Submitted:
22 September 2026
Posted:
23 September 2026
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
Generative artificial intelligence (AI) intensifies a long-standing question for religious education (RE): what is education for when information, explanation, and polished synthesis are available on demand? Using Catholic religious education (CRE) as a situated case, this conceptual article argues that wisdom should orient RE without displacing knowledge. Drawing on virtue ethics, Catholic thought, philosophy of education, and recent scholarship on digital religion and AI, it develops four dimensions of wisdom-centered RE: epistemic judgment, practical-moral discernment, relational responsibility, and tradition-situated orientation toward ultimate goods. It concludes with implications for curriculum, pedagogy, assessment, teacher formation, and interfaith and public RE.
Keywords:
artificial intelligence
; religious education
; Catholic religious education
; wisdom
; interfaith education
; educational aims
Introduction: AI as a Test of Educational Purpose
Artificial intelligence (AI), especially generative AI, has changed the conditions under which educational knowledge is encountered. Large language models (LLMs) can produce explanations, summaries, translations, comparisons, lesson materials, and plausible arguments within seconds. Their outputs remain fallible, biased, and unevenly accessible, yet they increasingly mediate what learners encounter and how they formulate questions. UNESCO (2023) and the OECD (2023) therefore treat generative AI as an educational-development challenge involving teaching, assessment, authorship, equity, and governance rather than as a classroom tool alone.
For religious education (RE), this shift is revealing. Religious traditions and nonreligious worldviews are not databases of propositions but historically embodied ways of interpreting reality, negotiating authority, sustaining communities, and orienting life. Yet RE can become informational when success is identified chiefly with recalling content or reproducing authorized explanations. Catholic religious education (CRE) provides a focused case: if an LLM can fluently explain a doctrine, compare scriptural interpretations, or simulate worldview debate, the distinctive educational task cannot be reduced to possessing or transmitting more information. It concerns how learners judge, interpret, relate, and become answerable for what they know.
Catholic educational thought has long framed education more broadly than content acquisition, emphasizing integral formation, truth, freedom and responsibility, community, the common good, and, within faith, communion with God (Congregation for Catholic Education 2022). The Vatican note Antiqua et Nova connects this tradition directly to AI by distinguishing human intelligence from computational performance and calling for a deeper ‘wisdom of the heart’ capable of ordering technological power and abundant data (Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith and Dicastery for Culture and Education 2025). The educational question is therefore whether CRE’s pedagogy and assessment actually cultivate the forms of judgment implied by its theological anthropology.
Recent scholarship has moved the discussion beyond generic enthusiasm or anxiety. Papakostas (2025) examines ethical, pedagogical, and theological dimensions of AI in RE; Corpuz (2025) develops a virtue-ethical account for Catholic education; Chrostowski and Mąkosa (2026) report teachers’ ambivalent perceptions of AI; and Chrostowski (2026) identifies a need for more theologically grounded, practice-based research. Gopez, Gozum, and Gopez (2026) stress human presence and accompaniment in CRE. Within the field, Yust (2026) advocates curiosity and critical reflection about children’s digital and spiritual worlds, Choi (2026) exposes questions of digital colonialism and global justice, and de Kock (2025) shows that digital faith formation depends on more than technological delivery. Hess’s earlier work on digital culture and faith formation likewise remains important for understanding mediated, relational learning (Hess 2012, 2014). Together with Mercer’s (2026) focus on wisdom, this literature makes educational purpose, not technological adoption, the decisive question.
This article argues that wisdom should be reclaimed as an orienting aim of CRE, provided it is defined carefully. Wisdom does not replace information, doctrinal knowledge, or conceptual understanding. It names the cultivated capacity to judge truthfully and responsibly what is worth attending to, believing, desiring, and doing in concrete circumstances and in relation to goods that exceed efficiency. In a Catholic horizon, such judgment is ordered toward truth, charity, justice, communion, and ultimately God. AI intensifies the need for this capacity because it expands the fluency and availability of representations without determining what they are for.
The article makes four contributions. It reframes AI as a test of educational ends rather than merely technological means; treats information, knowledge, understanding, and wisdom as nested educational goods; develops a four-dimensional framework for wisdom-centered CRE; and shows how a Catholic account of wisdom can enter wider interfaith and public RE without being universalized. As a conceptual study, its practical proposals are design hypotheses rather than empirically validated effects.
Conceptual Approach and Scope
This is a normative conceptual study, not an empirical investigation. It develops its argument through critical synthesis across philosophy of education, virtue ethics, Catholic educational thought, and recent research on AI, digital religion, and RE. The aim is not to establish a universal definition of wisdom, but to clarify educational goods that can be scrutinized, contested, and investigated empirically. The Catholic tradition functions as a situated source of conceptual depth rather than an unmarked norm for the whole field.
