Preprint
Article

This version is not peer-reviewed.

The Least Surprising Theory: An Information-Theoretic Approach to the Unification of Physics

Submitted:

04 August 2026

Posted:

06 August 2026

Read the latest preprint version here

Abstract
We propose \emph{least surprisal} as a variational principle for recovering physical laws by inference. Just as least action selects a history given a Lagrangian, least surprisal selects the Lagrangian given a \emph{displacement} from a \emph{reference}. Given \(\psi\), a covariant exterior derivative \(\mathbb D\) with curvature \(\mathbb D^2\) and Clifford contraction \(D\), we form displacement and reference jets: \(\mathfrak J_\epsilon\psi:=\bigl(\psi+i\epsilon D\psi,\ \sqrt\epsilon\,\mathbb D^2\bigr),\mathfrak J_r\psi:=\bigl(\psi, 0 \bigr), (1)\) We then calculate the surprisal between them, a complex-valued transition amplitude: \(\mathcal K( \mathfrak J_\epsilon \psi, \mathfrak J_r \psi):=-\ln\frac{\langle \mathfrak J_\epsilon \psi \mid \mathfrak J_r \psi \rangle_\mathfrak J} {\sqrt{\langle \mathfrak J_\epsilon \psi \mid \mathfrak J_\epsilon \psi \rangle _\mathfrak J \, \langle \mathfrak J_r \psi \mid \mathfrak J_r \psi \rangle _\mathfrak J}} . (2) \) Accumulation of surprisal captures the first order, \(\lim_{\epsilon\to0}\frac{1}{\epsilon} \mathcal K\bigl(\mathfrak J_\epsilon\psi,\mathfrak J_r\psi\bigr) =-i\int_X\dd^dx\,\sqrt{|g|} \left[\operatorname{Re}\braket{\psi}{D\psi}_x -\frac{1 {4}\operatorname{tr}\bigl(F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu}\bigr)\right], (3)\)which is the action. The least surprising displacement of \(\psi\) is therefore given by the Dirac equation along with the quadratic Yang--Mills term. Our main result introduces the \emph{intrinsic carrier}: an amplitude that uses only (and all of) the structures spacetime supplies of itself. It is parametrized over the pointwise metric bundle as \(\Psi=\Psi(x,g_x)\), and valued in\(\Cl^+(T_xX,g_x)\otimes\Sigma\bigl(\Sym^2(T_x^*X),G_{g_x}\bigr), (4)\) with \(G_{g_x}\) the DeWitt form on metric variations. In Lorentzian \(3+1\) spacetime, surprisal reduces the fibre symmetry from \(\Spin(6,4)\) to $U(3)\times U(2)$, whose Lie algebra is that of the Standard Model gauge group enlarged by one abelian factor \(U(1)_X\). On the gravity side, surprisal furnishes \(\Lambda\), \(R\), \(R^2\), and \(C_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}C^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\) to the action, yielding perturbatively renormalizable quadratic gravity. Its familiar negative-norm objection to probability measurements is addressed in Section~\ref{sec:measurement} by an intensity-positive measurement theory. Thus, \emph{the least surprising theory spacetime supplies of itself} accumulates to perturbatively renormalizable and intensity-measurable gravity coupled to the (\(U(1)_X\) enlarged) Standard Model---a unified matter-gravity theory.
Keywords: 

1. Introduction

1.1. Physics from Inference

Jaynes [31] observed that statistical mechanics need not be derived from mechanics at all. Extremizing the Shannon entropy
S [ p ] = − ∑ i p i ln p i subject to ∑ i p i f k ( i ) = 〈 f k 〉
returns the Gibbs distribution,
p i ∝ exp − ∑ k λ k f k ( i ) ,
the multipliers λ k being fixed by the constraints. No ergodic hypothesis is required and nothing is assumed about the underlying dynamics; thermodynamics on this reading is a rule of inference rather than a physical law.
The reframing was more ambitious than a rederivation. If one part of physics is inference under constraint, the rest may be as well, and the laws would then not be brute facts but the least biased account of nature available given what is held fixed. We shall call this the inferential programme. The present work belongs to it and claims to complete it; the two subsections that follow set out what has been achieved within it and why it has not been completed before.
Paths. Jaynes extended the construction from states to histories. In place of a distribution over configurations one seeks a distribution over trajectories, extremizing the path entropy—the caliber—subject to constraints on path functionals F k [ x ] . The output has the same form as (6),
p [ x ( t ) ] ∝ exp − ∑ k λ k F k [ x ] ,
from which follow diffusion, the fluctuation theorems and Onsager reciprocity; Pressé et al. [42] survey the construction and its applications.
Updates. A further refinement takes the object of inference to be not a distribution but the revision of one. Given a reference ρ , the least biased update is measured by the relative entropy, and for nearby distributions
D ρ + δ ρ ∥ ρ = 1 2 ∫ ( δ ρ ) 2 ρ + O δ ρ 3 ,
whose leading term is the Fisher–Rao metric. Its appearance is not a modelling choice: by Čencov’s theorem it is, up to normalization, the unique Riemannian metric on the probability simplex monotone under stochastic maps [2,17].
Quantum mechanics. That line reached its high point in the recovery of the Schrödinger equation [30,44]. A classical ensemble is described by a density ρ and a Hamilton–Jacobi action S, with ensemble Hamiltonian
H cl [ ρ , S ] = ∫ d 3 x ρ | ∇ S | 2 2 m + V ,
whose stationary points are the continuity and Hamilton–Jacobi equations. Adding the Fisher information of the density,
H [ ρ , S ] = H cl [ ρ , S ] + λ ∫ d 3 x | ∇ ρ | 2 ρ , λ = ℏ 2 8 m ,
and writing ψ = ρ e i S / ℏ , the two stationarity conditions become the real and imaginary parts of
i ℏ ∂ t ψ = − ℏ 2 2 m ∇ 2 + V ψ .
The Fisher term contributes exactly the quantum potential − ℏ 2 2 m ∇ 2 ρ / ρ ; the remainder of (11) comes from (9). The Schrödinger equation as a statement about inference rather than a postulate about nature is a genuine success of the programme.
Everything else. Frieden [26] carried the idea furthest. In the principle of extreme physical information a measurement is a transfer of information from source to observer, and the equations of physics are the extrema of I − J , with I the Fisher information of the observed data and J the bound information of the source. With appropriate choices of J the principle returns the Klein–Gordon, Maxwell and Einstein equations and the Boltzmann distribution.

1.2. Why Each Fell Short

Under the goal of completing the programme, the sequence above is a sequence of repairs, and each repair leaves something undone.
Maximum entropy assigns a distribution at an instant. It says nothing about evolution, and (6) contains no time. Maximum caliber answers this, replacing distributions over states by distributions over histories.
Maximum caliber therefore delivers dynamics, but (7) is real and positive, and real positive weights do not interfere. What it delivers is stochastic—diffusion and its relatives—and the passage to quantum dynamics still needs β → i τ ; that is, it introduces complex amplitudes by fiat. Replacing the entropy by the Fisher information answers this: (11) is quantum, and no rotation was performed to obtain it.
The Fisher route at first appears promising but falls short for two reasons. The first is structural. A divergence vanishes and is stationary where its arguments agree, so (8) has no first-order term and its leading content is the quadratic form; such a principle can supply a metric and nothing else. A metric is a second-order kinetic term, and in (10) that is precisely what it is—the quantum potential, the term of order ℏ 2 —while the kinetic and potential energies are imported with H cl . Second order is moreover the wrong order for fundamental matter. The Dirac Lagrangian ψ ¯ i γ μ ∂ μ ψ is linear in the derivative, and it is that linearity which carries the conserved current ψ ¯ γ μ ψ and its positive density; no functional stationary at coincidence produces a term linear in the displacement. Extreme physical information is no counterexample: its extremization returns the Klein–Gordon equation, second order as expected, and Dirac’s equation follows only on factorizing that output—the step Dirac [23] took in 1928, performed on the result rather than derived from the principle.
The second reason is methodological. Streater [49] observes that the bound information J is chosen so that the extremum of I − J is the equation sought, and that as the target theory becomes more structured more of the content sits in J than in the informational term. The breadth of the principle’s reach is bought at the cost of its discriminating power. The program is circular rather than foundational.

1.3. Surprisal

At minimum what is wanted, then, is an informational quantity whose expansion about coincidence has a first-order term. There is one, and it is the oldest: the surprisal − ln p of a single event.
Surprisal requires no sum, and so needs no ensemble. Applied to a local update, however, it requires both a displacement and a reference against which that displacement is compared. Where maximum entropy delivers the least biased distribution given constraints, least surprisal delivers the least surprising theory given a displacement from a reference. The two stand in the same relation to their inputs.
The decisive step is to attach surprisal to the normalized complex comparison of a displacement jet and a reference jet. The construction is given in Definitions 1.1–1.3 below, and the comparison to make is with (8). Infinitesimally,
D ρ + δ ρ ∥ ρ = 1 2 ∫ ( δ ρ ) 2 ρ + … ︸ Least biased update vs . K J ϵ ψ , J r ψ = − i ϵ 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 + s F 2 D 2 − F 0 2 + … ︸ Least surprising update .
Both quantities measure the informational cost of an infinitesimal update relative to a reference. Relative entropy is real and begins at second order. The state displacement in the jet comparison has a first-order term, which is imaginary and oriented: it changes sign when the displacement is reversed, as a divergence between probability distributions cannot. The curvature comparison is intrinsically quadratic, but its ϵ scaling makes it contribute at the same accumulated order, while the signature-dependent complex jet pairing places it in the same action phase.
This is precisely the local form required of a Lagrangian. An infinitesimal history segment with real Lagrangian density L has transition weight
A ϵ = e i ϵ L ,
whose transition surprisal, on the continuous local logarithm branch, is
− ln A ϵ = − ln e i ϵ L = − i ϵ L .
Comparison with (12) therefore identifies
L = Re 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 + s F 2 D 2 − F 0 2 .
The least-surprising update thus has exactly the form of the surprisal of a local action amplitude. Dividing by ϵ and accumulating over spacetime gives
I = − i S , S = ∫ X d d x | g | L , e − I = e i S .
This first-order structure is of the order that fundamental matter requires. For the displacement ψ ↦ ψ + i ϵ D ψ , its coefficient is 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 , linear in the transport, and Section 2.1 exhibits it as the Dirac Lagrangian. The curvature slot contributes the quadratic comparison 1 2 ∥ D 2 − F 0 ∥ 2 . Accumulation removes all higher powers of ϵ and retains these two terms as the local Lagrangian. Nothing need be imported alongside them: kinetic terms, potentials and curvature terms arise from the transport, reference and invariant pairings of the jets, so there is no analogue of a supplementary source J chosen to reproduce a predetermined equation.
No subsequent continuation β → i τ is required. The signature-dependent phase of the curvature contribution is already encoded in the complex jet comparison. Exponentiating the accumulated surprisal therefore returns the history weight e i S , because the least-surprising update is locally the negative logarithm of e i ϵ L .
Our claim is accordingly that the inferential programme was right but the functionals considered were wrong for dynamics recovery. Not entropy, relative entropy or Fisher information, but the surprisal of a displacement jet compared against a reference jet. In other words, the universe does not evolve according to the least biased update; it evolves according to the least surprising update.

