Photolysis of endogenous pigments reduces the virulence of corresponding pathogens
The phenomenon of color hinges upon its dependence on the absorption or reflection of light. This property can be quantified by isolating and measuring the pigment molecules responsible for selectively absorbing light [
6]. While isolated pigments are commonly utilized in various industries such as textiles, paper production, agricultural research, and water science, organic pigments play pivotal roles in the metabolic processes of organisms that produce them [
7]. In the plants and algae kingdom, the green chlorophyll pigment, for example, serves as the primary light-absorbing agent, converting absorbed sunlight into a chemical gradient essential for ATP production during photosynthesis [
8]. Conversely, within the animal kingdom, pigments like melanin employ their light-absorbing characteristics to safeguard against photodamage and function as scavengers of reactive oxygen species (ROS) generated by ultraviolet (UV) light [
9,
10]. This photosensitivity, prevalent in a diverse array of pigment molecules, is attributed to their conjugated C=C bond system, an alternating chain of single and double bonds capable of capturing and absorbing photons of specific wavelengths. Molecules with the ability to absorb visible light are often referred to as “chromophores” [
11,
12].
In the intricate world of microorganisms, pigments produced by both bacterial and fungal species play a significant role in microbial metabolism and survival. Carotenoid pigments, found in both bacteria and fungi, are renowned for their multifaceted contributions, including antioxidant defense against ROS, protection against heavy metal toxicity, and resilience in the face of extreme environmental temperature fluctuations [
13,
14,
15]. The bolstered survival mechanisms afforded by microbial pigments are thus considered significant virulence factors within microorganisms, making them potential targets for therapeutic interventions [
16]. Leveraging the innate photosensitivity inherent in biological pigments, phototherapy, particularly in the blue light spectrum, emerges as a compelling non-invasive approach to target these virulence factors within pathogens. This approach enhances sensitivity to specific antimicrobial agents, promising novel avenues for treatment.
While multiple pathogens are capable of pigment production, few hold as much medical significance as
Staphylococcus aureus (
S. aureus), including its more notorious antibiotic-resistant variant, methicillin-resistant
S. aureus (MRSA). Both
S. aureus and MRSA are notorious culprits behind a broad spectrum of medical conditions, spanning from bloodstream infections to conventional skin and soft tissue infections. Consequently,
S. aureus infections remain a substantial source of global morbidity and mortality [
17,
18,
19]. A distinctive feature found in over 90% of
S. aureus is their expression of the characteristic pigment, known as staphyloxanthin (STX), responsible for the trademark golden yellow hue frequently used for identifying
S. aureus strains [
20,
21]. In addition to its role in maintaining structural membrane stability, STX also plays a pivotal role in antioxidant defense against oxidative stress and immune cell evasion [
22,
23,
24]. Thus, staphyloxanthin can be considered a key virulence factor for
S. aureus, with some studies exploring the usage of cholesterol synthesis inhibitors to inhibit the synthesis of STX in
S. aureus [
25].
Nevertheless, owing to the conjugated C=C structure, STX exhibits an exceptionally high sensitivity to visible light (
Figure 1A,B). It has been documented that this pigment displays a prominent absorbance peak at 460 nm, falling within the blue light wavelength [
26,
27]. Comprehensive analysis employing both Raman spectroscopy and Mass spectrometry has unveiled that exposing isolated STX to 460 nm blue light leads to the cleavage of the conjugated C=C double bonds. This observation underscores the photolysis behavior exhibited by STX when subjected to 460 nm irradiance (
Figure 1C–E). A more in-depth exploration into the specific photochemistry governing the interaction between blue light and STX has revealed that the degradation of STX followed a second-order photobleaching mechanism via a triplet-triplet annihilation reaction: T* + T* → R + S (
Figure 1B). In this process, light-excited STX triplet molecules (T*) react with one another, ultimately yielding a reduced (R) and semi-oxidized (S) form, causing the disintegration of the STX structure. This triplet excitation phenomenon occurs with significant efficiency in carotenoids, particularly those prone to aggregation within cell membranes [
28]. Earlier studies have suggested that STX molecules within the
S. aureus membrane are organized into functional membrane microdomains (FMM), both structurally and functionally resembling the lipid rafts commonly found in eukaryotic cells [
29]. These embedded STX FMM not only play a pivotal role in enhancing membrane permeability and fluidity within the
S. aureus pathogen but also serve as crucial anchor points and assembly platforms for various protein complexes responsible for the observed antibiotic resistance mechanisms in MRSA, including the penicillin-binding protein (PBP2a) [
30].
