Submitted:
09 November 2026
Posted:
13 November 2026
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
As a form of theory elaboration, a comparative case illustration of two extremely divergent cases is employed to explore the two radically different evolutionary pathways that could challenge the well-documented team-scale barrier to non-hierarchical coordination. The first pathway is via Frederic Laloux’s proposed “evolution of human consciousness” combined with Mary Parker Follett’s “invisible leader”, and the second pathway is via the evolution of AI. The first case illustration explores a potentially unique example of scalable coordination via elevated human consciousness. A proposed pre-industrial anomaly is analyzed in the organization capability of the Apaches. Based on a distinctive nantan/diyin co-leadership relationship, non-hierarchical strategic coordination may have exceeded the team-scale barrier, despite the bounded rationality constraints that would normally apply. Moreover, their resilience endured across centuries of extreme environmental pressure and genocidal onslaught. This was in stark contrast to the Aztecs, Incas, and Indigenous contemporaries, whose political and military power backed by larger civilizations collapsed almost immediately once the European conquerors arrived. Arguably, the Apaches may have had one of the most resilient and scalable decentralized organizations in human history. However, despite their extraordinary resilience, the pre-industrial conditions that facilitated the proposed Apache model may be an anachronistic anomaly beyond our reach to replicate. As a result, a viable pathway towards organization-scale strategic coordination may require some form of AI. Even more so at modern societal-scale levels, it is argued that AI coevolution will likely be indispensable in achieving increasingly multidimensional human coordination. The business ecosystem platform of the Chinese company Haier is analyzed as the second case illustration to elucidate humanity’s most recent stage of societal-scale coordination via AI. Although this second case points to a viable pathway towards more complex evolutionary levels of multidimensional coordination, AI has still not succeeded in breaking the team-scale barrier without hierarchical coordination.
Keywords:
organization and management
; decentralized organization
; strategic resilience
; organizational democracy
; invisible leader
; coordination
; Apache
; AI
1. Introduction: Can We Predict the Pathway to OD?
Organizational democracy (OD) is defined as strategic, three-dimensional (3D) coordination at organization-scale, based on the four dimensions of the evolutionary intelligence (EI) framework originally introduced in Siegfried (2026a). The EI framework is extended as a theoretical lens and metatheory of coordination in Siegfried (2026b, 2026c, 2026d). It is important to recall here that EI’s four dimensions of coordination are expressed in R:A:D:E network graph format (corresponding to Resources, Alternatives, Directives, and Employees/Effort/Evaluators, respectively). The four dimensions can also be mnemonically described as the “four Ps”: Property/Platform, Preferences, Purposes, and People/Perspectives, respectively. When any of these terms is used in a dimensional context below, it will be followed by its dimensional ID (i.e., R, A, D, or E) unless otherwise clarified. Also, n:n:n refers to the A:D:E dimensions only, and both 1:n and n:n refer to the D:E dimensions only. The small “n” implies all team/organization-scale members of that dimension coordinating, whereas capital “N” implies societal-scale (or Web-scale) coordination for that dimension. A “1” implies dictatorial control over that dimension. Likewise, when there is only D:E coordination (n:n), that implies tactical two-dimensional (2D) coordination; and when adding the alternatives (A) dimension to the mix, that implies strategic (3D) coordination (n:n:n). The latter is the mathematically defined threshold to achieve OD.
As Siegfried (2026d) established, there appear to be no popularized OD practices that can coordinate beyond team-scale. All such non-hierarchical practices fail to achieve OD primarily due to their consistent inability to scale even tactically beyond a team-sized coordination limit of about 20 individuals. That is because the number of coordination integrations required (i.e., the number of network graph nodes) increases exponentially as both the number of dimensions and dimension members to coordinate increase. Without AI, surpassing this bounded rationality limit to achieve coherent 2D or 3D coordination does not appear to be possible, and no organization in modern history has so far been identified that has broken this team-scale barrier.
By stark contrast, an alleged extreme outlier from pre-industrial Western history (per Brafman & Beckström, 2006, pp. 15-21; Ingstad, 2004, pp. xvii-xxxix) is spotlighted to illustrate how non-hierarchical, strategic (3D) coordination may have actually been achieved by the Indigenous Apaches at Tribe/organization-scale, despite the aforementioned bounded rationality constraints. Even more stunning, this coordination appears to have endured across centuries of extreme environmental pressure and genocidal onslaught.
At first glance, given the apparent servant-leadership role of Apache leaders, the proposed Apache model appears to have been just another form of the more familiar benevolent dictatorship model. But it must have been far more than that. It is not credible that such a culturally non-coercive, non-hierarchical system of coherent coordination could sustain itself so resiliently via any form of benevolent top-down leadership alone, especially at organization-scale across so many centuries of extreme disruption. Something much different and more profound appears to be needed to explain this organization outlier. As a tentatively proposed theory, the key enabler may be rooted in the Apache’s distinctive nantan/diyin co-leadership model. Unfortunately, although some aspects of this model could guide future coordination innovation, it may not be possible to replicate this enabler today. As a result, we may be left once again without any viable 3D coordination system in the absence of a future AI innovation to facilitate it.
The purpose of this paper is to help predict the most likely evolutionary pathway from which OD will emerge (as defined by Siegfried, 2026a), and thus the most fruitful research pathway to explore empirically to help manifest it. The Apaches are the first of two extremely divergent coordination case illustrations sampled to help illuminate this pathway, since they arguably represent a pinnacle of human coordination without AI. The second, of course, is an AI-based coordination case illustration. The Chinese appliance conglomerate Haier was selected for this outlier case, since they arguably represent another pinnacle of human coordination with AI.
By leveraging EI as a theoretical lens, a compelling argument has already been made by Siegfried (2026b, 2026c, 2026d) regarding the inexorable coevolution of ICT, AI, the Web, and human coordination along the same basic pathway of increasingly multidimension coordination. However, humanity’s AI-based coordination has arguably still not achieved the level of complex multidimensional coordination that the Apaches had. Therefore, the key question is which evolutionary pathway to OD (and higher levels of societal-scale coordination) is more credible – or at least faster, assuming both are credible: 1) via Frederick Laloux’s (2014) “evolution of human consciousness”, based primarily on the Apache case illustration in conjunction with Mary Parker Follett’s “invisible leader” concept; or 2) via the evolution of AI, based primarily on extrapolating from the Haier case illustration. In addition, since the Apache case is allegedly an extreme organization outlier that we can no longer study today, a second key question to ask is whether the historically proposed Apache co-leadership model could still be replicated today, even by the Apaches themselves.
2. Methods
This paper adopts a comparative case illustration design, utilizing extreme case sampling to compare the two potential evolutionary pathways from which OD will emerge. Although both cases arguably represent a pinnacle of human coordination by modern standards – which is why each case was selected for illustration and conceptual extrapolation into the future – the contrasting attributes of the two cases are so extreme that they seem totally incomparable. In analyzing AI vs. human consciousness evolution, we must also implicitly assess, for example, modern innovations vs. ancient traditions, mathematical integration vs. spiritual interconnectedness, and intense computation vs. profound sympathy, respectively. Moreover, the evolution of AI is clearly a radical structuralist solution to our future human coordination needs, whereas the evolution of human consciousness is unequivocally a radical humanist solution. However, the goal is not to compare the two cases directly, but rather indirectly via the key criterion of which case points to the more likely evolutionary pathway towards more scalable and increasingly multidimensional human coordination vs. where we are today.
In order to make such extreme comparisons possible, the evolutionary intelligence (EI) framework will be applied as a theoretical elaboration lens to qualify the likely scope and scale of human coordination underlying each case. Then the replicability and evolutionary prospects for each pathway will be discussed, beginning from the evolutionary starting point of each case illustration. In other words, neither case will in any way be presented as the definitive blueprint of collective strategic coordination (OD) or be purported to eliminate hierarchical control. Since they are just case illustrations, not formal case studies, they are only meant to help illuminate the two evolutionary starting points and extrapolated pathways to get there in the future: either via a radical structuralist approach (via AI evolution) or via a radical humanist approach (via human consciousness evolution).
3. How the Apaches May Have Scaled Strategic Coordination
3.1. Sympathic Coordination
Currently, no form of 3D n:n:n strategic coordination exists today, since that appears to require AI that also does not yet exist (Siegfried, 2026d). That said, one could argue that n:n:n integration is theoretically possible without AI-enabled coordination via a more spiritualized form of benevolent dictatorship. This will tentatively be called “sympathic coordination”, since it would require much more than just vicarious understanding or moralistic empathy via the more familiar servant-leadership model of management (Sun et al., 2024). Although it is still theoretical, it is arguably as ancient as humanity itself and the Golden Rule.
As such, information and communications technology (ICT) connectivity is technically not a prerequisite for this integration process. The only prerequisite would be deep personal connectivity and identification with one’s fellow human beings across all three EI dimensions related to organizational and personal identity per Siegfried (2026a). A “sympathic coordinator” and leader, such as a chieftain or private company CEO, would strive to connect deeply with and to personally integrate other organization members’ / employees’ perspectives (E), purposes/directives (D), and preferences over alternatives (A). This 3D coordination would be done in order to subjectively prioritize and optimize strategic alternatives (A), such that collective welfare is sufficiently maximized while always sustaining coherent unity, even under severe organizational duress.
“Sympathic” is the term coined here to best describe this necessary depth and complexity of connection, given the root meanings of “sym” (together/same) and “pathos” (feeling). It also avoids the more superficially sentimental connotations that are embedded in the word “sympathetic”, along with the more internalized understanding (or ability) to objectively interpret feelings that is embedded in the word “empathetic” (or “empathic”). Follett similarly criticized both the sentimental and externalized understanding connotations – particularly “sympathy for” and “sympathy from outside”. She preferred instead the explicit terms “dynamic sympathy”, “sympathy with”, and “sympathy of identification” (Follett, 2013, p. 38; Metcalf & Urwick, 1940, p. 218).
