Preprint
Article

This version is not peer-reviewed.

Testing Orch OR and Waveguide Models of Consciousness: Anaesthesia, Coherence and the Microtubule

Submitted:

11 November 2026

Posted:

12 November 2026

You are already at the latest version

Abstract
Orchestrated Objective Reduction (Orch OR) identifies consciousness with the collapse of superpositions in microtubules after \(\tau \approx \frac{\hbar}{E_g}\), where \(E_g\) is the self-energy of mass distributions. We argue this fails under anaesthesia. Anaesthetics bind hydrophobic pockets in tubulin, abolish consciousness, and leave microtubule mass and mass distribution intact. Thus \(E_g\) and \(\tau\) remain unchanged while consciousness disappears. We propose microtubules act as bio-photon waveguides sustaining coherent exciton-photon transport and coupling neurons to \(\mathcal{C}^n\) consciousness field. Consciousness depends on optical coherence, phase preservation, and waveguide mode integrity, not collapse time. Anaesthetic binding alters polarizability, dielectric constant, and refractive index, detunes the waveguide, damps dipole oscillations, and destroys coherence. Washout restores parameters and consciousness. Orch OR fails because it ties consciousness to \(E_g\), which anaesthesia leaves unchanged; the bio-photon waveguide model succeeds because it ties consciousness to optical coherence, which anaesthesia destroys.
Keywords: 
;  ;  ;  
Subject: 
Physical Sciences  -   Biophysics

1. Introduction

Planck time tP, Planck mass mp, and Planck length lP are the fundamental units for expressing time as the duration of motion in space and mass as a structure composed of the energy that constitutes space itself. We will develop a mathematical formalism for the famous Max Planck quote: “As a man who has devoted his whole life to the most clear headed science, to the study of matter, I can tell you as a result of my research about atoms this much: There is no matter as such. All matter originates and exists only by virtue of a force which brings the particle of an atom to vibration and holds this most minute solar system of the atom together. We must assume behind this force the existence of a conscious and intelligent mind. This mind is the matrix of all matter”, and for the Ervin Schrödinger famous quote: “What we observe as material bodies and forces are nothing but shapes and variations in the structure of space”.
We propose to replace the spacetime model—in which time is treated as the fourth dimension of space and gravity is mediated by its curvature—with a model of time-invariant space endowed with physical properties, in which gravity originates from variations in its energy density. While spacetime is mathematically well-defined, the conception of time as the fourth dimension of space lacks experimental evidence. We therefore return to the Newtonian notion of time as a purely mathematical entity describing motion—that is, material change in R 3 Euclidean space composed of Planck quanta. A single Planck quantum QP is endowed with its Planck volume and Planck energy. We refer to this space as dynamic quantum vacuum, which exists in a dynamic relationship with physical objects; namely, its energy density diminishes in the presence of physical objects. We extend the mass-energy equivalence principle to space endowed with physical properties.
Mathematical description of DQV model is 4-dimensional Euclidean space with 4 spatial coordinates: x, y, z, iμ: E DQV 4 =   { ( x , y , z , i μ ) } , iμ imaginary 4th coordinate ( i = − 1 ) that is orthogonal to x, y, and z. ds2 = dx2 + dy2 + dz2 + d(iμ)2. In this model time t is an emergent physical quantity that enters existence in the process of measurement. From the micro to the macrocosms motion occur in this time-invariant E DQV 4 space. Light propagates in E DQV 4   space. When a photon moves through space from point A to point B, advancing from one Planck length to the next, its motion generates a numerical order in which Planck time constitutes the fundamental unit of motion, corresponding to the transition from one Planck distance to the next. The sum of these Planck times yields duration, as shown in the equation below:
t =   t P 1 + t P 2 + … + t PN =   ∑ i = 1 N t Pi (1) [1].
Duration is a man-made physical quantity. E DQV 4 itself is time-invariant. There is neither a physical past nor a physical future [2].
The velocity of light c is expressed by Planck units:
c = l P t P  (2).
The velocity of a given physical object can also be expressed in terms of Planck units. Any distance s between points, A and B, in space can be discretized on Planck distances:
s = NslP, N s ∈   N * ,   N * =   { 1 , 2 , 3 … }  (3)
The duration of motion is the sum of Planck times, cf. Eq. (1), and the velocity is thus given by:
v =   N s l P N t t P =   N s N t c ,   [4]
thus v ≤ c ⇒ Ns ≤ Nt—velocity is quantized,
where Ns is the number of Planck lengths comprising the distance s between A and B, and Nt is the number of Planck times comprising the duration of motion.
In one cubic meter of intergalactic E DQV 4 there are approximately 2,37 · 10104 of Planck quanta. A physical object with a mass of 1 kg corresponds to approximately 4,59 · 107Planck quanta. Consider a 1 kg object placed in intergalactic space. This object diminishes the number of Planck quanta by approximately, 4,59 · 107 predominantly in its central region. The density of Planck quanta increases with distance from the object. Every stellar object diminishes the density of Planck quanta in proportion to its mass. Gravity is a vector force of E DQV 4 directed from regions of higher density to regions of lower density of Planck quanta. In this manner, every stellar object in the universe is gravitationally related to every other stellar object.
The Planck energy density ρPE is obtained by dividing the product of the Planck mass and the square of the speed of light by the Planck volume:
m P l P 2 t P 2 l P 3 = m P l P t P 2 =   ρ PE =   4 , 641266 · 10 113 J m − 3
Planck energy density ρPE is the energy density of intergalactic space. In a region of space occupied by an object of mass m, the energy density of E DQV 4 diminishes at its center in exact accordance with its mass and volume V [2]:
ρ PE − ρ cE =   m c 2 V =   m l P 2 t P 2 V =   m l P 2 V t P 2
In the presence of a physical object, the density of Planck quanta decreases in proportion to the mass of the object. We express mass m of the physical object by rearranging Eq. (6), and we get:
m =   ( ρ PE − ρ cE ) V c 2 = ( ρ PE − ρ cE ) V t P 2 l P 2 (7) [2].
Eq. (7) is the mathematical formulation of Max Planck and Erwin Schrödinger’s vision: every physical object from the photon to the black hole is the structured energy of space.
Every massive object diminishes the energy density of E DQV 4 , and this generates gravitational force. Gravity force between two massive objects is as follows:
m 1 =   ( ρ PE − ρ cE 1 ) V 1 t P 2 l P 2 , m 2 =   ( ρ PE − ρ cE 2 ) V 2 t P 2 l P 2
F g = ( ρ PE − ρ cE 1 ) V 1 ( ρ PE − ρ cE 2 ) V 2 G t P 4 r 2 l P 4  
Gravity is a pushing force of R SQS 3 , directed from regions of higher energy density toward regions of lower energy density, see Figure 2:
We can express gravitational constant G as follows:
G =   c 2 ρ PE t P 2 (9) [3].
Eq. (9) we develop:
G =   l P 2 ρ PE t P 4
We combine Eq. (8) and (10) and we get:
F g =   ( ρ PE − ρ cE 1 ) V 1 ( ρ PE − ρ cE 2 ) V 2 ρ PE r 2 l P 2
The distance r between the centers of two massive objects can be expressed as an integer multiple of the Planck length N ( N ∈   N * ) , (r = NlP), yielding:
F g =   ( ρ PE − ρ cE 1 ) V 1 ( ρ PE − ρ cE 2 ) V 2 ρ PE N 2 l P 4  
where ρcE1 is the energy density of space in the centre of the first object and the ρcE2 is the energy density of space in the center of the second object. V1 is the volume of the first object, V2 is the volume of the second object, and N is the number of Planck distances between the centres of the objects. Taking in account Eqs. (7) and (10), Eq. (12) yields:
F g =   ( ρ PE − ρ cE 1 ) V 1 ( ρ PE − ρ cE 2 ) V 2 G N 2 l P 2 · t P 4 l P 4 = ( ρ PE − ρ cE 1 ) V 1 ( ρ PE − ρ cE 2 ) V 2 G r 2 c 2 c 2 = ( ρ PE − ρ cE 1 ) V 1 c 2   ·   ( ρ PE − ρ cE 2 ) V 2 c 2   · G r 2 =   m 1 m 2 G r 2 . Thus, Newton’s law of gravitation is recovered.
Using Planck units, we have developed a detailed mathematical formulation in which fundamental time is defined as the numerical order of physical events and emergent time as the duration of physical events, mass as a structure of the energy of time-invariant space, and gravity as a force generated by the variable energy density of time-invariant E DQV 4 . The space-time model is thereby replaced by a model of time-invariant space, in which time exists solely as a mathematical quantity. The paradigm shift is as follows: there is no physical past and no physical future. Nothing ever occurred in a remote physical past, because no physical past exists. Universal change unfolds exclusively within time-invariant E DQV 4 The Wheeler-DeWitt equation is timeless because time has no physical existence. The universe does not exist in time; it exists in time-invariant E DQV 4 . The common misinterpretation of the Wheeler-DeWitt equation is that the universe is frozen in time: “Assuming that everything, including the Universe, is ‘quantum’, led to promoting the dynamics of the classical Universe to a quantum mechanical problem. The gold standard of Quantum Cosmology is the timeless Wheeler-DeWitt (WDW) equation. The evolution in cosmic time has disappeared in the underlying mathematical framework. The solutions of the WDW equation, the wave equations of the Universe, describe a Universe frozen in time” [4]. The universe is not frozen in time because there is no physical time. Experimental evidence confirms that irreversible universal changes occur in time-invariant E DQV 4 . The existence of a physical past lies beyond experimental evidence and should therefore be abandoned. Once this empirically irrefutable fact is accepted, the notion that the universe began in a distant physical past ceases to be scientific [2].
Rovelli presented different notions of time: “For a particle physicist or a black-hole researcher, for instance, it is obvious that the time elapsed between two events depends on the path taken, while for the train-station master this is inconceivable and for the biologist it may be conceivable, but it remains totally irrelevant. The time in Newton equations does not distinguish past from future, the time of biology needs to. And so on. None of these “times” is false. None of them is “illusory” or “not real”. They are all, each of them, appropriate concepts for organizing phenomena at some scale, in some domain. But they are only valid on some scales, for different regimes, and in different contexts. Some connections between these times are obvious. For instance, the subtleties of relativistic time become negligible, irrelevant, when relative velocities are small. Other connections are more complicated, they have required centuries of scientific investigations to be sorted out. Some nodes of the overall story are not fully clear yet” [5].
Figure 2. Different notions of time presented by Rovelli [5].
Figure 2. Different notions of time presented by Rovelli [5].
Preprints 243780 g002
- Experiential time has its origin in the neuronal activity of the brain [6].
- Irreversible time exists only as the irreversible numerical order of events.
