Preprint
Article

This version is not peer-reviewed.

Chromatic Ritualization and the Reorganization of Religious Agency in Alejandro Jodorowsky’s Santa Sangre (1989)

Submitted:

21 September 2026

Posted:

22 September 2026

You are already at the latest version

Abstract
Alejandro Jodorowsky’s Santa Sangre (1989) places a disputed blood cult, an armless martyr, and a mother–son performance at the center of a narrative of violence and release. This article examines how these religious images acquire authority through their relationships with bodies and repeated actions. Bringing ritual theory into dialogue with material approaches to religion and film color, it develops chromatic ritualization as a term for the way recurring colors connect sacred objects, bodily roles, and obligations across changing narrative situations. A qualitative analysis follows the red pool at the destroyed shrine, Concha’s identification with the wounded saint, Fénix’s performance as his mother’s arms, and the removal of his red artificial nails before the final surrender. The argument is that color helps transfer authority from a contested religious site to an intimate arrangement in which devotion becomes bodily obedience. The ending interrupts this arrangement without establishing an unmediated or entirely autonomous self. Liberation appears instead as the possibility of refusing one command while entering other relationships of assistance and accountability. This reading locates the film’s religious significance in the reorganization of embodied agency, while distinguishing represented transformation from untested claims about cinema’s therapeutic effects.
Keywords: 
;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  

1. Introduction

An image of suffering can solicit care, authorize an institution, or demand another person’s obedience. These possibilities are brought into unsettling proximity in Alejandro Jodorowsky’s Santa Sangre (1989). Its religious imagery does more than establish a background of eccentric belief. A murdered girl’s missing arms become the identifying feature of a sacred image; a mother’s mutilation repeats that bodily configuration; and her son subsequently supplies the arms through which she appears to act. The same bodily absence passes through different relations among victim, image, devotee, performer, and aggressor. What begins as a demand that suffering be recognized becomes an arrangement in which recognition requires someone else’s body to remain at another’s disposal.
Color makes this movement perceptible without explaining it away. The shrine’s red pool is presented as the martyr’s enduring blood, while red artificial nails later mark the hands through which Fénix performs his mother’s agency. Red does not retain one stable meaning as it moves between these situations. Its significance depends on the material that bears it, the story told about that material, and the actions expected of those who encounter it. At the shrine, the question is whether a substance warrants collective devotion. In the mother–son performance, the question is whose intention a visible hand is understood to realize. At the ending, removing a colored attachment helps change the terms under which those hands can act.
This article asks how Santa Sangre reorganizes religious imagery through such relationships. Its central claim is that the film’s movement toward release is neither simply the rejection of religion nor the recovery of a self-untouched by images. It is a redistribution of embodied agency. The term chromatic ritualization names the contribution of recurring color to this process: color associates objects and actions with one another, supports their differentiation from ordinary conduct, and makes a previously established obligation available for repetition or refusal. The term does not designate a universal psychological effect of red, nor does it imply that every striking composition constitutes a ritual.
Scholarship on Jodorowsky provides several contexts for this argument. Church’s (2007) account connects the director’s cinema with theatrical performance, spiritual experimentation, and psychomagic, locating Santa Sangre within an artistic concern with familial domination and transformation. Breckenridge (2015), discussing El Topo and The Holy Mountain, argues that Jodorowsky’s challenges extend to countercultural spirituality as well as established religion. His argument makes it difficult to assume that leaving an institution necessarily brings freedom from spiritual authority. More recently, Kelleci and Sekmen (2026) interpret Santa Sangre alongside those films through Jungian archetypes and the process of individuation. Their account recognizes the importance of Fénix’s separation from maternal domination, including the significance of the artificial nails. The present analysis therefore does not claim to discover either the film’s transformation narrative or the symbolic importance of its hands.
It asks a different question about the mechanism of transformation. Instead of beginning with an archetype whose meaning the film realizes, it follows the changing practical relations through which a particular image becomes authoritative. The distinction matters because the same image can support incompatible actions. A wounded figure may call for protection, yet identification with that figure can also become a demand for unlimited service. Likewise, a raised hand may signify vulnerability, submission, or the recognition of one’s capacity to act. These meanings emerge within situations rather than preceding them as an invariant symbolic vocabulary.
The study draws on Bell’s (1992) account of ritualization, Meyer’s (2009) approach to religious mediation, and Morgan’s (2012) analysis of religious seeing as embodied practice. Plate’s (2017) comparison of cinematic and religious worldmaking supplies a bridge between the construction of filmic space and the organization of sacred relations. Work on film color by Coates (2010) and Misek (2010) further encourages attention to color as an element whose significance changes with its formal and cultural circumstances. Together, these approaches support a reading in which religious images are neither self-sufficient symbols nor passive illustrations of a psychological narrative.
The argument proceeds through the contested shrine, Concha’s transformation into a commanding maternal image, the choreography of borrowed hands, and the ending’s interruption of that choreography. It then considers the limits of interpreting these events as healing. Its contribution to religion and film studies is a specific account of how cinematic form can connect the authorization of sacred matter with the organization of bodily action. Santa Sangre makes that connection troubling: the film gives material form to the possibility that devotion and domination may share an arrangement of bodies even when their ethical claims differ.

