Submitted:
05 June 2025
Posted:
06 June 2025
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
The Aranmula Kanadi, a handcrafted metal mirror from Kerala, India, stands as a multifaceted symbol of cultural identity, spiritual significance, and artisanal excellence. Unlike conventional glass mirrors, it is crafted from a high-tin bronze alloy (Cu₃₁Sn₈) using secret traditional techniques passed down through generations. This paper explores the cultural, religious, and metallurgical dimensions of Aranmula Kanadi, analyzing its role in the preservation of traditional knowledge, community identity, and rural livelihoods. Special attention is given to the impact of its Geographical Indication (GI) registration, which enhances its marketability, fosters economic resilience, and reinforces cultural continuity. Additionally, the paper discusses sustainability prospects by examining the eco-friendly production methods and potential integration with modern technologies. Challenges such as globalization, resource scarcity, and commercialization are also critically evaluated. The study concludes with a call for policy support, innovation, and documentation to safeguard this unique tradition for future generations.
Keywords:
aranmula kanadi
; traditional craftsmanship
; geographical indication
; kerala culture
; high-tin bronze
; metallurgy
; cultural heritage
; sustainable development
; religious significance
; folk art preservation
Introduction
The Aranmula Kanadi, a traditional mirror crafted from metal, holds significant cultural importance in Indian traditions, particularly in the state of Kerala. This unique artifact is not just a functional object but a symbol of cultural heritage, craftsmanship, and spiritual significance. The Aranmula Kanadi is deeply intertwined with the cultural and religious practices of the region, reflecting the rich tapestry of Indian traditions. Its significance is multifaceted, encompassing aspects of art, religion, and cultural identity. Aranmula Kanadi is timeless mirror of Kerala’s culture and spirituality.
Cultural Heritage and Craftsmanship
The Aranmula Kanadi is a testament to the exquisite craftsmanship of Kerala artisans. It is made using a secretive alloy of metals, polished to create a reflective surface, unlike conventional glass mirrors. This craftsmanship is a part of the intangible cultural heritage of India, representing the skills and knowledge passed down through generations (Panicker et al., 2024).
- The mirror is traditionally crafted in the village of Aranmula, which is also known for the Aranmula Vallam Kali, a snake boat race that is a significant cultural event in the region. This connection highlights the village's role as a custodian of cultural traditions (Halder & Zheng, 2023).
Religious and Spiritual Significance
- The Aranmula Kanadi is often associated with religious rituals and is considered an auspicious object. It is believed to bring good luck and prosperity, and is often used in Hindu religious ceremonies. The mirror's reflective surface is symbolic of self-reflection and spiritual clarity, aligning with the broader Indian tradition of integrating art with spirituality (Kaur, 2024).
- In Hinduism, mirrors are sometimes used in rituals to symbolize the reflection of the soul and the pursuit of truth, which is a recurring theme in Indian religious practices (Baruah, 2022).
Symbol of Cultural Identity
- The Aranmula Kanadi serves as a cultural emblem for the people of Kerala, representing their unique traditions and artistic heritage. It is a part of the broader spectrum of Indian folk art, which includes various forms of expression such as music, dance, and visual arts, all of which contribute to the cultural identity of the region (Yadav & Pandey, 2024).
- The preservation and promotion of such traditional crafts are crucial for maintaining cultural diversity and identity in the face of globalization and modernization, which often threaten these age-old practices (Panicker et al., 2024).
While the Aranmula Kanadi is a significant cultural artifact, it is important to consider the broader context of Indian folk traditions and their role in cultural preservation. The challenges faced by traditional crafts, such as the Aranmula Kanadi, are not unique. Many Indian folk arts and traditions are under threat from modernization and the influence of Western culture, which can lead to the erosion of cultural identities. Efforts to revitalize and preserve these traditions, through education, community involvement, and policy support, are essential to ensure their survival and continued relevance in contemporary society (Panicker et al., 2024) (Yadav & Pandey, 2024).
The Aranmula Kanadi
A Testament to Ancient Indian Metallurgical Mastery
The Aranmula Kanadi, a unique metal mirror crafted in the village of Aranmula, Kerala, exemplifies the advanced metallurgical expertise of ancient India. This mirror is made from a high-tin bronze alloy, specifically a delta phase intermetallic compound (Cu31Sn8) with approximately 32.6% tin, which is known for its silvery color and high hardness. The creation of the Aranmula Kanadi reflects a sophisticated understanding of metal properties and casting techniques, showcasing the ingenuity and skill of ancient Indian metallurgists. The process involves optimizing the delta phase to achieve the desired reflective quality, while also managing the brittleness of the alloy through careful casting and polishing methods. This craft not only highlights the technical prowess of ancient Indian artisans but also their ability to produce high-quality, functional art using low-technology methods and organic materials (Srinivasan, 2020) (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
Metallurgical Composition and Properties
- The Aranmula Kanadi is crafted from a high-tin bronze alloy, specifically the delta phase intermetallic compound (Cu31Sn8), which contains about 32.6% tin (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
- This alloy is chosen for its silvery appearance and high hardness, making it ideal for polishing into a mirror (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
- The delta phase is optimized to enhance the mirror's reflective quality, while its brittleness is managed through specialized casting and polishing techniques (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
Crafting Techniques
- The creation of the Aranmula Kanadi involves a sophisticated casting process that offsets the brittleness of the high-tin bronze (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
- Artisans employ low-technology methods, using organic and everyday materials to achieve a high-technology end product (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
- The process reflects a deep understanding of metallurgical principles, allowing for the production of a functional and aesthetically pleasing mirror (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
Historical and Cultural Significance
- The Aranmula Kanadi is part of a broader tradition of metalworking in India, which includes the production of copper and iron artifacts with remarkable properties (Srinivasan, 2020) (Hegde, 1991).
- This craft is a testament to the rich metallurgical heritage of India, which has been recognized for its advanced techniques in metal extraction and artifact creation since ancient times (Srinivasan, 2020) (Gandhi, 2014).
- The survival of this craft through centuries underscores its cultural importance and the enduring legacy of Indian metallurgical expertise (Srinivasan, 2020).