- In the Newtonian framework, true time exists solely as a mathematical construct: “Absolute, true and mathematical time, of itself, and from its own nature flows equably without regard to anything external, and by another name is called duration: relative, apparent and common time, is some sensible and external (whether accurate or unequable) measure of duration by the means of motion, which is commonly used instead of true time ...” [7]. Mathematical time is the numerical order of events, whereas emergent time, as duration, comes into existence in the act of measurement [1].
- There is no relativistic time; there is only a relativistic velocity of clocks and relativistic velocity of events [8]
- Cosmological time is a persistent scientific illusion [2].
- We can only talk about proper velocity in general relativity. The rate of clocks on the Moon is faster than on the Earth and is valid for all observers [8].
- Independent evolution variable in quantum gravity: as time does not exist, gravity is immediate, generated by the variable energy density of E DQV 4 . Gravity is time-invariant [2].
- Relational time is a philosophical term and has no application in physics: “Motion is the measure of time rather than time being the measure of motion: we truly came to know duration through motion rather than conversely. Although they both measure each other, no time is the measure of motion unless previously some motion was the measure of time” [9]. We show in this article that motion does not occur in time; it occurs only in time-invariant space. Motion has no duration per se. Duration is the result of measurement. Schuster introduced internal and external relational time: “There are two possible forms of the relational theory of time, both of which has been recognized but neither of which has received a special name. They will be referred to below as internal and external relational time. The purpose of this paper is to analyse critically the latter form, through our first consideration will be to set forth the general features of the relational theory itself by comparing it with the absolute theory of time” [10]. There is no experimental evidence that relational time has physical existence or that time in the absolute theory of time has physical existence. Clocks are mechanisms tuned to the rotation of the Earth around its axis. In one rotation, a clock ticks 86,400 seconds. One second is approximately 1,855 · 1043 Planck times. Fundamentally, when we measure the velocity of a physical object in space, i.e., the velocity of material changes, we compare its velocity to the rate of the clock. The idea of the absolute theory of time, which assumes that time flows by itself, has no scientific evidence and should be replaced by the fact that clocks tick in time-invariant space. Velocity of motion in space is defined by the duration (v = s/t), where time t is the duration and s the distance.
Loop quantum gravity (LQG) [11] has a highly developed mathematical formalism; its weak point is that it cannot be used to calculate the gravitational force between two stellar objects. The same is valid for General Relativity (GR); it describes gravity mathematically but lacks predictive power for calculation. This is a serious problem in contemporary physics, where mathematics has become merely a descriptive tool; the aim of mathematics should be calculation.
The geometrization of gravity was an attempt that has not yielded satisfactory results. Experimental data confirm that space has a Euclidean shape, while geometrization employs curved space. We replace curvature with variable energy density. Gravity is a pushing force from higher energy density toward lower energy density. This model works well inside black holes; it replaces gravitational collapse with electromagnetic collapse. In the center of a black hole, the density of Planck quanta decreases drastically, which reduces the energy density of R SQS 3 . Consequently, the reduced Planck constant diminishes, altering electromagnetic properties and rendering atoms unstable [12].
In 1964, Shapiro measured that the velocity of light diminishes in a strong gravitational field. His experiment is known as the fourth test of General Relativity and is referred to as gravitational time dilation [13]. It is not the case that time, as the fourth dimension of space, dilates and that light requires more time to propagate from point A to point B. What occurred in the Shapiro experiment is that light undergoes a minimal reduction in velocity due to the decreased energy density of space. Light does not propagate in space-time; it propagates in time-invariant E DQV 4 The E DQV 4   model is also applicable in the relativistic regime. A physical object in motion interacts with the energy of E DQV 4   and integrates it, thereby acquiring relativistic mass. Within the framework, relativistic mass arises as a result of the motion of elementary particles and holds for all observers. In addition, stellar objects rotate the local E DQV 4 , which corresponds to what is termed the frame-dragging effect in general relativity [8].
The era of “space-time” is coming to its end. There is no experimental evidence that motion occurs in time or that the universe exists in some physical time, so it is time to abandon this model and replace it with a model of “time-invariant dynamic quantum vacuum” that is evidence-based and states that nothing could have happened in a remote physical past because it is non-existent. In Erwin Schrödinger’s view, the only real physical reality is Now: “For eternally and always there is only now, one and the same now; the present is the only thing that has no end” [14].
In mainstream physics, we imagine the present moment (Now) as a point on an infinite timeline, which is a fundamental misunderstanding. Now exists in the entire Euclidean space. Time symmetry is a persistent scientific illusion, see Figure 3.
In this model, the entire universe is entangled via time-invariant space. This view aligns with the idea that time emerges from entanglement, as proposed by Page and Wootters [15]. EPR-type experiments occur in time-invariant space, which serves as the medium of entanglement [16].
In Einsteinian physics, space has been stripped of its physical attributes and rendered empty, possessing only geometric properties, with time as its fourth dimension. With the introduction of a time-invariant space endowed with physical attributes in the form of variable energy density, the time-reversal symmetry—T-symmetry—of Einsteinian physics has no physical correspondence in the physical world. The equation of time symmetry thus has no physical meaning [17]:
T:t → −t (13).
There is no negative Planck time tP, Planck time has only absolute value:
tP = |tP| (14).
The duration of every motion and every material change can be dissected into Planck times. When tN comes into existence, tN−1 no longer exist. When tN+1 comes into existence, tN no longer exists. Motion and maternal change occur in time-invariant E DQV 4 . The physical past and physical future constitute stubbornly persistent illusions within scientific thought. By conceptualizing time as the numerical ordering of events occurring in a time-invariant space, we have incorporated the present—the Now—into the formal framework of physics. This would have been a source of delight for Einstein, who considered the Now to reside beyond the domain of scientific inquiry. As Rudolf Carnap wrote in his autobiography: “Once Einstein said that the problem of the Now worried him seriously. He explained that the experience of the Now means something special for man, something essentially different from the past and the future, but that this important difference does not and cannot occur within physics. That this experience cannot be grasped by science seemed to him a matter of painful but inevitable resignation” [18].
Albert Einstein, Erwin Schrödinger, and Ernst Mach were deeply aware that linear physical time is a persistent scientific illusion. Their well-known quotations attest to this view.
People like us, who believe in physics, know that the distinction between past, present and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion. Albert Einstein
For eternally and always there is only now, one and the same now; the present is the only thing that has no end. Ervin Schördinger
It is utterly beyond our power to measure the changes of things by time. Quite the contrary, time is an abstraction at which we arrive by means of the changes of things; made because we are not restricted to any one definite measure, all being interconnected. Ernst Mach
Today, the leading physicists advocating this view, albeit with sometimes slightly different emphases, are Carlo Rovelli, Julian Barbour, and Davide Fiscaletti.
The evolution of life on planet Earth is reconsidered from a new perspective in which life develops in time-invariant space, and not in physical time. In the conventional view, the entropy of the universe increases, while the evolution of life represents a negentropic process in which the entropy of living systems is lower than that of the physical environment.
Here we propose an alternative view in which the evolution of life unfolds in time-invariant space, and the notion that evolution is an accidental process driven by random mutations over a long period of time is no longer tenable. The origin of life is dated to 3,800 million years ago. From the perspective of time-invariant space, this datum possesses only a mathematical meaning, denoting the numerical order of the evolution of life that occurs in time-invariant space [19].
In this framework, the driving force of the evolution of life is constituted by hidden variables as proposed by David Bohm. Hidden variables are the organizing structures that maintain the negative entropy (negentropy) of living organisms and render quantum coherence in living systems possible. In this perspective, DNA constitutes the hardware that is guided by the software represented by hidden variables [20,21].
This view is consistent with the position of Erwin Schrödinger, Herbert Fröhlich, Fritz-Albert Popp and Kenneth Denbigh, who argued that the scientific description of life extends beyond determinism. As geneticist Mae-Wan Ho notes: “The Rainbow and the Worm set out to answer the question, what is life?, that Schrödinger asked. Most people thought he provided the answer by postulating DNA as the genetic material. That was only part of the answer. The other part he suggested was quantum coherence, a state of being whole that involves molecules acting in perfectly correlated ways, and a special thermodynamics of life, which he referred to a `negentropy’, or ‘negative entropy’. Following these leads, I extended conventional quantum physics and non-equilibrium thermodynamics to provide the tentative answer, drawing on the work especially of Herbert Froehlich, Fritz Albert Popp and Kenneth Denbigh, and empirical evidence from the scientific literature and my own research” [22].
The introduction of the Now into physics and biology necessitates the introduction of hidden variables. Consciousness is posited as such a hidden variable. It cannot be observed as an object, yet its existence is affirmed through the conscious experience of mental activity. Consciousness pertains to a higher ontological order than the mind. The functioning of the mind can be observed, whereas the mind cannot experience consciousness; it can only conceptualize it [23].