2. Materials, Method, and Conceptual Framework

2.1. A Relational Approach to Images and Ritual

Bell (1992) shifts the analysis of ritual toward the differentiated and strategically organized activity she terms ritualization. This perspective makes it possible to ask how certain actions acquire a privileged status in relation to other actions, rather than identifying ritual solely through a checklist of ceremonial features. Applied here, the question concerns the practical difference between recognizing a wounded body and allowing that body’s image to organize another person’s movements. The film’s relevant contrasts include sacred substance and ordinary material, foregrounded performer and supporting body, obligatory repetition and an action that can be withheld.
Meyer (2009) treats mediation as internal to religious life rather than an external instrument for conveying a preexisting spiritual content. Her discussion of aesthetic formations and sensational forms directs attention to the sensory arrangements through which people become connected to religious worlds and to one another. Morgan (2012), in turn, situates religious vision within relationships among the senses, bodies, and feeling. These perspectives resist an account in which religious meaning exists first as an idea and only subsequently acquires a visual illustration. The pool, costume, image, and moving hand in Santa Sangre are means through which authority becomes available to perception and action.
The application of these theories requires a distinction between an actual religious community and its fictional construction. Santa Sangre does not supply ethnographic evidence about a Mexican community’s ritual practices. Its blood cult is a cinematic invention presented in conflict with Catholic authority. Accordingly, the following analysis describes a Catholic-coded field of images, devotional claims, and institutional judgments. It does not identify the cult with a documented tradition merely because its imagery combines blood, martyrdom, popular devotion, and theatrical display. Nor does its invented character make it irrelevant to religion: the dispute over what counts as a sacred object is itself part of the film’s religious subject matter.
Plate (2017) identifies important formal correspondences between religious and cinematic worldmaking, including their organization of attention, space, and time. This article uses that comparison while maintaining three analytical levels. The first concerns rituals and devotional actions represented within the narrative. The second concerns the film’s arrangement of images and actions into patterns that invite comparison. The third concerns actual audience practices and responses. The first two can be investigated through textual interpretation; the third requires evidence about viewers, settings, and occasions of reception. A formal resemblance between a film sequence and a ritual does not establish that watching the sequence produces ritual participation or therapeutic benefit.

2.2. What Chromatic Ritualization Identifies

Chromatic ritualization refers here to the patterned association of color with objects, bodily positions, and repeatable actions that establish or contest an obligation. The definition contains three requirements. A color must be materially situated: the red of a pool is not interchangeable with the red of an artificial nail. Its appearance must enter a temporal relationship with other appearances: an earlier scene changes what a later one can suggest. Finally, the association must matter to an arrangement of agency, such as who authorizes a substance, who moves a hand, or who can refuse to continue a performance. Mere chromatic prominence is insufficient.
This approach draws a limited methodological lesson from studies of screen color. Misek’s (2010) historical account situates color within changing technological and aesthetic relations, while Coates (2010) examines its symbolic and formal possibilities across films and cultural contexts. Neither requires the critic to treat a hue as a fixed psychological instruction. In the present case, the relevant continuity is not an exact match between measured wavelengths or digital values. It is the narrative association of conspicuous red materials with blood, performance, and the attribution of action. The analysis therefore makes no quantitative claim about saturation, luminance, or a progressively changing palette.
Three questions guide each sequence reading. What gives the image or object a claim to special recognition? Through what bodily actions is that claim maintained? What changes when those actions are interrupted or assigned to a different participant? These questions permit comparison without forcing the narrative into a universal sequence of initiation and cure. Consecration, incorporation, and release are used as analytical descriptions of changing relationships, not as a claim that the film implements a complete traditional rite of passage.

