4.1. Catalyst Characterization
The crystalline phases of the active components in the nano-catalysts Ti-Al-Mg, Ti-Cr-Mg, and Ti-Fe-Mg were identified using X-ray diffraction (XRD), as depicted in
Figure 2. The resulting diffraction patterns were analyzed with the aid of the "Match!" software, and phase identification was validated through cross-referencing with reliable crystallographic databases and peer-reviewed literature.
All catalysts exhibited characteristic diffraction peaks at 2θ = 25.37°, 38.25°, 48.80°, 54.65°, and 62.75°, corresponding to the crystalline phases of MgTi
2O
5 [
16,
17], TiO
2 [
18,
19], Ti
3O
5 [
18,
20,
21], TiO
2 [
18,
19], and MgO [
22,
23], respectively.
In the case of Ti-Al-Mg, a distinct peak was observed at 2θ ≈ 47.45°, which was attributed to the formation of the ternary oxide phase MgAl
2Ti
3O
10 [
24]. Notably, no reflections corresponding to binary aluminum-magnesium oxides, such as MgAl
2O
4, or to aluminum oxide (Al
2O
3) were detected, indicating that the ternary phase is the dominant crystalline form in this system.
Conversely, the Ti-Fe-Mg and Ti-Cr-Mg catalysts exhibited additional diffraction peaks at 2θ = 64.10° and 36.17° which were assigned to the spinel-type binary oxides MgFe
2O
4 [
23,
25,
26] and Cr
2MgO
4 [
23], respectively. No evidence of ternary oxide phase formation was observed in either system.
Furthermore, the XRD diffractograms revealed the presence of monometallic oxide phases. In Ti-Fe-Mg, a peak at 2θ = 33.27° was consistent with the hematite phase of Fe
2O
3 [
27], while the Ti-Cr-Mg catalyst exhibited a peak at 2θ = 41.23°, corresponding to the crystalline phase of Cr
2O
3 [
28].
The crystallite size (D) of the catalysts were calculated using the Debye-Scherrer equation (1) [
29]:
In the equation employed for crystal size estimation, λ represents the wavelength of the X-ray radiation used (Cu Kα = 0.15406 nm), β denotes the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the diffraction peak, and θ corresponds to the Bragg diffraction angle. The constant k, known as the shape factor, is typically assumed to have a value of 0.98. Based on this equation, the average crystallite sizes of the phases formed during the preparation of the Ti-Al-Mg, Ti-Cr-Mg, and Ti-Fe-Mg catalysts were calculated, as presented in
Table 1.
The XPS spectra of the prepared catalysts, as shown in
Figure 3, confirm the presence of Mg, Ti, and O in all samples, as evidenced by the characteristic peaks of Mg 1s, Mg 2p, Ti 2p
3/2, Ti 2p
1/2, and O 1s. The Mg 1s peak at approximately 1303.20 eV indicates the successful incorporation of magnesium through Mg-O bonding, while the Mg 2p signal around 50.1 eV suggests the presence of Mg-OH groups [
30]. High-resolution Ti 2p spectra reveal a well-defined Ti 2p
3/2 peak at ~458 eV and a weaker Ti 2p
1/2 peak at ~464 eV, consistent with Ti
4+ species forming Ti-O bonds [
16]. The O 1s peak at 530.70 eV corresponds to lattice oxygen associated with Mg
2+, Al
3+, and Ti
4+, further confirming the formation of Ti-O, Al-O, and Mg-O bonds [
24,
31].
These observations are in agreement with XRD analysis, which shows the formation of crystalline phases such as TiO
2, MgO, and the binary oxide MgTi
2O
5 with an orthorhombic crystal structure [
32]. The Ti 2p binding energies confirm the presence of Ti
4+, as expected in TiO
2 and MgTi
2O
5, while the Mg 1s signal indicates Mg
2+ in accordance with the known crystal structures.
