Carpal Dislocations
Carpal and carpometacarpal dislocations and fracture-dislocations are infrequent but are severe injuries, which can be overlooked both clinically and radiographically [
8]. This has a significant functional and economic impact, especially since these injuries occur most frequently in working-age young men. A detailed understanding of the normal anatomy and appearance of the carpometacarpal and intercarpal joints is essential to assess for pathology, most notably the scapholunate joint. The normal scapholunate joint space is less than 3 mm. Widening can be subtle, and up to 4 mm may be normal in some patients; however, if a scapholunate injury is suspected, a clenched fist stress view radiograph may be useful for dynamic assessment, as this will make widening of the joint space more conspicuous [
5].
Normal alignment of the carpus should always be assessed on neutral lateral view (
Figure 18) as previously described [
6]. In the normal wrist, a line can be drawn down the long axis of the radius that passes through the lunate, capitate, and metacarpals, with the radius cupping the lunate and the lunate cupping the capitate in a pillar-like fashion. Even with small amounts of projectional rotation, the biomechanical pillar along this line should remain intact. It is important to note that these intercarpal angles are only accurate on a “true” lateral view, when the pisiform is observed between the ventral surface of the capitate and distal pole of the scaphoid, ideally at the midpoint between these two structures.
The scapholunate angle is formed between a line drawn along the axis or volar surface of the scaphoid and a line through the axis of the lunate, with the normal range being 30-60° (
Figure 19) [
3]. The capitolunate angle is formed between the lunate axis line and a line through the axis of the capitate, with the normal range less than 30°, as these should be neutrally aligned (near 0°) in a normal wrist (
Figure 19) [
6,
13].
The intrinsic ligaments of the wrist are deep, interosseous ligaments, spanning between adjacent carpals. Many have components of both true ligaments (with collagenous fibers and fascicles), and functionally less important areas of fibrovascular or fibrocartilaginous tissue. These are intimately related to the extrinsic ligaments in most cases. The key intrinsic ligaments are the scapholunate ligament (SLL), the lunotriquetral ligament (LTL), and the scaphotrapeziotrapezoid ligament (STTL) [
12].
The scapholunate ligament can be thought of as having 3 separate components: proximal, dorsal, and volar (
Figure 20) [
2,
14]. Tears are often traumatic in etiology (e.g., fall on outstretched hand or FOOSH) and associated with symptoms. The proximal component is also known as the “central membranous component” due to its location and composition (
Figure 21A). Partial tears or degenerative perforations of this membranous portion are common and usually are asymptomatic. Typically, this portion has a triangular, meniscal projection distally (
Figure 21B, C). The dorsal component is the thickest and has the most significant role functionally (
Figure 22). The volar component is thin and weak, and therefore is not of great biomechanical importance and isolated injury is uncommon.
The lunotriquetral ligament can also be thought of as having 3 separate components as well: volar, dorsal, and proximal (
Figure 23) [
8,
14]. The volar component is the thickest and most functionally important part of the LTL (as opposed to the SLL whose main structural fascicles are dorsal), limiting triquetral extension (
Figure 24). The dorsal component of the LTL is thinner, but still more robust than the proximal membranous component which is again frequently triangular with a meniscal projection distally. The proximal membranous component has a range of MRI appearances that can be mistaken for tears or may not be detectable at all.
The extrinsic ligaments are those that arise from the radius and ulna and insert onto the carpal bones [
23,
24]. More attention is generally given to the intrinsic ligaments of the wrist by the radiologists; however, the validity of that approach is questionable and full attention should be paid to the extrinsic ligaments as well. These ligaments are grouped as the dorsal capsular, volar radiocarpal, volar ulnocarpal, and volar midcarpal ligaments.