While the Aranmula Kanadi is a remarkable example of ancient Indian metallurgical skill, it is important to consider the broader context of metalworking in India. The country has a long history of producing high-quality metal artifacts, such as the rust-resistant iron pillars and the renowned wootz steel, which further demonstrate the advanced metallurgical knowledge of ancient Indian craftsmen (Hegde, 1991) (Agasti & Pani, 2023). These achievements highlight the diverse applications of metallurgical expertise across different regions and time periods in India, contributing to a rich legacy of technological innovation and cultural heritage.
Kerala's Iconic Metal Mirror Craft
The Aranmula Kanadi, a unique metal mirror crafted in the village of Aranmula, Kerala, is a testament to the region's rich tradition of craftsmanship. This mirror is made from a high-tin bronze alloy, known for its silvery color and high hardness, which is ideal for polishing into a reflective surface. The craft of making these mirrors is deeply rooted in the local culture and utilizes traditional techniques that have been passed down through generations. The process involves a sophisticated understanding of metallurgy and a meticulous casting and polishing method that offsets the brittleness of the alloy, resulting in a high-quality, distortion-free mirror. This craft not only reflects the technical prowess of the artisans but also embodies the cultural heritage of Kerala. Below are the key aspects of how Aranmula Kanadi reflects the traditional craftsmanship of Kerala:
Traditional Metallurgy and Craftsmanship
- The Aranmula Kanadi is made from a high-tin bronze alloy, specifically the delta phase (Cu31Sn8) with 32.6% tin, which is known for its silvery appearance and hardness, making it suitable for mirror production (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007) (Nagae et al., 2014).
- The crafting process involves a unique casting and polishing technique that compensates for the alloy's brittleness, showcasing the artisans' deep understanding of material properties and traditional metallurgical practices (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007) (Nagae et al., 2014).
Cultural and Historical Significance
- The craft of making Aranmula Kanadi is a part of the broader metalworking traditions in the Cauvery basin region, which includes Kerala. This region has a rich history of artisanal technologies, including the making of high-tin bronze mirrors, which have survived through centuries (Srinivasan, 2020).
- The mirrors are not just functional objects but are also considered auspicious and are often used in religious and cultural ceremonies, reflecting their cultural significance in Kerala (Srinivasan, 2020).
Preservation of Traditional Techniques
- The production of Aranmula Kanadi involves low-technology, organic, and everyday materials, emphasizing the sustainable and traditional methods employed by the artisans (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
- Despite modern technological advancements, the artisans of Aranmula continue to use age-old techniques, ensuring the preservation of this unique craft for future generations (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
Challenges and Resilience
- The craft has faced challenges, such as the 2018 floods around the Pampa river, which affected the village of Aranmula. However, the resilience of the artisans and the cultural importance of the craft have helped in its survival and continuation (Srinivasan, 2020).
While the Aranmula Kanadi is a remarkable example of traditional craftsmanship, it is important to consider the broader context of Kerala's artisanal heritage. Other crafts, such as the handloom industry and mural paintings, also reflect the region's rich cultural tapestry. These crafts, like the Aranmula Kanadi, rely on traditional techniques and materials, highlighting the importance of preserving these practices in the face of modernization and technological change. The continued interest and support for these crafts are crucial for maintaining the cultural identity and heritage of Kerala.
Kerala's Traditional Craftsmanship and Cultural Identity Preservation
The Aranmula Kanadi mirror-making process is a unique traditional craft that significantly contributes to the preservation of traditional craftsmanship by maintaining age-old techniques and cultural heritage. This craft, originating from Aranmula, Kerala, involves the creation of metal mirrors using a high-tin bronze alloy, which is a testament to the sophisticated metallurgical skills of the artisans. The process not only preserves the technical skills required for crafting these mirrors but also embodies the cultural and historical significance of the region. The preservation of this craft is crucial for maintaining the cultural identity and heritage of the community, as well as for fostering a sense of pride and continuity among the artisans. The following sections elaborate on the key aspects of how this process contributes to the preservation of traditional craftsmanship.
Technical Mastery and Skill Preservation
- The Aranmula Kanadi mirrors are crafted using a high-tin bronze alloy, specifically the delta phase (Cu31Sn8), which is known for its silvery color and high hardness, making it ideal for polishing into a mirror (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
- The process involves a clever casting and polishing technique that offsets the brittleness of the alloy, showcasing the artisans' mastery over traditional metallurgical skills (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
- This intricate process requires a deep understanding of materials and techniques, which are passed down through generations, ensuring the continuity of these specialized skills (Srinivasan & Glover, 2007).
Cultural Heritage and Identity
- Traditional crafts like the Aranmula Kanadi mirrors are vital components of a community's cultural heritage, reflecting the unique identity and history of the region (Tiwari, n.d.).
- The preservation of such crafts helps maintain the cultural identity of the community, providing a sense of belonging and pride among the artisans and the local population (Rivas, 2018).
- By continuing these traditional practices, the community not only preserves its cultural heritage but also contributes to the broader understanding and appreciation of traditional crafts worldwide (Tiwari, n.d.).
Economic and Social Impact
- The craft of making Aranmula Kanadi mirrors provides economic opportunities for the local community, supporting livelihoods and contributing to the local economy (Rivas, 2018).
- The craft's recognition as an important cultural heritage can attract tourism and interest from collectors and enthusiasts, further boosting the local economy (Rivas, 2018).
- The social structure of the community is strengthened through the transmission of skills and knowledge, fostering a sense of unity and shared purpose among the artisans (Suharson, 2024).
Challenges and Opportunities for Innovation
- Despite the importance of preserving traditional crafts, globalization and modernization pose challenges to their continuity, as younger generations may be drawn to more lucrative or modern professions (Tiwari, n.d.).
- However, there are opportunities for innovation by integrating traditional techniques with modern design and technology, which can enhance the appeal and functionality of traditional crafts (NamGoong et al., 2010).
- Documenting and promoting these crafts can inspire renewed interest and innovation, ensuring their relevance and sustainability in the modern world (Tiwari, n.d.).
