1. Introduction
Carriers of certain
TREM2 gene variants (R47H, D87N, L211P, H157Y, R62H, and T96K) have an increased risk of Alzheimer’s disease (AD). Therefore, the TREM2 receptor is commonly investigated in the context of AD [
1,
2]. After
APOE gene variants [
3], the R47H variant of
TREM2 is the second most common risk factor for AD, and it can increase the risk of developing AD by two- to fourfold [
2]. ApoE is one of the TREM2 receptor ligands, and its interaction, if altered, can have a significant effect on the onset of AD symptoms [
4]. The TREM2 receptor is indispensable for interacting with apolipoproteins, amyloid β (Aβ), and regulating the number of myeloid cells, phagocytosis, and inflammatory response [
1,
2]. TREM2 is also essential for synaptic pruning and regulates synaptic clearance via phagocytosis, whereas the absence of TREM2 results in aberrant synaptic clearance [
4]. Microglial cholesterol metabolism also depends on TREM2 signaling, as TREM2 deficiency is associated with impaired intracellular cholesterol storage and efflux [
5]. Intriguingly, TREM2 indirectly regulates the myelinating process by influencing cholesterol metabolism and clearing myelin debris [
5], which is severely disrupted by the
TREM2 p.Q33X mutation in microglia, which interferes with lysosomal function and contributes to Nasu-Hakola disease [
6,
7]. The downstream signaling of TREM2 induces transcriptional changes that promote the transition from homeostatic to disease-associated microglia phenotype (DAM) [
8]. The TREM2 receptor also mediates autophagy, one of the mechanisms for degrading cellular proteins, particularly abnormally aggregated, which is impaired in AD [
9]. Humans with TREM2 risk variants and TREM2-deficient mice accumulate vesicles resembling autophagy [
9].
The protective effect of increased
TREM2 expression against AD symptoms has previously been reported [
10]. The TREM2 receptor interacts with the Aβ to initiate its phagocytosis [
11]. Higher levels of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) sTREM2 are associated with delayed Aβ accumulation in the brain, as measured by amyloid-PET scan [
12]. In the 5XFAD model of AD, protracted TREM2 stimulation via injection of human TREM2 (hTREM2) agonistic mAb (AL002c) attenuated pathological changes of Aβ and neurite injury [
13]. However, a recent study suggests that chronic TREM2 antibody administration does not influence Aβ plaque burden [
14]. In addition, chronic TREM2 activation increased the dissemination of tau neurofibrillary degeneration and loss of the synapses surrounding plaques in the region with the highest pathological tau changes and neuritic dystrophy [
14]. In contrast, the soluble form of the TREM2 receptor (sTREM2) promoted Aβ plaque degradation [
15], indicating that two receptor isoforms may play distinct functions in relation to pathological changes and disease stages. In accordance with that statement, a recent study on APP/PS1 mice demonstrated that increased TREM2 activation indirectly inhibits tau protein phosphorylation and neuronal loss by inhibiting glycogen synthase kinase-3β, the major actor of tau hyperphosphorylation [
16]. In addition, AD-associated microglial activation stage 2 markers in non-demented individuals are predictive of a delayed accumulation of tau [
17]. The increased activity of TREM2 in the transgenic mouse model is associated with decreased expression of genes essential for the pro-inflammatory response of microglia [
18] and can increase its phagocytotic activity [
12,
13].
TREM2 expression and inflammasome activation produce contradictory outcomes [
19,
20,
21,
22,
23]. Microglia cells with the R47H variant have a diminished rate of inflammasome activation [
19], whereas macrophages with higher
TREM2 expression inhibit inflammasome activation [
20]. In contrast, their pyroptosis is increased in the absence of TREM2 [
21]. A similar effect was observed in C57/BL6 mice where overexpression of the
TREM2 attenuated postoperative neuroinflammation [
24].
TREM2 overexpression also ameliorates LPS-induced oxidative stress and inflammation in the BV2 cell line [
25]. In contrast, one study discovered that the AD mouse model
TREM2 knock-out (APPPS1;
Trem2-/-) has decreased expression of the pro-inflammatory cytokines IL-1β and IL-6 and increased expression of anti-inflammatory markers associated with reduced Aβ and tau protein pathological alterations [
22]. Microglia activated by high glucose levels increase
TREM2 expression and pro-inflammatory cytokine release, whereas downregulation of
TREM2 reduces inflammation caused by high glucose levels [
23]. Soluble TREM2 (sTREM2) is a form of TREM2 receptor that is released after its extracellular domain is cleaved by ADAM10 and ADAM17 metalloproteases [
11], and its function remains poorly understood. Another process can be involved in generating sTREM2. Namely, the soluble form of the receptor can be produced by transcription of the alternative transcript lacking a transmembrane domain [
26], and it appears that approximately 25% of the sTREM2 may be due to the expression of this isoform. As discussed, TREM2 shedding from the membrane may function as a negative regulator of TREM2 signaling [
27]. It is still debatable whether the soluble form of TREM2 has an agonistic effect or whether it competes with the presumably protective full-length membrane TREM2 [
11,
27].