2.3. Materials and Interpretive Limits

The primary object is Santa Sangre (Jodorowsky 1989). The analysis is organized around identifiable narrative sequences rather than edition-dependent timestamps: the dispute at the blood shrine; Concha’s mutilation and subsequent apparent return; the performance in which Fénix supplies her arms; the extension of that arrangement into violence; and the final separation and surrender. It brings narrative structure into relation with costume, bodily alignment, recurring objects, and the distribution of visible action. Scene descriptions identify the basis of an interpretation; statements about what a configuration authorizes or contests are the article’s analytical claims.
The retrospective revelation concerning Concha is especially consequential. Before that revelation, the narrative presents a mother who commands and a son whose hands enact her will. Afterward, this relation must also be understood through the mannequin and Fénix’s sustained performance of maternal presence. The analysis distinguishes these levels instead of treating every represented event as an objectively occurring interaction between two living people. It also avoids clinically diagnosing Fénix. Terms such as domination, repetition, and release describe the film’s organization of action rather than a verified disorder, treatment, or recovery.

3. The Blood Shrine and the Problem of Authorization

The shrine establishes a relation between an injured body and a community before the narrative makes the mother’s body central. Concha leads a group devoted to a girl whose arms were cut off in an act of sexual violence. A red pool is identified as the girl’s blood, and the bodily mutilation supplies a recognizable form through which her suffering can be represented. The visiting ecclesiastical authority rejects the shrine’s claim to sanctity; the site is subsequently destroyed. Church’s (2007) discussion identifies this conflict between the sect, Catholic authority, and the agents of demolition as part of the film’s social and religious field.
The scene’s central issue is not exhausted by asking whether the red substance is authentic blood. Its material identity becomes significant because different participants claim the right to determine what others should do in its presence. For Concha and the devotees, the pool gives the story of the victim a continuing location. The substance is offered as a surviving connection with an absent body, and the shrine organizes collective attention around that connection. For the ecclesiastical visitor, withholding recognition breaks the claimed passage from visible material to legitimate devotion. The disagreement is therefore simultaneously about an object, a narrative, and an authority to classify religious action.
The red pool does not speak independently of these relationships. Without the martyr’s story, it would not identify a particular victim. Without people prepared to gather around and defend it, the assertion of sacred blood would have no represented community of practice. Without the institutional visitor, the disagreement over legitimacy would have a different form. The scene assembles these elements so that religious authority appears as something enacted through competing judgments and bodily commitments. Red supplies a forceful perceptual focus, but the force of that focus remains dependent on the claims made around it.
The devotees’ matching red tunics extend this organization beyond the pool. A repeated pale emblem distinguishes the garments, while flowers, candles, and musical instruments place the collective body within a recognizable devotional setting. The gathering is not simply a set of individuals who happen to share a belief. Clothing makes their affiliation visible. Concha’s outstretched arms before the shrine further connect leadership with the exposure of a body that can still act and address others. The later loss of those arms retrospectively changes the gesture’s significance. This contrast does not establish that she is literally a Christ figure; it makes the relation between bodily capacity and devotional display available for comparison. Color thus operates at more than one scale: it marks the material focus of the shrine and the bodies gathered to defend that focus.
This arrangement evokes a broader Christian association among blood, bodily suffering, and sacred presence without reproducing a particular sacrament. Bynum’s (2007) historical study of late medieval blood devotion shows that blood could be both a material object of veneration and a source of theological dispute. Her account is useful here as a reminder that material intensity and institutional agreement need not coincide. It is not evidence that Jodorowsky derived the scene from medieval northern European practices. Nor should the pool be identified straightforwardly with Eucharistic wine. The film offers neither a stable liturgical equivalence nor sufficient grounds for tracing that genealogy.
The relationship to martyr imagery is more immediate. The girl’s mutilated body is made available as the object around which others organize fidelity. Her missing arms are not simply a sign that violence happened. They become the feature that permits the later association between the saint and Concha. This is a specifically cinematic possibility: the earlier configuration can persist in narrative memory and be activated by a later body without an explanatory theological statement. The film does not have to declare Concha a saint for the resemblance to become consequential.
The shrine also distributes vulnerability unequally. The absent girl cannot regulate how her image is used. The devotees can defend the place but cannot guarantee its survival. The institutional visitor can withhold religious recognition, while the machinery of demolition can eliminate the material site. These are different capacities, and the sequence gains complexity when they are not collapsed into a single conflict between belief and unbelief. To demolish the shrine is not to settle every question it raises about injury, remembrance, and the people attached to an image.
Destruction consequently fails to provide a simple narrative closure. The shrine disappears, but its principal bodily configuration survives in the story that follows. Once Concha loses her arms, the saint’s identifying absence returns in a new and intimate setting. The religious relation has been displaced rather than merely abolished. A public dispute over a sacred object gives way to a private arrangement in which a person appears to embody the wounded image and another person is required to complete it.
The transition is crucial to the article’s account of color. Red first gathers blood, remembrance, and devotion around a bounded site. Later, it is carried by attachments to a moving body. This does not mean the film transfers a measurable quantity of sacred power from pool to hand. It creates a relation of recognition through which the later performance can inherit the affective and ethical pressure of the earlier scene. The spectator is invited to ask not only what has been lost with the shrine, but also what happens when fidelity to an image survives the destruction of its original place.

