2.2.1. Data Sources
1.Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and VHI: To understand how the communities in Sigor and Kacheliba develop resilience and adapt in the face of 'extreme' and 'severe' weather events, GIS was useful in the mapping of the West Pokot County and the area at hand and using satellite imageries from the period 1990 to 2022. Landsat images utilized in this study comprise high-resolution satellite imagery sourced from the U.S. Geological Survey website 60. These images, characterized by a spatial resolution of 30 m, are provided in a standardized, orthorectified format. This study encompassed the entire twelve-month period, a necessity driven by the prolonged duration of drought disaster events. The analysis of vegetation health using the Vegetation Health Index (VHI) in Google Earth Engine (GEE) comprised several processing steps [
43]. Initially, satellite imagery from Landsat was imported. Images with a substantial cloud cover percentage were excluded to ensure that datasets from four distinct satellites accurately represented the land surface without interference from clouds. Following the application of cloud masking, the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) or the Vegetation Health Index (VHI) was calculated. This data was processed using GIS to pinpoint areas most affected by these climatic extremes.
2.Meteorological Trends: Accurate data on precipitation and temperature play a pivotal role in monitoring drought conditions, exerting profound impacts on agriculture, water supplies, and ecosystems. Precipitation data provides insights into the moisture quantity within an environment, aiding in assessing whether an area receives sufficient rainfall to sustain plant growth and replenish water sources. Conversely, temperature data influences the rates of evaporation and transpiration, delineating the speed at which available moisture may be lost. The integration of these two data types empowers scientists and policymakers to gauge the severity and duration of drought conditions. By closely scrutinizing these factors, informed decisions about water distribution, agricultural practices, and disaster preparedness can be made, ensuring communities are equipped to respond effectively to drought challenges. Climate Hazard Infrared Precipitation Stations (CHIRPS) data from UCSB were employed in both study areas (CHIROS), while temperature data were extracted from the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting fifth reanalysis [62, 63].
3. Survey Design: The survey is designed to delve into the intricate web of impacts that drought imposes on farming systems and communities within the West Pokot region of Kenya. Its overarching goal is to offer a comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted dimensions of drought, spanning the climatic, socio-economic, and meteorological realms. By focusing on these interrelated factors, the survey endeavors to unearth spatial correlations and resilience strategies crucial for mitigating the adverse effects of drought.
Geographically, the survey zooms in on areas profoundly affected by extreme drought, specifically targeting the regions of Kacheliba and Sigor. See the maps in
Figure 1 deriving from Humanitarian Exchange [
61]. These locations serve as microcosms of the broader challenges faced by communities grappling with erratic weather patterns and diminishing agricultural yields.
Methodologically, the survey adopts a structured approach, leveraging closed-ended questions to systematically gather data across various domains. It encompasses inquiries into demographics, agricultural practices, livestock rearing, crop cultivation, and adaptive measures employed by farmers to withstand drought-induced adversities. The utilization of Kobo Collect as the survey platform ensures not only the efficiency of data collection but also stringent quality control measures to uphold the integrity and reliability of the findings [
64].
In terms of participation, the survey aims to engage a representative sample of farmers hailing from the target regions. By ensuring inclusivity and diversity in participant selection, the survey endeavors to paint a holistic picture reflective of the broader community’s experiences and perspectives regarding drought resilience and adaptation strategies. Through this comprehensive approach, the survey endeavors to equip stakeholders with actionable insights and evidence-based recommendations to bolster resilience and foster sustainable agricultural practices in drought-prone regions like West Pokot, Kenya.
Participant selection is designed to ensure inclusivity and diversity, thereby enriching the survey’s findings with a broad spectrum of perspectives and experiences. One approach to achieving this is through proportional representation based on sub-locations, wherein participants are selected from various geographical areas within Kacheliba and Sigor. This method ensures that voices from different communities and demographic backgrounds are heard, thereby enhancing the representativeness of the data collected. Additionally, efforts are made to engage with community leaders and local organizations to facilitate outreach to marginalized groups, ensuring their inclusion in the survey process. Through these deliberate measures, the survey strives to capture the diversity inherent in the farming communities of West Pokot, Kenya, fostering a more nuanced understanding of the impacts of drought and the resilience strategies employed across different segments of the population.
4. Focused Group Discussions (FGDs): served as a complementary tool to the structured surveys, providing a nuanced exploration of farmers’ perceptions and experiences of drought [65-67]. Discussions centered on coping mechanisms employed, challenges faced in daily life and long-term planning, and potential solutions for building community resilience. Eight FGDs were meticulously conducted, specifically targeting farmers from extremely vulnerable sub-location communities to ensure a representative sample reflecting the diversity within the region’s farming population. Participant recruitment took into account the demographic composition of the farmer population, along with the documented impacts of drought on their livelihoods, ensuring inclusivity across various age groups and gender identities. FGDs served as a platform for participants to share their experiences, insights, and concerns regarding drought resilience, facilitating a deeper understanding of community perspectives and priorities [65-67]. Each FGD, comprising 8–10 participants, provided rich insights into the socio-economic, agro-pastoral, and meteorological impacts of drought on livelihoods, fostering discussions on community-based solutions for effective resilience. Thematic content analysis was employed to systematically analyze the transcripts.