It has been hypothesized that sTREM2 initiates the survival of microglia and the secretion of pro-inflammatory cytokines [
28]. In the 5xFAD transgenic mouse model, injection of sTREM2 into the hippocampus increases microglial clustering around amyloid plaques and reduces amyloid plaque load by uptake and degradation of Aβ, thus rescuing deficits of spatial memory and long-term potentiation [
15]. However, the depletion of microglia abolishes the neuroprotective effect of sTREM2 [
15]. Recently, a rare p.H157Y variant of
TREM2 was identified at the extracellular domain cleavage site; this variant is associated with increased production of sTREM2 and increased risk of AD [
29].
In vivo experiments with
Trem2 H157Y knock-in mice revealed that increased levels of sTREM2 are advantageous for the animals, resulting in improved synapse function and amelioration of amyloid pathological alterations [
29]. However, the study didn’t include other pathological factors, such as tau protein changes, which could be one explanation for why this mutation has a different effect in humans [
29]. In a separate study examining the effect of the R47H variant on tau pathology in the PS19 mouse model of tauopathy expressing either human TREM2 common or R47H variant, it was discovered that impaired TREM2 signaling (in the case of the R47H variant) significantly attenuated neurodegenerative changes caused by tau pathology. It is hypothesized that altered TREM2 receptor signaling influences microglial activation and, as a result, ameliorates microglia-mediated degeneration [
30]. It appears that tau neurofibrillary degeneration associated with TREM2 signaling is highly dependent on ApoE variants [
31]. TREM2 knock-out P301S tau mice with expressed ApoE4 variation have significantly higher neurodegenerative and tau protein alterations than mice with the same ApoE variant and an expressed
TREM2 gene [
31]. In the THY-Tau22 transgenic murine model of tauopathy, TREM2 deficiency decreased microglial activation, which exacerbated pathological changes in later stages [
32]. The TREM2 signaling pathways are extraordinarily complex, as evidenced by their varying effects on diverse pathological alterations, differences in signaling between soluble and membrane isoform signaling, and discordance between animal models and human AD patients. In amyloid mouse models of AD, for instance, brain expression or injection of wild-type sTREM2 decreases amyloid pathological changes, indicating that wild-type sTREM2 is protective against amyloid pathology [
33].
To determine whether sTREM2 protects against AD and AD models and at what stage of the disease, it is crucial to conduct additional longitudinal studies on the AD population. Analysis of the TREM2 levels in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) generally revealed elevated levels in AD patients; however, other studies did not confirm these findings [
34], and some reported variable TREM2 levels dependent on the disease stage, with the highest levels typically associated with earlier symptomatic stages (for review, see [
33]). Intriguingly, an increase in TREM2 CSF levels correlates positively with total and phosphorylated tau CSF levels, whereas an increase in Aβ correlates with a decrease in TREM2 [
1,
34,
35,
36,
37]. Lower Aβ-PET signal was associated with higher CSF TREM2 levels, indicating that microglial activity may be protective against the formation of Aβ plaques [
12]. Therefore, sTREM2 may be a useful biomarker of the pathological state of AD; however, future research should include additional studies with a greater number of patients and more uniform analysis procedures. This study aimed to determine the relationship between sTREM2 levels in CSF and plasma samples and other markers of AD pathology.
4. Discussion
Our findings demonstrate convincingly that CSF levels of sTREM2 are significantly greater in the AD group than in the MCI and HC groups. Apart from rare exceptions [
34,
42], the vast majority of previous studies [
43,
44] have, like the present study, found elevated concentrations of sTREM2 in the CSF to be strongly associated with AD. Importantly, we found that concentrations of sTREM2 in CSF are substantially higher in the MCI group compared to the HC group, confirming previous suggestions that sTREM2 could be used as the biomarker to detect conversion from MCI to AD [
44] and can indicate earlier changes in MCI stage. Our findings also demonstrate that, statistically, plasma levels of sTREM2 do not differ between the three groups analyzed. This once again confirms that prospective AD biomarkers in plasma are poor indicators of what is occurring in the brain, and as a result, these biomarkers have unsatisfactory outcomes. There are numerous reasons, but some of the most important are as follows: 1) probably only a small fraction of sTREM2 enters the peripheral biofluid system, 2) like other proteins, sTREM2 can be degraded by proteases or form complexes with various blood proteins, and 3) it can also be cleared in the liver, kidney, and by macrophages in peripheral organs and tissues [
45]. The third reason suggests that the optimal blood-collection site should be changed from the cubital vein to the internal jugular vein, as this would reduce blood dilution, degradation, and organ clearance effects [
45]. Regardless of the aforementioned explanations, our results indicate that plasma sTREM2 concentrations do not adequately differentiate microglial activity between the MCI, AD, and HC subject groups. On the other hand, differences in CSF sTREM2 levels suggest that the innate immune response in the brains of AD patients is much stronger and that microglia are more active in the MCI stage than during healthy aging. Using transgenic mouse models of amyloid deposition, it has been demonstrated that genetic variability in the microglial response to amyloid deposition may be a significant risk factor for AD [
46]. In the same study that confirmed the involvement of four mouse orthologs of GWAS-established risk genes for AD, including
TREM2, at least four new putative risk genes were identified with a high degree of statistical rigor, as increased expression of these genes in microglia was observed only in the presence of amyloid [
46].
