1. Introduction
The rapid and widespread increase of obesity in the western world, starting from the 1980s onwards, marked the emergence of a global epidemic, which caused a rise of obesity-related diseases. In addition to cardiovascular disease, obesity has been linked to higher rates of certain cancers, including renal cell carcinoma, colorectal, oesophageal, endometrial and breast cancer [
1,
2]. In addition, recent data suggest an association with cervical and vulvar cancer, too [
3]. That is because apart from being the main repository of energy in form of triglycerides in the human body, adipose tissue has been recognized to bear important endocrine, metabolic, and inflammatory regulatory functions. One of the factors responsible for the endocrine actions are adipokines, peptide hormones secreted by the adipose tissue into the bloodstream [
4]. They provide information about satiety and energy status and influence many physiological processes like reproductive functions and immune response. Adipokines can functionally be divided into pro- and anti-inflammatory players. Expansion of adipose tissue induces a dominance of proinflammatory effects [
5]. Adipokine dysregulation is often linked to metabolic disorders, i.e. cardiovascular diseases, and other health conditions. However, in recent years it has become clear that adipokines also play a critical role in cancer development and progression [
6]. The first adipokine described in 1994 was leptin [
7] that, together with its functional “counterplayer” adiponectin, regulates energy balance by influencing appetite, satiety, and energy expenditure [
8,
9]. Furthermore, in cancer patients a low adiponectin to leptin ratio has been implemented as an indicator of tumour aggressiveness [
10].
In solid tissues, adipokines exert their effects in the target tissue via specific membrane-bound adipokine receptors that are most often ubiquitously expressed [
11,
12,
13,
14].
Adipokine binding activates a variety of pathways, such as mitogen-activated protein kinase, leading to cell growth, inflammation and angiogenesis in the case of leptin, and insulin secretion and fatty acid oxidation in the case of adiponectin. In cancer, leptin receptor activation has been associated with proliferation and invasion [
15], while adipoR1 has been shown to be overexpressed in both cancer tissue and cancer-associated immune cells, thereby modulating the anti-tumour immune response [
11].
For the purpose of this study, we chose to analyse the receptors of two well-characterised adipokines with opposing functions, leptinR and adipoR1, in order to understand their role as potential biomarkers in two types of cancer with an established relationship with obesity, as well as in two types of cancer with a probable relationship with obesity.
4. Discussion
In recent years, the global surge in obesity rates has emerged as a critical public health concern, transcending mere cosmetic implications [
24]. Beyond its well-established association with cardiovascular diseases and metabolic disorders, obesity has been identified as a significant risk factor for the development of various types of cancer, including renal cell carcinoma [
25,
26] (RCC), cervical cancer [
27], vulvar cancer [
28], and endometrial cancer [
29,
30]. The intricate interplay between adipose tissue, metabolic dysregulation, and chronic inflammation creates a microenvironment conducive to tumorigenesis that is, at least in part, influenced by adipokines [
31].
Adipokines, furthermore, play a crucial role in signalling of hunger and satiety. Differential expression of adipokines thereby have been linked to obesity and obesity related diseases. The by far best studied adipokine is leptin. Leptin serum levels are higher in obese individuals and have been associated with adverse outcomes in tumour patients meanwhile adiponectin acts in an opposite fashion [
32,
33]. In the present study, the expression of the adipokine receptors leptinR and adipoR1 was examined in detail in four tumour entities, that have been epidemiologically linked to obesity. We had hypothesized to find a differential expression of these receptors in these tumours in correspondence to the BMI. Data on leptin serum levels were not available for our patients, but as patients with a higher BMI, namely > 30, show statistically higher levels of leptin, we used the BMI as a surrogate parameter. However, in none of the cohorts analysed, BMI and receptor expression did not show any significant association neither for leptinR, nor for adipoR1. Further studies with more detailed serum data of the respective adipokines are warranted to detect more subtle associations.