4. From Wounded Saint to Commanding Mother

Concha’s mutilation repeats the saint’s missing arms, but the repetition does not make the two figures identical. Concha is a circus performer and a religious leader before she becomes the injured mother whose apparent return structures Fénix’s adult life. Her confrontation with Orgo joins sexual betrayal, retaliation, mutilation, and suicide within a scene witnessed by the child. This history matters because maternal authority is subsequently encountered through the memory of a violently injured person. The demand to serve is difficult to separate from the demand not to abandon a victim.
The film’s reorganization of martyr imagery depends on that difficulty. A saint’s image conventionally separates the represented sufferer from the present bodies of devotees. In Santa Sangre, the later mother–son arrangement collapses that distance in an unusual way: the devotee supplies what the wounded image lacks. Fénix does not simply contemplate or imitate his mother. He inserts his own capacity for action into the space occupied by her missing arms. Bodily service appears to restore her public image while depriving him of a separate position from which to negotiate its demands.
The term living icon can describe Concha’s function at this stage, provided it is understood as an interpretive comparison. It does not mean that the film presents an orthodox icon or a recognized practice of saintly embodiment. Rather, the image of suffering appears to acquire an active body. The earlier martyr’s inability to act is replaced by the apparent mother’s power to direct another person. The relation between image and devotee becomes recursive: the son sustains the image, and the image returns as the authority that tells the son what his sustaining actions must be.
This is why the narrative cannot be reduced to a sequence in which a false public religion is replaced by an equally false private belief. Something more specific changes. At the shrine, legitimacy is contested among several visible parties. In the adult domestic arrangement, the commanding maternal presence narrows the field of recognition. Fénix encounters the mother’s demand as both intimate and difficult to externalize. The loss of a shared institutional setting does not necessarily diminish the force of the sacred pattern. Instead, a relation formerly organized around a defended place is concentrated in repeated bodily conduct.
The subsequent revelation of the mannequin transforms this account without making the preceding imagery irrelevant. The mother’s apparent agency must be understood as an effect sustained through Fénix’s movements, attachments, and acts of recognition. Her authority has not been physically independent of him, but it has nevertheless organized the actions presented by the narrative. The distinction between an externally acting person and a material image is therefore indispensable; the distinction between an effective image and a merely inert object is less secure. The mannequin has no intention of its own, yet it participates in an arrangement through which intention is attributed and responsibility displaced.
At the same time, an interpretation of domination must not make bodily difference its explanation. Concha is not dangerous because an armless body is inherently threatening, and Fénix’s assistance is not coercive simply because one body supports another. Mitchell and Snyder’s (2001) account of narrative prosthesis draws attention to the use of disability as a resource for characterization and narrative resolution. Their critique is relevant because the film repeatedly makes bodily difference carry a symbolic burden. A reading that equates physical completeness with moral autonomy would repeat that burden rather than examine it.
The ethical problem lies instead in the conditions of the relation: assistance is made compulsory, the assisting person’s other attachments become intolerable, and the capacity to stop is restricted. Shared action can be an ordinary and enabling feature of embodied life. What makes this arrangement destructive is the conversion of another person’s capacity into an exclusive entitlement. The distinction becomes especially important when Alma’s assistance later helps Fénix interrupt the maternal performance. The film presents more than one kind of dependence, and its resolution cannot be understood simply as the elimination of dependence itself.
Gender complicates the same interpretation. Concha occupies the position of victim before becoming the image through which violence against other women is authorized. These positions must remain in view together. Her suffering cannot excuse the subsequent violence, but the violence should not retrospectively erase what Orgo does to her. Likewise, attributing every killing to an overpowering maternal figure would risk reproducing the displacement of responsibility enacted by Fénix. The film’s final reattribution of the hands makes this displacement an object of inquiry: the maternal image explains the form of obedience within the narrative, but it cannot absolve the person whose body performs the acts.