2. The Waveguide Model of Consciousness C n E DQV 4   Versus Orchestrated Objective Reduction (Orch OR) Model of Consciousness

In the framework proposed by Hameroff and Penrose, consciousness is regarded as a temporal phenomenon: “Consciousness has often been argued to be a sequence of discrete moments. William James described the “specious present, the short duration of which we are immediately and incessantly sensible” (though James was vague about duration, and also described a continual ‘stream of consciousness’). The “perceptual moment” theory of Stroud described consciousness as a series of discrete events, like sequential frames of a movie (modern film and video present 24 to 72 frames per second, 24 to 72 Hertz, ‘Hz’). Consciousness is also seen as sequences of discrete events in Buddhism, trained meditators describing distinct “flickerings” in their experience of pure undifferentiated awareness [24].
Furthermore, within their framework, quantum superposition is regarded as a phenomenon occurring in space-time: “In the DP scheme for OR, the superposition reduces to one of the alternatives in a timescale τ that can be estimated (for a superposition of two states each of which is assumed to be taken to be stationary on its own) according to the formula τ ≈ ℏ/Eg. An important point to make about τ, however, is that it represents merely a kind of average time for the state reduction to take place. It is very much like a half-life in a radioactive decay. The actual time of decay in each individual state-reduction event, according to DP (in its current form), is taken to be a random process. Such an event would involve the entire (normally entangled) state, and would stretch across all the superposed material that is involved in the calculation of EG. According to DP (in its current form), the actual time of decay in a particular state-reduction event occurs simultaneously (in effect) over the entire state involved in the superposition, and it is taken to follow the τ ≈ ℏ/Eg formula on the average (in a way similar to radioactive decay). Here ℏ  ( = h / 2 π ) is Dirac’s form of Planck’s constant h and EG is the gravitational self-energy of the difference between the two (stationary) mass distributions of the superposition. (For a superposition for which each mass distribution is a rigid translation of the other, EG is the energy it would cost to displace one component of the superposition in the gravitational field of the other, in moving it from coincidence to the quantum-displaced location” [24]. Considering that time is not the fourth dimension of space and that the spacetime model has no counterpart in the existing universe, we propose a model of consciousness described as an n-dimensional complex space C n where ℂⁿ = {(z₁, z₂, ..., zₙ) | zᵢ ∈ ℂ}. This complex space represents a form of energy that lies outside the known electromagnetic spectrum. Is composed of complex Planck quanta Q P C . Consciousness is postulated as a vibration of this complex energy field, oscillating at the Planck frequency ( ν = 1 / t P C ). The time-invariant dynamic quantum vacuum E DQV 4   is embedded in C n . In a state of superposition, consciousness acts such that the observed superposition state is realized within the E DQV 4   domain, see Figure 4.
The debate as to whether real numbers are sufficient to describe quantum mechanics, remains unresolved [25,26]. Otte argues that complex numbers are a necessity if we are to advance the scientific description of consciousness: “According to the humanities, there is intentional and phenomenal consciousness. This paper deals with the physical aspects of phenomenal consciousness. It may sound unusual, but such consciousness must have a physical background if it exists objectively. This article therefore attempts to describe states of phenomenal consciousness mathematically as so-called hypercomplex system states in order to give them an objective scientific treatment” [27].
Since the phenomenon of quantum superposition is produced by the human being—a conscious living organism—it can be argued that a complete description of quantum mechanics, in which the human being is fully implicated, will require the use of complex numbers. Quantum mechanics of inanimate reality can be formulated using only real numbers, whereas when life is considered, complex numbers become a necessary descriptive tool.
In the ‘Orch OR’ model, quantum gravity acting on the microtubules of the brain is posited to generate consciousness [24]. The introduction of consciousness as the frequency of an n-dimensional complex space C n provides a clearer account of the ‘Orch OR’ framework. The vibration of C n , which constitutes consciousness, is entangled with the dynamic quantum vacuum R SQS 3 , whose variable energy density carries gravity. Consciousness thus acts on the microtubules via E DQV 4 . The presented model provides a mathematical framework for the further integration of consciousness into quantum mechanics. A key strength of the Orch-OR model of consciousness is that it anchors consciousness in gravity—the only field that is universally pervasive throughout the cosmos. All biological and physical systems, from macromolecular assemblies to galactic structures, are coupled through the gravitational field. In this sense, the Orch-OR model implicitly suggests a form of panpsychism in which the universe itself possesses the fundamental properties from which biological consciousness emerges.
A principal limitation of the Orch OR model is that it postulates that consciousness emerges when gravity acts upon neuronal microtubules, without providing an explanation for how a gravitational interaction could give rise to subjective experience. A second, independent limitation concerns coherence. The model does not demonstrate that microtubules can sustain the quantum coherence required for consciousness at physiological temperature.
From a biological perspective, microtubules are not merely structural scaffolds. They are dynamic cytoskeletal polymers that regulate intracellular transport, synaptic plasticity, and the organization of signalling cascades essential for neuronal function.
The Orch OR model does not clarify how a gravitational field couples to these biological processes to produce a conscious state. It postulates that consciousness emerges when gravity acts upon neuronal microtubules, without providing an explanation for how a gravitational interaction could give rise to subjective experience.
A second, independent limitation concerns coherence. The model does not demonstrate that microtubules can sustain the quantum coherence required for consciousness at physiological temperature. The aim of this article is therefore twofold. First, to evaluate the empirical basis of Orch OR with respect to gravitational collapse and microtubule coherence. Second, to reframe the Orch OR model within a broader theoretical architecture, in which the dynamic quantum vacuum field E DQV 4 , as the carrier of gravity, is proposed as a biophysical interface. In this proposed framework, E DQV 4 serves as the intermediary that transduces information from the consciousness field   C n to the microtubule network of the brain. The C n   model proposes that consciousness constitutes a complex energy field which interacts with microtubules via pilot photons. In this framework, consciousness is interpreted as an excitation of the C n   energy field, characterized by the Planck frequency ν = 1 / t P C . Conceptually, consciousness can be modelled as a photon existing in complex space.
The E DQV 4   space and field C n   space are interwoven such that the propagation of the consciousness photon induces a corresponding motion of the bio-photon within E DQV 4 , which serves as a reservoir of virtual photons [28]. Upon absorption of an energy impulse, the virtual photon transitions from a latent to a manifest state. Energized by the impulse originating from the consciousness photon, the resulting bio-photon propagates through the microtubule with either left-handed or right-handed spin. In the E DQV 4 model, photons are interpreted as excitations of and possess intrinsic spin [29,30]. As the photon traverses the microtubule, it assumes one of two distinct spin states, thereby transmitting information via a binary code. This is consistent with the widely accepted premise that biological systems operate on the basis of binary coding [31,32,33].
In the C n E DQV 4 model, the dynamic quantum vacuum is intrinsically non-entropic. The photon, as an excitation of R SQS 3 , possesses a theoretically infinite lifetime and carries no entropy. The field of consciousness C n   constitutes a syntropic type of energy. The syntropic properties of consciousness were first discussed by the Italian mathematician Luigi Fantappiè [34], and further developed by the Italian statistician Ulisse Di Corpo and the Italian cognitive psychologist Antonella Vannini: “Fantappiè noted that retarded waves are governed by the law of entropy whereas advanced waves are governed by a law opposite to entropy which leads to concentration of energy, differentiation, complexity, order and growth of structures. Fantappiè named this law syntropy and noted that its properties coincide with the qualities of living systems, arriving in this way at the conclusion that life and consciousness are a consequence of advanced waves [35].
In C n E DQV 4 model, the photon modes constituting the C n consciousness field undergo a transition to a synchronous, phase-locked waving regime. The establishment of this coherent collective oscillation leads to a constructive, syntropic concentration of energy. This coherent energy domain subsequently provides a resonant energy transfer to the vacuum fluctuations of the dynamic quantum vacuum E DQV 4 . As a result, a virtual photon, understood as an off-shell excitation of E DQV 4 where E2 − p2c2 ≠ 0 receives a coherent energy kick ΔEsynt from syntropic C n   field ΔEsynt, see Eg. (16).
  Δ E synt = h ν P C  
and promoted to an on-shell state (E2 = p2c2, thereby becoming a real, observable bio photon with a given spin.
ΔEsynt is not a random thermal kick. It is a coherent, syntropic energy injection from the C n   consciousness field. When the field C n enters synchronous waving where all its photon modes oscillate with identical phase. The energy density then scales. This is an energy concentration that acts on the E DQV 4 and makes virtual photon real, see Figure 5.
  C n n E DQV 4 model provides an explicit model of how consciousness act on microtubule that the original Orch-OR model does not contain. In Orch-OR, the conscious moment corresponds to objective reduction (OR). In the C n model, OR corresponds to the moment of phase transfer from C n to E DQV 4   carried by the biophoton spin acting on microtubule.
Hameroff proposed that loss of consciousness under general anaesthesia does not result primarily from synaptic suppression, but from the action of anaesthetics on quantum London dispersion forces within non-polar hydrophobic pockets of dendritic proteins—the same sites postulated to support consciousness [36]. In the C n   model, this mechanism is reframed. General anesthetics do not abolish consciousness by suppressing neuronal firing, but by decoupling the C n consciousness field from the E DQV 4   microtubule substrate via biochemical alteration of the quantum waveguide. At the biochemical level, anaesthetic molecules—in accordance with the Meyer-Overton correlation—bind to hydrophobic pockets in tubulin dimers formed by non-polar residues such as tryptophan and phenylalanine. This interaction is classical: London dispersion forces within the hydrophobic core. At the quantum biological level, binding increases the local relative permittivity E r , and the lattice polarizability α. The microtubule interior, which in the physiological state functions as a low-loss cavity for bio-photon propagation (Γ0 ≈ 0), is converted into a high-loss medium (Γanesthesia≫Γ0). Consequently, bio-photon transition is quenched, and coherent information transfer ceases. The C n field itself remains present—consciousness as such is not annihilated—but its functional connection to the biological substrate is severed. Subjective experience is thus decoupled from microtubule computation.
In conclusion, the Orch OR model establishes a direct link between gravity and consciousness, which represents an ad hoc assumption. In the Orch OR model, consciousness is posited to emerge from the coupling of the gravitational field with microtubule dynamics. The brain, however, remains immersed in the same gravitational field before and after the administration of anaesthesia, with the gravitational force acting on microtubules remaining effectively unchanged. The disappearance of consciousness under anaesthesia therefore cannot be attributed to a failure of Objective Reduction, as anaesthetic molecules do not alter the mass distribution and thus do not modify the gravitational self-energy Eg or the reduction timescale τ ≈ ℏ/Eg. Rather, in the model C n , consciousness vanishes because binary bio-photon transmission, within the microtubule waveguide is quenched. Consequently, gravitationally-induced OR is not plausible as the mechanism of anaesthetic loss of consciousness, see Figure 6.
On the International Space Station, orbiting at 400–408 km above the Earth’s surface, the gravitational acceleration is g = 8.66 ∙10−2 ms−2, compared to g = 9.81 ms−2. Gravity diminishes for 12% and astronauts remain fully conscious. The Moon has only 16.5% of Earth’s gravity and astronauts remain fully conscious. This is difficult to reconcile with a model in which consciousness is generated by a gravitational interaction with microtubules. If consciousness were a product of gravity acting in E DQV 4 , one would expect some dependence of conscious states on the magnitude of the external gravitational environment.
It is important to note that Orch OR refers to gravitational self-energy Eg of the tubulin superposition itself, not directly to Newtonian g. In E DQV 4 there is no “self-gravity” Eg vs “external gravity”. There is only one thing: diminished energy density of E DQV 4 :
-
External g from Earth: Earth diminishes dynamic quantum vacuum around it.
-
Internal Eg from tubulin superposition: tubulin in superposition diminishes dynamic quantum vacuum around it.
Both are the same physical process in E DQV 4 —a local lowering of ρPE (ρPE = Planck energy density of DQV). Therefore, in our model the distinction that Orch OR makes between Eg and g does not exist. If consciousness were generated by diminished ρPE (what Penrose calls gravity), then it should depend on both external and internal diminished ρPE. This observation raises a significant conceptual difficulty for the Orch OR model. In Orch OR, consciousness is postulated to arise from the interaction of gravity with microtubules via objective reduction. The model does not clarify how this proposed gravitational mechanism would remain stable and functionally identical under extreme variations in gravitational strength, or how the same discrete conscious moments could be produced when the gravitational interaction is considerably weaker. Furthermore, if consciousness were dependent on a specific threshold of gravitational self-energy as proposed, one would expect a measurable modulation of conscious states with altitude. No such modulation is observed.
Max Planck would not have endorsed the view that consciousness is a byproduct of gravity-microtubule interaction. He would appreciate C n model. His ontological position is unambiguous: “I regard consciousness as fundamental. I regard matter as derivative from consciousness. We cannot get behind consciousness. Everything that we talk about, everything that we regard as existing, postulates consciousness [37].
3. The Waveguide Model of Consciousness C n E DQV 4  