Since every organization faces critical decisions and must prioritize strategic alternatives (A), this difficult 3D strategic coordination gap must be filled in some way by either a top-down dictator or a bottom-up sympathic coordinator. Until AI becomes available to coordinate this process collectively, these appear to be the only two options, since strategic coordination beyond team-scale does not appear to exist anywhere today without some form of hierarchical (i.e., dictatorial) control to fill this critical coordination gap (Siegfried, 2026d).
3.2. Why Sympathic – Not Just Empathetic – Coordination Is Necessary
Surprisingly, it has actually been proven mathematically via social choice theory that aggregating the collective prioritizations of alternatives (A) in a consistently coherent fashion that meets minimal criteria of rationality requires cardinal (not just ordinal) interpersonal comparability of utilities as a necessary (not just sufficient) condition (Yamamura, 2017). Although there are still long unresolved – and arguable “impossibility” – issues in aggregating any objective measurements of interpersonal utility levels (see, e.g., Robbins, 1932, 1938; Sen, 2017, pp. 142-181), these computational issues do not necessarily apply in subjective, localized aggregations based on “extended sympathy” (Sen, 2017, pp. 142-181) or “imaginative empathy” (Harsanyi, 1955). The micro-scale feasibility of subjective aggregation is also intuitively obvious to anyone who has successfully resolved prioritization conflicts amongst close friends or family. That said, in order for such subjective utility levels to be cardinally comparable per Yamamura’s (2017) necessary condition, this mathematically and logically also requires a significantly deeper level of “sympathy” beyond just objective moral “empathy” (Adler, 2014; Gandjour, 2024). As these social choice theory authors argue and others agree, such empathy can normally only result in ordinal interpersonal utility comparisons. This lower level of utility granularity has been mathematically proven to be insufficient for the collective prioritization of alternatives (A) in a consistently coherent fashion.
That is why “sympathic” cannot simply mean being nice or empathetic “from outside” while still imposing one’s own top-down decisions or personal moral authority. It means channeling, integrating, and implementing the collective will of one’s organization, even if the hypothetical “sympathic coordinator/leader” personally disagrees with that will. It has the bottom-up depth of meaning that Follett describes as the entire purpose of organization and leadership, which is to seek “integrative unity” via an “interpenetration of values” (i.e., coordinating directives (D) and preferences (A)) and a “uniting of diversity” across all affected employees (E) (Metcalf & Urwick, 1940, pp. 35, 180-81, 192). Follett never lived to see even the very first ICT, let alone AI. So, the only possible means she had to achieve such a pre-ICT coordination objective would be deeply identifying with others’ values and vicariously experiencing their perceived satisfaction levels, and then integrating them together via sympathic coordination. This is what she calls a “unifying of differings” and a “spiritual expansion towards unity”, never a “reduction to unity”. And that is exactly what she continually alludes to and advocates, with more elaboration here from Metcalf & Urwick (1940) (unless otherwise specified):
The leader is more responsible than anyone else for that integrative unity which is the aim of organization (p. 267).
[W]e get control through unity. The great leader is he who so relates all the complex outer forces and all the complex inner forces that they work together effectively (p. 265).
The leader knows also that any lasting agreement among the members of the group can come only by their sharing each other’s experience (p. 285).
[T]he sympathy of identification is very different from the sympathy from outside….The definition of sympathy given by most psychologists to-day is a feeling with rather than a feeling for (p. 218).
When purposes of employees and employers become so integrated that they make one purpose, then we have the most real, the most vital sympathy – a feeling with rather than a feeling for (pp. 218-219).
The power of leadership is the power of integrating. This the power which creates community (Follett, 1918, p. 229).
The urge to unity is not a reduction, a simplification, it is the urge to embrace more and more, it is a reaching out, a seeking, it is the furthest possible conception of pluralism, it is pluralism spiritually not materially conceived. Not the reduction to unity but the expansion towards unity is the social process. That is, the expanding process and the unifying process are the same….the unifying of differings (Follett, 1919).
Likewise, Laloux (2014) allocates very significant portions of his influential book to sympathic-like “wholeness” organizational practices and philosophies to fill this massive gap in collective strategic coordination. In fact, his titular thesis is that “the Next Stage of Human Consciousness” – rather than more AI innovation – is what is critically required to achieve this next level of human coordination. In a way, he could be right if we assume that no such AI innovation will ever arrive. However, as even Laloux woefully concedes, his Teal Organization approach cannot persist without a morally sincere dictator to protect or “hold the space for Teal structures and practices”, which also implicitly requires perpetual private ownership and control by that dictator (Laloux, 2014, pp. 91-92, 237-243, 251-256; Nixon, 2015). That appears to be not just a disqualifying degree of organizational instability, but a definitive dead-end solution for a globalized humanity.
3.3. Why a Sympathic Co-Leadership Model Makes Symbiotic Sense
That said, a sympathic coordinator/leader could perhaps be more sustainably effective by trusting the dispassionate guidance of an intimate advisor whose role it is to maintain such extended sympathic connections on his or her behalf. A potential example of this is the historical relationship between the Apache nantan (chieftain) and the diyin. The latter is often translated as shaman, healer, medicine man/woman, and spiritual leader. However, none of these Westernized terms fully captures the diyin’s multifaceted and powerfully subtle leadership role, especially since each diyin is distinguished by one or more specific and divinely gifted “Powers” (Haley, 1997, pp. 63-67).
Likewise, nantans emerged organically through leading by example and held no coercive power or centralized authority (Brafman & Beckström, 2006, pp. 20, 151-152). As a result, nantans arguably needed a bottom-up way to channel the Tribe’s collective spiritual will consistently and coherently, rather than to command it top-down, in order to maintain their entrusted authority and legitimacy. This is partly supported by the fact that nantans closely paired themselves with diyins with whom they shared a strong familial or friendship bond since childhood (see, e.g., the diyins Geronimo and Lozen below), thereby enhancing their trust-based sympathic connection between each other and the extended Tribe. Moreover, the Tribe’s organic elevation of a prospective nantan appears to have been significantly dependent on the following criteria: 1) “wisdom”, 2) who the “important diyins” were who counseled him in making critical decisions, 3) how “seldom” he decided against his wise counsel, and 4) whether those decisions proved to be “the wisest and most successful” vs. other leaders (Haley, 1997, pp. 155-156). This implies that nantans and diyins were very much perceived by the Tribe as a cohesive and symbiotic co-leadership unit.
Therefore, a tentative theory introduced here is that diyins may have been the channel to that collective will and the sacred repository of “organizational wisdom” (as defined by Siegfried (2026a)). This is very similar to what Follet called “dynamic sympathy”. The diyins would quietly articulate the collective will, particularly in matters of strategic or existential importance, and then the nantans would bring it to life via Tribal leadership. This theory is, by necessity, somewhat speculative due to the paucity of ethnographic evidence regarding the historical nantan/diyin co-leadership relationship. Several primary sources discuss the lives and public healing rituals of diyins, but they do not sufficiently address, let alone fully expose, the more private nantan/diyin relationship dynamic (see, e.g., Bourke, 1892; Goodwin, 1969; Tedlock, 2005). However, there is some indicative evidence to support it, as discussed further below.
Similar to the Apache co-leadership model, Laloux (2014) implicitly relies upon all members of the organization to integrate conflicting perspectives (E), purposes (D), and preferences (A) into a collective will via a similar form of highly evolved 3D sympathic coordination. Although such collective “evolutionary” coordination is necessary to avoid the dictatorial intervention of hierarchical control, Siegfried (2026d) argues that this level of profound human interconnectivity is far too ambitious at organization-scale, and may even be unrealistic at team-scale. Moreover, even if every individual in an organization had the advanced sympathic coordination abilities of a diyin, there would still be the unavoidable problem of reconciling the conflicting integrations articulated by each sympathic coordinator.
A shared cultural foundation of common / unified purpose, beliefs or traditions could certainly help to facilitate coordination in an organization. However, that alone could also not eliminate the many conflicting directives (D) that are situationally dependent, context specific, or only loosely subordinate to any shared organizational purpose, beliefs or traditions. Nor could that shared cultural foundation automatically reconcile the many conflicting perspectives (E) and strategic alternatives (A) that must all be continuously integrated to maintain coherent organizational unity. The 3D strategic coordination problem persists.
By contrast, Follett relies more on a single, unnamed “invisible leader” to do all of the sympathic coordination, which is clearly compatible with the proposed Apache model (Follett, 2013, p. 38; Metcalf & Urwick, 1940, pp. 267-268, 288-292). On the one hand, Follett advocates that even the visible leader (CEO) must be an unwavering follower of this invisible leader, yet on the other she emphasizes that the CEO too must develop these sympathic abilities to be successful and to “articulate” with genuine conviction (i.e., accuracy) the invisible leader’s will, which she calls the “common purpose”. The latter is not just a single dominant purpose or shared overall directive (D), as the EI framework would define this term. It is the spiritually collective will, since it represents the full, post-coordination “integrative unity” across all dimensions of coordination:
[The common purpose] should be a purpose evolved by all the interweaving of activities of the enterprise. The best type of leader does not seek his ends, but the ends disclosed by an evolving process in which each [individual] has his special part. (Metcalf & Urwick, 1940, p. 288).
Leader and followers are both following the invisible leader, the common purpose. The best executives put this common purpose clearly before their group. While leadership depends on depth of conviction and the power coming there from, there must also be the ability to share that conviction with others, the ability to make purpose articulate. And then that common purpose becomes the leader. And I believe that we are coming more and more to act, whatever our theories, on our faith in the power of this invisible leader. Loyalty to the invisible leader gives us the strongest possible bond of union, establishes a sympathy which is not a sentimental but a dynamic sympathy. (Follett, 2013, p. 38)
Follett even labels this interplay between the visible leader “finding” the “evolving” common purpose / will that is “disclosed” by the invisible leader as a “multiple leadership” model (Metcalf & Urwick, 1940, p. 288). Therefore, she clearly recognizes the two leadership roles as being symbiotically distinct, if not separate. And then, in the same paragraph, she implies that the invisible leader is an integrated aggregation of “widely diffused leadership”, and that “our hope for the future [perhaps referring to societal-scale coordination] depends on a still more widely diffused leadership”. Thus, in essence, Follet’s invisible leader is a personified coherent aggregation of the collective will.