Nvivo software facilitated this process by enabling efficient coding, organization, and visualization of the thematic data, ensuring accuracy and consistency in data interpretation [
67]. Furthermore, the targeted nature of FGDs ensured that a diverse range of voices, including men, women, young people, and the elderly, contributed to the discussions, enhancing the credibility and richness of the findings. Overall, FGDs complemented the survey findings by providing contextual insights and facilitating participatory approaches to resilience-building efforts, thereby strengthening the study’s credibility and relevance.
2.2.2. Exploratory Data Analysis
A combined quantitative and qualitative approach was employed to delve deeper into community challenges and their resilience to climate variability, as illustrated in
Figure 2. The quantitative analysis involved surveys that helped identify the impacts of extreme and severe droughts on livelihoods, including agricultural productivity, water scarcity, and changes in pastoral practices. This approach provided a broad overview of the economic and social stresses these communities face during such periods. Conversely, the qualitative analysis, which included focus group discussions, was crucial in understanding the community-based resilience and adaptation capacities.
1. VHI method
The Vegetation Health Index (VHI), a well-established indicator of drought disasters, is derived from the combination of the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and Land Surface Temperature (LST). The Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) is calculated by utilizing the reflectance values from the red and near-infrared bands, NDVI products derived from 'Landsat Surface Reflectance' are generated from scenes captured by Landsat 4–5 Thematic Mapper (TM), Landsat 7 Enhanced Thematic Mapper Plus (ETM+), and Landsat 8-9* Operational Land Imager (OLI)/Thermal Infrared Sensor (TIRS) in both Collection 1 and Collection 2. These scenes undergo processing to become Landsat Level-2 Surface Reflectance products. In Landsat 4, 5, and 7, the infrared data corresponds to band number 4, while in Landsat 8, it corresponds to band number 5. Ghaleb et al. [
2] express the NDVI computation using the formula (Eq. 1):
where Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) values range between – 1 and 1.
The VHI is calculated using remote sensing data, combining measures of vegetation cover, land surface temperature, and rainfall. Ghaleb et al. [
40] and Bento et al. [
68] developed the Vegetation Condition Index (VCI), the Temperature Condition Index (TCI), and the Vegetation Health Index (VHI) using the following Equations (2) – (4):
where NDVI,
, and
represent the seasonal average of the smoothed weekly NDVI, its multiyear absolute minimum, and its maximum, respectively, and
,
, and
represent similar values for the land surface temperature in Celsius.
The VHI values range from 0 to 100, with higher values indicating healthier vegetation. The index values were further aggregated over a yearly temporal window due to the desire to capture temporal trends of extended drought starting from 1990 in the targeted country of interest (Kenya). The data obtained were visualized using charts, maps, or time series plots to observe vegetation health trends. Further statistical and spatial analyses were conducted to quantify and interpret the trends in vegetation health over time.
Furthermore, the land surface temperature (LST) serves as an indicator of the Earth’s surface temperature, reflecting its warmth or coolness to the touch [
69]. In determining the LST, thermal bands were employed, with Ghaleb et al. [
40] noting that for Landsats 4, 5, and 7 it is the sixth band, while for Landsat 8 it involves bands 10–11. The sensors within the Satellite Thermal Infrared (TIR) category gauge top-of-the-atmosphere (TOA) radiances, enabling the derivation of brightness temperatures through the application of Plank’s law [
70]. Specifically focusing on Landsat 8 imagery, both bands 10 and 11 are accessible, but band 10 was favored due to calibration uncertainties associated with the band 11 Landsat 8 Thermal Infrared Sensor (TIRS).
Figure 3 below illustrates the VHI map process, focusing specifically on vegetated areas.
The VHI values are classified into different drought severity levels to assess the impact on agriculture [
71].
Table 1 shows the drought severity classification:
2. Quantitative (Surveys) Analysis
The surveys targeted 88 participants, focusing on analyzing livestock production, crop production, the impact of drought, and community resilience and adaptation strategies using Python for data processing and analysis. Various statistical analyses were conducted. Initially, frequency distributions were run for all variables to identify missing cases and understand the underlying reasons for these gaps. This method was particularly useful in providing a clear overview of crop and livestock production levels, as well as other drought-related empirical data.
To gain deeper insights into how the community responds to and manages drought conditions, cross-tabulations were performed to explore the relationships between different variables. This helped in understanding the intricate dynamics of community resilience and adaptation strategies in detail. Furthermore, linear regression analysis was employed to examine the relationship between community resilience, adaptation strategies, and livestock production at the household level. This analysis aimed to quantify how different resilience and adaptation strategies influenced the economic aspects of households, particularly through livestock production. By doing so, the research provided a more nuanced understanding of the socio-economic impact of drought on these communities and highlighted potential areas for intervention to enhance their resilience.