5. Borrowed Hands and the Ritualization of Performance

5.1. The Composite Body

The mother–son act gives the film’s problem of agency a precise spatial form. Fénix stands behind Concha so that his arms appear to belong to her body. The arrangement makes one figure publicly legible as the source of expressive movement while another supplies that movement. It is not simply a metaphor for influence. It is an organized task requiring bodily placement, coordination, and the maintenance of a visible composite. The result is an image whose apparent unity depends on a labor that its presentation partly obscures.
The scene can be read at two levels simultaneously. Within the act, successful coordination makes the mother appear capable of gestures she could not perform alone. At the level of the narrative, the same coordination makes visible the son’s difficulty in acting independently. The pleasure of the theatrical illusion and the discomfort of submission are therefore produced by the same arrangement. An interpretation that labels the act only grotesque misses its skill; one that celebrates its bodily inventiveness without attending to the surrounding commands misses the conditions under which that skill is exercised.
The red artificial nails are particularly important because they identify the borrowed hands with the maternal performance. They do not alter the anatomical ownership of the fingers. They change their appearance and the role in which those fingers are recognized. Unlike the blood pool, which anchors devotion to a site and a story of irreversible injury, the nails are detachable objects. They offer a small but consequential material distinction between a body’s capacity and the visual identity imposed on that capacity. The ending can work with this distinction because the attachment is removable, even though its authority has been difficult to refuse.
Chromatic recurrence links these different materials without making them equivalent. Blood is a substance associated with the loss of bodily integrity; an artificial nail is an addition to a bodily surface. The film places subtraction and supplementation into relation: the absent arms are apparently supplied, and the supplied hands receive a visible mark of their assigned identity. Red helps connect these operations, but it does not provide their entire meaning. Position, costume, gesture, and narrative context make the association legible. The relevant unit of analysis is consequently a colored action performed within a relation, not an isolated red object.
Church (2007) notes that the pair’s mime includes the biblical creation story. This introduces another displacement within the performance. A narrative of origination is presented through a body whose visible power depends on another body’s partially concealed contribution. Creation becomes a performed appearance of agency. The comparison does not require identifying Concha with God or Fénix with a particular biblical figure. Its significance lies in the tension between the act’s capacity to produce a world of expressive gestures and the unequal attribution of the labor that makes that world possible.
The stage therefore reorganizes religious imagery at the level of action. The shrine asks spectators within the film to recognize an enduring trace of suffering; the performance asks them to recognize a unified acting body. Both depend on a relation between what is visible and what is attributed to it. Yet the second arrangement relocates the religious problem from the authenticity of matter to the source of movement. The mother’s image no longer primarily asks to be protected. It appears to command the very bodily activity through which it is maintained.

5.2. Repetition Beyond the Stage

The act would have a different ethical meaning if Fénix could enter and leave it as a delimited theatrical role. The narrative troubles that boundary. The mother’s claim on his hands extends beyond public performance into intimate conduct and the violence directed toward women with whom he might form other attachments. What initially appears as a coordinated act becomes a rule governing which relationships can be tolerated. The son’s body is made to preserve the exclusivity of the maternal image.
Ritualization is useful here because it directs attention to the production of a privileged pattern of action. The repeated relation distinguishes the mother’s command from competing requests and desires. It does not merely express a psychological state that exists elsewhere. It gives that state a repeatable practical form: the body is positioned, the role is recognizable, and action is attributed through a familiar arrangement. The interpretation extends Bell’s (1992) attention to differentiated practice to the film’s fictional organization of obedience; it does not claim that the murders constitute an established religious rite.
The temporal effect also differs from simple recurrence of the same visual motif. Once the hands have been presented as the mother’s, a later movement can carry the memory of that assignment even when the staging differs. The past remains effective as an instruction for future conduct. Conversely, later violence changes the earlier act’s meaning. What could initially be encountered as an ingenious solution to bodily absence becomes evidence of a relation whose demands exceed the stage. Color participates in this retroactive interpretation by allowing an attachment associated with performance to carry increasingly troubling implications.
This account preserves the original importance of duration while avoiding an unsupported claim that the film’s colors induce a particular altered state in viewers. The relevant duration is the persistence and revision of an association across narrative time. A colored object accumulates significance because the narrative repeatedly returns the body to a role. The contribution of editing and sequence is not reducible to the intensity of any individual hue. It lies in the spectator’s opportunity to compare what a visible mark permits in one situation with what it requires in another.
Nor does the argument require a universal opposition between red and white. Alma’s mime appearance and her difference from Concha can invite symbolic contrasts, but assigning white an intrinsic purity would settle the ethical question before examining what she does. Similarly, the red nails cannot be treated as inherently corrupting. Their function depends on the part they play in a coercive arrangement. The same hands become available for another relation when their assignment changes. The film’s moral difference is enacted through the treatment of bodies rather than secured by a color code.
The category of performance thus remains ambivalent. It can sustain an image that captures another person’s agency, but it can also expose the constructed character of that image. The composite body demonstrates both capacities. Its effects depend on whether its organization remains available for recognition, interruption, and revision. This ambivalence prepares the ending: release will require an alteration in the practice of maintaining the image, not simply a verbal announcement that the image is false.