3.4. Apache Diyin as the Personified “Invisible Leader”
Follet’s vision appears fully compatible with the proposed Apache model due to the following: 1) diyin appear to aggregate the common purpose / will via an integrated union of “widely diffused [invisible] leadership”, 2) the nantan (like the CEO) should have a deep personal connection with the diyin (the invisible leader) to qualify for the separate sympathic leader role, and 3) everyone has something to contribute to this collective will as a member of the Tribal circle (or any organization). Astonishingly, Follett did not cite a single historical example to support any actual personification of the invisible leader, even though such a mechanism or vehicle for this collective will appears to be necessary. Yet she could still somehow theorize how even a CEO must dutifully follow that invisible leader as if she had envisioned it being a real person, like a diyin.
With respect to point #2 above, a trusted, sympathic connection between nantan and diyin is arguably also necessary in order for the nantan to fully assimilate, articulate and make manifest the collective will of the Tribe, as Follet likewise implies. This collective will is what the diyin (as invisible leader) is dynamically integrating and communicating to the nantan via his or her sympathic coordinator role. Without this “extended sympathy” also existing between nantan and diyin, only ordinal interpersonal utility levels could be adequately communicated to the nantan per social choice theory, as explained above. Although a consistently rational collective ranking of alternatives (A) could still be possible in such a scenario, this would result in the loss of valuable cardinal interpersonal utility information in strategic decision making that could sometimes prove very costly to both Tribal cohesiveness and survival. That is because extreme variances in collective cardinal utility levels between adjacently ranked alternatives could still result in a severe misallocation of Tribal resources if the actual allocation is based instead on ordinal utility (i.e., ranking) alone.
As spiritual leaders and healers of body and mind, a diyin naturally developed deeply personal and spiritual relationships with many Tribe members. For example, they relied by necessity on sympathic, wholistic connections when diagnosing and treating their patients. This included unconventional and deeply personal diagnostic methods such as somatic empathy and clairsentience via “hand trembling”, often followed by spiritually inspired herbalistic remedies (Opler, 1996, pp. 213-214, 2002, pp. 29-30, 215-216), rather than relying on modern medical technology, which objectivizes patients as broken machines. Curing rites led by a diyin comprised a majority of all Apache ceremonies, and they sometimes extended over several days, with intimate storytelling and the sharing and interpretation of prophetic dreams by both patient and diyin (Opler, 1996, 2002). The stories, dreams, and prophetic interpretations were naturally focused primarily on the future of both the patient and the other ceremonial participants / Tribe, since the future was their primary source of uncertainty and concern.
This provides at least some positive documentary evidence that diyins were constantly sharing and collecting deeply personal evaluations about the critical strategic events surrounding the Tribe’s past and many possible futures during these frequent and lengthy curing rites. Moreover, Tribe members would naturally be at their most physically vulnerable and emotionally exposed during these extended ceremonies. This would allow a diyin to capture and synthesize in a sympathic manner the necessary depth of emotions and information shared to best interpret the past and present, and to best find the Tribe’s (and the patient’s) most promising future.
Likewise, the interpretation of dreams and real world “signs” – not just during healing ceremonies, but in general – was a culturally pervasive practice that allowed a diyin many additional opportunities to elicit and share such personal interpretations, evaluations, and prognostications related to a Tribe’s strategically uncertain future (Opler, 1996, pp. 186-193, 2002, pp. 274-276). Anthropological ethnographies of Navajo diyin / shaman document these deeply spiritual and intimate healing practices and prophetic interpretations as well (see, e.g. Goodwin, 1969; Milne & Howard, 2000; Tedlock, 2005). The Navajo are linguistically and culturally one of the seven Apachean groups (Ingstad, 2004).
3.5. Augmented Sortition as the Sympathic Coordination Scaling Mechanism
It is therefore conjectured that the necessarily random nature of these intimate diyin relationships would have serendipitously created a sortition-like random sampling of deep personal connections to the Tribe’s collective will. By definition, this would include the Tribe’s collectively desired future and which strategic alternatives (A) to pursue to get there. A sortition mechanism is what allows a much smaller sampling of independent random evaluations to scale in accuracy across a whole organization, and potentially across an entire society (Zeitoun et al., 2014). In the case of Apache diyin, this sortition effect would likely have been augmented even further by its focus upon ailing elders and wounded warriors due to their naturally higher medical needs. These individuals would have been the most common patients, who were naturally also the wisest, the most politically influential, and the most strategically knowledgeable members of the Tribe.
This serendipitously-enhanced sortition, aggregation, and integration of the Tribal collective will via the “invisible leader” vehicle of the diyin is therefore quite intriguing as a tentative theory. It becomes even more so given the critically central importance of the sortition mechanism to the lasting and resilient success of Athenian democracy (Zeitoun et al., 2014). As Siegfried (2026a, 2026c) repeatedly emphasizes, such “organizational wisdom”, via rationally coherent collective decision making based on independent individual evaluations, is the linchpin enabling capability of any resilient, “evolutionary organization” or society.
Coincidentally, we are also now seeing a strong revival of this sortition-driven “demarchy” in corporate boards, union leadership teams, and citizens’ assemblies to address single-issue choices (Baharav & Flanigan, 2024; Flanigan et al., 2021; Landemore, 2020; Pek, 2019; Van Reybrouck, 2018). Citizens’ assemblies, in particular, can involve hours-long education and deliberation sessions over several days to share not just information, but intimate personal feelings (i.e., interpersonal utility levels) about very controversial societal-scale issues, such as the legalization of assisted dying. That said, the single issue / alternative (A) approval voting scenario of demarchy only requires a one-dimensional integration of conflicting perspectives (E). Therefore, demarchy and its sortition mechanism alone cannot solve the more multidimensional problem of strategic coordination, let alone at organization-scale. An additional mechanism is required for more complex multidimensional coordination across the three strategic dimensions, E, D, and A. Therefore, the following proposition is suggested:
Proposition: Independent quasi-random sampling of sympathic connections between the diyin and the most highly representative strategically knowledgeable members of his or her Tribe (from a collective will perspective) may have allowed the diyin to scale intimate, sympathic-based strategic coordination accurately across the entire Tribe, well beyond the abovementioned team-scale barrier that would normally apply, especially when the widely respected divine “Power” of the diyin related directly to a critical strategic skill for the Tribe’s survival.
Assuming this proposition is true, the collective will (or “common purpose”) of the Tribe would dynamically reveal or “disclose” itself to the diyin, and hence to the nantan; and then the nantan could articulate that will in leading the Tribe. As a result, Tribal loyalty and resilience would be greatly enhanced due to the collectively dynamic coherence and union of that will, strengthened by centuries-long shared traditions and values. The less resilient alternative is the Tribe (or band) reluctantly following the coercive and collectively incongruent will of a transient dictatorial leader.
3.6. The Apache Diyins Geronimo and Lozen
Geronimo was one such example of a diyin who led bands of Apaches, even though he himself was never officially a nantan (Roberts, 1993, pp. 111, 119). Likewise, Lozen, the sister of the Apache nantan Victorio, was another famous diyin. Victorio described her not just as a great warrior in battle, but “as my right hand… cunning in strategy… a shield to her people”, and she held a leading role on the council of warriors (Roberts, 1993). Lozen in particular was renowned for having legendary sympathic abilities, including the divinely gifted or intuitive “Power” to guide her nantan brother to the best decisions in a strategic crisis or battle, even to the point of psychically anticipating the movements and locations of their enemies with astounding accuracy (Roberts, 1993, pp. 178, 206; Robinson & Ball, 2000, pp. 3-15). As an alleged form of clairsentience or remote sensing, the palms of her outstretched hands allegedly tingled or burned and changed color to varying degrees while she was in a meditative state of prayer, telling her in which direction and how far away their enemies were.
Like Lozen, Geronimo was also the right-hand man of his nantan, Juh, who “came to rely on Geronimo as his spokesman” (Roberts, 1993, pp. 62-63). They shared a very strong bond since childhood, which only increased when Juh married Geronimo’s favorite sister (Roberts, 1993, p. 206). In his strategic co-leadership role, Geronimo similarly had the divinely promised and gifted strategic “Powers” from his youth as follows: 1) to never be killed by any weapon in battle (which came true, despite many intense battles later against far superior weapons), 2) living to an old age (which he did), 3) having the clairvoyant “ability to divine events as they were happening miles away” or even in the future (with uncanny accuracy per several companion accounts), and 4) being a famously successful healer (just like Lozen) (Ball et al., 1988, pp. 13-14; Roberts, 1993, pp. 62-63, 119-120, 232-233).
Whether one believes these diyins truly had these superhuman strategic abilities or not, the entire Tribe clearly revered their “Powers” as divinely gifted. The Tribe instinctively trusted what may have actually been the diyins’ sympathic collective wisdom to make such critical strategic decisions under circumstances of significant uncertainty. Such reverence and trust are also clearly indicative of the diyins’ consistently proven reliability and level of influence over the Tribe’s strategic coordination decisions, per multiple sources (Ball et al., 1988; Roberts, 1993). For example, according to Haley (1997, p. 65), Apaches themselves were “uniformly emphatic in their affirmation of [diyin] accuracy” in terms of the diyins’ ability to “augur happenings” when later recounting to “white researchers” their personal experiences from healing ceremonies.