In the case of the Ti-Al-Mg catalyst, the Al 2p and Al 2s peaks at 73.9 and 117.8 eV, respectively, indicate oxidized aluminum forming Al-O bonds [
24]. These findings are supported by XRD results that confirm the formation of the ternary oxide phase MgAl
2Ti
3O
10, which arises due to cation substitution phenomena, specifically the replacement of Al
3+ by Ti
4+ within the oxide lattice, leading to a homogenous crystalline network [
24,
33]. Such substitutions induce changes in the crystal structure and are consistent with literature reports describing Ti-Al-Mg as a well-structured mixed-metal oxide catalyst with strong metal-oxygen interactions, which contribute to its enhanced performance in glycerol carbonate synthesis.
In contrast, no ternary oxide formation was observed for Ti-Cr-Mg and Ti-Fe-Mg catalysts. The XPS spectrum of Ti-Cr-Mg confirms the presence of chromium through the Cr 2p peak at ~579 eV, indicating the formation of Cr-O bonds within a mixed-metal oxide matrix. The O 1s peak is associated with lattice oxygen bonded to Mg
2+, Cr
3+, and Ti
4+, supporting the presence of Ti-O, Cr-O, and Mg-O bonds. These results are in line with XRD findings showing the formation of Cr
2MgO
4 with a classical AB
2O
4 spinel structure and Cr
2O
3 [
34,
35], reinforcing the presence of a well-defined oxide network with strong metal-oxygen interactions [
31,
36].
Similarly, the XPS spectrum of the Ti-Fe-Mg catalyst reveals Mg, Ti, O, and Fe species. The Fe 2p signal at approximately 712.20 eV corresponds to Fe
3+ species forming Fe-O bonds (Fe
2O
3) [
14,
31]. XRD analysis confirms the formation of MgFe
2O
4, a binary oxide with a classical spinel structure of the AB
2O
4 type [
34,
37,
38].
Figure 4 presents SEM images of the porous catalysts, revealing distinct morphological features across the prepared catalysts. The Ti-Al-Mg catalyst shows a porous, rough surface, and agglomerated surface, composed of irregularly shaped particles with layered and compact structures. This morphology suggests the presence of an extended network of pores and interparticle voids, which facilitates effective molecular diffusion. The roughness and porosity provide a large number of exposed active sites, allowing for efficient adsorption and activation of reactants. These features indicate minimal diffusion resistance and are generally associated with high catalytic activity due to the enhanced accessibility of internal active regions [
39,
40].
In contrast, the Ti-Cr-Mg catalyst exhibits a more agglomerated morphology with fewer visible pores and irregular particle shapes. The agglomeration reduces the external surface area and blocks the internal porosity, creating diffusion constraints. Such morphology limits the penetration of glycerol and CO₂ into the catalyst structure, reducing the contact between reactants and catalytic sites. This structural feature is consistent with the findings of Granados-Reyes et al. [
41], who observed that Cr-containing Mg-based catalysts exhibited decreased catalytic performance due to agglomeration-induced diffusion resistance and reduced site availability.
The Ti-Fe-Mg catalyst further emphasizes this limitation. SEM images show a fragmented, dense and heterogeneous surface with large agglomerates and significantly restricted porosity. The compact arrangement of particles and lack of interconnected pores severely hinder internal diffusion, especially under liquid-phase reaction conditions where glycerol's high viscosity further reduces mass transport. These morphological features impose substantial diffusion limitations, restricting the effective utilization of catalytic sites. Singh et al. [
42] reported similar observations in Fe-based catalysts for glycerol carboxylation, where particle agglomeration and low porosity resulted in low CO
2 activation and reduced catalytic activity.
In summary, the SEM images of Ti-Cr-Mg and Ti-Fe-Mg catalysts reveal morphologies that significantly restrict reactant diffusion. The agglomerated, dense structures with limited porosity create diffusion barriers, leading to poor catalyst performance due to reduced accessibility of active sites.
The EDS analysis in
Figure 5 confirms the successful formation of a Ti-Al-Mg oxide structure in the Ti-Al-Mg catalyst, as evidenced by the presence of Ti, Al, Mg, O, C, and N, with significant contributions from oxygen (64.09%), aluminum (23.51%), and magnesium (6.61%). Elemental mapping further reveals a uniform distribution of these key elements, which supports improved catalytic efficiency and thermal stability [
24].