The initial investigations into STX photobleaching employed 410 nm continuous wave (CW) light-emitting diodes (LED) [
27]. Subsequent studies, however, revealed that nanosecond pulsed 410 nm blue light accomplished STX photobleaching at a significantly higher efficiency, speed, and thoroughness compared to LED systems. This method demanded less than 18 J/cm
2 of light exposure to photobleach 80% of the STX content within MRSA cells [
31]. In contrast, LED systems necessitated nearly ten times that dosage, totally 180 J/cm
2 to attain an equivalent degree of photobleaching. This augmented efficiency is likely attributable to the microsecond-scale lifetime of the excited triplets of STX. As the high peak power present in a nanosecond pulse is able to excite the STX molecules to a triplet state within a single pulse, thus yielding nonlinear increments in excitation (
Figure 1F). Interestingly, this increased pulsed light bleaching efficiency was not observable when applied to extracted STX resuspended within solutions. This observation underscores the dependency of STX photobleaching efficiency on concentration, emphasizing that the densely packed and aggregated configuration of STX within MRSA membranes. While both LED and pulsed light devices remain viable options for inducing STX photolysis within MRSA, the improved efficiency of pulsed light can offer a potential method to reduce and limit light exposure dosages, improving the viability of this technology within clinical environments.
The application of 460 nm blue light for photolyzing STX within
S. aureus FMM leads to the disintegration of these domains, resulting in the formation of permeable pores measuring approximately 20~30 nm across the entirety of the bacterial membrane and subsequent cell death (
Figure 1G) [
31]. This pore formation not only enhances the overall membrane permeability but also disrupts the lipid packing within the domain, significantly increasing membrane fluidity. Moreover, the disintegration of FMM was observed to trigger the detachment of anchored protein complex assemblies, including the antibiotic-resistant PBP2a protein assembly, which was found to be released from the membrane of MRSA following blue light treatment [
31]. By harnessing the potential of blue light-induced STX photobleaching to initiate pore formation and disrupt resistance proteins within the
S. aureus membrane, multiple novel applications and therapeutic treatments involving blue light can be devised to target and combat antibiotic-resistant
S. aureus infections.
The removal of STX from both
S. aureus and MRSA using blue light immediately heightened their sensitivity to ROS in both
in vitro and
in vivo environments. The combination of blue light and low-concentration hydrogen peroxide synergistically eradicated
S. aureus, biofilms, and persisters
in vitro but also significantly reduced MRSA bioburden in well as a murine abrasion infection model [
27]. Furthermore, depletion of STX via light-induced photobleaching can increase the killing efficiency of macrophages containing phagocytosed MRSA cells, thus enhancing the sensitivity of the immune system to MRSA. Macrophages, as key immune cells, are known to generate ROS internally to effectively eliminate internalized pathogens [
16].
