2.1. Morphology, structure features and preparation of nanoparticles on Pd basis
Classic monometallic palladium nanoparticles were also obtained in the study. Microphotographs of the synthesized particles as a part of the modifier are presented in
Figure 1. The obtained particles had classic energetically favorable spherical shape. The average size for the 75% of particles was about 80-110 nm. This classic particle type was deliberately obtained for further comparison with developed pentatwinned nanoparticles in catalytic and membrane applications.
Non-classic bimetallic Pd-Pt nanoparticles as a part of the modifier with a fifth-order symmetry axis, which is unattainable in volumetric single crystals, were obtained in this study. The research concentrates on particle shaping and the combination of metals in their composition. The interest stems from the fact, that catalytic reactions can occur more selectively on certain facets or due to the introduction of a secondary metal that alters reactivity. Palladium and platinum are relatively similar in many basic characteristics. Both metals have face-centered cubic lattice with negligible difference in lattice parameter (Pd = 3890 Å, Pt = 3920 Å) and close standard reduction potentials. According to the density functional theory, platinum atoms occupy central positions, while palladium atoms concentrate on a surface during particle formation [
55]. This can be explained by higher surface energy and cohesion energy of platinum atoms.
Nevertheless, in the synthesis of nanoparticles, their deliberate design considering faceted structure, homogeneity and compositional control remains a challenge, especially for nanoparticles, that are composed of catalytically favorable metal pairs. Therefore, a number of synthesis methods, which allow controlling the shape and composition of nanoparticles, have been developed in recent years [
56]. The simplest and the most efficient method used in this work was the electrolytic deposition method. This method is unique because it provides additional control tools (voltage, current) along with classic tools for adjusting the shape and structure of particles (composition of the working solution, synthesis time). The developed method for the synthesis of non-classic pentatwinned particles combined several main distinctive features in comparison with the classic technique, which allowed to achieve similar particle morphology. Firstly, a two-step current variation was applied in the deposition process. At the beginning, sufficiently small current of 0.003 mA cm
–2 was applied for a short period of time to promote the nucleation process. Such step is important in the synthesis process, as it is the nucleation shape, which underlies the nanoparticle, that can dictate self-assembly into larger architectures with new properties. Further, current was significantly increased and maintained until the end of the synthesis This allowed to carry out directed growth of specific facets of the particle surface and to give them a certain shape. Secondly, the surfactant and halide ions were used as tools for adjusting and controlling morphology. Properly selected surfactant concentration prevents particles from rounding during growth, preserving the inoculum geometry. Chloride in the working solution promotes oxidative etching, while bromide is responsible for selective passivation, stimulating the growth of facets with high Miller index. High-index facets exhibit much higher reactivity than low-index ones, because they have higher density of undercoordinated atoms located on steps and bends. These atoms have high reactivity, which is required for high catalytic activity.
Bimetallic Pd-Pt nanoparticles, synthesized in this work, had fifth-order rotational symmetry. Such symmetry can be observed in flowers of many plants, however, it is not typical for objects of non-living nature. Microphotographs of the surface of the obtained nanoparticles are shown in
Figure 2. The particles had five-pointed star shape with high-energy facets with a big number of undercoordinated atoms. The average size for 60% of particles was in the range of 90-125 nm. According to EDS analysis, the resulting bimetallic modifier contained 94.8% of palladium and 5.2% of platinum.
Moreover, it was found, that pentagonal particles within the modifier were hollow. The obtained samples were weighed after the modifier was synthesized. However, according to the weighing results, the mass of the samples increased insignificantly. This raised a number of questions about the structure of the nanoparticles in the modifier composition. Chemical etching was used to determine structural features of the particle, as mechanical influence on particles of such a small size was a non-trivial task. During the etching process, the particle shell thinned and multiple explosion-like ruptures appeared. It was confirmed with electron microscopy (
Figure 3). Etching was performed with hydrochloric acid according to the mechanism, which was described in the paper [
57] for decahedral and icosahedral particles. This made it possible to speak about a similar destruction mechanism. The centers of destruction of pentagonal particles were the points of intersection of twin boundaries and disclinations on a particle surface. In other words, these were the points of maximum concentration of internal elastic stresses. Consequently, it can be assumed, that disclination content in electrolytically synthesized particles can lead to a formation of internal voids in them. This particle structure certainly has an economic benefit in terms of precious metal reduced consumption.