The dorsal capsular ligaments (
Figure 25) include the dorsal radiocarpal ligament (DRCL) and dorsal intercarpal ligament (DIC). The dorsal radiocarpal ligament (DRCL) is also referred to as the dorsal radiotriquetral ligament [
24]. The DRCL extends from dorsal rim of the radius, between Lister tubercle and the sigmoid notch, to the dorsal triquetrum. This ligament has fibers continuous with the 4th and 5th extensor compartment septa. Variants of this ligament include various additional bands, one of which may cover the dorsal aspect of the proximal scaphoid. The dorsal intercarpal ligament (DIC) is also sometimes referred to as the dorsal scaphotriquetral ligament due to its attachments. The DIC ligament extends from the dorsal ridge of the triquetrum to the dorsal groove of the scaphoid and proximal rim of the dorsal aspect of the trapezium. Along its course some fibers attach to the dorsal distal lunate. The DIC ligament may have 1 or 2 distinct fascicles, and sporadically has fibers extending to the trapezoid and capitate.
The volar radiocarpal ligaments include the radial collateral ligament (RCL), radioscaphocapitate ligament (RSCL), short radiolunate ligament (SRL), and long radiolunate ligament (LRL) (
Figure 26). . The RCL extends from the radial styloid to the scaphoid head. The RSCL arises from the radial half of the volar rim of the scaphoid fossa. The RSCL attaches to the capitate, forming a sling across the scaphoid. Some fibers may attach to the scaphoid. The SRL anchors the lunate from the radial half of the volar cortex of the lunate to the volar rim of the lunate fossa of the radius. The LRL arises from the volar aspect of the ulnar half of the scaphoid fossa rim of the radius. Distally, the LRL attaches to the volar aspect of the lunate, with some fibers also attaching to the volar triquetrum, and therefore may also be known as the radiolunotriquetral ligament.
The volar ulnocarpal ligaments (
Figure 26) include the ulnolunate ligament (ULL), the ulnotriquetral ligament (UTL), and the ulnocapitate ligament (UCL) [
23,
24]. The ULL and UTL originate from the volar radiolunate ligament and attach distally to the volar surfaces of the lunate and the triquetrum, respectively. The UCL extends from the ulnar head to the capitate. The ULL and UTL, deeper to the UCL, is a single sheet of tissue arbitrarily divided according to their distal attachments.
Lastly, the volar midcarpal ligaments include the arcuate and deltoid ligaments that are further subdivided into radial and ulnar limbs. The scaphocapitate ligament (SCL) arises from the ulnar aspect of the distal pole of the scaphoid, deep to the RSCL, and extends to the volar capitate body. It represents the radial limb of the arcuate ligament. The triquetrohamocapitate ligament (THL) extends from the triquetrum to the capitate, across the hamate. It represents the ulnar limb of the arcuate ligament. Some describe this as the distal band of the palmar scaphotriquetral ligament, which is another mid-carpal capsular ligament superficial to the SCL and THL [
24,
25]. The distal RSCL represents the radial limb of the deltoid ligament and the UCL constitutes the ulnar limb of the deltoid ligament, supporting the head of the capitate [
25].
In general terms, carpal instability (CI) may be categorized as dissociative (CID), non-dissociative (CIND), combined/complex (CIC), or adaptive (CIA) [
18]. These groupings permit for additional explanation of injury patterns such as DISI and VISI. CID is the disruption of a normal relationship between carpals in the same row and can be thought of as intrinsic ligament failure. The proximal row CID is more common than the very rare distal row CID. Proximal row CID includes scapholunate dissociation (SLD) which is associated with DISI, and lunotriquetral dissociation (LTD) which is associated with VISI, unstable scaphoid fracture, and Kienböck disease. CIND is the disruption of the normal relationship between the distal and proximal carpal row (midcarpal pattern), or between radius and proximal carpal row (radiocarpal pattern). CIND can be thought of as an extrinsic ligament failure. CIC is a combination of these two, containing features of both CID and CIND, with disruption of a normal relationship between carpals in the same row and between rows. This includes perilunate dislocation and fracture-dislocation spectrum, isolated carpal bone dislocation, and axial carpal dislocations. CIA is defined as altered carpal function as a result of extra-carpal pathology, where altered carpal postures are not due to injury to the carpus itself. CIA includes Madelung deformity and distal radial fracture with malunion as an example [
19].
