3.1. Fabrication and Electrocatalytic Performance of MnO2/NF
Ultrathin MnO
2 nanosheet arrays supported on NF were utilized as a substrate for the deposition of NiCo-LDH. These MnO
2 nanosheet arrays were selected because of their easy synthesis, large accessible surface areas, as well as half-metallic electronic properties. SEM images (
Figure S2) confirm the formation of vertically aligned MnO
2 nanosheets on the surface of NF, which is consistent with our previous report [
21]. The bare NF and NF-supported MnO
2 nanosheet arrays were employed as substrates for the electrodeposition of the NiCo-LDH active layer from solutions containing nickel and cobalt nitrate salts. As depicted in
Equations (1) and (2), the deposition was triggered through the increase of local pH at the surface of the electrode as a result of the electrochemical reduction of nitrate ions.
The formation of NiCo-LDH over the MnO
2 was investigated using SEM. As shown in
Figure 1, when the deposition was carried out at the current density of -20 mA cm
-2 and kept for a short time of 50 s, a uniform coating of LDH nanosheets was observed on the surfaces of individual MnO
2 nanosheets. Importantly, there were still ample free spaces present among the MnO
2@NiCo-LDH hybrid nanosheets. However, as the deposition time increased, a continuous overcoating of LDH occurred. For example, after deposition for 150 s, nearly all the available spaces between the primary MnO
2 nanosheets were occupied with LDH, and concurrently, cracks started to form within the overall deposition layer. These cracks became more pronounced as the deposition time was further extended to 200 s. As a control, NiCo-LDH was also deposited on bare NF, and the SEM image reveals that the LDH nanosheets were organized into close-packed microspheres (
Figure S3).
With a hierarchical structure, the MnO
2@NiCo-LDH fabricated with a deposition time of 50 s was further investigated in TEM. The presence of vertically aligned NiCo-LDH over the MnO
2 sheets was clearly demonstrated by the emergence of conspicuous black strips observed atop the bulk nanosheets in the TEM image (
Figure 2a). Upon further analysis using high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM), distinct lattice fringes with a measured spacing of 0.46 nm (
Figure 2b) were observed. These fringes are indicative of the interlayer spacing of the (001) atomic planes of the hydroxide, as documented in the hydroxide's crystallographic database entry (PDF#73-1520). Notably, the selected area electron diffraction (SAED) pattern (
Figure 2c) exhibited exclusive diffraction rings that matched the δ-MnO
2 phase (PDF#80-1098), suggesting the low crystallinity of the hydroxide deposits. Moreover, the high-angle annular dark-field (HAADF) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) mapping images (
Figure 2d–g) provided compelling evidence of the homogeneous distribution of the Mn, Ni, and Co elements throughout the sample. The general atomic contents of these elements were determined to be 16.41 % (Mn), 7.13% (Ni), and 4.81% (Co) according to the EDS spectrum (
Figure S4).
The performance of MnO
2@NiCo-LDH for urea oxidation reaction (UOR) was assessed in a 1 M KOH solution containing 0.5 M urea. NiCo-LDH/NF, MnO
2/NF, and bare NF were used as reference catalysts. The LSV curves and potential statistics required to achieve specified current densities are presented in
Figure 3a,b, respectively. It is evident that the MnO
2@NiCo-LDH possesses a significantly improved performance for UOR compared to the reference catalysts. Notably, by enlarging the low current density region of the LSV curves (
Figure S5), the onset potential of MnO
2@NiCo-LDH was measured as 1.228 V vs. RHE. This value is below both the thermodynamic redox potential of the OER (1.230 V) and the onset potentials of NiCo-LDH/NF (1.267 V), MnO
2/NF (1.311 V), and bare NF (1.377 V). Significantly, when subjected to an applied potential of 1.5 V vs. RHE, the current density of MnO
2@NiCo-LDH impressively reaches 905 mA cm
-2. This value surpasses the current densities of NiCo-LDH/NF (398 mA cm
-2) and MnO
2/NF (337 mA cm
-2) by more than two-fold. Similarly, to achieve current densities of 10 and 100 mA cm
-2, the MnO
2@NiCo-LDH requires potentials of 1.261 and 1.326 V vs. RHE, respectively. These values represent a considerable reduction compared to the potentials required by the reference catalysts. Furthermore, they are on par with the most superior UOR catalysts reported in the literature [
20] (
Table S1), underscoring the exceptional electrochemical capability of MnO
2@NiCo-LDH. In addition, Tafel plots (
Figure 3c) were generated based on the LSV curves for analyzing the kinetics of the UOR on the different catalysts. MnO
2/NF displayed a Tafel slope of 45.8 mV dec
-1, indicating a rapid UOR rate. However, its overall performance was limited due to a high onset potential. On the other hand, NiCo-LDH/NF exhibited a small Tafel slope of 42.2 mV dec
-1 in the low potential region, but this slope significantly increased to 111.5 mV dec
-1 at higher applied potentials. This discontinuity is likely attributed to an increase in mass transport resistance caused by an insufficient exposed surface area at high potentials. In comparison to the aforementioned catalysts, MnO