According to the logic of Occam’s Razor, the simpler explanation for this documented and remarkably consistent alleged ability is not direct divine intervention or revelation. It would more likely be the result of a diyin’s coherent and ongoing sympathic coordination of collective strategic wisdom across the Tribe’s conflicting perspectives (E), directives (D), and alternatives (A). If so, then a diyin’s uncanny “superhuman” accuracy would just be the direct consequence of the well documented “wisdom of crowds” effect (Surowiecki, 2005), even though to both the diyin and the Tribe it would likely seem indistinguishable from divine revelation. This documented effect is nearly always astounding, and sometimes even shocking, in its real-world accuracy, as Surowiecki (2005) illustrates in case after case. However, the effect is ultimately due to nothing more than the statistical variance in the average always being smaller than the average variance, in direct proportion to the number of independent individuals (i.e., the size of the “crowd”) contributing to any highly uncertain estimate (Siegfried, 2026a).
Tragically, Lozen’s nantan brother Victorio and many of their people were finally hunted down by the American and Mexican cavalries. However – perhaps not coincidentally – they were killed during one of the rare instances when Lozen had to separate herself from her brother to deliver a baby. After the delivery, she fought her way back to safety in Mexico over many weeks with the mother and newborn child (Ball, 1981, pp. 115-120; Roberts, 1993, pp. 186-192).
3.7. The Apaches’ Exceptional Strategic Resilience Demands Explanation
What is perhaps most intriguing to understand about Apache decentralized coordination is how demonstrably resilient it was by comparison. This was the main impetus for this paper in proposing a credible model to explain it. For example, the Spanish arrived as conquerors (no longer as just explorers) in the Americas around 1519 under the leadership of Cortés. In just two years, the Aztec empire was militarily obliterated by the Spanish and completely collapsed politically (Brafman & Beckström, 2006, pp. 17-21). A similar fate befell the exceptionally advanced Incas about a decade later when the Spanish applied their standard decapitation strategy of killing the leader (emperor) and taking the gold. Their political leadership was conquered and replaced in less than two years (Brafman & Beckström, 2006), notwithstanding some isolated guerilla resistance for some time thereafter when the puppet emperor later turned against the Spanish and retreated to a remote Amazonian mountain location to form a rump state (Lee, 2018). Similar fates have befallen many other Indigenous tribes worldwide with traditional top-down leadership structures, particularly at the hands of the Spanish (Thomas, 2003; Restall, 2003). Indigenous massacres, genocide, dehumanization, cultural desecration, and sustained political oppression generally followed soon thereafter.
By contrast, when the powerful Spanish armies encountered the Apaches, it was the Spanish, not the Apaches, that lost significant land that they had previously conquered from other Indigenous peoples (Ingstad, 2004, pp. xvii-xxxix). The Apaches were fundamentally unlike any opponent the Spanish had ever encountered (Ingstad, 2004). With severely inferior weaponry, the Apaches held off the Spanish for another two centuries, and then the Americans for a couple of decades after that (Ingstad, 2004). No matter how many nantans were killed, the Apaches could not be defeated; new nantans just organically emerged despite severe and repeated organizational disruption (Ingstad, 2004; Brafman & Beckström, 2006, pp. 17-21, 47, 151).
Based on the proposition above, the Apaches may have sustained their coherent coordination of bands and the overall Tribe via the sympathic coordination of diyins guiding the emergent leadership of new nantans, rather than via traditional top-down command-and-control. Likewise, it is perhaps no coincidence that the Apache Wars officially ended when the diyins Geronimo and Lozen surrendered together with other members of their Tribe in 1886. The spiritual unifying core of the demonstrably resilient Apache co-leadership structure was neutralized. From that point onward, only sporadic, uncoordinated guerilla resistance remained, but even that lasted a few more decades until about 1924 in the U.S. and 1933-35 in Mexico.
3.8. Alternative Explanations of Apache Strategic Resilience
An alternative proposition could be that the Apaches were just better at hiding or sustainably living off of the land due to their intimate knowledge of the land. However, that explanation cannot adequately explain how they drove the Spanish out of major regions like the northern Sonora and Chihuahua, along with northwestern Mexico, often raiding the Spanish bulwarks against the Apaches with impunity until the Spanish abandoned them (Ingstad, 2004). Nor can it explain why the Apaches were so uniquely resilient vs. many other Indigenous peoples, who also had intimate knowledge of their lands. The Apaches were so resilient, in fact, that the most reliable, fault-tolerant, and scalable web servers of the modern era were named after them. Ironically, the open-source software upon which they are based is still maintained today by similar decentralized, autonomous teams of dedicated individuals.
That said, one could argue that every resilient, fault-tolerant system of coordination relies on at least one fundamental principle that should never be violated, and the revered Geronimo likely did exactly that. After his family was ruthlessly massacred by Mexicans in 1851, Geronimo clearly crossed the line from dispassionate sympathic diyin to warrior leader: “For ten straight years after Arizpe, Geronimo raided into Mexico. He was nearly always the instigator, for his lust for revenge upon the Mexicans was insatiable” (Roberts, 1993, pp. 109-118). He even employed reckless tactics that “Apaches almost never pursued”, causing unnecessary Apache deaths for which even Geronimo guiltily admitted, “Some of the Apaches blamed me for the evil result of the expedition” (Roberts, 1993, p. 116). His personal bloodlust for revenge appears to have made him not just less capable of channeling and integrating the collective, resilient will of his warriors and his people, but to be in direct opposition to it. This may have been a key factor leading to the ultimate military surrender of the Apache people and their extremely resilient form of organization.
A second, alternative proposition to explain the extraordinary Apache resilience is the potential mediating variable of communally shared wealth. This was facilitated not by any explicit or centralized communal ownership, but rather by a strong culture of gift-giving, generosity, unreciprocated borrowing, and general sharing / circulating of personal property not currently needed or in use (Opler, 1996, pp. 397-400). Even “trading” or “selling” was something generally only done with those outside of the Tribe. This would have allowed the Apaches to keep all of their wealth fully decentralized and highly productive, unlike the Aztecs, Incas and so many other Indigenous peoples, who relied on large stores of passive wealth to function as a society. Without any hoarded or centralized unproductive wealth like gold under the control of a dictatorial Tribal leader who could be killed or compromised, there was no easy way to take control over the Apaches via that usurped wealth.
Ironically, this alternative explanation only further supports the argued proposition that the Apache’s strategic resilience was primarily due to their decentralized coordination capabilities. It simply adds the fourth and final resources (R) dimension to the decentralization proposition, which describes how organization-scale 3D strategic coordination may have occurred across the E, D, and A dimensions. If so, then this would lead to the extraordinary implication that the Apaches may have been the first potential case of full 4D n:n:n:n organization-scale coordination across human history.
Also, even if this additional mediating variable were found to be significant in explaining some strategic resilience, it could only explain how the Apaches avoided attracting conflict over resources (R) with the Spanish. This is opposite of what happened historically. Moreover, the Apaches successfully prevailed in those conflicts over such a long period, which would require effective 3D strategic coordination too.
That said, there is likely some truth to the relevance of this potential mediating variable of resource (R) dimension decentralized control. Collective beneficial ownership of a business by employees (e.g., via a U.S. ESOP trust) is persuasively hypothesized to have a similar neutralizing effect on the dictatorial shareholder primacy directive otherwise dominating the resources (R) dimension (Siegfried, 2026d). Such centralized dictatorial control can negatively impact organizational effectiveness, especially when serving shareholders and their short-term interests significantly overrides serving customers and their long-term interests. That is because any top-down dictatorial control over any one of the four dimensions of organization would impede the otherwise natural evolutionary resilience of decentralization via competitive multidimensional coordination (Siegfried, 2026a).
Thomas J. Nevins, the cultural anthropologist specializing in Apache ethnography who wrote the introduction to Ingstad (2004), implicitly confirms the critical importance of this mediating resource (R) dimension variable. In interview comments documented by Brafman and Beckström (2006, pp. 151-152), Nevins argues that the primary reason the Apaches were ultimately defeated militarily was due to the American government cunningly gifting nantans cattle, presumably in their name or under their direct personal control. The Americans “realized that they needed to attack the Apache at a very basic level in order to control them” – to “centralize them” with gifts (Brafman & Beckström, 2006). In essence, cattle gifted directly to the nantans was, by design, a cultural Trojan Horse to accomplish the colonial objective of subverting the non-coercive, symbolic leadership role of nantans. And it apparently worked. The nantans “began fighting each other for seats on newly created Tribal councils” to gain authoritative control over this massive store of passive wealth, and then Tribe members lobbied antagonistically for more allocations of it to “create a zero-sum battle over resources” (Brafman & Beckström, 2006).
This led to the deliberately intended effect of centralizing an otherwise resilient organization that may have been fully decentralized across all four dimensions of human organization. And once the resources (R) dimension fell under dictatorial control, the other three dimensions could easily follow, which may have been facilitated by the abovementioned disintegration of the proposed nantan/diyin symbiotic co-leadership model. Once power became concentrated at the top as a result of symbolic power transforming into material power, the once flat Apache organization became hierarchical under a centralized government, which the Americans were finally able to control (Brafman & Beckström, 2006, p. 152). Similar methods of propping up a puppet dictator have been used repeatedly by colonial and neocolonial extractive empires throughout history to solidify political control over land, resources, and the local dictator’s coercive power hierarchy.
4. How Haier Scaled Its Business Ecosystem Platform via AI
4.1. The 1:N Organization
To illustrate how the core coordination functionality of AI enables societal-scale human coordination, one of the newest forms of organization will be analyzed through this metatheory lens. Due to its coordination capability that extends well beyond the traditional confines of a single firm, it is often referred to as a “business ecosystem”. The “platform” suffix is also often added, since a specialized ICT and AI platform must generally be leveraged as its engine of coordination. One peculiar form of this innovation by the Chinese appliance conglomerate Haier is called RenDanHeYi (RDHY) (Minnaar et al., 2022). “Uberization” was similarly coined for a single business ecosystem platform focused on the ride-hailing industry (Davis & Sinha, 2021). A good compendium of how such platforms work from 28 contributors is provided by Crainer (2023). One of the key attributes these platforms tend to have in common is their N:N societal-scale connectivity and interaction, which creates a valuable ecosystem via traditional network effects. However, similar to social media networks, none of this N:N interactivity by independent individuals represents two-dimensional coordination within an organization.