2.2. Catalytic characteristics of the bimetallic Pd-Pt modifier on pentatwinned nanoparticles basis
Electrochemical measurements of the obtained bimetallic pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier were carried out with cyclic voltammetry in alkaline methanol solution to assess catalytic properties. They were also compared with measurements for classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier and unmodified electrode. Scanning was performed at potentials from –0.9 V to 0.5 V towards Ag/AgCl (saturated KCl) at a scan speed of 50 mV s
–1 at room temperature. Measurements for each sample were made for one hundred cycles. The 30th cycles, which are the highest ones, are shown in
Figure 4a. All the studied samples showed similar trends, namely a high current density peak around –0.1 V at anodic sweep (I
f), which is caused by oxidation of methanol. In addition, another peak around – 0.4 V at cathodic sweep (I
b) was observed for all samples, related to the accumulation of residual carbonaceous particles, which were produced during anodic sweep. However, forward peak current density and reverse peak current density for the electrode with bimetallic pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier were the highest and were approximately 60.72 mA cm
–2 and 5.89 mA cm
–2, respectively. Achieved values were 3 times higher than those for the electrode with classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier, 19.28 mA cm
–2 and 3.37 mA cm
–2 respectively, and more than two order of magnitude higher in comparison with unmodified electrode. The observed improvement in characteristics of pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier in methanol oxidation reaction can be explained with a bifunctional mechanism [
58,
59,
60].
The process of methanol electrooxidation with electrodes modified with Pd-Pt particles can be described with the following stages [
61]:
According to (1), intermediate carbon monoxide forms (CO) are produced during methanol oxidation reaction and then further adsorbed on the surface of the Pd-Pt modifier (PdPt-COads). The emerged COads blocks the surface of the Pd-Pt modifier, thereby inhibiting the continuous oxidation process of methanol. PdPt-COads can be oxidized by hydroxyl group (OH) with carbon dioxide (CO2) formation.
In the synthesized bimetallic modifier, platinum is responsible for chemisorption of methanol and palladium is responsible for oxidation of water particles. Platinum adsorbs carbon intermediate compounds such as COads and palladium adsorbs its counter intermediate compounds such as OHads, i.e., it catalyzes the dehydrogenation of water molecules. In the bimetallic PdPt modifier, the d-zone centers of platinum shift downwards and the Pt-COads bond becomes weaker. At the same time, Pd-OHads reacts with it and eventually leads to a formation of CO2. The reaction between Pt-COads and Pd-OHads leads to a removal of strongly adsorbed COads particles on active centers. The strong bonding between Pd-Pt atoms can also reduce the coordination between the Pt and –COads bonds, thereby destroying the Pt-COads. These synergistic effects significantly improve the overall characteristics of the Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier. The enhanced electrocatalytic performance of pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier in methanol oxidation reaction can also be explained with high density of atomic steps, protrusions and fractures on high-index facets.
The resistance of catalytic coatings to CO
ads poisoning is usually assessed via the ratio of forward (I
f) to reverse (I
b) current density peaks [
62]. In comparison with classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier (5.7), pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag one showed higher values of I
f/I
b ratio – 10.3. This indicates that poisoning particles are removed from the catalyst surface more efficiently and that the mutual contribution of palladium and platinum can significantly reduce CO poisoning during the reaction. The high value of the I
f/I
b ratio implies that most of the intermediate carbonaceous particles CO
ads are oxidized to CO
2 in the direct scan due to the presence of OH
ads.