2@NiCo-LDH demonstrated a relatively larger Tafel slope of 62.3 mV dec
-1, but this value remained consistent across the displayed potential range. These findings corroborate our hypothesis that the combination of high conductivity in MnO
2 nanosheets and the low onset potential of NiCo-LDH work synergistically to enhance the activity of the hybrid catalyst. The electrochemical surface areas of the catalysts were estimated by measuring their double-layer capacitance (C
dl) at the non-faradaic region through CV scanning at different rates. The definitive C
dl values were calculated as half of the slopes of the plots that depict the difference in current densities (Δj) between the anodic and cathodic scans against the scanning rate (
Figure 3d and Figure S6). The C
dl of MnO
2@NiCo-LDH reaches 4.03 mF cm
-2, which is almost twice that of MnO
2/NF (2.16 mF cm
-2) and 2.8 times that of NiCo-LDH (1.44 mF cm
-2). This significant increase in C
dl of MnO
2@NiCo-LDH reflects a much greater accessible surface area for the electrocatalytic reaction. Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) was employed to further explore the charge transport kinetics of the UOR. As shown in
Figure 3e, all the samples exhibit typical semicircular curves in their EIS, where the diameters of the semicircles reflect the charge transfer resistances (R
ct). MnO
2@NiCo-LDH has the smallest semicircle diameter, indicating a lowered R
ct at the catalyst/electrolyte interface. In previous studies, Botte et al. [
23,
24] proposed that the UOR process on nickel-based catalysts follows an indirect “electrochemical-chemical” (E-C) mechanism. Based on this mechanism, electrochemically generated Ni
3+ ions act as the active species responsible for the oxidation of adsorbed urea molecules. Therefore, the potential for the regeneration of Ni
2+ to Ni
3+ plays a crucial role in the catalytic process.
Figure 3f illustrates the cyclic voltammetry (CV) curves of MnO
2@NiCo-LDH and bare NF, revealing that the redox potential of Ni
2+/Ni
3+ in MnO
2@NiCo-LDH is shifted to a lower value compared to the pure nickel-based sample. This shift indicates that urea oxidation on MnO
2@NiCo-LDH can occur at a lower onset potential, consistent with the results obtained from the LSV curves of UOR.
XPS was employed to probe the possible change in the chemical states of the Ni and Co components during the electrolysis.
Figure 4a shows the high-resolution spectra of Ni 2p before and after the UOR test. The initial sample exhibit typical features of 2p
3/2 and 2p
1/2 and two satellites at the binding energy of 855.5, 873.3 eV, 861.5 and 879.3 eV, which signifies that the Ni has a valence state of 2+. Notable, after the UOR test, the Ni 2p presents no noticeable change in the valence state. In contrast, in the spectra of Co 2p (
Figure 4b), the 2p
3/2 component was shifted to a lower binding energy, and meanwhile, the satellite peaks were depleted, indicating the formation of Co
3+ species after UOR [
14]. During the UOR tests at the high potential region, both Ni
2+ and Co
2+ ions undergo partial oxidation, resulting in the formation of Ni
3+ and Co
3+ species, respectively. However, the Ni 2p spectrum of the sample after UOR revealed the absence of Ni
3+, indicating the rapid reduction of these high-valency species back to Ni
2+. The results obtained provide compelling evidence in favour of the indirect electrochemical (E-C) mechanism of UOR, where the electrochemically generated Ni
3+ species undergo a simultaneous reaction with urea molecules, leading to their reduction back to Ni
2+. Importantly, the regenerated Ni
2+ species can actively partake in subsequent cycles of the electrocatalysis process.
The samples obtained with longer deposition times (100 s, 150 s, 200 s) were also assessed as catalysts for the urea oxidation reaction (UOR). However, their performances were found to be subpar compared to the sample deposited for 50 s, particularly in the high-potential regions (Figure S7). This outcome is to be expected due to the presence of additional NiCo-LDH over-coatings, which exhibit poor conductivity and consequently impede the efficient transfer of electrons from the supporting electrode to the catalytic sites. Furthermore, these over-coatings obstruct the available space between the nanosheets, thereby impeding the mass-transport processes at the surfaces of the electrodes. These results also demonstrate that the designed hierarchical structure can facilitate the electrocatalysis.
Figure 5a shows a comparison of the LSV curves of NiCo-LDH deposited on MnO
2/NF with or without the addition of urea in the electrolyte. It is evident that the LSV curve for UOR (with urea) emerges at a lower potential region with a shift of up to 300 mV compared to that of OER (without urea). This finding suggests the great promise of adopting UOR as an alternative anodic reaction in energy-saving hydrogen production. Constant-current chronopotentiometry measurement was carried out to evaluate the stability of the catalyst.
Figure 5b displays the potential recorded for a time course of 20 h at the current densities of 10 and 100 mA cm
-2. As can be seen, the potential experienced only a slight change at each current density, indicating that the MnO
2@NiCo-LDH possesses excellent catalytic stability for UOR.