While the Aranmula Kanadi mirror-making process plays a crucial role in preserving traditional craftsmanship, it is important to recognize the challenges posed by modernization and globalization. The integration of traditional crafts with modern technology and design can offer new opportunities for innovation and sustainability. By documenting and promoting these crafts, communities can ensure their cultural heritage is preserved and appreciated by future generations, while also adapting to the changing demands of the modern world.
Aranmula Kanadi: Reflecting Kerala’s Cultural Soul
Aranmula Kanadi, a unique traditional Indian art form, is distinguished by its intricate craftsmanship and cultural significance. Unlike other Indian art forms, Aranmula Kanadi is not a painting or textile but a handcrafted metal mirror, known for its reflective surface made from a special alloy. This art form is deeply rooted in the cultural and religious traditions of Kerala, India, and is associated with the Aranmula Parthasarathy Temple. The mirrors are considered auspicious and are often used in religious rituals and ceremonies. The uniqueness of Aranmula Kanadi lies in its manufacturing process, cultural symbolism, and the socio-economic impact it has on the local community. Below are the key features and designs that set Aranmula Kanadi apart from other traditional Indian art forms.
Unique Manufacturing Process
- Metal Alloy Composition: Unlike conventional glass mirrors, Aranmula Kanadi is made from a special alloy of copper and tin, which is polished to achieve a reflective surface. This process is a closely guarded secret passed down through generations (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
- Handcrafted Precision: Each mirror is meticulously handcrafted, requiring significant skill and precision. The artisans use traditional methods that have been preserved over centuries, ensuring the authenticity and quality of each piece (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
Cultural and Religious Significance
- Association with Aranmula Parthasarathy Temple: The mirrors are traditionally linked to the Aranmula Parthasarathy Temple, where they are used in various rituals. This connection enhances their cultural value and makes them a symbol of spiritual purity (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
- Symbol of Prosperity and Good Luck: In Kerala, these mirrors are considered auspicious and are often gifted during weddings and other significant life events. They are believed to bring prosperity and good fortune to the recipient (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
Socio-Economic Impact
- Community-Based Craft: The production of Aranmula Kanadi supports the local economy by providing employment to artisans in the region. This craft is a vital source of income for many families, helping to sustain the traditional way of life (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
- Cultural Preservation: Efforts to preserve this art form are crucial for maintaining the cultural heritage of the region. The mirrors are not only artistic objects but also represent the historical and cultural identity of the community (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
While Aranmula Kanadi is a unique art form, it shares some common challenges with other traditional Indian arts, such as the threat of globalization and the need for preservation. Similar to other crafts, there is a growing need for documentation and digital preservation to ensure that these traditional skills are not lost to future generations (Panicker et al., 2024). Additionally, like many other traditional arts, Aranmula Kanadi faces competition from mass-produced items, which can undermine the value of handcrafted pieces. However, the cultural and religious significance of these mirrors continues to sustain their demand and relevance in contemporary society.
Kerala’s Sacred Mirror Craft
Aranmula Kanadi, a unique traditional Indian art form, is distinguished by its intricate craftsmanship and cultural significance. Unlike other Indian art forms, Aranmula Kanadi is not a painting or textile but a handcrafted metal mirror, known for its reflective surface made from a special alloy. This art form is deeply rooted in the cultural and religious traditions of Kerala, India, and is associated with the Aranmula Parthasarathy Temple. The mirrors are considered auspicious and are often used in religious rituals and ceremonies. The uniqueness of Aranmula Kanadi lies in its manufacturing process, cultural symbolism, and the socio-economic impact it has on the local community. Below are the key features and designs that set Aranmula Kanadi apart from other traditional Indian art forms.
Unique Manufacturing Process
- Metal Alloy Composition: Unlike conventional glass mirrors, Aranmula Kanadi is made from a special alloy of copper and tin, which is polished to achieve a reflective surface. This process is a closely guarded secret passed down through generations (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
- Handcrafted Precision: Each mirror is meticulously handcrafted, requiring significant skill and precision. The artisans use traditional methods that have been preserved over centuries, ensuring the authenticity and quality of each piece (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
Cultural and Religious Significance
- Association with Aranmula Parthasarathy Temple: The mirrors are traditionally linked to the Aranmula Parthasarathy Temple, where they are used in various rituals. This connection enhances their cultural value and makes them a symbol of spiritual purity (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
- Symbol of Prosperity and Good Luck: In Kerala, these mirrors are considered auspicious and are often gifted during weddings and other significant life events. They are believed to bring prosperity and good fortune to the recipient (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
Socio-Economic Impact
- Community-Based Craft: The production of Aranmula Kanadi supports the local economy by providing employment to artisans in the region. This craft is a vital source of income for many families, helping to sustain the traditional way of life (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
- Cultural Preservation: Efforts to preserve this art form are crucial for maintaining the cultural heritage of the region. The mirrors are not only artistic objects but also represent the historical and cultural identity of the community (Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure, 2022).
While Aranmula Kanadi is a unique art form, it shares some common challenges with other traditional Indian arts, such as the threat of globalization and the need for preservation. Similar to other crafts, there is a growing need for documentation and digital preservation to ensure that these traditional skills are not lost to future generations (Panicker et al., 2024). Additionally, like many other traditional arts, Aranmula Kanadi faces competition from mass-produced items, which can undermine the value of handcrafted pieces. However, the cultural and religious significance of these mirrors continues to sustain their demand and relevance in contemporary society.
Lisbon Agreement
The Aranmula Kanadi Lisbon agreement, while not directly mentioned in the provided papers, can be analyzed through the lens of the Lisbon Treaty's impact on international trade and commerce. The Lisbon Treaty has significantly influenced the European Union's (EU) Common Commercial Policy (CCP), which in turn affects international trade dynamics. The Treaty has expanded the EU's competence in trade matters, integrating trade policy into broader EU external relations, and has implications for international trade agreements and commerce. This integration aims to enhance the EU's role as a global trade actor, influencing trade liberalization and regulatory frameworks. The implications of such changes are multifaceted, affecting trade negotiations, investment flows, and the EU's strategic positioning in global trade.
Expansion of EU Competence
- The Lisbon Treaty has expanded the EU's exclusive competence in trade matters, including foreign direct investment, services, and intellectual property rights (Janků, 2017).