In comparison, the EDX spectrum of Ti-Cr-Mg shows the presence of Ti, Cr, Mg, and O, with chromium contributing 21.99%. While Cr incorporation enhances moderate Lewis’s acidity and structural stability, the elemental mapping displays a slightly less homogeneous distribution than in Ti-Al-Mg. This lower uniformity may hinder synergetic effects of acid-base sites ensured by different metal ions in proximity, behaving more like mechanical mixtures of different oxide phases. These results are in line with the findings of Granados-Reyes et al., who reported that Cr-based mixed oxides, though moderately effective, were limited by uneven elemental dispersion and lower acid site availability [
41].
The EDX analysis of the Ti-Fe-Mg catalyst confirms the presence of Ti, Fe, Mg, and O, with Fe comprising 28.97%. Although Fe contributes weak acid sites, its high content may lead to the formation of less active species, likely due to a reduced pore volume. As shown in
Table 2, the pore volume decreases to 0.166 cm³/g compared to 0.345 cm³/g for AL-Ti-Mg, which may hinder diffusion and catalytic activity. Additionally, elemental mapping reveals a non-uniform distribution of Fe, further reducing the number of effective catalytic sites. These findings are consistent with those reported by Singh et al., where Fe-containing catalysts exhibited low performance due to uneven elemental dispersion and weak acidity [
42].
The uneven elemental dispersion in the Cr- and Fe-containing catalysts resulted in the formation of single metal oxide clusters, leading to a reduction in surface area to 54.47 m²/g and 28.20 m²/g, respectively, as shown in
Table 2. This decline in surface area consequently reduced the number of available active sites compared to the Al-Ti-Mg catalyst, which exhibits a surface area of 119.43 m²/g.
The nitrogen adsorption–desorption isotherms of the Ti-Al-Mg, Ti-Cr-Mg, and Ti-Fe-Mg catalysts (
Figure 6) all exhibit type IV isotherms with H
2 hysteresis loops, characteristic of mesoporous structures with ink-bottle-shaped pores, according to IUPAC classification [
43,
44]. In all cases, the gradual increase in adsorption at low relative pressure (P/P
0 < 0.3) confirms the presence of micropores, while the sharp rise at higher pressures (P/P
0 > 0.7) indicates the existence of larger mesopores and some macropores.
However, differences in pore size distributions are observed. For Ti-Al-Mg and Ti-Cr-Mg, the inset graphs show sharp peaks around 3-5 nm, reflecting a dominant mesoporous region with limited expansion beyond 10 nm. This indicates a rather uniform porous textures, in line with literature reports [
24,
45], and confirms a well-structured pore network that supports catalytic performance [
31].
In contrast, Ti-Fe-Mg exhibits a broader mesoporous distribution with a sharp peak between 8-12 nm and minimal extension beyond 20 nm. Despite the larger average pore size, the distribution remains relatively narrow, indicating a fairly uniform structure. These observations are consistent with reported findings in the literature [
24,
45], further supporting the classification and textural analysis of these catalysts.
Table 2 summarizes the surface area, pore volume, and pore width of the as-prepared catalysts. Among metal oxides, Ti-Al-Mg has the highest BET surface area (119.43 m
2/g) and pore volume (0.345 cm
3/g), confirming a highly mesoporous structure (6.81 nm pore width) that supports good adsorption and catalytic activity. Ti-Cr-Mg, with a moderate surface area (54.47 m
2/g) and slightly larger pores (7.12 nm), offers a balance between porosity and stability, making it suitable for catalysis, but less efficient than Ti-Al-Mg. Ti-Fe-Mg has the largest pores (10.68 nm), allowing better mass transfer, but its lower surface area (28.20 m
2/g) and moderate pore volume (0.166 cm
3/g) indicate a trade-off between adsorption capacity and catalytic efficiency, which aligns with literature studies [
24,
45].