1.4. The Procedure

The construction has three ingredients: a transition surprisal; a jet, which collects the local data an amplitude makes available to comparison; and a reference, against which that data is compared. Fixing these fixes a theory, in the strong sense that its Lagrangian is computed rather than posited. The claim is best stated as a variational principle one order above the familiar one:
Least action selects the trajectory, given a Lagrangian. Least surprisal selects the Lagrangian, given a displacement from a reference.
Stationarity of the action operates on configuration space and presupposes the functional whose stationary points it seeks. The present principle operates on theory space: the output is the functional. Least action is recovered downstream and acquires an interpretation it does not otherwise possess: since e − K is the transition amplitude and amplitudes compose multiplicatively, the weight of a history is e − I , which by Definition 1.5 is e i S (Remark 1.6). Extremizing an action is extremizing a surprisal, and a system follows the least surprising path available to it.
Because surprisal carries no absolute value, a theory built on it is a declaration of what counts as unsurprising, and the declaration is made by the reference. Vacuum declares flatness; the instanton declares self-duality; gravity declares constant curvature; the Higgs declares a nonvanishing vacuum value. Each theory is its own null hypothesis, and what it calls dynamics is the residual. Section 2 exhibits this directly: one kernel, one jet, five references and five computed Lagrangians already known by other means.

1.5. The Ansatz

Ordinarily, a carrier is chosen to realize a Lagrangian already given: the theory determines which fields, representations and internal spaces must be supplied. Accumulated surprisal permits the reverse direction. Given the displacement of a carrier from a reference, it returns the least-surprising Lagrangian available to them.
We call a carrier intrinsic when its amplitude and parametrization uses only (and all of) the structures a geometry supplies of itself. A metric-space supplies a simple candidate: its local geometric configurations are the pairs ( x , g x ) ∈ M p , q ( X ) . At each such pair, g x determines the spacetime Clifford algebra. Taking g x as a parameter also supplies T g x M p , q , x ( X ) ≅ Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , together with its DeWitt form G g x and spin module Σ ( Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , G g x ) . We therefore make the Ansatz
Ψ = Ψ ( x , g x ) , Ψ ( x , g x ) ∈ Cl + ( T x X , g x ) ⊗ Σ Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , G g x .
The first factor is the spacetime-algebra amplitude and the second is the spin carrier associated with the local metric parameter space. No independent internal vector space or gauge group is introduced.
The consequences of this Ansatz constitute the main result. Since the carrier is intrinsic, the surprisal produces the least surprising theory spacetime supplies of itself. Theorems 3.6 and 3.8 determine the arena on which the carrier has the current and interference structures required by accumulated surprisal; the subsequent results determine its symmetry, representations and dynamics. The unique surviving arena is Lorentzian 3 + 1 spacetime. On it, the least-surprising action of the intrinsic carrier is the Standard Model, enlarged by one abelian factor U ( 1 ) X , coupled to quadratic gravity:
S = ∫ X d 4 x − g [ a C μ ν ρ σ C μ ν ρ σ + b R 2 + c E 4 + M P 2 2 R − Λ − 1 4 g 3 2 G μ ν A G A μ ν − 1 4 g 2 2 W μ ν I W I μ ν − 1 4 g 1 2 B μ ν B μ ν − 1 4 g X 2 X μ ν X μ ν − χ 2 g 1 g X B μ ν X μ ν + ∑ f ψ ¯ f i γ μ D μ SM + X ψ f − D μ SM + X H † D μ , SM + X H − ξ R H † H − m H 2 H † H − λ H ( H † H ) 2 − y u Q ¯ L H ˜ u R + y d Q ¯ L H d R + y e L ¯ L H e R + y ν L ¯ L H ˜ ν R + h . c . ] .
Here H ˜ = i σ 2 H * . While U ( 1 ) X remains unbroken, the right-handed neutrino is charged under it and a constant Majorana mass is not gauge invariant. This result is stated only to identify the destination; the dimension, symmetry, representations and operator sectors entering (18) are derived in Section 3.

1.6. Conventions and Definitions

Throughout, ℏ = 1 . Unless stated otherwise, the signature is ( − , + , + , + ) , and the state pairing 〈 · ∣ · 〉 is antilinear in its first argument.
To construct a Lagrangian from surprisal, we require a local complex comparison between a displaced amplitude and a reference. The parametrization of the amplitude supplies two forms of local data: its first-order transport and the curvature of that transport. We collect these data into jets and define transition surprisal directly from their normalized complex comparison.
Two operators built from the same connection must therefore be distinguished. The covariant exterior derivative D has curvature D 2 , while its contraction D is a first-order operator on the carrier, typically Clifford. They are not independent: D and D 2 are respectively the contracted transport and curvature supplied by the same connection.
Definition 1.1 
(Jets). Let ψ ∈ H , let D be a covariant transport with curvature D 2 and contraction D, let ϵ > 0 , and let F 0 be a curvature-valuedreference. Thedisplacementandreferencejets of ψ are
J ϵ ψ : = ψ + i ϵ D ψ , ϵ D 2 , J r ψ : = ψ , ϵ F 0 ,
the first slot of the displacement jet being the infinitesimal unitary transport generated by D, and the reference jet supplying the state against which the displaced jet is compared.
Definition 1.2 
(Complex jet pairing). For U = ( u 1 , u 2 ) and V = ( v 1 , v 2 ) in the jet carrier H J = H ⊕ H F , define thecomplex jet pairing
〈 U ∣ V 〉 J : = w 1 〈 u 1 ∣ v 1 〉 + w 2 〈 u 2 ∣ v 2 〉 , w 2 w 1 = − i s F , s F = − 1 Lorentzian , + 1 Euclidean ,
the slots being mutually orthogonal. Because their relative weight is imaginary, the resulting jet pairing is generally a complex comparison form rather than a Hermitian inner product. The form of the complex jet pairing was selected so that the surprisal is a real projection of the jet comparison.
Definition 1.3 
(Transition surprisal). Let U , V ∈ H J be jets for which the following comparison is nonzero and continuously connected to coincidence. Thetransition surprisalfrom V to U is the negative local logarithm of their normalized complex jet comparison,
K ( U , V ) : = − ln 〈 V ∣ U 〉 J 〈 V ∣ V 〉 J 〈 U ∣ U 〉 J ,
where the square root and logarithm are chosen by continuous local continuation from coincidence, with K ( V , V ) = 0 .
Proposition 1.4 
(Expansion of the jet surprisal). Let the jets be those of Definition 1.1, with normalized amplitude 〈 ψ ∣ ψ 〉 = 1 , and let the relative curvature-slot weight be
σ = − i s F , s F ∈ { + 1 , − 1 } .
If D is formally Hermitian and the curvature pairing is real and symmetric, then
K J ϵ ψ , J r ψ = − i ϵ 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 + s F 2 D 2 − F 0 2 + O ( ϵ 2 ) ,
and the coefficient in brackets is real.
Proof. 
Write
a : = 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 ∈ R , b : = ∥ D ψ ∥ 2 ,
c : = F 0 | D 2 ∈ R , d : = ∥ D 2 ∥ 2 , f : = ∥ F 0 ∥ 2 .
The three pairings entering the normalized jet comparison are computed separately. First, the cross pairing is
J r ψ | J ϵ ψ J = w 1 〈 ψ ∣ ψ + i ϵ D ψ 〉 + σ ϵ F 0 | D 2
= w 1 1 + i ϵ a + σ ϵ c .
The reference self-pairing is
J r ψ | J r ψ J = w 1 〈 ψ ∣ ψ 〉 + σ ϵ ∥ F 0 ∥ 2
= w 1 1 + σ ϵ f .
Finally, the displaced self-pairing is
J ϵ ψ | J ϵ ψ J = w 1 〈 ψ + i ϵ D ψ ∣ ψ + i ϵ D ψ 〉 + σ ϵ ∥ D 2 ∥ 2
= w 1 1 + i ϵ 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 − i ϵ 〈 D ψ ∣ ψ 〉 + ϵ 2 ∥ D ψ ∥ 2 + σ ϵ d
= w 1 1 + ϵ 2 b + σ ϵ d ,
where the two terms linear in ϵ cancel because D is formally Hermitian and hence
〈 D ψ ∣ ψ 〉 = 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 = a .
By Definition 1.3, the surprisal of the normalized jet comparison is
K = − ln J r ψ | J ϵ ψ J
+ 1 2 ln J r ψ | J r ψ J + 1 2 ln J ϵ ψ | J ϵ ψ J .
Substituting (27)–(32), the constant normalization cancels:
− ln w 1 + 1 2 ln w 1 + 1 2 ln w 1 = 0 .
Using
ln ( 1 + z ) = z − 1 2 z 2 + O ( z 3 ) ,
the three remaining logarithms give
− ln 1 + i ϵ a + σ ϵ c = − i ϵ a − σ ϵ c + ϵ 2 2 ( i a + σ c ) 2 + O ( ϵ 3 ) ,
1 2 ln 1 + σ ϵ f = σ ϵ 2 f − σ 2 ϵ 2 4 f 2 + O ( ϵ 3 ) ,
1 2 ln 1 + σ ϵ d + ϵ 2 b = σ ϵ 2 d + ϵ 2 2 b − σ 2 ϵ 2 4 d 2 + O ( ϵ 3 ) .
Collecting the first-order terms yields
K = − i ϵ a + σ ϵ 1 2 d − c + 1 2 f + O ( ϵ 2 )
= − i ϵ a + σ ϵ 2 d + f − 2 c + O ( ϵ 2 ) .
Since the curvature pairing is real and symmetric,
d + f − 2 c = D 2 − F 0 2 ,
and therefore
K = − i ϵ a + σ ϵ 2 D 2 − F 0 2 + O ( ϵ 2 ) .
Substituting σ = − i s F and restoring a = 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 gives (23).
Both terms in brackets are real. The displacement term is necessarily proportional to − i , so the curvature contribution shares the same phase precisely when its relative weight is imaginary. Its real magnitude is absorbed into the invariant curvature pairing, while the signature convention gives σ = − i s F in the normalization used here. □
Definition 1.5 
(Surprisal accumulation). Theaccumulated surprisalof the displacement jet relative to the reference jet is
Preprints 226801 i001
where, by Proposition 1.4 and the L 2 comparison of the carrier,
L = Re 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 x + s F 2 D 2 − F 0 x 2
is real. The accumulated surprisal is imaginary and S is the action it carries; the constant factor is immaterial to stationarity. The ϵ weighting of the curvature slot renders both slots of order ϵ, so a single division suffices and every higher power is removed by the limit. Stationary points at fixed norm are the equations of motion.
Remark 1.6 
(The exponentiated surprisal is the weight of a history). Since e − K is the normalized jet transition kernel, the weight associated with a fixed discretized history is the product of its infinitesimal kernels; the full propagator is obtained by integrating this product over intermediate configurations. Along a history divided into N steps with N ϵ = T held fixed, Proposition 1.4 gives
∏ k e − K k ⟶ e − I = e i S .
No subsequent analytic continuation of the resulting action is required: the signature-dependent phase of the curvature contribution is already encoded in the complex jet pairing.