Previously, variations in sTREM2 levels were determined at distinct disease stages. The MCI group had the greatest levels of sTREM2, which may be indicative of microglia’s response to early neuronal death [
35] and efferocytosis [
47]. Efferocytosis enables microglia to efficiently remove apoptotic and necrotic cells as well as cellular debris. In addition, it stimulates the production of anti-inflammatory cytokines, such as TGF-β and IL-10, while suppressing the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines. Thus, a deficiency in efferocytosis leads to the accumulation of apoptotic cells and cholesterol-rich brain tissue cellular detritus, resulting in chronic inflammation and autoimmunity [
47]. Other authors [
36,
37] have discovered that sTREM2 concentrations are exceedingly sensitive to the onset of pathological changes during the progression of the disease [
36,
37,
44]. In early non-symptomatic stages with low Aβ and normal tau levels, sTREM2 levels are lower, and sTREM2 concentrations increase when tau protein changes manifest as elevated CSF levels of p-tau and t-tau [
36,
37]. The TREM2 receptor is known to interact with Aβ and initiates its phagocytosis [
11]. Ewers and colleagues [
12] have demonstrated that elevated sTREM2 CSF levels prevent Aβ accumulation in the brain. In the 5xFAD model of AD, protracted TREM2 stimulation by injection of human TREM2 (hTREM2) agonistic mAb (AL002c) was protective against Aβ pathological changes and neurite damage [
13]. Even though the role of the TREM2 receptor in the pathogenesis of AD is not completely understood, it is reasonable to assume that in the early stages of the disease, it may play a protective role, but as the disease progresses and adaptive immune response gets more involved, it becomes harmful [
11,
48]. In addition, TREM2 may only be protective against a subset of the pathological alterations in AD, specifically the previously mentioned Aβ load, but not tau pathology. Recent research [
48] found that the number of T cells, particularly cytotoxic T cells, was significantly elevated in regions of pathological tau changes in the brains of mice with tauopathy and AD patients.
The cross-sectional design of the present investigation is a limitation; a longitudinal study would be preferable for tracking TREM2 level changes across disease stages. Notwithstanding, correlation analysis reveals a robust relationship between microglial activity and pathological alterations of tau proteins. In our study, sTREM2 CSF levels were positively correlated with both t-tau and p-tau
181 CSF levels - findings in good agreement with previous studies in which tau-related neurodegeneration was reported to be associated with an increase in CSF sTREM2 (for review, see [
11,
27]), but not with Aβ
1-42 CSF levels, similar to a recent report by Suarez-Cálvet et al. [
36]. Based on the current investigation and the study of Suarez-Cálvet et al., it is logical to conclude that the pathology of the longest form of amyloid (Aβ
1-42) in the absence of downstream tau-related neurodegeneration is associated with a decrease in CSF sTREM2. Intriguingly, a recent study found a positive association between sTREM2 in CSF and the shorter variants of amyloid – Aβ
x-40 [
49], which are not typically associated with AD [
50,
51]. These findings may be explained by the possibility that AD patients have a higher removal rate of soluble Aβ
1-42 because of increased cellular Aβ
1-42 uptake [
52].
This interdependence between sTREM2 levels and biomarkers of tau protein alterations has been reported previously, confirming the significance of the TREM2 receptor in tauopathy pathogenesis [
11]. However, the precise roles of the TREM2 receptor in tauopathies remain undetermined. Its primary functions appear to include promoting phagocytosis, moderating the response to neuronal injury, and modulating neuroinflammation [
7]. Recent research examining the effect of the R47H variant on tau pathology in the PS19 mouse model of tauopathy revealed that this variant improves microglia response and causes neurodegenerative alterations related to pathological changes of tau proteins [
30]. In the THY-Tau22 mouse model of tauopathy, another study revealed that TREM2 deficiency worsens tau pathological changes in later stages owing to the lower microglial activation rate [
32]. Depending on the
APOE genotype, TREM2 signaling has distinct effects on pathological changes of the tau protein. Tau pathological changes and neurodegeneration are significantly more severe in mice with a silenced
TREM2 gene and ApoE4 than in mice with an active
TREM2 gene [
31]. This is further evidence of the complexity of TREM2 signaling and a reminder of the distinctions between animal models of AD and humans. A positive correlation between sTREM2 concentrations and the age of the subjects suggests that microglial activation increases with age, whereas a negative correlation between sTREM2 concentrations and MMSE score suggests that sTREM2 could be a good indicator of cognitive deficits and that neurodegenerative changes and microglial activation are highly interrelated.