The thermal properties of the Ti-Al-Mg, Ti-Cr-Mg, and Ti-Fe-Mg catalysts were evaluated using thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) under nitrogen (N
2) flow. As shown in the TGA curves (
Figure 7), all three samples exhibit an initial weight loss below 300 °C, which is attributed to the decomposition of adsorbed water and interlayer crystal water. These materials display minimal weight loss during heating, indicating high thermal stability across the series.
Between 300 °C and 600 °C, a gradual weight reduction is observed in all samples, corresponding to the decomposition of interlayered crystal water and hydroxyl (-OH) layers [
4]. This steady mass loss reflects a stable thermal profile with no abrupt structural breakdown. The corresponding DTG curves for each catalyst further confirm this behavior, showing broad, low-intensity peaks that suggest a slow and continuous dehydration process rather than a sudden decomposition event [
46].
4.2. Catalysts Effect on Glycerol Carbonate Synthesis
Figure 8 shows the effect of temperature on glycerol carbonate yield using Al-Ti-Mg, Fe-Ti-Mg, and Cr-Ti-Mg catalysts at 5% catalyst-to-glycerol loading, 10 bar pressure, and a 4-hour reaction time.
For Al-Ti-Mg and Fe-Ti-Mg catalysts, the yield increased as the temperature rose from 130 °C to 175 °C. Beyond 175 °C, the yield with Al-Ti-Mg remained stable, while that with Fe-Ti-Mg began to decline. Specifically, Al-Ti-Mg produced a yield of 11.3% at 130 °C, which increased to 36.10% at 175 °C. In comparison, Fe-Ti-Mg showed a yield increase from 8.55% to 25.19% over the same temperature range, followed by a decrease to 17.35% at 200 °C. This decrease is attributed to the formation of undesired by-products resulting from side reactions, including glycerol dehydration and polymerization [
47,
48,
49].
Cr-Ti-Mg, however, exhibited a significantly lower yield at 175 °C and 10 bar CO2 pressure, over four times lower than Al-Ti-Mg and less than half that of Fe-Ti-Mg.
The Al-Ti-Mg catalyst exhibits high efficiency due to its large specific surface area (119.43 m
2/g), which is more than four times greater than that of Fe-Ti-Mg (28.20 m
2/g), enhancing its capacity to adsorb reactants, as shown in
Figure 6.
XRD and XPS analysis reveal the presence of iron oxides (Fe
2O
3) in Fe-Ti-Mg, which increase its acidity [
50] and reduce its effectiveness in converting CO
2 and glycerol to glycerol carbonate. Additionally, SEM-EDX analysis shows that the magnesium content in Al-Ti-Mg is 6.51%, nearly double that of Fe-Ti-Mg (3.36%).
Although Cr-Ti-Mg has a moderate surface area (54.47 m
2/g) and high magnesium content, its catalytic performance is poor due to the strong acidity of chromium oxide, which is higher than that of iron and aluminum oxides
. These findings align with previously reported literature, further validating the acidity-based classification of these metal oxide catalysts [
51,
52,
53], thus hindering its activity in this reaction.
As shown in
Figure 9, increasing the temperature enhances glycerol conversion. However, the glycerol carbonate yield remains relatively stable above 175 °C for Al-Ti-Mg, while it decreases for Fe-Ti-Mg beyond this point. This decline is attributed to the formation of undesired by-products from side reactions such as glycerol polymerization and thermal degradation [
47,
48,
49].
The sharp drop in glycerol carbonate yield with Fe-Ti-Mg at temperatures above 200 °C is likely due to iron-catalyzed degradation of glycerol carbonate, which reduces reaction efficiency and leads to product loss to byproducts.
Figure 10 shows that increasing the catalyst concentration up to 10% improves glycerol carbonate yield for all catalysts. Al-Ti-Mg delivered the highest yield, followed by Fe-Ti-Mg and then Cr-Ti-Mg. A significant improvement was observed increasing the catalyst loading between 2.5% and 5%, while the increase at 10% gave only a marginal increase in glycerol carbonate yield, suggesting the reaction may be approaching a catalytic efficiency limit at higher concentrations.