While the immediate depletion of STX increased ROS sensitivity, the pores formed during the disintegration of the STX microdomains also improved the efficacy and efficiency of antibiotics and other ROS-producing antimicrobial agents (
Figure 1H). Analysis on the size of the pores was performed by measuring the intake of dextran-labeled fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC-dextran) into light-treated MRSA cells. FD70, a FITC-dextran molecule with a molecular weight of 70 kDa and a Stokes radius of 6 nm was found to be inserted in light-treated cells, indicating a minimum pore size of 12 nm (
Figure 1I). Further analysis with additional FITC-dextran indicates that pores formed by light treatment have an upper limit of 30 nm. The increased membrane permeability resulting from pore formation not only improved the uptake and incorporation of membrane-targeting antibiotics like daptomycin but also enhanced bacterial interior accessibility for larger antimicrobial particles such as silver nanoparticles, thereby bolstering their overall antimicrobial efficiency and effectiveness [
31,
32]. One of the most significant consequences of STX photobleaching is the detachment of antibiotic resistance proteins from the MRSA membrane. This detachment allows for the resensitization of previously ineffective antibiotics like tetracycline, ofloxacin, oxacillin, ciprofloxacin, and linezolid against blue light-treated MRSA [
31].
While the resensitization of conventional antibiotics against light-treated MRSA presents an intriguing avenue for circumventing established antibiotic resistance mechanisms, questions arise regarding the potential for resistance development within STX-photobleached MRSA. A 48-day serial passaging study involving MRSA subjected to approximately 90 J/cm
2 of light revealed a near complete loss of STX expression, with colonies transitioning from a golden yellow to pure white over the course of passaging (
Figure 1J) [
31]. However, this depletion of STX has drastic changes in antibiotic resistance, underscoring that the photobleaching process can ultimately eliminate a key virulence factor within MRSA. More importantly, it was observed that the addition of light treatment actually inhibited the overall resistance-developing capabilities of MRSA. In a 48-day serial passage experiment involving daily treatment of MRSA with ciprofloxacin, it was revealed that the susceptibility of MRSA to ciprofloxacin did not change under the light treatment, with a MIC ≤ 2 μg/ml, whereas the MIC of the untreated MRSA surged to 128 μg/ml. Similar results were also noted with oxacillin. In all instances of light-treated MRSA strains within the antibiotic serial passaging studies, the depletion of STX was evident, suggesting that the efflux pumps responsible for antibiotic resistance, such as ciprofloxacin and oxacillin, are localized within the STX-rich FMM. Furthermore, it underscores that STX expression is pivotal for the localization of efflux pumps. Hence, the application of STX photobleaching not only revives conventional antibiotics against MRSA but also curbs and impedes the development of resistance to remaining susceptible antibiotics. While the ability of blue light phototherapy to enhance the effectiveness of ROS-producing antimicrobial agents is noteworthy, its capacity to rejuvenate conventional antibiotics against MRSA while mitigating the risk of resistance development presents a potentially groundbreaking and cost-effective method to treating MRSA infections.
While a significant portion of studies has primarily centered on the pigment photobleaching potential of blue light with a focus on STX within MRSA membrane, it is crucial to recognize that other pigment-producing pathogens have also shown susceptibility to blue light-induced pigment photobleaching. An illustrative example is the capacity of blue light to photobleach the red-orange pigment granadaene found in the membrane of
Streptococcus agalactiae (
S. agalactiae), commonly known as Group B
Streptococcus (GBS) (
Figure 1K) [
33,
34].
S. agalactiae is a beta-hemolytic pathogen that has been identified as one of the leading causes of delayed wound healing and infection within cutaneous wounds alongside
S. aureus and
Pseudomonas aeruginosa (
P. aeruginosa) [
35]. Like most pigments, granadaene contains a highly conjugated C=C system that renders it photosensitive to light, and like STX, granadaene has been understood to contribute to the overall survival and virulence of
S. agalactiae [
34,
36,
37]. Investigations into the role of granadaene have indicated that not only does the pigment play a role as an antioxidant to shield
S. agalactiae from oxidative damage, but the pigment has also been found to be responsible for the hemolytic activity heavily associated with beta-hemolytic streptococcus [
38,
39]. Examination of the effects of various blue light wavelengths on the granadaene pigment expressed by
S. agalactiae demonstrated that 430 nm blue light led to the photodegradation of granadaene. Raman spectroscopy further confirmed a significant reduction in the total amount of C=C double bonds detected [
34]. Beyond sensitizing
S. agalactiae to both H
2O
2 and daptomycin, the photobleaching of granadaene was found to markedly diminish the hemolytic activity of
S. agalactiae by nearly 50%, providing additional evidence of the pigment’s substantial involvement in the hemolytic activity of this pathogen [
34].