Regarding our cohorts in detail, high expression of leptinR was associated with longer overall survival both for RCC as well as vulvar carcinoma. In addition, analysis of publicly available mRNA data supported the finding of leptinR presence being associated with longer survival in ccRCC. Our findings, supported by two large cohorts (Bonn cohort, TCGA) and different methodologies are different from previous analyses, that did not identify this prognostic value. In 2006, Horiguchi
et al. found no prognostic value of leptinR expression in RCC. Possibly, the small size of their cohort (n=57) precluded a meaningful survival analysis [
34]. Nevertheless, a significant association with clinicopathological parameters such as histologic type was found, which is in line with our data, showing a significant correlation between high leptinR expression and clear cell and papillary RCC. Perumal
et al. analysed a similarly sized cohort and also found no association of leptinR expression with survival in ccRCC [
35]. Although ccRCC has so far been best linked to be causally associated with obesity we found equally high leptinR in papillary RCC [
36]. However, the impact of obesity on tumour initiation and progression depends on cofactors and differs between sexes and histologic subtypes of tumours, e.g. the strongest association with obesity was seen in clear cell RCC (ccRCC) [
26,
37].
Endometrial cancer was one of the first tumours for which an association between obesity and tumour development became evident. Increasing BMI is associated with increased incidence and negative oncologic outcomes [
30]. Adipose tissue also synthesizes oestrogen and is the major source of oestrogen in postmenopausal women. Thus it is not surprising, that elevated oestrogen serum levels in obese women have been associated with the development of endometrial cancer [
29].
Zhang et al. showed that higher levels of both leptin and leptinR are associated with high BMI, invasion, metastasis, and poor prognosis [
38]. Conversely, leptinR expression was also significantly higher when tumour grades were low [
38]. Those somewhat contradictory results may, partly, be explained by the small size of the study cohort. Another study with a similarly sized cohort found leptinR overexpression to be correlated with higher grades, and elevated serum leptin levels with BMI and higher grades [
39]. In the present cohort, we could not confirm an association between leptinR in tumour tissue and BMI or show a prognostic impact but found that higher leptinR expression was correlated significantly with lower tumour grades. LeptinR mRNA expression in TCGA data did not show a significant impact on survival. As the majority of patients included in the study were > 60 years old (62%, mean 63, SD 12 years), and age and receptor expression were not associated, a possible confounder of endogenous ovarian oestrogen synthesis can be rejected [
29]. In addition, the effect of adipokines and steroids hormones does not appear to be mutually exclusive, as presence of progesterone was found to suppress leptinR mRNA expression, an interaction that may be subject to subsequent research activity [
40]. Clearly, larger studies are necessary to resolve these discrepancies.
Recently, obesity was suggested to have a negative prognostic impact in vulvar carcinoma [
28]. High BMI and metabolic syndrome were found to increase the risk of tumour development [
41]. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to show a significantly longer survival of patients with vulvar carcinoma with high leptinR expression. This is in line with the data obtained in RCC where high leptinR expression was significantly associated with longer overall survival, too. Unfortunately, it was not possible to prove the results obtained by immunohistochemistry in an independent cohort, as TCGA data did not provide sufficient information on vulvar carcinoma.
In squamous cell carcinomas of the gynaecologic tract, the influence of circulating oestrogen as well as obesity-related hormones and chemokines remains controversial as the impact of human papillomavirus infection is considered to be the most important causative agent. Out of these tumours, the most common is cervical cancer [
42]. Although not statistically significant, high leptinR expression showed a strong trend toward a favourable overall survival in patients with cervical squamous cell carcinoma. Additionally, there was a strong and statistically significant association with favourable clinicopathological parameters such as low FIGO stage and absence of lymph node metastasis. Yuan
et al. found worse differentiation and disease progression when leptin expression was high, so that one might hypothesize that an inverse relationship between leptin and leptinR exists [
43]. However, further research is needed to understand the differential regulation processes. To our knowledge, this is the first study to investigate the relevance of the leptinR in cervical squamous cell carcinoma.
Most cervical cancers, as well as a significant proportion of vulvar cancers are, at least in part, driven by high-risk human papillomavirus (HPV). Given the small number of HPV-negative cervical cancers in our cohort, any conclusions about HPV and leptinR correlations appear speculative. However, as with vulvar carcinoma, HPV-dependent tumours showed significantly lower expression of leptinR, raising the possibility of an interaction. Contrarily to immunohistochemical results, high leptinR mRNA expression in cervical cancer was associated with shorter overall survival. These contradicting results might show that leptinR expression and its regulation on mRNA and proteomic levels act different in this tumour entity or are influenced by other causative agents such as HPV infection. To clarify these opposing associations further investigations are needed.