A core concept in all of these structures is essentially a marketplace to match buyers with sellers and then to complete transactions, similar to a stock market. But that too is nothing special. Any free-market system is nothing more than 1:1 coordination, since every individual acts independently of any organization. They can choose at any time to become the dictatorial buyer or seller by offering the highest bid or lowest ask price, respectively, to seize momentary dictatorial control over a particular “market price”. Freedom, not coordination, is the hallmark of this system. Therefore, neither N:N ICT interactivity nor a 1:1 free-market system can explain why these platform-based organizations have been so incredibly disruptive from a multidimensional innovation point of view.
Fortunately, EI’s metatheory lens of coordination explains why. These organizations represent the evolution of a whole new form of multidimensional coordination: the 1:N organization. This is analogous to 1:n rule-based consensus used in teams (Siegfried, 2026d), except automated up to societal-scale N via AI. They are not just free-market systems, like societal-scale stock markets, scaling 1:1 coordination via powerful hardware and software automation. They can be more appropriately called “coordination-market systems”. That is because there is never a dictatorial buyer or seller. Also, the market price alone is never decisive, and there is never just one winning offer. All participating members offering their services are routinely “winners”, as their automated offers are continuously coordinated and transacted by the business ecosystem platform. Complex pre-defined matching algorithms are used to synthesize multiple competing directives (D) into optimized outcomes for all participating platform members or their customers (E). This defining feature of ecosystems is confirmed by Jacobides et al. (2024) in their recent literature review: “[Ecosystems] serve as governance arrangements to internalize the externalities of these cooperation interdependencies” and to “define the roles and rules of participation” via “a relational architecture of interfirm collaboration”. The “autonomous” AI-driven scalability of this ecosystem governance feature is also confirmed by the authors.
4.2. An Algorithmic Dictator over Directives Defines 1:N Coordination
Note that 1:N is technically still only 1D coordination, but the magic here is really in the AI-based dictator of the directives (D) dimension that is able to coordinate conflicts in automated fashion across an entire society of N members (the E dimension). The embedded system of statistically driven optimization rules itself is the virtual dictator (the “1” part). Therefore, 1D coordination is still “multidimensional” in the sense of a complex AI dictator from one organization dimension (D) coordinating all members of another dimension (E). Likewise, in consensus-based teams, 1:n is based on Barker’s (1993) “concertive control” process, which is an increasingly restrictive cultural synthesis of social norms and rules (Siegfried, 2026d). By stark contrast, 1:N is based on an algorithmic synthesis of much more scalable, often non-deterministic, AI rules that can often conflict. The purpose of any dictatorial system of rule-based AI consensus is to automate the statistical integration of competing directives (D). And the more rules that are relevant in any automated process, the more likely they will conflict.
Compared to integrating unique personal profiles of directives (D), the number of directives (D) in a strict business context is far more limited. That is because business utilities with respect to price, quality, timeliness, profit-sharing, etc. are far easier to universalize objectively within a calculated AI rule than multistakeholder personal utilities would be. Personal utilities are far more subjective. So, to take Uber as a hypothetical example, if there are, say, five business directive (D) variables or 20 common profiles of directives (D) to integrate across a town of 100 Uber drivers and their customers, there may still be only five directive (D) variables or 20 profiles to integrate across a city of 100,000 Uber drivers and their customers. That is what makes 1:N coordination often so scalable in a business context. The virtual coordination complexity of 1:N may increase only linearly with N, despite the required societal-scale computation.
Jacobides et al. (2024, pp. 3, 7) hints at this vast scalability difference between coordinating across the very limited and standardized “complementarities” (i.e., directives (D)) in a 1:N “business ecosystem” context vs. coordinating across all citizens and their unique profiles of directives (D) in a “unified governance” political context. This difference is easy to grasp when one realizes that business ecosystems are coordinating across a fixed and low number of directives (D, generally <10) with static algorithmic rules. By contrast, in a political context, there would be an exponentially higher level of difficulty in coordinating across thousands or more unique and dynamic personal profiles of directives (D) as the number of contributors (i.e., citizens) increases.
4.3. Oticon vs. Haier: Why 1:1 Coordination Is Insufficient when 1:N Needed
As emphasized by Siegfried (2026b, 2026c, 2026d), it should not be underestimated how important it is for the required ICT and AI to exist in order to create such a complex ecosystem platform. Entire business units (BUs) and prospective employees (E) within Haier have used such an AI-enabled platform to bid, contract, and profit-share with each other across multiple directives (D) in an automated and ongoing fashion. An interesting case to compare against Haier is Oticon, a Danish hearing-aid producer that reorganized into similar team-sized microenterprises. Like Haier, it experienced extraordinary initial success after doing so in 1990, but the structure effectively collapsed starting in 1995. Foss (2003) and Foss & Klein (2022, pp. 89-102) document this rise and fall in detail, which is important due to how Oticon “has been one of the most used cases in business school teaching” and “has become a key poster child for the death-of-hierarchy narrative.” In his earlier 2003 paper, Foss summarizes the cause of collapse like this: “Frequent managerial meddling with delegated rights led to a severe loss of motivation.” However, in his more recent 2022 book with Klein, they correctly pivot towards the meddling just being a proximate cause. The root cause was the fundamental inability of Oticon’s simplistic 1:1 price-driven markets between BUs to “organize” (i.e., to coordinate) effectively (Foss & Klein, 2022, pp. 100-103). This is especially the case when “the pieces [increasingly] don’t fit together” over time because they “involve a lot of interdependencies that have to be managed” (Foss & Klein, 2022, p. 110). The latter could just as easily be restated as, “multiple directives beyond just price that have to be synthesized”, which is the core automation provided by the more complex 1:N coordination of competing directives (D) that was missing at Oticon. Price is just one of many relevant directives.
Yet another critical advantage of 1:N coordination is that it is an N-scale ecosystem. By contrast, Oticon and other attempts at creating internal markets would have only been n-scale, even if they had replicated the multi-directive (D) coordination capabilities of Haier within the walls of their own company. N-scale is characterized by permissionless societal-scale participation in the ecosystem by individuals and businesses, even before formalizing any job position or contract within it, whereas n-scale consists of only existing employees (E) and internal departments. Under n-scale, existing competencies must not only be relied upon even when better external market suppliers exist; they must also be vigorously defended by top management from outside threats. At Haier, by contrast, any interested outside individuals are actually paid a subsistence amount while they get free training and do no work. These are the incentives just for joining the “talent pool” so that they can then be matched to open roles up to three months later (Minnaar et al., 2022, pp. 88-95). Moreover, the entire supply chain is open to outside businesses, including digitally via application programming interfaces.
Since Haier is not a closed n-scale (single-organization) system, it is not concerned about new businesses or other outsiders displacing existing businesses or employees (E). It already dominates the entire industry ecosystem, and it actively incubates and nurtures nearly all the new start-ups and new employees (E) within it, so there is no real “outside” threat. As Haier’s CEO frequently emphasizes, his focus is on helping the entire industry flourish as a diverse ecosystem “rainforest” via evolutionary “creative destruction”; he has no interest in tending and protecting a single “closed garden” (Minnaar et al., 2022, pp. 7, 208-219). And as a Haier senior executive frankly admitted, “we do not have real competitors” (Minnaar et al., 2022, p. 72), while going on to explain that Haier would likely coopt such a hypothetical competitor by default via their “microenterprise platform”. Risk is also spread out over hundreds, even thousands, of teams, so the law of large numbers comes into play. Moreover, their “zero fund” policy further reduces risk on the front end, by ensuring that all new microenterprise (ME) projects are denied significant funding until prototypes are validated by many end users first (Hamel & Zanini, 2020, p. 95). This dramatically reduces the number of demoralizing top-down strategic interventions later due to too many failed, unproven initiatives, like at Oticon.
4.4. Why 1:1 Rule-Based AI Is Also Insufficient When 1:N AI Is Needed
Similarly, 1:1 AI is also insufficient when 1:N AI is needed to scale the human coordination. That is because 1:1 AI is just older “expert system” coordination, first popularized during the 1970s-1980s based on linear, deterministic logic designed to capture an “expert’s” static thought process. Similar to 1:1 human coordination via dictatorial hierarchies, 1:1 AI is often characterized by simpler IF-THEN hierarchical command-and-control over data outputs or robotic actions. By contrast, 1:N coordination is akin to the more computationally intensive machine learning or predictive analytics coordination that is based on parallel, probabilistic variables synthesized algorithmically. First popularized during the late 1990s-2000s, 1:N AI is often characterized by multiple independent variables having a simultaneous, statistically integrated impact on a dependent variable (Siegfried, 2026b). It is designed to explain, predict or optimize via constantly evolving pattern recognition rather than via static, deterministic command-and-control rules.
This distinction points to the most critical criterion for 1:N coordination, which is that the multiple independent variables often have a conflicting statistical impact upon the dependent variable. In both the Haier and Uber cases, the members of the directives (D) dimension are the conflicting independent variables that need to be statistically integrated into a coherent algorithmic dictator (the “1” in the “1:N”) to prioritize their collective impact on the individual N members of the employee (E) dimension. By contrast, with 1:1 AI, there is no multidimensional coordination required, since there are no conflicting statistical impacts between dimension members to coordinate. The 1:1 expert system logic is generally just linear and deterministic, despite its branching hierarchical logic.
According to Delipetrev (2020), there have been three distinct eras (and thus evolving definitions) of AI so far. And according to Siegfried (2026b), these correspond exactly to the first three quadrants of the evolutionary intelligence (EI) framework, each requiring increasingly multidimensional coordination. The Automation Intelligence quadrant (focused on generating actions and data) automates 1:1 coordination, the Business Intelligence quadrant (focused on generating new information from synthesizing new data and existing information) automates 1:N coordination, and the Collective Intelligence quadrant (focused on generating new knowledge from synthesizing new information and existing knowledge) automates N:N coordination.