Taken together, these findings collectively reinforce the feasibility of harnessing blue light to selectively target pigments within pathogens. This approach not only diminishes bacterial defenses and virulence but also significantly enhances the effectiveness of established antimicrobial agents. Molecularly targeting pigments within pathogens stands out as a particularly pathogen-specific strategy within the realm of blue light phototherapy.
Photoinactivation of catalase sensitizes wide-ranging bacteria to reactive oxygen species
Despite the benefits of pigment photobleaching, one key drawback to this technology is its selectivity. Since STX is exclusively expressed in S. aureus strains, STX photobleaching can only be employed to target and treat S. aureus infections. To expand the application of phototherapy for infection treatment, a more broad-spectrum molecular phototherapy target must be identified. While multiple ubiquitous compounds within biological organisms have been discovered to be photosensitive to visible light, one molecule, in particular, stood out.
Catalase, a heme-containing molecule (
Figure 2A), is known to be expressed in a diverse range of bacterial, fungal, and viral pathogens. Consisting of four iron-containing heme molecules, catalase is primarily responsible for efficiently neutralizing the toxic hydrogen peroxide (H
2O
2) to water and oxygen [
40,
41]. By shielding cells from oxidative stress, catalase indirectly serves as a defense mechanism against the host immune system. This capability aids catalase-positive pathogens in surviving the ROS burst produced by neutrophils and macrophages, allowing engulfed pathogens to persist the immune cell environment [
42,
43,
44].
Prior investigations into catalase properties had already established that the enzyme exhibited a substantial absorbance peak in the visible spectrum, specifically within the range of 405 to 410 nm blue light wavelengths [
45]. Building upon this knowledge, research conducted by the Cheng Lab revealed that exposure to this blue light wavelength range resulted in significant disruptions in the structural and enzymatic activity of catalase (
Figure 2B–D). Through Raman spectroscopy, it was found that treatment with 410 nm blue light led to a marked reduction in the characteristic peaks associated with the porphyrin heme groups (
Figure 2E). Complementary catalase activity assays further demonstrated that blue light wavelengths spanning from 400 and 420 nm exerted a nearly 50% reduction in the activity of isolated bovine catalase activity (
Figure 2D) [
46]. Furthermore, this reduction in catalase activity was also found to be reflected within catalase-positive bacterial strains such as MRSA and
P. aeruginosa following treatment with 410 nm blue light. These findings unequivocally indicated that catalase present within bacterial cells could indeed be inactived through exposure to 410 nm blue light.
By combining blue light-induced bacterial catalase deactivation with exogenous sources of ROS such as hydrogen peroxide, it was found that 410 nm light treatment induced significant ROS sensitization among treated bacterial pathogens, creating a synergistic relationship between photoinactivation of catalase and these ROS-producing agents (
Figure 2F). In this paper [
46], utilizing
E. coli BW25113 as a model bacterial strain, the incorporation of 410 nm light with low concentration H
2O
2 was found to improve the antimicrobial efficiency of the compound within a time-killing assay (
Figure 2G). To confirm this ROS sensitization phenomenon was due to the deactivation of catalase, identical time-killing assays were performed using the double catalase knockout mutant
E. coli ∆katGE. When comparing the two assays, the time-killing curve of the light and H
2O
2-treated
E. coli wild type was found to be nearly identical to the time-killing curve of the
E. coli ∆katGE mutant treated only with H
2O
2, underscoring the pivotal role of catalase during this ROS sensitization process. Interestingly, increased ROS sensitization was also observed in the
∆katGE mutant, indicating that there may be additional photosensitive molecules present within bacteria, although catalase remained the largest overall contributor to antioxidant activity. The ROS sensitization after photoinactivation of catalase was found to stand true among multiple catalase-positive bacterial pathogen strains, including
P. aeruginosa (
Figure 2I)
, S. enterica, A. baumannii (
Figure 2H)
, K. pneumoniae [
46]. When blue light treatment was combined with low concentration H
2O
2, these catalase-positive pathogens were found to experience near complete eradication in the population (
Figure 2G–I). In contrast, catalase-negative pathogens like
E. faecalis failed to exhibit the same extent of ROS sensitization, further confirming that catalase was a primary target of blue light. These