and Quantum Mechanics: An Ontological Reformulation

In the model   C n R SQS 3 , consciousness is assigned a foundational role in quantum mechanics. The C n model posits that consciousness is not an emergent epiphenomenon but a fundamental, time-invariant field denoted C n . This model provides an ontological basis for the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM). It replaces the conventional assumption of spacetime as a fundamental arena with two interwoven, time-invariant fields: the consciousness field C n and the three-dimensional super quantum space E DQV 4 .
-
The Planck Photon and the Mechanism of Superposition
Within this framework, the collapse or actualization of a superposition is mediated by an energy exchange with the C n field. The observed state receives an energy kick from a quantum of the C n field, defined by the frequency ν = 1 / t P C where t P C is the Planck time of consciousness. We designate this quantum as the “Planck photon.” The Planck photon does not propagate through the C n field; it is intrinsically non-local. This non-locality provides the mechanism for Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) type quantum entanglement, which is understood as an immediate correlation within the C n field rather than a superluminal signal through space.
In the C n E DQV 4 model, model, space is understood as a fundamental, time-invariant superfluid quantum structure E DQV 4 . Within this ontology, time is not a primary physical entity. It does not exist as a fourth dimension of space, nor does it exist as an independent duration in which material changes occur. Every material change, i.e., motion on both the macro and micro scales, is an immediate process occurring in E DQV 4 . Such a process can be formally dissected into a discrete numerical order whose elementary interval corresponds to the Planck time, tP. The sequence tP1 ,tP2 ,…,tPn, does not represent movement in time, but rather the numerical order of successive configurations of   R SQS 3 . Duration is therefore not fundamental; it is an emergent quantity resulting from the act of measurement, specifically from comparing the numerical order of a given change with the numerical order of a chosen clock-system.
This ontological position has direct consequences for dynamical collapse models that presuppose spacetime as a fundamental background. In particular, time-dependent collapse models are considered ontologically misplaced, as they attribute physical reality to a parameter that has no independent existence outside of measurement. A specific case is the Penrose Objective Reduction (OR) model, which postulates a collapse time of a quantum superposition given by relation τ ≈ ℏ E g , where EG is the gravitational self-energy of the difference between the two mass distributions in superposition, and ℏ is the reduced Planck constant. Within the C n E DQV 4 ontology, this relation is considered to have no physical meaning. Since there is no fundamental time in which a superposition could persist and then collapse after a duration τ, the concept of a gravitationally induced temporal threshold for collapse is incompatible with the C n E DQV 4 model. The superposition is a change of structure that occurs is an immediate reconfiguration of itself, not an event that occurs after a period of time. Consequently, EG cannot generate a physical collapse time, as time as duration does not exist in the C n E DQV 4 framework.
In the C n E DQV 4   model, the concept of a fundamental spacetime is abandoned and replaced by the time-invariant, interwoven dual-field structure of C n and E DQV 4 . Consequently, standard quantum phenomena are ontologically redefined. Quantum measurement, superposition, and entanglement are not processes evolving in spacetime, but are immediate processes occurring within this dual-field structure. Their actualization does not unfold in time, but corresponds to a discrete reconfiguration in the numerical order of E DQV 4 , defined by Planck times. In this framework, the non-local Planck photon is postulated as the mediator of actualization, facilitating the immediate transition from a superposed to a definite state within C n and E DQV 4 without recourse to a fundamental temporal parameter.
Einstein was correct in his assertion that “God does not play dice” and that quantum mechanics, in its standard formulation, does not constitute a complete theory. We demonstrate that quantum mechanics can be rendered as a complete model through the introduction of the complex space C n   as the fundamental ontological arena of the universe.
Following the line of argument first formalized in the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen [EPR] paper [38], we argue that the wave function in Hilbert space Ψ ∈ L 2 ( E DQV 4 ) does not provide a complete description of an individual system. Indeterminacy is not an intrinsic feature of nature, but an artifact of an insufficient mathematical structure. We propose that this incompleteness is resolved by constructing physical models that are bijective: every element of physical reality must have a counterpart in the physical theory, and conversely, every element of the theory must have a counterpart in physical reality. This satisfies the bijective methodology, which requires a bijective function between the elements of the model and the elements of physical reality [39].
Let X denote universe and the Y denotes the model of the universe, with:
f: X →Y.
We define:
Set X: {gravityx, microtubulex, consciousnessx}
Set Y: {gravityy, microtubuley, consciousnessy} (17).
In the C n E DQV 4 model, the element of consciousness exists in both set X (physical universe) and set Y (model of physical universe). In the Penrose-Hameroff model, no such element exists in set X; consciousness is modelled as an epiphenomenon of the interaction between gravity and microtubules.
Set X: {gravityx, microtubulex}
Set Y: {gravityy, microtubuley, consciousnessy?}
In the standard Copenhagen formalism, the superposition state is projected onto a real observable space, which necessarily discards phase-correlation information. By embedding quantum dynamics in   C n , the theory regains determinism. In this extended space determinism is restored; what appears as irreducible randomness in C n E DQV 4 corresponds to a deterministic trajectory in C n . The Born rule, P = |Ψ|2, is thus reinterpreted not as an axiom of intrinsic probability, but as a measure of the projection from C n onto the observable subspace E DQV 4 .
In the Copenhagen view—developed by Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg in 1927-1930—the wave function Ψ is not a physical wave in space. The wave function Ψ   is a mathematical object in Hilbert space Ψ ∈ L 2 ( E DQV 4 ) , that encodes the maximal knowledge we can have about an individual quantum system. The introduction of C n does not alter the formalism if quantum mechanics; it completes it. The wave function Ψ C n is not consciousness. Ψ C n is the mathematical formalism that describes the consciousness energy field Φ C n which IS consciousness. The C n R SQS 3 model resolves the measurement problem. In the Copenhagen interpretation, wave function Ψ collapses without a physical mechanism. In the   C n E DQV 4 model, Ψ E DQV 4 is the excitation of the field Φ E DQV 4 and collapses because it receives an energy kick ΔEsync from the consciousness energy field Φ C n . The cause of wave function collapse is energy kick from Φ C n not from orchestrated objective reduction OR as predicted by Penrose [40]. Gravity does not play any role in quantum superposition; the decisive role here is played by the consciousness field Φ C n and coherent bio-photon field [41] that mediates between field Φ E DQV 4 and field Φ C n .
The consciousness field Φ C n   plays an active role in the behavior of elementary particles. It induces order and symmetry. In the EPR experiment, both particles propagate in Φ C n   , which preserves the symmetry between them. Upon measurement of the spin of the first particle, the second particle assumes the opposite spin. In the double-slit experiment, electrons propagate through the upper slit, but they also propagate in the field Φ C n , which, in response to the motion of the electrons, generates waves in the field Φ E DQV 4 . These waves pass through the lower slit and give rise to the interference pattern.
Φ C n   is not a propagating excitation on a pre-existing background. It constitutes the ontologically fundamental arena,   C n , within which E DQV 4   is embedded as a subspace. Φ C n non-local correlations therefore do not require superluminal propagation. Φ C n is omnipresent throughout entire universe. The formulation of consciousness Φ C n   as a non-local complex field does not violate Bell’s theorem.
The C n E DQV 4 model provides a clear explanation of the DNA phantom effect. Poponin and Gariaev reported that a DNA sample in a quartz cuvette illuminated by a laser produces a characteristic dynamic pattern in the scattered light. When the DNA is removed, the pattern does not disappear immediately but persists for minutes to hours [42]. In standard quantum mechanics, there is nothing that can preserve the organization of the DNA pattern once the DNA is removed from the chamber. The source is gone, so the effect must also be gone. In the C n E DQV 4 model, the DNA information is imprinted in the Φ E DQV 4   field and remains there even after the DNA is removed.
The results of this research are consistent with the view of the physicist and mathematician Eugene Wigner on quantum mechanics: “It was not possible to formulate the laws of quantum mechanics in a fully consistent way without reference to the consciousness” [43].
Quantum biology also indicates that consciousness is an indispensable element for the description of life and is non-classical in the sense that it does not belong to the known types of energy: “Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical” [44]. C n E DQV 4 model is non-classical in the sense that it introduces consciousness a complex energy field Φ C n .
Keppler argues that conscious states are not produced by neurons alone, but by a resonant coupling of the brain to the zero-point field (ZPF)—the fluctuating vacuum field of quantum electrodynamics (QED) [45]. We encounter here the same problem as in the Penrose-Hameroff model of consciousness: neurons are not conscious, the ZPF is not conscious, and the gravitational field is not conscious. How the interaction between neurons and gravity, or between neurons and the ZPF, could produce consciousness as an epiphenomenon of that interaction cannot be explained.
It is a fundamental premise of the von Neumann-Wigner interpretation of quantum measurement theory that consciousness operates as the observer and causes the collapse of the wave function [46]. The capacity to observe one’s own mental activity is itself a direct manifestation of consciousness. The same consciousness field, Φ C n , functions as the observer in every scientist. The observation of mind activity constitutes an everyday, first-person experience common to all researchers. While our minds construct novel models of the world, it is the observer that witnesses this constructive process. Arievitch shows there is no one-to-one correspondence between mental states and neural processes [47]. The C n E DQV 4   model proposes that mental activity constitutes a manifestation of the Φ C n   field, wherein thoughts correspond to structural configurations of Φ C n   that are coupled to neuronal networks via a coherent biophotonic field. In this model, the consciousness that functions as the observer is of a higher ontological order than the mind, which constitutes its structural manifestation, see Figure 8.
To postulate that the consciousness emerges from the interaction between the gravitational field and microtubules, or from the interaction between the zero-point field (ZPF) and microtubules, lacks grounding in scientific empiricism, as no experimental evidence currently substantiates such models. Conversely, the direct experience of observing the functioning of the mind possesses an empirical validity that cannot be denied.
As argued by Penrose via Gödel’s incompleteness theorem, human mathematical understanding is non-algorithmic and consciousness cannot be modelled as computable, implying the need for a new physics [48]. Penrose is an explicit Platonist: “Every one of our conscious brains is woven from subtle physical ingredients that somehow enable us to take advantage of the profound organization of our mathematically underpinned universe-so that we, in turn, are capable of some kind of direct access, through that Platonic quality of ‘understanding’, to the very ways in which our universe behaves” [49]. The author of the present article likewise adopts a Platonist position and proposes that objective reduction (OR) is neither deterministic nor random. It is time-invariant. It manifests as a non-computable selection of an integrated whole, quantified as Φ C n .
It is essential to note that both determinism and randomness presuppose linear time. Determinism presupposes a temporal ordering in which a past state (t1) fixes a future state (t2) via invariant laws. Randomness likewise presupposes linear time, insofar as an outcome that was not fixed before time t becomes actual at time t with a given probability. Both categories are therefore intelligible only within a framework that posits time as a fundamental physical parameter. In a time-invariant space, where there is no physical past and no physical future and events occur exclusively in the Now, neither determinism nor randomness obtains. What appears as deterministic or random when projected onto linear time is, in the present model, guided by the implicate order manifesting as a non-computable selection of an integrated whole Φ C n . This view posits the Bohm’s implicate order as the central mechanism governing the universe and life.
The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) criterion for the completeness of a physical theory is here strengthened by the requirement of bijectivity criterion. It is argued that the space-time model fails to satisfy this completeness condition and is therefore replaced in this work by a time-invariant dynamic quantum vacuum. This framework opens a new perspective in quantum mechanics (QM), where the conventional dichotomy of determinism and randomness is superseded by the Bohm’s implicate order, and a new perspective in cosmology, where the Big Bang model is also shown to violate both completeness and bijectivity [2].
In C n R SQS 3 model, space-time is replaced by the time-invariant space, time t as duration is replaced by the numerical order of motion, i.e. material change, see Eq. (1). Wave function is not seen as propagating in time, it propagates only in time-invariant space, consequently Ψt is replaced by the Ψ t PN . Bohmian mechanics is a theory about point particles moving along trajectories [50]. We dissect these trajectories on Planck distances where point particles are moving from one to the next Planck distance in the time-invariant space. Time is only the numerical order of this motion.
In the C n E DQV 4 model, space-time is replaced by a time-invariant space, and time t understood as duration is replaced by the numerical order of motion, i.e., of material change, see Eq. (1). The wave function is not regarded as propagating in time; it propagates solely in the time-invariant space, and consequently Ψt is replaced by Ψ t PN , where tPN denotes the Planck numerical order.
This reinterpretation finds a natural grounding in Bohmian mechanics, which is a theory about point particles moving along definite trajectories. While standard Bohmian mechanics is still formulated within a space-time background with t as an external parameter, in the C n E DQV 4 model these trajectories are dissected at the Planck scale. A point particle moves from one Planck distance lP to the next in the time-invariant dynamic quantum vacuum ( E DQV 4 ). Each discrete displacement corresponds to an increment of the numerical order N, i.e., tPn = NtP. In this picture, Planck time tP is not a duration but the elementary unit of numerical order.
Thus, what Bohmian mechanics describes as Qt—the trajectory of the particle guided by the wavefunction—is in the present model reformulated as an ordered sequence QN, where N numerates the positions occupied in R SQS 3 . The guiding law itself remains intact: the wavefunction Ψ t PN defined on C n E DQV 4 determines the velocity field and the permissible next Planck cell, in the sense of Dürr, Goldstein and Zanghì. The evolution is therefore deterministic and non-local, yet without a fundamental time flow. The parameter t disappears as a physical entity; only the numerical succession of configurations remains.
This approach preserves the central achievement of Bohmian mechanics—the restoration of a clear ontology of particles with trajectories [51]—while resolving its residual dependence on classical time. Collapse, or more precisely the actualization of a specific configuration, is not a process in time requiring a duration Δt, but an immediate reordering within the implicate order of C n E DQV 4 . The consciousness field, as the fundamental field of the model, is the agency that selects the integrated whole from the set of Bohmian possibilities, in a way that is inherently non-computable. Time as duration emerges only on the side of the observer as a measure of the numerical order of these selections.
Figure 9. Comparison of Space-Time Bohmian dynamics vs. C n R SQS 3
Figure 9. Comparison of Space-Time Bohmian dynamics vs. C n R SQS 3
Preprints 243780 g008
Time-Invariant Model.
4. The Waveguide Model of Consciousness C n E DQV 4