Three delimitations guide the argument. First, AI refers primarily to contemporary generative systems, especially LLMs, because fluent natural-language generation makes authority, verification, authorship, and judgment especially salient. Second, CRE is treated as school-based educational practice rather than simply catechesis; such settings may include Catholic, other Christian, other religious, nonreligious, and uncertain learners. Third, Catholic concepts are offered comparatively. Epistemic judgment, responsible freedom, relationality, and the ordering of knowledge toward worthwhile ends function as bridge concepts that other traditions and worldviews may affirm, revise, or contest.
This situated approach protects both theological integrity and educational legitimacy. Catholic language should not be presented as religiously neutral, yet CRE should not be stripped of the commitments through which its claims can be tested. The relevant stance is dialogical particularity: learners encounter traditions in their historical and theological thickness while retaining genuine space for interpretation, disagreement, comparison, and responsible judgment. In interfaith or public RE, the same principle requires attention to internal diversity, lived religion, nonreligious positions, and asymmetries of power.
What Generative AI Changes - and What It Does Not
AI discourse often oscillates between two exaggerations: that automation makes conventional education largely redundant, or that AI changes nothing fundamental. Neither is adequate. Generative AI does not remove the need for teachers, disciplines, institutions, or substantive knowledge, but it does alter how informational and discursive tasks are performed and therefore how educational achievement can be evidenced.
The first shift is from searchable to conversational abundance. Generative systems synthesize material into a unified response, often without displaying the sources, disagreements, or interpretive decisions from which an answer emerges. This creates epistemic convenience but also dependence. Even accurate output can weaken learning when students no longer practise identifying evidence, weighing authorities, tolerating uncertainty, or constructing arguments. In RE, where inquiry draws on scripture, doctrine, history, lived religion, ethical reasoning, and internal diversity, fluent simplification is a particular risk (Papakostas 2025; Yust 2026).
A second shift concerns the evidential value of student products. LLMs can imitate performances associated with understanding: comparing thinkers, outlining interpretations, generating objections, and drafting reflective prose. Educators should therefore be cautious about inferring formation from polished text alone. Assessment increasingly needs to make reasoning, source use, dialogue, revision, oral explanation, and accountable judgment visible.
A third shift concerns authority. AI interfaces commonly speak in a unified voice even when the underlying material is contested, obscuring denominational differences, intra-traditional debate, historical development, and the distinction between description and theological affirmation. Papakostas (2025) warns of theological distortion and epistemic conformity, while Chrostowski and Mąkosa (2026) report concerns about oversimplification. Choi (2026) further shows that AI’s infrastructures raise questions of power and global justice. These are reasons to teach technological mediation critically, not simply to prohibit it.
What AI does not change is equally important. Learners still need substantive religious and worldview knowledge to evaluate generated claims, and unequal access, privacy, platform governance, and digital literacy remain educational concerns (UNESCO 2023; OECD 2023). Moral and educational accountability also remains with persons and institutions that select, trust, circulate, and act on AI outputs. The appropriate conclusion is not that information no longer matters, but that information is easier to generate and harder to trust without judgment.
Information, Knowledge, Understanding, and Wisdom as Nested Educational Goods
A common temptation is to arrange information, knowledge, understanding, and wisdom as a simple ladder. The hierarchy is too neat. Information does not automatically become knowledge through organization, knowledge does not become understanding merely through connection, and wisdom is not a final quantity accumulated after enough understanding. Wise judgment depends upon, rather than supersedes, relevant information, disciplined knowledge, and meaningful understanding.
It is more helpful to treat these as nested educational goods. Information concerns communicable representations; knowledge adds warrant, disciplinary location, and practices of inquiry; understanding concerns relations, significance, and explanation; wisdom concerns the responsible ordering and use of these goods toward worthwhile ends. Hirst’s (1974) account of forms of knowledge is useful because disciplines are not databases but traditions organized by concepts, questions, evidence, and criteria. Wisdom is therefore less a further store of content than a quality of judgment about truth, attention, action, and purpose.
This account avoids both overstating and understating AI. A system may generate sophisticated representations of knowledge or understanding without participating in human practices of belief, responsibility, or commitment; yet AI can still support access, comparison, questioning, feedback, and rehearsal of argument. The educational task is not to preserve human distinctiveness by denying machine capability, but to identify what responsible formation requires beyond fluent performance.
Maxwell’s distinction between knowledge-inquiry and wisdom-inquiry remains relevant because it asks whether knowledge is directed toward questions of value and flourishing (Maxwell 2007). In CRE, however, the horizon is more tradition-specific: learners encounter truth claims concerning ultimate meaning and must learn epistemic humility - distinguishing what is known, believed, interpreted, uncertain, or contested. In an AI-mediated environment, such distinctions are basic conditions of responsible learning.