2. Calibration

A procedure that claims to output the form of a new unified matter-gravity law must first be shown to output the laws already known. The five subsections that follow are therefore not illustrations but calibration: in each, the same kernel is applied to the same pair of jets, only the reference changing, and the output is compared with a Lagrangian established independently by other means. The sequence is the Dirac equation, the Dirac–Yang–Mills action together with its source current, the Bogomolny bound, quadratic gravity with an Einstein–Hilbert and a cosmological term, and the Friedmann equations. Each is an application of Proposition 1.4, which supplies the first-order coefficient in closed form; what changes from one to the next is the carrier, the transport and the reference.
Two features of the instrument are visible in advance. First, the first-order coefficient is quadratic in the curvature slot, and curvature has mass dimension two, so a comparison of curvatures produces operators of mass dimension four—which in four dimensions is precisely the power-counting-renormalizable ceiling. The procedure cannot emit a dimension-six operator, and it cannot emit the Einstein–Hilbert term alone: unrenormalizable gravity is outside its range. Second, a nonvanishing reference reaches below dimension four, to the dimension-two and dimension-zero terms M P 2 R and Λ , and this is where the dimensionful content of physics resides. The calibration is arranged to occupy first the displacement slot, then the curvature slot, then the reference.

2.1. Dirac

Let X be flat, let ψ ∈ H be an amplitude, let D = i γ μ ∂ μ − m be the distinguished transport operator on H , formally Hermitian, and let ϵ > 0 . Since X is flat and no gauge field is present, D 2 = 0 , and the curvature slot is empty. The relevant jets are
J ϵ ψ = ψ + i ϵ D ψ , ϵ D 2 , J r ψ = ψ , 0 .
By Proposition 1.4, with D 2 = F 0 = 0 ,
K J ϵ ψ , J r ψ = − i ϵ Re 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 + O ( ϵ 2 ) ,
so that, on accumulating we find
Preprints 226801 i002
the Dirac action.

2.2. Dirac–Yang–Mills

Let X be flat, let ψ ∈ H be an amplitude, and let
D = d + A , D μ = ∂ μ − i g A μ , D 2 = F = d A + A ∧ A
be a covariant exterior derivative with Hermitian generators normalized by tr ( T a T b ) = δ a b . Let D = i γ μ D μ − m be its Clifford contraction and the distinguished transport operator on H . Unlike the previous example, the curvature slot is now occupied, D 2 = F ≠ 0 , while the reference remains flat. The relevant jets are
J ϵ ψ = ψ + i ϵ D ψ , ϵ D 2 , J r ψ = ψ , 0 .
By Proposition 1.4, with F 0 = 0 , s F = − 1 , and the two-form norm
〈 F ∣ F 〉 x = 1 2 tr F μ ν F μ ν ,
one has
K J ϵ ψ , J r ψ = − i ϵ Re 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 − 1 4 tr F μ ν F μ ν + O ( ϵ 2 ) .
Both terms are of order ϵ , which is the purpose of the ϵ weighting: a single accumulation serves both slots. Accumulating yields
S = ∫ X d 4 x | g | ψ ¯ i γ μ D μ − m ψ − 1 4 tr F μ ν F μ ν ,
the Dirac–Yang–Mills action.

2.3. Instantons

Nothing requires the curvature slot to be compared against flatness. Let X be a Euclidean four-manifold, so that ★ 2 = + 1 on two-forms and consequently ∥ ★ F ∥   =   ∥ F ∥ . Let the curvature slot carry the Euclidean weight s F = + 1 rather than the Lorentzian − 1 , so that the accumulated surprisal carries the Euclidean action. Let D = d + A with D 2 = F as before. Comparing the curvature against its own Hodge dual, the relevant jets are
J ϵ ψ = ψ , ϵ D 2 , J ★ ψ = ψ , ϵ ★ D 2 .
The displacement slot is common to both jets and therefore inert; this calibration concerns the geometry alone. By Proposition 1.4, with D = 0 and F 0 = ★ F ,
K J ϵ ψ , J ★ ψ = − i ϵ 1 2 F − ★ F 2 + O ( ϵ 2 ) ,
and, on accumulating,
S ★ = 1 2 F − ★ F 2 = ∥ F ∥ 2 − ★ F | F ≥ 0
= 2 S YM − ★ F | F , S YM : = 1 2 ∥ F ∥ 2 = 1 4 ∫ X d 4 x tr F μ ν F μ ν .
Here S YM is the action accumulated by the same curvature against the flat reference of the previous example. Nonnegativity is unconditional because the setting is Euclidean and the slot arguments are Lie-algebra-valued forms with a positive Hilbert–Schmidt norm. The cross term is topological: with the coupling absorbed into the normalization of the pairing,
1 2 ★ F | F = 8 π 2 k g 2 , k ∈ Z ,
where k is the instanton number. Nonnegativity of the surprisal is therefore the Bogomolny bound,
S YM ≥ 8 π 2 k g 2 , S ★ = 0 ⇔ F = ★ F .
Replacing the reference by − ★ D 2 reverses the orientation and gives the anti-self-dual branch,
S YM ≥ − 8 π 2 k g 2 , F = − ★ F
at equality; together the two references yield
S YM ≥ 8 π 2 | k | g 2 .
Two features are worth mentioning. First, the topological charge is the irreducible surprisal of a sector: no field in the class k can be less surprising than 8 π 2 | k | / g 2 relative to flatness, and the instanton saturates the bound. Second, the same curvature compared against two different references returns two different theories: against 0 the Yang–Mills action, against ★ F the Bogomolny functional. This is the point of Section 1.4 in its sharpest form. A theory is a declaration of what counts as unsurprising, and the declaration is made by the reference.

2.4. Dirac–Einstein–Stelle

The previous Dirac examples compared curvature against flatness. Here the reference is nonzero, and this supplies the dimensionful content of gravity: one quadratic comparison contributes at three orders in the reference scale at once and returns the Lagrangian of Stelle [45,48]—quadratic gravity with an Einstein–Hilbert term, a cosmological term and Dirac matter.
Carrier and transport. Let ψ ∈ H be an amplitude and let ω be the Levi-Civita spin connection of g, so that the construction is second-order and torsion-free. Set
D = d + ω , D 2 = : F , F μ ν a b = R μ ν a b ,
so that the curvature slot carries the Riemann curvature two-form. Let
D = i γ μ ∇ μ − m
be the Clifford contraction of the same connection.
The curvature-slot pairing. The curvature slot takes values in the space of algebraic curvature tensors, which in four dimensions is twenty-dimensional and splits into three irreducible sectors: Weyl ( 10 ) , traceless Ricci ( 9 ) and scalar ( 1 ) . For a curvature two-form K , write C [ K ] , S [ K ] and R [ K ] for its Weyl, traceless-Ricci and scalar parts. The general invariant real pairing carries one weight per sector:
K 2 : = 1 2 κ C C [ K ] · C [ K ] + 2 κ S S [ K ] · S [ K ] + κ R 6 R [ K ] 2 .
For the Riemann two-form itself,
S μ ν : = R μ ν − 1 4 R g μ ν ,
and the identities used below are
R μ ν ρ σ R μ ν ρ σ = C μ ν ρ σ C μ ν ρ σ + 2 S μ ν S μ ν + 1 6 R 2 ,
E 4 = C μ ν ρ σ C μ ν ρ σ − 2 S μ ν S μ ν + 1 6 R 2 ,
where E 4 is the Euler density. The choice
( κ C , κ S , κ R ) = ( 3 , − 2 , 1 )
is carried through this calibration for concreteness.
The reference. The metric supplies a canonical nonzero element of the same slot: the constant-curvature two-form of radius ℓ,
F 0 : = 1 2 ℓ 2 g x g x , F 0 μ ν a b = 1 ℓ 2 e μ a e ν b − e ν a e μ b ,
with
( h k ) μ ν ρ σ = h μ ρ k ν σ + h ν σ k μ ρ − h μ σ k ν ρ − h ν ρ k μ σ .
Its sector decomposition is
C [ F 0 ] = 0 , S [ F 0 ] = 0 , R [ F 0 ] = R 0 : = 12 ℓ 2 ,
and therefore
F 0 2 = κ R R 0 2 12 , F 0 | F = κ R R 0 R 12 .
Jets and surprisal. The jets are
J ϵ ψ = ψ + i ϵ D ψ , ϵ D 2 , J r ψ = ψ , ϵ F 0 .
By Proposition 1.4, with s F = − 1 ,
K J ϵ ψ , J r ψ = − i ϵ Re 〈 ψ ∣ D ψ 〉 − 1 2 F − F 0 2 + O ( ϵ 2 ) .
Expanding the square,
1 2 F − F 0 2 = 1 2 ∥ F ∥ 2 ︸ quadratic − F 0 | F ︸ linear + 1 2 ∥ F 0 ∥ 2 ︸ constant .
The comparison thus contributes at three orders in the reference: quadratic curvature, the Einstein–Hilbert term and the cosmological term. Substitution of (67) and (75) gives
1 2 F − F 0 2 = 1 4 κ C C μ ν ρ σ C μ ν ρ σ + 2 κ S S μ ν S μ ν + κ R 6 R 2 − κ R R 0 R 12 + κ R R 0 2 24 .
Eliminating S μ ν S μ ν with (69) and (70),
1 2 F − F 0 2 = 1 4 ( κ C + κ S ) C 2 + κ S + κ R 6 R 2 − κ S E 4 − κ R R 0 3 R + κ R R 0 2 6 .
Accumulation. Accumulating yields
S = ∫ X d 4 x | g | ψ ¯ i γ μ ∇ μ − m ψ + a C μ ν ρ σ C μ ν ρ σ + b R 2 + c E 4 + M P 2 2 R − Λ ,
with
a = − κ C + κ S 4 , b = − κ S + κ R 24 , c = κ S 4 , M P 2 = 2 κ R ℓ 2 , Λ = 6 κ R ℓ 4 .
At (71),
a = − 1 4 , b = 1 24 , c = − 1 2 , M P 2 = 2 ℓ 2 , Λ = 6 ℓ 4 .
This is quadratic gravity with an Einstein–Hilbert and a cosmological term. It is local, generally covariant and perturbatively renormalizable in four dimensions [48], with known asymptotically free trajectories in its coupling space [7,25,45]. Its linearized spectrum contains the massless graviton, a massive spin-two mode with parameter
m 2 2 = − M P 2 4 a ,
and a scalaron with parameter
m 0 2 = M P 2 12 b ,
both positive at (71). Variation with respect to ψ ¯ gives the Dirac equation, while variation with respect to the metric gives the fourth-order gravitational equation.
The zero-surprisal vacuum. In vacuum, the configuration F = F 0 has vanishing surprisal and solves that equation. It is de Sitter space of radius ℓ:
R μ ν ρ σ = 1 ℓ 2 g μ ρ g ν σ − g μ σ g ν ρ , R = R 0 = 4 Λ geo ,
where
Λ geo : = Λ M P 2 = 3 ℓ 2 .
Being conformally flat, it annihilates the Bach tensor; being Einstein with constant R, it also annihilates the variation of R 2 . It therefore solves the full fourth-order equation, not merely its Einstein–Hilbert truncation. The dimensionful content of gravity is carried by the reference.