For example, deep learning and generative AI represent the most recent AI innovations to automate the coordination of unstructured document and media data in N:N fashion at Web-scale. The latter is achieved via a sequential 2D layering of N:N neural networks (See Posner et al., 2019, pp. 213-220 for an easy visual introduction to neural networks). Although N:N currently represents the most advanced form of AI today, there is no N:N form of human organization yet; hence the choice of Haier as the case illustration. The most advanced form of human coordination that exists today without AI is only team-scale n:n via self-management practices (Siegfried, 2026d).
Due to bounded rationality constraints, the multidimensional AI innovation must always come first before the same level of multidimensional human coordination can be achieved at societal-scale (e.g., to move from n:n to N:N) (Siegfried, 2026b, 2026c). In fact, as forthcoming research will argue, it is predicted that N:N human coordination may arrive soon, followed by N:N:N and then N:N:N:N AI and human coordination over a much longer time horizon. As even the advanced Haier case indicates, these more complex levels of coordination will eventually become necessary as the less complex forms become increasingly insufficient.
4.5. Haier May Fail Too When 1:N Coordination Becomes Insufficient
Oticon, ironically self-styling itself as a “spaghetti organization”, ultimately failed due to its lack of any 1:N (or even 1:n) coordination mechanism to manage its lateral, market-based interdependencies between its otherwise independent BUs. However, it is possible that Haier may only be deferring a similar fate due to its inability to coordinate strategically across at least three organization dimensions, instead of just two like now. Haier initially relied on the geographic independence and “modularity” of its MEs (per Foss & Klein, 2022, pp. 109-111), with optimal team sizes of only 10-15 individuals each (Hamel & Zanini, 2020, p. 86). This naturally decreased their initial interdependence and AI-based coordination requirements, both within and between MEs. However, several of the most successful MEs have since grown into much larger organizations called Ecosystem Micro-Communities (EMCs), which have then unavoidably transformed their partner MEs into nearly captive departments. Even a single production line in one of these EMCs can contain many dedicated MEs contracting with each other (Minnaar et al., 2022, p. 136). Thus, the ineluctable march towards captive bureaucratic bloat continues in a different form, and the paradoxical curse of scaling success persists.
In fact, the organization cracks are already emerging at Haier, especially as it grows via acquisition beyond China, and as individual companies try to replicate its coordination-market system in 1:n fashion without being in a much larger 1:N ecosystem (Minnaar et al., 2022, pp. 157-185). For example, U.S. EMCs at Haier “often have over 2,000 members” (Minnaar et al., 2022, p. 171), which would make them strategically indistinguishable on their own from a typical hierarchical organization. Also, there are various hints throughout Minnaar et al.’s (2022) case study to indicate that a more monoethnic and collectivist Chinese culture may play a significant factor in smoothing over market-based frictions that would otherwise inevitably arise in such a complex, rule-based system as it automates coordination across multiple (and sometimes subjective) directives (D). In a worst-case scenario, we could potentially see similar tragic organizational failures in transplanting Haier’s 1:N coordination like we already saw decades ago in trying to transplant 1:n Japanese TQM into the U.S. That is because TQM relies very heavily on cultural consensus to achieve effective 1:n rule-based coordination, which a monoethnic culture more naturally supports (Boje & Winsor, 1993; Garrahan & Stewart, 1992).
4.6. Why Haier Represents a Pinnacle of Human Coordination via AI
From a high level, top-down perspective across all business units, Haier most closely still resembles a classic 1:1 bureaucratic hierarchy, with its typical carrot-based budgetary systems of control and reward (Minnaar et al., 2022, pp. 97-109, 220-232). However, from a lateral and bottom-up perspective, something very different is going on. The way Haier achieved its greatest renewal and growth was after 2012 when it completed the unprecedented flattening of its massive organizational hierarchy into a portfolio of 4,000 relatively independent, team-sized microenterprises (MEs) (Minnaar et al., 2022, pp. 59-67). This effectively pushed nearly all value-add accountability down to (usually much smaller) customer-facing teams so that all four organization dimensions (E, D, A and R) were fully or partially moved under front-line control, instead of only one (E) under the prior bloated bureaucracy.
Shifting to a much more entrepreneurial form of team organization on the customer-facing front lines naturally resulted in many positive benefits. However, most of those benefits were arguably predictable in the shorter term based on TQM, “agile”, and similar popularized reorganizations. An entrepreneurial team structure is also how nearly all start-up organizations work very effectively. So, Haier’s restructuring by itself was not an organization innovation. It was its 1:N AI-based system of multidimensional coordination between MEs, ME directives (D), and all individual employees (E) that was the true innovation. This is what allowed such a decentralized entrepreneurial ecosystem to take root and to be persistently stable at scale, even while it naturally evolves.
Haier’s 1:N coordination is continuously facilitated by its industry-specific microenterprise platform (MEP) for bidding, contracting, profit-sharing, invoicing and payments, both between MEs and for individual employees (E) to pitch themselves to join MEs and get paid. It also fully automates the supplier and HR onboarding processes. In effect, ICT and AI were leveraged at scale to immediately eliminate roughly 12,000 middle management positions (Minnaar et al., 2022, p. 64) and nearly 2,400 (over 99% of) HR positions (Minnaar et al., 2022, p. 75) due to significantly reducing the transaction costs of coordination. This is a classic demonstration of the Coase Theorem, where a firm (equivalent here to each independent ME) can externalize its transactions until market transaction costs equal the internal marginal costs of management (Coase, 1937; Godłów-Legiędź, 2009, p. 63). Therefore, the more transaction costs can be lowered, the more management costs can be eliminated.
The ride-hailing industry and Haier are just two case studies of likely many more business ecosystem platforms to come. Each will no doubt feature a hollowing out of middle management due to their industry-specific coordination capabilities (Crainer, 2023; Davis & Sinha, 2021). This logic also makes perfect sense from a basic organizational point of view, since the primary job of middle management is to coordinate and control front-line employees (E) via their tactical directives (D).
Minaar et al. (2022, p. 72) actually make the direct connection to Uber explicit in their book-length case study of Haier: “It’s like Uber: entrepreneurs [including employees] have an app and can select suitable ‘rides’. With more experience, they can expand their services and become salespeople as well.” Even the bidirectional peer-performance ratings (on productivity, cost, quality, and customer satisfaction) are standard and fully transparent to all buyers and sellers within Haier, which then factors into the 1:N MEP coordination algorithm (Minnaar et al., 2022, pp. 92-94). All of this is once again just like Uber. This parallel is actually predictable, since any 1:N coordination algorithm must, by definition, effectively automate the synthesis of multiple relevant directives (D) related to each participant’s expected mutual benefits across all major attributes of alignment before appropriate contract options can be presented and finalized. Merely offering a one-time dictatorial commodity price in a 1:1 free-market system would be wholly insufficient for 1:N continuous coordination purposes, especially given the changing coordination attributes of each buyer and seller that must be aligned.
For each industry, 1:N coordination platforms will likely be unique in at least some industry-specific respects, so they will never be as universal as 1:N Web1 connectivity or even N:N social media platforms, which only provide generic interaction not coordination. That said, any N-scale coordination requires immense multidimensional calculation intensity, such as (for Uber) filtering, calculating, and optimizing across dozens of travel times, distances, routes, costs, and other directives (D) in real time for multiple alternative drivers/employees (E). This must be done for all ride-hailing requests, often concurrently, not to mention balancing competing requests fairly between those drivers as yet another directive (D). As such, it effectively represents a new application of AI capability due to its scaling of existing coordination from organization / team-scale n to societal-scale N.
The AI algorithm under 1:N becomes the new dictator of rule-based consensus across multiple directives (D). For Haier, this coordination capability is arguably even more complex and risky than at Uber due to the more variable and subjective attributes of prospective employees (E) and MEs bidding for high-value contracts, each with unique and changing business requirements/directives (D). By contrast, Uber drivers and their vehicles are far more commoditized by comparison and contracted only for short, low-value trips, each with nearly universal rider requirements. This is why Minnaar (2018) may be correct to suggest that Haier could very well be “the world’s most pioneering company of our time” from a coordination point of view, particularly given their massive scale and growing geographic scope. The recent transition of both Zappos and Boi.com away from the n:n self-management system of Holacracy to a 1:N coordination-market system strongly supports this view (Minnaar et al., 2022, pp. 186-192; Siegfried, 2026d).
4.7. Haier’s Blockchain-Based Ecosystem Contracting Platform
There is still one more substantial AI-driven coordination innovation at Haier, though. That is their reliance on blockchain-based “smart contract” technology to finalize all contracts and to support the ongoing relationships between MEs and employees (E) with respect to their mutual financial rights and responsibilities over organizational resources (R) (Minnaar et al., 2022, pp. 143-152). Such a decentralized network without organizational borders is logically far more compatible with its RDHY system due to the fundamental independence of all the MEs and outside individuals, who need to coordinate together from behind their firewalls on the same ecosystem platform.
Due to the cryptographically unhackable and immutable blockchain technology, all contracted ownerships rights, obligations, and transactions are publicly transparent, trustless, tamperproof, and under completely decentralized control – not even Haier can edit them. As discussed in Siegfried (2026b), this is essentially N:1:N:N coordination technology due to its Web3 foundation, which is yet another reason why Haier is a leading pioneer of AI-based organizational coordination.