Philosophical and Theological Resources for Wisdom-Centered RE
Aristotle: Phronesis and the Irreducibility of Particular Judgment
Aristotle’s phronesis (practical wisdom) identifies reasoning that cannot be reduced to technical procedure. In Book VI of the Nicomachean Ethics, phronesis concerns deliberation about what is good and fitting in action; it is directed toward particulars, depends on experience, and is bound to moral character (Aristotle 1999). The practically wise person does not merely apply a rule but judges what matters here, where goods, obligations, and consequences may conflict.
This matters because educational uses of AI are often framed in technicist terms - optimization, efficiency, personalization, automated rubrics. Such tools can be useful, but educational judgment also interprets the goods at stake. A teacher deciding whether to pursue a difficult question, respond to a vulnerable disclosure, challenge an interpretation, or balance doctrinal accuracy with dialogical openness is not solving a merely technical problem. Dunne’s (1997) critique of the ‘lure of technique’ clarifies why teaching requires judgment internal to practice.
Wisdom-centered CRE therefore treats AI outputs as materials for judgment rather than substitutes for it. The question is not only whether an answer is accurate, but whether its use serves truthful inquiry, respects the learner, preserves intellectual agency, and advances the educational good. The stronger claim about human practical wisdom is not that machines can never imitate deliberation, but that human agents are answerable for judgments, formed through habits and relationships, and implicated in their consequences.
Aquinas: Prudence, Sapientia, and the Ordering of Human Intelligence
Aquinas receives and transforms Aristotle. Prudence (prudentia) remains right reason concerning action, while wisdom (sapientia) concerns judgment in relation to highest causes and, in its theological sense, divine things shaped by charity (Summa Theologiae, especially II-II qq. 45-47). This distinction prevents ‘wisdom’ from becoming a generic twenty-first-century skill.
For CRE, the Thomistic contribution is that educational judgment occurs within an account of ends. Prudence becomes mere cleverness when detached from worthy purposes; wisdom orders knowledge in relation to truth and the good. The learner is therefore not simply an information processor but a person whose intellectual, moral, relational, embodied, and spiritual life forms a unity.
Antiqua et Nova extends this anthropological claim to AI, emphasizing human intelligence as embodied, relational, moral, and open to truth and goodness (Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith and Dicastery for Culture and Education 2025). Its call for a ‘wisdom of the heart’ gives contemporary Catholic warrant to a wisdom-centered argument, but the educational task is pedagogical translation: identifying curricular, dialogical, and assessment practices through which responsible judgment can develop.
Biesta: Subjectification, World-Centered Education, and Responsible Freedom
Biesta’s philosophy corrects any account of wisdom that becomes inward or individualistic. His distinction among qualification, socialization, and subjectification resists reducing education to outcomes or competencies (Biesta 2022). Qualification concerns knowledge and skills; socialization concerns participation in traditions and practices; subjectification concerns the learner’s emergence as a responsible subject. Good education negotiates tensions among all three.
For CRE, qualification includes religious and theological literacy; socialization involves encounter with traditions, communities, practices, and inherited vocabularies; subjectification concerns response in freedom and responsibility. AI may support qualification, but subjectification cannot be engineered through better information. Biesta’s world-centered emphasis is particularly relevant because highly personalized systems can over-adapt the world to the learner, whereas education also involves interruption and encounter with what is not chosen.
RE consequently involves more than helping learners generate personally satisfying meanings. Traditions confront them with claims, narratives, practices, communities, and differences that may attract, disturb, or resist them. Wisdom-centered CRE seeks neither compliance nor sovereign self-expression, but responsible freedom in relation to a shared world.
Dunne and the Educational Limits of Technique
Dunne’s reconstruction of practical judgment provides a bridge from Aristotle to pedagogy. Teaching is a practice whose goods cannot be reduced to externally specified outputs; educators must judge appropriately in situations marked by contingency and competing goods (Dunne 1997). AI can optimize toward a target once specified, but optimization alone cannot determine whether the target is educationally worthy.
Wisdom-centered CRE therefore resists both technological and curricular reduction: the assumption that better AI tools solve questions of purpose, and the assumption that doctrinal outcomes are units simply to be delivered, retrieved, and tested. Both overlook the interpretive work through which teachers and learners judge why knowledge matters and what responsible response may require.