- This expansion allows the EU to negotiate and implement trade agreements more comprehensively, potentially leading to more cohesive and unified trade policies (Woolcock, 2010).
Integration into EU External Relations
- The Treaty integrates the CCP into the EU's external relations, aligning trade policy with broader foreign policy objectives (Dimopoulos, 2010) (Pollet-Fort, 2010).
- This integration ensures consistency and unity in the EU's external actions, potentially strengthening its negotiating position in international trade agreements (Dimopoulos, n.d.).
Role of the European Parliament
- The Lisbon Treaty enhances the role of the European Parliament in trade policy, providing it with greater oversight and influence over trade agreements (Janků, 2017).
- This change introduces a democratic element into trade policy decision-making, potentially affecting the content and direction of trade agreements (Woolcock, 2010).
Implications for International Trade Agreements
- The Treaty’s changes may lead to more streamlined and efficient trade negotiations, as the EU can act as a single entity in international forums (Dimopoulos, 2008).
- The inclusion of trade in services and investment under the CCP could lead to more comprehensive trade agreements, covering a broader range of economic activities (Janků, 2017).
Challenges and Considerations
- The expansion of EU competence and integration into external relations may lead to tensions with member states over sovereignty and control over trade policy (Janků, 2017).
- The increased role of the European Parliament could slow down the negotiation process, as more stakeholders are involved in decision-making (Woolcock, 2010).
While the Lisbon Treaty strengthens the EU's position in international trade, it also presents challenges related to internal coordination and the balance of power between EU institutions and member states. The Treaty’s impact on international trade and commerce is significant, as it enhances the EU's ability to negotiate and implement trade agreements, potentially leading to more liberalized and integrated global trade. However, the increased complexity of decision-making processes and the need for alignment with broader EU policies may pose challenges in maintaining efficiency and coherence in trade negotiations.
Impact of Aranmula Kanadi's Geographical Indication Registration on Local Economy and Community
Geographical Indications (GIs) are intellectual property rights that identify a product as originating from a specific geographical region, often associated with unique qualities, traditions, or cultural heritage. The registration of Aranmula Kanadi, a traditional metal alloy product from Kerala, India, under the GI Act, has significant implications for the local economy, cultural preservation, and community development. This response explores the economic, cultural, and community development impacts of GI registration, supported by insights from relevant research papers.
Economic Impact
Enhanced Market Value and Price Premiums
The registration of Aranmula Kanadi as a GI has likely increased its market value by distinguishing it from similar products. GIs often command a price premium due to their unique origin and quality, which can enhance the profitability of local producers. For instance, studies have shown that GI-registered products such as "Boseong" green tea in South Korea have experienced increased production and market competitiveness due to their enhanced reputation (Suh & MacPherson, 2007). Similarly, agricultural products with GI tags in China have seen improved market performance, which can be replicated for Aranmula Kanadi (Yang et al., 2024).
Employment Generation and Rural Development
The GI registration of Aranmula Kanadi can contribute to rural development by generating employment opportunities in production, processing, and marketing. Research indicates that GIs help in creating sustainable livelihoods for rural communities by preserving traditional industries (Shafi, 2022) (Sood & Sharma, 2024). For example, the registration of GI products in India has been shown to alleviate rural poverty by promoting agricultural development and industry agglomeration (Zhang et al., 2024).
Promotion of Local Industries and Tourism
Aranmula Kanadi's GI registration can also promote local industries and tourism. GI products often attract tourists who are interested in experiencing the cultural and historical significance of the product. This phenomenon has been observed in regions like Hami City, where GI-tagged agricultural products have boosted tourism and enhanced the local brand image (Yang et al., 2024). Similarly, the unique traditional knowledge associated with Aranmula Kanadi can be leveraged to create tourism experiences, further stimulating the local economy.
Cultural Impact
Preservation of Cultural Heritage
The GI registration of Aranmula Kanadi plays a crucial role in preserving the cultural heritage associated with its production. GIs are recognized for their ability to protect traditional knowledge and cultural practices, which are often passed down through generations. For example, the registration of GI products in India and Thailand has been shown to preserve traditional methods of production and cultural heritage (Jena et al., 2015). Aranmula Kanadi's unique manufacturing process, which involves traditional metal alloy techniques, is likely to be safeguarded through its GI status.
Promotion of Traditional Knowledge
The GI registration of Aranmula Kanadi also promotes the traditional knowledge embedded in its production. This is particularly important in the context of globalization, where traditional products often face competition from mass-produced alternatives. Studies have highlighted the role of GIs in preserving and promoting traditional knowledge, which is essential for maintaining cultural identity (Yadav, 2024) (Pick, 2022).
Community Identity and Pride
The GI registration of Aranmula Kanadi can foster a sense of community identity and pride among local residents. GIs often become symbols of regional identity, as they are deeply rooted in the history and culture of the area. For instance, the registration of "Boseong" green tea in South Korea has enhanced the regional identity and reputation of the product (Suh & MacPherson, 2007). Similarly, Aranmula Kanadi's GI status can serve as a source of pride for the local community, reinforcing their cultural heritage.
Community Development Impact
Empowerment of Local Producers
The GI registration of Aranmula Kanadi empowers local producers by providing them with a competitive edge in the market. GIs ensure quality assurance and authenticity, which can increase consumer trust and willingness to pay a premium price for the product. This empowerment is particularly significant for small-scale producers, who often struggle to compete with larger industries. Research has shown that GIs can help smaller producers survive in a globalized market by leveraging regional ethnocentrism and consumer preferences for local products (Priyanka & Vimala, 2021) (Eliasson, 2022).
Social Cohesion and Community Engagement
The GI registration of Aranmula Kanadi can also foster social cohesion by bringing the community together around a shared cultural asset. The production process of Aranmula Kanadi, which may involve collective efforts and traditional practices, can strengthen social bonds and community engagement. Studies have highlighted the role of GIs in promoting social benefits, such as improved living conditions and poverty alleviation, particularly in rural areas (Shafi, 2022) (Yadav, 2024).