5. Discussion
Comparing historically Indigenous sympathic coordination to modern AI-based algorithmic coordination may seem incongruous in a post-ICT world, but it is not. We can reasonably infer or conjecture how Apaches may have had the most resilient form of pre-ICT – or even post-ICT – organization in human history without the scalability enhancement of AI. It is at least credibly explainable how they might have scaled strategic 3D (or even 4D) coordination beyond the team level to an entire organization, and sustainably so as it was battle-tested for centuries across both successive leaders and loosely connected Tribal bands. To be clear, this paper does not claim that Apaches demonstrably achieved n:n:n or n:n:n:n coordination, since that would require significantly more validation via facts that may no longer be available. It is only conjecturing how such coordination might have been achieved to explain their extraordinary strategic resilience across such an extended period of overwhelming external disruption and conflict.
Although no modern organization appears to have replicated the proposed Apache model to achieve such multidimensional coordination, we have seen many historical calls to do something similar since at least 1970 via “moral leadership” (Rhode, 2006), “servant leadership” (Sun et al., 2024), “transformational leadership” (Eaton et al., 2024), and similar management philosophies, as elaborated upon by Siegfried (2026d). However, these concepts only emphasize more superficial ethics and empathy “from outside” – “a feeling for” rather than “a feeling with”. This is Follett’s key distinction between mere “sympathy from outside” and true “sympathy of identification”. The latter is required, per the logic of social choice theory, to achieve sympathic coordination, and it must “evolve” continuously in the form of “dynamic sympathy”. When comparing mere leadership empathy vs. sympathic coordination, the difference in the depth and continuity of spiritual interconnectedness is vast. It is the difference between just feeling the occasional pulse of an organization and perpetually sharing its collectively beating heart.
Likewise, as Siegfried (2026d) argues and social choice theory further supports when a prioritization of alternatives (A) is required (Adler, 2014; Gandjour, 2024; Sen, 2017; Yamamura, 2017), the quasi-sympathic Teal ideas that Laloux (2014) advocates are not sufficient for such strategic (3D) coordination. They still fall far short of both 1) the spiritual depth of sympathic coordination needed for cardinal interpersonal utility comparability and 2) the resilience of sustainable co-leadership inherent in the proposed Apache model. Also, Teal (or self-management in general) has never succeeded in going beyond team-scale coordination without hierarchical control, despite its extraordinary effectiveness within teams. At organization-scale, it has consistently proven itself to be quite fragile and anything but resilient, as even Laloux fully concedes. Moreover, the vast majority of any organization’s members today would never have the honed and dispassionate lifelong wisdom of a diyin to be a sympathic coordinator, as Teal seems to require in order to avoid hierarchical control without Follett’s personified invisible leader.
Even worse, if successive decisions are made that flagrantly violate the collective will (as in Geronimo’s case), the sacred system of trust would eventually become unstable and quickly break down due to the lack of any coercive authority to fill the void. That is why symbiotic co-leadership would logically be a key criterion of stability, for which Teal has no equivalent. In other words, instead of leveraging sympathic leadership, as n:n:n coordination without AI likely requires, Teal is essentially trying to extend the “decision by consent” model of n:n coordination by making everyone the logical equivalent of both a diyin (sympathic coordinator) and a nantan (sympathic leader) in one person.
In fact, Laloux (2014, p. 243) openly hopes for a time when a benevolent dictator CEO “holding the space” for wholeness (of perspectives) (E) and purpose (D) will no longer be necessary if everyone can evolve to “hold the space” together instead. That is the essence of Laloux’s titular appeal to the “next stage of human consciousness”. However, as Siegfried (2026d) argues, that psychological and spiritual bar of a collectively unified human consciousness is far too high for everyone to reach, both individually and together. Even the Apaches have long recognized that such extraordinary coordination roles are based on certain exceptional attributes that first appear in youth and must be nurtured with special teachings and training (Robinson & Ball, 2000, pp. 181-186).
Nor would that utopian evolution in human consciousness be logically stable or sustainable, even if it could be achieved, due to the natural duality of the two co-leadership roles. There is no credible hope of everyone assuming both the sympathic coordination and leadership roles as the evolutionary starting point, especially since their related responsibilities are not compatible within the same person. As Siegfried (2026c) explains, this fundamental incompatibility of competing roles and directives (D) within the same person is the same faulty logic underlying paradox theory as a way to achieve organizational evolution. For example, profoundly listening to the desired directions of others to discover and internalize their collective will (in the coordinator role) is arguably not compatible with publicly articulating and directing others towards that will (in the leadership role). Likewise, profoundly sympathizing with others’ pains and joys to internalize their collective welfare and aspirations (as both spiritual healer and coordinator) is arguably not compatible with being the one most responsible for causing those pains and joys (as leader), and for then inspiring and leading those collective feelings towards a higher common purpose. That said, at least Laloux (2014, p. 283) clearly recognizes the need for both profound listening and human connection as a core requirement for any organization to evolve continuously via a unified human consciousness in order to achieve strategic resilience and growth.
Scaling the proposed sympathic coordination model is yet another hurdle to n:n:n coordination. In theory, adding ICT to the mix to enhance connectivity and content could make the proposed Apache form of organization substantially more viable instead of just an historical anomaly, in the same way ICT and AI coevolution was able to popularize 1:n and n:n team coordination (Siegfried, 2026b, 2026c, 2026d). Unfortunately, however, just as 1:n and n:n non-AI coordination revealed themselves to be deceptive mirages at organizational-scale, non-AI n:n:n coordination would almost certainly be the same when packaged as a replicable, popularized practice. Despite the apparently extraordinary Apache precedent in scaling this coordination across an entire organization, attempting to mass-replicate it today would likely persistently fail. This is due to the same “top team of 20” rule (as coined by Siegfried, 2026d) when coordinating without AI (i.e., without the prerequisite N:N:N AI coevolution that does not yet exist to facilitate it).
Even Apaches themselves could likely not replicate their previous scale and effectiveness of proposed coordination due to the significant diminishment of the mythical spiritual healer role in the age of modern technology and medical science. That role, in conjunction with its widely respected divine “Power” to sustain the Tribe’s long-term resilience, would have serendipitously provided the necessary sortition-based randomness to extrapolate an entire organization’s collective will from the diyin’s more limited set of intimate contacts. Perhaps this tentative conclusion is incorrect, but there appears to be no obvious way to replicate such a random sortition of deep interpersonal relationships deliberately. Ironically, both technology and modern medicine may be widening this coordination chasm rather than creating the bridge to cross it.
In addition, Geronimo’s obsession with revenge points to a fatal instability in this proposed model, where dispassionate evaluation, aggregation, and integration of the collective will and organizational wisdom by a revered spiritual leader must never be significantly conflated with the worldly power of leadership and personal ambition to carry it out. Logically, the sympathic coordinator role should almost certainly be independent from the sympathic leader role, as already emphasized. Only then could a diyin provide the necessary check and balance on the power of nantan leadership by publicly exposing when it deviates from the collective will, even though this would likely have been rarely needed given the nantan’s dedication and commitment to the Apache Nation. With Geronimo after 1851, that symbiotic co-leadership relationship appears to have gradually collapsed into a dictatorship model, along with the diyin’s check on leadership power to keep it in balance.
As Follett implied in her naming of this critical yet mysterious leadership role, the key to sustaining the invisible leader’s success is keeping it invisible. Geronimo’s mistake – arguably forced upon him due to the sustained and overpowering genocidal onslaught upon both him personally and his people – was making his invisible leadership role blatantly visible. He could no longer be accountable to any collective will, since he could no longer deeply sense it, let alone coherently coordinate it into Follet’s integrative unity. His senses and wisdom were too clouded by insatiable vengeance.
6. Conclusion and Future Research Directions
In the modern world, there appears to be no credible way to resurrect a revered spiritual co-leadership role that could ever match and challenge the dictatorial leadership authority of a worldly CEO, even though we clearly need this collective spiritual integration and wisdom more than ever to overcome society’s grandest challenges. In the business world, this would mean shifting our overriding common purpose from maximizing profit to maximizing human (and planetary) flourishing. This is arguably impossible while we are universally still under dictatorial strategic control, even at organization-scale (Siegfried, 2026d). Despite the extraordinary historical success of the Apaches (and possibly other Indigenous peoples) in being so demonstrably resilient across centuries, it may be beyond our reach to replicate the symbiotic co-leadership model of nantan/diyin sympathic coordination that is proposed to achieve that resilience. This is especially the case in our modern multicultural societies, where there is far greater conflict within the directives (D) dimension of human coordination. Also, the vast majority of us now have far more faith in objective medical science than sympathic healers, and there is no realistic collective hope in any universal spiritual leader to integrate and unify such greatly conflicting spiritual diversity.
Unfortunately, the pre-ICT conditions that facilitated the proposed Apache model are likely an anachronistic anomaly. As a result, the most viable evolutionary pathway towards organizational democracy and freedom that can finally break the non-hierarchical team-scale barrier appears to be via AI-enabled multidimensional coordination, as originally theorized by Siegfried (2026b). This conclusion becomes even more emphatic at the societal-scale level, which requires orders of magnitude more coordination than at organization-scale, as the Haier case illustrates. Despite how Apaches may have achieved a level of coordination that even AI has not yet achieved, there currently appears to be no viable evolutionary pathway towards higher levels of human consciousness that could ever coordinate at modern societal-scale. Moreover, barring the biological evolution of mass telepathic abilities, that scale is beyond the hope of any single human being to coordinate due to bounded rationality constraints, even with a hypothetical sortition-based sympathic coordinator like a diyin.
By contrast, as Siegfried (2026a, 2026b, 2026c, 2026d) shows, there are five mathematically distinct evolutionary stages of increasingly higher multidimensional levels of connectivity and coordination for humanity via the coevolution of ICT and AI. The progression is 1:1(*N), 1:N, N:N, N:N:N, and finally N:N:N:N at societal-scale based on the four dimensions of organization. And this progression is always in conjunction with team / organization-scale human coordination evolving first after the related N-scale connectivity to facilitate it (e.g., 1:N connectivity evolves first, then 1:n coordination, and finally1:N coordination). This coevolution has steadily continued, and arguably accelerated, since the popularization of ICT in the early 1960s, and there is no sign that it will be coming to an end anytime soon. In fact, as forthcoming research documents in more detail, it appears to be not just inevitable, but unstoppable. The only question is whether it will be soon enough to address the grand challenges and existential threats related to humanity’s societal-scale – and even planetary-scale – coordination problems.