2.5. Friedmann Equations

Let D , D, F , F 0 and the curvature-slot pairing be as in the previous example. Restrict the metric to the homogeneous isotropic class
g = − t 2 + a ( t ) 2 Σ k 2 ,
where Σ k 2 is the maximally symmetric three-metric of constant curvature k. The surviving curvature components reduce to
F 0 ^ i ^ 0 ^ j ^ = A δ i j , F i ^ j ^ k ^ l ^ = B δ i k δ j l − δ i l δ j k ,
where
A : = a ¨ a , B : = a ˙ 2 + k a 2 .
The reference has A 0 = B 0 = ℓ − 2 . Set
α : = A − 1 ℓ 2 , β : = B − 1 ℓ 2 .
Every FLRW metric is conformally flat, so C μ ν ρ σ = 0 . For Δ : = F − F 0 ,
R [ Δ ] = 6 ( α + β ) , S [ Δ ] μ ν S [ Δ ] μ ν = 3 ( β − α ) 2 , C [ Δ ] = 0 .
Hence
1 2 ∥ Δ ∥ 2 = 3 2 κ R ( α + β ) 2 + κ S ( β − α ) 2 .
Accumulating, with | g | = a 3 h k and V c the comoving volume, gives
S = V c ∫ d t a 3 ψ ¯ i γ μ ∇ μ − m ψ − 3 κ R 2 ( α + β ) 2 − 3 κ S 2 ( β − α ) 2
= V c ∫ d t a 3 ψ ¯ i γ μ ∇ μ − m ψ + M P 2 2 R − Λ + b R 2 + c E 4 ,
with the coefficients of (82). The Weyl term vanishes, while the Euler term does not enter the field equations. The R 2 term contributes through derivatives of R, which vanish when R is constant. Displaying the remaining equations at leading order in b, variation with respect to the lapse and to a gives
B = a ˙ 2 + k a 2 = ρ 3 M P 2 + 1 ℓ 2 , A = a ¨ a = − ρ + 3 p 6 M P 2 + 1 ℓ 2 .
These are the leading-order Friedmann and Raychaudhuri equations, with
Λ geo = 3 ℓ 2 , 8 π G = M P − 2 .
At this order the two normal modes obey
α + β = ρ − 3 p 6 M P 2 = − T μ μ 6 M P 2 , β − α = ρ + p 2 M P 2 .
Substituting these leading-order relations back gives the corresponding on-shell geometric surprisal:
1 2 F − F 0 2 = ℓ 2 48 M P 2 ( ρ − 3 p ) 2 + 9 ς ( ρ + p ) 2 = ρ 2 ℓ 2 48 M P 2 ( 1 − 3 w ) 2 + 9 ς ( 1 + w ) 2 ,
where
w : = p ρ , ς : = κ S κ R .
At this order it vanishes when ρ = p = 0 , in which case α = β = 0 and the geometry is exactly de Sitter space of radius ℓ: the empty de Sitter universe is a cosmology of zero surprisal, and a homogeneous isotropic universe is surprising to the extent that it contains matter.

3. Main Result

The procedure having been calibrated against five known Lagrangians, we now apply it to the intrinsic carrier.

3.1. The Intrinsic Carrier

An intrinsic carrier uses only (and all of) the structures that spacetime supplies of itself. Its local geometric data are a point x ∈ X and a nondegenerate metric g x of signature ( p , q ) on T x X . Denote by M p , q ( X ) the bundle of local metric configurations, whose points are the pairs ( x , g x ) . A metric field on X is a section g ∈ Γ ( M p , q ( X ) ) .
Each pair ( x , g x ) supplies the spaces in which an intrinsic amplitude can take values. The metric g x defines the spacetime Clifford algebra Cl ( T x X , g x ) . Taking g x as a parameter also supplies the tangent space to its local metric fibre, T g x M p , q , x ( X ) ≅ Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , equipped with the DeWitt form G g x . These metric structures furnish the corresponding Clifford and spin carriers; no independent internal vector space or symmetry group is appended.
Definition 3.1 
(The intrinsic carrier). Let X d be a smooth manifold and fix a metric signature ( p , q ) . Theintrinsic carrieris the metric-parametrized amplitude
Ψ = Ψ ( x , g x ) , Ψ ( x , g x ) ∈ Cl + ( T x X , g x ) ⊗ Σ Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , G g x ,
defined for every ( x , g x ) ∈ M p , q ( X ) , together with the spacetime and metric-fibre transport admitted by this parametrization.
Here Σ ( Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , G g x ) denotes an irreducible complex spinor representation of Spin ( Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , G g x ) . When dim Sym 2 ( T x * X ) is even, one irreducible half-spin representation is used.
Remark 3.2 
(The even spacetime carrier). We use Cl + ( T x X , g x ) because it is the unital subalgebra containing Spin ( p , q ) and ensures that the unprojected current J = Ψ e 0 Ψ ˜ is odd; the full algebra generically produces even cross terms, while the odd subspace is not a unital subalgebra.
Remark 3.3 
(Closure of the metric parametrization). Since S y m 2 ( T x * X ) is a vector space, then its tangent space is an exact copy of itself—the construction spots automatically, rather than being truncated.

3.2. intrinsic vs Non-Intrinsic Carriers

The non-intrinsic carrier of ordinary field theory is constructed over an arena externally chosen. It has the form
ψ ( x ) ∈ S ( T x X , g x ) ⊗ E ρ , D = d + ω + A ,
where S ( T x X , g x ) is a selected spinor module and E ρ a selected representation of an internal group. An adjoint, complex structure, internal group, representation and connection are supplied so that the carrier supports the intended dynamics. This is the carrier used in Section 2.1 and Section 2.2, and in the ordinary formulation of the Standard Model.
Such a construction is deliberately adaptable. Precisely for that reason, however, it cannot situate itself. Once the required structures have been supplied, analogous carriers may be built over many dimensions and signatures, with many internal groups. The arena and internal symmetry are inputs rather than consequences.
An intrinsic carrier reverses this relation. Its spacetime algebra, metric-variation space and internal spin carrier are all furnished by ( x , g x ) . No independent internal group is appended, and no projected current is introduced to ensure success. The structures required by surprisal must occur intrinsically, or the carrier over that geometry is not physical.
Non-intrinsic carrier (102) Intrinsic carrier (101)
spacetime amplitude a selected spinor module S ( T x X , g x ) the intrinsic even algebra Cl + ( T x X , g x )
complex structure supplied with the representation must be admitted by the intrinsic carrier
current and density defined using a chosen adjoint and vector bilinear obtained from Ψ e 0 Ψ ˜ without grade projection
internal carrier a chosen group representation E ρ the spin module of ( Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , G g x )
internal symmetry chosen before the connection obtained from the structures preserved by the metric-fibre carrier
transport ω and A supplied the generalized transport admitted by the parametrization
arena fixed before constructing the carrier selected by the conditions under which the carrier is physical
The physicality of the intrinsic carrier is tested by the structures it must carry. The spacetime-algebra factor must produce a grade-one current with density of fixed sign, while the metric-variation factor must admit the complex structure required for intrinsic interference. No external structure is added when either test fails. Applied to Definition 3.1, these requirements leave only Lorentzian 3 + 1 spacetime (Theorem 3.8).
The intrinsic carrier therefore selects its own geometry: among the geometries over which the construction can be written, only one makes it a physical amplitude from which surprisal generates dynamics. Other geometries remain valid arenas for non-intrinsic carriers, but they do not induce a least-surprisal dynamic for their intrinsic carriers. The surviving intrinsic carrier then fixes the internal symmetry, matter content, scalar transport and gravitational action derived below.