Similarly, as shown in
Figure 11, glycerol conversion increased steadily with higher catalyst loading. Al-Ti-Mg again showed the highest conversion, followed by Fe-Ti-Mg and Cr-Ti-Mg. At 10% concentration, the conversion was significantly higher than at 2.5%, due to the increased number of active sites available at higher catalyst concentrations, which enhances both glycerol conversion and glycerol carbonate formation.
The superior performance of Al-Ti-Mg is attributed to its balanced acid–base properties, which play a key role in CO2 activation and glycerol adsorption.
The catalytic performance follows the order: Al-Ti-Mg > Fe-Ti-Mg > Cr-Ti-Mg. This is attributed to Al-Ti-Mg’s higher surface area, better porosity, and uniform magnesium content at the surface, which improves base sites at the surface. Its lower acidity also minimizes over-adsorption and suppresses undesired side reactions.
At 10% concentration, performance tends to stabilize, likely eliminating mass transfer limitations that might occur at lower catalyst loading concentration resulting to limited active sites available for reaction. Therefore, increasing catalyst concentration from 2.5% to 10% at 175 °C and 10 bar CO2 pressure significantly improves both glycerol carbonate yield and glycerol conversion. However, the benefit beyond 5% is less pronounced, emphasizing the need to optimize catalyst loading for maximum efficiency without excess material use.
The catalytic performance of the synthesized mixed metal oxide catalysts (Ti-Al-Mg, Ti-Fe-Mg, and Ti-Cr-Mg) is governed by a complex interplay of surface composition, homogeneity, acid-base character, and textural properties. Among the three catalysts, Ti-Al-Mg exhibited the highest catalytic activity, with a maximum glycerol carbonate yield of 36.1%. This superior performance is attributed to the formation of a well-defined ternary oxide phase (MgAl2Ti3O10), confirmed by XRD and XPS analyses. This phase reflects strong metal-oxygen interactions and a homogeneous distribution of Ti, Al, and Mg, as revealed by EDX mapping. The structural uniformity promotes a balanced distribution of active sites and reduces phase segregation, which are essential for efficient CO2 activation and glycerol conversion.
In contrast, Ti-Fe-Mg and Ti-Cr-Mg formed binary spinel-type oxides (MgFe2O4, Cr2MgO4) and segregated metal oxide phases (Fe2O3, Cr2O3), without evidence of ternary phase formation. These structures led to surface heterogeneity and less uniform elemental dispersion, which limited the accessibility and effectiveness of active sites. The SEM images confirmed that both catalysts exhibited more agglomerated and fragmented morphologies, contributing to reduced surface exposure.
The acid-base character of the catalysts further explains the observed differences in performance. Ti-Al-Mg displayed a well acid-base balance due to the presence of weak Lewis acid sites from Al3+ and basic sites from Mg2+. This balance favors the GC formation by facilitating CO2 adsorption and minimizing side reactions. In contrast, Fe3+ and Cr3+ introduced stronger acidic sites, as supported by literature and indirectly confirmed by the catalytic behavior. The acidity in Ti-Fe-Mg and Ti-Cr-Mg promoted glycerol dehydration and polymerization side reactions, reducing the GC yield.
Textural analysis reinforced these trends. Ti-Al-Mg had the highest BET surface area (119.43 m²/g) and a well-developed mesoporous structure, providing more accessible sites for reactants. Ti-Cr-Mg had a moderate surface area (54.47 m2/g), while Ti-Fe-Mg exhibited the lowest (28.20 m²/g), limiting its adsorption capacity despite a larger average pore size.
In summary, the findings confirm that optimal catalytic performance is achieved when the catalyst exhibits structural homogeneity, uniform dispersion of metal ions capable of forming stable ternary oxide phases, and a well-balanced acid-base surface. Ti-Al-Mg meets these conditions, resulting in superior activity. In contrast, the less organized structures and higher surface acidity of Ti-Cr-Mg and Ti-Fe-Mg limit their effectiveness. Consequently, the observed activity trend Ti-Al-Mg > Ti-Fe-Mg > Ti-Cr-Mg is directly correlated with these parameters.