in vitro results were able to be translated to an
in vivo murine model, where the antimicrobial performance of H
2O
2 against
P. aeruginosa-infected abrasion wounds was significantly enhanced by light exposure.
While light-induced catalase inactivation was clearly able to sensitize catalase-positive bacterial pathogens to exogenous H
2O
2 from both
in vitro and
in vivo environments, additional experiments revealed that 410 nm light was also able to sensitize pathogens to more indirect exogenous sources of ROS, such as the ROS produced indirectly by antibiotics. While only a minor contribution to the overall mechanism of action of most antibiotics, traditional antibiotic classes like aminoglycosides and quinolones are understood to stimulate and activate the citric acid cycle, resulting in significant internal ROS production [
48,
49]. As such, photoinactivation of catalase was found to improve the performance of antibiotics like tobramycin and ciprofloxacin against multiple bacterial pathogens [
46]. In contrast, antibiotics like silver sulfadiazine are known to be able to produce ROS by disrupting the bacterial respiratory chain through protein disruption from silver ions [
50,
51,
52]. Investigation into the potential synergy between photoinactivation of catalase and silver sulfadiazine revealed that catalase depletion results in significantly increased ROS production by silver sulfadiazine, significantly improving the antimicrobial efficiency of silver sulfadiazine against both
P. aeruginosa and MRSA. The synergy between catalase photoinactivation and silver sulfadiazine was confirmed and validated with a checkerboard assay against a model bacterium in the form of
E. coli. Through this assay, the individual and combined minimum inhibitory concentrations (MIC) of two different treatments can be found to calculate the overall fractional inhibitory concentration index (FICI). FICI can be used to identify the type of relationship between two agents, with synergistic interactions defined by FICI values ≤ 0.5 [
53]. Based on the combined and individual MIC values of 410 nm light treatment and silver sulfadiazine obtained through the checkerboard assay, the FICI of light treatment and silver sulfadiazine was found to be 0.375, indicating that the relationship between light and silver sulfadiazine is synergistic. Additional tests on
E. coli found that while the addition of light treatment improved the performance of wild-type
E. coli BW25113 (
Figure 2J), the same light treatment had no impact on the antimicrobial activity of catalase deficient
E. coli ΔkatGE (
Figure 2K), indicating that the inactivation of catalase is responsible for the improved silver sulfadiazine performance. Overall, this synergistic relationship between catalase photoinactivation and silver sulfadiazine was also found to be reflected within an
in vivo murine abrasion model, demonstrating the viability and potential translatability of this combination therapy for the treatment of infected wounds [
54].
Although antibiotics represent just one potential exogenous source of ROS capable of synergizing with light-induced catalase inactivation, another ROS source is inherent to the host immune system. While antibiotics generate ROS internally within bacterial pathogens, immune cells, such as macrophages, employ an external ROS exposure method through their “ROS burst”. This burst is generated within macrophages via NADPH oxidase (NOX2) proteins [
55], allowing them to eliminate ingested pathogens. Catalase has been found to defend pathogens like
S. aureus and
Campylobacter jejuni from the ROS burst produced by macrophages during phagocytosis, demonstrating the protective role catalase plays in bacterial survival [
45,
56]. To determine if photoinactivation of catalase can sensitize pathogens to the ROS burst produced by MRSA, light-treated MRSA was allowed to be phagocytized by RAW 264.7 macrophages. Following phagocytosis, the bacteria and macrophage co-culture were allowed to incubate for 1 hour before live (SYTO 9)/dead (PI) staining was performed on the phagocytosed MRSA (
Figure 2L–O). Confocal imaging revealed that 410 nm light treatment significantly increased the amount of dead MRSA within macrophages, indicating that photoinactivation of catalase improved the killing efficiency of the macrophages. The improved killing efficiency of macrophages against light-treated pathogens was further validated based on CFU measurements of the surviving phagocytosed bacteria. To confirm that this improved killing efficiency was due to the synergy between the ROS burst and the deactivation of catalase, a NOX inhibitor known as diphenyleneiodonium chloride (DPI) was used to neutralize the ROS burst within macrophages. The addition of DPI was found to neutralize the improved killing efficiency of macrophages with light-treated pathogens, confirming that the photoinactivation of catalase is indeed synergizing with the ROS burst produced by the immune system [
46].