CRE as a Situated Case: Knowledge, Formation, and the Catechesis Distinction
Making wisdom an orienting aim must not weaken knowledge. Contemporary RE scholarship rightly resists approaches that reduce religion to generic values, personal experience, or unstructured discussion. CRE requires accurate access to scripture, doctrine, liturgy, history, ethics, Catholic social teaching (CST), internal diversity, and relations with other religions and worldviews. Similarly, interfaith and public RE need sufficiently rich knowledge to prevent dialogue from becoming an exchange of stereotypes. Recent debates about religion-and-worldviews education reinforce the need to clarify what counts as substantive knowledge and how worldview language is used (Moulin 2023; Wright and Wright 2024; Cooling 2025).
The argument is therefore not a move from knowledge to formation as though the two were alternatives. Formation includes learning how to know: how to read sources, recognize authority, distinguish genres, identify development and disagreement, and test interpretations. AI heightens this need because generated religious content can collapse such distinctions. Students should ask not only what a tradition teaches but what kind of source is being used, what authority it claims, how interpretations differ, and what does or does not follow from a claim.
A second clarification concerns catechesis. Catholic teaching explicitly distinguishes, while relating, school RE and catechetical formation (Congregation for Catholic Education 2009; Sultana 2020). Catechesis explicitly seeks maturation in faith; school-based CRE operates within an educational mission and may include learners whose relation to Catholic faith ranges from commitment to uncertainty, other religious belonging, or nonbelief. If wisdom-centered CRE is defined as producing Catholic assent, it becomes coercive; if Catholic truth claims are bracketed entirely, it becomes indistinguishable from generic ethics.
Dialogical particularity offers an alternative. CRE can present Catholic convictions as substantive claims while cultivating learners’ capacities to understand, question, compare, interpret, and judge. The Identity of the Catholic School for a Culture of Dialogue is important precisely because it refuses a choice between Catholic identity and dialogue (Congregation for Catholic Education 2022). Wisdom here includes intellectual hospitality: taking others seriously without pretending that all claims are equivalent.
The Catholic case therefore opens a wider RE question: how can learners encounter strong truth claims without indoctrination or relativistic flattening, recognize internal disagreement without reducing traditions to fragments, and contribute to common life when AI can reproduce religious language without participating in the communities, histories, and obligations that give such language meaning?
From Catholic Particularity to Interfaith and Public-Educational Significance
The wider field increasingly treats RE as a space in which religious and nonreligious worldviews are encountered under conditions of plurality. The issue is not whether Catholic sapientia can serve as a universal vocabulary, but what dimensions of a wisdom-centered approach can travel across traditions. Relevant comparative questions include: What counts as trustworthy knowledge? What constitutes human flourishing? Which authorities deserve allegiance or critique? What obligations bind persons to others? What should be done when goods conflict? What, if anything, gives life an ultimate horizon?
This differs from seeking a lowest common denominator. Interfaith education becomes educationally significant when differences are rendered intelligible rather than dissolved. Accountable comparison requires identifying sources and authorities, tracing reasons, attending to internal diversity, recognizing asymmetries of power, and asking how visions of the good bear upon common life. AI makes such practices more urgent because generated answers can collapse traditions into generic moral language or present contested claims in an artificially unified voice.
Public RE adds further responsibilities. Work on religions and nonreligious worldviews emphasizes interpretive competence, dialogue, human rights, and attention to representation (Jackson 2014), while more recent debates show that inclusivity itself can generate tensions when conflicting truth claims and worldview categories are handled too simply (Moulin 2023; Wright and Wright 2024; Cooling 2025). A wisdom-centered approach adds the question of judgment: whether learners can evaluate representations, give reasons, live with unresolved disagreement, and deliberate about shared problems without demanding either confessional conformity or public irrelevance.
The framework should therefore be read in two registers. Epistemic judgment, practical-moral discernment, and relational responsibility are comparative bridge concepts. The fourth dimension - theological and worldview orientation - remains tradition-situated. The aim is not to homogenize ultimate commitments but to make their educational consequences discussable in a plural public world.
A Four-Dimensional Framework for Wisdom-Centered RE
Wisdom-centered RE is best understood as a pattern of interrelated dispositions and practices rather than a single competency. Four dimensions are proposed: epistemic judgment, practical-moral discernment, relational responsibility, and theological/worldview orientation. The first three are readily comparative; the fourth names a tradition’s or worldview’s relation to ultimate goods. In CRE it is explicitly Catholic and theological; in interfaith or public RE it becomes an object of disciplined comparison rather than a norm imposed on all learners.
Epistemic Judgment: Learning What and Whom to Trust
Epistemic judgment concerns evaluating claims, sources, interpretations, and degrees of certainty. In an AI environment this includes verifying generated content, tracing claims to sources, recognizing fabrication and bias, distinguishing authorities, and identifying when confidence conceals disagreement. In RE it also means distinguishing historical description, social-scientific interpretation, theological affirmation, philosophical argument, and personal testimony rather than collapsing them into ‘religious information.’