3.3. Dimension and Signature

We begin with two observations.
Observation 3.4 
(Observation require positive currents). The Noether current of the first slot of (156) is the Dirac bilinear
J = Ψ e 0 Ψ ˜ ,
and its density 〈 J , e 0 〉 is what a channel counts: an observer exists only where that density is of one sign.
Observation 3.5 
(Surprisal requires a common intrinsic phase). Following Hestenes, the imaginary unit appearing in quantum dynamics is required to be realized by the geometry of the carrier rather than adjoined as an external scalar. Accordingly, the spacetime algebra and metric-fibre carrier must each furnish a geometric phase operator,
I S , x 2 = − 1 , I F , x 2 = − 1 ,
where I S , x is realized within Cl + ( T x X , g x ) , as in spacetime algebra, and I F , x is induced on the fibre-spin module by the metric-variation geometry.
The intrinsic carrier identifies these two realizations as one common phase through the balanced tensor product
E x = Cl + ( T x X , g x ) I S , x ⊗ C Σ ( V x , G g x ) I F , x , V x = Sym 2 ( T x * X ) ,
so that
I x ( s ⊗ f ) = ( I S , x s ) ⊗ f = s ⊗ ( I F , x f ) , I x 2 = − 1 .
Thus the single phase acts geometrically on either component of the complete wavefunction, and the displacement jet is intrinsically
J ϵ Ψ = Ψ + ϵ I x D Ψ , ϵ D 2 , [ D , I x ] = 0 ,
which is written as Ψ + i ϵ D Ψ in ordinary complex notation.
For the fibre phase to be intrinsic, V x must admit a G g x -compatible complex structure
J x 2 = − 1 , G g x ( J x u , J x v ) = G g x ( u , v ) ,
whose polarization induces I F , x and is preserved by the fibre transport.
Each factor must therefore furnish its own phase structure: the spacetime factor through its intrinsic algebra and the metric-fibre factor through a compatible complex structure. Only existence is at issue here. Positivity of the induced fibre pairing is a separate requirement imposed in Section 3.4.
Theorem 3.6 
(Spacetime selection). Let Ψ ∈ Cl + ( T x X , g x ) with p timelike directions, n = p + q , and let
J : = Ψ e 0 Ψ ˜
be the Noether current of the first-order coefficient. Then J is of grade one for every Ψ if and only if n ≤ 4 , and 〈 J , e 0 〉 has one sign for every Ψ ≠ 0 if and only if p = 1 or q = 1 . The geometries admitting a positive grade-one current are therefore
0 + 1 , 1 + 1 , 2 + 1 , 3 + 1 ,
and no others.
Proof. 
J is odd by parity and reversion-invariant, since
Ψ e 0 Ψ ˜ ˜ = Ψ e 0 ˜ Ψ ˜ = J .
Reversion acts on grade k as ( − 1 ) k ( k − 1 ) / 2 , which is + 1 exactly for k ≡ 0 , 1 ( mod 4 ) . Intersecting with the odd grades gives
J ∈ Λ 1 ⊕ Λ 5 ⊕ … .
Thus J is necessarily pure grade one for n ≤ 4 . At n = 5 , for example,
Ψ = 1 + e 1 e 2 e 3 e 4
gives
J = 2 e 0 + 2 e 0 e 1 e 2 e 3 e 4 ,
so the grade-five component occurs.
For the sign, 〈 J , e 0 〉 is of fixed sign precisely when the connected spin group preserves a time cone about e 0 . If p ≥ 2 , a rotation in a plane containing two timelike directions carries e 0 continuously to − e 0 , and both signs occur. For p = 1 , the future timelike cone is preserved by the orthochronous spin group, and the current lies in its closure with positive e 0 -component for nonzero amplitudes. Imposing n ≤ 4 and one timelike direction, up to overall reversal of the metric sign, gives (110). □
Four geometries remain. To test the second factor, we first need its signature.
Lemma 3.7 
(DeWitt signature). For
G g ( h , k ) = h μ ν k ρ σ g μ ρ g ν σ − λ g μ ν g ρ σ
on V = Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , with g Lorentzian and λ > 1 / d ,
dim V = d ( d + 1 ) 2 , sig G g = d ( d − 1 ) 2 , d .
On (110), these signatures are
( 0 , 1 ) , ( 1 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 3 ) , ( 6 , 4 ) .
At λ = 1 / d , the trace direction is null.
Proof. 
Split G orthogonally into trace and traceless parts. The d diagonal elements E ( μ μ ) have positive norm. The off-diagonal elements E ( μ ν ) , with μ < ν , have norm proportional to g μ μ g ν ν , negative for the d − 1 elements containing one timelike index and positive for the remaining d − 1 2 . Finally,
G ( g , g ) = d − λ d 2 < 0
for λ > 1 / d . Summing gives d ( d − 1 ) / 2 positive and d negative directions. □
Theorem 3.8 
(Only 3 + 1 survives). Of the four geometries (110), the internal factor V = Sym 2 ( T x * X ) admits a G g x -compatible complex structure in 3 + 1 dimensions alone. Hence d = 4 and
sig G g x = ( 6 , 4 ) .
Proof. 
By Observation 3.5, intrinsic fibre interference requires a G g x -compatible complex structure. Such a structure exists on a real quadratic space if and only if both entries of its signature are even. By Lemma 3.7, the candidates are ( 0 , 1 ) , ( 1 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 3 ) and ( 6 , 4 ) , of which only ( 6 , 4 ) has both entries even. Hence only Lorentzian d = 4 survives. □
Carrier sig G g x Verdict
0 + 1 ( 0 , 1 ) no compatible complex structure
1 + 1 ( 1 , 2 ) entries not both even
2 + 1 ( 3 , 3 ) entries not both even
3 + 1 ( 6 , 4 ) complex structure exists
The dimension and signature of spacetime are thus what remains once the current is required to be a positive vector and the metric’s own tangent space is required to admit an intrinsic complex structure. Existence is not yet readability: the induced Hermitian form is indefinite. Section 3.4 imposes the remaining requirements.

3.4. The Internal Symmetry

Observation 3.5 leaves the fibre with a compatible complex structure and its transport confined to U ( 3 , 2 ) . A requirement remains: the first-order term must be a density, producing another reduction [10].
Theorem 3.9 
(Bundle selection). Let the fibre amplitude be valued in a module of
Spin ( 6 , 4 ) = Spin ( V , G g x ) .
The first-order term of the transition surprisal exists, is a density, and is written in a unit belonging to the carrier if and only if the fibre carries a compatible parallel complex structure J x , a polarization R x on which the induced Hermitian form is positive definite. Hence
Spin ( 6 , 4 ) → J x U ( 3 , 2 ) → R x U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) ∼ loc G S M × U ( 1 ) X
the Standard Model gauge group in its faithful global form, with a U ( 1 ) X extension.
Proof. 1. Existence. By Observation 3.5, the transport preserves both parts of the pseudo-Hermitian form
h : = G g x + i G g x ( · , J x · ) ,
so it lies in U ( 3 , 2 ) , of dimension 25 within S O ( 6 , 4 ) of dimension 45. At the spin level, the corresponding covering group acts on the modules of Theorem 3.11.
2. Density. The coefficient is sesquilinear in Ψ , so its physical polarization must carry a positive-definite Hermitian pairing. Choosing a compatible positive polarization splits the complex fibre into positive and negative subspaces of dimensions 3 and 2. A transport preserving both is unitary on each:
U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) ,
of dimension 13, the maximal compact subgroup selected by positivity. Write W for the polarization so determined.
3. Standard Model. The Lie algebra of U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) decomposes as
u ( 3 ) ⊕ u ( 2 ) = s u ( 3 ) ⊕ u ( 2 ) ⊕ u ( 1 ) X ,
where
s u ( 3 ) ⊕ u ( 2 ) = ( X , Y ) : tr X + tr Y = 0 .
The corresponding connected subgroup is
S U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) = ( A , B ) ∈ U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) : det A det B = 1 ≅ S U ( 3 ) × S U ( 2 ) × U ( 1 ) Y Z 6 ,
the faithful Standard Model gauge group. Consequently, U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) contains the Standard Model gauge group and has one additional abelian direction, denoted U ( 1 ) X . □
Corollary 3.10 
(Hypercharge and the additional abelian direction). The centre of u ( 3 ) ⊕ u ( 2 ) is two-dimensional and consists of generators of the form ( i a 1 3 , i b 1 2 ) . Its trace-free line is characterized by 3 a + 2 b = 0 and is generated, up to overall normalization and sign, by
Y = diag − 1 3 , − 1 3 , − 1 3 , + 1 2 , + 1 2 .
This is the Standard Model hypercharge generator. A linearly independent central generator may be chosen as the total-phase direction
X 0 = diag 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 ,
which defines the additional abelian factor U ( 1 ) X , up to normalization and a change of basis among the two abelian generators.
Consequently,
u ( 3 ) ⊕ u ( 2 ) ≅ su ( 3 ) ⊕ su ( 2 ) ⊕ u ( 1 ) Y ⊕ u ( 1 ) X .
On the Standard Model subgroup, electric charge is
Q em = T 3 + Y ,
and the half-spin branching has the usual quantized Standard Model hypercharges.
Surprisal therefore reduces Spin ( 6 , 4 ) to U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) , locally the Standard Model gauge group enlarged by one abelian factor U ( 1 ) X . The Standard Model subgroup is its unimodular subgroup.

3.5. Matter and Scalar Sectors

Let W be the complex polarization determined by J x , so that dim C W = 5 . Under the unitary subgroup, the selected irreducible half-spin carrier is more precisely
F + ≅ Λ even W ⊗ ( det W ) − 1 / 2 , dim C F + = 16 ,
while reversal of the orientation exchanges it with
F − ≅ Λ odd W ⊗ ( det W ) − 1 / 2 .
The determinant-half factor records the lift of the unitary action to the spin module. It is trivial on the unimodular subgroup but supplies the charges of the additional central direction on the full unitary group. The group statements below may equivalently be read at the Lie-algebra level, avoiding finite-cover conventions.
Theorem 3.11 
(Matter content from the spinor module). Since 6 − 4 = 2 ≡ 2 ( mod 8 ) , the half-spin modules of Spin ( 6 , 4 ) are complex and chiral [4,35]. Under U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) , with the hypercharges of Corollary 3.10 and the additional abelian generator normalized so that its charge on Λ k W is
X = 2 k − 5 ,
the positive half-spin module decomposes as
Preprints 226801 i003
Here the two subscripts denote ( Y , X ) . This is one complete anomaly-free chiral generation, including a right-handed neutrino, written entirely in left-handed Weyl notation [1,11,12,27,47,50].
That a sixteen-dimensional chiral module accommodates a generation has been exploited since the earliest Spin ( 10 ) unification [27,28]. What is new here is that the sixteen was not chosen: it follows from d = 4 through dim Sym 2 ( T x * X ) = 10 and Lemma 3.7, while d = 4 follows from Theorems 3.6 and 3.8. The construction fixes the content of one generation but does not by itself fix the generation multiplicity. Copies of the same module are compatible with Definition 3.1; a possible realization of their multiplicity through vertical modes is discussed in Section 5.
The branching also makes the weak interaction chiral: Q L and L L are S U ( 2 ) doublets, while u R c , d R c , e R c , ν R c are singlets. After charge conjugation, the latter become the physical right-handed weak singlets. Since the spacetime spinor factor in the selected Lorentzian four-dimensional arena decomposes as S = S L ⊕ S R , the fermion carrier may equivalently be written
E f = ( S L ⊗ F L ) ⊕ ( S R ⊗ F R ) , F L = Q L ⊕ L L , F R = u R ⊕ d R ⊕ ν R ⊕ e R .
This is the physical left–right realization of the all-left-handed module above and introduces no additional states. In physical right-handed notation, the corresponding X charges are
Preprints 226801 i004
Let
∇ g , A : = ∇ g spin + ∇ A SM + X
denote the ordinary covariant derivative on this graded carrier. Here ∇ g spin is the spin connection determined by the metric, while ∇ A SM + X contains the independent U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) gauge connection and therefore both abelian directions U ( 1 ) Y and U ( 1 ) X . A generalized covariant derivative additionally admits an odd Lorentz-scalar zero-form connecting the two summands [43]. Including the minimal nonzero, colour-preserving and quark–lepton-preserving transport gives
D = ∇ g , A + Φ H , Φ H = 0 Φ L R ( H ) Φ L R ( H ) † 0 .
Theorem 3.12 
(Higgs and Yukawa sector). For the minimal transport above, gauge covariance fixes the independent field content of Φ H to one complex Higgs doublet,
H ∼ ( 1 , 2 ) ( 1 / 2 , 2 ) , H ˜ : = i σ 2 H * ∼ ( 1 , 2 ) ( − 1 / 2 , − 2 ) ,
where the two subscripts denote ( Y , X ) , with
Φ L R ( H ) ∼ diag Y u H ˜ , Y d H , Y ν H ˜ , Y e H .
Its contribution to the contracted transport is
− Q ¯ L Y u H ˜ u R + Q ¯ L Y d H d R + L ¯ L Y ν H ˜ ν R + L ¯ L Y e H e R + h . c . ,
the renormalizable Yukawa interaction of the U ( 1 ) X -extended Standard Model.
Proof. 
The maps d R → Q L and e R → L L require a colour-singlet weak doublet with
Y Q L − Y d R = Y L L − Y e R = 1 2 ,
X Q L − X d R = X L L − X e R = 2 ,
whereas u R → Q L and ν R → L L require its conjugate:
Y Q L − Y u R = Y L L − Y ν R = − 1 2 ,
X Q L − X u R = X L L − X ν R = − 2 .
The pseudoreality of the defining S U ( 2 ) representation identifies the conjugate weak doublet with H ˜ = i σ 2 H * , so one independent complex doublet supplies all four channels. □
While U ( 1 ) X remains unbroken, ν R carries X charge and a constant Majorana block is not gauge invariant. The Dirac Yukawa channel in (143) remains allowed. If U ( 1 ) X is broken by a suitable determinant-charged vacuum, a right-handed Majorana mass and a type-I-seesaw regime may additionally be generated; such a breaking sector is not fixed here.
Finally,
D 2 = F g , A + D g , A Φ H + Φ H 2 , F g , A : = ∇ g , A 2 , D g , A Φ H : = [ ∇ g , A , Φ H ] ,
so the same zero-form supplies the Yukawa interaction through the contracted transport, the covariant Higgs kinetic term through D g , A Φ H , and the quartic Higgs potential through comparison of Φ H 2 with the zero-form reference.