For adipoR1, no prognostic value could be demonstrated in any of the analysed tumour entities neither immunohistochemically nor on mRNA level in TCGA data. Consistent with previous findings, we confirmed a continuous increase in adipoR1 expression with increasing BMI in all our gynaecologic cancer cohorts. In obese patients adipoR1 expression is reduced in adipose tissue and increased after weight loss. Thereby obese subjects aggravate negative metabolic effects of low serum level adiponectin [
44]. In RCC, adipoR1 expression was different depending on subtype with high levels in papillary RCC and low levels in ccRCC. Previously, it was found that patients with ccRCC had lower adiponectin serum levels, and hence the hormone level could be helpful to differentiate ccRCC from non-ccRCC in a non-invasive manner [
45]. Moreover, other factors such as insulin-like growth factor or fibroblast growth factor have different secretion rates in different RCC subtypes, so one could argue that differential receptor expression is plausible [
45]. In keeping with published data, adipoR1 expression was reduced in ccRCC [
46]. Additionally, Kleinmann
et al. demonstrated an underactivation of the entire adiponectin hormonal axis in ccRCC [
46]. In 2008 Pinthus
et al. showed that lower adiponectin levels were associated with tumour aggressiveness [
47]. However, the literature is contradictory: Ito
et al. postulated high levels of adiponectin were associated with tumour aggressiveness [
48]. Regarding this discrepancy, multiple factors were suggested which might affect circulating adiponectin levels, like diabetes, racial background and diurnal variation [
49,
50]. Secondly, it was pointed out that adipoR1 was not associated with survival which is consistent with our findings [
48]. An association between low serum adiponectin levels and the development of RCC and endometrial cancer has also been described [
51,
52].
Significant correlation of adipoR1 expression with lower FIGO stage but higher grades was found in cervical cancer. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to investigate adipoR1 expression in a large cervical cancer cohort. Previous
in vitro studies using HeLa cells showed that cells express adipoR1 and that adiponectin can induce apoptosis [
53]. Other tumours associated with obesity such as renal and colorectal cancer more frequently express adipoR1 than cervical squamous cell carcinoma, in which the role of obesity remains unclear [
54]. Possible factors that determine this uncertain role are reliability and noncompliance of screening test in obese patients [
55]. A pan-cancer analysis of a publicly available dataset identified adipoR1 upregulation as a risk factor for shorter disease-free survival in cervical cancer [
11]. One might hypothesize that lower levels of adiponectin, which acts as an oncoprotective hormone, could lead to higher expression of adipoR1. However, in the context of our results, we could not confirm an effect of adipoR1 expression on overall survival. Possible confounding factors in tumorigenesis and progression, such as HPV infection as mentioned above and decreased screening compliance with increasing body weight, need to be kept in mind [
55].
In both vulvar and endometrial cancers, none of the clinicopathological parameters examined nor the overall survival was significantly associated with the intensity of adipoR1 expression. In prior studies, a high BMI could be associated with shorter disease-free survival in vulvar cancer, suggesting an association with obesity [
28].
There is evidence that adiponectin is a potent inhibitor of cell growth in endometrial cancer [
56]. AdipoR1 expression is found in non-neoplastic as well as tumour tissues [
56]. In addition, Yamauchi
et al. demonstrated a strong association between decreased adipoR1/adipoR2 expression and tumour progression in terms of higher grading, growth, invasion, and metastasis [
57]. Somewhat contradictorily, we found an increase in adipoR1 expression for both tumour stage and lymph node metastasis as well as shorter survival, although most of our findings did not reach statistical significance.
Strengths of this study are the analysis of multiple tumour types and the careful in-depth statistical evaluation of the protein expression data including patient survival. Weaknesses are the descriptive nature of this analysis and the lack of serum adipokine data.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, G.K. and I.B.; methodology, G.K. and I.B.; software, I.B.; validation, G.K., M.B., and I.B.; formal analysis, I.B. and M.B.; investigation, I.B., F.W. and T.T.; resources, G.K., A.T., M.R., A.M., F.W., and T.T.; data curation, F.W., T.T., M.B., and I.B.; writing—original draft preparation, I.B.; writing—review and editing, G.K., M.B., and I.B.; visualization, G.K., M.B., and I.B.; supervision, G.K.; project administration, G.K., M.B., and I.B. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.