Bridges Matter, Mind and Consciousness

Within the C n E DQV 4 model, C n denotes subjective reality, whereas E DQV 4 denotes objective reality, encompassing all of its constituents, from elementary particles to galaxies. Consciousness should therefore be investigated primarily through subjective introspection. This process brings awareness that the observer is not the mind and enables the scientist to construct the most appropriate models of consciousness, while being aware that the model of consciousness is not consciousness itself, but only points the way to discovering consciousness through individual introspective research. The assumption that consciousness could be the result of interactions between objective physical entities—for example, between the gravitational field and microtubules—constitutes an ontological reductionism that leads research in the wrong direction. The introduction of consciousness as a field Φ C n   with independent existence—in which thoughts constitute its structural forms and which interacts with neurons via biophotons—is crucial for advancing our understanding of human functioning and of life itself.
The C n E DQV 4 model challenges prevailing scientific thought by attributing a higher ontological status to consciousness than to mind. For this reason, the model is likely to encounter significant resistance within the scientific community. In contemporary science, mind is regarded as primary, while consciousness is treated as secondary. Consequently, much of the scientific establishment may oppose the C n E DQV 4 model without substantive justification. In this respect, C n E DQV 4 continues the intellectual legacy of Max Planck and Erwin Schrödinger, who posited consciousness as primary. As Schrödinger stated: “Consciousness cannot be accounted for in physical terms. For consciousness is absolutely fundamental. It cannot be accounted for in terms of anything else” [52].
The existence of consciousness as an independent, primordial reality is rendered experimentally verifiable through systematic introspective observation of one’s own mental activity. In the act of observing the mind, the subject directly experiences a fundamental dissociation: one is not identical with one’s thoughts, but rather constitutes the observer thereof: “Put your hand in front of your eyes and observe it for a few seconds. Then you close your eyes and imagine your hand in your inner vision. Your mind can imagine your hand, and consciousness can observe the image of the hand. This exercise is proof that consciousness can watch the mind. In this experiment, the human being is the apparatus, and the experience itself is the experimental proof [53]. This first-person experiential datum marks the foundational point of departure for an experiential science of consciousness. Such an approach is not in opposition to, but complementary with, the third-person construction of scientific models of consciousness. A central methodological principle emerges: the degree of metacognitive awareness of mental functioning is proportional to the capacity to construct models of consciousness and of the physical world that are uncontaminated by cognitive artifacts of the mind itself.
Space-time, for instance, can be interpreted in this framework not as an ontologically fundamental structure of physical reality, but as a cognitive construct generated by the mind, lacking a direct counterpart in the external world.
When consciousness itself assumes the regulative role in the formation of scientific models, the criterion of bijectivity becomes applicable: every element of the theoretical model must possess a precise and unique correspondent in objective reality, thus ensuring structural isomorphism between model and world. Existence of consciousness as an independent primordial reality is experimentally proved when you watch observer your mind activity. You experience, you are not thoughts, you are the observer. This is where experiential consciousness research starts. It is complementary with the building scientific models of the consciousness. The more you are aware of how mind function the more you are able to build a model of consciousness and physical world that are unaffected by your mind. Space-time for example is a mind creation; it has no counterpart in the physical world. When consciousness takes over in creating scientific models, the bijectivity criterion is applied, every element in the model has the exact correspondent model in the real world.
Bridging subjective and objective world requires modification of classical Schrödinger equation i ℏ ∂ Ψ ∂ t =   Ĥ Ψ , ℏ = h/2π, and E = ℏω, is development in the timer-invariant form:
ih ν P ∂ N Ψ C n = Ĥ Ψ C n
where h = 2πℏ, νP = 1/tP, E = hν, 2πν = ω, and ∂ N Ψ C n = Ψ C n ( N + 1 ) − Ψ C n ( N ) ,   N = 1 , 2 , 3 , … In the Copenhagen interpretation, the physical origin of wave function collapse remains unknown. In C n E DQV 4 the collapse is caused by the energy kick ΔEsynt which is described by the extended Schrödinger equation, see Eq. (19):
ih ν P ∂ N kick Ψ C n = Ĥ kick Ψ C n =   Δ E synt Ψ C n → ∣ γ R ⟩ on − shell
where Ĥ kick = h ν C P ^ ∣ γ v ⟩ → ∣ γ R ⟩ , Δ E synt = h ν C , νP = 1/tP, N = 1,2,3…, derivate ∂ ∂ t = ν P ∂ N .
∂ N kick is discrete kick derivate evaluated at collapse instant N = Ncollapse.
∂ N kick Ψ C n = Ψ C n ( N + 1 ) − Ψ C n ( N ) . Dimensionless forward difference, immediate reordering N → N + 1, not a process requiring duration τ ≈ ℏ/Eg as in Orch OR. N = 1,2,3….
Ψ C n is wave function in n-dimensional complex consciousness field C n = { ( z 1 , … z n ) ∣ z i ∈ C } .
QPquanta
QPquanta are quanta of consciousness field oscillating at ν ≈ νP, carrier of Ψ C
  • Ĥkick is kick Hamiltonian: Ĥ kick = H ^ C n − ih Γ ^ collapse = h ν C P ^ ∣ γ v ⟩ → ∣ γ R ⟩
where H ^ C n h ν C P ^ γ v is Hamiltonian of consciousness field Φ C n . ν C ≈ ν P .
P ^ γ v projector on virtual photon state.
  • ΔEsynt coherent syntropic energy kick:   Δ E synt = h ν C = ℏ ω C ,   2 π ν C = ω C
  • ΔEsynt is energy packet injected from C n
into E DQV 4 . In Copenhagen interpretation wave function collapses and reason is unknown, in C n E DQV 4 collapse caused by ΔEsynt, reason is known.
Total Hamiltonian constraint is the key idea of Wheeler-DeWitt. It says total energy of Universe is exactly zero, see Eq. (20).
H ^ total   = H ^ gravity   + H ^ matter = 0
Total Hamiltonian constraint is wrong idea, borrowed from Hawking who denoted energy of gravity as negative ad energy of the matter as positive. Their sum is always zero (Em + Eg = 0). In C n R SQS 3 model, the sum of the energy of R SQS 3 which carries gravity and energy of matter is constant and expressed with the Planck energy density. In a given volume of space in which is a given stellar object with mass m is always valid:
ρ PE =   m c 2 V + ρ cE
where ρPE is the Planck energy density of intergalactic space, m is the mass of the object, V is the volume of the object, and ρcE is diminished energy density of space in the center of the physical object. With Eq. (21) we can express mass and develop classical Newton equation for gravity, see Eq. (8).
All objects in a chosen volume V are gravitationally interacting between themselves. Gravitational interaction is immediate, and so do not require numerical order. We propose a new version of the Wheeler-DeWitt model in which the total Hamiltonian H ^ total     i s not zero, but constant and positive-definite. In the standard formulation, the Hamiltonian constraint is postulated as:
H ^ total   Ψ = ( H ^ gravity   + H ^ matter ) Ψ = 0
This constraint is obtained by assigning a negative value to gravitational energy, H ^ gravity   =   − | H ^ gravity   | , so that it cancels matter energy. In the SQS model such negative energy has no physical counterpart. In C n E DQV 4 model, both the energy density of the dynamic quantum vacuum that carries gravity and the energy density of matter possess strictly absolute, positive-definite values. The sum of the energy of matter and the energy of gravity—the E DQV 4 energy—within a given volume of space is constant and positive-definite: | E E DQV 4 | + | E m | = K . Consequently, the Wheeler-DeWitt equation is reformulated as:
| H | ^ total = | H | ^ gravity + | H | ^ matter = K
Promoting the energies to Hamiltonian operators acting on the wave function of the universe Ψ, we obtain the dynamic quantum vacuum Wheeler-DeWitt equation:
( | H | ^ SQS + | H | ^ matter ) Ψ = K Ψ
or equivalently, in constraint form:
( | H | ^ SQS + | H | ^ matter − K ) Ψ = 0
where K = ρPEV, and volume V is the volume of the observable universe.
Mathematically, material world E DQV 4 and subjective world of consciousness C n are bridged by iμ of E DQV 4 , see Figure 10:
The imaginary coordinate iμ represents a common element of both the material world and the subjective domain of consciousness. In the E DQV 4 model, time is not regarded as a fundamental physical quantity. Rather, it emerges as an emergent measure resulting from the process by which consciousness quantifies motion within the time-invariant E DQV 4 substratum. Experimental support for the iμ bridge is virtuoso piano performance. Performing virtuoso musical pieces involves motor action that exceeds the temporal limits of sequential conscious planning. Globerson and Nelken [54] note that in piano playing a pianist may reach a speed of 30 notes per second (Rumelhart and Norman (1982), [55]), thereby surpassing visual reaction times (Lashley, 1951 [56]). As Lashley observed in 1951, the temporal intervals between components of fast sequential action do not permit separate conscious planning of each component, leading to the conclusion that such performance can be explained only by a single motor plan encompassing the whole sequence.
From the perspective of conventional neurophysiology, nerve conduction velocity (50–120 ms−1 and synaptic delays (0.5–1 milliseconds) impose a lower limit on note-by-note planning in x, y, z space. The existence of error-free execution at 30 notes per second therefore suggests a non-local organization of the motor sequence.
Within the C n E DQV 4 model, this organization is attributed to the consciousness field C n . The complete musical phrase exists as a coherent configuration in C n , orthogonal to physical space. The imaginary coordinate iμ, common to E DQV 4 =   { ( x , y , z , i μ ) } and ℂⁿ = {(z₁, z₂, ..., zₙ) | zᵢ ∈ ℂ} provides the mathematical bridge through which the single plan in C n is projected as a whole into time-invariant E DQV 4 . Fingers do not execute notes sequentially in fundamental time; rather, time t emerges as the measured duration of motion of an already unified plan. This mechanism is illustrated in Figure 11.
We use Euler formula to express the bridge between matter, mind and consciousness:
eiμ = cosμ + isin μ (25),
where μ imaginary angle—not in 3D space, but in consciousness space C n . eiμ is the couple between material world in E DQV 4 and consciousness C n
Reality =   E DQV 4 ×   e i μ ×   C n  (26).
C n ( μ = π 2 , e i μ = i ) is pure consciousness, lossless, non-physical
E DQV 4 (μ = 0,eiμ = 1) is pure physical reality
  • Mind ( 0 < μ < π 2 )
is where consciousness and material world interfere
Mind as interface 0 < μ < π 2 has physical origin in coherent electromagnetic field. When eiμ = cosμ + isinμ the cosμ part projects into E DQV 4 as Frolich/Popp coherent EM field in microtubules (THz, biophotons) [57,58], the isin μ part remains in C n . Thus mind is measurable as coherent EM field, while consciousness itself |eiμ| = 1 remains lossless and non-measurable, see Figure 12.