3.6. Assembly

The preceding results determine the carrier and its transport. Although the intrinsic carrier admits transport in both spacetime and the metric fibre, the spacetime action assembled here uses its restriction to a physical metric section; Section 5 considers the more general fibre-dependent extension. Its generalized covariant derivative and Clifford contraction are
D = ∇ g , A + Φ H , D = i γ μ ∇ g , A , μ − Φ H ,
where ∇ g , A = ∇ g spin + ∇ A SM + X contains the spin connection determined by the metric and the independent U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) gauge connection, including the two abelian directions U ( 1 ) Y and U ( 1 ) X .
As for any superconnection [43],
D 2 = R g ︸ spacetime curvature + F A SM + X ︸ gauge curvature + D g , A Φ H ︸ one - form + Φ H 2 ︸ zero - form , D g , A Φ H : = [ ∇ g , A , Φ H ] .
Here R g is the curvature of ∇ g spin and F A SM + X is the curvature of ∇ A SM + X . The homogeneous form-degree and carrier sectors are orthogonal. The complete renormalizable pairing additionally admits the independent mixed scalar invariant
R g , Φ H 2 mix : = ξ R H † H ,
whose coefficient ξ is a pairing weight.
Because the centre of u ( 3 ) ⊕ u ( 2 ) is two-dimensional, the invariant pairing on its abelian curvature sector is a real symmetric quadratic form. In a basis adapted to hypercharge and the additional direction, it admits
F A SM + X , F A SM + X ab ⊃ 1 2 g 1 2 B μ ν B μ ν + 1 2 g X 2 X μ ν X μ ν + χ g 1 g X B μ ν X μ ν ,
where X μ ν is the additional abelian field strength and χ is the allowed kinetic-mixing coefficient.
The reference has a spacetime-curvature component and a zero-form component,
F 0 = 1 2 ℓ 2 g x g x + C .
The first is the constant-curvature two-form (72), while C fixes the scalar vacuum reference. Their forms are supplied by the carrier; the scales ℓ and C remain reference data.
The jets are
J ϵ Ψ = Ψ + i ϵ D Ψ , ϵ D 2 , J r Ψ = Ψ , ϵ F 0 .
By Proposition 1.4, their accumulated surprisal is I = − i S , where
S = ∫ X d 4 x − g L
and
L = Re 〈 Ψ ∣ D Ψ 〉 x + s F 2 D 2 − F 0 , D 2 − F 0 x .
The slots evaluate sector by sector:
Slot Carrier Term
displacement ( S L ⊗ F L ) ⊕ ( S R ⊗ F R ) fermion kinetic terms and Yukawa couplings
curvature, R g − F 0 , grav R ( T x X ) C 2 , R 2 , E 4 , M P 2 R and Λ
curvature, F A SM + X u ( 3 ) ⊕ u ( 2 ) G 2 , W 2 , B 2 , X 2 and B μ ν X μ ν
curvature, D g , A Φ H odd chiral intertwiner − ( D μ H ) † D μ H
curvature, Φ H 2 − C even endomorphism sector m H 2 H † H and λ H ( H † H ) 2
mixed scalar contraction R ( T x X ) ⊗ End even ( F ) − ξ R H † H
While the full U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) symmetry is unbroken, ν R carries charge under the additional abelian direction and a constant right-handed Majorana block is not gauge invariant. The displacement slot nevertheless contains the gauge-invariant Dirac neutrino Yukawa channel. A Majorana block may arise only after an appropriate breaking of the additional abelian symmetry; such a breaking sector is not included in the operator table above.
The operator content is fixed by these sectors, while their numerical couplings are the corresponding invariant pairing weights. Evaluating them gives the action collected in Section 3.7.

3.7. The Least Surprising Theory of the Intrinsic Carrier

The slots of Section 3.6 may now be evaluated, the filtering having fixed d = 4 , the fibre symmetry and the modules the realizations carry. The accumulated surprisal
I = lim ϵ → 0 1 ϵ K J ϵ Ψ , J r Ψ = − i S
has
S = ∫ X d 4 x − g [ a C μ ν ρ σ C μ ν ρ σ + b R 2 + c E 4 + M P 2 2 R − Λ − 1 4 g 3 2 G μ ν A G A μ ν − 1 4 g 2 2 W μ ν I W I μ ν − 1 4 g 1 2 B μ ν B μ ν − 1 4 g X 2 X μ ν X μ ν − χ 2 g 1 g X B μ ν X μ ν + ∑ f ψ ¯ f i γ μ D μ SM + X ψ f − D μ SM + X H † D μ , SM + X H − ξ R H † H − m H 2 H † H − λ H ( H † H ) 2 − y u Q ¯ L H ˜ u R + y d Q ¯ L H d R + y e L ¯ L H e R + y ν L ¯ L H ˜ ν R + h . c . ] .
Here H ˜ = i σ 2 H * , X μ ν is the field strength of the additional abelian connection, and χ is the allowed kinetic-mixing coefficient. The derivative D μ SM + X contains the full U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) connection, whose Lie algebra is
su ( 3 ) ⊕ su ( 2 ) ⊕ u ( 1 ) Y ⊕ u ( 1 ) X .
In particular, on a field f it contains the abelian contribution
D μ SM + X f ⊃ − i Y f B μ f − i X f X μ f ,
with normalization conventions absorbed into g 1 , g X , Y f and X f .
Gauge-fixing, Faddeev–Popov and BRST terms are understood but not displayed, and the globalization of the pointwise modules to principal and associated bundles is standard [32,40]. The non-minimal coupling ξ R H † H is the mixed invariant (151). It belongs to the renormalizable curved-space operator basis and must be included for closure under renormalization [14,16,41].
The right-handed neutrino carries charge under U ( 1 ) X . Consequently, while the full U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) symmetry remains unbroken, the constant Majorana term
1 2 M R ν R c ¯ ν R
is not gauge invariant and is absent from (158). The gauge-invariant Yukawa interaction
− y ν L ¯ L H ˜ ν R + h . c .
nevertheless supplies a renormalizable Dirac neutrino-mass channel after electroweak symmetry breaking. A right-handed Majorana mass and a type-I-seesaw regime may arise if an additional vacuum breaks U ( 1 ) X ; such a breaking sector is not included in (158).
Thus the action is perturbatively renormalizable quadratic gravity coupled to an anomaly-free one-factor abelian extension of the Standard Model, with one right-handed neutrino in each fermion generation.
Formally, the resulting theory is quantized by the gauge-fixed functional integral
Z = ∫ D g D A D H D ψ D ψ ¯ D c D c ¯ e i S gf , S gf = S + S g . f . + S gh ,
where A collectively denotes all U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) gauge fields, including X μ , and D g integrates over metric sections modulo diffeomorphisms. Since I = − i S , the history weight is
e − I = e i S .