In addition, sTREM2 CSF levels were positively correlated with CSF ASC protein levels, indicating a potential link between the release of the soluble TREM2 form and the activation of the inflammasomes. Multiple studies [
19,
20,
21,
23] have demonstrated the relationship between inflammasomes and TREM2 receptors. Microglia cells with the R47H
TREM2 gene variant, which increases the risk of AD onset, have a decreased activation of the NLRP3 inflammasome activation upon ligand binding to the TREM2 receptor [
19]. Overexpression of
TREM2 in macrophages inhibits activation of NLRP3 inflammasome [
20], whereas silencing the
TREM2 gene substantially increases macrophage pyroptosis [
21]. These results suggest that TREM2 receptor expression performs a protective and anti-inflammatory role (for review, see [
53]). In the context of AD, this property of TREM2 would imply greater control over inflammatory response and protection from over-activation and cross-activation of the inflammasomes, including the neuronal NLRP1 inflammasome [
54], but this does not imply that silencing the inflammatory response is always the best course of action. For a healthy immune response, the timing and sequence of events are of the utmost importance, as AD pathological changes may affect the interaction between two receptors differently. In interpreting the results, it is important to remember that a previous study [
55] has already demonstrated a correlation between elevated sTREM2 levels and pathological changes of the white matter, specifically small vessel disease and amyloid angiopathy, regardless of the severity of other pathological changes. This study demonstrates that CSF sTREM2 concentrations can differentiate between healthy and AD patients. With a cutoff value of 23950 pg/ml, CSF sTREM2 had a sensitivity of 66.81% and a high specificity of 80%.
AD is also characterized by a dysregulation of glucose metabolism [
56,
57,
58,
59], and a recent study found that inflammation initiated by elevated glucose levels in the BV2 microglial cell line results in a higher rate of NLRP3 inflammasome activation [
23]. Additional experiments have shown that the TREM2 receptor can modulate the inflammatory response initiated by high glucose levels and the NLRP3 inflammasome [
23]. Choi and colleagues found that 5xFAD mouse microglia consume significantly more glucose than wild-type microglia and that as the disease progresses, microglia express a greater number of glucose transporters (GLUT1 and GLUT2), have insufficient glycolysis, and a higher level of oxidative phosphorylation [
28]. In addition, they discovered a positive correlation between the levels of CSF sTREM2 and glucose intake in the human hippocampus [
28], which, given the activation of inflammasomes in glia in response to high glucose concentrations, could be a link between sTREM2 levels and the activation of inflammasomes. Despite the apparent connection between TREM2 signaling and the inflammasome activation pathway, the role and interaction of sTREM2 and inflammasome activation remain undefined. Even though other monocytes can also express the TREM2 receptor and release its soluble form into the blood [
60], our results indicate a positive correlation between CSF and plasma sTREM2, which suggests that the state of the periphery indicates alterations in the brain to some extent. Several studies have failed to find a correlation between CSF sTREM2 levels and peripheral blood sTREM2 levels [
61,
62], and one study reported a negative correlation between CSF and plasma sTREM2 levels [
63]. Despite obvious differences in CSF sTREM2 levels, a later statement can explain the lack of significant differences in plasma sTREM2 levels between the analyzed groups due to the reasons already discussed (for review, see [
45]). Lastly, plasma sample groups were substantially smaller than CSF sample groups, which may explain why the differences were not statistically significant.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, G. Š.; methodology, E.Š.P., M.B.L., L.L.H., G.Š.; software, E.Š.P., M.B.L., G.Š.; validation, F.B., G.Š.; formal analysis, E.Š.P., M.B.L., G.Š.; investigation, E.Š.P., M.B.L., L.L.H., K.B., Ž.V., M.B., N.K., F.B., G.Š.; resources, G.Š.; data curation, E.Š.P., G.Š.; writing—original draft preparation, E.Š.P., G.Š.; writing—review and editing, E.Š.P., M.B.L., L.L.H., K.B., Ž.V., M.B., N.K., F.B., G.Š.; visualization, E.Š.P., M.B.L., G.Š.; supervision, G.Š.; project administration, E.Š.P., L.L.H., G.Š.; funding acquisition, G.Š. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.