Sustainable Development and Resource Conservation
The GI registration of Aranmula Kanadi can contribute to sustainable development by promoting the sustainable use of local resources. GIs often encourage the conservation of biodiversity and the use of environmentally friendly practices, as seen in the case of GI-tagged products in developing countries (Shafi, 2022) (Yadav, 2024). The sustainable production of Aranmula Kanadi can help preserve the local environment while supporting the livelihoods of the community.
Challenges and Considerations
Barriers to GI Benefits
While the GI registration of Aranmula Kanadi offers numerous benefits, there are challenges that need to be addressed. Research has identified barriers such as inefficient institutions, organizational problems, and power asymmetry, which can prevent producers from fully benefiting from GI registration (Eliasson, 2022). Additionally, the appropriation of value by more powerful actors in the supply chain can undermine the benefits for local producers (Eliasson, 2022).
Need for Effective Governance and Policy Support
The success of Aranmula Kanadi's GI registration depends on effective governance and policy support. This includes the formulation of public policies that address the specific needs of the product and the community. Research has emphasized the importance of strong legal frameworks and governance systems to ensure the effective protection and promotion of GIs (Shafi, 2022) (Martins et al., 2024).
Balancing Commercialization and Authenticity
The commercialization of Aranmula Kanadi must be balanced with the need to maintain its authenticity and cultural integrity. Over-commercialization can lead to the dilution of the product's unique qualities and the loss of its cultural significance. This challenge has been observed in other GI-registered products, where the pressure to meet market demands can compromise traditional practices (Singh & Bhatt, 2024) (Peredriy et al., 2024).
Table 1. Key Impacts of Aranmula Kanadi's GI Registration.
Sustainable Futures of Aranmula Kanadi: Tradition Meets Innovation
Aranmula Kanadi, a traditional mirror crafted from metal alloys, holds potential applications in promoting sustainability through its unique production process and cultural significance. The crafting of Aranmula Kanadi involves traditional methods that emphasize resource efficiency and minimal environmental impact, aligning with sustainable practices. The future prospects of Aranmula Kanadi in sustainability can be explored through its integration with modern technologies and its role in cultural preservation. This transition to the potential applications and future prospects of Aranmula Kanadi in sustainability is explored in the following sections.
Traditional Craftsmanship and Resource Efficiency
- Aranmula Kanadi is crafted using a unique blend of copper and tin, which are melted and polished to create a reflective surface. This process is resource-efficient as it utilizes locally sourced materials and traditional techniques that minimize waste.
- The production of Aranmula Kanadi does not involve harmful chemicals or processes, making it an environmentally friendly alternative to conventional glass mirrors, which often involve energy-intensive manufacturing and chemical coatings (Applications and Future Prospects of Biosurfactants, 2022).
Cultural Significance and Sustainable Tourism
- The cultural heritage associated with Aranmula Kanadi can be leveraged to promote sustainable tourism. By attracting tourists interested in traditional crafts, local economies can benefit while preserving cultural practices.
- Sustainable tourism initiatives can include workshops and demonstrations of the mirror-making process, providing educational opportunities and raising awareness about sustainable practices (Aboukhousa et al., 2024).
Integration with Modern Technologies
- The integration of modern technologies, such as AI and IoT, can enhance the production and distribution of Aranmula Kanadi. For instance, AI can optimize resource use and improve the efficiency of the crafting process, reducing the environmental footprint (Bansode et al., 2024) (Parameshwari & Gnanaguru, 2024).
- Smart technologies can also be used to monitor and manage the supply chain, ensuring that the materials used are sustainably sourced and that the production process adheres to environmental standards (Bogunovich, 2002).
Future Prospects in Sustainable Development
- Aranmula Kanadi can play a role in sustainable development by serving as a model for other traditional crafts. Its production process can inspire innovations in other sectors, such as textiles and agriculture, where traditional methods can be combined with modern technologies to enhance sustainability (Gautam et al., 2021) (Rahaman et al., n.d.).
- The promotion of Aranmula Kanadi can also contribute to the achievement of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) by fostering economic growth, cultural preservation, and environmental sustainability (Nasir et al., 2022) (Omer, 2014).
While Aranmula Kanadi presents promising opportunities for promoting sustainability, challenges remain in scaling its production and integrating it with modern technologies. The preservation of traditional craftsmanship must be balanced with the need for innovation and efficiency. Additionally, consumer awareness and acceptance of sustainable products like Aranmula Kanadi are crucial for its success in the global market. Addressing these challenges requires collaboration between artisans, policymakers, and technology developers to ensure that traditional crafts can thrive in a sustainable future.
Myth, Aesthetics, and Cultural Identity of Kerala
The Aranmula Kanadi, a unique metal mirror from Kerala, holds significant cultural and mythological importance. Its origins are deeply rooted in the traditions and beliefs of the region, reflecting the intricate interplay between mythology, aesthetics, and cultural identity. The mirror is not just a functional object but a symbol of Kerala's rich heritage, embodying the state's artistic and spiritual dimensions. The mythological origins and aesthetic dimensions of the Aranmula Kanadi contribute to its cultural significance in Kerala through various aspects.
Mythological Origins
- Connection to Deities: The Aranmula Kanadi is believed to be associated with the temple of Aranmula Parthasarathy, dedicated to Lord Krishna. The mirror is often linked to the divine, with legends suggesting that it was crafted for the deity's adornment, thus imbuing it with sacred significance (Karasinski, 2020).
- Cultural Myths: The mythology surrounding the mirror is intertwined with the broader cultural narratives of Kerala, such as the stories of Mahabali and Vamana, which emphasize themes of prosperity and divine intervention. These myths are celebrated during the Onam festival, highlighting the mirror's role in the cultural tapestry of the region (Kuriakose & Soreng, 2020) (Moncy, 2021).
Aesthetic Dimensions
- Craftsmanship: The Aranmula Kanadi is renowned for its unique manufacturing process, which involves a secretive alloy of metals polished to create a reflective surface. This craftsmanship is a testament to the traditional skills passed down through generations, reflecting the aesthetic values of precision and beauty (Joseph & R., 2024).
- Symbolism in Design: The mirror's design often incorporates motifs and patterns that are significant in Kerala's artistic traditions, such as those seen in the Thidambu Nritham and other ritualistic performances. These designs are not merely decorative but carry symbolic meanings related to fertility, prosperity, and divine presence (Puthumana & Puthumana, 2021).