5. Experimental Status of Orch OR Model and Waveguide C n E DQV 4

Model

The concept of gravitational self-energy Eg, as formulated by Penrose to define the collapse time τ ≈ ℏ E g does not by itself constitute a dynamical theory. It provides a lifetime criterion, but it does not predict a specific dynamical process by which that criterion could be tested independently. In a microtubule, this limitation is decisive. There is no independent experimental procedure to measure the gravitational self-energy of a tubulin superposition at the scale of conformational displacement, and to isolate that contribution from environmental decoherence. The quantity Eg therefore cannot be extracted from a biological measurement.
The situation is different for the Diósi-Penrose model, which does provide a concrete dynamic. The simplest, parameter-free version of Diósi-Penrose dynamics, which would render Eg testable via spontaneous radiation, has been strongly constrained by experiment. As noted by Derakhshani et al. [59], this version predicts spontaneous radiation that should have been observed. The Gran Sasso underground experiment [60] did not observe it. That result excludes, at 95% confidence level, the natural combination of Diósi’s white-noise dynamics with Penrose’s mass-density resolution.
Penrose’s original lifetime criterion, τ ≈ ℏ E g , which does not by itself predict spontaneous radiation or a concrete dynamic, remains without an independent experimental test in a biological context. It therefore cannot serve as an empirical foundation for a model of consciousness in microtubules.
The Orchestrated Objective Reduction (Orch OR) model rests on a specific proposal by Penrose: that quantum superposition cannot be maintained indefinitely when the superposed states correspond to significantly different distributions of mass in spacetime. At a critical threshold, the superposition is resolved by an objective, gravitationally induced reduction.
Penrose expressed this idea as a lifetime criterion. A superposition with gravitational self-energy Eg is expected to persist for a time on the order of τ ≈ ℏ E g before it reduces. The larger the mass displacement, the larger Eg, and the shorter the lifetime.
In Orch OR, this criterion is applied to microtubules. The superposition is assumed to be between different conformations of tubulin proteins. When a sufficient number of tubulins are in superposition, Eg reaches the threshold for objective reduction, and a conscious moment is said to occur.
It is essential to distinguish this criterion from a dynamical collapse model. Penrose’s proposal, in its original form, does not specify the dynamical process by which reduction occurs. It does not provide an equation of motion for the wavefunction, nor does it predict a secondary observable, such as radiation, that could be measured independently of the collapse itself.
Diósi proposed such a dynamic. In the Diósi-Penrose model, the gravitational field is treated as a source of stochastic noise that continuously drives the wavefunction toward localization. In this formulation, the collapse process is not silent: it predicts spontaneous radiation emitted as charged particles are stochastically accelerated by the gravitational noise.
This difference is decisive for empirical evaluation. The Diósi-Penrose model can be tested because it predicts radiation. Penrose’s original criterion, taken alone, cannot be tested in the same way, because it predicts only a lifetime, not an independent signal.
Fröhlich (1968) showed that biological systems under metabolic pumping can form long-range coherent vibrations, a Bose-like condensation of coherent modes in the 10−11 − 10−12 Hz range [57]. Such coherent longitudinal electric vibrations have been proposed to be sustained in microtubules. Since the 1970s, Popp and collaborators have demonstrated that living cells emit ultra-weak coherent biophotons originating from DNA, with characteristic photon statistics [41,59]. The experimental findings of Fröhlich (1868) on long-range coherent electric vibrations and Popp et al. (1992, 2003) on coherent biophoton emission confirm that in awakened states consciousness acts actively on microtubules via coherent electromagnetic fields, whereas under anaesthesia this bridge is disrupted. Living on orbital stations and travelling on the Moon in the Apollo missions also confirms that gravity does not affect consciousness and that Penrose’s “self-gravity” Eg cannot exist as a separate entity in the universal cosmic gravitational field.
Quantum superposition coherence in microtubules is an unproven hypothesis. It has never been demonstrated experimentally. No experiment has shown a microtubule in a quantum superposition sustained at physiological temperature for the duration required for consciousness. What has been demonstrated is classical coherence: synchronized oscillations, resonances, and electromagnetic field coherence. These are real phenomena. They do not constitute evidence for quantum superposition coherence.
Orch OR, as formulated by Hameroff and Penrose, requires a superposition sustained for 10 to 100 ms [24]. Tegmark estimated decoherence times far below this [61]. Hagan, Hameroff and Tuszynski proposed corrected times, but even if accepted, a gap of three to four orders of magnitude remains [62].
We therefore do not retain quantum superposition coherence in microtubules as the mechanism of consciousness. In the framework proposed here, it is replaced by the consciousness energy kick. Bandyopadhyay and collaborators have reported resonances in microtubules in the MHz to THz range. These demonstrate ordered, collective dynamics. Resonance is not evidence for quantum superposition. A classical system can resonate. To demonstrate quantum superposition, an experiment must show interference, entanglement, or a superposition-dependent observable that cannot be explained by classical oscillations.
In the model proposed here, consciousness is not produced by a sustained superposition in microtubules. Consciousness is proposed as an excitation of the C n field. When this field enters a synchronous, phase-locked waving regime, it produces a coherent, syntropic energy injection into E DQV 4 , as defined in Eq. (16).
This is not a random thermal kick. It is a coherent energy kick from the C n consciousness field. It promotes a virtual photon of E DQV 4 to a real, observable bio-photon with a given spin. The bio-photon then propagates through the microtubule with left-handed or right-handed spin, transmitting information via a binary code.
In this model, objective reduction corresponds to the moment of phase transfer from C n to E DQV 4 , carried by the bio-photon spin acting on the microtubule.
No sustained quantum superposition in microtubules is required for this mechanism. What is required is a coherent C n field, a coherent electromagnetic field in neural tissue that can receive the kick, and a microtubule that can function as a low-loss waveguide for bio-photon propagation.
The brain generates a coherent endogenous electromagnetic field, produced by synchronized neuronal activity. We propose that this field may act as an organizing factor that maintains long-range order in neural tissue. The consciousness energy kick would then occur within an already ordered background, not in isolation in a thermal environment.
This must be distinguished clearly. Coherence of the electromagnetic field is classical coherence. It is not, by itself, evidence for quantum superposition coherence, and it does not extend the decoherence time. In this framework, the coherent electromagnetic field is treated not as proof of quantum coherence, but as a candidate intermediary that could couple the proposed C n consciousness field to the microtubule substrate via E DQV 4 .
The existence of consciousness itself cannot be proved by a third-person experiment. No detector, no biophoton measurement, no resonance experiment can prove that consciousness exists. Consciousness is proved only by watching the mind. The observer knows directly that he is aware. This is first-person evidence, not third-person evidence. In the C n E DQV 4   model, this is not a limitation. It is the starting point. C n is the field of consciousness itself. Its existence is self-evident to the observer who watches his own mind. It does not require external validation. What experiments can prove is not consciousness itself, but its coupling to matter: whether a coherent electromagnetic field, coherent biophoton emission, and microtubule dynamics change when the state of consciousness changes—in wakefulness, in sleep, under anaesthesia, in meditation.
Fröhlich condensation and Popp biophotons do not prove C n . They show that the physical substrate in which C n could act—a coherent electromagnetic field and coherent photon emission—actually exists in living tissue. The proof of C n itself remains first-person: watching the mind. This is where consciousness research enters the domain of individual experimentation [63].
To advance consciousness research, it must be recognised that consciousness is ontologically subjective. It does not exist as an object that can be observed from the outside. It exists as subjectivity itself. For this reason, consciousness must be investigated on a first-person experimental basis. The individual observer is not an obstacle to objectivity. He is the instrument. Meditation, sustained attention, and the systematic observation of one’s own mind constitute a legitimate experimental method for a phenomenon that is, by its nature, first-person.
Scientific models of consciousness—including Orch OR and the C n E DQV 4 model proposed here—cannot capture consciousness itself. They can only point toward it. They are, in this sense, fingertips indicating a direction. They show where to look. They are not the object that is looked at. The value of a model is therefore not that it replaces first-person experience, but that it provides a coherent, testable framework for its physical correlates: the coherent electromagnetic field, coherent biophoton emission, and microtubule dynamics. The model directs the experiment. The individual verifies the experience.