The various patterns of carpal instability exist as a spectrum which ranges from frankly obvious instability (acute fracture-dislocation) all the way to nearly normal with only a clinical complaint and normal imaging and physical exam. The Watson classification categorizes carpal instability in relation to imaging in five stages. Stage 0 is termed ‘normal’, described as an asymptomatic patient with normal function of the carpus. Stage 1 is termed ‘pre-dynamic’, described as wrist pain with symptoms of instability, however the imaging is normal. Stage 2 is termed ‘dynamic’, described as pain with dynamic or stress imaging demonstrating an imaging abnormality. Stage 3 is termed ‘static’, described as pain with abnormal imaging without stress. Stage 4 is termed ‘posttraumatic arthritis’, which includes scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse (SNAC) and scapholunate advanced collapse (SLAC).
Perilunate injury involves both intrinsic and extrinsic ligaments and results in a fairly predictable order of progression when the wrist is loaded in extension, ulnar deviation, and intercarpal supination. The typical history is a fall onto a dorsiflexed wrist (e.g. the FOOSH) and the injury progresses through 4 distinct stages depending on the magnitude of the traumatic force that it sustained. The first stage consists of scapholunate dissociation (
Figure 27A). As the scapholunate joint is disrupted, the scapholunate and radioscaphocapitate ligaments are injured, causing volar scaphoid rotation with or without dorsal rotation of the lunate, and scapholunate joint widening (
Figure 27B). The second stage consists of perilunate dislocation (
Figure 28). In this stage, the scapholunate injury found in the first stage is still present, but as the force is increased, this trauma has extended to involve the capitolunate ligament, which then allows the capitate to be dislocated. The third stage is again a progression of the prior stages in which the lunotriquetral ligament is disrupted in addition to the findings of second stage. Neither the capitate nor lunate is aligned with the distal radius, often referred to as a midcarpal dislocation. There is also interval development of widening/malalignment of the lunotriquetral and triquetrohamate joints, which is frequently associated with a volar triquetral fracture (
Figure 29). The fourth and final stage of injury results in tears/disruptions of all the ligaments surrounding the lunate including the dorsal radiocarpal ligament, resulting in palmar dislocation of the lunate (lunate dislocation). On PA radiographs, the lunate shows the classic “piece-of-pie” sign and on the lateral view, there is a “tipped teacup” appearance (
Figure 30).
The previously mentioned ligamentous perilunate injuries are considered “lesser arc” injuries, but each stage may occur as a greater arc injury, which has a trans-osseous (or equivalent) path of biomechanical failure (
Figure 31) instead of the previously described transligamentous path. Stage 1 injury is divided into transradial styloid and transscaphoid injuries. In transradial styloid injury, a large radial styloid fragment may be seen as the result of avulsion of the radioscaphocapitate ligament, which is itself typically injured in the lesser arc pattern. Stage 1 transscaphoid injury constitutes approximately 95% of greater arc injuries as this is simply a scaphoid fracture (usually the waist), and the proximal pole maintains its relationship to the lunate with an intact SLL. In stage 2 injury, a small radial styloid fragment from a radial styloid tip fracture may be seen as a result of avulsion of the radial collateral ligament. The distal pole of the scaphoid moves dorsally with the capitate and as the capitate dislocates, the dorsal lip of the radius or lunate may act as a chisel, causing a transverse fracture of the waist or proximal pole of the capitate. In stage 3 injury, triquetral body fracture and avulsion of the LRL and/or UTL may occur. The classic dorsal avulsion of the common attachment of the dorsal extrinsic ligaments seen in isolated triquetral fractures is not typically associated with this injury. An ulnar styloid fracture is commonly associated and may be seen with any stage of injury [
11].
Management of stage 2 and 3 perilunate dislocation consists of immediate closed reduction in which axial traction is used and posteroanterior pressure applied while the hand moves from extension to flexion to bring the capitate back into the lunate fossa. An audible clunk usually signifies reduction. Management of stage 4 injuries consists of closed reduction with axial traction and anteroposterior pressure applied while the hand moves from flexion to extension to bring the lunate back into the lunate fossa between the capitate and radius [
20]. Of note, if the lunate is rotated >90°, this maneuver may compromise the vascularity to the lunate, as the lunate vascular supply may solely come through the vascular bundle within the short radiolunate ligament. Operative management occurs after 3-5 days after closed reduction so that swelling can subside to the point where corrective surgical repair of ligamentous injury can be performed in addition to percutaneous fixation using Kirshner wires to maintain alignment [
19].