Collectively, these studies shed light on catalase as a potential broad-spectrum target for blue light phototherapy, offering the prospect of enhanced ROS sensitization across various catalase-positive pathogens. This increased ROS sensitization not only bolsters the antimicrobial efficacy of direct ROS sources such as H2O2 in both in vitro and in vivo settings but also elevates the performance of conventional antibiotics like ciprofloxacin and silver sulfadiazine. Additionally, light-induced ROS sensitization has been shown to enhance the killing efficiency of macrophages by augmenting the effectiveness of the ROS burst, hinting at the promising applicability of photoinactivation of catalase in wound environments.
Photoinactivation of catalase sensitizes Candida spp. and Candida auris to reactive oxygen species
While the catalase deactivating capabilities of 410 nm blue light offer new and exciting opportunities for the treatment of bacterial infections, it is important to note that drug-resistant bacterial pathogens are not the only rising concern within the global healthcare community. Over the past few decades, drug resistance has developed within invasive fungal pathogens like
Candida spp., posing a severe health risk to immunocompromised patients [
57,
58,
59]. While
Candida albicans continues to be the predominant cause of invasive
Candida infections globally, recent trends have witnessed the emergence and rapid spread of
Candida strains that are resistant to multiple drugs, particularly notable in the case of
Candida auris [
60,
61]. This phenomenon can, in part, be attributed to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, which has led to an increase in hospitalizations and compromised immune systems among those affected by the viral infection. Consequently, several
Candida outbreaks, including those involving
C. auris, have occurred in hospital settings. These events underscore the pressing need for the development of novel approaches to diagnose, treat, and combat these infections [
61]. As eukaryotic organisms, fungal strains such as
Candida are recognized for their expression of catalase, which plays a crucial role in their antioxidant defense system. These fungi employ this enzyme to counteract oxidative stress triggered by the immune system, mirroring the mechanisms seen in bacterial organisms [
62,
63]. Based on this similarity, the impact of photoinactivation of catalase through blue light exposure was explored on various
Candida fungal strains.
Research conducted on multiple
Candida strains, including
C. auris and
C. glabrata, have found that exposure to 410 nm blue light results in a nearly 60% reduction in catalase activity, demonstrating that the fungal catalase behaves similarly as bacterial catalase and that greater eukaryotic complexity of fungal cells has little impact on its photosensitivity (
Figure 3A) [
64]. Based on this reduction in catalase activity, ROS-sensitizing effects of catalase photoinactivation were quantified within a wildtype strain
C. albicans SC5314. While individual treatments of 410 nm light and low concentration dosages of H
2O
2 barely had an impact on the viability of
C. albicans, the combination of the two resulted in significant reductions in overall fungal viability, reducing the pathogen population by nearly 4-log
10 in the span of 4 hours (
Figure 3B). This increased ROS sensitization was confirmed to be attributable to the photoinactivation of catalase, based upon the similar ROS sensitization phenomenon observed in
C. albicans treated with the chemical catalase inhibitor 3-Amino-1,2,4-triazole [
64]. While these results confirmed that photoinactivation of catalase achieved synergistic eradication of
Candida fungi when combined with H
2O
2, additional exploration was conducted to evaluate the potential improved efficiency that could be applied to established ROS-generating anti-fungal agents like amphotericin B. Amphotericin B has been found to universally induce the accumulation of ROS species within multiple pathogenic yeast species, and increased catalase expression has been found to play role in amphotericin B resistance in
Candida strains [
65,
66]. Through viability assays, photoinactivation of catalase was found to improve the antifungal performance of amphotericin B against
C. albicans strains, confirming the ability for photoinactivation of catalase to synergize with conventional antifungal agents. Similar improvements in performance were also observed for other conventional antifungal agents like micafungin and miconazole.