6. Removing the Nails and Raising the Hands

Alma’s return places the established pattern under pressure because her presence opens a relation that the maternal command cannot accommodate. The demand that Fénix repeat violence confronts the possibility of refusal. The resulting revelation—that Concha has been dead and that a mannequin has sustained her apparent presence—reclassifies the preceding performances. The commanding figure is disclosed as an image maintained through the very body it appeared to control. Yet the disclosure alone does not complete the movement toward release. The film proceeds through practical acts that dismantle the arrangement and change what the hands can signify.
The destruction of the private devotional construction recalls the earlier destruction of the public shrine, but the parallel should not conceal the difference between them. At the earlier site, an external force eliminates a place that others seek to preserve. Near the ending, Fénix acts against the material arrangement through which the maternal presence has been maintained. The same general action—destroying a charged object or place—can therefore occupy opposing positions in the narrative. Its ethical meaning depends on the relation it interrupts and the capacity of those involved to participate in that interruption.
This difference also complicates the language of iconoclasm. Destroying an image does not by itself establish freedom, because an image’s relations can persist after its physical disappearance. The earlier shrine has already demonstrated that possibility. The later destruction acquires its force from its connection with other acts: refusal of the command, recognition of the mannequin, Alma’s intervention, and the altered status of the hands. The material image is neither the sole source of domination nor a negligible prop. Its removal matters within a wider reorganization of conduct.
Alma removes the red artificial nails from Fénix’s fingers. Kelleci and Sekmen (2026) read this episode in relation to his liberation from maternal control. The present argument specifies the episode’s material and relational structure. What is removed is not the hand and not the capacity to act. It is an attachment that helped identify the hand as the vehicle of another’s will. The action reverses the earlier supplementation: where a colored addition supported the composite image, detachment now makes that image harder to sustain in the same form.
Alma’s role prevents this reversal from being described as a solitary triumph of will. Fénix does not achieve independence by withdrawing from all contact. Another person participates in the alteration of his body’s visible role. This assistance differs from the maternal arrangement because it loosens an exclusive claim rather than establishing a new requirement that his hands act as hers. The distinction is enacted through what the contact enables. The same general fact of dependence can support either a restriction of possible action or an opening toward it.
Alma’s deafness and nonspeaking performance should likewise not be transformed into evidence of supernatural purity. The film gives her an important role in the protagonist’s release, but this role does not justify treating disability as a direct route to spiritual authenticity. Such an interpretation would substitute one idealized bodily sign for another. It would also obscure her practical acts and her own exposure to violence. What matters to the present reading is that she changes the terms of contact: the other person’s hands become capable of relinquishing an imposed role without becoming isolated from help.
The final command to raise those hands makes the ending more complicated than an uncomplicated restoration of autonomy. Fénix emerges from the private space and complies with the police. He recognizes the hands as his own at precisely the moment when their movement answers an external instruction. The scene therefore does not present selfhood as freedom from every command. It distinguishes between a relation that obscures the source of action and a situation in which the acting body becomes publicly identifiable and answerable.
This is an ethical interpretation of the ending, not a prediction of what the legal system will do to him. The film does not establish a completed process of judgment, rehabilitation, or restitution. It does, however, end at a point where the hands can no longer be attributed exclusively to an absent mother. Their recognition restores the question of responsibility. The joy attached to their recovery exists alongside, rather than outside, the history of what those hands have done.
The raised gesture also remains visually open to more than one association. It can suggest surrender, exposure, wonder, or a relinquishing of the capacity to harm in that moment. Reading it as an unequivocal Christian gesture of salvation would narrow this plurality without sufficient evidence. The earlier religious images make the action resonant, but they do not authorize a single theological translation. The sequence leaves the body visible and vulnerable in a shared world instead of installing a new image as the final guarantor of its meaning.
The film’s reorganization can consequently be described as a shift from enforced completion to interruptible relation. Fénix is no longer required to make the wounded maternal image whole through an exclusive supply of his own movement. His hands remain capable of dependence, response, and responsibility. Release consists in their altered availability: they can stop sustaining one configuration and enter another without being visually absorbed into the other person’s body. That is a more limited claim than total healing, but it is also more faithful to the ending’s unresolved conjunction of recognition and surrender.