Dorsal intercalated segment instability (DISI) occurs when there is disruption of the SLL [
21]. The “intercalated segment” can be considered a bone or series of bones fixed in a passive position between other active motion segments [
4]. Because the proximal carpal row including the scaphoid, lunate, and triquetrum has no tendinous attachments, its motion is solely passive, dependent on the forces applied through its surrounding constraints. DISI deformity begins when the SLL loses its integrity. Because the posterior fibers of SLL are the thickest, it is the main dorsal stabilizer restricting dorsal rotation of the lunate relative to the capitate, and the volar scaphoid rotation. Rupture of the SLL disrupts the stabilizing balance and results in this malalignment pattern. On a lateral radiograph of a normal wrist, the scapholunate angle measures between 30° and 60° as the scaphoid and lunate are both held upright by the SLL. After SLL rupture, the scapholunate angle widens to greater than 60° due to excessive volar rotation of the scaphoid relative to the lunate (
Figure 32) often with eventual dorsal rotation of the lunate as well [
8,
19]. Management of DISI and acute tears of the SLL consists of surgical repair with suture anchors and temporary K-wire fixation.
Similar to the role that disruption of the SLL plays in DISI, volar intercalated segment instability (VISI) deformity occurs when there is disruption of the lunotriquetral ligament (LTL) [
21]. Because the anterior fibers of LTL are thickest, it is the main volar stabilizing element restricting the lunate from volar rotation relative to the capitate [
4]. Rupture of LTL causes the capitolunate angle to increase beyond the normal range of less than 30°, in the opposite direction as seen with DISI. Because the scaphoid is usually still tethered to the lunate in VISI, it rotates in a volar direction with the lunate. On a lateral radiograph of a normal wrist, the capitolunate angle measures less than 30° and if the angle measured greater than 30°, it would represent LTL rupture and VISI (
Figure 33). VISI is considered a CID lesion when there is a traumatic etiology and CIND lesion if rheumatic. When this occurs with perilunate injury, it is classified as a CIC lesion as it involves ligaments and/or bone from proximal and distal rows. Management of VISI consists of early reduction and casting, closed reduction and fixation with K-wires, or capitolunate fusion.
Midcarpal instability (MCI) is a confusing, uncommon and somewhat poorly understood topic with a wide spectrum of information regarding its etiology, mechanism, terminology, and treatment [
26]. It is a form of CIND, with instability between proximal and distal carpal rows. One way of approaching MCI is dividing it into extrinsic and intrinsic categories (
Figure 34). Extrinsic MCI is described as adaptive instability. When there is angular change at the radius (usually with fracture of the distal radius), the volar carpal ligaments become lax and eventually fail to properly shift the proximal carpal row when the wrist ulnar deviates [
27]. The classic example of this is dorsal tilt of the distal radius with extension of the proximal carpal row and flexion of the distal row. Treatment is with a corrective osteotomy to re-affirm stability in the carpus.
Intrinsic MCI is further broken down into palmar, dorsal, and combined (
Figure 34). In palmar MCI, the head of the capitate translate anteriorly, and the proximal carpal row is flexed [
26]. With ulnar deviation, the triquetrohamate joint engages, resulting in the proximal row snapping into extension. Treatment options of palmar MCI include conservative management, arthroscopic thermal capsulorrhaphy, soft tissue reconstruction, and a limited radiocarpal/intercarpal fusion depending on the structures involved. Dorsal MCI entails the subluxation of the capitate dorsally. Treatment of dorsal MCI includes conservative management, palmar ligament reefing, and/or dorsal intercarpal capsulodesis for stability. Combined intrinsic MCI has elements of both palmar and dorsal MCI, in addition to volar sag of the proximal row and dorsal subluxation of the capitate.