Cultural Significance
- Ritualistic Importance: The Aranmula Kanadi is often used in religious and cultural ceremonies, symbolizing purity and clarity. Its presence in rituals underscores its role as a conduit between the material and spiritual worlds, much like the sacred groves and serpent worship practices in Kerala (B, 2024) (Guillebaud, 2004).
- Cultural Identity: The mirror is a cultural emblem of Kerala, representing the state's artistic heritage and spiritual beliefs. It is a part of the broader cultural practices that include dance, music, and visual arts, all of which contribute to the region's unique identity (Debnath, 2022).
While the Aranmula Kanadi is deeply embedded in the cultural and mythological fabric of Kerala, it also faces challenges in the modern era. The rapid urbanization and changing socio-economic conditions pose threats to traditional crafts and practices. However, efforts to preserve and promote these cultural artifacts continue, highlighting their enduring significance in Kerala's cultural landscape. The mirror, thus, remains a symbol of resilience and continuity amidst change.
Challenges and Opportunities in the Production and Market Demand of Aranmula Kanadi
The production and market demand of Aranmula Kanadi, a traditional handcrafted mirror from Kerala, face several challenges that are common to other artisanal and agricultural products. These challenges include issues related to production efficiency, market access, and consumer awareness. The constraints faced by Aranmula Kanadi producers can be understood by examining similar challenges in other sectors, such as handicrafts, agriculture, and traditional industries.
Production Challenges
- Resource Scarcity and Cost: Similar to the handmade paper industry, Aranmula Kanadi production may face challenges related to the availability and cost of raw materials. The scarcity of traditional materials and the high cost of production inputs can hinder efficient production (Bayram, 2022).
- Skill and Knowledge Gaps: Like the sesame and khoya producers, Aranmula Kanadi artisans may struggle with a lack of skilled labor and technical knowledge, which are crucial for maintaining the quality and authenticity of the product (Krishna et al., 2024) (Goswami, 2023).
- Production Efficiency: The production of Aranmula Kanadi, akin to baijiu, may suffer from low production efficiency and inconsistent quality, which can affect the overall output and market competitiveness (Tottoli, 2023).
Market Demand Challenges
- Market Access and Pricing: Artisans often face difficulties in accessing markets and securing fair prices for their products. This is a common issue in the handicraft sector, where market mechanisms are often inefficient, leading to low prices and delayed payments (Dalal et al., 2023).
- Consumer Awareness and Demand: Limited consumer awareness and demand for traditional products like Aranmula Kanadi can be a significant barrier. This is similar to the challenges faced by sesame producers, where low demand and inadequate market mechanisms affect profitability (Krishna et al., 2024).
- Competition and Modern Alternatives: The handloom industry illustrates how traditional products face competition from modern, mass-produced alternatives, which can lead to a decline in demand for handcrafted items like Aranmula Kanadi (Maulik, 2021).
Broader Perspectives
While these challenges are significant, there are opportunities for overcoming them through strategic interventions. For instance, enhancing market linkages and consumer awareness, as suggested for sesame and arecanut producers, can improve market demand and pricing for Aranmula Kanadi (Krishna et al., 2024) (Premalatha et al., 2024). Additionally, adopting modern production techniques and diversifying product offerings, as seen in the handloom and handmade paper industries, can help sustain traditional crafts in a competitive market (Bayram, 2022) (Maulik, 2021). These strategies highlight the potential for traditional industries to adapt and thrive despite the challenges they face.
Suggestions:
Expand Literature Integration: Incorporate more comparative analyses with other GI-tagged traditional crafts in India and globally to broaden context. As the other sustaining traditions and empowered communities across India demanding protection of their rights (Kumar, R., & Singh, T. G. (2025).
Visual Documentation: Include photographs or diagrams of the mirror-making process and finished products for better illustration.
Quantitative Data: Add data on employment statistics, economic impact, or tourism revenue post-GI registration to strengthen arguments.
Future Scope Section: A dedicated section on future research avenues—such as digital marketing for GI crafts or youth engagement programs—would enrich the paper.
Policy Recommendations: Propose clear policy interventions such as tax incentives, dedicated artisan hubs, or government craft fairs.
Legal Framework Analysis: Include brief insights on IP law (e.g., GI Act 1999 in India) to ground the discussion in legal scholarship. Linking theory and practice in legal training can leverage University Incubation Centres for Clinical Legal Education (Yadav, R. K. 2025). Study of clinical legal education in India and the role of positive psychology in achieving the global goal of access to justice can also be helpful in policy making (Yadav, R. K., & Ghanghash, S. 2022).
Gender Dimension: Highlight the role of women artisans (if applicable) in the craft’s continuity and community development.
Sustainability Metrics: Apply a sustainability framework (e.g., SDGs) to evaluate environmental benefits more systematically.
Cross-disciplinary Insight: Use perspectives from anthropology, material science, and economics to enrich the interdisciplinary appeal.
Language Diversity: If possible, integrate local terms or artisan testimonials (translated) to reflect the community’s voice. Legal Aid Clinics can play an important role in bridging this gap of language barrier. The power of storytelling in clinical legal education can enhance advocacy, empathy, and legal skills (Yadav, R. K. 2025). IPR violation cases are increasing as per NCRB reports ( Rahul, S. K., & Yadav, R. K. 2025).
Curriculum Integration: Enhancing the skills required for effective clinical legal education and their integration into law school curriculum can spread awareness among local people for transferring traditional knowledge to future generations and protection of geographical indications (Yadav, R. K. 2025). Insights from experienced legal professionals can train law students in protecting community rights (Yadav, R. K. 2025).
Conclusion
The Aranmula Kanadi, a living tradition in Kerala, is threatened by modern challenges such as market competition, resource depletion, and fading artisan interest. To protect it, a coordinated approach involving policy support, community engagement, technological integration, and academic documentation is needed. The GI registration of Aranmula Kanadi can significantly impact the local economy, cultural preservation, and community development by enhancing market value, generating employment, and promoting traditional knowledge. However, addressing inefficient institutions, power imbalances, and effective governance is crucial to ensure equitable distribution and sustained benefits. As a beacon of India's intangible heritage, it calls for deeper appreciation and urgent action to ensure its transmission to future generations.