Chronoamperometric tests of pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier, classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier and unmodified electrode were carried out to study electrocatalytic stability, durability and resistance to methanol oxidation at fixed temperature. At the initial stage, modified electrodes had high current values, which can be explained by a big number of active centers on the surface. Typically, methanol is continuously oxidized on the surface of the modifier at a fixed potential, and many intermediate adsorbed CO
ads particles also begin to accumulate on the surface during methanol oxidation reaction. As can be seen from
Figure 4b, the initial current of pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier was significantly higher than that of classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier and unmodified electrode. This is an indicator of a higher charging of the double layer [
63]. However, a rapid drop of current up to 500 s was observed due to the formation of CO-like intermediates, which were adsorbed on the active centers of catalysts. This prevented further oxidation of methanol [
64]. It was recorded, that pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier demonstrated significantly higher current than classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier and unmodified electrode over the entire time period, even though current drop was observed. Final current density of pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier was about 2.39 mA cm
–2, which was higher than that of classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier (1.25 mA cm
–2) and unmodified electrode (0.01 mA cm
–2). In addition, pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier had the lowest calculated current density reduction (41 %) in comparison with classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier (62 %). This indicated better resistance of Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag to poisoning in methanol oxidation reaction. The gradual decrease in current over time was an indicator of the good anti-poisoning ability of the modifier [
63]. The slower current decline, which was observed for the electrode with pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier, indicated less accumulation of adsorbed CO
ads particles on the modifier surface. Therefore, it means that pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Pd-Ag modifier showed superior electrocatalytic performance and better stability than classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier and unmodified electrode towards alkaline oxidation reaction of methanol. The activity level in chronoamperometric measurements corresponded directly to the activity level in cyclic voltammetry measurements. The obtained results can be due to the synergistic effect of the palladium-platinum alloy, which has superior poisoning resistance in comparison with monometallic palladium.
Thus, bimetallic pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier, synthesized in this work, demonstrated excellent catalytic activity, long-term stability, and resistance to COads poisoning in alkaline oxidation reaction of methanol. The achieved results can be due to both the synergistic effect of the combination of palladium and platinum metals and the large number of available catalytically active centers, which are results of the non-classic morphology with high-index facets.
2.3. Diffusion and selective characteristics of bimetallic Pd-Pt modifier on pentatwinned nanoparticles basis
Developed bimetallic pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier was studied in hydrogen transport processes to assess gas transport characteristics. Resulting characteristics were compared with those of classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier and unmodified membrane. In the first series of experiments, diffusion characteristics of obtained membranes were assessed in terms of hydrogen permeate flux density as a function of temperature in the range from 25 to 100 °C and pressure 0.4 MPa. The choice of this temperature range is based on the role and properties of the modifier to achieve permeability for palladium-based membranes even at room temperature.
Figure 5a shows the temperature dependence of hydrogen flux density for membranes with pentagonally structured modifier and classic one. Data for the smooth unmodified Pd-Ag membrane are shown for comparison. It is evident, that the flux of hydrogen permeating through the membranes increases with the rise of permeation temperature. However, it should be noted that the permeation flux was not recorded up to a temperature of 50 °C for unmodified membrane, while modified membranes showed hydrogen permeation flux density up to 14.7 mmol s
–1 m
–2 for Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag and 10.1 mmol s
–1 m
–2 for Pd
black/Pd-Ag already at a temperature of 25 °C. The highest values of hydrogen permeation flux density at 100 °C were demonstrated by the membrane with pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier - up to 27.3 mmol s
–1 m
–2. Obtained hydrogen flux density was 2 times higher than that for membranes with classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier, up to 13 mmol s
–1 m
–2, and an order of magnitude higher than that for unmodified membrane. To confirm the hypothesis of the influence of surface processes on permeability in the selected low-temperature range, activation energy (
) was calculated using the Arrhenius equation [
65]:
where
– hydrogen permeability,
– pre-exponential multiplier ,
R – universal gas constant,
T – temperature. It is known from the literature [
66], that
ЕА values below 30 kJ mol
–1 indicate a significant contribution of diffusion to the hydrogen transfer process, while surface phenomena require much higher activation energy up to 146 kJ mol
–1. The
ЕА for developed membranes was estimated to be about 75 kJ mol
–1 for unmodified membrane and about 49 kJ mol
–1 for the membrane with pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier. Such results can be caused not only by activation of the membrane surface, which accelerates surface limiting processes in the range of low temperatures (up to 100 °C), but also by special morphology and structure of nanoparticles in the composition of pentagonally structured modifier. Pentagonally structured particles, in contrast to classic spherical particles, have a large number of available catalytically active centers due to the presence of high-index high-energy facets. The synergetic effect of the favorable combination of palladium and platinum metals in the modifier also makes a significant contribution. These conclusions are confirmed by electrochemical studies presented earlier, the results of which correlate closely with those of the gas transportation studies.