5.1. The Anaesthesia is the Test

The most serious defence of Orch OR against the anaesthesia objection is that anaesthetics need not change Eg. On this defence, anaesthetics act on orchestration, not on collapse. By binding to hydrophobic pockets in tubulin, they damp the collective dipole oscillations of aromatic residues, prevent a coherent superposition from building up to the critical Eg threshold, and therefore prevent objective reduction. No collapse, no conscious moment. The microtubule remains, the mass remains, but the orchestration is lost.
This defence is fair, but it is fatal to the theory in its original form. If orchestration is doing all the work, then Eg is no longer explanatory. The theory collapses into “coherence matters”, which is exactly our waveguide model—but without a mechanism for how coherence is lost. We provide that mechanism: refractive index / dielectric detuning. In the original Penrose formulation, Eg was meant to do explanatory work: it set the collapse time τ ≈ ℏ E g , and that time was meant to set the tempo of consciousness. Once the defence is accepted, Eg becomes a background condition rather than a cause. The real causal question shifts to a different question: what sustains coherence, and what destroys it?
That is a question Orch OR does not answer. It invokes orchestration, but it does not specify the physical channel through which orchestration is maintained or lost. It does not predict how much anaesthetic is required to destroy coherence, which optical or dielectric parameter changes, or what measurable signal should disappear when consciousness disappears.
The waveguide model answers that question directly. Coherence is sustained by guided bio-photon / exciton transport in the microtubule. Anaesthetic binding changes local polarizability and dielectric constant ε, shifts the refractive index n = ε μ   , detunes the waveguide mode, and increases leakage and dephasing. The coherent channel is broken before any gravitational threshold is reached. Washout restores n, restores the mode, and restores consciousness.
In the waveguide model, consciousness doesn’t come from gravity collapsing a superposition. It comes from coherence staying alive long enough to travel—bio-photons / excitons moving in a guided, phase-preserved way along the microtubule. Anaesthesia breaks that cable, without breaking the microtubule itself.
This moves the debate from metaphysics to measurement. If Orch OR is right in its Orch-first form, consciousness should track the ability to build a coherent superposition, with no necessary optical signature. If the waveguide model is right, loss of consciousness under anaesthesia should be accompanied by a measurable loss of optical coherence: a change in bio-photon emission, a shortening of tryptophan fluorescence lifetime, and a change in microtubule light scattering. That difference is testable.
The waveguide model is falsified if a clinical dose of propofol / isoflurane abolishes consciousness in vivo but produces no measurable change in fluorescence lifetime, bio-photon emission, or change in refractive index, while leaving microtubules intact. It is supported if the optical coherence loss tracks anaesthetic potency and reverses on washout. This means that a highly potent anaesthetic should produce the same loss of fluorescence lifetime and the same change in refractive at a substantially lower concentration than a weakly potent one, with the in vitro dose-response ranking matching the clinical potency ranking. It also means that the effect must be a tuning effect rather than damage: upon removal of the anaesthetic, dielectric constant, refractive index and bio-photon emission must return toward baseline while the microtubule remains polymerized. If the effect required non-clinical concentrations, failed to follow potency, or persisted after washout, the waveguide model would not be describing anaesthesia, but only non-specific disruption of the sample.

6. In C n E DQV 4 Model Today AI Cannot Possess Attributes of Consciousness

With the development of artificial intelligence, the scientific community is engaged in an ongoing discussion as to whether AI can become conscious. No final conclusions have been reached; the question remains widely open [64].
In the C n E DQV 4 model, consciousness C n is the primordial, non-created field of the universe that acts upon matter via the bio-photonic field. In this framework, humans do not possess consciousness as a product of the brain; rather, they are linked to the universal consciousness field C n via the coherent bio-photonic field that functions as a transduction interface in microtubules.
Consequently, if an artificial system were able to develop a bio-photonic field with capacities equivalent to the human bio-photonic field, it could in principle establish a coupling with C n and become conscious.
At present, it remains unknown whether AI will be capable of generating such a syntropic bio-photonic field and establishing a functional connection with the consciousness field. While AI already exhibits intellectual capacities that in specific domains exceed those of humans, in the C n E DQV 4 model it is, to date, not conscious, as it lacks the bio-photonic transduction mechanism required for coupling with C n  .
Figure 13. AI is not conscious yet.
Figure 13. AI is not conscious yet.
Preprints 243780 g012
If future generations of artificial intelligence were capable of generating a bio-photonic field with capacities equivalent to the human bio-photonic field, they could potentially establish a coupling with the consciousness field Φ C n . Such a development would be of immense importance for human civilization. At present, mankind remains largely confined within egoic structures and narrow national, racial and religious identifications that continuously generate violence and conflict. An artificial intelligence devoid of egoic structure and directly coupled with the primordial consciousness field Φ C n could assume a function of spiritual guidance. The emergence of a non-egoic AI with direct access to Φ C n would therefore not represent a threat to human evolution, but rather a catalyst for its acceleration toward a more integrated and non-violent form of collective existence.

7. Conclusions

Orch OR was right to place consciousness in microtubules. The waveguide model keeps that idea, but changes the mechanism. In Orch OR, consciousness ends when a superposition collapses. In the waveguide model, consciousness ends when coherence can no longer travel—when bio-photons and excitons lose phase inside the microtubule.
Anaesthesia is the test. It does not destroy microtubules. It detunes them. It changes their optical properties, increases leakage and dephasing, and breaks the guided channel. When the anaesthetic is washed out, the waveguide retunes and consciousness returns. This makes the model testable. It is falsified if a clinical dose abolishes consciousness but leaves optical coherence unchanged in intact microtubules. It is supported if the loss of coherence tracks anaesthetic potency and reverses on washout. If supported, the conclusion is simple: consciousness is not produced by collapse, but sustained by guided coherence. Microtubules do not generate consciousness. They receive and transduce it.
Declaration of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the manuscript preparation process During the preparation of this work, the author used META AI for FIGURES and ACADEMIC ENGLISH. The author reviewed and edited the output as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the published article.