References
- Panicker, J. J., John, A. E., & Chandrasekharan, N. A. (2024). A tapestry of tradition: Revitalization of Indian Heritage and Folk Art. The Scientific Temper. [CrossRef]
- Halder, A. K., & Zheng, G. (2023). The Cultural Ecological Adaptation and Contemporary Development of Folk Sport: A Systematic Investigation Based on the Harvest Festival (Onam) Custom of Snake Boat Race (Vallam Kali) at Aranmula Village in Southern India. Journal of the Anthropological Survey of India. [CrossRef]
- Kaur, M. (2024). Indian art and religion. ShodhKosh Journal of Visual and Performing Arts. [CrossRef]
- Baruah, S. (2022). Indian Devotional Music: Its Relation with the Religious Concept of People and Iconography. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, M. R., & Pandey, S. (2024). Contribution of folk arts in the promotion of Indian culture. ShodhKosh Journal of Visual and Performing Arts. [CrossRef]
- Srinivasan, S. (2020). Metal Craft Heritage of Cauvery and Riverine Regions (NIAS/HUM/HSS/U/RR/02/2020).
- Kumar, R., & Singh, T. G. (2025). Yu Wine: Sustaining Tradition and Empowering Communities in Manipur. Preprints. [CrossRef]
- Srinivasan, S., & Glover, I. (2007). Skilled mirror craft of intermetallic delta high-tin bronze (Cu31Sn8, 32.6% tin) from Aranmula, Kerala.Current Science.
- Hegde, K. T. M. (1991). Ancient Indian iron metallurgy.
- Gandhi, S. M. (2014). Copper, zinc, lead ores — Their exploitation and metal extraction by the ancients in the northwestern India.Journal of The Geological Society of India. [CrossRef]
- Agasti, N., & Pani, B. (2023). Chemistry of ancient materials of iron in India.Applied Surface Science Advances. [CrossRef]
- Nagae, T., Srinivasan, S., Ranganathan, S., Pillai, R. M., Shimizu, Y., & Mifune, H. (2014). Thermographical Analysis of Continuing Tradition of Mirror Casting in Kerala.Isij International. [CrossRef]
- Tiwari, Dr. S. (n.d.). “Preserving the Legacy: Documenting Kashmiri Traditional Crafts for Cultural Continuity and Innovation.”.
- Rivas, R. D. (2018). La artesanía : patrimonio e identidad cultural. [CrossRef]
- Suharson, A. (2024). Regenerasi Pengrajin Gerabah Perempuan di Pundong, Kasongan, dan Bayat dalam Mempertahankan NilaiNilai Kearifan Lokal Budaya Jawa.Panggung. [CrossRef]
- NamGoong, S., Jeong, S.-K., & Kim, T.-H. (2010). Traditional Crafts for the use of Modern Technology. The Journal of the Korea Contents Association. [CrossRef]
- Structural Analysis of Heritage Timber Structure. (2022). [CrossRef]
- Janků, M. (2017). The Lisbon Treaty and Changes in the Legal Rules on the Common Commercial Policy.EU Agrarian Law. [CrossRef]
- Woolcock, S. (2010). The Treaty of Lisbon and the European Union as an actor in international trade.
- Dimopoulos, A. (2010). The Effects of the Lisbon Treaty on the Principles and Objectives of the Common Commercial Policy. European Foreign Affairs Review.
- Pollet-Fort, A. (2010). Implications of the Lisbon Treaty on EU External Trade Policy. EU Centre Background Brief No. 2, March 2010.
- Dimopoulos, A. (n.d.). The Effects of the Lisbon Treaty on the Principles and Objectives of the Common Commercial Policy. [CrossRef]
- Dimopoulos, A. (2008). The common commercial policy after lisbon: establishing parallelism between internal and external economic relations? [CrossRef]
- Suh, J., & MacPherson, A. (2007). The impact of geographical indication on the revitalisation of a regional economy: a case study of ‘Boseong’ green tea Area. [CrossRef]
- Yang, R., Liang, Z., Jin, H., & Chen, F. (2024). Geographical indication agricultural products promote the development of local tourism economy. Frontiers in Humanities and Social Sciences. [CrossRef]
- Shafi, M. (2022). Geographical indications and sustainable development of handicraft communities in developing countries. The Journal of World Intellectual Property. [CrossRef]
- Sood, E., & Sharma, Y. (2024). Geographical Indicators as Tools of Economic Development. Indian Journal of Public Administration. [CrossRef]
- Zhang, S., Sun, Y., & Wang, Y. (2024). Geographical indication, agricultural development and the alleviation of rural relative poverty.Sustainable Development. [CrossRef]
- Jena, P. R., Ngokkuen, C., Rahut, D. B., & Grote, U. (2015). Geographical indication protection and rural livelihoods: insights from India and Thailand.Asian-Pacific Economic Literature. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, A. (2024a). Geographical Indication As A Tool For Revitalizing Endangered Traditions And Sustaining Livelihoods. [CrossRef]
- Pick, B. (2022). Intellectual Property and Development. [CrossRef]
- Priyanka, U., & Vimala, Dr. V. (2021). Geographical Indicated (GI) Products of the Regional Ethnocentrism of Kerala Prudently Influences Consumer Behaviour. [CrossRef]
- Eliasson, M. N. (2022). The benefits and barriers of geographical indications to producers: A review. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, A. (2024b). Social Dynamics of Geographical Indications: Community Empowerment and Collective Identity. International Journal of All Research Education and Scientific Methods. [CrossRef]
- Martins, L. O. S., Oliveira, V., Lora, F. A., Fraga, I. B., Saldanha, C. B., Silva, D. T., Pereira, M. G. A., & Silva, M. S. (2024). Geographic Indications, Sustainability and Sustainable Development: A Bibliometric Analysis. Journal of Scientometric Research. [CrossRef]
- Singh, P., & Bhatt, V. (2024). Leveraging Geographical Indications for Tourism Development and Destination Branding. Advances in Hospitality, Tourism and the Services Industry (AHTSI) Book Series. [CrossRef]
- Peredriy, O., Pakholiuk, O., & Golodyuk, G. (2024). Systems of goods geographical indications: EU and Ukraine experience. Tovaroznavčij Vìsnik. [CrossRef]
- Applications and Future Prospects of Biosurfactants. (2022). [CrossRef]