To ensure data integrity and analysis accuracy, we conducted a comprehensive data preprocessing phase using Python’s Pandas library. This involved handling missing data through techniques like imputation and deletion (considering potential biases from exclusion). We employed robust outlier detection and removal methods (z-scores, winsorization) [
72] from Pandas and SciPy libraries to mitigate their influence. Finally, the study performed data validation to ensure consistency and alignment with the study’s objectives, including cross-referencing [
73] with external sources where applicable.
Key variables were useful for the statistical analysis. The study first determined agricultural activity farmers engaged the most in Sigor and Kacheliba.
Figure 4 depicts that Mixed farming, encompassing both livestock rearing and crop cultivation is the prevalent activity of households with a proportion of 81.4%. This shows the community’s diverse farming activities. In addition, livestock rearing is the second most common activity, with a proportion of 12.8%. While only 5.8% of households practically engage in crop farming activity.
Furthermore, determining the frequency of livestock and crop production in
Table 2 and
Table 3 respectively revealed that Cows have a notable presence with a percentage of 72% of livestock holdings, demonstrating their importance to the regional agricultural economy. On the other hand, the Goat and Camel have a large percentage respectively of 96%, and 90%, this shows their importance in Livestock production and local cultures, and they are the two main types. Conversely, sheep have a small percentage of 52%. This distribution shows the variety of livestock farming in the area. Each of these livestock types provide various roles, ranging from producing dairy and meat to having cultural and financial importance.
Meanwhile, Maize has the most common crops. It makes up a large proportion of 97%. This indicates its crucial role in local agricultural practices. Sorghum follows, but to a lesser extent. It has a 51% presence. This reflects its importance as a staple food. On the other hand, Beans represent an important proportion of 73%. This proportion shows the big role of Beans in farm diversity and food security. While the other various minor types of crops have a 64% proportion.
With Pokot being nomad, the livestock herd size is a critical information requiring particular attention. The livestock herd size distribution, as shown in
Table 4, Kenya, indicates a predominance of small-scale livestock farming, with a smaller percentage of medium and large-scale herders. Due to repetitive drought disaster cases, limited access to veterinary services, high vulnerability to diseases and limited resources, small herds are more sustainable for households.
In West Pokot, Kenya, agricultural production relies on community resilience strategies to cope with environmental and economic challenges. The most common practices, as shown in
Table 5, include adopting modern agriculture techniques, practicing diverse grazing areas, using resilient livestock breeds, and diversifying income through business ventures. These strategies ensure consistent productivity, financial stability, and resilience against agricultural risks.
Furthermore, understanding the distribution of age and gender in the agricultural workforce of West Pokot is crucial for designing effective interventions. By addressing the specific needs of different age groups and supporting both women and men, the agricultural sector in West Pokot can be made more productive, sustainable, and resilient. The gender disparity in agricultural practices leans towards female farmers, with 53% being female and 47% male. This skew towards female-headed households has cultural roots. Culturally, women are more involved in crop production in West Pokot, often practiced near family households, while men are more involved in livestock farming, which typically takes place further from home, within a 10 km radius.
In the context of agricultural production in West Pokot, Kenya, the age distribution of the population in
Table 6 provides insights into labor availability, productivity, and the community resilience against an escalating threat of climatic extremes. The age distribution in West Pokot’s agricultural sector reveals a workforce with diverse age groups, each bringing different strengths and challenges. The presence of a large number of individuals in the 27-35 and 36-42 age intervals is a positive sign for current productivity. However, the relatively low number of young adults (18-26) suggests potential future labor shortages, likely due to the increased risk of agricultural losses. The significant number of older adults (50-80) highlights the importance of succession planning and the need to attract younger individuals to agriculture to sustain and advance the sector.
Table 7 reveals that over half of the population in West Pokot involved in agriculture has no formal education. An additional 20% of the agricultural population has some primary education but did not complete it. This high percentage suggests a reliance on traditional farming methods passed down through generations.
Overall, the diverse range of strategies employed by the community underscores the importance of adaptation in building resilience and mitigating the negative consequences of environmental stressors on their livelihoods
3. Qualitative (FGDs) Analysis
Focus Group Discussions (FGDs) were also utilized to capture farmers' perceptions and understanding of climate change and variability, as well as the community-based resilience and adaptation strategies employed in the face of these challenges. As stated by Eeuwijk and Angehan [
74], in the FGD, participants are encouraged to share their attitudes, perceptions, knowledge, and experiences, with an emphasis on practices that emerge during interactions with a diverse range of individuals [
74]. FGDs, typically comprising 8-10 participants, provided deep insights into the socio-economic, agro-pastoral, and meteorological impacts of drought on livelihoods.
Thematic content analysis was applied to distill and interpret the rich qualitative data gathered from the discussions. This method, facilitated by the use of NVivo software [
75], allowed for a systematic exploration of themes and patterns related to how communities perceive and respond to drought. By employing thematic content analysis, the study could effectively organize and analyze the complex layers of data, revealing the nuanced ways in which communities adapt to and cope with the adverse effects of drought. The integrated methodology, combining remote sensing, surveys, and FGDs, offers a comprehensive approach to assessing the impacts of drought and enhancing community resilience in West Pokot County. This approach ensures that the multifaceted nature of drought impacts and the varied strategies of community adaptation are thoroughly explored and understood.