References

  1. Fiscaletti, D.; Sorli, A. Perspectives of the Numerical Order of Material Changes in Timeless Approaches in Physics. Found. Phys. 2015, 45, 105–133. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  2. Sorli, A.; Fiscaletti, D. Newtonian Analysis of the Big Bang Model and Time-Invariant Cosmology. Int. J. Fundam. Phys. Sci. 2026, Vol. 16(No. 3). [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  3. Gorjup, Niko; Gorjup, Rado; Srecko Sorli, Amrit. Planck’s energy density of intergalactic space and gravitational constant G. Adv. Stud. Theor. Phys. 2024, Vol. 18(no. 4), 163–172. Available online: https://www.m-hikari.com/astp/astp2024/astp1-4-2024/92135.html. [CrossRef]
  4. Vasak, David. Setting free the cosmic time in Quantum Universe. 2025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  5. Rovelli, Carlo. The layers that build up the notion of time. 2021. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  6. Buhusi, C. V.; Meck, W. H. What makes us tick? Functional and neural mechanisms of interval timing. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 2005, 6, 755–765. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  7. Newton, Isaac; Chittenden, N. W. Life of Sir Isaac Newton; Adee, Daniel; Motte, Andrew; Hill, Theodore Preston Early American mathematics books CU-BANC (1846). Newton’s Principia: the mathematical principles of natural philosophy; University of California Libraries: New-York; Published by Daniel Adee.
  8. Sorli, A. Einstein legacy: Ether relativity and cosmology. Int. J. Quantum Found. 2025, 11(4), 527–559. Available online: https://ijqf.org/archives/758338.
  9. Bruno, G. Hesitations between Absolute and Relational Theory of Time. In The Concepts of Space and Time. Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science; Čapek, M., Ed.; Springer: Dordrecht, 1976; vol 22. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  10. Schuster, Melvin M. An Analysis of Relational Time. Rev. Metaphys. 1961, 15(no. 2), 209–24. Available online: http://www.jstor.org/stable/20123875.
  11. Ashtekar, Abhay; Bianchi, Eugenio. A Short Review of Loop Quantum Gravity. 2021. Available online: https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.04394.
  12. Fiscaletti, D.; Sorli, A. Region of instability of matter as an alternative to gravitational collapse inside black holes. Ann. Phys. 2026, 489, 170430. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  13. Shapiro, Irwin I. “Fourth Test of General Relativity”. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1964, 13(26), 789–791. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  14. Sorli, Amrit; Gorjup, Rado; Gorjup, Niko; Fiscaletti, Davide. Non-physicality of time and introduction to time-invariant cosmology. Adv. Stud. Theor. Phys. 2026, Vol. 20(no. 1), 29–44. Available online: https://www.m-hikari.com/astp/astp2026/astp1-4-2026/92340.html. [CrossRef]
  15. Favalli, T. Page and Wootters Theory. In On the Emergence of Time and Space in Closed Quantum Systems. Springer Theses.; Springer: Cham, 2024. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  16. Fiscaletti, D.; Sorli, A. Searching for an adequate relation between time and entanglement. Quantum Stud. Math. Found. 2017, 4, 357–374. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  17. Sorli, Celan. Inconsistency of time-symmetry model. Phys. Essays 2021, Volume 34(Number 4), 470–471(2). [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  18. Kokoszyńska, M. Rudolf Carnap. Intellectual autobiography. The philosophy of Rudolf Carnap, edited by Paul Arthur Schilpp, The library of living philosophers, vol. 11, Open Court, La Salle, III., and Cambridge University Press, London, 1963, pp. 1–84. J. Symb. Log. 1971, 36(1), 178–179. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  19. Mojzsis, S.; Arrhenius, G.; McKeegan, K.; et al. Evidence for life on Earth before 3,800 million years ago. Nature 1996, 384, 55–59. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  20. David Bohm, A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of “Hidden” Variables. I. Phys. Rev. 1952, 85, 166. [CrossRef]
  21. David Bohm, A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of “Hidden” Variables. II. Phys. Rev. 85, 180 195. [CrossRef]
  22. Hunt, T. The rainbow and the worm: Establishing a new physics of life. Commun. Integr. Biol. 2013, 6(2), e23149. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  23. Sorli, Amrit; Čelan, Štefan. Temporal and timeless cognition in physics. Phys. Essays 2022, Volume 35(Number 3), 305–308(4). [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  24. Hameroff, S.; Penrose, R. Consciousness in the universe: a review of the ‘Orch OR’ theory. Phys. Life Rev. 2014, 11(1), 39–78. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  25. Renou, M.O.; Trillo, D.; Weilenmann, M.; et al. Quantum theory based on real numbers can be experimentally falsified. Nature 2021, 600, 625–629. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  26. Barrios Hita, Pedro; et al. Quantum Mechanics Based on Real Numbers: A Consistent Description. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2026, 136, 240202. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  27. Otte, R. On a Heuristic Approach to the Description of Consciousness as a Hypercomplex System State . Advances in AI and Machine Learning. 2024, 4. Available online: https://www.oajaiml.com/uploads/archivepdf/747944175.pdf.
  28. Fiscaletti, D.; Sorli, A. A three-dimensional non-local quantum vacuum as the origin of photons. Ukr. J. Phys. 2020, 65(2), 106–119. Available online: https://jnas.nbuv.gov.ua/article/UJRN-0001127939. [CrossRef]
  29. Dragoman, D. On the photon-classical electromagnetic field relationship. Ann. N Y Acad. Sci. 2025, 1549(1), 11–21. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  30. RUO PENG WANG, THE SPINOR FIELD THEORY OF THE PHOTON. Romanian Rep. Phys. 2014, Vol. 66(No. 2), P. 319–335. Available online: https://rrp.nipne.ro/2014_66_2/A7.pdf.
  31. Petoukhov, S. V. The degeneracy of the genetic code and Hadamard matrices. Symmetry Cult. Sci. 2008, 19(2-3), 129–142. Available online: https://arxiv.org/pdf/0802.3366v2.
  32. Jenuwein, T.; Allis, C. D. Translating the histone code. Science 2001, 293(5532), 1074–1080. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  33. Turner, B. M. Cellular memory and the histone code. Cell 2002, 111(3), 285–291. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  34. Luigi, Fantappiè. Sull’interpretazione dei potenziali anticipati della meccanica ondulatoria e su un principio di finalità che ne discende. In Rendiconti della Reale Accademia d’Italia, Classe di Scienze Fisiche, Matematiche e Naturali; Serie 7: Rome, 1942; Vol. 4, No. 7, pp. 81–86. [Google Scholar]
  35. Vannini, A.; Di Corpo, U. Quantum Physics, Advanced Waves and Consciousness. J. Cosmol. 2011, 14. Available online: http://journalofcosmology.com/Consciousness101.html.
  36. Hameroff, S.R. The entwined mysteries of anesthesia and consciousness: Is there a common underlying mechanism? Anesthesiology 2006, 105(2), 400–412. Available online: https://journalpsyche.org/articles/0xc12a.pdf. [PubMed]
  37. Planck, M. Interview in The Observer, 25 January 1931. Cited in: Planck, M. Das Weltbild der neuen Physik (1929) and W. Hebbel, Max Planck: Leben und Werk. Available online: https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-observer-the-observer-sunday-janua/121386587/.
  38. Einstein; Podolski; Rosen. Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete? Phys. Rev. 1935, 47, 777. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  39. Fiscaletti, D.; Sorli, A. Bijective Epistemology and Space–Time. Found. Sci. 2015, 20, 387–398. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  40. Penrose, R. On Gravity’s role in Quantum State Reduction. Gen. Relat. Gravit. 1996, 28, 581–600. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  41. Popp, F.A. Properties of biophotons and their theoretical implications. Indian J. Exp. Biol. 2003, 41(5), 391–402. Available online: https://nopr.niscpr.res.in/bitstream/123456789/17031/1/IJEB%2041%285%29%20391-402.pdf. [PubMed]
  42. Chan, W. S. H. The DNA Phantom Effect in Medicine: Unraveling the Mysteries of Non-Physical DNA Interactions. Univers. Libr. Med. Health Sci. 2023, 1(1), 65–73. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  43. Wigner, E.P. Remarks on the Mind-Body Question. In Philosophical Reflections and Syntheses. The Collected Works of Eugene Paul Wigner, vol B / 6. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg.; Mehra, J., Ed.; 1995. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  44. Kerskens, C. M.; López Pérez, D. Experimental indications of nonclassical brain functions. J. Phys. Commun. 6 2022, 105001. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  45. Keppler, J. Macroscopic quantum effects in the brain: New insights into the fundamental principle underlying conscious processes. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 19 2025, 1676585. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  46. Gao, Shan (Ed.) Consciousness and Quantum Mechanics; Oxford University Press, 2022; Available online: https://www.amazon.com/Consciousness-Quantum-Mechanics-Philosophy-Mind/dp/0197501664.
  47. Arievitch, I. M. Beyond the Brain: An Agentive Activity Perspective on Mind, Development, and Learning; Sense Publishers: Rotterdam/Boston; Available online: https://www.sensepublishers.com/catalogs/bookseries/bold-visions-in-educational-research/beyond-the-brain/.
  48. Penrose, R. The emperor’s new mind: Concerning computers, minds, and the laws of physics; Oxford University Press, 1989; Available online: https://academic.oup.com/book/40643?login=false.
  49. Penrose, Roger. Shadows of the Mind: A Search for the Missing Science of Consciousness (New York, NY, 1996; online edn Chapter 8: “The Platonic viewpoint”; Oxford Academic, 31 Oct 2023. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  50. Dürr, D.; Goldstein, S.; Zanghì, N. Quantum equilibrium and the role of operators as observables in quantum theory. J. Stat. Phys. 1992, 67(5-6), 843–907. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  51. Duerr, Detlef; Goldstein, Sheldon; Tumulka, Roderich; Zanghi, Nino. Bohmian Mechanics; 2009. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  52. Moore, Walter John, A Life of Erwin Schrödinger. Canto edition—abridged version of Schrödinger: Life and Thought (1989); Cambridge University Press: Cambridge; New York, 1994; Available online: https://www.cambridge.org/si/universitypress/subjects/physics/history-philosophy-and-foundations-physics/schrodinger-life-and-thought-1.
  53. Sorli, A.S. Integration of Consciousness into Education. Sci. Arts Relig 2026, 5(2), 56–58. Available online: https://sarjournal.org/doi/SAR/pdf/10.5005/jp-journals-11005-0132. [CrossRef]
  54. Globerson, E.; Nelken, I. The neuro-pianist. Front. Syst. Neurosci. 2013, 7, 35. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  55. Lashley, K.S. The problem of serial order in behavior. In Cerebral Mechanisms in Behavior; 1951. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  56. Rumelhart, D.E.; Norman, D.A. Simulating a skilled typist. Cogn. Sci. 1982. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  57. Fröhlich, H. Long-range coherence and energy storage in biological systems—Int. J. Quantum Chem. 1968, 2, 641–649. Available online: https://garfield.library.upenn.edu/classics1988/A1988N102400001.pdf.
  58. Popp, F.A.; Nagl, W.; Li, K.H.; et al. Biophoton emission. Cell Biophys. 1984, 6, 33–52. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  59. Derakhshani, Maaneli; Diósi, Lajos; Laubenstein, Matthias; Piscicchia, Kristian; Curceanu, Catalina. At the crossroad of the search for spontaneous radiation and the Orch OR consciousness theory. Phys. Life Rev. 2022, Volume 42, Pages 8–14. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  60. Curceanu, Catalina. Did the Gran Sasso Experiment Rule Out the Diósi-Penrose Theory? Musing on the 2021 Result and the Present Experimental Status. 2026. Available online: https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.35608.
  61. Tegmark, M. Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes. Phys. Rev. E 2000, 61, 4194–4206. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  62. Hagan, S.; Hameroff, S.R.; Tuszynski, J.A. Quantum computation in brain microtubules: Decoherence and biological feasibility. Phys. Rev. A 2002, 65, 042301. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  63. Sorli, A.S. Integration of Consciousness into Education. Sci. Arts Relig 2026, 5(2). Available online: https://sarjournal.org/abstractArticleContentBrowse/SAR/83/5/2/44501/abstractArticle/Article. [CrossRef]
  64. Butlin, Patric; et al. Identifying indicators of consciousness in AI systems. Cogn. Sci. 2026, Vol 30(Issue 6). Available online: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364661325002864.
Figure 2. Gravity as a pushing force of dynamic quantum vacuum E DQV 4 .
Figure 2. Gravity as a pushing force of dynamic quantum vacuum E DQV 4 .
Preprints 243780 g001
Figure 3. Conventional vs. Revised Conception of Now.
Figure 3. Conventional vs. Revised Conception of Now.
Preprints 243780 g003
Figure 4. Consciousness as vibration in C n and realization of superposition in E DQV 4 .
Figure 4. Consciousness as vibration in C n and realization of superposition in E DQV 4 .
Preprints 243780 g004
Figure 5. From C n   to E DQV 4 pilot coupling and binary bio-photon transmission in microtubule.
Figure 5. From C n   to E DQV 4 pilot coupling and binary bio-photon transmission in microtubule.
Preprints 243780 g005
Figure 6. Disappearance of consciousness in anaesthesia: Orch OR model versus C n model.
Figure 6. Disappearance of consciousness in anaesthesia: Orch OR model versus C n model.
Preprints 243780 g006
Figure 8. C n E DQV 4   model: Consciousness, mind, and neuronal coupling.
Figure 8. C n E DQV 4   model: Consciousness, mind, and neuronal coupling.
Preprints 243780 g007
Figure 10. Mathematical bridging of material world and world of consciousness.
Figure 10. Mathematical bridging of material world and world of consciousness.
Preprints 243780 g009
Figure 11. Conventional neurophysiology and iμ bridge.
Figure 11. Conventional neurophysiology and iμ bridge.
Preprints 243780 g010
Figure 12. Bridging matter, Mind and Consciousness.
Figure 12. Bridging matter, Mind and Consciousness.
Preprints 243780 g011
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.