This dimension exceeds generic digital literacy. A student may know that AI fabricates citations yet lack the religious literacy to detect subtle distortion. Learners can audit generated explanations against sacred texts, doctrinal or institutional sources, scholarship, lived voices, and multiple perspectives. The educational product is not merely a corrected paragraph but the capacity to justify why a source deserves weight, what authority it claims, and where uncertainty remains.
Practical-Moral Discernment: Judging What Ought to Be Done
Practical-moral discernment concerns action where rules do not mechanically determine an answer. Catholic moral education draws on prudence, conscience, virtue, natural law, CST, and traditions of discernment. A wisdom-centered approach asks learners to identify morally relevant features, distinguish goods from preferences, consider affected persons and consequences, and justify action in relation to coherent commitments.
AI provides concrete cases involving authorship, fairness, privacy, surveillance, labor, environmental cost, bias, and dependence. Students can compare AI-generated advice on a dilemma, identify what it notices or omits, and reconstruct the case through concepts such as dignity, justice, solidarity, subsidiarity, or care for the vulnerable. Choi’s (2026) postcolonial critique is especially relevant here because ethical evaluation must include who benefits from AI infrastructures and who bears their costs. The goal is accountable moral reasoning, not the slogan that ‘AI is wrong.’
Relational Responsibility: Wisdom Is Not a Solitary Achievement
Wisdom is not merely an individual possession. RE concerns persons whose identities and judgments are mediated by teachers, peers, families, communities, texts, practices, institutions, and inherited narratives. Research on religious and spiritual development similarly emphasizes relational contexts and meaning-making in human flourishing (King, Hardy, and Noe 2021; King, Mangan, and Riveros 2023). In digital RE, Hess (2012, 2014) has long emphasized mediated relationality and meaning-making; more recently, Gopez, Gozum, and Gopez (2026), de Kock (2025), and Cohen (2026) show why community and relational formation cannot be treated as incidental to technology-enhanced learning.
Relational responsibility includes listening, truthful speech, responsiveness to vulnerability, willingness to revise judgment, and awareness of how power shapes whose voice counts. AI can personalize explanations, but education also requires inhabiting a world with persons who cannot be optimized to one’s preferences. Dialogue involves patience, misunderstanding, disagreement, repair, and mutual obligation. These are not inefficiencies to eliminate; they are part of the formation of judgment.
Theological and Worldview Orientation: Relating Knowledge to Ultimate Goods
The specifically Catholic form of the fourth dimension is theological orientation. Catholic faith situates human intelligence within creation, vocation, sin, grace, and communion with God and neighbor. Antiqua et Nova accordingly evaluates AI through an integral vision of the person and common good rather than performance alone. Other religious traditions articulate ultimate goods through different authorities and metaphysical commitments; nonreligious worldviews may do so through accounts of dignity, flourishing, justice, meaning, or finitude. The educational principle is not uniformity but explicitness about the horizons within which judgments are made.
In CRE, questions about personhood, freedom, dependence, knowledge, love, responsibility, and the common good can be engaged through creation, incarnation, conscience, grace, and CST. In interfaith and public RE, analogous questions can be investigated comparatively, attending to how traditions and worldviews construe authority, agency, suffering, community, and the good life. King’s developmental work is useful here because it treats spirituality and meaning-making as dimensions of human development linked to purpose and thriving rather than as detachable content (King, Hardy, and Noe 2021; King, Mangan, and Riveros 2023).
A crucial restraint follows. Theological or worldview orientation should not be assessed by measuring a learner’s personal faith, nonfaith, or conformity. In school-based RE, assessment should focus on understanding, interpretation, reasoning, comparison, and justified application. A faith-based institution may teach from a substantive tradition without making personal assent a compulsory academic performance; public RE may facilitate encounters among ultimate commitments without pretending that one worldview-neutral standpoint exists.
From Aim to Practice: Curriculum, Pedagogy, Assessment, and Teacher Formation
Curriculum: Organize Content Around Questions of Judgment
A wisdom-centered curriculum retains systematic content but links it explicitly to judgments that content enables. In CRE, a unit on CST might connect dignity, solidarity, subsidiarity, the common good, and preferential concern for the poor to algorithmic hiring, surveillance, automated decision-making, or unequal access to AI. In interfaith or public RE, the same problems can be examined through multiple religious and nonreligious accounts of dignity, justice, responsibility, technology, and flourishing.
Content thereby becomes a resource for interpreting reality rather than material learned only because it is examinable. At the same time, not every topic needs an AI application. Wisdom includes deciding when unmediated attention to text, silence, conversation, ritual, art, or community is educationally better.