4. Measurement on the Hilbert–Krein Carrier

One difficulty remains. The quadratic-gravity action is perturbatively renormalizable and admits asymptotically free trajectories [7,25,45,48], but its standard covariant quantization contains a massive spin-two pole with opposite residue. This pole is not an incidental excitation that can simply be removed: schematically,
1 k 2 ( 1 + k 2 / m 2 2 ) = 1 k 2 − 1 k 2 + m 2 2 ,
so the same pole that produces the indefinite sector is tied to the k − 4 ultraviolet decay underlying perturbative renormalizability.
Retaining the complete spectrum therefore places the massive spin-two mode in a negative-metric sector, conventionally called the Stelle ghost. The curvature pairing already exhibits this indefiniteness, having signature ( 11 , 9 ) , with its negative propagating content reducing after the linearized constraints to the five-polarization massive spin-two mode. Since the U ( 1 ) X -extended Standard Model sector is Hilbert-positive, the resulting kinematical carrier is
K kin = H SM + X ⊗ ^ K QG , η kin = 1 SM + X ⊗ η QG ,
where η QG acts as + 1 on the positive sectors and as − 1 on the massive spin-two sector.
The usual objection conflates measurement with a globally normalized probability measure. A probability measure satisfies three Kolmogorov requirements: nonnegativity, countable additivity on disjoint channels, and normalization of an exhaustive family to unity. Detector records prior to normalization are intensities, which require only the first two:
I A ( ω ) ≥ 0 , I ∑ m A m ( ω ) = ∑ m I A m ( ω ) .
Whenever a registered family D = { A m } has finite nonzero total intensity, it defines ordinary probabilities by
p ( m ∣ D , ω ) = I A m ( ω ) ∑ n I A n ( ω ) .
These satisfy all three Kolmogorov requirements within the registered experiment.
This is sufficient for quantum measurement on the Krein carrier. The order isomorphism
A ⟼ E : = η A
identifies intensity-positive Krein observables with ordinary positive Hilbert-space effects, so measurement families, state updates, and instruments transfer directly between the two descriptions. The indefinite form remains a conserved signed charge, while every detector record is a nonnegative intensity and every registered experiment with finite nonzero total admits the usual probabilistic interpretation. What fails is only a universal positive normalization of the conserved form, not quantum measurement itself.
We now construct this intensity-positive measurement structure without altering the action, propagator, or spectrum.
The intensity cone. Write K for K kin and η for η kin , so that
η † = η , η 2 = 1 , [ ϕ , ψ ] = ( ϕ , η ψ ) ,
with ( · , · ) the positive pairing defining the topology. The Krein adjoint is
A ♯ = η A † η ,
and the bounded Krein-self-adjoint observables form
A sa = { A : A ♯ = A } .
Definition 4.1 
(Intensity-positive observable). An observable A ∈ A sa isintensity-positivewhen
[ ψ , A ψ ] ≥ 0
for every ψ ∈ K . The resulting cone is
C : = A ∈ A sa : [ ψ , A ψ ] ≥ 0 for all ψ .
Apreparationis a nonzero continuous real-linear functional ω on A sa satisfying ω ( A ) ≥ 0 on C , and the intensity of a channel A ∈ C is
I A ( ω ) : = ω ( A ) ≥ 0 .
Vectors define preparations by
ω ψ ( A ) : = [ ψ , A ψ ] .
No normalization is imposed.
Lemma 4.2 
(Structure). A ♯ = A if and only if η A is Hilbert-self-adjoint, and
[ ψ , A ψ ] = ( ψ , η A ψ ) .
Hence
A ⟼ E : = η A
is a linear bijection from A sa onto the Hilbert-self-adjoint operators, carrying C onto the ordinary positive cone. Detector channels are therefore A = η E with E ≥ 0 .
Proof. 
The condition A ♯ = A is
A † η = η A ,
equivalently ( η A ) † = η A . The displayed identity is immediate, and η 2 = 1 inverts the map. If both A and − A belong to C , then η A = 0 , hence A = 0 . □
Proposition 4.3 
(Generation and tomography). η is an order unit for C : for every B ∈ A sa ,
− M η ≤ B ≤ M η , M = ∥ η B ∥ .
Consequently,
A sa = C − C ,
and preparations agreeing on C agree everywhere.
Proof. 
M η ∓ B ∈ C if and only if
M 1 ∓ η B ≥ 0 ,
which holds for M = ∥ η B ∥ . Writing
B = B + − B − , B ± = 1 2 ( M η ± B ) ∈ C ,
shows that the cone generates the full observable space. □
A signed observable value is therefore a difference of two nonnegative records, not a negative detector event.
The dichotomy. In a Hilbert space one observable is simultaneously conserved and positive. An indefinite pairing separates these roles.
Theorem 4.4 
(Conservation and positivity are exclusive). Let H ♯ = H generate the Krein-unitary evolution
U ( t ) = e − i H t .
Then:
(i)
1 is conserved, but 1 ∈ C only if η = 1 ;
(ii)
η ∈ C , but its reading is conserved if and only if [ η , H ] = 0 ;
(iii)
no countable family { A m } ⊂ C satisfies ∑ m A m = 1 , whereas, with
P ± = 1 2 ( 1 ± η ) , A ± = η P ± ,
one has
A + + A − = η , A + − A − = 1 ;
(iv)
if the Krein-unitary group acts irreducibly, the only element of C invariant under all of it is 0.
Proof. 
For (i), intensity positivity of 1 would require η ≥ 0 , which fails unless the carrier is definite. For (ii), H ♯ = H implies
H † = η H η .
Hence the Hilbert norm is conserved for every state if and only if H † = H , equivalently [ η , H ] = 0 . For (iii), if ∑ m A m = 1 , then
∑ m η A m = η
would be an increasing limit of positive operators and hence positive, contradicting indefiniteness. The identities for A ± follow from η 2 = 1 . For (iv), invariants lie in the commutant, which by irreducibility consists of scalar multiples of 1 ; no nonzero such multiple lies in C when η is indefinite. □
Corollary 4.5 
(Krein charge and energy). The identity has the conserved signed reading
Q ( ω ) : = ω ( 1 ) = I + ( ω ) − I − ( ω ) , Q ( ω ψ ) = [ ψ , ψ ] .
When [ η , H ] = 0 and H ≥ 0 , the observable η H belongs to C and has nonnegative conserved reading
I η H ( ω ψ ) = ( ψ , H ψ ) .
Energy intensity and signed energy charge are therefore distinct.
Frequencies. For a registered family D = { A m } ⊂ C of mutually exclusive channels with finite nonzero total, define
p ( m ∣ D , ω ) = I A m ( ω ) ∑ n I A n ( ω ) .
Then
p ( m ∣ D , ω ) ≥ 0 , ∑ m p ( m ∣ D , ω ) = 1 .
Probabilities are normalized ratios of registered intensities. On the Standard Model factor of (166), where η SM = 1 , an exhaustive positive family is available and the ordinary Born rule is recovered.
Remark 4.6 
(Covariance and scattering). Every Krein-unitary transformation preserves C , its dual preparation space and the conditional frequencies. Any Krein-unitary scattering operator is therefore measurement-consistent: outgoing channels have nonnegative readings while the signature-weighted sum is the conserved charge. The existence, renormalization and spectral stability of the scattering operator for (158) are dynamical questions and are not settled here. Alternative treatments modify the pole prescription, physical spectrum or inner product [3,21,24,34,36,37,38,39].

5. Possible Metric-Fibre Origin of Generations

The half-spin carrier of Theorem 3.11 fixes the particle content of one chiral Standard Model generation, but it does not determine the number of generations. The metric-fibre dependence of the intrinsic carrier suggests a possible mechanism for this remaining multiplicity.
The interpretation of internal zero-mode multiplicity as fermion-family multiplicity is standard in dimensional reduction and flux compactification. In such constructions, Yukawa matrices arise as overlap integrals of internal mode profiles, and their relative diagonalizations produce the CKM and PMNS matrices [9,20]. In the present setting, the candidate spectral directions are not appended extra dimensions, but the metric-fibre directions already present in Ψ ( x , g x ) .
To resolve this dependence spectrally, one may extend the carrier pairing by integration over a suitable vertical domain Y x ⊆ M 1 , 3 , x ( X ) :
S tot = ∫ X d 4 x − g ∫ Y x μ x ( h ) Re 〈 Ψ ∣ D Ψ 〉 x , h + s F 2 D 2 − F 0 x , h 2 .
Here h denotes the metric-fibre coordinate, while g remains the physical spacetime metric. The generalized transport would contain a vertical component D V , whose contraction D V enters the displacement slot and whose mixed and vertical curvatures enter the curvature slot.
If D V admits normalizable modes,
D V χ n = λ n χ n , Ψ ( x , h ) = ∑ n ψ n ( x ) χ n ( h ) ,
and commutes with the U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) action, then each selected chiral mode χ n multiplies the same half-spin representation. Each such mode therefore supplies one copy of the complete generation found in Theorem 3.11. The effective generation number would be the dimension of the selected low-energy chiral mode space.
The same reduction naturally supplies the matrix structure of flavour. If Y f ( h ) is the component of the Higgs transport in the fermion sector f, then its matrix elements between vertical modes are
( Y f ) m n = ∫ Y x μ x ( h ) χ L , f , m ( h ) | Y f ( h ) | χ R , f , n ( h ) h , f = u , d , e , ν .
For three selected modes these become the usual 3 × 3 Yukawa matrices. After canonical normalization, their relative diagonalizations give
V CKM = U u L † U d L , U PMNS = U e L † U ν L .
The existence of the matrices follows from the mode multiplicity, but their numerical masses, mixing angles and phases depend on the mode profiles and Higgs transport. Nontrivial mixing requires the relevant sectoral overlap operators not to be simultaneously diagonalizable.
This mechanism does not by itself select three generations. That number could arise from a protected chiral index, a symmetry-protected threefold degeneracy, or a spectral gap leaving exactly three light modes. The strongest possibility would be a suitable vertical Fredholm problem satisfying
ind D V = 3 .
The metric fibre is noncompact and carries the indefinite DeWitt form, however, so the ordinary compact Riemannian index theorem does not apply directly. A complete realization would require a physical vertical domain, a measure or pairing, boundary or asymptotic conditions, and a well-defined discrete or Fredholm spectral problem. It would also have to distinguish the fibrewise pairing in (193) from the functional integral over complete metric sections, avoiding double counting of gravitational degrees of freedom.
Metric-fibre modes therefore provide a natural possible origin of generation multiplicity and its associated flavour matrices, while the existence of exactly three suitable chiral modes remains an open spectral problem.

6. Conclusion

This work proposed accumulated transition surprisal as an inferential principle for dynamics. Rather than selecting a history from a prescribed Lagrangian, it compares an infinitesimal displacement with a reference and extracts the Lagrangian from the first-order coefficient of their normalized complex comparison. For the displacement and curvature jets considered here,
J ϵ Ψ = Ψ + i ϵ D Ψ , ϵ D 2 , J r Ψ = Ψ , ϵ F 0 ,
this coefficient is
I = lim ϵ → 0 1 ϵ K J ϵ Ψ , J r Ψ = − i S ,
with
S = ∫ X d d x | g | Re 〈 Ψ ∣ D Ψ 〉 x + s F 2 D 2 − F 0 x 2 .
The exponentiated accumulated surprisal is therefore the usual history weight,
e − I = e i S .
The Dirac term and the quadratic curvature terms arise at the same accumulated order because the state displacement is weighted by ϵ and the curvature displacement by ϵ .
The construction was first calibrated against independently known theories. Changing the carrier, transport, and reference recovers the Dirac and Dirac–Yang–Mills actions, the instanton functional and Bogomolny bound, quadratic gravity with Einstein–Hilbert and cosmological terms, and the corresponding cosmological equations. In this framework the reference is not auxiliary data that disappear from the result: it specifies what the theory declares unsurprising. A flat reference produces the usual curvature norm, a self-dual reference produces the instanton functional, and a constant-curvature reference supplies the dimensionful terms of gravity.
The main application was to an intrinsic carrier built solely from the metric geometry,
Ψ ( x , g x ) ∈ Cl + ( T x X , g x ) ⊗ Σ Sym 2 ( T x * X ) , G g x .
Its admissibility was tested before its dynamics were assembled. The spacetime-algebra factor was required to furnish an unprojected grade-one current with density of fixed sign. The common phase required by transition surprisal was required, following its geometric realization in spacetime algebra, to be furnished intrinsically by both factors of the carrier. On the metric fibre this requires a G g x -compatible complex structure. Among the geometries surviving the current condition, the DeWitt signatures are
( 0 , 1 ) , ( 1 , 2 ) , ( 3 , 3 ) , ( 6 , 4 ) ,
and only ( 6 , 4 ) admits such a compatible complex structure. Within the intrinsic-carrier assumptions of this work, the admissible arena is therefore Lorentzian spacetime of dimension four.
The surviving metric-fibre geometry has orthogonal symmetry Spin ( 6 , 4 ) . Preservation of its compatible complex structure reduces the transport to U ( 3 , 2 ) , while positivity of the selected polarization gives
U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) .
Its unimodular subgroup is the faithful Standard Model gauge group, and its remaining central direction supplies an additional U ( 1 ) X . A chiral half-spin module contains one complete Standard Model generation, including a right-handed neutrino, and the minimal colour-preserving and quark–lepton-preserving odd transport supplies one Higgs doublet and the allowed Yukawa channels. These structures are not appended as an independently chosen internal space: they arise from the spin geometry of the metric-variation fibre.
Accumulating the surprisal of this carrier produces the operator content of the U ( 1 ) X -extended Standard Model coupled to quadratic gravity. The curvature comparison supplies the gauge kinetic terms, the Higgs kinetic and quartic sectors, the nonminimal scalar-curvature coupling, and the gravitational terms
C μ ν ρ σ C μ ν ρ σ , R 2 , E 4 , M P 2 R , Λ .
The displacement comparison supplies the fermion kinetic and Yukawa terms. The resulting fundamental operator basis is local and power-counting renormalizable in four dimensions; its numerical couplings and reference scales remain invariant-pairing and reference data rather than predictions of the present construction.
Quadratic gravity brings an unavoidable interpretive challenge. Its improved ultraviolet propagator contains a massive spin-two pole with opposite residue, so retaining the local renormalizable theory leads naturally to a Hilbert–Krein carrier. The measurement construction developed here separates the signed conserved form from detector readings. The latter are nonnegative additive intensities: they satisfy the first two Kolmogorov requirements and yield ordinary normalized probabilities whenever a registered family has finite nonzero total intensity. The order isomorphism
A ⟼ η A
identifies intensity-positive Krein observables with ordinary positive Hilbert-space effects, allowing measurement families and instruments to be transferred between the two descriptions. Indefiniteness is therefore not, by itself, an obstruction to nonnegative measurement or tomography. This does not settle the separate dynamical questions of interacting stability, causality, or the existence of a consistent renormalized scattering theory.
Several limitations remain explicit. The argument is conditional on the definition of the intrinsic carrier, particularly the use of the full even spacetime algebra, the unprojected current, and the requirement that the phase of surprisal be realized by the carrier’s own geometry. The construction determines one chiral generation but not the observed multiplicity of three. Vertical modes of the metric fibre provide a possible source of generation multiplicity and flavour matrices, but a suitable measure, domain, boundary conditions, and Fredholm or discrete spectral problem have not yet been established.
The central result is that a single normalized comparison of displacement and reference can simultaneously organize inference, phase, matter transport, gauge curvature, and gravitational curvature into an action. When this comparison is applied to the carrier furnished by metric geometry itself, the requirements that the carrier support a positive current and an intrinsic common phase select Lorentzian four-dimensional spacetime and expose within its metric fibre the geometry of one Standard Model generation and its gauge interactions. The resulting chain is
metric geometry ⟶ intrinsic carrier ⟶ positive current and intrinsic phase ⟶ Lorentzian 3 + 1 spacetime ⟶ U ( 3 ) × U ( 2 ) , chiral matter and Higgs transport ⟶ S SM + X + S QG ⟶ e i S = e − I .
In this sense, least surprisal does not replace least action. It precedes it: least action selects a history once the action is known, whereas accumulated surprisal determines the action available to a carrier from its displacement and its reference.