The second series of experiments was carried out to support obtained data on the effect of developed modifiers on hydrogen permeability of palladium-containing membranes. During these experiments, the dependence of permeate flux density as a function of overpressure in the range from 0.05 to 0.4 MPa and temperature 25 °C was studied.
Figure 5b shows the pressure dependence of hydrogen flux density for membranes with pentagonally structured modifier and classic one. A smooth unmodified Pd-Ag membrane is shown for comparison. In the conducted experiment, a similar dependence of penetration flux density was observed as in the previous series of experiments. Higher feed pressure determined higher driving force for hydrogen permeation, causing an increase in the density of flux permeated through the membrane. The membrane with pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier had the highest hydrogen permeation flux density at 0.4 MPa, up to 14.7 mmol s
–1 m
–2. Achieved hydrogen flux density was 1.5 times higher than for membranes with classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier, up to 10.1 mmol s
–1 m
–2, and two order of magnitude higher than for unmodified membrane. However, the main point of this series of experiments was to identify the limiting stage of hydrogen transport for developed membrane materials. The hydrogen flux permeating through the membrane is expressed as follows [
67]:
where
– penetrating hydrogen flux,
– hydrogen permeability,
δ – membrane thickness,
and
– partial pressure on inlet and outlet sides of the membrane, respectively,
n – pressure exponent. The exponent
n can be from 0.5 to 1. At the boundary value
n=0.5, equation (5) turns into Sieverts-Fick law and points to a limitation of the transfer process by diffusion of atomic hydrogen in the volume. In contrast, at the boundary value of
n=1, equation (5) indicates that the transport process is limited by surface reactions, i.e., hydrogen dissociation/recombination takes longer time and consequently consumes more energy than diffusion. According to the data presented in
Figure 5b, obtained permeate flux density for unmodified membrane is easily approximated by a first order line. The n value was 0.98, which means that the transport process is completely limited by surface stages. This is confirmed by activation energy, which was calculated above. For membranes with pentagonally structured modifier, the exponent n was about 0.76, which indicates the control of hydrogen permeation flux by a combination of several mechanisms, namely volumetric diffusion and surface processes. Moreover, it is confirmed by the evidently decreased activation energy in comparison with unmodified membrane. The conducted series of experiments confirms the acceleration of dissociative adsorption and recombinative desorption processes, which are limiting in the low-temperature range. Such acceleration was achieved by activation of the membrane surface with bimetallic pentagonally structured modifier with an increased number of reactive active centers towards hydrogen.
In the third series of experiments, hydrogen permeation and nitrogen leakage tests of developed membranes with bimetallic pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier were performed at 25 °C and transmembrane pressure range from 0.1 to 0.4 MPa to assess selectivity. The results were compared with those for classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier and unmodified membrane.
Figure 6 shows long-term permeability data for membranes with pentagonally structured modifier and classic one for 300 hours. A smooth unmodified Pd-Ag membrane is shown for comparison. According to the results, developed membranes showed high selectivity over a long period of time. The membrane with pentagonally structured Pd-Pt/Pd-Ag modifier demonstrated the highest H
2/N
2 selectivity at a pressure of 0.4 MPa – up to 3514. Achieved selectivity was 1.2 times higher than for the membranes with classic Pd
black/Pd-Ag modifier, up to 3019, and was 1.5 times higher than for unmodified membrane. It can be seen from the data, that the hydrogen permeation flux was increasing with each pressure rise and stabilized over time. During the whole penetration test, there was a slight drop in selectivity in the selected pressure range (0.1–0.4 MPa), but in numerical equivalent it could be considered as insignificant. It should be noted, that the hydrogen flow was stabilized at a fixed pressure each time, and the nitrogen leakage did not increase either. This proves that developed membranes demonstrate stability and resistance to pressure drops over a long period of time, as well as the absence of significant mechanical defects such as holes and seals.