Pedagogy: Inquiry, Comparison, Deliberation, and Contemplative Attention
Four pedagogical moves are especially congruent with wisdom-centered RE: inquiry that requires interpretation rather than retrieval; comparison of AI-generated answers with primary sources, scholarship, and lived voices; deliberation where learners justify judgments under conditions of conflict; and disciplined attention that interrupts speed and optimization. Yust’s (2026) call for curiosity and critical reflection in digital culture and Hess’s (2012, 2014) work on mediated, relational learning support pedagogies that neither romanticize nor reject technology.
In confessional settings, disciplined attention may draw on silence, lectio, examination of conscience, prayerful reflection, or patient reading; other traditions have analogous practices of study, meditation, recollection, and listening, while public education can cultivate nonconfessional forms of slow inquiry. Such practices should not test faith. Their educational value lies in learning to remain with a text, person, question, or difficulty before producing an answer.
Assessment: Make Judgment Visible
Assessment is where an informational curriculum most readily reproduces itself. When success is inferred mainly from correct or polished text, generative AI can obscure what the student actually understands. Wisdom-centered assessment should therefore make reasoning, source use, and judgment visible without abandoning writing.
Approaches include oral defense of written work, annotated source trails, comparison of interpretations, reflective commentaries on revision, supervised analytical writing, dialogical assessment, and AI-use statements. Rubrics can reward accurate knowledge, evidence, recognition of uncertainty, ethical reasoning, theological or worldview literacy, and responsiveness to counterargument. They should not reward personal religiosity, disclosure, or conformity to an expected spiritual conclusion.
Such assessment distinguishes assistance from substitution by asking which educational work remained the student’s: identifying the problem, selecting and checking sources, making distinctions, judging reasons, revising claims, and taking responsibility for the final argument.
Teacher Formation: From AI Competence to Professional Wisdom
Teacher development must move beyond prompt training. RE teachers need AI literacy concerning capabilities, limitations, privacy, bias, and likely student use, but also secure subject knowledge, religious and worldview literacy, awareness of confessional and public responsibilities, and opportunities to exercise professional judgment about when AI enhances or diminishes the educational good.
Chrostowski and Mąkosa (2026) show that teachers’ readiness to use AI is shaped by digital competence and professional experience while concerns persist about theological simplification and spiritual depth. Chrostowski’s (2026) review similarly calls for practice-based, theologically grounded models. Case-based professional learning is therefore preferable to isolated technical training: teachers can analyze ambiguous scenarios, compare responses, and make explicit the goods guiding their choices.
Professional wisdom also includes justified non-use. Technological uptake is not itself evidence of educational quality. Teachers should be able to explain why AI is valuable in one context and why slower, interpersonal, embodied, or text-centered practice is preferable in another.
A Practical Design Matrix
Table 1.
A design matrix for aligning AI use with wisdom-centered RE. The matrix is illustrative rather than prescriptive.
Table 1.
A design matrix for aligning AI use with wisdom-centered RE. The matrix is illustrative rather than prescriptive.
| AI-related educational condition | Wisdom-centered risk | Disposition to cultivate | Illustrative religious-education practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fluent instant answers | Confusing plausibility with truth | Epistemic judgment | Audit an AI explanation against primary and scholarly sources; justify corrections and remaining uncertainty. |
| Personalized assistance | Over-dependence and reduced intellectual agency | Responsible autonomy | Require students to document what they accepted, rejected, verified, and revised. |
| Automated ethical advice | Treating moral judgment as rule application | Practical-moral discernment | Compare AI advice with multiple ethical traditions, affected perspectives, and explicit criteria for judgment. |
| Unified algorithmic voice | Flattening intra- and interreligious difference | Intellectual hospitality | Prompt multiple perspectives, then trace each to identifiable traditions, communities, and authorities. |
| Speed and continuous availability | Loss of patience, silence, and sustained attention | Disciplined attention | Use slow reading, reflective silence, dialogue, or handwritten reflection before consulting AI. |
| Efficient content generation | Substituting production for formation | Professional and learner responsibility | Assess reasoning process, oral defence, source use, and accountability rather than polished output alone. |
Objections, Tensions, and Limits
The proposal faces several objections. First, ‘wisdom’ can become too broad and normatively loaded to function as an educational aim. The four-dimensional framework makes it more contestable by specifying practices of source judgment, deliberation, relational responsibility, and theological/worldview interpretation. Even so, wisdom should not be treated as a directly measurable outcome; it is an orienting aim expressed through dispositions and practices whose development is partial and contextual.
Second, the argument may appear to underestimate knowledge. It does not: wisdom-centered CRE depends on strong substantive and disciplinary knowledge. The proposal is not ‘knowledge versus wisdom’ but knowledge ordered through judgment. AI increases the importance of knowing enough to detect confident error, theological flattening, and inappropriate synthesis.