7. Discussion

7.1. What the Film Changes in Religious Imagery

The analysis identifies three connected operations. First, the shrine makes injury available as an enduring object of collective recognition. Second, the maternal performance converts recognition of injury into a demand for bodily service. Third, the ending breaks the exclusivity of that demand by separating a living capacity from the material attachments and repeated actions that had assigned it to the mother. These operations are not equivalent to a movement from religion to secular reason. The film’s critical object is a particular organization of devotion and authority, and its imagined alternative remains dependent on images, gestures, and other people.
The religious images are therefore reorganized in their relationships rather than discarded as meaningless. Martyrdom supplies a form of recognition that is subsequently made to authorize command. The sacred trace becomes an embodied demand. A performance of creation reveals a dependence hidden within an apparent origin of action. Image destruction becomes potentially liberating only when connected to a different distribution of agency. The final hands retain the history of these relations even as they become available for an action the earlier arrangement could not permit.
Color contributes to this movement because it can persist across a change of material support. The red pool and the red nails do not share a substance, scale, or use. Their relationship is made through narrative association. That association allows a spectator to connect a public claim about sacred blood with the intimate problem of whose hands are acting. The removal of the nails then gives the association an endpoint that is material without requiring the disappearance of color from the screen. The account does not depend on a final purification of the entire palette.
This is also why chromatic ritualization should remain a precise rather than expansive concept. It is most useful when color participates in a demonstrable change in the relation among an image, a body, and an obligation. It becomes less useful if applied to every repetition or visually intense passage. In this case, its explanatory value lies in following a limited cluster of materials and acts across the narrative. The resulting interpretation can be contested by asking whether the proposed associations are supported and whether they change the attribution of action; it cannot be secured by the general claim that Jodorowsky’s cinema is spiritual.

7.2. Transformation Without a Guarantee of Healing

Turner’s (1969) account of liminality makes transitions in social position available as an important comparative problem. Santa Sangre, however, does not warrant a direct equation between its narrative and a completed rite of passage. Fénix’s departure from the maternal arrangement does not end in an established communal status whose stability the film demonstrates. The police encounter introduces a new set of relations, but the narrative stops before their consequences are known. Liminality is therefore more useful as a question about transition and recognition than as a template that guarantees successful incorporation.
The same restraint applies to embodiment. Sobchack (2004) offers a phenomenological account of the bodily dimensions of moving-image experience. That perspective supports taking the film’s visible hands, surfaces, and contacts seriously as more than abstract signs. It does not establish that all spectators undergo the same bodily response, still less that such a response repairs trauma. The present study identifies formal invitations to notice constraint, substitution, and release. Whether particular viewers accept those invitations, resist them, or experience them as distressing requires a different research design.
There is nevertheless a defensible sense in which the film concerns repair. Its ending makes a previously compulsory performance available for interruption. The body can be recognized as capable of another action without pretending that its previous acts have disappeared. Repair in this restricted sense is a change in the conditions of acting and relating. It is not a claim that Fénix has recovered a pristine self, achieved clinical recovery, or completed moral restitution. Retaining these distinctions allows the film’s hopeful ending to remain ethically difficult.
The distinction also positions this argument in relation to archetypal interpretation. An individuation reading can describe the separation from a dominating maternal figure as part of an integrated self’s emergence. A relational reading asks what practices make separation possible and what dependencies remain afterward. It does not need to disprove every account of inner transformation. It shows that transformation has a visible organization: detachable objects, spatial alignment, assistance, refusal, and the public presentation of the hands. These details prevent selfhood from becoming an explanatory destination that renders its material conditions incidental.
Several limits remain. The article addresses a single film and a selected network of motifs; it does not offer a comprehensive history of Mexican devotional imagery or Jodorowsky’s religious sources. It does not establish the director’s intention for every color recurrence. Nor does it compare the color grading of different releases. Such a comparison could refine claims about appearance, while reception research could examine how religious background, disability experience, and viewing context affect interpretation. These extensions should test the argument’s boundaries rather than be treated as findings already contained in the close reading.