While
C. albicans remains the most common pathogen responsible for nosocomial infections, recent developments have seen the growing emergence of additional invasive
Candida strains such as
C. glabrata and
C. tropicalis [
67]. Among these differing resistant
Candida strains,
C. auris has been noted for its high mortality and morbidity, as well as its ability to survive and persist on various surfaces. Furthermore,
C. auris has been found to exhibit strong resistance to multiple antifungal classes, ranging from azoles like fluconazole to polyenes like amphotericin B [
68]. Thus, with the spread and growing rates of
C. auris infections occurring worldwide [
69,
70,
71,
72], we closely examined the potential antimicrobial effect of photoinactivation of catalase on this multi-drug resistant pathogen. Examination of the potential synergy between blue light and low concentration H
2O
2 found that the addition of light-induced catalase inactivation significantly improved the performance of just 22 mM of H
2O
2 by nearly 3-log
10 (
Figure 3C) [
64]. Additional strains of
C. auris were found to exhibit even better improvements in fungal clearance. These results indicate that
C. auris strains remain susceptible to the ROS-producing agents under blue light irradiance. This ROS-sensitizing effect can be used in conjunction with existing antifungal agents that are known to produce ROS as part of their mechanisms of action, such as fluconazole [
73] and amphotericin B [
74]. Through high-throughput PrestoBlue viability assays and CFU quantification, blue light was found to significantly improve the antifungal capability of both amphotericin B and fluconazole against proliferating
C. auris, indicating that photoinactivation of catalase can provide a non-invasive and non-drug reliant method of bypassing established resistance (
Figure 3D).
Following the
in vitro exploration of the potential therapeutic synergy between photoinactivation of catalase and antifungal agents, the potential translatability of applying light-induced catalase photoinactivation on fungal skin infections was determined through a combination of in vitro immune cell assays as well as
in vivo murine models. Like the bacterial tests,
C. albicans fungi treated with blue light were found to boost macrophage killing of
C. albicans, and within
C. albicans infected murine abrasion wounds, treatment with a combination of 410 nm light and 0.5% H
2O
2 was found to significantly improve the performance of H
2O
2 in reducing fungal bioburden while inducing no detectable damage to the murine skin [
64]. However, one interesting observation found among these results was that blue light treatment appeared to inhibit or suppress the development of
C. albicans hyphae. As a dimorphic fungi,
C. albicans is unique in that it can grow and reproduce through both unicellular yeast budding and filamentous hyphae formation [
75]. This dimorphism gives
C. albicans strong survival and virulence capabilities, providing the fungi with a method of escaping macrophage phagocytosis through the mechanical force exerted by hyphae or providing a method of improving invasion capabilities through the epithelial cells [
76,
77]. Previous studies have established a close link between
Candida catalase expression and hyphae growth, as
C. albicans with double catalase gene disruptions exhibited suppressed hyphae growth [
78]. Based on these previous observations and studies, the impact of catalase photoinactivation on hyphae growth was closely examined.