Third, confessional power remains a concern. In Catholic settings, ordering wisdom toward communion with God must not make educational success depend on faith. Learners need genuine space to question, compare, dissent, and suspend judgment, and academic evaluation should concern the quality of understanding and reasoning rather than confessional assent.
Fourth, AI may be treated too exceptionally. Education has always required judgment, and earlier technologies also disrupted access to information. AI’s significance here is diagnostic and accelerative: it makes the appearance of knowledgeable discourse unusually easy to produce, exposing assessments that confuse product with understanding and curricula that confuse coverage with formation.
Finally, the framework is theoretical. It has not demonstrated that wisdom-centered CRE improves learning, discernment, or responsible AI use. Its claims require empirical testing across confessional and nonconfessional settings, with particular caution because pedagogies of ‘formation’ can become coercive when internal moral or spiritual states are inferred from classroom behavior.
Research Agenda
A research program should examine classroom discourse when AI-generated material enters RE, test tasks that require learners to audit outputs against primary and scholarly sources, and compare whether the framework travels across Catholic, other Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, other religious, interfaith, and nonconfessional/worldview settings. Such comparison should attend to where translation fails, since both RE and AI are institutionally and culturally situated.
Assessment research is particularly urgent because take-home writing is less transparent as evidence of individual learning. Studies could compare oral defense, process portfolios, source annotations, dialogical assessment, and supervised synthesis, asking not only what prevents misconduct but what each form makes educationally visible.
Teacher education is a further priority. Chrostowski’s (2026) review calls for practice-based, theologically grounded approaches to AI in Christian religious education (Christian RE). Professional-learning research should investigate how teachers develop criteria for justified use and non-use, and how theological anthropology interacts with classroom decisions. Negative cases - where AI makes learning shallower, increases dependence, or intensifies inequity - are especially important.
Student voice is equally necessary. Learners should be asked how AI changes their experience of authority, effort, trust, uncertainty, disagreement, and religious or worldview inquiry. Particular attention should be given to minority positions and students who do not identify with the sponsoring tradition of a faith-based school, because their responses may expose epistemic or confessional pressures that a theory of wisdom otherwise misses.
Conclusion: Beyond Information Without Abandoning Knowledge
Generative AI has not made information irrelevant; it has made the educational insufficiency of information harder to ignore. The durable question for RE is not which tasks machines cannot yet perform, but what forms of knowing, judging, relating, and acting are worth cultivating in persons who must live with religious difference, technological mediation, and shared public problems.
Wisdom offers a compelling orienting aim when understood neither as a vague spiritual ideal nor as the final rung of a cognitive ladder. Information, disciplinary knowledge, and understanding remain indispensable; wisdom concerns their responsible ordering through judgment. Aristotle clarifies the practical and particular character of judgment, Aquinas relates prudence and wisdom to truth and ultimate ends, Dunne exposes the limits of technique, and Biesta highlights responsible subjecthood in relation to a shared world.
In the Catholic case, these resources converge in four dimensions: epistemic judgment, practical-moral discernment, relational responsibility, and theological orientation. The first three can function as bridge concepts for wider RE; the fourth requires explicit translation within each tradition or worldview. Together they imply curricula that make the purposes of knowledge visible, pedagogies of inquiry and patient attention, assessments that make judgment accountable, and teacher formation that exceeds technical AI competence.
The proposal remains deliberately modest. Wisdom cannot be engineered or measured directly, faith-based education should not use formation to compel assent, and public education should not invoke neutrality in ways that silence substantive commitments. RE can, however, create disciplined conditions in which learners encounter traditions and worldviews in depth, judge claims and sources, deliberate about action, attend to others, and engage competing accounts of the human good with intellectual seriousness and freedom.
AI therefore functions as an epistemic stress test for RE, including CRE and wider Christian RE. It reveals how easily educational practice can confuse retrieval with knowledge, fluency with understanding, and production with formation. It also increases the need for discernment about truth, trust, authority, purpose, power, and responsibility. The future relevance of RE will depend less on guarding information that technology can reproduce than on cultivating forms of judgment through which persons can inhabit deep difference, resist reduction, and seek the common good. Wisdom, on this account, is not a nostalgic alternative to technology but a demanding description of educational work that technology makes newly visible.
References
- Aquinas, Thomas. 1947. Summa Theologiae. Translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province. New York: Benziger Brothers. Original work written ca. 1265-1274.
- Aristotle. 1999. Nicomachean Ethics. 2nd ed. Translated by Terence Irwin. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett.
- Biesta, Gert J. J. 2022. World-Centred Education: A View for the Present. London: Routledge.