- Aboukhousa, H., Hassan, M., & Badran, M. (2024). Empowering environmental sustainability: Islamic values and their synergy with the SDGs. Journal of Infrastructure, Policy and Development. [CrossRef]
- Bansode, S. S., Hiremath, R., & Hiremath, G. R. (2024). Promoting Sustainability. [CrossRef]
- Parameshwari, M., & Gnanaguru, G. (2024). Artificial Intelligence for Climate Sustainability: A Comprehensive Review of Applications, Challenges, and Future Prospects. [CrossRef]
- Bogunovich, D. (2002). Eco-tech cities: Smart metabolism for a green urbanism. [CrossRef]
- Gautam, K., Rajvanshi, M., Chugh, N., Dixit, R. B., Kumar, G. R. K., Kumar, C., Sagaram, U. S., & Dasgupta, S. (2021). Microalgal applications toward agricultural sustainability: Recent trends and future prospects. [CrossRef]
- Rahaman, Md. T., Khan, Md. S. H., & Hasan, Md. K. (n.d.). Eco-innovation in Organic Phase Change Materials for Thermoregulatory Textiles: Sources, Applications, Fabrications, and Future Prospects Towards Sustainability. [CrossRef]
- Nasir, N. A. N. M., Zakarya, I. A., Kamaruddin, S. B. A., & Islam, A. K. M. S. (2022). Advances and Future Prospects on Biotechnological Approaches Towards Azolla for Environmental Sustainability. Pertanika Journal of Tropical Agricultural Science. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, A., Yadav, R. K., Singh, V. P., Rajpurohit, G. S., & Singh, S. (2025). Recognition to Implementation: Bridging the Gap in Moral Rights Protection under Indian Copyright Law. Journal of Intellectual Property Rights (JIPR), 30(3), 295-303.
- Omer, A. M. (2014). Clean and Green Energy Technologies, Sustainable Development, and Environment. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, Raj Kumar, The Langdell Method in Clinical Legal Education: Origins, Development, and Criticism (February 19, 2025). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=5144269.
- Karasinski, M. (2020). A Goddess Who Unites and Empowers: Śrīvidyā as a Link Between Tantric Traditions of Modern Kerala—Some Considerations.Journal of Indian Philosophy. [CrossRef]
- Kuriakose, H., & Soreng, E. (2020). Myth of Vamana and Mahabali: Jungian approach to the origin of Onam festival. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, Raj Kumar, Enhancing Clinical Legal Education Through Drafting Skills: A Focus on Intellectual Property Rights and Beyond (February 28, 2025). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=5159770.
- Moncy, A. A. (2021). The Myth of Resurrection: Reimagining Mahabali through the Semiotics of Select Folk Songs. [CrossRef]
- Joseph, P., & R., S. R. (2024). The costume and decorations of sree muthappan cult of north malabar in kerala with special refernce to eruvessy- the birth place of sree muthappan.ShodhKosh Journal of Visual and Performing Arts. [CrossRef]
- Puthumana, G. N., & Puthumana, G. (2021). Cultural Identity and Aesthetics in Indian Folk Dance Thidambu Nritham: A Performance Outlook. [CrossRef]
- Rahul, S. K., & Yadav, R. K. (2025). The Copyright Quandary: Criminalization and Judicial Backlog in India. Journal of Intellectual Property Rights (JIPR), 30(2), 188-196.
- B, D. (2024). The Sacred Groves of the Serpent Gods: ‘Sarpakavus’ of Kerala as Indigenous Ecology. Rupkatha Journal on Interdisciplinary Studies in Humanities. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, Raj Kumar, Training Law Students in Arbitration: Clinical Legal Education and Insights from Veteran Legal Professionals (March 01, 2025). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=5160965.
- Guillebaud, C. (2004). De la musique au dessin de sol et vice-versa. Un répertoire kéralais de formes sonores et graphiques. [CrossRef]
- Debnath, D. (2022). P. K. Rosy and Devaki Bai. [CrossRef]
- Bayram, J. M. (2022). Handmade Paper Industry: A Green and Sustainable Enterprise and Its Challenges. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, R. K., & Ghanghash, M. S. (2022). Role of Positive Psychology in Achieving Global Aim of Access to Justice: A Study of Clinical Legal Education in India. SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS, 1(43).
- Krishna, K. C., Vijayan, A., Kuruvila, A., B, Lovely., & Gopinath, P. P. (2024). Challenges in Sesame Production and Marketing: Insights from Kerala’s Onattukara Region, India. [CrossRef]
- Goswami, B. G. (2023). Ranking of the Constraints Faced by the Khoya Producers in Production and Marketing of Khoya, in Almora District of Uttarakhand, India. International Journal of Environment and Climate Change. [CrossRef]
- Tottoli, R. (2023). Challenges and Perspectives (Strategies). [CrossRef]
- Yadav, Raj Kumar (2025) The Power of Storytelling in Clinical Legal Education: Enhancing Advocacy, Empathy, and Legal Skills (February 26, 2025). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=5155478.
- Dalal, A. S., Bhattacharya, S., & Chattopadhyay, S. (2023). Hurdles to handicraft marketing for artisan entrepreneurs in an emerging economy. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, Raj Kumar (2025). Leveraging University Incubation Centers for Clinical Legal Education: Bridging Theory and Practice in Legal Training (February 26, 2025). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=5155471.
- Maulik, S. R. (2021). Handloom—The Challenges and Opportunities. [CrossRef]
- Yadav, Raj Kumar (2025). Essential Skills for Effective Clinical Legal Education and Their Integration into the Curriculum (March 04, 2025). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=5164165 or. [CrossRef]
- Premalatha, K., H.L, S., Sharma, K. K., & Nayak, M. M. (2024). Cultivating arecanut in India: challenges, opportunities and sustainable practices. Madras Agricultural Journal. [CrossRef]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2025 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.