While untreated
C. albicans grown in hyphae-inducing conditions were found to express strong hyphae growth (
Figure 3E),
C. albicans treated with 60 J/cm
2 of 410 nm light exhibited inhibited hyphae growth (
Figure 3F) [
47]. Measurements determined that while the untreated hyphae had an average hyphae length of 11.62 ± 4.22 μm, the light-treated hyphae were significantly shorter at 6.47 ± 2.39 μm, corresponding to an average hyphae length reduction of 44.3%. Further histogram analysis revealed that while over 72% of untreated hyphae were over 10 μm in length, only 11% of light-treated hyphae reached that threshold, indicating a clear suppression in overall hyphae development (
Figure 3G). Further study into the potential metabolic changes induced by light-induced catalase photoinactivation found the light treatment to significantly reduce the metabolic activity of
C. albicans, with a specific apparent disruption in lipid droplet formation, indicating a potential alteration in lipid metabolism caused by light treatment. Usage of Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectroscopy (GC-MS) found significant reductions in both unsaturated and saturated fatty acid production within the light-treated
C. albicans, indicating that the deactivation of catalase appears to cause a significant disruption in lipid metabolism, therefore suppressing hyphae development. These results line up with previously established literature, which indicates that disruption in sterol or sphingolipid biosynthesis results in impaired hyphae development [
79].
Taken together, light-induced catalase deactivation not only sensitizes fungal Candida strains to ROS sources like H2O2 and amphotericin B, but the deactivation of catalase is capable of significantly reducing the survival and invasion capabilities of C. albicans by inhibiting hyphae formation through disruption of the lipid metabolism. Coupled with the fact that this light treatment remains effective against even multi-drug resistant Candida pathogens like C. auris, light-induced catalase deactivation offers a non-invasive and easily translatable method of targeting and treating Candida surface infections.
Photoexcitation of endogenous porphyrins induces intracellular ROS and triggers cellular damage
Niels Ryberg Finsen was awarded with the Nobel prize for his contribution to utilizing concentrated ultraviolet light to treat
Mycobacterium tuberculosis-induced lupus vulgaris in 1903 [
82]. This is a great application of photobiomodulation, or more specifically, photonic antimicrobial therapy. However, the underlying mechanism of photobiomodulation, especially the effect of photons on microbes, has remained elusive for decades. Here, we demonstrated that those endogenous pigments (staphyloxanthin, granadaene, catalase) are vital targets of visible lights, especially from 400 nm to 450 nm. However, we concur that these pigments do not constitute the sole factors contributing to the antimicrobial effects induced by blue light. Another widely accepted hypothesis is the cytotoxic reactive oxygen species generated though the photoexcitation of endogenous porphyrins and flavins [
83,
84].
Carolina dos Anjos
et al. examined the morphology change of individual
P. aeruginosa and
S. aureus by transmission electron microscopy under the blue light irradiance (
Figure 4A) [
80]. A dense cytoplasm was observed, which echos with the cytoplasmic condensation in the presence of antibiotic lethality [
85]. Meanwhile, evident aggregation of cellular content and detached membrane was found. Collectively, this suggested blue light exposure elicits oxidative damage. They also quantified the concentration of intracellular porphyrins from those bacteria, and it turned out that coproporphyrins were the most abundant intracellular porphyrins among all the tested bacteria. They also captured the potential intrinsic fluorophores at the single-cell level through fluorescence lifetime imaging (
Figure 4B), a method allowing for achieving the spatial localization of endogenous fluorophores based on the fluorescence lifetime [
86]. They found more than one certain fluorophore exists in the bacteria, which indicates the multifaceted targets of antimicrobial blue lights.
Besides the sole antimicrobial treatment from blue light, Leon Leanse
et al. also combined antimicrobial blue light with other antimicrobial adjuvant such as quinine, to eliminate both molds and Gram-negative bacteria [
81,
87]. Blue light irradiance demonstrated the enhanced uptake of quinine, an antiseptic agent, at single-cell level through label-free Raman imaging of accumulated quinine. Moreover, through the combinatorial treatment between blue light and quinine, the extracellular polymeric substances were significantly reduced and degraded in the
P. aeruginosa biofilms (
Figure 4C). And they also quantified the amount of intracellular porphyrins and found a substantial accumulation of coproporphyrins from most of the tested molds. It has been well studied that protoporphyrins can produce reactive oxygen species due to the photodynamic reaction under blue light irradiance [
88]. Therefore, akin to the aforementioned pigments, porphyrins are regarded as another class of targets for blue light.