Submitted:
16 November 2026
Posted:
18 November 2026
You are already at the latest version
Abstract
Cesarean section is a life-saving intervention, yet access to and acceptance of the procedure vary across healthcare systems and cultural contexts. Among pregnant Ni-gerian women, decisions about cesarean delivery may be influenced by perceived sur-gical risks, fear of pain or impaired fertility, previous childbirth experiences, economic and geographic barriers, language differences, communication quality, and expecta-tions related to family, religion, and gender. This critical narrative review examined the literature on refusal or delayed acceptance of medically recommended cesarean deliv-ery and analyzed the associated bioethical challenges. Publications from 2010 to 2023 were identified through a structured search complemented by biomedical and regional sources. Evidence was charted by setting, population, methodological design, influenc-ing factors, and ethical implications.
Refusal could not be attributed to a single cultural belief or to Nigerian identity. Rather, it reflected interactions among autonomy, trust in healthcare professionals, ex-planatory models of illness, previous experiences, social relationships, economic con-straints, and maternity-care organization. The principal ethical tension concerns a pregnant woman’s right to informed refusal and bodily integrity, alongside profession-als’ duty to recommend effective treatment and reduce preventable maternal and fetal risks. Evidence from Nigeria, sub-Saharan Africa, migrant populations, and bioethical literature should be treated as contextual rather than as direct evidence of local preva-lence or outcomes. Clinical care should therefore prioritize clear risk communication, qualified interpreters when needed, shared decision-making, assessment of capacity and coercion, respect for valid refusal, and contingency planning for deterioration. Further local research is needed to characterize care contexts without inferring indi-vidual decisions from nationality or origin
Keywords:
cesarean section
; global trends
; pregnant immigrant population
; bioethical principles
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.