Author Contributions

A. Harvey-Tremblay is the sole author and is responsible for all aspects of the work.

Funding

The author received no funding for this work.

Data Availability Statement

No datasets were generated or analysed. All results are analytic and contained in the manuscript.

Use of Artificial Intelligence

The author used a large language model as an aid during the development and drafting of this manuscript. The author verified and approved all scientific content and takes full responsibility for the claims, derivations and conclusions.

Conflicts of Interest

The author declares no competing interests.

Ethics approval

Not applicable; this work involves no human or animal subjects.

Code availability

Not applicable; all calculations are analytic and contained in the manuscript.

References

  1. Adler, S. L. Axial-Vector Vertex in Spinor Electrodynamics. Phys. Rev. 1969, 177, 2426–2438. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  2. Amari, S.; Nagaoka, H. Methods of Information Geometry; American Mathematical Society: Providence, 2000. [Google Scholar]
  3. Anselmi, D. On the Quantum Field Theory of the Gravitational Interactions. J. High Energy Phys. 2017, arXiv:1704.0772806, 086. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  4. Atiyah, M. F.; Bott, R.; Shapiro, A. Clifford Modules. In Topology; 1964; Suppl. 1, pp. 3–38. [Google Scholar]
  5. Atiyah, M. F.; Singer, I. M. The Index of Elliptic Operators: I. Ann. Math. 1968, 87, 484–530. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  6. Atiyah, M. F.; Singer, I. M. The Index of Elliptic Operators: IV. Ann. Math. 1971, 93, 119–138. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  7. Avramidi, I. G.; Barvinsky, A. O. Asymptotic Freedom in Higher-Derivative Quantum Gravity. Phys. Lett. B 1985, 159, 269–274. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  8. Azizov, T. Ya.; Iokhvidov, I. S. Linear Operators in Spaces with an Indefinite Metric; Wiley: Chichester, 1989. [Google Scholar]
  9. Bachas, C. A Way to Break Supersymmetry. arXiv 1995, arXiv:hep. [Google Scholar]
  10. Baez, J. C.; Huerta, J. The Algebra of Grand Unified Theories. Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 2010, arXiv:0904.155647, 483–552. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  11. Bardeen, W. A. Anomalous Ward Identities in Spinor Field Theories. Phys. Rev. 1969, 184, 1848–1859. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  12. Bell, J. S.; Jackiw, R. A PCAC Puzzle: π0→γγ in the σ-Model. Nuovo Cim. A 1969, 60, 47–61. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  13. Berezin, F. A. Wick and Anti-Wick Operator Symbols. Math. USSR Sb. 1971, 15, 577–606. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  14. Birrell, N. D.; Davies, P. C. W. Quantum Fields in Curved Space; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 1982. [Google Scholar]
  15. Bognár, J. Indefinite Inner Product Spaces; Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1974. [Google Scholar]
  16. Buchbinder, I. L.; Odintsov, S. D.; Shapiro, I. L. Effective Action in Quantum Gravity; IOP Publishing: Bristol, 1992. [Google Scholar]
  17. Čencov, N. N. Statistical Decision Rules and Optimal Inference; American Mathematical Society: Providence, 1982. [Google Scholar]
  18. Chamseddine, A. H.; Connes, A. The Spectral Action Principle. Commun. Math. Phys. 1997, arXiv:hep186, 731–750. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  19. Connes, A.; Lott, J. Particle Models and Noncommutative Geometry. Nucl. Phys. B Proc. Suppl. 1991, 18, 29–47. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  20. Cremades, D.; Ibáñez, L. E.; Marchesano, F. Computing Yukawa Couplings from Magnetized Extra Dimensions. J. High Energy Phys. 2004, arXiv:hep05, 079. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  21. Cutkosky, R. E.; Landshoff, P. V.; Olive, D. I.; Polkinghorne, J. C. A Non-Analytic S Matrix. Nucl. Phys. B 1969, 12, 281–300. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. DeWitt, B. S. Quantum Theory of Gravity. I. The Canonical Theory. Phys. Rev. 1967, 160, 1113–1148. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  23. Dirac, P. A. M. The Quantum Theory of the Electron. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 1928, 117, 610–624. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  24. Donoghue, J. F.; Menezes, G. Unitarity, Stability, and Loops of Unstable Ghosts. Phys. Rev. D. 2019, arXiv:1908.02416100, 105006. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  25. Fradkin, E. S.; Tseytlin, A. A. Renormalizable Asymptotically Free Quantum Theory of Gravity. Nucl. Phys. B 1982, 201, 469–491. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  26. Frieden, B. R. Physics from Fisher Information: A Unification; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 1998. [Google Scholar]
  27. Fritzsch, H.; Minkowski, P. Unified Interactions of Leptons and Hadrons. Ann. Phys. 1975, 93, 193–266. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  28. Georgi, H. The State of the Art—Gauge Theories. AIP Conf. Proc. 1975, 23, 575–582. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  29. Georgi, H.; Glashow, S. L. Unity of All Elementary-Particle Forces. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1974, 32, 438–441. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  30. Hall, M. J. W.; Reginatto, M. Schrödinger Equation from an Exact Uncertainty Principle. J. Phys. A 2002, arXiv:quant35, 3289–3303. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  31. Jaynes, E. T. Information Theory and Statistical Mechanics. Phys. Rev. 1957, 106, 620–630. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  32. Kobayashi, S.; Nomizu, K. Foundations of Differential Geometry, Vol. I; Wiley, New York, 1963. [Google Scholar]
  33. Kolmogorov, A. N. Grundbegriffe der Wahrscheinlichkeitsrechnung; Springer: Berlin, 1933. [Google Scholar]
  34. Kuntz, J. Unitarity through PT Symmetry in Quantum Quadratic Gravity. Class. Quantum Grav. 2025, arXiv:2410.0827842, 175003. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  35. Lawson, H. B.; Michelsohn, M.-L. Spin Geometry; Princeton University Press: Princeton, 1989. [Google Scholar]
  36. Lee, T. D.; Wick, G. C. Negative Metric and the Unitarity of the S Matrix. Nucl. Phys. B 1969, 9, 209–243. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  37. Lee, T. D.; Wick, G. C. Finite Theory of Quantum Electrodynamics. Phys. Rev. D. 1970, 2, 1033–1048. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  38. Mannheim, P. D. Solution to the Ghost Problem in Fourth Order Derivative Theories. Found. Phys. 2007, arXiv:hep37, 532–571. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  39. Mostafazadeh, A. Pseudo-Hermiticity versus PT Symmetry. J. Math. Phys. 2002, 43, 205–214. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  40. Nakahara, M. Geometry, Topology and Physics, 2nd ed.; Institute of Physics Publishing: Bristol, 2003. [Google Scholar]
  41. Parker, L.; Toms, D. Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 2009. [Google Scholar]
  42. Pressé, S.; Ghosh, K.; Lee, J.; Dill, K. A. Principles of Maximum Entropy and Maximum Caliber in Statistical Physics. Rev. Mod. Phys. 2013, 85, 1115–1141. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  43. Quillen, D. Superconnections and the Chern Character. Topology 1985, 24, 89–95. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  44. Reginatto, M. Derivation of the Equations of Nonrelativistic Quantum Mechanics Using the Principle of Minimum Fisher Information. Phys. Rev. A 1998, 58, 1775–1778. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  45. Salvio, A. “Quadratic Gravity,” Front. Phys. 2018, arXiv:1804.099446, 77. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  46. Schmidt, H.-J. The Metric in the Superspace of Riemannian Metrics and Its Relation to Gravity. In Differential Geometry and Its Applications; corrected reprint; Janyška, J., Krupka, D., Eds.; World Scientific, Singapore, 1990; pp. 405–411. [Google Scholar]
  47. Slansky, R. Group Theory for Unified Model Building. Phys. Rep. 1981, 79, 1–128. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  48. Stelle, K. S. Renormalization of Higher-Derivative Quantum Gravity. Phys. Rev. D. 1977, 16, 953–969. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  49. R. F. Streater, Lost Causes in and beyond Physics; Springer: Berlin, 2007.
  50. Witten, E. An SU(2) Anomaly. Phys. Lett. B 1982, 117, 324–328. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.