3.3. Vessel and Fiber Characteristics
Optical micrographs of the cell components of tapped
S. sumatrana are shown in
Figure 6. The vessel elements were tubes with tails at both ends (
Figure 6A), with a few vessels showing parallel and opposite arrangements of the perforation plates on the tips of their elements (Figures 6A: 4 and 5).
The length of the vessels ranged from 436 to 965 μm and the average was 721±171 μm. The vessel length of
S. sumatrana in the present study was shorter than that of
Styrax wood in previous studies [17, 21, and 24]. Pasaribu et al. [
17] reported an
S. sumatrana vessel length of 396–1449 μm and an average of 1031±178 μm. In addition, the vessel length of
S. paralleloneurum was 671–1374 μm, and the average was 1026±187 μm. In addition, the vessel length of
S. paralleloneurum was 671–1374 μm, and the average was 1026±187 μm. Damayanti et al. [
21] reported
S. benzoin and
S. paralleloneurum vessel element lengths of 1135±168 μm and 1055±166 μm, respectively. Machado et al. [
24] reported that the vessel lengths of
Styrax latifolium,
Styrax martii,
Styrax leprosus, and
Styrax camporum from Brazil were 970±197 μm, 873±197 μm, 853±157 μm, and 738±121 μm, respectively.
The vessel lumina diameter of
S. sumatrana ranged from 96 to 190 with an average of 131 ± 28 μm. As reported by Pasaribu et al. [
17] and Damayanti et al. [
21], vessel lumina diameters of
S. sumatrana, S. benzoin, and
S. paralleloneurum were 168 ± 37 μm, 160±21 μm, and 140±25 μm, respectively, showing larger value than
S. sumatrana in the present study. Machado et al. [
24] reported that the vessel lumina diameters of
Styrax latifolium,
Styrax martii,
Styrax leprosus, and
Styrax camporum from Brazil were 91±14 μm, 97±17 μm, 69±17 μm, and 72±14 μm, respectively, which is distinctively smaller than the vessel lumina diameter of
S. sumatrana in the present study.
The dimensions and derivative values of the tapped
S. sumatrana wood fibers are listed in
Table 3. The fiber length was 1390.8 μm, which is categorized into moderate to extensive based on the Hardwood List of the IAWA Committee [
23]. The fiber length of
S. sumatrana was smaller than that of
Styrax wood reported in previous studies. Pasaribu et al. [
17] reported that the fiber length and diameter of untapped
S. sumatrana ranged from 1525 to 2290 μm and the average was 1860±163 μm. Damayanti et al. [
21] reported an
S. benzoin fiber length of 1930±184 μm and an
S. paralleloneurum fiber length of 1870±139 μm. Machado et al. [
24] reported that the fiber lengths of
Styrax latifolium,
Styrax martii, and
Styrax leprosus were 1904±317 μm, 1798±262 μm, and 1811±294 μm, respectively.
The fiber diameter was 29.23 μm, whereas the wall thickness and fiber lumina diameter were 5.62 μm and 17.99 μm, respectively. The fiber wall of
S. sumatrana in the present study was classified as thin to moderate based on the Hardwood List of the IAWA Committee [
23]. Damayanti et al. [
21] mentioned that the fiber wall thickness and lumen diameter of tapped
S. benzoin were 2.3±0.4 and 32.5±3.1, respectively. The fiber walls of untapped
S. sumatrana and tapped
S. benzoin in previous studies were distinctively thinner than those of tapped
S. sumatrana in the present study. Pasaribu et al. [
17] reported that the fiber and lumina diameter of untapped
S. sumatrana ranged from 25 to 48 μm and from 20 to 43 μm, respectively, and the average was 35±3 μm in fiber diameter and 31± 3 μm in lumina diameter. In addition, the authors also mentioned that the fiber wall thickness of
S. sumatrana ranged from 1 to 3 μm with an average of 2.3±0.4 μm.
RR is the double cell wall thickness ratio to the lumen diameter. A lower RR value is more favorable for producing high-quality fiber pulp, which is essential for achieving complete flatness and adequate fiber bonding in pulp sheets [25, 26]. In the present study, the average RR of
S. sumatrana wood was 0.64, and the RR ranged from 0.42 to 1.00, indicating a 3
rd grade pulp quality. The RR in the present study demonstrated a lower pulp grade than that of
Styrax wood reported in previous studies. Pasaribu et al. [
17] reported a 0.15 RR in
S. sumatrana and
S. paralleloneurus, demonstrating the potential production of 1
st grade pulp. Damayanti et al. [
21] reported that the RR of both tapped
S. benzoin and untapped
S. paralleloneurus was 0.14, which was another indicator of 1st-grade pulp.
The FP refers to the ratio of fiber length to diameter. A higher FP indicates a greater inter-fiber bonding and tear strength, which positively correlates with the tensile strength of paper sheets [25, 26]. The FP of
S. sumatrana wood was 46.38 and ranged from 34.73 to 57.40, showing 3
rd grade pulp quality. The FP of
S. sumatrana and
S. paralleloneurus were 52.42 and 47.70, respectively in a previous study, indicating 3rd grade pulp quality [
17]. The FP of tapped
S. benzoin and untapped
S. paralleloneurus revealed 3
rd grade pulp quality at 52.09 and 53.12, respectively, in another study [
21].
The
MR refers to the ratio of the surface area of the fiber wall to the total surface area of the fiber. A smaller MR value leads to greater density in pulp sheets, with high mechanical strength [25, 26]. The MR of tapped
S. sumatrana wood ranged from 50.73% to 74.98% and averaged at 62.13 % in this study, showing 3rd grade pulp quality. This MR demonstrated a lower pulp quality grade than that of
Styrax wood reported in previous studies. Pasaribu et al. [
17] reported an
S. sumatrana and
S. paralleloneurus MR of 24.35 and 23.72, respectively, demonstrating 1
st grade pulp quality. Similarly, the MR of tapped
S. benzoin and untapped
S. paralleloneurus showed 1
st grade pulp quality at 23.26 and 22.94, respectively [
21].
The coefficient of rigidity (CR) is the ratio of the cell wall thickness to the fiber diameter, and a higher CR of a fiber reduces tensile strength [25, 26]. The CR of tapped S. sumatrana ranged from 0.15 to 0.25, with an average value of 0.19 in the present study, showing 3rd grade pulp quality. However, this quality class was considerably lower than that of other Styrax woods reported in previous studies. The CR of untapped S. sumatrana, tapped S. benzoin, and untapped S. paralleloneurus were approximately 0.06, showing 1st grade pulp quality [17, 21]
The FR is the ratio of the lumen to fiber diameter. Here, the FR of tapped S. sumatrana ranged from 0.50 to 0.70, with an average of 0.61. However, it was lower than that of other Styrax wood reported in previous studies. The FR of untapped S. sumatrana, tapped S. benzoin, and untapped S. paralleloneurus was approximately 0.88, showing 1st grade pulp quality [17, 21]
The total score of tapped S. sumatrana wood fibers in the present study demonstrated a 2nd grade pulp quality. In contrast, the total scores of untapped S. sumatrana, tapped S. benzoin, and untapped S. paralleloneurus showed 1st grade pulp quality in previous studies [12, 13].