the samples than the H
2O/∙OH potential (+2.40 eV) which leads to the generation of the ∙OH radicals [
66]. Therefore, only for TaTi sample photogenerated e
- has been able to reduce O
2 to ∙O
2-. Hence, it means that only TaTi-MCM-41 sample is favorable for both oxidation and reduction reactions. These results were confirmed by the photocatalytic tests carried out for the degradation of methyl orange in aqueous solution.
Figure S9 shows a significant absorption of MO on the photocatalyst surface. However, under irradiation, the MO concentration decreases only in the case of the TaTi sample. In presence of H
2O
2 de efficiency of MO degradation increased significant for all the photocatalysts
Figure 14. A similar stability was evidenced for Fe
3O
4@SiO
2@ZnO composite in photodegradation of MO under UV [
72]. The significant increase in the MO photodegradation efficiency was achieved by adding H
2O
2. As an electron acceptor, H
2O
2 generated hydroxyl radicals (H
2O
2+e
-→OH
- +∙OH). Thus, the possibility of photogenerated e
-/h
+ recombination was reduced and the number of ∙OH radicals on the surface increased. Since in the case of the synthesized materials, excepting TaTi sample, the photogenerated electrons can not form ∙O
2- radicals with O
2, they can inhibit the photocatalytic reaction by recombining with the holes. For this reason, the photocatalytic reactions have been performed in the presence of H
2O
2.
In degradation of phenol the higher efficiency was obtained for TaTi and TaV samples (
Figure 14).
The mechanism proposed for these oxidation reactions with hydrogen peroxide marked formation of •OH with •O
2− species [
68]. The obtained results recommend the modified Ta-MCM-41 materials as catalysts for oxidation of organic compounds and confirm their possible application in photocatalytic reactions. Furthermore, the maximum degradation of MO and Ph was obtained for all the samples in the presence of H
2O
2. The degradation of these organic pollutants, at macro level, is most probably due to the synergistic effect of adsorption and photocatalytic oxidation, whereas at the micro level, the degradation is the result of a large number of hydroxyl radicals resulted in the presence of H
2O
2 and photocatalytic process.