- Choi, Miseon. 2026. Navigating Digital Colonialism: A Postcolonial Approach to AI and Global Justice. Religious Education 121 (1): 12-25. [CrossRef]
- Chrostowski, Mariusz. 2026. Artificial Intelligence in Christian Religious Education: A Scoping Review. Religions 17 (8): 991. [CrossRef]
- Chrostowski, Mariusz, and Paweł Mąkosa. 2026. Ambivalent Perceptions of Artificial Intelligence in Religious Education: A Comparative Study among Teachers in Germany and Poland. Teaching Theology & Religion 28 (2): 110-123. [CrossRef]
- Cohen, Etan. 2026. Caught Between Faith and Faithfulness in a Knowledge Building Community: Constructing Religious Identity in a Technologically Enhanced Learning Environment. Religious Education. Advance online publication. [CrossRef]
- Congregation for Catholic Education. 2009. Circular Letter to the Presidents of Bishops’ Conferences on Religious Education in Schools. Vatican City: The Holy See.
- Congregation for Catholic Education. 2022. The Identity of the Catholic School for a Culture of Dialogue. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana.
- Cooling, Trevor. 2025. Knowledge in a Religion and Worldviews Approach in English Schools. British Journal of Religious Education 47 (2): 130-139. [CrossRef]
- Corpuz, Jeff Clyde G. 2025. Faith and Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Catholic Education: A Theological Virtue Ethics Perspective. Religions 16 (8): 1083. [CrossRef]
- de Kock, A. (Jos). 2025. Christian Digital Faith Formation Among Young Adults: A Literature Review. Religious Education 120 (5): 438-455. [CrossRef]
- Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, and Dicastery for Culture and Education. 2025. Antiqua et Nova: Note on the Relationship between Artificial Intelligence and Human Intelligence. Vatican City: The Holy See.
- Dunne, Joseph. 1997. Back to the Rough Ground: Practical Judgment and the Lure of Technique. 2nd ed. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.
- Gopez, Jose Ma W., Ivan Efreaim A. Gozum, and Beatriz B. Gopez. 2026. The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Catholic Religious Education: A Tool for Engagement, Not a Substitute for Human Presence. Journal of Religious Education 74: 207-223. [CrossRef]
- Hess, Mary E. 2012. Mirror Neurons, the Development of Empathy, and Digital Story Telling. Religious Education 107 (4): 401-414. [CrossRef]
- Hess, Mary E. 2014. A New Culture of Learning: Digital Storytelling and Faith Formation. Dialog 53 (1): 12-22. [CrossRef]
- Hirst, Paul H. 1974. Knowledge and the Curriculum. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
- Jackson, Robert. 2014. Signposts: Policy and Practice for Teaching about Religions and Non-Religious World Views in Intercultural Education. Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publishing.
- King, Pamela Ebstyne, Sam A. Hardy, and Sean Noe. 2021. Developmental Perspectives on Adolescent Religious and Spiritual Development. Adolescent Research Review 6: 253-264. [CrossRef]
- King, Pamela Ebstyne, Susan Mangan, and Rodrigo Riveros. 2023. Religion, Spirituality, and Youth Thriving: Investigating the Roles of the Developing Mind and Meaning-Making. In Handbook of Positive Psychology, Religion, and Spirituality, edited by Edward B. Davis, Everett L. Worthington Jr., and Steven J. Schnitker, 263-277. Cham: Springer. [CrossRef]
- Maxwell, Nicholas. 2007. From Knowledge to Wisdom: A Revolution for Science and the Humanities. 2nd ed. London: Pentire Press.
- Mercer, Joyce Ann. 2026. Wisdom in Religious Education. Religious Education 121 (2): 113-116. [CrossRef]
- Moulin, Daniel. 2023. Religion and Worldviews Education and the Paradox of Inclusivity. Journal of Religious Education 71: 269-278. [CrossRef]
- OECD. 2023. OECD Digital Education Outlook 2023: Towards an Effective Digital Education Ecosystem. Paris: OECD Publishing.
- Papakostas, Christos. 2025. Artificial Intelligence in Religious Education: Ethical, Pedagogical, and Theological Perspectives. Religions 16 (5): 563. [CrossRef]
- Sultana, Carl-Mario. 2020. Catechesis and Catholic Religious Education: Distinct Nonetheless Complementary. Verbum Vitae 37 (2): 365-379. [CrossRef]
- UNESCO. 2023. Guidance for Generative AI in Education and Research. Paris: UNESCO.
- Wright, Andrew, and Elina Wright. 2024. Religious Education and Worldview Theory. British Journal of Religious Education 46 (1): 4-13. [CrossRef]
- Yust, Karen-Marie. 2026. Reflections on Children, Digital Culture, and AI. Religious Education 121 (1): 4-11. [CrossRef]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the author. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.