8. Conclusions

Santa Sangre reorganizes religious imagery by changing the actions and obligations through which it becomes effective. The armless martyr’s image makes suffering an object of devotion; Concha’s corresponding injury allows that image to return as an intimate authority; and the composite mother–son body turns devotion into a repeated allocation of movement. Red helps link these arrangements across differences of material, scale, and setting. Its function depends on what bodies do in relation to the colored object, not on an invariant meaning carried by the hue.
The ending changes that allocation through refusal, disclosure, detachment, and assistance. Removing the artificial nails separates the hand’s capacity from a visible role that had helped bind it to the maternal image. Raising the hands before the police then places recognition of agency alongside exposure and accountability. The result is neither a complete exit from mediation nor a demonstrated cure. It is the possibility of acting without having every action absorbed into a single image’s demand.
For the study of religion and film, the case shows the value of moving between iconography and practical relations. The question is not only which religious symbols a film contains, but how its formal organization makes bodies sustain, contest, or relinquish those symbols’ authority. Chromatic ritualization offers one way of tracing this process. In Santa Sangre, the decisive transformation is not that the world ceases to contain commanding images. It is that a body begins to interrupt the arrangement through which one image has claimed the exclusive right to act in its place.

Author Contributions

The author was responsible for conceptualization, methodology, formal analysis, investigation, original draft preparation, and writing review and editing. The author has read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Institutional Review Board Statement

Not applicable. This article analyzes a publicly released film and published literature and does not report research involving human participants or animals.

Data Availability Statement

No new datasets were generated or analyzed. The primary film and the published works discussed are identified in the references.

Acknowledgments

Not applicable.

Conflicts of Interest

The author declares no conflicts of interest.

Conference disclosure

This article develops an earlier version accepted for conference presentation. No full-length paper was published in the conference proceedings. Identifying details are provided in the cover letter.

References

  1. Bell, Catherine. 1992. Ritual Theory, Ritual Practice. New York: Oxford University Press.
  2. Breckenridge, Adam. 2015. A Path Less Traveled: Rethinking Spirituality in the Films of Alejandro Jodorowsky. Journal of Religion & Film 19 (2): Article 2. [CrossRef]
  3. Bynum, Caroline Walker. 2007. Wonderful Blood: Theology and Practice in Late Medieval Northern Germany and Beyond. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
  4. Church, David. 2007. Jodorowsky, Alejandro. Senses of Cinema 42. Available online: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2007/great-directors/jodorowsky/ (accessed on 21 September 2026).
  5. Coates, Paul. 2010. Cinema and Colour: The Saturated Image. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
  6. Jodorowsky, Alejandro, director. 1989. Santa Sangre. Mexico and Italy. Feature film.
  7. Kelleci, Zelfi, and Muhsine Sekmen. 2026. Jungian Archetypes in the Cinema of Alejandro Jodorowsky. Ordu Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Sosyal Bilimler Araştırmaları Dergisi 16 (1). [CrossRef]
  8. Meyer, Birgit. 2009. Introduction: From Imagined Communities to Aesthetic Formations: Religious Mediations, Sensational Forms, and Styles of Binding. In Aesthetic Formations: Media, Religion, and the Senses. Edited by Birgit Meyer. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 1–28. [CrossRef]
  9. Misek, Richard. 2010. Chromatic Cinema: A History of Screen Color. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell. [CrossRef]
  10. Mitchell, David T., and Sharon L. Snyder. 2001. Narrative Prosthesis: Disability and the Dependencies of Discourse. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. [CrossRef]
  11. Morgan, David. 2012. The Embodied Eye: Religious Visual Culture and the Social Life of Feeling. Berkeley: University of California Press.
  12. Plate, S. Brent. 2017. Religion and Film: Cinema and the Re-Creation of the World, 2nd ed. New York: Columbia University Press.
  13. Sobchack, Vivian. 2004. Carnal Thoughts: Embodiment and Moving Image Culture. Berkeley: University of California Press.
  14. Turner, Victor. 1969. The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. Chicago: Aldine.
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.