Author Contributions
DS is responsible for all aspects of the manuscript. However, a tentatively anonymous Indigenous scholar assisted in the review process of the Apache case illustration and related discussions / conclusions, providing many useful, challenging, and well-appreciated insights, some of which may still need to be integrated into subsequent versions of this paper based on our ongoing discussions.
Funding
No specific funding was received for this work.
Conflicts of Interest
No potential competing interests to declare.
Declaration of AI Use: The author did not use AI-assisted technologies in the writing, editing, or data analysis of this manuscript.
References
- Adler, M. D. EXTENDED PREFERENCES AND INTERPERSONAL COMPARISONS: A NEW ACCOUNT. Economics and Philosophy 2014, 30(2), 123–162. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Baharav, C.; Flanigan, B. Fair, Manipulation-Robust, and Transparent Sortition. arXiv 2024, arXiv:2406.15009. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Ball, E. In the days of Victorio: Recollections of a Warm Springs Apache, 4. printing ed; The University of Arizona Press, 1981. [Google Scholar]
- Ball, E.; Henn, N.; Sanchez, L. Indeh, an Apache odyssey; University of Oklahoma Press, 1988. [Google Scholar]
- Barker, J. R. Tightening the Iron Cage: Concertive Control in Self-Managing Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly 1993, 38(3), 408–437. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Boje, D. M.; Winsor, R. D. The Resurrection of Taylorism: Total Quality Management’s Hidden Agenda. Journal of Organizational Change Management 1993, 6(4), 57–70. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Bourke, J. G. 1892. The Medicine-men of the Apache. US Government Printing Office. [Google Scholar]
- Brafman, O.; Beckström, R. A. The starfish and the spider: The unstoppable power of leaderless organizations; Portfolio, 2006. [Google Scholar]
- Coase, R. H. The Nature of the Firm. Economica 1937, 4(16), 386–405. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Crainer, S. (Ed.) The Power of Ecosystems: Making sense of the new reality for organizations; Business Ecosystem Alliance, 2023. [Google Scholar]
- Davis, G. F.; Sinha, A. Varieties of Uberization: How technology and institutions change the organization(s) of late capitalism. Organization Theory 2021, 2(1), 263178772199519. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Delipetrev, B.; Tsinaraki, C.; Kostic, U. Historical Evolution of Artificial Intelligence [Monograph]; Publications Office of the European Union, 2020; Available online: https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC120469.
- Eaton, L.; Bridgman, T.; Cummings, S. Advancing the democratization of work: A new intellectual history of transformational leadership theory. Leadership 2024, 20(3), 125–143. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Flanigan, B.; Gölz, P.; Gupta, A.; Hennig, B.; Procaccia, A. D. Fair algorithms for selecting citizens’ assemblies. Nature 2021, 596(7873), 548–552. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Follett, M. P. The new state; Longmans London, 1918. [Google Scholar]
- Follett, M. P. Community is a Process. The Philosophical Review 1919, 28(6), 576. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Follett, M. P. Freedom and Co-ordination: Lectures in Business Organization; Routledge, 2013. [Google Scholar]
- Foss, N. J. Selective Intervention and Internal Hybrids: Interpreting and Learning from the Rise and Decline of the Oticon Spaghetti Organization. Organization Science 2003, 14(3), 331–349. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Foss, N. J.; Klein, P. Why managers matter: The perils of the bossless company (First edition); PublicAffairs, 2022. [Google Scholar]
- Gandjour, A. Perspectives on interpersonal utility comparisons: An analysis of selected models. Journal of Philosophical Economics, Volume XVII(Articles) 2024, 11271. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Garrahan, P.; Stewart, P. The Nissan enigma: Flexibility at work in a local economy; Mansell, 1992. [Google Scholar]
- Godłów-Legiędź, J. The Coase theorem and idea of transaction costs – their significance for the development of economics. Comparative Economic Research. Central and Eastern Europe 2009, 12(4), 61–76. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Goodwin, G. The social organization of the Western Apache; University of Arizona Press, 1969. [Google Scholar]
- Haley, J. L. Apaches: A history and culture portrait; University of Oklahoma Press, 1997. [Google Scholar]
- Hamel, G.; Zanini, M. Humanocracy: Creating organizations as amazing as the people inside them; Harvard Business Review Press, 2020. [Google Scholar]
- Harsanyi, J. C. Cardinal Welfare, Individualistic Ethics, and Interpersonal Comparisons of Utility. Journal of Political Economy 1955, 63(4), 309–321. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Ingstad, H.; Nevins, T. J. The Apache Indians: In search of the missing tribe; U of Nebraska Press, 2004. [Google Scholar]
- Jacobides, M. G.; Cennamo, C.; Gawer, A. Externalities and complementarities in platforms and ecosystems: From structural solutions to endogenous failures. Research Policy 2024, 53(1), 104906. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Laloux, F.; Wilber, K. Reinventing organizations: A guide to creating organizations inspired by the next stage of human consciousness, First edition (revised)); Nelson Parker, 2014. [Google Scholar]
- Landemore, H. Open democracy: Reinventing popular rule for the twenty-first century; Princeton University Press, 2020. [Google Scholar]
- Lee, V. Vilcabamba: Last stronghold of the Inca. In The Oxford Handbook of the Incas; Alconini, S., Covey, A., Eds.; Oxford University Press, 2018. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Metcalf, H. C.; Urwick, L. F. (Eds.) Dynamic administration: The collected papers of Mary Parker Follett; Harper & Row, 1940; Available online: https://books.google.com/books?id=s1-KvgAACAAJ.
- Milne, D.; Howard, W. Rethinking the Role of Diagnosis in Navajo Religious Healing. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, New Series 2000, 14(4,), 543–570. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Minnaar, J. The World’s Most Pioneering Company Of Our Times. Corporate Rebels. 31 January 2018. Available online: https://www.corporate-rebels.com/blog/haier.
- Minnaar, J.; de Morree, P.; Van Der Lecq, B. Start-up Factory: Haier’s RenDanHeYi Model and the End of Management as We Know it. In CORPORATE REBELS NEDERLAND B.V.; 2022; Available online: https://books.google.com/books?id=YsQ4zwEACAAJ.
- Nixon, T. Resolving the awkward paradox in Frederic Laloux’s Reinventing Organisations. Medium. 14 April 2015. Available online: https://blog.maptio.com/resolving-the-awkward-paradox-in-frederic-laloux-s-reinventing-organisations-f2031080ea02.
- Opler, M. E. An Apache life-way: The economic, social, and religious institutions of the Chiricahua Indians; University of Nebraska Press, 1996. [Google Scholar]
- Opler, M. E. Apache odyssey: A journey between two worlds; University of Nebraska Press, 2002. [Google Scholar]
- Pek, S. Rekindling Union Democracy Through the Use of Sortition. Journal of Business Ethics 2019, 155(4), 1033–1051. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Posner, E. A.; Weyl, E. G.; Buterin, V. Radical markets: Uprooting capitalism and democracy for a just society; (New paperback edition); Princeton University Press, 2019. [Google Scholar]
- Restall, M. Seven myths of the Spanish conquest; Oxford University Press, 2003. [Google Scholar]
- Rhode, D. L. (Ed.) Moral leadership: The theory and practice of power, judgment, and policy; Jossey-Bass, 2006. [Google Scholar]
- Robbins, L. An Essay on the nature and significance of economic science, 1st ed.; Macmillan, 1932. [Google Scholar]
- Robbins, L. Interpersonal Comparisons of Utility: A Comment. The Economic Journal 1938, 48(192), 635–641. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Roberts, D. Once they moved like the wind: Cochise, Geronimo, and the Apache wars; Simon & Schuster, 1993. [Google Scholar]
- Robinson, S.; Ball, E. Apache voices: Their stories of survival as told to Eve Ball, 1st ed; University of New Mexico Press, 2000. [Google Scholar]
- Sen, A. Collective choice and social welfare (Expanded edition); Harvard University Press, 2017. [Google Scholar]
- Siegfried, D. Effective Organization is a System of Four-Dimensional Evolutionary Coordination 2026a. [CrossRef]
- Siegfried, D. ICT, AI, and Web Coevolution are Explained and Predicted by Humanity’s Increasingly Multidimensional Connectivity and Coordination 2026b. [CrossRef]
- Siegfried, D. Organizational Ambidexterity and Dynamic Capabilities are Euphemisms for Lamarckian Evolution 2026c. [CrossRef]
- Siegfried, D. Popularized “Organizational Democracy” Practices Have Not Yet Evolved Beyond Team-Scale Coordination Without Hierarchical Control 2026d. [CrossRef]
- Sun, P. Y. T.; Anderson, M. H.; Gang, H. Determining the Hierarchical Structure and Nature of Servant Leadership. Journal of Business and Psychology 2024, 39(3), 715–734. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Surowiecki, J. The wisdom of crowds; Anchor Books, 2005. [Google Scholar]
- Tedlock, B. The woman in the shaman’s body: Reclaiming the feminine in religion and medicine; Bantam, 2005. [Google Scholar]
- Thomas, H. Rivers of gold: The rise of the Spanish Empire, from Columbus to Magellan, 1st U.S. ed; Random House, 2003. [Google Scholar]
- Van Reybrouck, D. Against elections; Seven Stories Press, 2018. [Google Scholar]
- Yamamura, H. Interpersonal comparison necessary for Arrovian aggregation. Social Choice and Welfare 2017, 49(1), 37–64. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Zeitoun, H.; Osterloh, M.; Frey, B. S. Learning from Ancient Athens: Demarchy and Corporate Governance. Academy of Management Perspectives 2014, 28(1), 1–14. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the author. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.